You are on page 1of 8

XV COLOMBIAN GEOTECHNICAL CONGRESS & II INTERNATIONAL SPECIALIZED CONFERENCE OF SOFT ROCKS.

CARTAGENA ON OCTOBER 5th -7th 2016

3D-TSP Advanced geological prediction during tunneling projects in


the Andes

3D-TSP Prediccin geolgica avanzada durante proyectos de


tunelacin en los Andes
Jozsef Hecht-Mndez and Thomas Dickmann
Amberg Technologies AG, Regensdorf-Watt, Switzerland
jhecht@amberg.ch

Abstract
In recent years, a large number of underground projects have been developed in challenging environments in the
Andean region. A common problem for these projects is the scarce a prior geological and geotechnical information
available. Hence, at the construction stage ongoing characterization of the underground is crucial. Tunnel Seismic
Prediction (TSP) is a geophysical technique based on the principle of seismic reflection. The TSP method allows
detecting rock mass changes exploding their intimate link to seismic wave velocities. As a result, derived
geomechanical properties grant the identification of fault and shear zones, cavities and exploring water bearing
formations in a cost effective manner. The TSP technology is being currently used in the stage III of Chavimochic
Special Project. Results of a TSP campaign performed in volcanic rocks demonstrate its capability in detecting
changes in the rock mass condition. The results obtained are in good agreement with the excavated geology and the
complementary mechanical probe drills.

Resumen
En aos recientes un gran nmero de proyectos subterrneos se han desarrollado en ambientes retadores en la
regin andina. Un problema comn para estos proyectos es la poca informacin geolgica y geotcnica previa
disponible. Por ende, la caracterizacin del macizo durante la construccin es crucial. La Prediccin Ssmica para
Tneles (TSP) es una tcnica geofsica basada en la ssmica de reflexin. El mtodo TSP permite detectar cambios
del macizo explotando su relacin con la velocidad de las ondas ssmicas. Como resultado, los parmetros
geomecnicos facilitan la identificacin de zonas de falla y cizalla, cavidades y exploracin de formaciones
portadoras de agua de manera econmica. La tecnologa TSP est siendo actualmente empleada en la etapa III del
Proyecto Especial Chavimochic. Resultados de una campaa TSP ejecutada en rocas volcnicas demuestran su
capacidad de detectar cambios en las condiciones del macizo. Los resultados obtenidos concuerdan con la
geologa excavada y con sondeos exploratorios mecnicos complementarios.

poorly hardened and low durability volcanic tuffs


1 INTRODUCTION and/or highly altered andesites to extremely strong
and high abrasive andesites. These sequences have
Advance geological prediction during been strongly folded and faulted in some regions
construction of tunnel should be a normal practice (Brox and Venturini, 2009).
to avoid any unpredicted risk and in order to
complete the project within the defined time The key aspects to success or failure of any
schedule. The Andes are the longest continental tunnelling project is dealing with the quality of the
mountain range with complex geology. It is rock mass that the tunnel passes through and the
relatively young with lithology varying from support measures applied during tunnel
construction. In this respect, accurate analysis and
XV COLOMBIAN GEOTECHNICAL CONGRESS & II INTERNATIONAL SPECIALIZED CONFERENCE OF SOFT ROCKS.
CARTAGENA ON OCTOBER 5th -7th 2016
interpretation of rock mass quality plays a being presented and TSP prognosis is being
significant role. Past and present tunnel experience compared with actual geology after excavation
in the Andes shows that there are still many and complementary exploration methods.
uncertainties and challenges that have to be coped
with during tunnelling. Table 1. Use of TSP Latin America
The geological risk involved during tunnelling Country Project Tunnel Length
in the Andes range and the rock mass Per C. H. Yuncan 20 km
characterisation by means of 3D seismic Per Proyecto Olmos 20 km
prediction using the TSP 303 technology is a Per P.E. Chavimochic ~4 km
worthwhile discussion. TSP 303 is a geophysical Brasil GASDUC III 3.8 km
technique based on the reflection seismic method Dominican Republic Palo Mino 13.5 km
which helps to avoid risks associated to poor rock Costa Rica P. H. Cach 6 km
strata (Dickmann, 2014). It saves costly Mxico Acatnel 3.2 km
downtimes and increases the production Chile - >20 km
efficiency. The TSP technology has already been The list is not deemed to be complete.
used in more than 100 measurements in various
projects in the Andean region and in volcanic 2 APPLICATION OF GEOLOGICAL
rocks in North and Central America (Table 1). PREDICTION IN ANDEAN TUNNELING
Currently, the last generation of the TSP system is
being used in the III stage of the Chavimochic Most of the tunneling projects in the Andean
Special Project located in La Libertad department, region can be categorised in two main sectors:
northern Per. This major project consists of hydropower and water transfer. Within the
taking the water of the Santas river through a hydropower sector two major types of projects are
long channel of about 280 km towards the Chao, distinguished, conventional or dam system and
Vir, Moche y Chicama valleys. With the Run-of-the-river projects. In Colombia, the
proposed system, irrigation of more than 160,000 Ituango Hydroelectrical Dam, the largest
ha of agriculture land will be possible. In addition, conventional project in the country and second
the project aims at hydropower generation and largest in Latin America, is currently being
drinking water supply to the city of Trujillo. constructed including a 200 m high dam and two
Development of the projects third stage, carried water diversion tunnels. One important example
out by the Concesionaria Chavimochic S.A.C, will of water transfer is the Olmos Trans-Andean
allow irrigation of about 63,000 ha of new arable tunnel finished in 2,011. This 20 km long tunnel is
land improving in turn irrigation of additional integral part of a large water transfer system
50,000 ha. The works foreseen for the projects bringing water from the Huancabamba River on
stage III are the following: the Eastern side of the Andes to drought areas on
Palo Redondo dam and complementary the Pacific Coast. A run-of-the-river project is
facilities now being constructed in Chile and another
example of this type of projects is found in
Third siphon line across Vir River
volcanic rock in Costa Rica (expansion of the
Main water channel Moche-Chicama- Cach Hydroelectrical Plant). Contrary, road
Urricape projects are still scarce in this region. However,
Lateral conduction for the Urricape sector due to the increasing commercial exchange in the
under the main channel region and need of rapid transportation, more and
more challenging road projects in the Andean
Integral refurbishment of the existing inlets
region are expected. The 4G highway project in
system throughout stages I and II and new
Colombia, and the Agua Negra and Corredor
inlets in the stage III.
Biocenico Aconcagua, Chile/Argentina, are only
Control, measuring and automation system a few examples.
with full coverage for the major hydraulic
In spite of the increasing energy and
infrastructure.
transportation demand, such infrastructure
To date 12 TSP campaigns have been carried projects have not yet been developed to a desired
out. TSP measurements are being performed by extent due to various constraints. Among these
DNA-BLAST Latinoamrica S.A.C. Here, one of constraints, inaccessible terrain and
the results performed at the restitution tunnel is adverse/uncertain geological condition are
XV COLOMBIAN GEOTECHNICAL CONGRESS & II INTERNATIONAL SPECIALIZED CONFERENCE OF SOFT ROCKS.
CARTAGENA ON OCTOBER 5th -7th 2016
significant ones. Moreover, in some cases, charged zones by probe drilling and Tunnel
extremely rugged, densely forested and Seismic Prediction. TSP 303 is an advance tool
inaccessible topography together with high which can explore the water bearing formation in
overburdens provide limited prior investigations true 3D image and help reduce the costly probe
and more assumptions and projections are made drilling. It takes less time to do a measurement as
which finally become a cause of concern for compared to probe drilling methods.
projects owners and contractors during execution. 2.3 Management of geological risk
These unavoidable uncertainties can be managed
by carrying out comprehensive 3D geological Once the geological risk is identified and
prediction which is a pre-requisite realistic delineated properly, the next step is to manage
prognosis (Dickmann and Krger, 2014). them during construction. The risk management is
manageable as long as geological prediction in
2.1 Occurrence of adverse geological advance is being applied by means of tunnel
conditions seismic prediction and probe drilling.
Occurrence of deformed, crushed rock mass due Contractually, every geological risk event is
to fault or shear zones and squeezing rock along costly and its magnitude depends on how risk can
tunnel route poses several risks during excavation be managed.
like formation of cavities, collapse, convergence,
debris flow, etc. Considering the length of the 3 BENEFITS AND ADVANTAGES OF
tunnels, encountering such zones during GEOLOGICAL PREDICTION
excavation is common.
For instance, during the construction of the 8.6 The geotechnical risk that can affect projects
km La Linea road tunnel, Colombia, for which an result from a range of hazards associated with
exploration tunnel was built in advance, strong geologic condition, but also from hazards
instability at two faces and collapse due to strong associated with the geo-engineering process.
water ingress and poor rock quality was When the site investigation from the surface is
experienced (Corba Colombo, 2015). Maybe the limited given the topography, TSP 303 can detect
most significant example of rock squeezing in the lithological uncertainties within a distance of up to
Andean region and the world is the Yacamb- 150 metres from tunnel face. It is the most
Qubor water transfer tunnel in Venezuela (Hoek effective prediction methods because of its large
and Guevara, 2009). Besides being constructed on prediction range, high resolution and ease of
a tectonically complex area, poor understanding of handling and operating on a tunnel construction
the geology and unanticipated rock condition site.
made this project a real challenge. After 32 years 3.1 Advantages
the tunnel was finished. TSP offers an advanced geological prediction to
Tunneling through fault zones or swelling rock meet daily operational needs such as:
pose severe risk to manpower and machinery. In Spatial investigation ahead of face.
order to overcome such problems, advance
geological prediction by TSP 303 should be a Detection of hazardous fault zones and

useful practice. cavities.


Another important risk in tunneling projects in Exploration of water bearing formation.

the Andean region is posed by the rock burst Discovery of change in rock mechanical
phenomena. Such phenomenon occurred properties.
throughout the excavation of the Trans-Andean Employed as a predictive method during
tunnel (Olmos project) and has been already excavation process for both drill & blast and TBM
reported in some excavations in Chilean Andes. heading, no access to face is required to perform
2.2 The ground water problem measurements, which are taken in tunnelling
Investigations of groundwater conditions are production breaks of around 60 minutes. Acoustic
very important for a successful completion of the signals are produced by a series of 24 shots of
tunnel work. Though it is difficult to judge the usually 50 to 100 grams of detonation cords
groundwater condition during investigation stages, aligned along one tunnel wall side and having
efforts are being made to probe simultaneously additional shot line along opposite tunnel wall
while advancing tunnel excavation in water side in case of more complex geology. The 3
XV COLOMBIAN GEOTECHNICAL CONGRESS & II INTERNATIONAL SPECIALIZED CONFERENCE OF SOFT ROCKS.
CARTAGENA ON OCTOBER 5th -7th 2016
component receivers pick up the seismic signals water bearing zones and changes in rock
which were being reflected from any kind of mechanical properties are key factors for a sound
discontinuity in rock mass ahead. The capability risk management, consistent operational safety
of system to record the full wave field of and timely planning of construction
compressional and shear wave in conjunction with countermeasures.
intelligent analysis software enable a
determination of rock mechanical properties such 4 CASE STUDY OF PREDICTION DURING
as Poisons ratio and Youngs modulus within the TUNNELLING IN THE CHAVIMOCHIC
prediction area. The final 2D and 3D summary SPECIAL PROJECT
result produced by the system software presents as
well detected events and boundary planes crossing 4.1 Background
the tunnel axis coordinates ahead of face The III stage of the Chavimochic Special
(Dickmann and Krger, 2014). Project comprises the excavation of five tunnels
3.2 Benefits with an approximate total length of 4 km, among
other infrastructure work (Figure 2). The tunnels
The owner and contractor can make know their are being excavated by the Drill & Blast method.
risk, because they can detect and quantify the To date, development of the project shows a
geological hazard. Unknown uncertainties should remarkable advance due to an efficient and
belong to the past and they become known faultless execution.
uncertainties. With regular tunnel seismic
operation they identify their geological risk Local geology within the project area comprises
detecting hazards and quantifying the impact to intercalation of sedimentary rocks and intrusive
their tunneling projects. By this means, tunnel and extrusive volcanic rocks. Along the tunnel
builders can understand the risk as chance and in under investigation, intercalations of slightly
very economical way. altered and fractured andesite of moderate quality
with sedimentary rocks of similar characteristics
Depending on heading length and type of the are found.
projects, the investment in knowing the risk by a
regular TSP operation is just between 0.7 % and
1.8% of the time dependent site cost, provision of
installation and energy expenses (Figure 1).

Figure 1: TSP expenses when applied on regular base Figure 2: Overview of the Chavimochic Project, in red
dependent on heading length and excavation method. infrastructures of phase III (modified from DNA-Blast
Expenses are based on time related site costs. Numbers in Latinoamrica, 2016).
bars give TSP expenses in percentage of total heading days.
4.2 Objective
In other words, all investments in this
technology are already paid after saving 3 to 7 The objective of this case study is a geological
days of downtime. For TBM operation a minimum prediction of minimum 130 meter ahead of tunnel
length of 3 km is assumed, here a reduction of face and verification of the TSP result by
only three to five days of downtime pays off TSP contrasting the prediction against the excavated
operation on a regular basis. geology. In addition, results of the TSP campaign
are compared with complementary predictive
Advance knowledge of approximate spatial mechanical technology called DNA-Drill-Log
dimensions of geological fault zones, cavities, developed by Thierry Bernard Technologie,
XV COLOMBIAN GEOTECHNICAL CONGRESS & II INTERNATIONAL SPECIALIZED CONFERENCE OF SOFT ROCKS.
CARTAGENA ON OCTOBER 5th -7th 2016
France. The latter method consists of the Finally, the last step of the processing flow
estimation of the rock strength based on a automatically extracts dominant reflector
calibrated assessment of the probing drilling elements, which can be presented in 2D or 3D
parameters. views with a reflective layer extraction of P-
Investigation target of the TSP measurement waves, SH-waves and SV-waves and all
was to assess changes in the rock conditions due geotechnical parameters calculated during
to alternating lithology and detection of geological processing of data. During the interpretation of
structures relevant for the excavation. results, the rock formations are divided depending
on P- and S-wave velocities and elastic moduli.
4.3 Approach For the data evaluation, only the more prominent
The measurement was carried out in the reflection signals ahead of the tunnel face are
restitution tunnel face at tm 0+975 using the taken into account.
system TSP 303 Plus with 24 shots holes drilled in 4.4 Results
the right tunnel wall and small explosive charges,
ranging from 20 to 40 g used as the seismic In the TSP layout, reference P- and S-wave
source. Behind the shot hole line, two holes were velocities are estimated as 5,603 m/s and 3,239
drilled each on both side of tunnel wall for setting m/s, respectively. These reference velocities
the seismic sensors (accelerometers) as shown in correspond to the direct wave traveling from the
Figure 3. The method is completely non- shot holes to the receiver; hence, they are
destructive. After the recording unit had been representative of the prevailing geology within the
connected to the receivers and trigger box, a first layout which in this case corresponds to
shot in the borehole closest to the receivers was competent andesites. Similarly, a reference
being fired with 20 g explosive charge in order to dynamic Youngs modulus (Edyn) of 74 GPa was
test the seismic signal amplitude. Recorded estimated. Since Edyn is directly derived from the
seismic data can be viewed on the screen at any wave velocities and density, it can be in most
time during acquisition in order to check the data cases correlated to the rock stiffness.
quality and the signal to noise ratio. Based on the P and S-wave velocities and
estimated geomechanical parameters ahead of the
face, three major sections were identified as
shown in Figure 4.
Section 1: TM 0+976 to 1+010

Increasing P- and S-wave velocities (Vp >6,000


m/s and Vs >3,290 m/s) in comparison to the
reference value. Edyn increases from 74 GPa to 87
GPa indicating increasing rock stiffness. Some
reflectors are found at TM 0+996 with slightly
Figure 3: Layout of TSP survey at restitution tunnel with decreased Edyn.
reference position at pk 0+919 and tunnel face location at Section 2: TM 1+010 to 1+035
0+976 km. Blue dots indicate seismic 3C-receivers and red
dots indicate the seismic source points (shots). Large decrease in Vp reaching values down to
5,240 m/s. S-wave velocities also decreases to
After acquisition, the data is processed using the values around the reference (3,205 m/s). The Edyn
Amberg TSP Plus software. In general, the aim of decreases to values around 69 GPa, lower than the
seismic data processing is an extraction and reference indicating a significant decrease in rock
enhancement of the reflected wave field. For this stiffness. The high number of extracted reflectors
purpose the data have been run through a given indicates a high reflectivity at this area possibly
number of specially designed processing steps, due to a high density of joints. It might be
where intermediate results are stored enabling a associated to a fracture zone or a cluster of joints.
review during processing at any time. The Within it, a 6 m wide area with improved rock
subsequent wave separation process of Amberg condition is also found from TM 1+026 to 1+032
TSP Plus separates the recordings into wave types characterized for an increase in the P-wave
according to their polarization type. velocity.
XV COLOMBIAN GEOTECHNICAL CONGRESS & II INTERNATIONAL SPECIALIZED CONFERENCE OF SOFT ROCKS.
CARTAGENA ON OCTOBER 5th -7th 2016

Figure 4: Reflectors longitudinal view (top) with colour shading according of P-wave velocity and rock property charts
(bottom).

Section 3: TM 1+035 to 1+140 unfavorable conditions. The major features were:


sedimentary rocks with low angle stratification,
P- and S-wave velocities increase to values well defined unconformable lithological contacts
higher than the reference (Vp >5,700 m/a and Vs and a minor fault system crossing the face sub-
>3,300 m/s). Likewise, Edyn increases to values vertically showing a high weakening of the rock
around 83 GPa indicating rock conditions similar mass at some segments.
to slightly better than in the TSP layout.
Section 3: TM 1+050 to 1+115
4.5 Excavated geology and rock mass
This section presents similar geological feature
classification along the prediction range
as found in Section 1: alternation of sedimentary
Main geological features as found during the and volcanic rocks with moderate alteration and
excavation are described for the three sections fracturing and moderate rock mass strength.
previously defined.
4.6 Predictive mechanical probing
Section 1: TM 0+976 to 1+010
For comparative purposes, the mechanical rock
The excavated rock comprises alternating mass characterization method was applied
sedimentary and volcanic rocks, fractured and throughout the prediction range every 30 m. The
moderately altered. The rock mass strength is method takes into account a site coefficient
moderate. measured at the face at the moment of the probing,
Section 2: TM 1+010 to 1+035 used for calibration. By applying this coefficient,
The excavation was characterized by the the rock strength in MPa can be estimated.
occurrence of various geological structures with
XV COLOMBIAN GEOTECHNICAL CONGRESS & II INTERNATIONAL SPECIALIZED CONFERENCE OF SOFT ROCKS.
CARTAGENA ON OCTOBER 5th -7th 2016
Figure 5 depicts the estimated strength which is The second segment classified as type IV occurs
proportional to the compressional strength at the end of the prediction range. Due to the
resulting from the relationship between the attenuation of the seismic signals, both resolution
advance rate, torque and injection pressure. and accuracy of detectable targets diminish with
Considering these values, operator observations increasing distance from the face position. Since it
and drilling cuts, three major sections were is found 140 m ahead of the face; the possibility to
defined and characterized in terms of rock mass obtain reliable reflections from a discontinuity
types. In addition, the rock mass types based on located at this distance diminishes considerably.
RMR calculations for each section are presented. Moreover, the presence of the minor fault system
with fractured rock from TM 1+010 to 1+035,
most likely further attenuates the seismic energy
making more difficult to detect geological
structures towards the end of the prediction range.

Figure 5: Rock mass strength in function of the tunnelmeter


(DNA DRILL LOG, Thierry Bernard, 2015).

Section 1: TM 0+960 to 1+015


Moderate to good rock mass strength with
volcanic rock as main lithology. Occurrence of
minor geological structures. Minor features
relevant for the excavation are found which
require local treatment. The rock mass is
catalogued as type III
Section 2: TM 1+015 to 1+035

Altered rock mass with low strength and


occurrence of unfavorable geological structures
such as: minor faults, unconformable Figure 6: Rock mass classification after excavation upon the
lithological contact among others. The rock baseline geological profile (top), Vp estimated from the
mass type is IV. seismic waves together with the rock mass classification
Section 3: TM 1+035 to 1+135
(bottom).

Homogenous rock mass characterized by high Table 2 presents a summary of TSP parameters
strength. It is slightly fractured with low to (Vp, Vs and Edyn), the rock mass strength and
moderate alteration. No major features relevant type of rock coming from the mechanical probing.
for the excavation are found. The rock type is The tunnelmeter sections were defined according
III. Around TM 1+120, a decrease in the rock to the occurrence of relevant features along the
mass strength is found. At this section of about TSP prediction range for each applied method.
5 m, the rock type is IV.
4.7 Results comparison 5 CONCLUSION
Figure 6 depicts the rock mass classification The result and their comparison with excavated
(RMR) after excavation upon the geological geology and the mechanical probing method
profile and the P-wave velocity as interpreted proved TSP 303 as an efficient and reliable tool to
along the prediction range. The rock mass along obtain 3D geological information up to 150 m
most of the prediction range is classified as type ahead of the face.
III. The seismic section 2 with a significant Three major seismic zones could be defined
decrease in seismic velocities and geomechanical which are in good agreement with the prediction
parameters is in very good agreement with the of the complementary exploration method. In
section catalogued as type IV (first orange addition, the geological findings while tunnel
segment) corresponding to a decrease in rock excavation corroborates the seismic results in
strength as indicated by the mechanical probing. almost the entire prediction range. Towards the
end of the prediction range, a 6 m width zone was
XV COLOMBIAN GEOTECHNICAL CONGRESS & II INTERNATIONAL SPECIALIZED CONFERENCE OF SOFT ROCKS.
CARTAGENA ON OCTOBER 5th -7th 2016
not fully detected possibly due to the large TSP 303 applications are the right way to turn
attenuation of the seismic energy and due to the the geological risk into manageable risk providing
fact that this area coincide with the end of the detection rates up to 80-90% of rock formation
seismic model where the detection accuracy changes and geological discontinuities and a
significantly diminishes. However, according to location accuracy of about 5% of the distance to
the heading, this zone did not represent a face.
significant risk for the excavation. Geology always plays a major role in the
Based on the experience gained so far, the TSP planning stage. Hence, there must be proper
303 system can be successfully used in tunneling investigations to be carried out by advanced 3D
activities in the Andean region. The prevailing Tunnel Seismic Prediction technology on a
rock types and expected geological structures continuous basis.
offers ideal scenario for using this technology.
Data acquisition does not significantly delay or 6 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
effect the tunnel operation and can be performed
on a continuous basis and as demonstrated in the We like to thank the concession holder
case study, the use of tunnel seismic investigations Concesionaria Chavimochic S.A.C. for order and
use together with complementary exploration approval to publish this case study and to the TSP
tools considerably helps in reducing the geological user company at the project, DNA-BLAST
risk. Latinoamrica S.A.C. for the support and
facilitating the results for preparing this article.

Table 2. Summary of TSP parameters and rock strength and rock types according to the mechanical probes along TSP
prediction range (the blue cells correspond to the reference values estimated within the TSP layout).

Tunnemeter (m) Vp (m/s) Vs (m/s) Edyn (GPa) Rock strength (MPa) Rock type
Initial Final min max min max min max min max
0+919 0+976 5,603 3239 74 33 42 III
0+976 1+010 6,000 6,200 3,290 3,395 81 87 29 40 III
1+010 1+035 5,244 5,294 3,205 3,360 69 74 25 30 IV
1+035 1+042 5,973 5,973 3,262 3,262 79 79 30 33 III
1+042 1+048 5,379 5,379 3,276 3,276 73 73 30 35 III
1+048 1+140 5,782 6,018 3,253 3,351 78 83 29 42 III

7 REFERENCES
Corba Colombo, A. (2015). Tecnologa y experiencia
italiana en la construccin del tnel automovilstico
ms largo de Amrica Latina. Interempresas.net.
Retrieved from http://www.interempresas.net/
Dickmann, T. (2014). The Role of Tunnel Seismic
prediction in a Tunnelling projects: best practises.
Proceedings of the Fifth Indian Rock Conference
2014, Delhi, India.
Dickmann, T. and Krueger, D. (2014), How to turn
geological uncertainty into manageable risk.
Proceedings of the World Tunnel Congress 2014
Tunnels for a better Life. Foz do Iguau, Brazil.
Brox, D. and Venturini, G. (2009). Technical
considerations for TBM tunneling in the Andes, in:
2009 Rapid Excavation and Tunneling Conference
Proceedings, 1261-1292, SME, Colorado, USA.
Hoek, E., and Guevara, R. (2009). Overcoming
squeezing in the Yacamb-Qubor tunnel,
Venezuela. Rock Mechanics and Rock Engineering
42: 389418.

You might also like