Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract: New data on the epidemiology of peripheral artery disease (PAD) are available, and they should be
integrated with previous data. We provide an updated, integrated overview of the epidemiology of PAD, a focused
literature review was conducted on the epidemiology of PAD. The PAD results were grouped into symptoms,
diagnosis, prevalence, and incidence both in the United States and globally, risk factors, progression, coprevalence
with other atherosclerotic disease, and association with incident cardiovascular morbidity and mortality. The
most common symptom of PAD is intermittent claudication, but noninvasive measures, such as the ankle-
brachial index, show that asymptomatic PAD is several times more common in the population than intermittent
claudication. PAD prevalence and incidence are both sharply age-related, rising >10% among patients in their 60s
and 70s. With aging of the global population, it seems likely that PAD will be increasingly common in the future.
Prevalence seems to be higher among men than women for more severe or symptomatic disease. The major risk
factors for PAD are similar to those for coronary and cerebrovascular disease, with some differences in the relative
importance of factors. Smoking is a particularly strong risk factor for PAD, as is diabetes mellitus, and several
newer risk markers have shown independent associations with PAD. PAD is strongly associated with concomitant
coronary and cerebrovascular diseases. After adjustment for known cardiovascular disease risk factors, PAD
is associated with an increased risk of incident coronary and cerebrovascular disease morbidity and mortality.
(Circ Res. 2015;116:1509-1526. DOI: 10.1161/CIRCRESAHA.116.303849.)
Key Words: ankle brachial index intermittent claudication peripheral artery disease prognosis
Original received September 3, 2014; revision received November 10, 2014; accepted November 14, 2015. In February 2015, the average time from
submission to first decision for all original research papers submitted to Circulation Research was 13.9 days.
From the Division of Preventive Medicine, Department of Family and Preventive Medicine, Division of Cardiology, Department of Medicine, University
of California, San Diego, La Jolla, CA (M.H.C.); Department of Cardiology, Dupuytren University Hospital, Limoges, France (V.A.); and INSERM 1094,
Tropical Neuroepidemiology, Limoges School of Medicine, Limoges, France (V.A.).
Correspondence to Michael H. Criqui, MD, MPH, Department of Family and Preventive Medicine, University of California, 9500 Gilman Dr, MC 0607,
La Jolla, CA 92093. E-mail mcriqui@ucsd.edu
2015 American Heart Association, Inc.
Circulation Research is available at http://circres.ahajournals.org DOI: 10.1161/CIRCRESAHA.116.303849
1509
1510Circulation ResearchApril 24, 2015
been shown to have high intra- and inter-rater reliability.13 In In line with this, recent data document that in normal subjects,
practice, the ABI is measured using a blood pressure cuff, a the influence of height on the ABI is small.17 On average, ABIs
standard sphygmomanometer, and a Doppler instrument to are slightly lower in women independent of height and slight-
detect pulses. Technical considerations in measuring the ABI ly lower in African Americans (AA).17 This has little clinical
include the choice of ankle pressure for the ABI numera- effect on the diagnosis of PAD at an individual level but may
tor and the choice of arm pressure for the ABI denominator. contribute to an overestimation of PAD prevalence in popula-
Many protocols have been suggested. In an attempt to pro- tion studies. Perhaps, the most significant limitation is arterial
vide the best evidence base for measuring the ABI, an interna- stiffness noted above. Recommendations for PAD assessment
tional working group was assembled. The recommendations when the ABI is >1.40 are given in Table2.
were published as an American Heart Association Scientific
Statement in 2012.14 Selected key recommendations are sum- Incidence and Prevalence of PAD
marized in Table2. The recommendations are grouped into 5 The study of PAD epidemiology raises many methodological
categories: (1) measurement of ABI, (2) measurement of sys- issues that should be kept in mind while reviewing the litera-
tolic pressures of the 4 limbs, (3) calculation of ABI, (4) use ture. As discussed earlier, the definition of disease has evolved
and interpretation of the ABI if clinical presentation of PAD, over time, with earlier studies focusing more on IC, as mea-
and (5) interpretation of ABI as a marker of subclinical cardio- sured using Rose and other criteria, and later studies using the
vascular disease (CVD) and risk in asymptomatic individuals. ABI, with a value of 0.90, now widely used to define disease.
Within each of these 5 categories, specific issues concerning Uncommon among younger people, the prevalence of PAD
measurement and interpretation of the ABI are addressed.
Downloaded from http://circres.ahajournals.org/ by guest on May 30, 2017
70%
incidence was 1.7 per 1000 at the age of 40 to 54 years; 1.5 per
60% 1000 at the age of 55 to 64; and 17.8 per 1000 at the age of 65.
50%
Annual incidence in women was higher: 5.9, 9.1, and 22.9 per
1000, respectively, for the same age groups.25 Sex differences
Prevalence
40%
in the incidence and prevalence of PAD are less clear than those
30% in other CVDs. IC incidence and prevalence have usually been
20%
found to be higher in men than in women. For example, in the
Framingham Study, annual IC incidence for all ages combined
10%
was 7.1 per 1000 in men versus 3.6 per 1000 in women, for a
0% male to female ratio of 1.97.23 In the Framingham Offspring
40 50 60 70 80 90
Age (years) Study, IC prevalence was 1.9% in men versus 0.8% in wom-
NHW AA HS AS AI
en (ratio, 2.38), whereas in the Rotterdam Study, it was 2.2%
Figure 1. Ethnic-specific prevalence of peripheral arterial in men versus 1.2% in women (ratio, 1.83).7,26 However, the
disease in men in the United States.18 AA indicates African Edinburgh Artery Study and the Limburg PAOD Study found
Americans; AI, American Indians; AS, Asian Americans; HS,
Hispanics; and NHW, non-Hispanic whites. much lower male to female ratios of IC prevalence of 1.1 and
1.2, respectively.15,20 The case for an excess of disease among
men is less clear for PAD diagnosed based on ABI. This is true
PAD, or both. The results for men are shown in Figure1. PAD even in those studies finding a clear male excess with respect
was uncommon before the age of 50 years. Rates rose sharply
Downloaded from http://circres.ahajournals.org/ by guest on May 30, 2017
strict Rose criteria for probable IC.24 In the Reykjavik Study, 50%
40%
clude that IC rates among Icelandic men dropped significantly
30%
between 1968 and 1986; among 50-year-old men, their esti-
mate of the rate of IC dropped from 1.7 per 1000 per year in 20%
1970 to 0.6 per 1000 per year in 1984, whereas in men aged 10%
presentation of some patterns of atypical pain in women,5 as large studies.21,22,25,3542 Although the discussion draws on data
well as a modestly intrinsic lower ABI in women.17 In general, from many other studies, data are presented from these 5 in-
more severe disease as manifested by lower ABIs or symptom- dex studies across all the conventional CVD risk factors to
atic disease is more common in men. A recent study evaluated provide some consistency and comparability for the reader.
a large representative US sample of 12 million insured adults The effect of age and sex on PAD incidence and prevalence is
for PAD and critical limb ischemia incidence and prevalence discussed above.
based on insurance claims.31 From 2003 to 2008, the annual
incidence of PAD was 2.35%, and for critical limb ischemia, it Cigarette Smoking
was 0.35%. The prevalence of PAD was 10.69%, and for criti- Smoking is one of the strongest risk factors for PAD in virtu-
cal limb ischemia, it was 1.33%. ally all studies. Studies vary as to the measurement of smoking,
Global data on trends in PAD prevalence between the years often combining a categorical assessment of smoking status
2000 and 2010 were recently published.2 Over that period, the (current, past, or never) with some measures of current or his-
number of individuals with PAD increased by 28.7% in low- torical volume of smoking, such as pack-years. However, even
income and middle-income countries and by 13.1% in high- with some type of additional adjustment for volume of smok-
income countries. ing, current smoking versus nonsmoking has been shown to
at least double the odds of PAD in most studies, with some
estimates as high as a 4 greater risk among smokers than oth-
PAD Risk Factors ers. Among the index studies, current smoking (versus never
The strongest epidemiological evidence for a causal relation- or former/never) resulted in 1.9 to 3.4 higher odds of PAD in
Downloaded from http://circres.ahajournals.org/ by guest on May 30, 2017
ship between disease and putative risk factors comes from the 3 studies using such categorization; however, in 2 of these
studies of incident disease. Such studies usually involve the studies, the models also included pack-years of smoking as a
measurement of risk factors at a baseline examination, with significant variable (Table4). All of the large, population-based
subsequent tracking of incident disease among the subjects. studies that were reviewed found a significant, independent as-
Acute events, such as myocardial infarction and stroke, lend sociation between PAD and smoking. According to recent data
themselves to such study because the date of onset of disease on incident cases of clinical PAD in US male professionals,
is generally documented in the records of healthcare provid- smoking is the most contributive risk factor for occurrence of
ers and recalled by subjects. Conversely, the onset of PAD as PAD, with a population attributable fraction of 44%.42
defined by ABI is often asymptomatic, and in any case, it is Cessation of smoking among patients with IC has been
unlikely to be documented other than through periodic re-ex- shown to improve various functional and physiological
amination of all the subjects, which involves substantial time measures related to PAD, as well as reducing mortality.43,44
and expense. For that reason, many studies of PAD risk fac- However, because symptomatic patients with PAD have long
tors are based on cross-sectional associations, that is, the asso- been advised to quit smoking, it is possible that observational
ciation between current disease status and current risk factor comparisons of patients who quit smoking with those who do
measurements. Although such studies are potentially informa- not are confounded by other differences in compliance with
tive, the reported associations cannot conclusively prove cau- medical advice between the 2 groups. Randomized trials of
sation because it is not known whether the risk factor preceded this question would raise ethical issues. However, substantial
the disease or vice versa. Caution should, therefore, be exer- bias is unlikely given the large effect size for cigarette smok-
cised in reviewing the results of such cross-sectional studies, ing. In the Health Professionals Follow-up Study (HPFS),
particularly where reverse causation is plausible. For exam- smoking was associated with increased risk of incident clini-
ple, low physical activity might cause IC, but IC might just as cal PAD even after 20 years of smoking cessation, although
plausibly cause low physical activity. It is necessary to adjust this association was substantially diminished beyond 10 years
for multiple potential risk factors in a single statistical model after quitting smoking cigarettes.42
to accurately estimate the unique contribution of any single There are limited data on the association of passive smok-
risk factor because the potential risk factors for PAD are them- ing and PAD. In a Chinese study conducted with women who
selves interrelated in various ways. The estimates presented have never smoked, the hazard ratio (HR) for PAD (either IC
here are based on such multiple adjustments for all traditional or ABI<0.90) after secondhand smoke exposure was signifi-
PAD risk factors, except as noted. Null findings may indicate cant at 1.67, with a significant doseresponse relationship,
the lack of a real association but may also be based on insuf- both for the amount and the duration of exposure.45
ficient sample size. Most of the null findings discussed below Similar relationships were reported from 2 studies of never
are based on the failure of the risk factor of interest to remain smokers in Scotland. The first study used reported secondhand
statistically significant in stepwise regression models. The fol- smoke as the exposure variable, whereas the second used sali-
lowing discussion of risk factors focuses on the results from vary cotinine measures.46,47 Smoking seems to have an even
5 large epidemiological studies,26,28,3234 which are referred more prominent role in PAD than in other atherosclerotic dis-
to as index studies (Table3). These studies each had >3000 eases. In a comparison of risk factors conducted in the same
subjects drawn from the general population and included both large cohort, Fowkes et al36 found smoking to be associated
men and women. These studies are similar enough in their with a significantly higher relative risk for PAD compared
selection and manner of measuring risk factors, and in their with other CVDs; smoking was the only traditional CVD risk
statistical analyses, to allow reasonable comparisons for most factor for which the odds ratio differed significantly between
of the common risk factors. Table3 also includes 11 other PAD and other CVDs.
1514Circulation ResearchApril 24, 2015
Disease
Reykjavik Study Ingolfsson, 199421 9141 Iceland Men only Longitudinal IC
Honolulu Heart Program Curb, 199637 3450 United States Japanese Cross-sectional and ABI<0.9
American men longitudinal
Limburg PAOD Study Hooi, 200125 2327 Netherlands Longitudinal ABI<0.95
Womens Health and Aging McDermott, 200038 930 United States Women aged 65+ Longitudinal ABI<0.9
Study
Physicians Health Study Ridker, 200139 14916 United States Male physicians Nested casecontrol IC or PAD surgery
San Diego Population Study Criqui, 200540 2343 United States Multiethnic Cross-sectional ABI0.9, abnormal
waveform, PAD
revascularization
National Health and Nutrition Pande, 201141 7458 United States American men Longitudinal ABI0.9
Examination Survey and women aged
40+
Health Professionals Follow- Joosten, 201242 51529 United States Male health Longitudinal Clinical PAD
Up Study professionals
ABI indicates ankle-brachial index; IC, intermittent claudication; PAD, peripheral artery disease; and PAOD, peripheral arterial occlusive disease.
*Where multiple articles were published, this refers to the article most frequently referenced herein.
Includes limb amputation or revascularization, angiography with vascular obstruction 50%, ABI0.90, or physician-diagnosed PAD.
incident PAD.49 Studies conducted in patients with diabetes studies, total cholesterol has usually been found to be associat-
mellitus have shown that duration of diabetes mellitus, level of ed with PAD21,22,36,37 with occasional null findings in multivari-
glycemic control assessed by glycated-hemoglobin, and use able analyses in which other lipid measures are considered.48,60
of insulin are associated with PAD.5053 According to the HPFS, the population attributable fraction for
Outcomes of PAD in diabetic patients have been shown to PAD related to hypercholesterolemia is at 17%.42
be worse. In one study, diabetic patients with PAD were 5 HDL-C has been shown to be protective against PAD
more likely to have an amputation than other patients with in most studies where it was evaluated, usually in models
PAD; they also had >3 the odds of mortality.54 There is also that also considered total cholesterol. HDL-C was included
some evidence to support a somewhat different anatomic dis- among the potential risk factors in 3 of the 5 index studies
tribution of disease, with more disease in arteries distal to the and the total cholesterol/HDL-C ratio in the fourth, and it was
knee in diabetic versus nondiabetic patients.54,55 Beyond isch- significantly associated with PAD in multivariable analysis
emia, infection has an important role aggravating the risk of in all 4. In 2 studies, both HDL-C and total cholesterol were
amputation in these patients.56,57 significant in multivariable analysis, whereas in 1 study,
HDL-C (but not total cholesterol) was significant. Other
Hypertension and Blood Pressure studies have also shown a protective effect of HDL-C.37,60
The association of hypertension with PAD has been demon- Bowlin et al22 found that nonHDL-C (total cholesterol
strated in most studies in which blood pressure was studied. minus HDL-C) was significantly associated with incident
All 5 of the index studies reported a significant association IC in a large cohort of Israeli men; neither total cholesterol
between hypertension as a categorical variable and PAD. nor HDL-C were significantly associated with disease in
Downloaded from http://circres.ahajournals.org/ by guest on May 30, 2017
The lowest reported odds ratio was 1.32 as reported in the models that included nonHDL-C. In a comparison of
Rotterdam Study; this is somewhat understated relative to oth- incident cases of IC with healthy controls in the Physicians
ers, as it was based on a model that included both a categori- Health Follow-up Study (PHFS), Ridker et al39 found that
cal hypertension variable and an adjustment for systolic blood the ratio of total cholesterol/HDL-C was the lipid measure
pressure level, which was also significant.33 Other than this, most strongly associated with disease, with patients in the
odds ratios for hypertension ranged from 1.50 to 2.20. highest quartile having 3.9 the IC risk of patients in the
Most other large, population-based studies have also found lowest quartile; screening for other lipid fractions was judged
a significant, independent association of hypertension or sys- to have little clinical usefulness beyond measurement of this
tolic blood pressures with PAD.25,35,36,40,48 Where both systolic ratio. Previous casecontrol studies showed a consistent
and diastolic pressures were considered, systolic pressure was relationship between triglycerides and PAD, suggesting
usually found to be associated with PAD, whereas diastolic a uniquely strong relationship with PAD; however, large,
pressure was not significantly associated.28,33,58 Although the population-based cohort studies using multivariable
relative risks associated with hypertension are modest in some modeling later called this into question.36,61 Among the index
studies, its high prevalence, particularly among older patients, studies, only 2 included triglycerides among the potential risk
makes it a significant contributor to the total burden of PAD factors evaluated. In both cases, triglycerides were significant
in the population. For example, in one large study from the in univariate analysis but dropped out of multivariable
Netherlands, the odds ratio for hypertension was 1.32, but its models based on stepwise logistic regression.26,28 Similarly,
attributable fraction (a measure of the proportion of PAD in in the Edinburgh Artery Study cohort and in a large study
the population attributable to hypertension) was 17.0%.33 In of geriatric patients in the United States, triglycerides were
the Framingham Study, 30% of the risk of IC in the popula- not significantly associated with PAD after adjustment for
tion was attributable to blood pressure in excess of 160/100 other lipid measures.36,60 However, other studies have shown
mmHg.32 An even higher population risk attributable to hyper- triglycerides to be significantly and independently associated
tension, 41%, was recently reported in the HPFS.42 In these 3 with PAD in multivariable analysis.48,51,62 There is also some
latter studies, hypertension was second only to current smok- evidence suggesting that elevated triglycerides may have a
ing as the most contributive risk factor for PAD in population. role in disease progression or more severe PAD.36,58
In summary, although total cholesterol, HDL-C, and tri-
Dyslipidemia glycerides all seem to be associated with PAD on a univari-
In recent studies, the recognition that the total cholesterol to ate basis, in multivariable analysis, triglycerides frequently
high-density lipoprotein cholesterol (HDL-C) ratio is the best drop out as an independent risk factor. It is unclear whether
lipid measure of risk,59 along with the increasing use of medi- total cholesterol is the strongest independent risk factor for
cation, has led to analyses that use both these variables in the PAD; in one comparison of patients with PAD with healthy
same model40 or combine the ratio with medication use in a controls, it was found that mean total cholesterol did not differ
single variable, for example, dyslipidemia.34 Total cholesterol significantly, whereas triglycerides, very low-density lipopro-
has been the most widely studied lipid measure as a potential tein cholesterol, low-density lipoprotein cholesterol, HDL-C,
risk factor for PAD. Total cholesterol was examined as a poten- and the total-cholesterol/HDL-cholesterol ratio all did.63 Total
tial risk factor in 4 of the index studies, and it was significantly cholesterol and HDL-C seem to provide distinct information,
associated with PAD in multivariable analysis in 328,32,33; in the and they lend themselves to summarization in a single ratio.
remaining study, total cholesterol was significant in univari- Irrespective of results from multivariable analysis, simple de-
ate analysis but dropped out of multivariable models in which scriptive statistics and clinical observation both suggest that
other lipid measures were considered.26 Similarly, in other patients with PAD are frequently diabetic or insulin resistant,
1516Circulation ResearchApril 24, 2015
with the typical dyslipidemia of insulin resistance (ie, low lead to weight loss, allowing for a spurious inverse correlation
HDL-C and high triglycerides). between obesity and PAD. Ix et al64 evaluated this question in
the CHS of adults aged 65 years. In cross-sectional analysis,
Obesity each 5-U increase in BMI was inversely associated with PAD
To date, the preponderance of evidence fails to support a (PR [prevalence ratio], 0.92). However, among people in good
consistent, independent positive association between obe- health who had never smoked, the direction of association
sity and PAD. In one of the few large studies with a positive was opposite (PR=1.20). Similar results were observed be-
finding, Bowlin et al22 estimated an odds ratio of 1.24 (95% tween BMI calculated using weight at the age of 50 years and
confidence interval, 1.051.46) for incident claudication re- PAD prevalence (prevalence ratio, 1.30), and between BMI at
lated to a 5.0-kg/m2 difference in body mass index (BMI) in baseline and incident PAD events occurring during follow-up
a study of 10059 Israeli men. Three of the index studies and (HR, 1.32), among never smokers in good health. Thus, the
many other large, population-based studies have failed to find reported inverse associations between BMI and PAD may be
a significant association between obesity and PAD or claudi- artifactual.
cation after multivariable adjustment.21,25,26,33,34,60 There have As in coronary artery disease epidemiology, there is some
also been many studies, including the other 2 index studies, evidence to suggest that central adiposity may be more closely
in which higher relative weight or BMI was actually shown to related to an increased risk of PAD. Vogt et al8 found that, af-
be protective against PAD. In the Framingham Study, claudi- ter adjustment for BMI, higher waist/hip ratio was associated
cation was significantly inversely related to relative weight in with significantly higher risk of PAD. In a group of patients
men in multivariable analysis and seemed to have a U-shaped with diabetes mellitus, it was shown that waist/hip ratio, but
Downloaded from http://circres.ahajournals.org/ by guest on May 30, 2017
nonlinear relationship with relative weight in women.23 In an not BMI or body fat percentage, was associated with PAD.51
analysis from the Edinburgh Artery Study, BMI was signifi-
cantly associated with less disease in preliminary multivariable Alcohol Consumption
analysis, although BMI was excluded from the articles final Evidence for a protective effect of light-to-moderate alcohol
multivariable model because it suggested a counterintuitive consumption, as seen in coronary heart disease (CHD), is less
effect.36 The CHS found higher BMI to be significantly pro- consistent for PAD. Two of the 5 index studies considered alco-
tective against PAD after multivariable adjustment in a large hol intake; neither showed alcohol to be significantly associated
sample of Medicare beneficiaries.28 BMI was significantly with PAD in either age- and sex-adjusted or multivariable mod-
protective against PAD (defined based on a combination of els.26,33 However, in a later analysis of data from one of these
ABI, Doppler flow curves, and history of surgery) in the Hoorn studies, a significant protective effect was found in women but
Study.19 Similarly, the odds of PAD among subjects in the high- not in men.65 Conversely, a protective effect of alcohol was seen
est quintile of BMI compared with the lowest quintile were in men but not in women in the Edinburgh Artery Study, but
found to be significantly reduced in a cross-sectional analysis this association disappeared after adjustment for social class.66
of elderly Japanese American men.37 Subjects with higher BMI In Native Americans, a protective effect of alcohol was seen
were again shown to be at significantly lower risk of PAD in a in multivariable analysis,67 but in elderly Japanese American
study of Taiwanese subjects with diabetes mellitus.52 Finally, men, alcohol intake was found to increase rather than decrease
the multi-ethnic San Diego Population Study (SDPS) reported the risk of incident PAD.37 In a large Chinese population study,
a significant inverse association of BMI and PAD.40 low alcohol intake was associated with decreased prevalence of
Obesity has been implicated in the causes of other risk fac- PAD in men but not in women.68 Data from the PHFS suggest
tors for PAD, such as hypertension, type II diabetes mellitus, that a protective effect related to moderate alcohol consumption
and dyslipidemia. In epidemiology, adjusting for factors that may exist.69 In that study, there was no univariate association
are on the causal pathway between a risk factor and disease is between alcohol and claudication incidence, but adjustment for
known to attenuate the observed strength of that risk factor. cigarette smoking unmasked a significant protective associa-
Therefore, estimates of risks related to obesity in multivari- tion, reflecting the positive correlation of alcohol consumption
able models are estimates of the risk of obesity that artifi- with smoking, a strong risk factor for PAD.
cially ignore most of the mechanisms by which obesity might Race and Ethnicity
reasonably cause PAD. In a few cases, unadjusted models or Data on the association of race with PAD are limited because
models adjusted only for age and sex show a significant as- many of the large studies of PAD have been conducted in NHW
sociation with PAD, although obesity was nonsignificant or groups. Several studies suggest a higher risk of PAD among
protective after multivariable adjustment.26,36,60 However, in blacks. A study conducted in elderly native Africans in 2 cit-
other studies, obesity was found to be either protective or non- ies in Central Africa found high rates of PAD, 15% and 32%.70
significant even in unadjusted models or models adjusted only The CHS, a study of 5084 Medicare beneficiaries in the United
for age and sex.23,28,33,37,48 Thus, the failure to find more cases States, found that nonwhite (mostly black) race was associated
of positive association between PAD and obesity is not simply with an odds ratio of 2.12 for PAD after adjustment for tradition-
an artifact of adjusting for factors on the causal pathway in al risk factors.28 A study of 933 women aged 65 years found
multivariable modeling. a higher percentage of black subjects among the PAD (36.3%)
Unaccounted for in the multivariable analyses just cited is versus non-PAD (24.8%) groups.38 In the Atherosclerosis Risk
possible residual confounding by cigarette smoking, which in Communities (ARIC) study, Zheng et al71 found that PAD
is strongly associated with both PAD and lower BMI. In ad- prevalence was higher in AA versus whites in both men (3.3%
dition, chronic illness in older patients, including PAD, may versus 2.3%) and women (4.0% versus 3.3%). The MESA
Criqui and Aboyans Epidemiology of Peripheral Artery Disease 1517
reported a multivariable odds ratio of 1.67 for blacks versus missed significance after adjustment for other novel risk fac-
NHW.34 The SDPS reported an odds ratio of 2.34 for blacks tors.34 A nested casecontrol study using the PHFS cohort failed
versus NHW after adjustment for hypertension and diabetes to find any association between quartiles of fasting tHcy and
mellitus,40 and additional analyses also showed no evidence of IC.39 A casecontrol study of young women in the Netherlands
a greater sensitivity of blacks to traditional CVD risk factors. also failed to find any significant association between fasting
Finally, a synthesis of 3 studies addressing this question report- homocysteine and symptomatic PAD.76 More recently, 2 nested
ed odds ratios of 2.3 to 3.1 for blacks versus NHW adjusted casecontrol studies within the Nurses Health Study and the
for age and sex; odds ratios of 1.7 to 2.9 after adjustment for HPFS cohorts found homocysteine levels positively associated
traditional risk factors; and odds ratios of 1.5 to 2.0 after further and dietary folate intake inversely associated with risk of PAD
adjustment for novel risk factors, including inflammatory risk in men but not in women.79 Among patients with PAD, disease
factors.72 Thus, this association is in part explained by tradition- progression based on ABI was not significantly different in pa-
al risk factors and in part by novel risk factors, but there is an tients with the highest and lowest 20% of homocysteine levels.80
unexplained residual difference. Interestingly, hospital-based Although it is still possible that homocysteine may be an inde-
studies suggest that the anatomic distribution of disease may pendent risk factor for PAD, it seems that the previous results
differ in blacks, with a higher percentage of distal disease in summarized in the 1995 meta-analysis may have overstated the
black subjects, even after adjustment for diabetes mellitus and importance of homocysteine. Accordingly, a more recent meta-
other cardiovascular risk factors.73 analysis of 14 studies in 2009 showed that homocysteine was
Data on other races and ethnic groups are more limited. A significantly elevated (pooled mean difference, +4.31 mol/L)
study of Native Americans suggested PAD prevalence com-
Downloaded from http://circres.ahajournals.org/ by guest on May 30, 2017
History of CVD
High HDL-cholesterol
High Cholesterol
Smoking (past)
Figure 3. Odds ratios for peripheral artery disease
Smoking (current) in high-income countries (HIC) and low- to middle-
income countries (LMIC).2 BMI body mass index;
Diabetes
CVD, cardiovascular disease, CRP, C-reactive protein;
Hypertension and HDL, high-density lipoprotein.
BMI (per 1 kg/m2)
Male sex
hypercholesterolemia, a genetic disorder, is related to a higher shingles, mumps, pneumonia, chronic bronchitis, or peptic
Downloaded from http://circres.ahajournals.org/ by guest on May 30, 2017
measured, but none has yet gained acceptance. Of note, the was related to smoking, the total cholesterol to HDL-C ratio,
General Framingham score is used to predict a composite lipoprotein(a), and high-sensitivity CRP, but only diabetes mel-
outcome of CHD, stroke, IC, or congestive heart failure.107 litus was associated with progression in smaller arteries.122
Analyses of prediction of the individual outcome components
showed that an IC specific model and prediction of IC with the Coprevalence of PAD and Other
general score showed high concordance. Atherosclerotic Disease
Given the common risk factors for PAD and other cardiovas-
Progression of PAD cular and cerebrovascular diseases, it is not surprising that
Little is known about the early natural history of PAD, particu- people with PAD are more likely to have these other disorders
larly the progression from asymptomatic to early symptomatic concomitantly and vice versa (Figure3, global data). Among
disease. The average annual change in ABI has been estimated 5084 Medicare beneficiaries in the CHS, the prevalence of
as 0.01 and 0.02 in various groups.108,109 However, these fig- history of myocardial infarction was 2.5 as high in subjects
ures may be somewhat misleading because an average change with PAD (based on ABI<0.9) versus those without; for angi-
in ABI masks a variety of changes of different directions and na, congestive heart failure, stroke, and transient ischemic at-
magnitudes. tack, the prevalence rates were 1.9, 3.3, 3.1, and 2.3 as high,
A more meaningful approach may be to look at the percent- respectively.28 Conversely, the prevalence of PAD was 2.1 as
age of the population achieving some categorically defined high in patients with a history of myocardial infarction versus
measure of change. The CHS, a population-based study, found those without; the corresponding ratios for angina, conges-
Downloaded from http://circres.ahajournals.org/ by guest on May 30, 2017
that during 6 years of follow-up, 9.5% of people showed in- tive heart failure, stroke, and transient ischemic attack were
cident PAD, defined as an ABI drop of >0.15 to a level of 1.7, 2.6, 2.4, and 2.1, respectively.28 Other studies have found
0.90.110 Nicoloff et al111 found that in 5 years, 37% of pa- similar cross-sectional correlations.71,123,124 One study found
tients experienced a significant (0.15) worsening of ABI, correlations between the ABI and coronary artery disease se-
whereas 22% of patients experienced clinical progression of verity estimated by the SYNTAX score.125 Subjects with PAD
PAD based on a change in symptoms or a need for surgical have also been shown to have an elevated prevalence of carot-
intervention. Among 415 English smokers with PAD referred id artery stenosis,126,127 and a similarly modest but significant
for a surgical opinion, about one half experienced a signifi- correlation between the severities of the 2 diseases has been
cant (0.14) drop in ABI over the following 48 months.58 In demonstrated.128 The global REduction of Atherothrombosis
a group of German patients with PAD, PAD was reported to for Continued Health registry has highlighted the high preva-
progress in 18.6% of patients during an average follow-up of lence of patients with PAD who also have concomitant coro-
64 months, based on a variety of criteria, including change nary or cerebrovascular disease (Figure4).129
in ABI.112 Bird et al108 defined a ranked series of 6 categories
of PAD based on ABI and other tests; in a study of patients PAD as a Predictor of Mortality and Morbidity
referred to a vascular laboratory, 30.2% of limbs progressed PAD is prospectively related to morbidity or mortality from
to a more serious category of PAD over an average follow-up other types of atherosclerotic disease, even after adjustment
time of 4.6 years. for known common risk factors. Although PAD seems unlike-
In a study based on angiography, 9.1% of patients were ly to directly cause these other diseases, the presence of PAD
found to have evidence of progression of PAD annually.113 In may serve as a marker for underlying atherosclerotic pro-
a study using development of rest pain or gangrene as the cri- cesses or susceptibilities affecting other vascular beds. These
teria for PAD progression, PAD progressed in 2.5% of patients prospective relationships are clinically important, to the extent
annually.105 One study reported that PAD progressed at a rate that the PAD has prognostic value independent of other known
of 3 greater in the first year after diagnosis than in subse- risk factors.
quent years.114 Longer studies of PAD progression tend to be Table5 provides a summary of studies of the association
conservatively biased because people with faster progression of PAD with various mortality and morbidity outcomes.130144
are likely to have earlier mortality.115 Table5 is limited to studies using a noninvasive measure of
Data on risk factors associated with progression of PAD are PAD (usually ABI at various cut points). The clinical use of
relatively sparse. In the CHS, significant independent predictors ABI testing is addressed.14 In addition, included studies re-
of decline were age, cigarette smoking, diabetes mellitus, and quired logistic or proportional hazards regression models,
dyslipidemia.110 One report showed age, diabetes mellitus, clas- with multivariable adjustment for conventional cardiovascular
sic IC, previous intervention, and PAD in the contralateral leg to risk factors. Results are shown with multivariable adjustment
be independently predictive of PAD progression.108 One study and after exclusion of subjects with baseline CVD where such
of English smokers with PAD identified hypertriglyceridemia exclusion was attempted.
as the most important independent risk factor for progression Attempts to elucidate this association epidemiologi-
of PAD and onset of critical ischemia.58 Hemorheologic factors cally began with studies of patients having symptomatic
have been shown to be associated with an increased risk of need PAD in the form of IC. Elevated mortality rates among sub-
for vascular intervention.116 Patients with premature PAD (on- jects with IC were reported in the 1970s and 1980s in the
set of symptoms at or before age 45) seem to have more rapid Framingham cohort, although this excess risk was marked-
progression of disease and generally poorer outcomes.117121 ly attenuated when subjects with baseline cerebrovascular
One study suggested that PAD progression in large arteries and CHD were excluded.23,145,146 Similarly, a Finnish study
1520Circulation ResearchApril 24, 2015
Criqui, 1992130 Large-vessel PAD 6.3 2.6 15.0 Adjusted for conventional risk factors; excludes subjects with baseline angina, MI, stroke
(multiple criteria)
Vogt, 1993132 ABI<0.9 4.5 1.5 6.7 Adjusted for conventional risk factors; excludes subjects with baseline CVD
Kornitzer, 1995134 ABI<0.9 3.3 1.0 10.6 Adjusted for conventional risk factors other than blood pressure; excludes baseline CHD
Jager, 1999135 ABI<0.9 2.4 0.9 6.1 Adjusted for conventional risk factors
Newman, 1999136 ABI<0.9 2.1 1.2 3.4 Adjusted for conventional risk factors; excludes subjects with baseline CVD
Hooi, 2002137 ABI<0.7 (vs. >0.95) 2.3 1.7 3.1 Adjusted for conventional risk factors
Lee, 2004139 ABI0.9 1.3 0.9 1.8 Adjusted for conventional risk factors
Resnick, 2004140 ABI0.9 2.5 1.7 3.6 Adjusted for conventional risk factors
Coronary heart disease mortality
Criqui, 1992130 Large-vessel PAD 4.3 1.4 12.8 Adjusted for conventional risk factors; excludes subjects with baseline angina, MI, stroke
(multiple criteria)
Kornitzer, 1995134 ABI<0.9 3.6 1.1 11.8 Adjusted for conventional risk factors other than blood pressure; excludes baseline CHD
Cardiovascular morbidity
Newman, 1993131 ABI<0.9 2.1 1.1 4.1 Adjusted for conventional risk factors
Hooi, 2002137 ABI<0.7 (vs. >0.95) 1.7 1.3 2.4 Adjusted for conventional risk factors
Myocardial infarction
Newman, 1999136 ABI<0.9 1.4 0.9 2.2 Adjusted for conventional risk factors; excludes subjects with baseline CVD
Stroke
Newman, 1999136 ABI<0.9 1.1 0.7 1.7 Adjusted for conventional risk factors; excludes subjects with baseline CVD
All coronary heart disease morbidity and mortality
Ogren, 1993133 ABI0.9 2.3 1.2 4.3 Adjusted for conventional risk factors
Newman, 1999136 ABI<0.9 1.4 0.9 2.2 Adjusted for conventional risk factors; excludes subjects with baseline CVD
Abbott, 2000141 ABI<0.8 (vs. >1.0) 2.7 1.6 4.5 Adjusted for conventional risk factors
Lee, 2004139 ABI0.90 1.1 0.8 1.5 Adjusted for conventional risk factors
Criqui, 2010142 ABI<1.0 1.8 1.3 2.7 Adjusted for conventional risk factors; excludes subjects with baseline CVD
ABI>1.4 2.2 1.1 4.2
All stroke morbidity and mortality
Newman, 1999136 ABI<0.9 1.1 0.7 1.7 Adjusted for conventional risk factors; excludes subjects with baseline CVD
Abbott, 2000141 ABI<0.9 2.0 1.1 3.5 Adjusted for conventional risk factors
Tsai, 2001143 ABI<0.9 1.4 0.7 2.6 Adjusted for conventional risk factors
Hollander, 2003 144
ABI<1.01 (vs. >1.17) 1.3 0.9 1.9 Adjusted for conventional risk factors
Murabito, 2003138 ABI<0.9 2.0 1.1 3.7 Adjusted for conventional risk factors
Lee, 2004139 ABI0.90 1.1 0.7 1.7 Adjusted for conventional risk factors
Criqui, 2010142 ABI<1.0 1.6 0.9 3.0 Adjusted for conventional risk factors; excludes subjects with baseline CVD
ABI>1.4 2.7 0.9 7.6
ABI indicates ankle-brachial index; CHD, coronary heart disease; CI, confidence interval; CVD, cardiovascular disease; MI, myocardial infarction; and PAD, peripheral
artery disease.
Criqui and Aboyans Epidemiology of Peripheral Artery Disease 1521
failed to find an association between IC and total or CVD and cerebrovascular disease morbidity and mortality, with risk
mortality in men after adjustment for CVD risk factors and ratios of 3.3 for men and 9.0 for women after multivariable
baseline CVD.147 Other studies demonstrated increased adjustment.154 Data from the Edinburgh Artery Study also
mortality risk among claudicants but did not fully adjust showed such an association based on ABI, although after mul-
for the conventional CVD risk factors.35,113,148 However, in tivariable adjustment, the association persisted for nonfatal
a large and methodologically rigorous study, data from the but not fatal stroke.153 However, data from the CHS failed to
18403 men in the Whitehall cohort were used to show that show a relationship between low ABI and incident stroke.136
after adjusting for CVD risk factors, IC was a significant Another large study, the ARIC Study, showed a significant as-
predictor of CVD mortality, even after excluding subjects sociation between ABI as a continuous variable and ischemic
with baseline disease.149 stroke after multivariable adjustment but failed to show such
The development of the ABI and other noninvasive mea- an association when ABI was categorized based on a cut point
sures of PAD permitted further investigation of the associa- of 0.80.143 The MESA reported associations with incident
tion of PAD and CVD. In 1985, it was first demonstrated that stroke for both low ABI (HR, 1.56) and high ABI (HR, 2.69),
a combination of noninvasive measures, including ABI, was but both were of borderline significance because of modest
prospectively related to all-cause mortality, even after adjust- numbers.142 Sutton-Tyrrell et al155 also reported elevated stroke
ment for CVD risk factors and exclusion of subjects with risk in people with both low and high ABIs.
baseline CVD.150 Relative risks in this study were in the range A meta-analysis of 16 population-based cohort studies
of 4 to 5; a later reanalysis of the same cohort with additional evaluated the association of ABI with subsequent coronary
mortality follow-up demonstrated elevated relative risks for events, CVD mortality, and total mortality.156 An ABI of
Downloaded from http://circres.ahajournals.org/ by guest on May 30, 2017
CVD and CHD in particular, with no significant increase in 0.90 was associated with approximately twice the 10-year
noncardiovascular death.130 event rates in each of these 3 categories. In addition, these
In the 1990s, many other prospective studies confirmed that results held across the full range of Framingham Risk Score
ABI was related to CVD, based on either mortality or com- categories. The ABI was also evaluated as a continuous vari-
bined mortality and morbidity. This was found to be true in able. As shown in Figure5, there was a graded association of
a variety of populations: vascular laboratory patients,115,151,152 increasing risk with decreasing ABIs <1.00, with an HR of 4
elderly patients with hypertension,131 elderly women,132 an for ABIs of 0.60. Risk was essentially flat for ABIs in the
employment-based cohort from Belgium,134 the Edinburgh normal range, 1.00 to 1.40.
Artery Study cohort,153 and the CHS cohort.136 Most of these Population studies suggest that a high ABI, >1.40, is also
studies controlled for various known CVD risk factors and associated with elevated risk of CVD. In the meta-analysis
the presence of CVD at baseline. The relative risks reported of 16 population studies, ABIs of >1.40 were associated
ranged from 2 to 5. Many of these studies also found PAD with a modest but significant increase in total mortality,
to be significantly associated with incident CHD in particular, with an HR of 1.3.156 Such high ABIs are caused by stiff,
although the CHS failed to find such associations for either often calcified ankle arteries, which may mask underlying
total myocardial infarction or angina.136 PAD.12 Recently, the MESA reported that both low (<1.00)
The data on the association of PAD with cerebrovascular and high (>1.40) ABIs were associated with an increased
disease are less conclusive. A 1991 study showed a strong risk of incident CVD events, even after adjustment for tradi-
association between multiple noninvasive measures of PAD tional and novel risk factors.142 Also, this was the first report
Figure 5. Hazard ratios for total mortality in men and women by ankle-brachial index (ABI) at baseline for all studies combined in
the ABI collaboration.155
1522Circulation ResearchApril 24, 2015
19. Beks PJ, Mackaay AJ, de Neeling JN, de Vries H, Bouter LM, Heine lipoprotein(a), and standard cholesterol screening as predictors of periph-
RJ. Peripheral arterial disease in relation to glycaemic level in an elderly eral arterial disease. JAMA. 2001;285:24812485.
Caucasian population: the Hoorn study. Diabetologia. 1995;38:8696. 40. Criqui MH, Vargas V, Denenberg JO, Ho E, Allison M, Langer RD, Gamst
20. Stoffers HE, Rinkens PE, Kester AD, Kaiser V, Knottnerus JA. The preva- A, Bundens WP, Fronek A. Ethnicity and peripheral arterial disease: the
lence of asymptomatic and unrecognized peripheral arterial occlusive dis- San Diego Population Study. Circulation. 2005;112:27032707. doi:
ease. Int J Epidemiol. 1996;25:282290. 10.1161/CIRCULATIONAHA.105.546507.
21. Ingolfsson IO, Sigurdsson G, Sigvaldason H, Thorgeirsson G, Sigfusson 41. Pande RL, Perlstein TS, Beckman JA, Creager MA. Secondary prevention
N. A marked decline in the prevalence and incidence of intermit- and mortality in peripheral artery disease: National Health and Nutrition
tent claudication in Icelandic men 19681986: a strong relationship to Examination Study, 1999 to 2004. Circulation. 2011;124:1723.
smoking and serum cholesterolthe Reykjavik Study. J Clin Epidemiol. 42. Joosten MM, Pai JK, Bertoia ML, Rimm EB, Spiegelman D, Mittleman
1994;47:12371243. MA, Mukamal KJ. Associations between conventional cardiovascu-
22. Bowlin SJ, Medalie JH, Flocke SA, Zyzanski SJ, Goldbourt U.
lar risk factors and risk of peripheral artery disease in men. JAMA.
Epidemiology of intermittent claudication in middle-aged men. Am J 2012;308:16601667. doi: 10.1001/jama.2012.13415.
Epidemiol. 1994;140:418430. 43. Faulkner KW, House AK, Castleden WM. The effect of cessation of smok-
23. Kannel WB, McGee DL. Update on some epidemiologic features of ing on the accumulative survival rates of patients with symptomatic pe-
intermittent claudication: the Framingham Study. J Am Geriatr Soc. ripheral vascular disease. Med J Aust. 1983;1:217219.
1985;33:1318. 44. Jonason T, Bergstrm R. Cessation of smoking in patients with inter-
24. Leng GC, Lee AJ, Fowkes FG, Whiteman M, Dunbar J, Housley E, mittent claudication. Effects on the risk of peripheral vascular com-
Ruckley CV. Incidence, natural history and cardiovascular events in symp- plications, myocardial infarction and mortality. Acta Med Scand.
tomatic and asymptomatic peripheral arterial disease in the general popu- 1987;221:253260.
lation. Int J Epidemiol. 1996;25:11721181. 45. He Y, Lam TH, Jiang B, Wang J, Sai X, Fan L, Li X, Qin Y, Hu FB. Passive
25. Hooi JD, Kester AD, Stoffers HE, Overdijk MM, van Ree JW,
smoking and risk of peripheral arterial disease and ischemic stroke in
Knottnerus JA. Incidence of and risk factors for asymptomatic periph- Chinese women who never smoked. Circulation. 2008;118:15351540.
Downloaded from http://circres.ahajournals.org/ by guest on May 30, 2017
60. Ness J, Aronow WS, Ahn C. Risk factors for symptomatic peripheral arte- 80. Taylor LM Jr, Moneta GL, Sexton GJ, Schuff RA, Porter JM. Prospective
rial disease in older persons in an academic hospital-based geriatrics prac- blinded study of the relationship between plasma homocysteine and
tice. J Am Geriatr Soc. 2000;48:312314. progression of symptomatic peripheral arterial disease. J Vasc Surg.
61. Fowkes FG. Epidemiology of atherosclerotic arterial disease in the lower 1999;29:819; discussion 19.
limbs. Eur J Vasc Surg. 1988;2:283291. 81. Khandanpour N, Loke YK, Meyer FJ, Jennings B, Armon MP.
62. Cheng SW, Ting AC, Wong J. Fasting total plasma homocysteine and ath- Homocysteine and peripheral arterial disease: systematic review and me-
erosclerotic peripheral vascular disease. Ann Vasc Surg. 1997;11:217223. ta-analysis. Eur J Vasc Endovasc Surg. 2009;38:316322. doi: 10.1016/j.
doi: 10.1007/s100169900037. ejvs.2009.05.007.
63. Mowat BF, Skinner ER, Wilson HM, Leng GC, Fowkes FG, Horrobin D. 82. Liew YP, Bartholomew JR, Demirjian S, Michaels J, Schreiber MJ Jr.
Alterations in plasma lipids, lipoproteins and high density lipoprotein sub- Combined effect of chronic kidney disease and peripheral arterial disease
fractions in peripheral arterial disease. Atherosclerosis. 1997;131:161166. on all-cause mortality in a high-risk population. Clin J Am Soc Nephrol.
64. Ix JH, Biggs ML, Kizer JR, Mukamal KJ, Djousse L, Zieman SJ, de Boer IH, 2008;3:10841089. doi: 10.2215/CJN.04411007.
Nelson TL, Newman AB, Criqui MH, Siscovick DS. Association of body mass 83. OHare AM, Glidden DV, Fox CS, Hsu CY. High prevalence of periph-
index with peripheral arterial disease in older adults: the Cardiovascular Health eral arterial disease in persons with renal insufficiency: results from
Study. Am J Epidemiol. 2011;174:10361043. doi: 10.1093/aje/kwr228. the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey 19992000.
65. Vliegenthart R, Geleijnse JM, Hofman A, Meijer WT, van Rooij FJ, Circulation. 2004;109:320323. doi: 10.1161/01.CIR.0000114519.
Grobbee DE, Witteman JC. Alcohol consumption and risk of peripheral 75433.DD.
arterial disease: the Rotterdam study. Am J Epidemiol. 2002;155:332338. 84. OHare AM, Vittinghoff E, Hsia J, Shlipak MG. Renal insufficiency
66. Jepson RG, Fowkes FG, Donnan PT, Housley E. Alcohol intake as a and the risk of lower extremity peripheral arterial disease: results from
risk factor for peripheral arterial disease in the general population in the the Heart and Estrogen/Progestin Replacement Study (HERS). J Am Soc
Edinburgh Artery Study. Eur J Epidemiol. 1995;11:914. Nephrol. 2004;15:10461051.
67. Fabsitz RR, Sidawy AN, Go O, Lee ET, Welty TK, Devereux RB,
85. Rajagopalan S, Dellegrottaglie S, Furniss AL, Gillespie BW, Satayathum
Howard BV. Prevalence of peripheral arterial disease and associated risk S, Lameire N, Saito A, Akiba T, Jadoul M, Ginsberg N, Keen M, Port
Downloaded from http://circres.ahajournals.org/ by guest on May 30, 2017
factors in American Indians: the Strong Heart Study. Am J Epidemiol. FK, Mukherjee D, Saran R. Peripheral arterial disease in patients with
1999;149:330338. end-stage renal disease: observations from the Dialysis Outcomes and
68. Xie X, Ma YT, Yang YN, Li XM, Liu F, Huang D, Fu ZY, Ma X, Chen BD, Practice Patterns Study (DOPPS). Circulation. 2006;114:19141922. doi:
Huang Y. Alcohol consumption and ankle-to-brachial index: results from 10.1161/CIRCULATIONAHA.105.607390.
the Cardiovascular Risk Survey. PLoS One. 2010;5:e15181. doi: 10.1371/ 86. OHare A, Johansen K. Lower-extremity peripheral arterial dis-
journal.pone.0015181. ease among patients with end-stage renal disease. J Am Soc Nephrol.
69. Camargo CA Jr, Stampfer MJ, Glynn RJ, Gaziano JM, Manson JE,
2001;12:28382847.
Goldhaber SZ, Hennekens CH. Prospective study of moderate alcohol 87. Joosten MM, Pai JK, Bertoia ML, Gansevoort RT, Bakker SJ, Cooke JP,
consumption and risk of peripheral arterial disease in US male physicians. Rimm EB, Mukamal KJ. 2-microglobulin, cystatin C, and creatinine
Circulation. 1997;95:577580. and risk of symptomatic peripheral artery disease. J Am Heart Assoc.
70. Guerchet M, Aboyans V, Mbelesso P, Mouanga AM, Salazar J, Bandzouzi 2014;3:e000803. doi: 10.1161/JAHA.114.000803.
B, Tabo A, Clment JP, Preux PM, Lacroix P. Epidemiology of peripheral 88. Pasqualini L, Schillaci G, Pirro M, Vaudo G, Siepi D, Innocente S, Ciuffetti
artery disease in elder general population of two cities of Central Africa: G, Mannarino E. Renal dysfunction predicts long-term mortality in pa-
Bangui and Brazzaville. Eur J Vasc Endovasc Surg. 2012;44:164169. tients with lower extremity arterial disease. J Intern Med. 2007;262:668
doi: 10.1016/j.ejvs.2012.05.019. 677. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2796.2007.01863.x.
71. Zheng ZJ, Sharrett AR, Chambless LE, Rosamond WD, Nieto FJ, Sheps 89. OHare AM, Sidawy AN, Feinglass J, Merine KM, Daley J, Khuri S,
DS, Dobs A, Evans GW, Heiss G. Associations of ankle-brachial in- Henderson WG, Johansen KL. Influence of renal insufficiency on limb
dex with clinical coronary heart disease, stroke and preclinical carotid loss and mortality after initial lower extremity surgical revascularization.
and popliteal atherosclerosis: the Atherosclerosis Risk in Communities J Vasc Surg. 2004;39:709716. doi: 10.1016/j.jvs.2003.11.038.
(ARIC) Study. Atherosclerosis. 1997;131:115125. 90. OHare AM, Bertenthal D, Shlipak MG, Sen S, Chren MM. Impact of
72. Ix JH, Allison MA, Denenberg JO, Cushman M, Criqui MH. Novel car- renal insufficiency on mortality in advanced lower extremity periph-
diovascular risk factors do not completely explain the higher prevalence eral arterial disease. J Am Soc Nephrol. 2005;16:514519. doi: 10.1681/
of peripheral arterial disease among African Americans. The San Diego ASN.2004050409.
Population Study. J Am Coll Cardiol. 2008;51:23472354. doi: 10.1016/j. 91. Lacroix P, Aboyans V, Desormais I, Kowalsky T, Cambou JP, Constans J,
jacc.2008.03.022. Bura Rivire A; COPART Investigators. Chronic kidney disease and the
73. Hobbs SD, Wilmink AB, Bradbury AW. Ethnicity and peripheral arte- short-term risk of mortality and amputation in patients hospitalized for
rial disease. Eur J Vasc Endovasc Surg. 2003;25:505512. doi: 10.1053/ peripheral artery disease. J Vasc Surg. 2013;58:966971. doi: 10.1016/j.
ejvs.2002.1884. jvs.2013.04.007.
74. Kojima I, Ninomiya T, Hata J, Fukuhara M, Hirakawa Y, Mukai N,
92. Wassel CL, Loomba R, Ix JH, Allison MA, Denenberg JO, Criqui MH.
Yoshida D, Kitazono T, Kiyohara Y. A low ankle brachial index is associ- Family history of peripheral artery disease is associated with preva-
ated with an increased risk of cardiovascular disease: the Hisayama study. lence and severity of peripheral artery disease: the San Diego popula-
J Atheroscler Thromb. 2014;21:966973. tion study. J Am Coll Cardiol. 2011;58:13861392. doi: 10.1016/j.
75. Boushey CJ, Beresford SA, Omenn GS, Motulsky AG. A quantita-
jacc.2011.06.023.
tive assessment of plasma homocysteine as a risk factor for vascu- 93. Prushik SG, Farber A, Gona P, Shrader P, Pencina MJ, DAgostino RB
lar disease. Probable benefits of increasing folic acid intakes. JAMA. Sr, Murabito JM. Parental intermittent claudication as risk factor for
1995;274:10491057. claudication in adults. Am J Cardiol. 2012;109:736741. doi: 10.1016/j.
76. Bloemenkamp DG, van den Bosch MA, Mali WP, Tanis BC, Rosendaal amjcard.2011.10.032.
FR, Kemmeren JM, Algra A, Visseren FL, van der Graaf Y. Novel risk 94. Carmelli D, Fabsitz RR, Swan GE, Reed T, Miller B, Wolf PA.
factors for peripheral arterial disease in young women. Am J Med. Contribution of genetic and environmental influences to ankle-brachial
2002;113:462467. blood pressure index in the NHLBI Twin Study. National Heart, Lung, and
77. Graham IM, Daly LE, Refsum HM, et al. Plasma homocysteine as a Blood Institute. Am J Epidemiol. 2000;151:452458.
risk factor for vascular disease. The European Concerted Action Project. 95. Kroon AA, Ajubi N, van Asten WN, Stalenhoef AF. The prevalence of pe-
JAMA. 1997;277:17751781. ripheral vascular disease in familial hypercholesterolaemia. J Intern Med.
78. Hoogeveen EK, Kostense PJ, Beks PJ, Mackaay AJ, Jakobs C, Bouter 1995;238:451459.
LM, Heine RJ, Stehouwer CD. Hyperhomocysteinemia is associated with 96. Murabito JM, White CC, Kavousi M, et al. Association between chromo-
an increased risk of cardiovascular disease, especially in non-insulin-de- some 9p21 variants and the ankle-brachial index identified by a meta-
pendent diabetes mellitus: a population-based study. Arterioscler Thromb analysis of 21 genome-wide association studies. Circ Cardiovasc Genet.
Vasc Biol. 1998;18:133138. 2012;5:100112. doi: 10.1161/CIRCGENETICS.111.961292.
79. Bertoia ML, Pai JK, Cooke JP, Joosten MM, Mittleman MA, Rimm EB, 97. Kullo IJ, Shameer K, Jouni H, Lesnick TG, Pathak J, Chute CG, de
Mukamal KJ. Plasma homocysteine, dietary B vitamins, betaine, and cho- Andrade M. The ATXN2-SH2B3 locus is associated with peripheral arte-
line and risk of peripheral artery disease. Atherosclerosis. 2014;235:94 rial disease: an electronic medical record-based genome-wide association
101. doi: 10.1016/j.atherosclerosis.2014.04.010. study. Front Genet. 2014;5:166. doi: 10.3389/fgene.2014.00166.
Criqui and Aboyans Epidemiology of Peripheral Artery Disease 1525
98. Wassel CL, Lamina C, Nambi V, et al. Genetic determinants of the an- 118. Pairolero PC, Joyce JW, Skinner CR, Hollier LH, Cherry KJ Jr. Lower
kle-brachial index: a meta-analysis of a cardiovascular candidate gene limb ischemia in young adults: prognostic implications. J Vasc Surg.
50K SNP panel in the candidate gene association resource (CARe) 1984;1:459464.
consortium. Atherosclerosis. 2012;222:138147. doi: 10.1016/j. 119. Hallett JW Jr, Greenwood LH, Robison JG. Lower extremity arterial dis-
atherosclerosis.2012.01.039. ease in young adults. A systematic approach to early diagnosis. Ann Surg.
99. Hung HC, Willett W, Merchant A, Rosner BA, Ascherio A, Joshipura 1985;202:647652.
KJ. Oral health and peripheral arterial disease. Circulation. 2003;107: 120. Valentine RJ, MacGillivray DC, DeNobile JW, Snyder DA, Rich NM.
11521157. Intermittent claudication caused by atherosclerosis in patients aged forty
100. Whiteman MC, Deary IJ, Fowkes FG. Personality and social predictors years and younger. Surgery. 1990;107:560565.
of atherosclerotic progression: Edinburgh Artery Study. Psychosom Med. 121. Levy PJ, Hornung CA, Haynes JL, Rush DS. Lower extremity ischemia
2000;62:703714. in adults younger than forty years of age: a community-wide survey of
101. McDermott MM, Greenland P, Guralnik JM, Liu K, Criqui MH, Pearce WH, premature atherosclerotic arterial disease. J Vasc Surg. 1994;19:873881.
Chan C, Schneider J, Sharma L, Taylor LM, Arseven A, Quann M, Celic L. 122. Aboyans V, Criqui MH, Denenberg JO, Knoke JD, Ridker PM, Fronek
Depressive symptoms and lower extremity functioning in men and women A. Risk factors for progression of peripheral arterial disease in large
with peripheral arterial disease. J Gen Intern Med. 2003;18:461467. and small vessels. Circulation. 2006;113:26232629. doi: 10.1161/
102. Taylor LM Jr, Chitwood RW, Dalman RL, Sexton G, Goodnight SH, CIRCULATIONAHA.105.608679.
Porter JM. Antiphospholipid antibodies in vascular surgery patients. 123. Criqui MH, Denenberg JO, Langer RD, Fronek A. The epidemiology of
A cross-sectional study. Ann Surg. 1994;220:54450; discussion 550. peripheral arterial disease: importance of identifying the population at
103. Lam EY, Taylor LM Jr, Landry GJ, Porter JM, Moneta GL. Relationship risk. Vasc Med. 1997;2:221226.
between antiphospholipid antibodies and progression of lower extrem- 124. Ness J, Aronow WS. Prevalence of coexistence of coronary artery dis-
ity arterial occlusive disease after lower extremity bypass operations. ease, ischemic stroke, and peripheral arterial disease in older persons,
J Vasc Surg. 2001;33:976982. doi: 10.1067/mva.2001.115163. mean age 80 years, in an academic hospital-based geriatrics practice.
104. Mya MM, Aronow WS. Increased prevalence of peripheral arte-
J Am Geriatr Soc. 1999;47:12551256.
Downloaded from http://circres.ahajournals.org/ by guest on May 30, 2017
rial disease in older men and women with subclinical hypothyroidism. 125. Kim EK, Song PS, Yang JH, Song YB, Hahn JY, Choi JH, Gwon HC, Lee
J Gerontol A Biol Sci Med Sci. 2003;58:6869. SH, Hong KP, Park JE, Kim DK, Choi SH. Peripheral artery disease in
105. Asgeirsdttir LP, Agnarsson U, Jnsson GS. Lower extremity blood flow korean patients undergoing percutaneous coronary intervention: preva-
in healthy men: effect of smoking, cholesterol, and physical activitya lence and association with coronary artery disease severity. J Korean
Doppler study. Angiology. 2001;52:437445. Med Sci. 2013;28:8792. doi: 10.3346/jkms.2013.28.1.87.
106. Navas-Acien A, Selvin E, Sharrett AR, Calderon-Aranda E, Silbergeld 126. Alexandrova NA, Gibson WC, Norris JW, Maggisano R. Carotid artery
E, Guallar E. Lead, cadmium, smoking, and increased risk of periph- stenosis in peripheral vascular disease. J Vasc Surg. 1996;23:645649.
eral arterial disease. Circulation. 2004;109:31963201. doi: 10.1161/01. 127. Pilcher JM, Danaher J, Khaw KT. The prevalence of asymptomatic carot-
CIR.0000130848.18636.B2. id artery disease in patients with peripheral vascular disease. Clin Radiol.
107. DAgostino RB Sr, Vasan RS, Pencina MJ, Wolf PA, Cobain M, Massaro 2000;55:5661. doi: 10.1053/crad.1999.0345.
JM, Kannel WB. General cardiovascular risk profile for use in primary 128. Long TH, Criqui MH, Vasilevskis EE, Denenberg JO, Klauber MR,
care: the Framingham Heart Study. Circulation. 2008;117:743753. doi: Fronek A. The correlation between the severity of peripheral arterial dis-
10.1161/CIRCULATIONAHA.107.699579. ease and carotid occlusive disease. Vasc Med. 1999;4:135142.
108. Bird CE, Criqui MH, Fronek A, Denenberg JO, Klauber MR, Langer RD. 129. Bhatt DL, Steg PG, Ohman EM, Hirsch AT, Ikeda Y, Mas JL, Goto S, Liau
Quantitative and qualitative progression of peripheral arterial disease by CS, Richard AJ, Rther J, Wilson PW; REACH Registry Investigators.
non-invasive testing. Vasc Med. 1999;4:1521. International prevalence, recognition, and treatment of cardiovascular
109. Fowkes FG, Lowe GD, Housley E, Rattray A, Rumley A, Elton RA, risk factors in outpatients with atherothrombosis. JAMA. 2006;295:180
MacGregor IR, Dawes J. Cross-linked fibrin degradation products, pro- 189. doi: 10.1001/jama.295.2.180.
gression of peripheral arterial disease, and risk of coronary heart disease. 130. Criqui MH, Langer RD, Fronek A, Feigelson HS, Klauber MR, McCann
Lancet. 1993;342:8486. TJ, Browner D. Mortality over a period of 10 years in patients with pe-
110. Kennedy M, Solomon C, Manolio TA, Criqui MH, Newman AB, Polak ripheral arterial disease. N Engl J Med. 1992;326:381386. doi: 10.1056/
JF, Burke GL, Enright P, Cushman M. Risk factors for declining ankle- NEJM199202063260605.
brachial index in men and women 65 years or older: the Cardiovascular 131. Newman AB, Sutton-Tyrrell K, Vogt MT, Kuller LH. Morbidity and mor-
Health Study. Arch Intern Med. 2005;165:18961902. doi: 10.1001/ tality in hypertensive adults with a low ankle/arm blood pressure index.
archinte.165.16.1896. JAMA. 1993;270:487489.
111. Nicoloff AD, Taylor LM Jr, Sexton GJ, Schuff RA, Edwards JM, Yeager 132. Vogt MT, Cauley JA, Newman AB, Kuller LH, Hulley SB. Decreased
RA, Landry GJ, Moneta GL, Porter JM; Homocysteine and Progression ankle/arm blood pressure index and mortality in elderly women. JAMA.
of Atherosclerosis Study Investigators. Relationship between site of 1993;270:465469.
initial symptoms and subsequent progression of disease in a prospec- 133. Ogren M, Hedblad B, Isacsson SO, Janzon L, Jungquist G, Lindell SE.
tive study of atherosclerosis progression in patients receiving long-term Non-invasively detected carotid stenosis and ischaemic heart disease in
treatment for symptomatic peripheral arterial disease. J Vasc Surg. men with leg arteriosclerosis. Lancet. 1993;342:11381141.
2002;35:3846; discussion 46. 134. Kornitzer M, Dramaix M, Sobolski J, Degre S, De Backer G. Ankle/
112. Taute BM, Glser C, Taute R, Podhaisky H. Progression of athero- arm pressure index in asymptomatic middle-aged males: an indepen-
sclerosis in patients with peripheral arterial disease as a function of dent predictor of ten-year coronary heart disease mortality. Angiology.
angiotensin-converting enzyme gene insertion/deletion polymorphism. 1995;46:211219.
Angiology. 2002;53:375382. 135. Jager A, Kostense PJ, Ruh HG, Heine RJ, Nijpels G, Dekker JM, Bouter
113. Walsh DB, Gilbertson JJ, Zwolak RM, Besso S, Edelman GC, Schneider LM, Stehouwer CD. Microalbuminuria and peripheral arterial disease
JR, Cronenwett JL. The natural history of superficial femoral artery ste- are independent predictors of cardiovascular and all-cause mortality, es-
noses. J Vasc Surg. 1991;14:299304. pecially among hypertensive subjects: five-year follow-up of the Hoorn
114. Jelnes R, Gaardsting O, Hougaard Jensen K, Baekgaard N, Tnnesen Study. Arterioscler Thromb Vasc Biol. 1999;19:617624.
KH, Schroeder T. Fate in intermittent claudication: outcome and risk fac- 136. Newman AB, Shemanski L, Manolio TA, Cushman M, Mittelmark M,
tors. Br Med J (Clin Res Ed). 1986;293:11371140. Polak JF, Powe NR, Siscovick D. Ankle-arm index as a predictor of car-
115. Criqui MH, Ninomiya JK, Wingard DL, Ji M, Fronek A. Progression diovascular disease and mortality in the Cardiovascular Health Study.
of peripheral arterial disease predicts cardiovascular disease morbidity The Cardiovascular Health Study Group. Arterioscler Thromb Vasc Biol.
and mortality. J Am Coll Cardiol. 2008;52:17361742. doi: 10.1016/j. 1999;19:538545.
jacc.2008.07.060. 137. Hooi JD, Stoffers HE, Kester AD, van RJ, Knottnerus JA. Peripheral ar-
116. Smith FB, Lowe GD, Lee AJ, Rumley A, Leng GC, Fowkes FG.
terial occlusive disease: prognostic value of signs, symptoms, and the
Smoking, hemorheologic factors, and progression of peripheral arterial ankle-brachial pressure index. Med Decis Making. 2002;22:99107.
disease in patients with claudication. J Vasc Surg. 1998;28:129135. 138. Murabito JM, Evans JC, Larson MG, Nieto K, Levy D, Wilson PW;
117. McCready RA, Vincent AE, Schwartz RW, Hyde GL, Mattingly SS, Framingham Study. The ankle-brachial index in the elderly and risk of
Griffen WO Jr. Atherosclerosis in the young: a virulent disease. Surgery. stroke, coronary disease, and death: the Framingham Study. Arch Intern
1984;96:863869. Med. 2003;163:19391942. doi: 10.1001/archinte.163.16.1939.
1526Circulation ResearchApril 24, 2015
139. Lee AJ, Price JF, Russell MJ, Smith FB, van Wijk MC, Fowkes FG. Improved 150. Criqui MH, Coughlin SS, Fronek A. Noninvasively diagnosed peripheral
prediction of fatal myocardial infarction using the ankle brachial index in ad- arterial disease as a predictor of mortality: results from a prospective
dition to conventional risk factors: the Edinburgh Artery Study. Circulation. study. Circulation. 1985;72:768773.
2004;110:30753080. doi: 10.1161/01.CIR.0000143102.38256.DE. 151. McKenna M, Wolfson S, Kuller L. The ratio of ankle and arm arte-
140. Resnick HE, Lindsay RS, McDermott MM, Devereux RB, Jones KL, rial pressure as an independent predictor of mortality. Atherosclerosis.
Fabsitz RR, Howard BV. Relationship of high and low ankle bra- 1991;87:119128.
chial index to all-cause and cardiovascular disease mortality: the 152. McDermott MM, Feinglass J, Slavensky R, Pearce WH. The ankle-bra-
Strong Heart Study. Circulation. 2004;109:733739. doi: 10.1161/01. chial index as a predictor of survival in patients with peripheral vascular
CIR.0000112642.63927.54. disease. J Gen Intern Med. 1994;9:445449.
141. Abbott RD, Petrovitch H, Rodriguez BL, Yano K, Schatz IJ, Popper JS, 153. Leng GC, Fowkes FG, Lee AJ, Dunbar J, Housley E, Ruckley CV. Use of
Masaki KH, Ross GW, Curb JD. Ankle/brachial blood pressure in men ankle brachial pressure index to predict cardiovascular events and death:
>70 years of age and the risk of coronary heart disease. Am J Cardiol. a cohort study. BMJ. 1996;313:14401444.
2000;86:280284. 154. Criqui MH, Langer RD, Fronek A, Feigelson HS. Coronary disease and
142. Criqui MH, McClelland RL, McDermott MM, Allison MA, Blumenthal stroke in patients with large-vessel peripheral arterial disease. Drugs.
RS, Aboyans V, Ix JH, Burke GL, Liu K, Shea S. The ankle-brachial 1991;42(suppl 5):1621.
index and incident cardiovascular events in the MESA (Multi-Ethnic 155. Sutton-Tyrrell K, Venkitachalam L, Kanaya AM, Boudreau R,
Study of Atherosclerosis). J Am Coll Cardiol. 2010;56:15061512. doi: Harris T, Thompson T, Mackey RH, Visser M, Vaidean GD,
10.1016/j.jacc.2010.04.060. Newman AB. Relationship of ankle blood pressures to cardiovascu-
143. Tsai AW, Folsom AR, Rosamond WD, Jones DW. Ankle-brachial in- lar events in older adults. Stroke. 2008;39:863869. doi: 10.1161/
dex and 7-year ischemic stroke incidence: the ARIC study. Stroke. STROKEAHA.107.487439.
2001;32:17211724. 156. Ankle Brachial Index Collaboration. Ankle brachial index combined
144. Hollander M, Hak AE, Koudstaal PJ, Bots ML, Grobbee DE, Hofman A, with Framingham risk score to predict cardiovascular events and mortal-
Witteman JC, Breteler MM. Comparison between measures of athero- ity. A meta-analysis. JAMA. 2008;300:197208.
sclerosis and risk of stroke: the Rotterdam Study. Stroke. 2003;34:2367 157. Aboyans V, Lacroix P, Tran MH, Salamagne C, Galinat S, Archambeaud
Downloaded from http://circres.ahajournals.org/ by guest on May 30, 2017
2372. doi: 10.1161/01.STR.0000091393.32060.0E. F, Criqui MH, Laskar M. The prognosis of diabetic patients with high
145. Kannel WB, Skinner JJ Jr, Schwartz MJ, Shurtleff D. Intermittent claudica- ankle-brachial index depends on the coexistence of occlusive periph-
tion. Incidence in the Framingham Study. Circulation. 1970;41:875883. eral artery disease. J Vasc Surg. 2011;53:984991. doi: 10.1016/j.
146. Kannel WB, Shurtleff D. The natural history of arteriosclerosis obliter- jvs.2010.10.054.
ans. Cardiovasc Clin. 1971;3:3752. 158. Arain FA, Ye Z, Bailey KR, Chen Q, Liu G, Leibson CL, Kullo IJ.
147. Reunanen A, Takkunen H, Aromaa A. Prevalence of intermittent claudi- Survival in patients with poorly compressible leg artries. JACC.
cation and its effect on mortality. Acta Med Scand. 1982;211:249256. 2012;59:4007.
148. Kller KS. Mortality and morbidity in patients with intermittent clau- 159. Sampson UK, Fowkes FG, McDermott MM, Criqui MH, Aboyans
dication as defined by venous occlusion plethysmography. A ten-year V, Norman PE, Forouzanfar MH, Naghavi M, Song Y, Harrell FE Jr,
follow-up study. J Chronic Dis. 1981;34:455462. Denenberg JO, Mensah GA, Ezzati M, Murray C. Global and regional
149. Smith GD, Shipley MJ, Rose G. Intermittent claudication, heart dis- burden of death and disability from peripheral artery disease: 21 world
ease risk factors, and mortality. The Whitehall Study. Circulation. regions, 1990 to 2010. Glob Heart. 2014;9:145158.e21. doi: 10.1016/j.
1990;82:19251931. gheart.2013.12.008.
Epidemiology of Peripheral Artery Disease
Michael H. Criqui and Victor Aboyans
Downloaded from http://circres.ahajournals.org/ by guest on May 30, 2017
The online version of this article, along with updated information and services, is located on the
World Wide Web at:
http://circres.ahajournals.org/content/116/9/1509
An erratum has been published regarding this article. Please see the attached page for:
/content/117/1/e12.full.pdf
Permissions: Requests for permissions to reproduce figures, tables, or portions of articles originally published
in Circulation Research can be obtained via RightsLink, a service of the Copyright Clearance Center, not the
Editorial Office. Once the online version of the published article for which permission is being requested is
located, click Request Permissions in the middle column of the Web page under Services. Further information
about this process is available in the Permissions and Rights Question and Answer document.
In the Circulation Research article by Criqui and Aboyans (Epidemiology of Peripheral Artery Disease.
Circ Res. 2015:116:15091526. DOI: 10.1161/CIRCRESAHA.116.303849.), corrections were needed.
In Figure 3, the label for the final risk factor, Age (per 10 yrs), was omitted.
History of CVD
High HDL-cholesterol
High Cholesterol
Smoking (past)
Smoking (current)
Diabetes
Hypertension
Male sex
In addition, the sentence describing the figure erroneously stated, Figure 3 presents the meta-anal-
yses of the effect size of 10 risk factors investigated in at least 3 studies among those summarized in
Table 3, using multivariate design, as well as the association with other CVD. It should read, Figure
3 presents the meta-analyses of the effect size of 11 risk factors investigated in at least 3 studies among
those summarized in Table 3, using multivariate design, as well as the association with other CVD.
The authors apologize for these errors, and the errors have been noted and corrected in the online
version of the article, which is available at http://circres.ahajournals.org/content/116/9/1509.full.
e12