You are on page 1of 3

Technical Bulletin

FiberSystems
521 Kiser Street The Benefits of FRP Composite
Dayton, OH 45404-1641 Pipe versus HDPE Pipe
Tel: 937-222-9000
Fax: 937-222-9020 10-29-2008 Page #1 of 3

Pipe Features FRP Composite Pipe High Density Polyethylene Pipe


Pipe FRP composite pipe, built to ASTM The inside diameters of high density
Inside D-2996 Table 4, has constant and full polyethylene (HDPE), depending
Diameters normal inside diameters - regardless upon the pressure rating.
of the pressure rating.
Flow The flow capabilities of FRP For HDPE pipe the engineer needs to
Capabilities composite pipe can be calculated use a larger nominal pipe size
using the full nominal pipe diameter. because of the significantly reduced
Often, for equal flow capacity, FRP i.d. - and thus lower flow capabilities.
pipe can be one or two diameters At least one full size larger HDPE
smaller than HDPE pipe. pipe is required to provide the full
flow capacity.
Installation FRP composite pipe can be installed HDPE pipe requires special costly,
Equipment with minimal field equipment and complex, difficult to adjust and
tools. Pipe shavers for field bell and calibrate equipment for making field
spigot adhesive welds. Hand fusion welds. In addition a separate
grinders, rollers, and brushes for field fusion plate is required for each
butt overlay welds. diameter.
Field FRP composite pipe can be field HDPE pipe requires pipe joiners with
Skills installed and joined with skilled special factory training and skills in
Required piping journeyman, who have operating adjusting and calibrating
to Install received the appropriate classroom complex equipment. Because of
Pipe and job site training - including limitations of the cost of equipment
making qualifying joints. It is not and trained installation personnel,
unusual, or costly, to have multiple often only one joint can be made at a
journeyman and crews qualified for time.
large FRP composite pipe projects,
so many joints can be worked on at
one time
Job Site FRP composite pipe, is much lighter Because of the heavier walls, and
Handling weight, and often can be handled in coiling of the smaller diameters,
the field with just one or two men. HDPE pipe requires specialized
When longer lengths require lifting handling equipment, and including
capability - much lighter lifting cranes. In large diameter and single
equipment, such as a back hoe, can lengths a spreader bar with multiple
be used. lift points is typically required.
Technical Bulletin
FiberSystems
521 Kiser Street The Benefits of FRP Composite
Dayton, OH 45404-1641 Pipe versus HDPE Pipe
Tel: 937-222-9000
Fax: 937-222-9020 10-29-2008 Page #2 of 3

Pipe Features FRP Composite Pipe High Density Polyethylene Pipe


Attack from Thermoset FRP composite pipe has There have been many documented
Rodents, and proven to be not at all attractive to instances where HDPE pipe is a
Other Critters and attacked by rodents. FRP favorite food of rodents, and
composite pipe is also specified as mammals. Being a thermoplastic
the material of choice when material it can even be attacked by
microbial induced corrosion (MIC) microbial organisms.
can occur.
Thermal and The engineering and cost of supports HDPE pipe, because of its very high
Pressure for thermoset FRP composite pipe is thermal coefficient and pressure
Expansion well established with programs like expansion requires special design,
Algor and Caesar available to and engineering support
provide easy engineering of the considerations. The costs for HDPE
types, location, and number of pipe supports and expansion joints
supports; all at a much lower cost can be as much as 65% greater than
than for thermoplastic pipe. those required for alternate materials.
Pumping FRP composite pipe is the ideal When used as a pressure pipe HDPE
Consideration material selection at pumps - being pipe requires special design
available also in an abrasion resistant consideration, including often larger
version, where an abrasion slurry is sizes, to prevent starving of pumps,
being handled or cavitation might with subsequent pump failure.
occur. Costly replacements have been
required, especially in the power
industry, where HDPE pipe was
originally installed on both the intake
and output sides of pumps.
Service FRP composite pipe has been in HDPE pipe is a relatively new
Life successful use for 60+ years (well development and technology. Case
over half a century). Many of those history and experiences for specific
early installations, when inspected service environments are relatively
still look almost new. limited; and service life is difficult to
predict.
Technical Bulletin
FiberSystems
521 Kiser Street The Benefits of FRP Composite
Dayton, OH 45404-1641 Pipe versus HDPE Pipe
Tel: 937-222-9000
Fax: 937-222-9020 10-29-2008 Page #3 of 3

Pipe Features FRP Composite Pipe High Density Polyethylene Pipe


Chemical FRP composite pipe can be tailored; HDPE pipe is typically made from
Service by the proper selection of resins, only a single or very limited ranges
Environments and reinforcements and manufacturing of polyethylene resins. Only the wall
Capabilities technologies; to handle the widest thickness is varied to handle the
range of chemical service and different pressure ratings and/or
pressure applications. Well over 82 external loads. HDPE pipe lacks the
different Series or types of FRP ability to be optimized for severe and
composite pipe and duct are readily unusual chemical service
available. environments.

Fire Retardancy FRP composite pipe is available in HDPE pipe is highly flammable with
fire retardant versions that can be very high smoke contributions and
certified to ASTM 84 flame spread smoke toxicity.
rating of under 25. Other versions of
FRP composite pipe are available for
low smoke and low smoke toxicity.

Stiffness Factor FRP composite pipe is installed as a HDPE pipe is also flexible. But,
flexible pipe (per the ring requires careful installation,
compression theory). But, yet it still handling, and backfilling to maintain
has hoop and axial stiffness to allow roundness and axial straightness
easy field handling, installation, and during installation.
when buried, backfilling.
Field Modifications The technology and materials for Making changes in HDPE piping
and making field modifications and systems in the field, requires.
Repair repairs in FRP composite pipe are specialized equipment and welding
well established. The techniques for techniques. Field repairs are
field modifications and repairs are especially difficult to accomplish.
easily learned and accomplished in a Often the modifications, especially
minimal amount of time. for T branches and saddles have to be
encased with FRP composites to
provide the necessary strength.
Lower Pumping Because of the larger diameter , over Because of the significantly smaller
Cost the life of the pipe, FRP composite inside diameters for the same size
pipe will have much lower energy pipe, HDPE pipe will have much
pumping costs. higher annual energy costs.

You might also like