Professional Documents
Culture Documents
UNITED STATES
Appellee
v.
Emmanuel Q. BARTEE, Lance Corporal
United States Marine Corps, Appellant
No. 16-0391
Crim. App. No. 201500037
Argued November 15, 2016 Decided March 15, 2017
Military Judge: M. D. Zimmerman
For Appellant: Major Benjamin A. Robles, USMC (argued).
For Appellee: Major Cory A. Carver, USMC (argued); Ma-
jor Suzanne M. Dempsey, USMC, Captain Matthew Harris,
USMC, and Brian K. Keller, Esq. (on brief); Colonel Mark
K. Jamison, USMC.
Judge SPARKS delivered the opinion of the Court, in
which Judges STUCKY and OHLSON joined. Judge
RYAN filed a separate opinion concurring in the result.
Chief Judge ERDMANN filed a separate dissenting
opinion.
_______________
2
United States v. Bartee, No. 16-0391/MC
Opinion of the Court
3
United States v. Bartee, No. 16-0391/MC
Opinion of the Court
4
United States v. Bartee, No. 16-0391/MC
Opinion of the Court
5
United States v. Bartee, No. 16-0391/MC
Opinion of the Court
6
United States v. Bartee, No. 16-0391/MC
2
United States v. Bartee, No. 16-0391/MC
2
United States v. Bartee, No. 16-0391/MC
Chief Judge ERDMANN, Dissenting
3
United States v. Bartee, No. 16-0391/MC
Chief Judge ERDMANN, Dissenting
4
United States v. Bartee, No. 16-0391/MC
Chief Judge ERDMANN, Dissenting
5
United States v. Bartee, No. 16-0391/MC
Chief Judge ERDMANN, Dissenting
6
United States v. Bartee, No. 16-0391/MC
Chief Judge ERDMANN, Dissenting
7
United States v. Bartee, No. 16-0391/MC
Chief Judge ERDMANN, Dissenting
8
United States v. Bartee, No. 16-0391/MC
Chief Judge ERDMANN, Dissenting
9
United States v. Bartee, No. 16-0391/MC
Chief Judge ERDMANN, Dissenting
10