Professional Documents
Culture Documents
In the end, Piñera, who led all candidates in the first round with
36% of the vote, beat Frei quite handily in the run-off, reaching
almost 52%. Frei, who disappointed throughout, failed to capi-
talize on the unfading popularity of president Bachelet (SP) and
managed to scramble together 48% in the run-off, compared to
the lowly 29% he received in the first round. The candidacy of
‘independent’ Socialist, Marco Enríquez Ominami or MEO, made
these elections more interesting than past ones. MEO broke from
the Concertación ranks and obtained just over 20% in the first
round, having successfully tapped into the current frustration with
Chile’s neoliberal model and the Concertación governments that
have managed it. And, Jorge Arrate, an old-school Socialist (albeit
with strong ties to the Concertación) ran on the Communist-led
ticket, getting a respectable 6.2% of votes cast. As Arrate’s votes
were already committed to Frei, the second round largely became
a contest over MEO’s followers.
page 2
elections in chile:
a loss for the left?
The regime also excludes large chunks of the working class from
even formal incorporation. Recent estimates show that well over
half of Chilean workers are under-employed, informally employed
or generally employed in jobs considered ‘precarious’. The per-
centage of workers in unions and those covered by collectively
bargained contracts have actually shrunk since 1990, from 10%
and 12.5%, to 8.5% and 11%, respectively. This should come as
no surprise as under the current regime, Pinochet’s regressive la-
bor law remains in effect. To this day, industrial unionism is not
allowed (workers can only bargain at the firm level) and the broad
layers of informal and subcontracted workers enjoy no legal pro-
tections. Similarly, the peasants have not only failed to recover the
land which the 1967-1973 land reform process granted them and
which the coercion of the market or the military took away, small-
holders continue to lose their lands to highly capitalized export
farmers and transnational food conglomerates. The recent worries
expressed by Concertacionista Viera-Gallo that Piñera might opt
for repression when dealing with Mapuche grievances is nothing
short of absurd. When adjudicating between claims on natural re-
sources disputed between indigenous communities and large capi-
tal, the Concertación consistently responded with brutal coercion
against the Mapuche!
page 3
Solidarity: a socialist, feminist, anti-racist organization
While poverty has been reduced, the social problems that afflict
Chilean society are not too far beneath the surface. They are in-
creasingly exposed and everyday move closer to the point of erup-
tion. Chile has become one of the most unequal societies in the
world and large sectors are losing their patience. The explosion
of the students’ movement in 2005-2006 shows this as do other
smaller and more local struggles. Along with the persistent Mapu-
che movement, the huge 2007 wildcat strikes by sub-contracted
miners, and the persistent shanty debtors’ protests, are clear indi-
cators of the potential for large-scale social unrest.
page 4
elections in chile:
a loss for the left?
page 5
Solidarity: a socialist, feminist, anti-racist organization
been far from impartial. In the 2005 Mar de Plata Summit, where
Washington’s proposed FTAA was definitively defeated, the head of
state that most fervently promoted this neocolonization scheme,
after Mexico’s ultra-conservative Vicente Fox, was Ricardo Lagos,
the SP president who preceded Bachelet. Further, Chile’s national
security forces are highly integrated into US projects, both in terms
of military strategy and weapons systems, a development, to re-
peat, that Bachelet facilitated. While foreign policy under Piñera
might be more openly aligned with US strategic interests, it will be
marked by basic continuity.
page 6
elections in chile:
a loss for the left?
page 7
Solidarity: a socialist, feminist, anti-racist organization
page 8
elections in chile:
a loss for the left?
youth, things are even worse. The apparent apathy and resignation
that the exclusionary character of the post-1990 regime has bred
is a problem that the radical left will have to address.
page 9
Solidarity: a socialist, feminist, anti-racist organization
first round wholeheartedly supported Frei in the run off for this
very reason. In exchange for this support, the Communists and its
allies were ceded three congressional seats by the Concertación.
The logic behind such a deal with Christian Democrat and Social-
ist Party neoliberals is that it keeps the Right at bay while simul-
taneously giving the Left a parliamentary foothold. However, for
the reasons listed above, this position is unconvincing. Having the
Concertación in office does no more to level the political playing
field for the anti-capitalist left. And tying the success of the left to
the fortunes of the neoliberal Concertación seems doomed to fail.
page 10
elections in chile:
a loss for the left?
page 11
Solidarity: a socialist, feminist, anti-racist organization
page 12
elections in chile:
a loss for the left?
To the extent that the post-1990 regime has been shaken and
openings will present themselves for increasing active popular
struggles, and to the extent that the a new generation of anti-capi-
talist activists and movements follow the advice of groups like the
MPT, the prospects for a genuine radical left in Chile may improve.
page 13
massive earthquake shatters
myth of chilean exceptionalism:
deep Class Faultlines Exposed
By Rene Rojas -- March 3, 2010
page 15
Solidarity: a socialist, feminist, anti-racist organization
One has to wonder at the outcome if the quake in Chile had been
centered right next to and right beneath Santiago’s or Concep-
ción’s poor neighborhoods. Still, as the disparate death tolls sug-
gest (thus far 3000 deaths and missing persons have been reported
in the wake of the Chilean quake), Chile undoubtedly fared much
better. But beneath the more positive assessment lies a grim real-
ity produced by Chile’s neoliberal model. The extreme free market
policies inherited from and pursued vigorously since the end of
Pinochet’s dictatorship have generated catastrophic vulnerabilities
among Chile’s working class and have needlessly aggravated the
suffering caused by the earthquake.
If the country is no doubt in better shape than Haiti, what the Chil-
ean quake also reveals is that amidst Chile’s glorified economic
‘miracle’, there are deep and wide pockets of Haiti-like conditions.
It is estimated that out of a total population of 17 million people,
at least one million families have lost their homes. Half a million
homes have been completely destroyed. Another one to two mil-
lion have been seriously damaged. By comparison, it is estimated
that the Haitian quake left one million people homeless out of a
total population of ten million. To this day in Chile, there is no
plan in place to provide these people with proper housing. The
government simply has no contingency plans in place to respond.
While the state is functional, it has been stripped of its capacity
to act in such circumstances after decades of religiously pursuing
neoliberal policies.
page 16
Massive Earthquake Shatters Myth of Chilean Exceptionalism:
Deep Class Faultlines Exposed
relief.
So far, reports are that they fared well. In his NYT op-ed, ‘Santiago
Stands Firm’, architecture professor Sebastián Gray gave the coun-
try the highest marks suggesting that our ‘height of civilization’ ex-
plains why ‘of the thousands of contemporary mid- to high-rises in
Santiago and Concepción, most were able to withstand the quake
with only cosmetic damage, if any. Thank the stringent building
codes and responsible building practices that have existed here
since the devastating earthquakes of 1939 and 1960, which lev-
eled many older structures.’ In his view, the ‘few modern structures
[and highway overpasses] that crumbled’ were ‘spectacular excep-
tions’, that is, the few bad yet unrepresentative rotten apples.
page 17
Solidarity: a socialist, feminist, anti-racist organization
A similar two year old building in the Maipu district of the capital
collapsed. Another, built by the same company responsible for the
Concepción deathtrap, has been quietly vacated by officials in the
Nuñoa district. Reports are emerging of other hushed evacuations.
The cosmetic damage reported by Gray seems to be widespread
and irreparable structural disrepair. In Nuñoa, at least one resident
reported that the foundational underground beams had been com-
pressed into ‘S’s’ like putty.
I’m willing to bet this is the case with a number of these new build-
ings. It’s unconceivable that the construction companies did not
cut corners in this unbridled race to erect these buildings. And one
can only speculate the degree to which the endemic corruption
that characterizes the ruling Concertación political coalition in-
cluded inspectors and regulators who took bribes to look the other
way. It is a well known fact that infrastructure concessions were
granted in ways that benefited state brokers who cut profitable
deals with contractors. These arrangements favor the pockets of
officials over the safety of consumers.
page 18
Massive Earthquake Shatters Myth of Chilean Exceptionalism:
Deep Class Faultlines Exposed
Proto-Class War?
page 19
Solidarity: a socialist, feminist, anti-racist organization
page 20
Massive Earthquake Shatters Myth of Chilean Exceptionalism:
Deep Class Faultlines Exposed
page 21
Solidarity: a socialist, feminist, anti-racist organization
What the episode makes clear is who calls the shots in Chile. At-
tention to this issue did not emerge until business forcefully raised
its concerns. The state will now take minor steps to distribute
some goods to the affected poor. But the main message of its ac-
tions was that it immediately stepped up to make sure that the pri-
vate property of the huge retailers, and their fundamental power
to shape the distribution of commodities, would not be threatened
even when the goods will probably go bad or be thrown away.
Two things happened at this point. First, things did get out of hand.
They were unable to do this in an orderly fashion. When people
heard what was happening, they rushed over. Young men in par-
ticular started ‘riling things up’, liberally taking and distributing all
kinds of goods to those gathered. Second, and more importantly,
the retail and supermarket executivess got wind of this unaccept-
able reality--cops ALLOWING workers to take was they needed!--
and it was at this point that they held their meeting with Bachelet,
a meeting that is no longer being reported in the news.
page 22
Massive Earthquake Shatters Myth of Chilean Exceptionalism:
Deep Class Faultlines Exposed
military’s behavior after the 1973 coup. Yet this time, the Socialist
Party is squarely behind the repression. Bachelet and other heads
of the SP have thrown their full weight behind these measures;
indeed, they ordered them!
page 23
Solidarity: a socialist, feminist, anti-racist organization
His exaggeration reflected more than the hyperbole that these ca-
lamities evoke; workers in Concepción, and throughout Chile, ex-
perience chronic deprivation. Ironically, the quake offered them
the opportunity to obtain the food, water, etc., which under normal
circumstances they are not sure to come by. The quake has thus
revealed the daily and basic material uncertainty that neoliberal-
ism has produced for large swaths of the working class in Chile.
page 24
Massive Earthquake Shatters Myth of Chilean Exceptionalism:
Deep Class Faultlines Exposed
For one, I think that the disaster will tend to bolster the current
regime in Chile. The two competing alliances will confront this
situation with common language and policies. This is clear in their
shared desire for and appreciation of the militarized response.
This will tend to reinforce their power-sharing arrangements and
lock in their hold on governing institutions.
page 25
Solidarity: a socialist, feminist, anti-racist organization
page 26
elections in chile:
a loss for the left?
page 27
Interested in learning more about organizing with
SOLIDARITY?
A REVOLUTIONARY SOCIALIST, FEMINIST AND ANTI-RACIST ORGANIZATION