You are on page 1of 37

bs_bs_banner

The Society for Visual Anthropologys


Visual Research Conference: The First
Twenty-Four Years (19852008)
JOANNA COHAN SCHERER

The Society for Visual Anthropologys Visual Research Conference (VRC) has been an active presence at the American
Anthropological Association (AAA) annual meetings since the mid-1980s. Although critical studies and selected
histories of visual anthropology have been written, no history has ever included this Special Event of the AAA. The
absence of the VRC in past studies has prompted this history that reviews the first 24 years, from 1985 to 2008. It
identifies the 166 participants, their 225 presentations, and many of their associated or resulting publications. It
shows that the VRC has stimulated scholarly research in a wide range of anthropological studies, from collaboration
with indigenous community to studies of gesture and primate studies, etc. Through statistics and personal testimony,
this study reveals the value as well as some problems associated with the VRC. [history, presentations, statistics,
VRC (Visual Research Conference)]

Introduction From Pictorializing to Visual Anthropology, in Hand-


book of Methods in Cultural Anthropology, 1998; Jay

V
isual anthropology has come of age. It is now Ruby, The Last 20 Years of Visual AnthropologyA
fully recognized and accepted that anthropolo- Critical Review, in Visual Studies, vol. 20, no. 2, Oct.
gists use all kinds of images, including still 2005; Rethinking Visual Anthropology, Marcus Banks
photography, film, video, and non-camera-generated and Howard Morphy, eds., 1997; Viewpoints: Visual
images for the description, analysis, communication, Anthropologists at Work, Mary Strong and Laena
and interpretation of human (and sometimes nonhu- Wilder, eds., 2009; and Made to Be Seen: Perspectives
man) behavior. Research routinely includes the study of on the History of Visual Anthropology, Marcus Banks
kinesics, proxemics, and related forms of body motion and Jay Ruby, eds., 2011.
communication (e.g., gesture, dance, sign language), as Histories of the field, however, have consistently
well as visual aspects of culture, including architecture, overlooked the Society for Visual Anthropologys (SVA)
indigenous media, art, and material culture. Visual Visual Research Conference (VRC). That absence has
anthropologists are interested in how aspects of culture prompted this study.1 The following history looks at the
can be pictorially/visually interpreted and expressed, first 24 years of the VRC (19852008) and identifies
and how images can be understood as artifacts of the conference participants as well as many of their
culture. Historical photographs are also seen as a source associated or resulting publications. I recognize that
of ethnographic data, expanding our horizons beyond memory is selective, and thus I cited sources whenever
the reach of memory culture. possible.2 This study shows that the VRC has stimulated
Critical studies and selected histories of visual scholarly research in a wide range of anthropological
anthropology have been written, and the field has been topics. Among many others, these topics include col-
invigorated by debate and varying points of view. To laboration with indigenous people and community
mention a few, Emilie de Brigard, The History of Eth- studies, tourism, dance/ceremonies/rituals, family photo
nographic Film, in Paul Hockings, ed., Principles of studies, gestures, sign language, Labanotation, and
Visual Anthropology, rev. in 1995; Fadwa El Guindi, primate studies. One surprising discovery that has

Visual Anthropology Review, Vol. 28, Issue 2, pp. 83119, ISSN 1058-7187, online ISSN 1548-7458. 2012 by the American Anthropological Association. DOI: 10.1111/j.1548-7458.2012.01118.x.
84 VISUAL ANTHROPOLOGY REVIEW Volume 28 Number 2 Fall 2012

FIGURE 1. Tom Blakely (in baseball cap) and Craig Campbell at the 24th VRC in San Francisco. The audience includes Peter Biella, Cynthia
Close, Rafael Domingo, Andrea Heckman, Carol Hermer, and Anne Zeller. Photograph by Jerome Crowder, November 18, 2008.

resulted from this research has been that, although years of dedication that Blakely has given and is
photographs and films are the basic component of VRC giving to the continuation of these conferences. The
presentations, few participants or audience members years of sustained perseverance pulling together the
seem to have visually documented the conference itself. VRCs have not daunted his enthusiastic spirit. In fact,
The images that appear with this article are some of the that spirit has been a major factor in the success of
only photographs of the VRC that exist. Some photo- the conferences.
graphs have been lost due to photographers changing
computers, cameras, and equipment. This lack of visuals
from the many conferences is lamented. Conference Purpose and Scheduling:
The VRCs have been organized and chaired from Perspectives of the Organizer
the beginning by Dr. Thomas D. Blakely (Figure 1), and
reflect his perseverance and dedication to both SVA Three years after the initiation of the VRC, Blakely
and visual anthropology. I wish to acknowledge the described it in terms that are still relevant today:

Joanna Cohan Scherer is an Emeritus Anthropologist at the Smithsonian Institution (SI) and a former president of the Society for
Visual Anthropology (SVA). She was the anthropologist/illustrations researcher for the 20-volume Handbook of North American
Indians (19782006) at the SI, where she created a collection of over 100,000 images relating to Native Americans currently
housed in the SI National Anthropological Archives. As well as numerous articles and reviews, she is the author of the
award-winning book A Danish Photographer of Idaho Indians: Benedicte Wrensted (Norman: University of Oklahoma Press,
2006). She is an active member of the SVA and currently serves as its historian.
Society for Visual Anthropologys Visual Research Conference SCHERER 85

These conferences have enabled people in the four- Seven or eight years ago, a number of SAVICOM
field anthropological study of visual phenomena to [Society for the Anthropology of Visual Communi-
extend discussions on theoretical, methodological, cation] (later SVA) and AFRI [Anthropological Film
and substantive topics of mutual interest, with Research Institute] members started discussing and
time also to show each other their visual research tentatively planning a conference for somewhere
materials at some length. Some of the discussions in the mountains that would focus on visual
have also included direct implications for the research in anthropology and related disciplines.
professional practice of anthropology (applied Ultimatelyafter a couple of years of intermittent
anthropology).3 talk and reflection on this subjectwe decided that
since travel budgets were at a low ebb and national
Describing the conference in 1998, Blakely wrote: foundation funding was even more difficult to find,
we would try to hold a conference as an early
In the first two days of the American Anthropo- Special Event at the AAA meetings a day or two
logical Association annual meeting, the Visual just before the time when many of us would be
Research Conference will again provide opportuni- gathering together anyway.7
ties for exploring cutting-edge research in the
anthropological study of visual signification, com- Blakelys decision to schedule the VRC before the
munication, and representation.4 annual meetings did not meet with unanimous
approval. Chalfen notes that the VRC-AAA programs
Twenty-three years later, in 2011, Blakely expanded made for a very long week and time away from classes
his description to include its unique and highly valued at a crucial time of the year; this also made for increased
emphasis on audience interaction: expenses (personal communication, July 12, 2009). Jay
Ruby echoed this concern: . . . there is the problem of
The Visual Research Conference is like a panel timing to attend the conference means leaving home on
discussion or open roundtable with ALL a Monday and missing a week of teaching. As Temples
participants (including the audience) as poten- semesters were only 12 weeks long that is simply not a
tially contributing in each presentation. Presenters responsible thing to do (personal communication, July
come with works-in-progress, ready to dialogue, 2, 2009). This scheduling is sometimes cited as the
not to read a paper or show a film with a reason why only 2050 individuals attend some of the
question or two at the end. Visual Research Con- presentations. Wednesday sessions of the VRC also
ference presentations feature much interaction and often overlap with the first AAA sessions that begin at
feedback from an actively participating audience noon. This overlap has been a source of concern by
working to maximize the productive possibilities of some of the SVA board, but since so many AAA sessions
being co-present with each other. Of course some- are concurrent, this criticism has fallen on deaf ears
times a presenter or other participant cannot attend over the last decade.
Monday evening through Wednesday early after- The VRC has been a designated Special Event of the
noon, but those who can do should plan to come AAA since at least 1987, and it should be noted that it
on Monday . . . for dinner at 7 p.m. and participate is only one activity of the SVA that occurs at the yearly
in the Tuesday and Wednesday presentation to AAA meetings. In addition, the SVA organizes poster
FULLY contribute to and benefit from this small- sessions, invited roundtable discussions, workshops,
conference experience.5 and invited sessions.

Beginning with the first conference in 1985, the


VRC has been held on Tuesday and Wednesday morn- The Conference Format, Selection of
ings prior to the start of the scientific programs at Participants, and Publication of Program
annual meetings of the American Anthropological
Association (AAA).6 The AAA convenes Wednesday The VRC presentations are very different from AAA
afternoon through Sunday afternoon, in November or meeting papers. The latter are 15 minutes in length
December. The rationale for the VRC to gather at this and rarely allow time for questions. The presentations
time was described in a letter that Blakely wrote to at the VRC, in contrast, usually run for 45 minutes,
SVA President Richard Chalfen. The letter was part of including as much as 15 minutes for in-depth discus-
Blakelys annual report to the SVA Board of Directors sions. This allows feedback to the presenters that
in 1990: includes suggestions for improvement and challenges
86 VISUAL ANTHROPOLOGY REVIEW Volume 28 Number 2 Fall 2012

to the method, theory, or approach. The number of


presenters varies from year to year, but the generosity
of time granted to each is indicated by the fact that
the day-and-a-half-long conference has an average of
only ten presenters.
As indicated by the comments quoted below, both
students and seasoned colleagues find this face-to-face
conversation about their work invigorating. Often pre-
senters, excited by the interaction at the VRC, take their
discussions back to their classrooms, where they share
them with their students, producing spin-off projects. In
2003, Cynthia Gray presented a documentary film about
video as a tool for academic inquiry and communica-
tion. This film was used in a regional forum to stimulate
dialogue about interdisciplinary curricula. As a result of
the feedback she received at the conference, she later FIGURE 2. The partial audience at the 24th VRC in San Francisco,
guided her students in the production of a remarkable right to left: Peter Biella, Karl Heider, Tom Blakely, and Andrea
variety of additional short documentaries.8 Feedback Heckman. Photograph by Jerome Crowder, November 18, 2008.
received at the VRC also improves subsequent formal
presentations. Some participants also give 15-minute
papers on the same topic during the AAA meeting the be chosen from the board. The first co-organizer
same year. One such presenter, Jelani Mahiri, noted that assigned was Peter Biella (Figure 2) in 2000.11
as a result of her VRC presentation, she was able to Pursuing his preference for works-in-progress
make a more concise presentation a few days later and late breaking projects, Blakely would typically
during the AAA meetings as well (personal communi- communicate with participants about four weeks before
cation, July 16, 2009). the VRC meetings. At that time, he would solicit revi-
In the early years of the VRC, Blakely often post- sions to abstracts or titles of presentations. Thus, par-
poned announcing the names of participants, their ticipants could change their topic, direction, point of
abstracts, and presentation times until September or viewor all of the aboveand the presentation would
October. He did this to accommodate late blossoming go forward. Blakely sometimes allowed changes in
research. He wrote: abstracts and participants up to a few days before the
conference began. In the past, attendees first saw the
final schedule and abstracts for the program only when
[On one hand, the selection of participants] is the
Blakely handed them out the first day of the conference.
product of much advance spadework and planning
A preliminary program was sometimes printed in Visual
(sometimes presenters have given us a rain check
Anthropology Review, with a note that interested par-
for two or three years before finally giving a focus-
ticipants should consult the official conference publi-
ing presentation at the conference). On the other
cations for final information.12 More recently, abstracts
hand, we make special efforts to remain flexible
have been placed online on the SVA website (society
and open to spontaneity and serendipity in the final
forvisualanthropology.org).
selection of the program content, since every year
Potential contributors have always sent their
some very interesting work comes to our atten-
abstracts to Blakely, and in recent years to his
tion well after the April 1 deadline for Scientific
co-organizers. This now occurs prior to the March 15th
Program submissions.9
deadline. Since 2003, abstracts have been submitted
online to the organizers, with copies to the SVA presi-
Whatever the merits of this position, in 1999, the SVA dent and secretary. Blakely and his co-organizers pri-
board insisted that Blakely change his selection and oritize the selections and then agree on the final list of
publication of the program timetables to match those of presenters, who are notified well in advance of the
the AAA. The many participants who complained that conference.
the program announcement was too slow and late pre- The informal nature of the VRC organization allows
cipitated this change. The former approach was known for the inclusion of unofficial presentations. Blakely
to be in step with Blakelys favored African time orien- sometimes fits a participant in at the last minute, either
tation.10 The SVA board also insisted that co-organizers because an accepted presenter found they could not
Society for Visual Anthropologys Visual Research Conference SCHERER 87

make it or because the subject was just too interesting, selves. In some instances, information was received
as he would say, to turn away. Amy Donovan remem- from one co-presenter and not the other, but if full
bered that she was a last-minute invitee to the 1992 or information was obtained, we considered that contact
1996 VRC in San Francisco, where she showed a video successful for both co-presenters. Also, even though
on an exhibition she had created about homeless youth some presenters could not be located, we have been able
in San Francisco.13 There is no evidence of Donovans to find the full information needed to complete this
participation in either the schedule or abstracts, and she study through persistent research in journals and
remembers that Blakely squeezed her in at the last looking at participants vitae online.16 We have com-
minute. Another contributor, David Plath, a seasoned plete information for 160 (96.4 percent) of the partici-
professional who presented in four conferences, pants and incomplete information on the remaining six
remarked: (3.6 percent). All participants were asked to comment on
the effectiveness of the VRC, and importantly, whether
. . . your list only loosely reflects the times I made their participation resulted in or was based on any sort
some sort of presentation, and truth tell the memory of publication.
cells cant summon up a precise account . . . but [I] The information about the participants includes
know there were other times when I made a pre- name, sex, U.S. or non-U.S. residence at the time of the
sentation that may not have been on the official presentation, field of anthropology (linguistics, cultural
list, Tom allowing me to do so because there had anthropology, physical anthropology, etc.), and status
been no-shows from the official list. [personal com- at the time of each presentation (professor, student,
munication, July 14, 2009] researcher, filmmaker, independent scholar, etc.). The
table also includes information about participants who
Again, there is no existent record in the program co-presented, gave more than one presentation, were
schedules, abstracts, or post-conference reports that deceased at the time of this study, and whether infor-
documents such non-scheduled presentations.14 mation is complete. An asterisk after the presenters
A few participants expressed the opinion that the name means that the information is incomplete: either
VRC was poorly organized and too informal. Such we were unable to locate the individual or the indi-
informality extended to lack of audience control, and vidual was deceased, and we were unable to complete
some participants commented that chatter during their the information through our own research.
presentation was disruptive, annoying, and resulted in Of the 166 participants, 49.4 percent were male
their not submitting abstracts for future conferences. and 50.6 percent female; 82.5 percent were based in
However, the informal organization of the VRC was, the United States and 17.5 percent were not based
more often than not, applauded. Plath pithily observed: in the United States; 43 (25.9 percent) participants
co-presented; 36 (21.7 percent) presented in more than
Its a creatively messy operation, and thats its great one conference; and 5 (3 percent) are deceased. The
virtue by contrast with the anal-compulsive over- participants were asked to identify their fields of anthro-
control exercised by AAA. I quit presenting papers pology, which most did unambiguously. However, four
at the AAA once I discovered the VRC. The obvious individuals identified their field as both cultural and
value for me is that Ive had opportunities to hear visual anthropology, and four others as both cultural
reactions to works-in-progress; almost no other anthropology and linguistics.17 The distribution of the
conference allows time for that. [personal commu- participants was 44 percent cultural anthropology, 23.5
nication, July 14, 2009] percent visual anthropology, 3.6 percent social anthro-
pology, 4.2 percent applied anthropology, 2.4 percent
both visual and cultural anthropology, 2.4 percent both
Demographics of Conference Participants cultural anthropology and linguistics, 1.2 percent lin-
guistics and body language (gestures/signs), 0.6 percent
I began this study by making an exhaustive search for archaeology, 0.6 percent physical anthropology, and
each of the 166 participants listed in the programs of 17.5 percent who did not consider themselves anthro-
the VRC from 1985 to 2008, then produced a table (see pologists or whose field is unknown.
Appendix) that includes data on the participants, their Presenters at more than one VRC provided their
225 presentations, and publications based on these pre- professional status at the time of each of the 225 pre-
sentations.15 All the participants were contacted by sentations. Since the professional status of presenters
e-mail, telephone, mail, and/or Facebook, and much of often changed over time, it is necessary for statistical
the information was reported by the presenters them- purposes to count each participation in a presentation
88 VISUAL ANTHROPOLOGY REVIEW Volume 28 Number 2 Fall 2012

separately, giving a total of 253 participations.18 The sentation or one or more articles from a presentation.
professional status was 20.5 percent full professors, 6.7 Thus, in a number of cases, multiple publications
percent associate professors, 18.5 percent assistant pro- resulted from or were based on that one presentation.
fessors, 15.8 percent independent scholars, 3.6 percent Sometimes a participant gave a presentation after
filmmaker/photographer, 3.6 percent researchers, 2.4 recently completing a project, so that the publication
percent retired, 1.6 percent curators, 25.7 percent stu- date precedes the presentation. In the table, there is
dents, 1.2 percent multiple statuses (filmmaker and pro- also a category unpublished, which indicates that the
fessor, assistant professor, or independent scholar, etc.), presentation did not result in any type of publication
and 0.4 percent unknown. that was found. The bibliography and other publication
The table also lists the 225 presentations from 1985 lists only include materials published prior to June 1,
to 2008 by title, year given, geographic area of the 2012, when research for this study was concluded. I
topic, and whether the presentation resulted in publica- did not include any publications, films, or dissertations
tion. A few presentations included more than one geo- in progress. While there are many publications result-
graphic area, so a category of multiple geographic ing from the VRC, it must be noted that rarely have
areas was established. Statistically, 70 (31.1 percent) of participants acknowledged in their publications the
the presentations related to North America, 50 (22.2 fact that they presented at the conferences. This lack of
percent) were worldwide, and 23 (10.2 percent) related credit is probably more the result of negligence on the
to sub-Saharan Africa. The remaining geographic areas part of the presenters than a comment on the value of
were 1 (0.4 percent) North Africa, 11 (4.9 percent) South the VRC.
America, 3 (1.3 percent) Central America and Mexico, In looking at the publications resulting from the
10 (4.5 percent) Europe (including western Russia), 6 VRC, it is clear that they are varied and appear in
(2.7 percent) Middle East, 6 (2.7 percent) China (includ- multiple venues. In some cases, the mere publication of
ing northern Asia), 13 (5.8 percent) Southeast Asia papers or films introduced at the VRC does not do
(including Indonesia, New Guinea, and Philippines), 5 justice to their wider significance. An example is
(2.2 percent) Indian subcontinent, 8 (3.6 percent) Japan Mathew Barrs 2002 VRC presentation about a tradi-
or Korea, 2 (0.9 percent) Oceania (including Micronesia, tional fishing village on the North Carolina coast. Barrs
Polynesia, and Melanesia), 2 (0.9 percent) Australia and resulting 2006 film played a significant role in that
New Zealand, 12 (5.3 percent) multiple geographic states general assembly passing a bill that set aside $70
areas, and 3 (1.3 percent) unknown. million to preserve maritime and fishing communities in
the state. A version of Barrs film was later broadcast on
public television nationwide via the National Educa-
Publications Based on or Resulting from tional Telecommunications Association, and was also
Conference Presentations shown at numerous film festivals, including one in
Lorient, France, March 2011. The impact of this film
Because the VRC has been ignored in recent histories outside academic anthropology is to Barrs credit and is
of visual anthropology, one of the main goals of this an indication of the films significance.
review was to demonstrate that participation in the In evaluating the value of film publications based
conferences was reflected in a wide variety of publica- on VRC presentations, one of the individuals who pro-
tions. In fact, the 225 presentations are evident in 219 vided comments was Cynthia Close, formerly the execu-
publications: 93 book chapters or journal articles, 34 in tive director of the Documentary Educational Resources
film or video, 30 dissertations or theses (either M.A. or (DER). Her comments were centered on the importance,
Ph.D.), 20 university press books, 17 commercial books popularity, and monetary rewards of some of these films
or textbooks, 14 electronic media productions, and 11 marketed by DER.
exhibits.19 Of the presentations, 100 resulted in at least
one publication, 48 can be credited with multiple pub- John Bishop and Harold Prins film Oh, What a
lications, 71 resulted in no publications, and for 6 no Blow That Phantom Gave Me! Edmund Carpenter.
publication information is available. This is a major contribution to the history of visual
Only publications directly related to the presenta- anthropology and sells fairly well. Andrea Heckman
tions are included in the bibliography, filmography, list film Ausangate. Her film received recognition in
of exhibits, and list of electronic media. Checks in the both the academic world and the world of popular
table indicate that one or more publications may be culture. It was licensed for broadcast, and sells
found in the bibliography. A presenter may have pub- relatively well in the educational market as well
lished an article, a book, and a film related to a pre- as direct to consumers. This is what I call a
Society for Visual Anthropologys Visual Research Conference SCHERER 89

made significant contributions to the field of anthro-


pology that are clearly reflected in their many diverse
publications.

Visionary Presentations

Some of the VRC presentations reported on projects


that, in hindsight, were significantly innovative and
far ahead of their time. For example, in 1991, Patrick
Dionne and Raymond Carpentier gave a presentation A
New Electronic Mail Journal: A Project of the Commis-
sion on Visual Anthropology. Dionne made these com-
ments about his project:
FIGURE 3. Malcolm Collier presenting Inside Views: The Research
and Applied Legacies of John Adairs Film Work at the 14th VRC
In 1991, the Internet existed but not the Web so our
in Philadelphia. Photograph by Anne Zeller, December 2, 1998.
idea was to create an Internet site via an ftp server
just like the comparative literature journal Surfaces,
then published at the University of Montreal,
cross-over film as it works well in several markets already had. People would have selected a year and
and on different levels of interest. David Plath an issue before downloading articles individually or
Makikos New World. This is also a crossover film news items or reviews bundled in one text for each
that did very well in sales the first couple of years kind, all in Word format, which was the main text
it was released. It tried to appeal to both a popular standard at the time. The site would also have
audience as well as an academic audience. It was included a bulletin board to pass on the news as
a very ambitious undertaking for David Plath. soon as we received them and it could also have
[Regarding] Anne Zellers primate films: I been used, for instance, to discuss works in progress
approached Anne when I first came to DER and saw or to help people to connect. It would have been an
her film work. It was not particularly well done adjunct to the paper publication, but I could
from an artistic or technical POV but there was little imagine that after networks and computers devel-
about primates available for academic studyyou oped only a little more, it could become, in accor-
had Jane Goodall and that was about it. Anne was dance with the Commissions worldwide mandate,
reluctant and modest recognizing that she was not visual anthropologys main hub. As for audio-
a professional filmmaker and not sure if she visual media, they remained only a very near
should make her work available through a major eventuality in 1991. [personal communication,
distributor like DER. I talked her into it, and now December 4, 2011, and June 22, 2012]
distribute her entire series of more than a dozen
DVDs on primates. They sell like hot cakes . . . Unfortunately, the project did not get off the ground
royalties she shares with her university. They sell because the head of the commission, Asen Balikci, was
year after year. Obviously they found an immediate retiring from the University of Montreal, where the
market because they filled a need . . . it found its project was conceived. No funding existed to get it up
rightful audiencea purely academic one. [per- and running. This was a missed opportunity, but the
sonal communication, March 16, 2010] project foreshadowed electronic mail journals of today.
Three other presenters who were significantly ahead
Based on the entries in the bibliography, filmogra- of their time in utilizing new technology were Brenda
phy, and the list of electronic media publications and Farnell (1989 presentation and 1995 CD-ROM publica-
exhibits, some of the most productive authors are tion), Peter Biella (1991 and 1992 presentations and
Fadwa El Guindi (nine publications), Peter Biella (nine 1993 publications), and Cynthia Korpan (2005 presen-
publications), Adam Kendon (eight publications), Karl tation and 2009 publication). Farnell incorporated her
Heider (eight publications), Malcolm Collier (seven pub- ethnographic field data in an interactive CD-ROM,
lications; Figure 3), Richard Chalfen (six publications), which was also published with a traditional book. The
Marjorie Goodwin (six publications), and Anne Zeller CD-ROM greatly increased Farnells ability to present
(six publications). These presenters at the VRC have videos of Assiniboine telling stories in Plains Indian
90 VISUAL ANTHROPOLOGY REVIEW Volume 28 Number 2 Fall 2012

sign talk, and to analyze these performances using Bishop, Cynthia Close, Malcolm Collier, Howard
Labanotation. It also allowed her to more easily share Conklin, Fadwa El Guindi, Karl Heider, Carol Hermer,
the results of her work with the indigenous community. Allison Jablanko, Adam Kendon, Mary Strong, and me.
Biella used CDs and computers to incorporate his raw These participants encouraged her to continue with her
data from fieldwork among the Maasai both for research visual studies on primates (Macaque monkeys and
and teaching.20 He demonstrated the potential of exter- chimpanzees). The validation she received from col-
nal storage devices, such as CDs and DVDs, which can leagues, she said, encouraged her to complete her film
hold an enormous amount of text, sound recordings, research and analysis, to the enhancement of both her
and photographs. Biella also developed a course using intellectual growth and ultimately her professional
this technology that foreshadowed much of our online career (see Zeller filmography).
visual anthropology teaching methods today. In Cynthia In particular, Zeller cites Blakelys interest in the use
Korpans case, her masters thesis, completed in 2009 of space, directionality of gaze, and concept of gestural
and available in electronic format, will soon be made silence as particularly helpful in her work. It led her to
available as a hypermedia document, although the Uni- the realization that various levels of the face in pri-
versity of Victoria, Department of Anthropology did not mates provided different kinds of information in facial
accept that format for her degree. Korpan wrote about gestures, and that they communicated about their social
the creation of this document: selves as well as the messages they were sending.
Kendons work on gesture was influential in Zellers
My argument was that the community from which analysis of threatening, friendly, and cheerful facial
the research [derived], needed to have access to gestures in primates, helping her to convert these facial
academic work and that the format was just as gestures into patterns and to research in those patterns
acceptable as the paper/pdf version. For the hyper- information about social relations.23 Zeller utilized
media document I have simply created a more Jablonkos methodology of analyzing film of work and
dynamic document that can be viewed by anyone. dance through a frame-by-frame analysis of individual
[personal communication, October 3, 2011]21 movement patterns to help study facial communication
among primates.24 From my work, she learned points for
All of these presentations showed the practicality of the analysis of setting, means to extract a wide range of
making esoteric anthropological data into user-friendly information from what is seen in an image, and for a
materials that then became available not only to the theoretical concern with reciprocity between actor
wider academic community but to indigenous commu- (subject) and recorder (photographer). Zellers interest in
nities as well. non-formal art was inspired by Strongs work on group
patterning in murals as accessible, structured, non-
linear productions, and helped Zeller read the spatial
Conference Longevity and Value geography of primate artistic work.
to Participants The VRC has also helped many young scholars in
their academic pursuit. For example, Wilton Martinez, a
Publications are not the only evidence of the wider student in 1989, commented:
significance of the VRC. Clearly, its longevity is also an
indicator of its vitality. From presenters comments, one The conference definitely had a most positive
can see that the contacts and support that presenters got impact on my academic work and my career. It was
from attending the conferences, especially the two-way very stimulating to present my research in progress
interactivity that students and junior scholars had with and receive feedback in the context of the confer-
senior scholars of the field, stimulated the presenters to ence. Those presentations played a key role in my
think through problems and helped many to revise their decision to pursue the project as part of my MA
work into creative final results. Comments received thesis, then my doctoral research and eventually,
from the majority of participants show that many sea- my dissertation. [personal communication, Febru-
soned professionals as well as students found value in ary 9, 2011]
presenting at the VRC. This was expressed to me
empathically by Anne Zeller,22 who said that the feed- The fact that students had the opportunity to inter-
back she received from her participation in the VRC act with seasoned professionals is a positive aspect of
(from 1986 through 2009) was especially useful. She the VRC that was articulated by many participants.
said that she received insightful comments from people Victor Fuks, a student in 1988, subsequently published
such as Najwa Adra, Tom Blakely, Peter Biella, John his presentation, and in a footnote to it remarked:
Society for Visual Anthropologys Visual Research Conference SCHERER 91

This text is a revised version of the paper presented culture studies that build on visual ethnography,
at the 1988 meeting of the American Anthropologi- and which the students continue to use in their
cal Association Visual Research Conference in theses and art projects, and have also introduced it
Phoenix, Arizona, and I am grateful for the stimu- into their own teaching in the Swedish grade
lating and helpful suggestions and comments raised schools and high schools. The key elements in it
by the audience. I also appreciate the stimulus of were to do field documentation and then analyze
Thomas Blakelys invitation to participate in the the documents, reflecting particularly on the visual
Visual Research Conference. [Fuks 1989:24 n. 1] genres that shaped the ways the documentation was
carried out. I also used my 1997 SVA presentation
To date, as Jay Ruby commented, the contributions as my lecture when I interviewed for that position
made by the VRC have not been recognized or included . . . I am on the board of a Nordic Network of Visual
in previous surveys of the history of visual anthropol- Studies which has organized a series of workshops
ogy.25 The present study sets the record straight. and conferences over the past 6 years, and that
draws heavily on the groundwork laid through the
SVA, as well as visual sociology. [personal commu-
nication, February 24, 2011]
Reflections on the SVA VRCs by Participants
Peter Biella, a presenter in 1991, 1992, 1996, 1999,
I have been a participant observer of many of the VRCs 2000, and 2006, and with students in 2004 and
since their beginning in 1985. Thus, while not a totally 2008:
objective observer, I have tried to be as even a com-
One important function of the VRC is an atmo-
piler of the history of the conferences as possible. I
sphere that allows students interested in anthro-
have attempted to balance the statistical data, cited
pological film production to meet and observe the
earlier, with what follows: the voices of 32 of the 166
work in progress of professors who teach in
participants. Included are both positive and negative
various visual anthropology programs. My presen-
comments that I have edited from the replies to my
tations have stimulated students in the audience
inquiries. I thank all the individuals who have partici-
to apply to my program. In 2006, in San Jose, a
pated in this study and for granting me permission to
number of my students presented their films. My
quote from their replies. In alphabetical order they are
program was 5 years old at the time. Several
as follows:
visual anthropologists at the meetings congratu-
lated me on my students work and began recom-
Najwa Adra, a presenter in 1999:
mending students to come to my program.
What I like about VRC presentations is the collegial Applications increased noticeably. [personal com-
response in an informal setting. It isnt so much munication, December 14, 2011]
that my presentation helped my career but that
Craig Campbell, a presenter in 2008:
I received good feedback from colleagues that
encouraged me to further develop this topic [of The feedback I received turned out to be an excel-
belly dancing as an urban folk genre]. [personal lent discussion on art and expression in documen-
communication, June 13, 2009]26 tary works. It was also an excellent opportunity for
me to discuss anxiety about the use of images that
Elisenda Ardevol, a presenter in 1997:
depict the history of others. [personal communica-
The conferences were very useful to legitimate the tion, July 12, 2009]
use of visual methods in the field of anthropology
Richard Chalfen, a presenter in 198688, 1992,
and also in the field of law, social studies and
1996, and 1998:
qualitative methodologies. [personal communica-
tion, September 21, 2009] I always felt the Visual Research Conference (VRC)
was very successful on several fronts. Tom Blakely
Karin Becker, a presenter in 1997:
wanted us to have adequate time to offer, witness
The SVA conferences were extremely important to and digest a presentation of ideas and data. The
the work I continue to do in visual ethnography, AAA 15-minute time slot was broken! This was
both in my teaching and research. During my years indeed successful and much appreciated by most
as professor of Art Education (Konstfack, College of of us. I also recall a much-needed congenial
Art and Design), I introduced a unit on visual atmosphere-another contrast to other gatherings.
92 VISUAL ANTHROPOLOGY REVIEW Volume 28 Number 2 Fall 2012

Tom was skilled at mediating debates and the (very) Jerome Crowder, a presenter in 2005:
few conflicts that emerged. [personal communica-
tion, July 12, 2009] The most important aspect for me about presenting
at the VRC is meeting the people and being able to
Jenny Chio, a student presenter in 2007 and 2008: dialogue with other VAs about my work. I found
that my presentation was well received and helped
I really enjoyed the format and felt challenged in a give me some credibility within the subdiscipline
positive manner throughout the event. It is rare to . . . I have tried to attend the VRC since 2002 . . .
have the opportunity to really engage in a discus- Since 2002 I have witnessed the quality of the
sion about ones work with a specialized, friendly presentations decline significantly, and feel that the
audience. I was able to test out new ideas and discussion and dialogue generated at the meeting
arguments in both of my talks, and to rethink a had been below par . . . it may be time for the SVA
number of my assumptions and expectations about to direct leadership to the VRC and help with
my research as well. [personal communication, administration and/or support of the Conference.
June 24, 2009] There needs to be more credibility within the
process, and while it may take a little time to have
Malcolm Collier, a presenter in 1988, 1990, 2000, a small committee read the applications, it is in the
and with students in 1996, 1998, and 2002: best interest of the SVA and VRC that innovative,
While not without frustrations and problems, the unique and developing projects get stage-time
Visual Research Conference is the primary reason I during this once-a-year event . . . Id like the VAs to
have continued to attend the annual meetings of get it together again and make the VRC something
the AAA. Appreciation: A) Opportunity to both special and professional. [personal communication,
present and to see work in progress . . . B) Time July 8, 2009]
frames that allow for significant presentation of Brenda Farnell, a student at the time of her 1989
visual materials . . . C) Opportunity to meet and presentation and an assistant professor in 1994:
have conversations with people over some period of
time, both in the context of the presentations and I participated regularly in the early conferences,
across the day and half of the sessions. D) A setting but lost interest since there appeared to be little
in which it is easier for students to present and get interest or useful feedback in my particular area
feedback on their work. E) A venue in which people (movement/body/dance/performance). I came to
not necessarily in AAA, or even in anthropology at feel that the Conference, with the presentations
all, can come, present, listen, participate without always selected by the same organizer, was not
the exclusionary registration/fee processes of the representing the best of visual anthropologymore
AAA. This especially includes the opportunity . . . of interesting work was being presented and discussed
having local participants in the visual projects be at other venues (e.g., at New York University and
part of sessions asmore or lessequals . . . Prob- British venues). [personal communication, Novem-
lems: A) Presentations without significant visual ber 3, 2009]
content. B) The temptation to have known present- Marc Tizoc Gonzalez, a student presenter in 2000
ers dominate the sessions . . . C) Could be more and 2001:
tightly run . . . D) . . . need to coach better regarding
how to approach their presentation, emphasizing My SVA presentations were very helpful in devel-
importance of visual, need for dialogue, and the oping the projects that constituted my MA thesis
general desirability of in progress, exploratory and earned me college honors from the SFSU
material. E) Although the advent of computers, LCD College of Behavioral and Social Sciences in 2002
projectors, etc. has very much improved the situa- and to my career thereafter . . . my experiences with
tion, it would be nice to have better ways of pre- the SVA, especially its relatively longer periods
senting still photographs, especially in terms of for individual presentations, provided significant
display wall spaces and other means of presenting opportunities to practice public speaking before a
photographic arrays in a format that allows more professional audience, which is a skill that I have
dynamic audience participation. F) Figure out ways continued developing both in scholarly circles, at
to have presenters from a wider range of regions of law as a practicing attorney and in the classroom.
the world. [personal communication, September 29, [personal communication, July 16, 2009, and June
2009] 14, 2012]
Society for Visual Anthropologys Visual Research Conference SCHERER 93

Karl G. Heider, a participant in 198689, 1996, and careers, because the presentation and ensuing dis-
with students in 1993 and 1994: cussion helped to sharpen our ideas on the project,
and then the paper we presented was published in
As for which [films] have been particularly
Visual Anthropology. Publish or perish. [personal
innovativeI think first of [David] Plaths
communication, June 25, 2009]
Makikos New World [1999] where he uses actors
and old photographs to illustrate an old document; Jayasinhji Jhala, a presenter in 1994:
and [Andrea] Heckmans film Ausangate, which
The Visual Research Conference has been good for
together with her Collier-award-winning book
me, my students, and colleagues and for the disci-
form an exemplary combination of visuals and text.
pline as a whole. Even when I have not been able to
[personal communication, March 17, 2010]
attend I have only heard positive things about the
Carol Hermer, a student during her presentations in proceedings . . . it is incredibly difficult to start and
1995 and 1997, and an assistant professor in 2002: sustain this type of initiative and offering. It is easy
to tear anything down. [personal communication,
Ive had my misgivings about the VRC over the October 14, 2009]
years. I think the addition of someone to help Tom
decide on which presentations to choose is crucial, Adam Kendon, a presenter in 1990, 1991, 1993,
also the use of the web in submitting presentations 1994, and 1998:
so things dont get lost as in years past. Every year The presentation of 1991, which was the first time I
I try to attend as it is for me the most interesting had ever tried to say anything about gesture in
part of the meetings. I like the format tremendously. Southern Italy, which I was just then beginning to
I dont know how one weeds out the dudsmaybe study, was very well received and this did give me
including a sample of the visuals in the submission a good deal of confidence that it was worth going
or asking for a longer abstract. Every year there are on with what I had started. [personal communica-
a few fascinating papers and a few terrible ones. I tion, March 29, 2010]
know Tom likes the idea of late-breaking news but
maybe it has to be pretty clear what people want to Patricia G. Lange, a participant in 2008:
say in April. Perhaps one needs to restrict it to I found Thomas Blakelys comments particularly
people actively working in visual anthropology. helpful. He had a way of engaging with my work,
Often outsiders think that what they are doing is and drawing on what he knew of my linguistic
path breaking because it is in their fields, but it isnt background to provide insightful suggestions
for old-hat visual anthro people . . . I would be about where I might productively take the
terribly upset if it disappeared or became like the research. For instance, I tend to like to examine
rest of the meetings. [personal communication, very small units of linguistic analysis, and he
September 16, 2009] asked if I had considered finding analogously
Allison Jablonko, a co-organizer (with Blakely in small but socially revealing units of behavior in
198586) for the first 1985 conference in Washing- visual form. Comments that engage most directly
ton, DC, and a presenter in 1985, 1994, 1996, 1997, with a creators material are often the most stimu-
and 2001: lating and helpful . . . I support the conference and
I think it is a wonderful way to obtain feedback
Presenting at the SVA Conference is a major infu- from colleagues to work with the material. I found
sion of energy and focus for the larger conversa- the feedback on my work to be interesting. What I
tion among a large group of people who are observed, however, was some uncertainty about
concerned with issues of visual anthropology. how the newer, more experimental material was
Although . . . I did not move from the stage of received and critiqued . . . Ideally feedback would
presentation on to the stage of publication, I feel offer suggestions that help scholars maintain stan-
that this periodic, face-to-face meeting has been dards of excellence while being allowed to push
central to the development of the discipline as a the envelope. [personal communication, September
whole. [personal communication, June 12, 2009] 18, 2009]
Sabine Jell-Bahlsen, a presenter in 2002: Jacqueline Maingard, a participant in 1995:
Our presentation at the visual anthropology My presentation at the Conference had a very
Research Conference had a positive effect on our positive effect on both my career and on the project
94 VISUAL ANTHROPOLOGY REVIEW Volume 28 Number 2 Fall 2012

itself . . . it was also a useful forum and framework in in my work, including the significance of eye
which to screen the film [Uku Hamba ZeTo Walk contact, posturing and clothing, as well as to more
Naked] and consider my work. The feedback and broadly conceived theoretical concerns such as
discussion was excellent and was also very affirming staging and performance. I am convinced that
at a point when the film had just been produced. there is nothing more central to our field of
Since then it has had many successful runs in all Visual Anthropology than the ability to jointly
kinds of events and screenings all over the world. interrogate the visual evidence of our work. The
[personal communication, February 8, 2011] communal, processual discussion is central to the
manner that I pursue my work in the context of
Jonathan S. Marion, a participant in 2005 and
Native American communities and I am grateful to
2006:
have had the opportunity to enact this collaborative
The VRC . . . was invaluable in presenting me a exploration of the visual with my professional col-
chance to test run some of my ideas [on competi- leagues. [personal communication, September 10,
tive ballroom dancing] amongst visual scholars, 2009]
and the interactive nature of the VRC allowed for
Michael Naimark, a presenter in 1996:
feedback that helped me refine my own thinking,
approaches, and presentations . . . the VRC essen- My presentation at the SVA Conference had a pro-
tially served as a springboard for my involvement found effect on my professional growth . . . I was a
in the SVA . . . brought me to the attention of more media artist and researcher with a great deal of
established visual scholars including my nomina- respect for the field of visual anthropology . . . The
tion and then election to the SVA board . . . people feedback was an important and refreshing change
I met at the VRC formed the majority of those I then from the usual media art and media tech commu-
recruited for the 2007 SVA Special Event discus- nities with which I associate. Since then, Ive been
sions on visual ethics, which in turn have given rise both enthusiastic and critical of the role that
to SVA Invited Roundtables on Visual Ethics in both anthropology could play in new media. [personal
2008 and 2009. Finally, the open and supportive communication, July 9, 2009]
nature of the VRC provided an ideal setting to have
J.R. Osborn, a presenter in 2008:
some of my visual anthropology students present
their own work. [personal communication, October The Visual Research Conference provided a forum
22, 2009] for extended discussion on my project with col-
leagues and critics. I received a good deal of spe-
Nancy Marie Mithlo, a presenter in 2006:
cific feedback, which has helped me refine the
My participation at the 2006 SVA Visual Research methodology and apply it to new topics and situ-
Conference was very significantboth for my own ations. My only suggestion for the Conference
professional development and for advancing the would be to focus the discussions toward the
research goals of the two archival projects I visual tools and methods being shared rather than
directedthe Horace Poolaw Photography Project the content of the works. [personal communica-
and the Yeffe Kimball Collection at the Institute of tion, October 7, 2009]
American Indian Art . . . At the Conference, I was
Sara Elizabeth Perry, a student presenter in 2005:
able to meet these two outstanding scholars [Karl
Heider and Thomas D. Blakely] and ask them I was very pleased with the critical feedback that I
directly questions about my teaching pedagogy received during and immediately subsequent to my
using the textbook [Heider 1997] and other presentation, but I am a bit disappointed that the
resources . . . these connections became central to VRC is not directly linked to opportunities to
my professional standing and my ability to con- publish our research projects either in special VRC-
tinue the research I was committed to. My students related volumes, or in the SVA journal, or even
who attended the Conference were likewise inspired online on the SVA website. I would have liked the
. . . the Conference made the educational process conversation to continue beyond the VRC itself.
come alive for them in a manner similar to the [personal communication, June 25, 2009]
process of conducting fieldwork, except our field
Tereza Porybna, a student in 2007:
was the tribe of the SVA . . . I found that the
Conference participants were finely attuned to The main benefit of conferences is the possibility
the nuances of the theses I wished to forward to meet and talk with colleagues. In my case,
Society for Visual Anthropologys Visual Research Conference SCHERER 95

because visual anthropology is still in its begin-


nings in Czech Republic, it is also a very important
opportunity to catch up with the field . . . this
workshop type of conference style is the most
useful and it would be nice to have more of
these. [personal communication, September 29,
2009]

Jack R. Rollwagen, a retired professor at the time of


his 2006 presentation:

The SVA Research Conference has always had one


or more organizers,27 but (at least during the last
meeting at which I presented) had no CHAIR. The
function of a symposium CHAIR . . . is to keep that
symposium in order, to limit the presenter to the
time allotted for him/her, to keep members of the FIGURE 4. Jennifer Wolowic presenting Visually, Orally, Rela-
audience from interrupting presenters, to respond tively: Collaborative Representations of First Nations Youth at
to any unusual circumstances, and so forth . . . I the 24th VRC in San Francisco. Photograph by Jerome Crowder,
began my presentation, and within five minutes . . . November 19, 2008.
one of the members of the audience began chal-
lenging anything that I said. I tried to be polite, I
tried to be firm, and I tried to move on with my have little formal education. [personal communi-
presentation, all with no effect . . . neither Tom nor cation, July 8, 2009]
Joanna intervened to restore order so that I could
David J. Steele, a presenter in 1986:
complete my presentation . . . My presentation was
ruined because neither of the ORGANIZERS took [The Conference] provided me an opportunity to
the responsibilities of CHAIR of that symposium . . . share how I was using visual methods and an eth-
The SVA Research Conference MUST have someone nographic perspective in applied medical and edu-
who acts as chair, and someone who has the cational anthropology. Over the years my active
strength and willingness to assert themselves in affiliation with the field of anthropology has waned
such a case as I have described. [personal commu- as I went native in medical education. But I have
nication, July 11, 2009] had a very rewarding and interesting career and I
bring sensitivities to my work that is derived from
Lynn Selby, a student presenter in 2001: an anthropological perspective. [personal commu-
I was not integrated into a graduate program at nication, August 25, 2009]
the time, and as my subsequent enrollment in Drid Williams, a presenter in 1988 and 1990:
graduate school at the University of Texas at
Austin in 2003 did not present the time and types I found the Conferences valuable for drawing atten-
of networks to help me deepen my relationship tion to the dance and human movement studies by
with SVA. I would say that Dr. Peter Biellas active an audience who was (and still is) interested in the
outreach to students at San Francisco State Uni- visual arts . . . but Im still affected by the fact that
versity was critical to my participation in the SVA many of my audiences feel that they dont know
Visual Research Conference, and I am grateful for enough to ask questions, so I dont get all that
his role in recruiting younger scholars into SVA much feedback that way. [personal communication,
activities . . . I hope to return to SVA as an active October 14, 2009]
participant after the later stages of my dissertation
Jennifer Wolowic (Figure 4), a student presenter in
writing, as I am still using ethnographic video as
2008:
a research tool, and am creating a short documen-
tary at the end of my research period for the com- [The Conference was] very useful. 10 minutes into
munity which is hosting most of my research so my presentation the head of Documentary Educa-
I can share some of the results of my research tional Resources stood up, interrupted my presen-
with non-academic community members who tation and offered to distribute my film!! Because of
96 VISUAL ANTHROPOLOGY REVIEW Volume 28 Number 2 Fall 2012

learning about. I also found the discussions and


presentation at the Conference of the use of pho-
tographs very informative and helpful in my teach-
ing. Work on new media has opened my eyes to the
kinds of archiving and innovative use of material
gathered for other purposes and altogether my
career would not have been the same at all without
this group and this conference. [personal commu-
nication, June 10, 2009]

Notes
1
This study was encouraged by Peter Biella (personal com-
FIGURE 5. Katharine Young presenting Time and the Body: munication, December 11, 2007), who, after the 2007 SVA/
Posture, Memory, and Narrative in Somatic Psychology at the 14th AAA meetings in Washington, DC, suggested that I pursue
VRC in Philadelphia. Photograph by Anne Zeller, December 2, 1998. a challenge that Jay Ruby gave to me. Ruby had remarked
to me that nothing significant had ever come out of the
VRC presentations, and that was why he had never men-
tioned them in his study of the history of visual anthropol-
ogy. Ruby also commented, I have never seen a reference
that my film has since screened at multiple festivals to any SVA conference presentation as a footnote or bibli-
worldwide. ography reference or noted that a published paper started as
a conference presentation (personal communication, July
Katharine Young (Figure 5), a presenter in 1993, 2, 2009).
2
1996, 1998, 1999, and 2008: All the correspondence, e-mails, and copies of the records
on which this history is based are in the authors files, and
I have never had the faintest intimation that any of will be placed in the Smithsonian Institution, National
my presentations at the Visual Research Conference Anthropological Archives (NAA), along with the records of
have made any difference to my professional career, the society. SVA signed a depository agreement with the
except with respect to my status in the Society for NAA, July 8, 2011. Any readers who find errors or omis-
Visual Anthropology itself, nor with the exception sions are invited to write to the author to place the infor-
of my most recent presentation in 2008, do I feel mation in the record.
3
presenting my material has made any difference to Blakely, Thomas D. 1988. Society for Visual Anthropology
me in my development of the project on which I News: Outgoing Presidents Report, Annual Meeting of the
presented. I found some of the questions in 2008 American Anthropological Association, Chicago, November
1722, 1987. SVA Newsletter 4(1):1314.
very sharp and have them in mind in my reworking 4
From the handout of the 14th Annual VRC, November
of the material. [personal communication, June 12, 30December 2, 1998, in authors possession.
2009] 5
From website of the 27th annual VRC preliminary program,
Anne Zeller, a presenter in 1986, 1990, 1994, 2000, 2011 in Montreal, Canada.
6
2001, and 2007: Locations of SVA Visual Research Conferences/AAA
Meetings:
I strongly feel that the Visual Research Conference 1985 Washington, DC
and the people I met through the Society for Visual 1986 Philadelphia, PA
Anthropology have had a very positive effect on my 1987 Chicago, IL
career . . . I have made 12 teaching videos on mate- 1988 Phoenix, AZ
rial I have gathered and many of the visuals for the 1989 Washington, DC
1990 New Orleans, LA
presentations I made [at the SVA/VRC] were part of
1991 Chicago, IL
the films that are currently distributed by DER and 1992 San Francisco, CA
used by over 100 colleges and universities in North 1993 Washington, DC
America and a few other places. These have been a 1994 Atlanta, GA
big help to the teaching of primate behavior for 1995 Washington, DC
many students who otherwise might not have had 1996 San Francisco, CA
the opportunity to see the behaviors they were 1997 Washington, DC
Society for Visual Anthropologys Visual Research Conference SCHERER 97

1998 Philadelphia, PA time. The difference is not about being late. Not about
1999 Chicago, IL calendars. It is about social relations and personal interac-
2000 San Francisco, CA tions. It is a qualitative difference (Blakely quoted in El
2001 Washington, DC Guindi 2008:25 from a telephone conversation, October
2002 New Orleans, LA 2004). Tom prefers African timea metaphor for a more
2003 Chicago, IL relaxed notion of time than that adopted as the ideal in the
2004 Atlanta, GA West. That is how he conducts the Visual Research Confer-
2005 Washington, DC ence, a successful project he innovated close to two decades
2006 San Jose, CA ago for the Society of Visual Anthropology. Almost annu-
2007 Washington, DC ally the Society tries to put pressure on Tom to conduct it
2008 San Francisco, CA differentlyto follow deadlines, stick to time limits for
7
Blakely to Chalfen, November 8, 1990. National Anthropo- presentations, etc. Tom strongly clings to his mode of
logical Archives, Smithsonian Institution, Washington, DC. operation, which he sums up as African time, using his
8
Samples of the mini-documentaries produced by students long-term ethnographic experience in Africa as a guide for
while on campus, University of Wisconsin-Eau Claire (per- a workable alternative to the North American notion of
sonal communication, March 21, 2011). time and space. He challenges the absoluteness and imag-
Abstract: Students were required to understand and use ined universality of one notion of time and the very idea of
visual anthropological methods as a basis for making being on time (El Guindi 2008:25).
11
their mini-docs, in addition to learning all technical Tom Blakely has been and remains to date the principal
aspects of iMovie and presenting their work at the Human organizer of these conferences. Co-organizers were listed
Diversity Expo I organized every semester from 2004 to or suggested for 198586, Allison Jablonko (personal com-
2007. We also held the first ever Media Teaches/Film Fes- munication, December 2, 2011); 1987, Karl Heider; 2000
tival (using selected work from the following mini-docs) 02, Peter Biella; 2003, Rolf Husmann and Marcelo Fiorini;
by education students (future teachers) on the UWEC 2004, Najwa Adra; and 200608, Joanna C. Scherer. Anne
campus. Zeller, who was president from 2006 to 2007, recalled that
she had been actively participating in the selection of
Spring 2004 presenters both during her presidency and before in order
Koran versus QuRan: Clarifying the View of Islam in the to ensure the proposed timeline for VRC completion, as
Chippewa Valley, Nathan Franklin well as to reduce the impression that all the decisions on
Coming Together: Ethnography of the Unitarian Univer- conference participants were being made by one indi-
salist Church, Kristin Bogyo, Nathan Fritz, Elizabeth vidual, and to continue the noticeable level of student
Hauser, Rebecca Longtin, Andrei Strizek participation (personal communication, November 16,
2011).
Fall 2004 12
For an example, see 1990. AAA Annual Meetings:
En Busca de Trabajo: The Journey of Mexican Workers in
Visual Anthropology Events. Visual Anthropology Review
Eleva, Annie Geurkink, Megan Himmer, Kelly Kavanaugh,
6(2):113.
Nate Klinger 13
Donovans presentation was expanded and became an
Spring 2005 exhibit at the Cesar Chavez Gallery in San Francisco State
GLASS: A Look into the Lives of Queer Youth, Kristin University, entitled Refuse and Refuge: Youth at the Edge
Choudoir, Kelly Matzke, Kim Wagner of Consumer Society (personal communication, April 27,
Cheerleading: Breaking the Stereotype, Jeanna Rotunno, 2011).
14
Pat Emlaw, Helen Frankowiak, Kaela Borgen We were unable to locate any records that would allow us
to include such unofficial presentations. Presentations that
Fall 2005
could not be documented were NOT included in this study,
Defying Deafness: Sara Obermeye-Tuttle, Stephanie Shult,
and the publications based on such presentations were NOT
Kelsey Lundgren, Kayleen Parker, Cori Seveson
listed in the bibliography, filmography, electronic media, or
Vision Quest: The Story of Lisa Johnson, Jesse Brink-
exhibits.
mann, Emily Hoverstein, Jeremy Johnson, Brian Lundgren 15
The creation of a table and the statistics resulting from it
Spring 2007 would not have been possible without the expertise and
On the Margins: Native American Issues at UWEC, Chris- patience of my husband, Noel P. Elliott. I am greatly
tina Wood, Rebecca Phelps, Tim Mulrain, Scott Vogel indebted to him.
16
Jake: An Amish Mans Struggle Between Two Worlds, The gathering of the information for the table (and bib-
Erica Lundberg, Theresa Soules, Elizabeth Soules, Ally liography) was assisted by a number of interns working
Witkowski with me. My thanks to all these interns: Justine Benanty,
9
Blakely to Chalfen, November 8, 1990. Spring 2009; Emma LeClerc, Spring 2009; Savannah Fet-
10
I know African time, I know Polynesian time, I know teroff, Summer 2009; Madeline Johnson, Fall 2009; Mattie
Native American time, and, of course there is Draconian Wong, Spring 2010; Kayleigh Stack, Winter/Spring 2011;
98 VISUAL ANTHROPOLOGY REVIEW Volume 28 Number 2 Fall 2012

Anne Dorland, Fall 2011; Bryanna Goldfinch, Spring plays (personal communication, June 2526, 2012). The
2012; Erin Beasley, Spring 2012; and Amanda Kelch, hypermedia document was not available as of June 1, 2012.
22
Summer 2012. Zeller, Anne. 2009. Reflections I Couldnt Have Done It
17
Some participants considered themselves aligned with mul- Without You. Paper presented at the Annual Society for
tiple fields, or they identified with different fields according Visual Anthropology Visual Research Conference, Philadel-
to the topic discussed, such as cultural anthropologist for phia, November 30December 2; and recording of talk by
one presentation and linguist for another (see C. and M. Flavia de Paula, December 1; and Anne Zeller, interviews
Goodwin as examples). It was impossible for some to make with the author, June 610, 2011.
23
a distinction. Thus, Glen Muschio noted, . . . my degree Anne went on to explain that the upper part of their face
was in cultural anthropology, although it dealt with visual is about the message, and their lower part of their face is
material. By the time I finished my degree I did not feel that about their social selves. Which is really quite interesting in
visual anthropology was significantly distinguished from terms of codification (de Paula recording from December 1,
cultural anthropology (personal communication, August 2009).
24
6, 2011). According to Anne, The components of the movements
18
A problem was encountered in attempting to tally the had to be recognized and then the patterning that I was able
statuses (academic levels or professions) of presenters. The to extract was analyzed by the cultural/social aspects of the
status of those who presented multiple times generally animals. I found patterns in various social categories, but
changed from year to year as their career advanced. A most importantly by kin group membership . . . I did take
presenter may have started as a student and later become an from her [Jablonko] suggestions on the choreometric pat-
instructor, associate professor, etc. Furthermore, the main terns of graphing intensity of movement into a chart that
purpose of compiling status data is to characterize the could visually and graphically represent differences in
academic background for each presentation, not simply to threat patterns between different species (Zeller 2009:4,
track the presenters. Consequently, it is necessary to list the see endnote 22).
25
status of a presenter separately for each participation in a In addition to my earlier comments, I wish to point out
presentation. Most of the presentations were given by a sole that when the journal Visual Studies asked me to review the
presenter; status has been tabulated separately for each of last 20 years of visual anthropology, I did not think that the
these 198 participations. Two co-presenters, adding 52 SVA conference was worth including . . . Should you find as
more participations, gave 26 presentations. Finally, one a result of your survey that some of the presentations from
presentation was given by three co-presenters, adding three the conference were published and that they represent a
more participations. Thus, the total number of times significant contribution to our field, I would urge you to
someone participated, including all presenters for all pre- publish these results as they should be known (Jay Ruby,
sentations, is 198 + 52 + 3 = 253. personal communication, July 4, 2009).
19 26
We have not included in press publications or any dis- When Adras video player refused to work, she broke the
sertations that were not completed by June 1, 2012. usual routine by demonstrating belly dancing herselfa
20
Biella is also working on two films, Maasai Migrants and spirited presentation indeed (Peter Biella, oral communica-
Maasai Migrant Trigger Films, which will be available tion, November 2011).
27
through DER sometime in 2012 but were not available as of Rollwagen is correct in that a number of the conferences
June 1, 2012. had co-organizers, but speaking as one of them, rarely did
21
The hypermedia document will be an interactive version, the co-organizer take a leading role in either the selections
something like a website that has hyperlinks embedded in of the participants, the organization of the final program, or
the document that allow the reader to jump to images or the running of the actual program at the meetings. Those
other objects. Additionally, there is film footage that is responsibilities were deferred to Blakely as the primary
in the document that shows [individuals] performing the organizer.
Society for Visual Anthropologys Visual Research Conference SCHERER 99

Appendix E Europe and Western Russia


ME Middle East
Table of Presenters W Worldwide
U Unknown
Column one of this table alphabetically lists the names Fields
of Anthropology
of the presenters as they appear in the program. Infor- CA Cultural Anthropology
mation for each presenter is given in the next four SocA Social Anthropology
columns: sex, USA/or non-USA, field of anthropology, VA Visual Anthropology
and presenters academic status. Columns six through AA Applied Anthropology
eight give the title of the presentation, year given at the L Linguistics and Body Language (Gestures/
VRC, and the principal geographic area covered by the Signs)
presentation. The remaining eight columns give infor- PA Physical Anthropology
mation about publications that have resulted from or Arch Archaeology
were associated with the presentation. Multiple lines are U Unknown or Not Anthropology
used for presenters who have given more than one
presentation. The entries in the cells of the table have Presenters Status
been abbreviated; the abbreviations are as follows: S Student (includes Undergraduate, Graduate,
Teaching Assistant, Research Assistant)
P Full Professor
Table Abbreviations
AsscP Associate Professor
AsstP Assistant Professor (includes Lecturer,
Geographic Area
Visiting, Adjunct Professor)
NA North America
Ret Retired
SA South America
Res Researcher (post-doctorate fellows)
CAM Central America and Mexico
IS Independent Scholar (may be affiliated with
O Oceania (Micronesia, Polynesia, Melanesia)
an institute, fellow)
SEA Southeast Asia including Indonesia, New
F Filmmaker/Photographer
Guinea, and Philippines
Cu Curator
JK Japan/Korea
U Unknown
C China including Northern Asia
I Indian subcontinent Miscellaneous Abbreviations
A North Africa * Incomplete Information
Afs Sub-Saharan Africa F Female
Au Australia including New Zealand M Male
Table 100

Univ.
Thesis

Article

Comm.
Exhibit

Field of
Geo. Area
Book/Text
Press Book
Unpublished

Male/Female
Dissertation/
Presenters Name

Anthropology

USA/Non-USA
Film and Video

Electronic Media

(Journal or Book)

Presenters Status
in Program Title of Presentation or Subject Year

Adra, Najwa F USA CA AsstP Belly Dancing: Translating the Mundane and Exploring the Exotic 1999 ME Yes
Aguilar, Gaelyn F USA CA S Visual Techniques for Observing, Collection, and Analyzing Folk Dance 1999 E Yes Yes
Aibel, Robert and M USA CA AsstP A Social Approach to Visual Communication: A Community Study 1986 NA Yes Yes
Chris Musello
Ambiee, Jess M USA AA S We Need Doctors, Stat!: Analyzing Physician Volunteerism through Applied 2007 NA Yes
Visual Anthropology
Amidon, Audrey F USA VA Res Re-presenting the Far North: Donald MacMillans Films of Inuit Peoples 2006 NA Yes
Arango, Monica F Non-USA CA AsstP Between Framing and Recalling: A Glimpse of Indigenous Memories (Entre al 2006 SA Yes Yes
L. Espinosa Encuadre y la Remembranza: El Lado Oblicuo de la Memorias Indgenas)
Ardevol, Elisenda F Non-USA CA Res Ethnography of a Learning Process: Ongoing Methodology for Ethnography 1997 E Yes
and Audiovisual Data Construction in Legal Settings
Asch, Timothy* M USA CA P Title Unknown 1985 U
(d. October 3,
1994)
Asch, Timothy* M USA CA P A Photojournalism for Anthropology 1990 W
Askew, Kelly M. F USA CA AsstP Music Videos in Tanzania: An Emergent Genre 2000 Afs Yes
Babb, Seth (see M USA CA S Explicating Graffiti 2001 NA Yes
Gonzalez)
Balikci, Asen M Non-USA CA Ret Visual Anthropology Seminar for the Native Peoples of Siberia 1991 C Yes Yes
Banderali, Clara* F USA CA S The Sorwe in Benin: Towards the Circumcision. . .With Humor 2001 Afs
VISUAL ANTHROPOLOGY REVIEW Volume 28 Number 2 Fall 2012

Barr, Matthew M USA U AsscP Sneads Ferry: Ethnographic Research and Filmmaking in a Traditional 2002 NA Yes
Fishing Village
Becker, Karin F Non-USA CA P Photographs from the Field: A Critical Reevaluation 1997 E Yes
Benthall, Jonathan M Non-USA SocA IS Imagery and Narratives of Disaster and Relief 1992 W Yes
Beresin, Anna F USA VA S Ice Coke, Milk Shake, Foot: Commercial Transformation in an Urban School 1993 NA Yes Yes
Richman Yard
Beresin, Anna F USA VA AsstP Play and Aggression: A Video Ethnographic Analysis of Urban School Yard 1995 NA Yes
Richman Violence
Bessire, Lucas M USA VA S Asking Ayahai: Indigenous Imagery, Shared Anthropology and the 2003 SA Yes
Chronopolitics of Representation
Biella, Peter M USA VA F Maasai Interactive: Research and Teaching with Videodisc and Computer 1991 Afs Yes
Innovations
Biella, Peter M USA VA F/AsstP Visual Anthropology on Computer 1992 Afs Yes
Biella, Peter M USA VA AsstP Practical Interactive Media 1996 W Yes Yes
Biella, Peter M USA VA AsstP Micro, Macro and Emotion in Visual Anthropology 1999 Afs Yes
Biella, Peter M USA VA AsstP Tierney Interactive 2000 SA Yes
Biella, Peter and M USA VA AsscP Dissemination of Interactive Visual Anthropology: CD-ROM and Web 2004 Afs Yes
Kate Hennessy Versions of Visual Anthropology Review
Biella, Peter M USA VA AsscP A DV and a Place to Screen: Participatory Social Action in Visual 2006 NA Yes
Anthropology
Biella, Peter and M USA VA P Maasai Migrants: A Case Study of Collaborative Applied Visual Anthropology 2008 Afs Yes
Shamia Sandles
Bishop, John M USA VA F Managing the Enormity of the Moment in Ethnographic film 1999 Afs Yes
Bishop, John (see M USA VA F The Hampton Jamboree: Reflecting and Remembering Visual Anthropology 2000 SEA/NA Yes
Prins)
Bishop, John and M USA VA F Oh, What a Blow That Phantom Gave Me! Edmund Carpenter on the Culture 2001 SEA/NA Yes Yes
Harald Prins of Illusion
Blakely, Pamela F USA CA S Ethnoaesthetics of Womens Dance Ritual in African Funerals 1989 Afs Yes Yes
Blakely, Thomas M USA CA IS Gaze among the Hemba 1985 Afs Yes
Blakely, Thomas M USA L IS Informant-Guided Microanalysis of Hemba Negotiation 1986 Afs Yes
Blakely, Thomas M USA L IS Visual Means of Description and Analysis of Gesture in Africa 1987 Afs Yes
Blakely, Thomas M USA L IS Verbal and Gestural Art in Central African Negotiation and Conflict 1988 Afs Yes
Resolution
Blakely, Thomas M USA CA AsstP Gardners and strs Interactive Making Forest of Bliss 2001 W Yes
Boonzajer Flaes, M Non-USA CA P Feedback Interviews in the Study of a Dance Tradition on Two Continents 1986 W Yes
Robert M. and
Maarten Rens
Brandon, Sara F USA CA P The Image of Indigenous Women in Brazilian and North American History, 2008 SA/NA Yes
Artwork, Popular Culture, and Society
Braun, Kwame M USA U F Funky Exotic: More Contributions to the Video Glut 1998 Afs Yes
Brodsky, Charlee F USA U F Complementary Perspectives: Anthropologist and Photographer in the Field 1993 NA Yes Yes
(see Schachter)
Byers, Paul* M USA VA AsstP Toward an Advance in the Communications of Science 1985 W
(d. December 31,
2001)
Caldarola, Victor M USA CA S Imaging Process as Ethnographic Inquiry 1987 SEA Yes
Campbell, Craig M Non-USA CA S Agitating Images 2008 C Yes
Carpentier, M Non-USA VA S A New Electronic Mail Journal: A Project of the Commission on Visual 1991 W Yes
Raymond Anthropology
(see Dionne)
Cartwright, F USA AA AsscP The Wizard of Final Cut Pro: Deconstructing the Visual Image via Non-linear 2005 NA Yes
Elizabeth* Digital Editing Systems
Chalfen, Richard M USA VA AsscP The Home Mode in Comparative Perspective 1986 NA Yes
Chalfen, Richard M USA VA AsscP Audio-Visual Extensions of Life: Beginning Research on Home Videotaping 1987 NA Yes
Chalfen, Richard M USA VA AsscP Developing DIVA: Is a Video Journal Really Needed? 1988 NA Yes
Chalfen, Richard M USA VA P The Japanese American Family Album Project 1992 NA Yes Yes
(see Horiuchi)
Chalfen, Richard M USA VA P Studying Japanese Home Media 1996 JK Yes
Chalfen, Richard; M USA VA P Inside Views: The Research and Applied Legacies of John Adairs Film Work 1998 NA Yes
Malcolm Collier
Society for Visual Anthropologys Visual Research Conference

and Amy Donovan


Chio, Jenny F USA CA S Know Yourself: Making the Visual Work in Tourism Research 2007 C Yes
Chio, Jenny F USA CA S The Practice of Photographing Model Minorities in Chinese Tourism 2008 C Yes
Collier Jr., John M USA VA P How to Get Information onto Film and How to Get It Off Again 1986 W Yes
(d. February 25,
SCHERER

1992)
Collier, Malcolm M USA CA AsstP Photographic Exploration of Asian-America 1988 NA Yes Yes Yes
Collier, Malcolm M USA VA AsstP Teaching and Learning with Photographs 1990 W Yes
101
Table Continued 102

Univ.
Thesis

Article

Comm.
Exhibit

Field of
Geo. Area
Book/Text
Press Book
Unpublished

Male/Female
Dissertation/
Presenters Name

Anthropology

USA/Non-USA
Film and Video

Electronic Media

(Journal or Book)

Presenters Status
in Program Title of Presentation or Subject Year

Collier, Malcolm M USA CA AsstP Community Video Projects 1996 NA Yes


and Spencer
Nakasako
Collier, Malcolm; M USA CA AsstP Inside Views: The Research and Applied Legacies of John Adairs Film Work 1998 NA Yes
Richard Chalfen
and Amy
Donovan
Collier, Malcolm M USA VA AsstP Explorations in Building Photographic Communications 2000 W Yes
Collier, Malcolm M USA VA AsstP The John and Mary Collier Collection 2002 NA Yes
and Mari Lyn
Salvador
Congdon, Kristin F USA CA P Folkvine.org: Floridas Arts and Culture on the Web 2005 NA Yes
and Natalie
Underberg
Conklin, Harold M USA CA P Visual Communication of Ethnographic Information 1986 SEA Yes
Coover, Roderick M USA CA IS Visualizing Cultures in the Age of Digital Media and the Harvest in 2000 W/E Yes Yes
Burgundy, Documentary Photography, and the Rhetorics of the Digital
Image
Cox, Rupert M Non-USA CA AsstP Guns, God, and Golden ScreensInvestigating Past and Present Images of 2005 JK Yes
the Namban Foreign Barbarian Phenomenon in Japan
VISUAL ANTHROPOLOGY REVIEW Volume 28 Number 2 Fall 2012

Crowder, Jerome M USA CA AsstP Short Time, Big Story24 Hours of Exploring Life in Puno 2005 SA Yes
Dare, Adrianne F USA VA S Seeing and Saying: Visual Text as Ethnographic Form 1992 NA Yes
Lisa
de Maaker, Erik M Non-USA CA S Integrating Ethnographic Filmmaking and Field Research: Participant 1998 I Yes
Feedback as a Means of Understanding a Ritual and Exploring
Participants Interpretations of Visual Representation of this Ritual
de Maaker, Erik M Non-USA CA S Beyond Mnemonics? Interpreting Explorative Video Registrations of Garo 2003 I Yes
Mortuary Rituals
Dean, Sharon F USA CA Cu Vision, Social Change, and the American West: The Photographs of Andrew 2003 NA Yes Yes Yes
A. Forbes (18621921)
Dennison, Jean F USA CA S Displaced Identity: A Contemporary Indian Artist and the Construct of 2003 NA Yes
Native American Legitimacy
Dennison, Jean F USA CA IS Visualizing Osage Belonging: Utilizing the Science Studies Model 2008 NA Yes
Diawara, Manthia M USA CA P Jean Rouch, African Cinema, and Speaking for the Subject in Visual 1990 A Yes
Anthropology
Dionne, Patrick M Non-USA VA S A New Electronic Mail Journal: A Project of the Commission on Visual 1991 W Yes
and Raymond Anthropology
Carpentier
Donovan, Amy F USA CA S Inside Views: The Research and Applied Legacies of John Adairs Film Work 1998 NA Yes
(see Chalfen)
Donovan, Amy F USA CA S The Labor Memoir Project 2000 NA Yes
El Guindi, Fadwa F USA CA P The Transparency of Veiling 1995 ME Yes Yes
El Guindi, Fadwa F USA CA P My Son Eloped: What Should I Do? 1998 NA Yes
and Dwight
Read
El Guindi, Fadwa F USA CA P 911: A Power Point 2002 NA Yes
El Guindi, Fadwa F USA CA P The Story Behind Visual Anthropology 2004 W Yes Yes
Engelbrecht, F Non-USA CA IS A Film Returns: Experiences with the Film Semana Santa en Patamban, 1992 CAM Yes
Beate Michoacan, Mexico
Engelbrecht, F Non-USA VA IS Teaching Ethnographic Film Summer Schools with 16 mm 1997 E Yes
Beate
Engelbrecht, F Non-USA CA IS Indigenous Filmmaking/Community Filmmaking? Experiences from India 2000 I Yes
Beate
Engelbrecht, F Non-USA VA IS IWF-Digiclip: An Archive Goes Online 2000 W Yes
Beate
Engelbrecht, F Non-USA VA IS Ethnographic Film On-Line: An Update 2002 W Yes
Beate
Erickson, M USA CA P Methods in the Analysis of Interactional Rhythm 1989 NA Yes Yes
Frederick
Farnell, Brenda F USA L S Sign Talk of the Plains: The Visual Record 1989 NA Yes
Farnell, Brenda F USA L AsstP Ethnography Goes Interactive: Plains Indian Sign Talk on CD-ROM 1994 NA Yes Yes Yes
and J. Huntley
Ferrero, Pat F USA U P/F Yield to Total Elation: The Life and Art of Achilles Rizzoli 2000 E Yes
Fink, Zachary M USA U F Dead Birds Remastered: A First Look at a Forthcoming Double DVD 2003 SEA Yes
Commemorating the Films 40th Anniversary Retrospective
Fiorini, Marcelo* M USA U P Mimesis in Cultural Contact, or What Is Being Mediated in the Ethnographic 2003 SA
Film Encounter
Fischer, Michael D. M Non-USA SocA AsscP WWW and Anthropology: Dissemination of Ideas via Cyberspace 1995 W Yes Yes
and Dwight
Read
Freeman, Richard M USA VA S Photography in Ethnography 1999 SA Yes Yes
Freeman, Richard M USA VA IS Towards an Activist Visual Anthropology: Will It Harm the Sheep? 2002 NA/SA Yes
Fuks, Victor M USA CA S Feedback Interviews and Reflexivity in the Anthropological Study of Waipi 1988 SA Yes
Festivals
Garic-Humphrey, F USA VA AsstP Applied Visual Anthropology and Digital Storytelling 2006 NA Yes
Nataa
Givens, David M USA CA IS The Five Hundred Million Year Evolution of Television 1993 W Yes
Givens, David M USA L IS In Search of Gestural Fossils: Our Hands 1996 W Yes
Gonzalez, Marc M USA U S The Art of Graffiti 2000 NA Yes
Society for Visual Anthropologys Visual Research Conference

Tizoc
Gonzalez, Marc M USA U S Explicating Graffiti 2001 NA Yes
Tizoc and Seth
Babb
Goodwin, Charles M USA L P The Interactive Organization of Talk 1989 NA Yes
SCHERER

Goodwin, Charles M USA CA P Seeing a Normal Scene: Culture and the Interpretation of a Video Image in 1990 NA Yes
and Marjorie H. a Multi-Activity Work Setting
Goodwin
103
Table Continued 104

Univ.
Thesis

Article

Comm.
Exhibit

Field of
Geo. Area
Book/Text
Press Book
Unpublished

Male/Female
Dissertation/
Presenters Name

Anthropology

USA/Non-USA
Film and Video

Electronic Media

(Journal or Book)

Presenters Status
in Program Title of Presentation or Subject Year

Goodwin, Charles M USA CA P Visual Representations within Communities of Practice 1994 NA Yes
and Marjorie H.
Goodwin
Goodwin, F USA L P Diversions on Talk: Strategies for Selective Playful Interpretation 1989 NA Yes
Marjorie H.
Goodwin, F USA CA P Seeing a Normal Scene: Culture and the Interpretation of a Video Image in 1990 NA Yes
Marjorie H. a Multi-Activity Work Setting
(see Charles
Goodwin)
Goodwin, Marjorie F USA CA P Visual Representations within Communities of Practice 1994 NA Yes Yes
H. (see Charles
Goodwin)
Gray, Cynthia A. F USA U AsscP Documentary Process and Product as a Tool for Academic Inquiry and 2003 NA Yes
Dialogue
Grimshaw, M USA U P Microanalysis of Sound-Image Records: The Multiple Analysis Project (MAP) 1990 W Yes Yes
Allen D. and Generals and Admirals International Negotiations (GAIN) Research
(d. June 15,
2011)
Guimarin, Amelia F USA U S Illustrating Identity: Body Piercing and Photography 2006 NA Yes
Guthrie, Stewart M USA CA P Seeing the World as Alive and Humanlike 1995 W Yes
VISUAL ANTHROPOLOGY REVIEW Volume 28 Number 2 Fall 2012

Hagens, Bethe F USA CA P Bullroarers in the Celestial Geometric Matrix 2004 W Yes
Hall, Edward T. M USA CA Ret Doing Research on Inter-Ethnic Encounters 1987 U Yes
(d. July 20,
2009)
Hardy, Lisa Jane F USA SocA S Dog 2004 NA Yes
Harriman, F Non-USA VA S Telling Crafty Ethnography 2007 E Yes Yes
Kathryn
Heckman, Andrea F USA CA AsstP Woven Stories: Visual Communication through Andean Textiles and Rituals 2003 SA Yes Yes
Heckman, Andrea F USA CA AsstP Ausangate, Peru and the Pilgrimage of Qoyllur Ritl: From Still Photography 2004 SA Yes
to Documentary Film Making as Visual Communication
Heider, Karl G. M USA CA P Visual Anthropological Approaches to the Ethnography of Emotion among 1986 SEA Yes Yes Yes
the Minangkabau of West Sumatra, Indonesia, 19831986
Heider, Karl G. M USA CA P Emotion and Indonesian Cinema 1987 SEA Yes
Heider, Karl G. M USA CA P Emotion in Indonesia 1988 SEA Yes Yes
Heider, Karl G. M USA CA P Narrative Conventions in Indonesian Cinema 1989 SEA Yes
Heider, Karl G. and M USA CA P Indonesian Houses: Constructing Cultures 1993 SEA Yes
Caroline Vinel
Heider, Karl G. and M USA CA P Videotaping Indonesia for Schoolteachers 1994 SEA Yes Yes
Melissa Lefko
Heider, Karl G. M USA VA P Seeing Anthropology: Building an Introductory Textbook around 1996 W Yes
Ethnographic Films
Henley, Paul M Non-USA VA P Ethnographic Documentary-Making at the University of Manchester 2001 W Yes
Hennessey, Kate F Non-USA VA S Dissemination of Interactive Visual Anthropology: CD-ROM and Web 2004 Afs Yes
(see Biella) Versions of Visual Anthropology Review
Hennessy, Kate F Non-USA VA S Repatriation, Digital Media, and Community Collaboration: The Doig River 2006 NA Yes Yes
First Nation Dane Wajich Website Project
Hermer, Carol F USA CA S Negotiating Old Age 1995 NA Yes
Hermer, Carol F USA CA S The Video Interview as a Communicative Event 1997 NA Yes
Hermer, Carol F USA CA AsstP Hiding Anthropology in an Art Museum 2002 Afs Yes
Hicks, Deborah F USA AA AsscP Discourse, Social Activity, and Learning in the First Grade: A Case Study of 1991 NA Yes
Two Children
Hockings, Paul M Non-USA VA P Visual Anthropology in Yunnan, China 2001 C Yes
Holmes, Amanda F USA VA S The Role of Embodied Communication in Transmitting Ways of Knowing 2004 W Yes Yes Yes
Nature: Yoruba Diaspora in Matanzas, Cuba and Oyatunji Village, South
Carolina
Homiak, John P. M USA CA IS Eye-in-I: Politics of Representation in Rastafari 2001 NA/Afs Yes
Horiuchi, Lynne F USA U IS The Japanese American Family Album Project 1992 JK/NA Yes
and Richard
Chalfen
Huntley, Joan F USA U U Ethnography Goes Interactive: Plains Indian Sign Talk on CD-ROM 1994 NA Yes
(see Farnell)
Husmann, Rolf M Non-USA CA IS Ethnographic Film and the History of Anthropology 1993 W Yes
Husmann, Rolf M Non-USA CA IS Historical Ethnographic Films from Russia and China 1997 C/E Yes
Husmann, Rolf M Non-USA CA IS Visualizing the History of Anthropology 2001 W Yes
Husmann, Rolf M Non-USA VA IS New Activities of the Commission on Visual Anthropology: An Invitation to 2002 W Yes
Participate
Husmann, Rolf M Non-USA CA IS Fascist or Fantastic? Leni Riefenstahl and the Visual Representation of the 2005 Afs Yes
Nuba
Jablonko, Allison F Non-USA CA IS Research Film: Counting & Contexting 1985 SEA Yes
Jablonko, Allison F Non-USA CA IS Tania la Russa: Thoughts on Sharing Student Research Projects 1994 E Yes
Jablonko, Allison F Non-USA CA IS Into the Hands of the Next Generation: A Visual Anthropological Approach 1996 NA Yes
to the Estate of Verda V. Peters, Artist, 19071996
Jablonko, Allison F Non-USA CA IS The Moving Team: A Portion of a Work-in-Progress 1997 NA Yes
Jablonko, Allison F Non-USA CA IS A Record: Purposes and Cross-Purposes 2001 W Yes
Jacknis, Ira M USA CA Cu Visual Anthropology in the Exhibitions of the Hearst Museum of 1995 NA Yes Yes Yes
Anthropology
James-Duguid, F USA CA IS Lumberjacks or Loggers: A Visual Study in Work, Play, and Ethnoaesthetics 1991 NA Yes
Charlene
Jell, George (see M USA U AsstP Ecology and the Oscillation between Melanesian Culture and 2002 SEA Yes
Society for Visual Anthropologys Visual Research Conference

Jell-Bahlsen) Contemporary Architecture in Papua New Guinea


Jell-Bahlsen, F USA CA IS/F Ecology and the Oscillation between Melanesian Culture and Contemporary 2002 SEA Yes
Sabine and Architecture in Papua New Guinea
George Jell
Jhala, Jayasinhji M USA VA AsstP Exploring the Dynamics of the Video Interview 1994 I Yes
SCHERER

Jones, Wes (see M USA U S Are You a Kook?: Seeing Surfing as Activity-Based Visual Signs and Norms 2007 W Yes
Layden)
Kaeppler, Adrienne F USA CA Cu The Writing of Hula Pahu: Hawaiian Drum Dances 1991 O Yes
105
Table Continued 106

Univ.
Thesis

Article

Comm.
Exhibit

Field of
Geo. Area
Book/Text
Press Book
Unpublished

Male/Female
Dissertation/
Presenters Name

Anthropology

USA/Non-USA
Film and Video

Electronic Media

(Journal or Book)

Presenters Status
in Program Title of Presentation or Subject Year

Kendon, Adam M USA L AsstP Sign Languages of Aboriginal Australia: A Visual Exposition 1990 Au Yes Yes
Kendon, Adam M Non-USA L AsstP Towards Some Research on Neopolitan Gesture 1991 E Yes Yes
Kendon, Adam M Non-USA L AsstP Recent Observations on Southern Italian Gesture Use 1993 E Yes Yes
Kendon, Adam M Non-USA L AsstP Spatial Orientation, Posture, and Bodily Maneuver in Conversation 1994 NA/E Yes
Kendon, Adam M Non-USA L AsstP Some Contrasts in Gesticulation between Speakers in Naples and Speakers in 1998 E Yes Yes
Northhamptonshire
Korpan, Cynthia F Non-USA CA S Canadian Indian Folk Drama: Inkameep Plays of Okanagan Legends 2005 NA Yes
Kratz, Corinne A. F USA CA IS Okiek Portraits: Representation, Mediation, and Interpretation of a 1992 Afs Yes Yes
Photographic Exhibition
Kumar, Anita F USA CA S Dancing with Shakti: Performing Nation and Gender in the South Asian 2004 I/NA Yes
Diaspora
Lange, Patricia G. F USA CA AsstP Video Reciprocity: Conversations with YouTubers 2008 W Yes
Layden, Ryan and M USA U S Are You a Kook?: Seeing Surfing as Activity-Based Visual Signs and Norms 2007 W Yes
Wes Jones
Lefko, Melissa F USA U S Videotaping Indonesia for Schoolteachers 1994 SEA Yes
(see Heider)
Legge, L. K. F USA U S Working at Play: Creating the Ultimate Reality 1997 W Yes
Gypsye
Levine, Susan F Non-USA CA AsstP STEPS for the Future: HIV/AIDS and the Emergence of Media Activism in 2002 Afs Yes
Southern Africa
VISUAL ANTHROPOLOGY REVIEW Volume 28 Number 2 Fall 2012

Levine, Suzanne F USA VA S Exploring the Image: Self-Determination and Photographic Representation 1996 CAM Yes Yes Yes
of Self in Disability Culture in Western Mexico
Lindberg, Tess F USA U S Friendly Ghosts 2002 NA Yes
Litten, Laura F USA VA P Sifting through Methodologies: Linking Visual Research Inside and Outside 1998 W Yes
the Academy
Loizos, Peter M Non-USA SocA AsscP Reflections on Ethnographic Film: A Conversation with Peter Loizos 1994 W Yes
Luber, Steve M USA CA S Your Attention Please: Media, Spectacle, and The Complex 2004 NA Yes
Mahiri, Jelani M USA CA Res Facing the Challenges of Inclusion: Documentary Portraiture, Non-formal 2008 SA Yes
Education, Collaboration, and Engagement with At-Risk Youth in So
Paulo, Brazil
Maingard, F Non-USA U AsstP Visually Representing a South African Womens Protest 1995 Afs Yes
Jacqueline
Marion, M USA CA S Presenting the Visual: Considerations from the World of Competitive 2005 W Yes
Jonathan S. Ballroom Dancing
Marion, M USA CA IS Seeing Salsa: Viewing, Aesthetics, and Values 2006 W Yes
Jonathan S.
Martinez, Wilton M USA VA S The Visual Translation of Cultures 1989 W Yes Yes Yes
McDowell, Garrett M USA VA S A Hermeneutic Approach to Anthropological Photography through Web 2004 NA Yes
Alexandrea Media: First Comes Love, Then Comes. . .
Michael, Barbara F USA CA AsstP Behind the Lens: The Anthropologist/ 1996 Afs Yes
Photographer and Social Distance in the Field
Michael, Barbara F USA CA Res Bringing the Field to the Classroom: Visual Ethnography for Observation and 1997 ME Yes
Training
Miller, Laura F USA CA AsstP Viewing Tokyos Corporate Landscape 1993 JK Yes
Mithlo, Nancy F USA CA AsstP Being Indian, Playing Indian: The Visual Legacies of Horace Poolaw and Yeffe 2006 NA Yes
Marie Kimball
Moore, Sadie F USA VA S Filmmaking in Anthropology: Reflections on Building a Website 1999 W Yes
(see Mykytyn)
Moyer, Teresa F USA AA IS Finding Perspective in the Photographs of Archeology in the Images of 2005 NA Yes
Louise Lawler
Muschio, Glen M USA VA S Videotaped Presentations in Civil Litigation 1986 NA Yes
Musello, Chris M USA CA S A Social Approach to Visual Communication: A Community Study 1986 NA Yes Yes
(see
Aibel)
Mykytyn, F USA VA S Filmmaking in Anthropology: Reflections on Building a Website 1999 W Yes
Courtney and
Sadie Moore
Naimark, M USA U Res An Immersive Virtual Environment: About Landscape and Public Gathering 1996 W Yes Yes
Michael Places
Nakasako, Spencer M USA U F Community Video Projects 1996 NA Yes
(see Collier)
Ness, Sally Ann F USA CA AsstP Coming to Terms with a Philippine Ritual Dance: A Study of Performers 1988 SEA Yes
Kinesthetic and Linguistic Knowledge
OBarr, William M. M USA CA P The Advertising of Power: The Representation of Foreigners in 20th Century 1990 NA Yes
American Advertising
ODonnell, Mary F USA CA S Dirt Thats Better Than Dirt: The Symbolism of Sanitary Landfills in 1992 NA Yes
Ann (see Contemporary Society
Welton)
Osborn, J.R. M USA VA AsstP Playing with Signs: The Strategy of Digital Unmixing and the Anthropology 2008 W Yes
of Art
Pandian, Anand M USA VA AsstP Cinematic Landscape as Visual Artifact: On the Production of the Foreign in 2007 I Yes
South Indian Cinema
Paulay, Forrestine F USA U AsstP Cross-Cultural Movement Observations: The Choreometric Baselines 1986 W Yes
Perry, Sara F Non-USA Arch S Prehistoric Re-visions: New Ways of Picturing Archaeological 2005 W Yes Yes
Elizabeth Representations of the First Colonisations of New Territories
Pigliasco, Guido M USA CA S Betwixt and Between Applied Visual Anthropology and Jurisprudence: The 2006 O Yes
Carlo Sawau Project
Piner, Judie F USA AA AsstP Ethnographic Method or Just Plain FunUsing Digital Storytelling in 2005 NA Yes
Anthropological Research
Society for Visual Anthropologys Visual Research Conference

Plath, David M USA CA P On the Shores of Vision: Sea-Gazing in Shima 1990 JK Yes Yes
Plath, David M USA CA Ret Brief Exposures, Long Revisions: Visual and Verbal Self-Recording in 1910 1999 JK Yes
Japan
Plath, David and M USA CA Ret Doing Ethnography in Pre-Camera Japan 2003 JK Yes
R. Toby
SCHERER

Plath, David and M USA CA Ret Cosmic Disc: Translating the Kumano Mandala onto a DVD 2005 JK Yes Yes
R. Toby
Porybna, Tereza F Non-USA CA S Film and Imagination: Representations of Inuit Culture in Visual Media 2007 NA
107
Table Continued 108

Univ.
Thesis

Article

Comm.
Exhibit

Field of
Geo. Area
Book/Text
Press Book
Unpublished

Male/Female
Dissertation/
Presenters Name

Anthropology

USA/Non-USA
Film and Video

Electronic Media

(Journal or Book)

Presenters Status
in Program Title of Presentation or Subject Year

Prins, Harald and M USA CA P The Hampton Jamboree: Reflecting and Remembering Visual Anthropology 2000 SEA/NA Yes
John Bishop
Prins, Harald M USA CA P Oh, What a Blow That Phantom Gave Me! Edmund Carpenter on the Culture 2001 SEA/NA Yes Yes
(see Bishop) of Illusion
Read, Dwight M USA U P Kinship Terminologies and Formal Modeling: A Visual Excursion 1994 W Yes
Read, Dwight M USA U P WWW and Anthropology: Dissemination of Ideas via Cyberspace 1995 W Yes
(see Fischer)
Read, Dwight M USA U P My Son Eloped: What Should I Do? 1998 NA Yes
(see El Guindi)
Rens, Maarten M Non-USA VA F Feedback Interviews in the Study of a Dance Tradition on Two Continents 1986 W Yes
(see Boonzajer
Flaes)
Reynolds, Peter C. M USA CA IS The One-Two Punch: The Ritual Process of Technocratic Culture 1992 W Yes
Rollwagen, Jack R. M USA CA Ret The Modular Information Cluster (MIC) Approach to Anthropological 2006 C Yes
Filmmaking: The Example of the Menu-Driven DVD The Song of the
Grasslands
Roper, Roy M USA SocA S Ethical Images(ing) 1990 W Yes
Ruoff, Jeffrey M USA U Res Around the World in Eighty Minutes: The Travel Lecture Film 1998 W Yes Yes
Salvador, Mari F USA VA P The John and Mary Collier Collection 2002 NA Yes
Lyn (see
VISUAL ANTHROPOLOGY REVIEW Volume 28 Number 2 Fall 2012

Collier)
Sandles, Shamia F USA VA S Maasai Migrants: A Case Study of Collaborative Applied Visual Anthropology 2008 Afs Yes
(see Biella)
Sapir, J. David M USA CA P Speaking of Pictures 1990 W Yes
Sault, Nicole* F USA CA AsstP Soft Breasts and Hard Bodies: Silicone Implants as a Cycle of Mutilation and 1992 NA
Prosthesis

Schachter, Judith F USA CA AsscP Complementary Perspectives: Anthropologist and Photographer in the Field 1993 NA Yes Yes
Modell and
Charlee Brodsky
Scherer, Joanna C. F USA VA Res Microanalysis of Historical Native American Still Pictures 1987 NA Yes
Scherer, Joanna C. F USA VA Res A Preponderance of Evidence: The 1851-52 Omaha Delegation 1997 NA Yes Yes
Daguerreotypes Recovered
Scherer, Joanna C. F USA VA Res The Red Cloud Manikin: An Early Representation of a Plains Indian in a 2001 NA Yes Yes Yes
Museum
Schildkrout, Enid F USA CA Cu Working with the Pros 1995 U Yes
Selby, Lynn F USA U S Critical Consciousness as a Goal of Applied Ethnographic Film 2001 NA Yes
Sheets-Johnstone, F USA U IS Corporeal Representation 1992 W Yes
Maxine
Sherlick, Lucille F USA CA S In Search of Peace: Israeli Womens Voices 2003 ME Yes
Steele, David J. M USA AA AsstP Visual Anthropology in the Clinic: Applied and Research Uses of Videotape 1986 NA Yes
Stern, Linda F USA AA S Visualizing Exile: Video as Testimonio 1996 SA Yes Yes
Stoller, Paul M USA VA P Embodied KnowledgeJean Rouch, Theory, and Ethnographic Film 1991 Afs Yes
Takahashi, Masami M USA CA AsscP Last Kamikaze: Testimonials from WWII Suicide Pilots 2007 JK Yes
Toby, Ronald P. M USA U P Doing Ethnography in Pre-Camera Japan 2003 JK Yes
(see Plath)
Toby, Ronald P. M USA U P Cosmic Disc: Translating the Kumano Mandala onto a DVD 2005 JK Yes
(see Plath)
Torres, Carlos M USA VA S Small Media and Cultural Revitalization: Self-Realization and the Emergent 2008 CAM Yes
Mediascape in Chiapas, Mexico
Tubutis, Todd J. M USA CA IS Filming a Makah Village for Jim Jarmuschs Dead Man 1999 NA Yes Yes
Underberg, F USA CA AsstP Folkvine.org: Floridas Arts and Culture on the Web 2005 NA Yes
Natalie (see
Congdon)
Vinel, Caroline F USA U S Indonesian Houses: Constructing Cultures 1993 SEA Yes
(see Heider)
Walsh, Daniel J. M USA VA S The Palestine Poster: The Graphic Vocabulary of Zionism and Palestinian 2005 ME Yes
Nationalism1900-Present
Ward, Leta F USA CA S Painting the Future and Reflecting the Past: Pride, Solidarity, and Resistance 2000 NA/CAM Yes
in Two Communities
Welton, Marlea F USA CA S Dirt Thats Better Than Dirt: The Symbolism of Sanitary Landfills in 1992 NA Yes
and Mary Ann Contemporary Society
ODonnell
Westmoreland, M USA VA S Lebanese Documentary in the Intersection of Art and (Auto)ethnography 2007 ME Yes Yes
Mark
Wilder, Laena M. F USA U S Portraits from Tanzania 2000 Afs Yes
Williams, Drid F Non-USA SocA AsstP Space, Intersubjectivity and the Conceptual Imperative 1988 W Yes
Williams, Drid F Non-USA SocA AsstP Ceci nest pas un Wallaby This is not a Wallaby 1990 Au Yes
Williams, Joan F USA VA IS A Proposed Classification System for Moving Image Media: Films of New 1985 NA/CAM Yes
Mexico Folk Dances
Wolowic, Jennifer F Non-USA VA S Visually, Orally, Relatively: Collaborative Representations of First Nations 2008 NA Yes Yes
Youth
Wood, William M USA VA P The Visualization of Cultural Process 1988 SEA Yes
Young, Katharine F USA CA IS Narrative Representations of Emotion: Gestures and Expressions 1993 NA Yes
Young, Katharine F USA CA IS The Philosophers Body: Thinking as Corporeal Practice in Somatic 1996 NA Yes
Psychology
Young, Katharine F USA CA IS Time and the Body: Posture, Memory, and Narrative in Somatic Psychology 1998 NA Yes
Young, Katharine F USA CA IS The Memory of the Flesh: The Family Body in Somatic Psychology 1999 NA Yes
Young, Katharine F USA CA IS The Angry Gesture 2008 NA Yes
Society for Visual Anthropologys Visual Research Conference

Zeller, Anne F Non-USA PA AsstP Anthropological Factors in Primate Film Analysis 1986 W Yes
Zeller, Anne F Non-USA PA AsscP Analysis of Grooming Interactions in Four Primate Species 1990 W Yes
Zeller, Anne F Non-USA PA AsscP Analysis of Primate Interaction with Humans in Africa 1994 Afs Yes
Zeller, Anne F Non-USA PA AsscP Verbal and Non-Verbal Cues in Chimpanzee-Human Communication 2000 NA Yes
Zeller, Anne F Non-USA PA AsscP Object Use and Tool Use in Primates 2001 W Yes
SCHERER

Zeller, Anne F Non-USA PA P Object Use, Tool Use, and Tool Making among Three Species of Macaque 2007 W Yes
Monkeys
109
110 VISUAL ANTHROPOLOGY REVIEW Volume 28 Number 2 Fall 2012

Bibliography of Articles, Books, and Theses Becker, Karin


2000 Picturing a Field: Relationships between Visual
Culture and Photographic Practice in a Fieldwork
Adra, Najwa Setting. In Folklore, Heritage Politics, and Ethnic
2005 Belly Dance: An Urban Folk Genre. In Belly Dance: Diversity: A Festschrift for Barbro Klein. Pertti Ant-
Orientalism, Transnationalism, and Harem Fantasy. tonen, ed. in collaboration with Anna-Leena Siikala,
Anthony Shay and Barbara Sellers-Young, eds. Stein R. Mathisen, and Leif Magnusson. Pp. 100121.
Pp. 2850. Costa Mesa, CA: Mazda. Botkyrka, Sweden: Multicultural Centre.
Aguilar, Gaelyn Becker, Karin, and Barbro Klein
2004 Explorations on the Move: Dance in the Republic 2003 Med svenska gon: Ett mngkulturellt odlingsom-
of Macedonia. The Anthropology of East Europe rde 1990 och 2000 [With Swedish Eyes: A Multi-
Review 22(1):115124. cultural Garden Territory 1990 and 2000]. In Stadens
2005 Image(a)nation: Dance and the Parapolitics of Being odlare: Nordiska museet och Skansens arsbok 2003.
in the Republic of Macedonia. Ph.D. dissertation, Christina Westergren, red. s. 151181. Stockholm:
Department of Anthropology, University of South- Nordiska museet.
ern California. Benthall, Jonathan
Aibel, Robert 1993 Disasters, Relief and the Media. London: I. B. Tauris.
1984 Art as Social Communication. Ph.D. dissertation, Reprinted with a new preface. Wantage, England:
Annenberg School for Communication, University Sean Kingston Publishing, 2010.
of Pennsylvania. Beresin, Anna
Ambiee, Jess 1995 Double Dutch and Double Cameras: Studying the
2007 Examining Physicians Motivations to Volunteer: An Transmission of Culture in an Urban School Yard. In
Applied Visual Anthropological Approach. M.A. Childrens Folklore: A Source Book. Brian Sutton-
thesis, Department of Anthropology, University of Smith, ed. Pp. 7591. New York: Garland.
Southern Florida. 1996 Sui Generis: Mock Violence in an Urban School
Arango, Monica L. Espinosa Yard. Childrens Folklore Review 18(2):2535.
2007 Memoria Cultural y el Continuo del Genocidio: Lo 2004 School Power, Childrens Play, and the Timing of
Indgena en Colombia [Cultural Memory and the Recess Violence. In The Cultural Shaping of Vio-
Genocidal Continuum: Indigeneity in Colombia]. lence: Victimization, Escalation, Response. Myrdene
Antpoda, Revista de Antropologa y Arqueologa. Anderson, ed. Pp. 1823. West Lafayette, IN: Purdue
Universidad de los Andes. nmero 005:5373. University Press.
Ardvol, Elisenda 2010 Recess Battles: Playing, Fighting, and Storytelling.
1998 Esto no es una Pelcula: Etnografa y Construccin Jackson: University Press of Mississippi.
de Datos Audiovisuales en la Investigacin Socio- Biella, Peter
jurdica. In Transformaciones del Estado del Derecho 1993a Beyond Ethnographic Film: Hypermedia and
Contemporneo: Nuevas Perspectivas de la Investi- Scholarship. In Anthropological Film and Video in
gacin Socio-jurdica. Encarna Bodelon Gonzlez the 1990s. Jack R. Rollwagen, ed. Pp. 131176.
and Maria Teresa Picont Novales, Coords. Pp. 211 Brockport, NY: The Institute.
230. Madrid: Dykinson, Instituto Internaciontal 1993b The Design of Ethnographic Hypermedia. In
Sociologa Jurdica. Anthropological Film and Video in the 1990s. Jack
Askew, Kelly R. Rollwagen, ed. Pp. 293341. Brockport, NY: The
2006 Images, Documentation, and Imagined Ethnography. Institute.
Michigan Quarterly Review 45(1):2746. 2000 Visual Anthropology in the Plague Year. Anthropol-
2009 Musical Images and Imaginations: Tanzanian Music ogy News 41(9):56.
Videos. In Media and Identity in Africa. Kimani 2008 A DV and a Place to Screen: The Lever of Applied
Njogu and John F. M. Middleton, eds. Pp. 208217. Visual Anthropology. In Audiovizualnaya antropo-
Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press. logia: teoria i praktika. Mezhdunarodnaya nauchno-
Balikci, Asen, and Mark Badger prakticheskaya konferentsii: Sbornik statej. Moskvo:
1992 Siberian Seminar: In the Village of Kazim, Activists Izd. MGU TEIS, 2008. Pp. 160171. [Audiovisual
Learn to Portray Their Own Culture with Video. Anthropology: Theory and Practice. International
Cultural Survival Quarterly 16(1):6871. Scientific and Practical Conference: Collected
1995 A Visual Anthropology Seminar for the Native papers. Moscow: Izd. TEIS, Moscow State University.
Peoples of Siberia and Alaska. In Advocacy and Pp. 160171].
Indigenous Film-making: InterventionNordic 2009 Visual Anthropology in a Time of War. In View-
Papers in Critical Anthropology, No. 1. Birgitte points: Visual Anthropologists at Work. Mary Strong
Markussen and Hans Henrik Philipsen, eds. Pp. and Laena Wilder, eds. Pp. 141180. Austin: Univer-
3954. Hjbjerg, Denmark: Smyrna Press. sity of Texas Press.
Society for Visual Anthropologys Visual Research Conference SCHERER 111

Biella, Peter, Kate Hennessy, and Peter Orth 1993 Reviewing DIVA: A Video Journal for Visual
2004 Essential Messages: The Design of Culture-Specific Anthropology. In The 1992 Yearbook for Visual
HIV/AIDS Media. Visual Anthropology Review Anthropology. Paolo Chiozzi, ed. Pp. 101115. Flo-
19(12):1356. rence, Italy: A. Pontecorboli.
Bishop, John See Prins, Harald. 1995 Japanese American Family Photography. Sensei
2007 Let Me Tell You a Story: Edmund Carpenter as 1(2):2529.
Forerunner in the Anthropology of Visual Media Chalfen, Richard, Clifford R. Barnett, James Faris,
[Also Titled Edmund Carpenter: A Tricksters Explo- Katherine Halpern, Susan McGreevy, and Willow Powers
rations of Culture & Media]. In Memories of the 1999 John Adair 19131987: Work Across the Anthropo-
Origins of Ethnographic Film. Beate Engelbrecht, ed. logical Spectrum. Journal of Anthropological
Pp. 207246. Frankfurt am Main and New York: Research 55:429445.
Peter Lang. Chio, Jenny Treugen
Blakely, Pamela 2009 Landscape of Travel: Tourism, Media and Identity in
1987 Dances of Death: Womens Mourning Performances Southwest China. Ph.D. dissertation, Department of
in Hemba Funerals. In Semiotics 1983: Proceedings Anthropology, University of California, Berkeley.
of the Eighth Annual Meeting of the Semiotic Collier, John Jr., and Malcolm Collier
Society of America, October 69, 1983. Jonathan 1986 Visual Anthropology: Photography as a Research
Evans and John N. Deely, eds. Pp. 477486. Lanham, Method. Albuquerque: University of New Mexico
MD: University Press of America, co-published with Press.
the Semiotic Society of America. Collier, Malcolm
1993 Performing Dangerous Thoughts: Womens Song- 1993 Asians in America: A Reader. Dubuque, IA:
Dance Performance Events in a Hemba Funeral Kendall-Hunt.
Ritual (Republic of Zaire). Ph.D. dissertation, Folk- 2001 Approaches to Analysis in Visual Anthropology. In
lore Institute, Indiana University. Handbook of Visual Analysis. Theo Van Leeuwen
Blakely, Pamela, and Thomas Blakely and Carey Jewitt, eds. Pp. 3560. London: Sage.
1994 Ancestors, Witchcraft, & Foregrounding the 2003 The Vicos Photographs of John Collier, Jr. and
Poetic: Mens Oratory & Womens Song-Dance in Mary E. T. Collier. Visual Anthropology 16(23):159
Hemba Funerary Performance. In Religion in 206.
Africa: Experience & Expression. Thomas Blakely, 2007 The Applied Visual Anthropology of John Collier: A
W.E.A. van Beek, and Dennis L. Thomson, eds. Photo Essay. In Visual Interventions: Applied Visual
Pp. 398442. London: J. Currey. Portsmouth, NH: Anthropology. Sarah Pink, ed. Pp. 2952. Oxford:
Heinemann. Berghahn Books.
Blakely, Thomas 2009 Photographic Exploration of Social and Cultural
1983 To Gaze or Not to Gaze. In Case Studies in the Experience. In Viewpoints: Visual Anthropologists
Ethnography of Speaking: A Compilation of at Work. Mary Strong and Laena Wilder, eds. Pp.
Research Papers in Sociolinguistics. Richard Bauman 1332. Austin: University of Texas Press.
and Joel Sherzer, eds. Pp. 234248. Austin, TX: Congdon, Kristin See Underberg, Natalie.
Southwest Educational Development Laboratory. Coover, Roderick
Blakely, Thomas, and Walter E. A. van Beek 1999 Visualizing Cultures: The Tropologies of Montage
1994 Introduction. In Religion in Africa: Experience and and the Ethnographic Image. Ph.D. dissertation, The
Expression. Thomas Blakely, W.E.A. van Beek, and Committee on the History of Culture, University of
Dennis L. Thomson, eds. Pp. 120. London: J. Currey. Chicago.
Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann. Cox, Rupert
Brodsky, Charlee See Schachter, Judith Modell. 2008a Introduction. In The Culture of Copying in Japan:
Caldarola, Victor Critical and Historical Perspectives. Rupert Cox, ed.
1988 Imaging Process as Ethnographic Inquiry. Visual Pp. 117. London and New York: Routledge.
Anthropology 1(4):433451. 2008b Walking without Purpose: Auditory Journeys
Chalfen, Richard through History and Memory in Nagasaki. Special
1988a Creating DIVA: A Video JournalA Call for Issue, Senses of Spatial Equilibrium and the
Response. Commission on Visual Anthropology Journey: Confounded, Discomposed, Recomposed,
Newsletter May:4448. Journeys. The International Journal of Travel and
1988b Home Video Versions of LifeAnything New? Travel Writing 9(2):7696.
Society for Visual Anthropology Newsletter 2010 Objects That Move: Japanese Namban Screens in
4(1):15. Time, Space, and the Imagination. Revista de
1991 Turning Leaves: The Photograph Collections of Two Histria da Arte. [Journal of the History of Art],
Japanese American Families. Albuquerque: Univer- Instituto de Histria da Arte, Universidade Nova de
sity of New Mexico Press. Lisboa 8:127139.
112 VISUAL ANTHROPOLOGY REVIEW Volume 28 Number 2 Fall 2012

de Maaker, Erik El Guindi, Fadwa, and Wesaqm al-Othman


2000 Integrating Ethnographic Research and Filmmaking: 2010 Dress from the Gulf States, Bahrain, Kuwait, Qatar,
Video Elicitation for a Performance-Oriented Analy- United Arab Emirates. In Berg Encyclopedia of
sis of the Teyyam Ritual. Visual Anthropology World Dress and Fashion, Central and Southwest
13(2):185197. Asia, Vol. 5: Central and Southwest Asia. Gillian
2006 Negotiating Life: Garo Death Rituals and the Trans- Vogelsang-Eastwood, ed. Pp. 245251. Oxford:
formation of Society. Ph.D. proefschrift [disserta- Berg.
tion], Universiteit Leiden. Erickson, Frederick
Dean, Sharon 1992 They Know All the Lines: Rhythmic Organization
2002 Vision, Social Change, and the American West: The and Contextualization in a Conversational Listing
Photographs of Andrew A. Forbes (18621921). Routine. In The Contextualization of Language.
Ph.D. dissertation, Department of Anthropology, Peter Auer and Aldo di Luzio, eds. Pp. 365397.
New School for Social Research, New York. Amsterdam and Philadelphia: John Benjamin.
2004 Weaving a Legacy: Indian Baskets and the People of 2004 Talk and Social Theory: Ecologies of Speaking and
Owens Valley, California. Salt Lake City: University Listening in Everyday Life. Cambridge and Oxford:
of Utah Press. Polity Press.
Dennison, Jean 2009 Musicality in Talk and Listening: A Key Element in
2008 Constituting as Osage Nation: Histories, Citizen- Classroom Discourse as an Environment for Learn-
ships, and Sovereignties. Ph.D. dissertation, Depart- ing. In Communicative Musicality: Exploring the
ment of Anthropology, University of Florida. Basis of Human Companionship. Stephen Malloch
Diawara, Manthia and Colwyn Trevarthen, eds. Pp. 449463. Oxford:
1992 African Cinema: Politics and Culture. Bloomington: Oxford University Press.
Indiana University Press. Farnell, Brenda
Donovan, Amy 1994 Ethno-Graphics and the Moving Body. MAN,
2002 Telling Me Different: An Ethnography of Homeless Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute
Youth in San Francisco. Ph.D. dissertation, Depart- 29(4):929974. Reprinted in Narrative Research
ment of Anthropology, New School for Social Methods. Paul Atkinson and Sarah Delamoat, eds.
Research, New York. Oxford: Bardwell Press, 2006.
El Guindi, Fadwa 1995 Do You See What I Mean? Plains Indian Sign Talk
1999a Veil: Modesty, Privacy, and Resistance. Oxford and and the Embodiment of Action. Austin: University of
New York: Berg. Redistributed. Oxford: Berg. Indo- Texas Press. 2nd edition, University of Nebraska
nesian version: Jilbab: antara kesalehan, keso- Press, 2009.
panan dan perlawanan. Jakarta: Serambi Ilmu Farnell, Brenda, and Joan Huntley
Semesta, 2003. 1995 Ethnography Goes Interactive. Anthropology Today
1999b Veiling Resistance. Fashion Theory: The Journal of 11(5):710.
Dress, Body & Culture 3(1):5180. Fischer, Michael D.
1999c Veiled Men, Private Women in Arabo-Islamic 1995 Desktop tools for the social scientist. In Information
Culture. ISIM Newsletter 4:6. Technology for the Social Scientist. Raymond M.
2004 Visual Anthropology: Essential Method and Theory. Lee, ed. Pp. 1432. London: University College
Walnut Creek, CA: AltaMira Press. London Press.
2005a Regreso al futuro de la Anthropologa Visual [Back Freeman, Richard
to the future of Visual Anthropology]. In Culturas, 2001a Learning to Rebel: Socialist Youth Activism in Con-
poder y mercado [Culture, power and market]. Juan temporary Buenos Aires. Ph.D. dissertation, Depart-
Agudo Turrico, coord. pgs. 5988. X Congreso de ment of Anthropology, University of Illinois at
Antropologa de la FAAEE. Sevilla: Fundacin el Urbana-Champaign.
Monte. 2001b The City as Mise-en-Scne: A Visual Exploration of
2005b Djellaba; Hijab; Kaffiyeh. In Encyclopedia of Cloth- the Culture of Politics in Buenos Aires. Visual
ing and Fashion. Valerie Steele, ed. Vol. 1 Academic Anthropology Review 17(1):3659.
Dress to Eyeglasses, Pp. 369371. Vol. 2 Fads to 2009 Photography and Ethnography. In Viewpoints:
Nylon, Pp. 209213; 293294. Detroit: Charles Visual Anthropologists at Work. Mary Strong and
Scribners Sons. Laena Wilder, eds. Pp. 5275. Austin: University of
2008 By Noon Prayer: The Rhythm of Islam. Oxford: Berg. Texas Press.
2010 Islam and Islamically Correct Dress (Hijab). In Berg Fuks, Victor
Encyclopedia of World Dress and Fashion, Central 1989 Feedback Interviews and Reflexivity: In the Anthro-
and Southwest Asia, Vol. 5: Central and Southwest pological Study of Waiapi Festivals and Musical
Asia. Gillian Vogelsang-Eastwood, ed. Pp. 446448. Performances. Society for Visual Anthropology
Oxford: Berg. Newsletter 5(1):2428.
Society for Visual Anthropologys Visual Research Conference SCHERER 113

Gonzalez, Marc Tizoc of Professional Talk. Allen Grimshaw and David


2002 Representing the Future: The Youth Practice of Graf- Jenness, eds. Pp. 401466. Norwood, NJ: Ablex.
fiti. M.A. thesis, Program in Social Studies (Interdis- Guthrie, Stewart
ciplinary Studies), San Francisco State University. 2000 Bottles Are Men, Glasses Are Women. Anthropology
Goodwin, Charles News 41(4):2021.
1994 Professional Vision. American Anthropologist 2007 Bottles Are Men, Glasses Are Women: Religion,
96(3):606633. Reprinted in Linguistic Anthropol- Gender, and Secular Objects. Material Religion: The
ogy: A Reader. Alessandro Duranti, ed. Pp. 452478. Journal of Objects, Art and Belief 3(1):1433.
Oxford: Blackwell, 2009. Hardy, Lisa Jane
2001 Practices of Seeing, Visual Analysis: An Eth- 2007 Dog Eat Dog: Biological Metaphors, Identity Politics
nomethodological Approach. In Handbook of Visual and Gentrification in Philadelphias Northern Liber-
Analysis. Theo van Leeuwen and Carey Jewitt, eds. ties. Ph.D. dissertation, Department of Anthropology,
Pp. 157182. London: Sage. Temple University.
Goodwin, Charles, and Marjorie H. Goodwin Harriman-Lichti, Kathryn
1996 Seeing as a Situated Activity: Formulating Planes. 2010 An Argument of Images through a Symbolist Lens:
In Cognition and Communication at Work. Y. Experiences of Craft in North-East Scotland. Ph.D.
Engestrm and D. Middleton, eds. Pp. 6195. Cam- dissertation, Department of Anthropology, Univer-
bridge: Cambridge University Press. sity of Aberdeen, Scotland.
Goodwin, Marjorie H. Heckman, Andrea
1995 Co-Construction in Girls Hopscotch. Research on 2003 Woven Stories: Andean Textiles and Rituals. Albu-
Language and Social Interaction 28(3):261282. querque: University of New Mexico Press.
1997 Byplay: Negotiating Evaluation in Storytelling. Heider, Karl G.
In Amsterdam Studies in the Theory and History 1991a Indonesian Cinema: National Culture on Screen.
of Linguistic Science, Series IV: Current Issues in Honolulu: University of Hawaii Press.
Linguistic Theory. No. 128: Social Interaction and 1991b Landscapes of Emotion: Mapping Three Cultures of
Discourse Structures. Gregory R. Guy, Crawford Emotion in Indonesia. New York: Cambridge Uni-
Feagin, Deborah Schiffrin, and John Baugh, eds. Pp. versity Press.
77102. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. 1997 Seeing Anthropology: Cultural Anthropology
1998 Games of Stance: Conflict and Footing in Hopscotch. through Film. Boston: Allyn & Bacon.
In Kids Talk: Strategic Language Use in Later Child- 2011 The Cultural Context of Emotion: Folk Psychology in
hood. S. Hoyle and C. T. Adger, eds. Pp. 2346. New West Sumatra. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
York: Oxford University Press. Heider, Karl G., Pamela Blakely, and Thomas Blakely
2006 The Hidden Life of Girls: Games of Stance, Status, 2007 Seeing Anthropology: Cultural Anthropology
and Exclusion. Oxford: Blackwell. through Film. 4th edition. Boston: Pearson/Allyn &
Goodwin, Marjorie H., and Charles Goodwin Bacon.
2000 Emotion within Situated Activity. In Communica- Heider, Karl G., and Anthony Chan, Irene Diacoyanni-Tarlatzis,
tion: An Arena of Development. Nancy Budwig, Ina Paul Ekman, Wallace Friesen, Rainer Krause,
C. Uzgiris, and James V. Wertsch, eds. Pp. 3354. William LeCompte, Maureen OSullivan, Tom Pitcairn,
Stamford, CT: Ablex. Reprinted in Linguistic Pio Ricci-Bitti, Klaus Scherer, Masatoshi Tomita, and
Anthropology: A Reader. Alessandro Duranti, ed. Pp. Athanase Tzavaras
239257. Oxford: Blackwell, 2001. 1987 Universals and Cultural Differences in the Judg-
Gray, Cynthia A. ments of Facial Expressions of Emotion. Journal
1992 Video as a Tool of Inquiry and Communication: of Personality and Social Psychology 53(4):712
Application in an Urban High School. Ph.D. dis- 717.
sertation, Department of Education, Harvard Heider, Karl G., and Carol Hermer
University. 1995 Films for Anthropological Teaching. 8th edition.
Grimshaw, Allen D., Peter J. Burke, Aaron V. Cicourel, Arlington, VA: American Anthropology Association.
Jenny Cook-Gumperz, Steven Feld, Charles J. Fillmore, Hennessy, Kate
Lily Wong Fillmore, John J. Gumperz, Michael A. K. Halliday, 2009 Virtual Repatriation and Digital Cultural Heritage:
Ruqalya Hasan, and David Jenness The Ethics of Managing Online Collections. Anthro-
1994a Whats Going on Here? Complementary Studies pology News 50(4):56.
of Professional Talk. (Volume Two of the Hermer, Carol
Multiple Analysis Project). Advances in Discourse 1998 Performing Our Pasts: Representing History, Repre-
Processes, 43. Norwood, NJ: Ablex. senting Self. Ph.D. dissertation, Department of
1994b What We Have Learned: Some Research Conclu- Anthropology, University of Washington.
sions and Some Conclusions about Research. In 2004 My Africa, Your Africa: Can Our Africa Exist?
Whats Going on Here? Complementary Studies Visual Anthropology 17(34):387399.
114 VISUAL ANTHROPOLOGY REVIEW Volume 28 Number 2 Fall 2012

2006 Curatorial Authority and Postmodern Representa- 1997 Alcuni modi di usare i gesti nella conversazione. In
tions of African Art. In Exploring World Art. Eric Linguaggio e cognizione. Atti del XXVIII Congresso
Venbrux, Pamela Sheffield Rosi, and Robert L. della Societ di Linguistica Italiana, Palermo 1994.
Welsch, eds. Pp. 357370. Long Grove, IL: Waveland M. Carapezza, D. Gambararra, and F. Lo Piparo, eds.
Press. Pp. 215223. Roma: Bulzoni.
Holmes, Amanda 2004a Gesture: Visible Action as Utterance. Cambridge:
2008 Cuban Voices on Being Cuban and the Future in Cambridge University Press.
Cuba. Transforming Anthropology: Journal of the 2004b Some Contrasts in Gesticulation: A Neapolitan and
Association of Black Anthropologists 16(1):7071. a British Speaker Compared. In The Semantics and
2010 Who Is Nature? Yorb Religion and Ecology in Pragmatics of Everyday Gestures: Proceedings of
Cuba. Ph.D. dissertation, Department of Anthropol- the Berlin Conference, April 1998. Cornelia Mueller
ogy, University of Florida. and Roland Posner, eds. Pp. 173193. Berlin:
Huntley, Joan See Farnell, Brenda. Weidler Buchverlag.
Husmann, Rolf Korpan, Cynthia
2011 Leni Riefenstahl und die Masakin-Nuba: Von der 2009 Authentic Culture: The Inkameep Plays as Canadian
Empathie zur Vermarktung. In Kunst und sthetik im Indian Folk Drama. Electronic M.A. thesis, Depart-
Werk Leni Riefenstahls. Markwart Herzog and Mario ment of Anthropology, University of Victoria. http://
Leis, eds. Pp. 137161. Munich, Germany: edition hdl.handle.net/1828/1756, accessed October 23,
text + kritik. 2012.
Jacknis, Ira Kratz, Corinne A.
1995 The Carvers Art of the Indians of Northwestern 2002 The Ones That Are Wanted: Communication and
California: An Exhibition at the Phoebe A. Hearst the Politics of Representation in a Photographic
Museum of Anthropology. American Indian Art Exhibition. Berkeley: University of California
Magazine 20(4):4455. Press.
Jacknis, Ira, and Isabel Kelly Kumar, Anita
1995 Carving Traditions of Northwest California. Berke- 2005 Dancing with Shakti: Bharatanatyam and Embodied
ley, CA: Phoebe A. Hearst Museum of Anthropology, Performativity within the South Asian Diaspora.
2007. M.A. thesis, Department of Anthropology, University
James-Duguid, Charlene of Southern California.
1996 Work as Art: Idaho Logging as an Aesthetic Moment. Lange, Patricia G.
Moscow: University of Idaho Press. 2010 Achieving Creative Integrity on YouTube: Reciproci-
Jell, George, and Sabine Jell-Bahlsen ties and Tensions. In Enculturation, 8: Video and
2005 From Haus Tambaran to Church: Continuity and Participatory Cultures Issue. Sarah Arroyo and
Change in Contemporary Papua New Guinean Geoffrey Carter, eds. George Mason University,
Architecture. Visual Anthropology 18(5):407437. Virginia. http://enculturation.gmu.edu/achieving-
Jhala, Jayasinhji creative-integrity, accessed June 1, 2012.
2007 From Privy Purse to Global Purse: Maharaja Gaj Levine, Susan
Singhs Role in the Marketing of Heritage and Phi- 2003 Documentary Film and HIV/AIDS: New Directions
lanthropy. In Raj Rhapsodies: Tourism Heritage and for Applied Visual Anthropology in Southern Africa.
the Seduction of History. Carol Henderson and Visual Anthropology Review 19(12):5772.
Maxine Weisgrau, eds. Pp. 141157. Aldershot, UK: 2007a Documentary Film Matters: The Steps for the
Ashgate. Future Media Advocacy Project in Southern Africa.
Kaeppler, Adrienne, and Judy Van Zile Critical Arts 21(2):234249.
1993 Hula Pahu: Hawaiian Drum Dances, Vol. 1. Hono- 2007b Steps for the Future: HIV/AIDS, Media Activism
lulu, HI: Bishop Museum Press. and Applied Visual Anthropology in Southern
Kendon, Adam Africa. In Visual Interventions: Applied Visual
1988 Sign Languages of Aboriginal Australia: Cultural, Anthropology. Sarah Pink, ed. Pp. 7189. Oxford
Semiotic, and Communicative Perspectives. Cam- and New York: Berghahn Books.
bridge: Cambridge University Press. Levine, Suzanne
1992 Some Recent Work from Italy on Quotable Gestures 1995 Return to Life: Photos from the PROJIMO Centre de
(Emblems). Journal of Linguistic Anthropology Rehabilitacion. New Mobility 6(27):4849.
2(1):92108. Levine, Suzanne, ed. and photographer
1995a Andrea De JorioThe First Ethnographer of 1996 Volver a Vivir/Return to Life. Berkeley, CA: Chardon
Gesture? Visual Anthropology 7(4):371390. Press.
1995b Gestures as Illocutionary and Discourse Structure Loizos, Peter
Markers in Southern Italian Conversation. Journal 1993 Innovation in Ethnographic Film. Chicago: Univer-
of Pragmatics 23(3):247279. sity of Chicago Press.
Society for Visual Anthropologys Visual Research Conference SCHERER 115

Marion, Jonathan S. 2009 Sights of Invention: Deconstructing Depictions of


2008 Ballroom: Culture and Costume in Competitive the Earliest Colonisations of Australia and Oceania
Dance. Oxford: Berg. in the Academic Archaeological Literature. Archaeo-
Martinez, Wilton logical Review from Cambridge 24(1):109130.
1990a Critical Studies and Visual Anthropology: Aberrant Pigliasco, Guido C.
vs. Anticipated Readings of Ethnographic Film. 2007 Visual Anthropology and Jurisprudence: The Sawau
Commission on Visual Anthropology Review Project. (Society for Visual Anthropology column).
Spring:3447. Anthropology News 48(1):65.
1990b Ethnographic Film Spectatorship and the Crisis of 2009 Intangible Cultural Property, Tangible Databases,
Representation in Visual Anthropology. M.A. Visible Debates: The Sawau Project. International
thesis, Department of Anthropology, University of Journal of Cultural Property 16(3):255272.
Southern California. Plath, David, and Jacquetta Hill
1992 Who Constructs Anthropological Knowledge? 1988 Fit surroundings: Japanese shellfish divers and the
Toward a Theory of Ethnographic Film Spectator- artisan option. Social Behaviour 3(2):149159.
ship. In Film as Ethnography. D. Turton and P. 1998 Moneyed knowledge: How women become commer-
Crawford, eds. Pp. 130161. Manchester, UK: cial shellfish divers. In Learning in Likely Places,
Manchester University Press. Varieties of Apprenticeship in Japan. John Single-
Miller, Laura ton, ed. Pp. 211225. Cambridge: Cambridge Univer-
1995 Two Aspects of Japanese and American Co-Worker sity Press.
Interaction: Giving Instruction and Creating Prins, Harald, and John Bishop
Rapport. Journal of Applied Behavioral Science 2002 Edmund Carpenter: Explorations in Media &
31(2):141161. Anthropology. Visual Anthropology Review 17(2):
Modell, Judith See Schachter, Judith Modell. 110140.
Musello, Christopher 2007 Let Me Tell You a Story: Edmund Carpenter as
1986 Family Houses and Social Identity: Communica- Forerunner in the Anthropology of Visual Media
tional Perspectives on the Homes of Ridge County. [Also Titled Edmund Carpenter: A Tricksters Explo-
Ph.D. dissertation, Annenberg School for Communi- rations of Culture & Media]. In Memories of the
cations, University of Pennsylvania. Origins of Ethnographic Film. Beate Engelbrecht, ed.
Naimark, Michael Pp. 207246. Frankfurt am Main and New York:
1997a A 3D Moviemap and a 3D Panorama. Theme issue, Peter Lang.
Stereoscopic Displays and Virtual Reality Systems Prins, Harald, and Jay Ruby, eds.
IV. Scott Fisher, John Merritt, and Mark Bolas, eds. 2002 Introduction. Theme Issue, North American Contri-
Proc. SPIE 3012: 297305. butions to the History of Visual Anthropology.
1997b Artists as Researchers: Some Personal Observa- Visual Anthropology Review 17(2):34.
tions. In Art@Science. C. Sommerer and L. Read, Dwight
Mignonneau, eds. Pp. 123132. Vienna and New 2006 Kinship Algebra Expert System (KAES): A Software
York: Springer Press. Implementation of a Cultural Theory. Social Science
2005 Two Unusual Projection Spaces. Presence 14(5):597 Computer Review 24(1):4367.
605. Reynolds, Peter C.
OBarr, William M. 1991 Stealing Fire: The Atomic Bomb as Symbolic Body.
1994 Culture and the Ad: Exploring Otherness in the Palo Alto, CA: Iconic Anthropology Press.
World of Advertising. Boulder, CO: Westview Press. Ruoff, Jeffrey
Osborn, J.R., and Bennetta Jules-Rosette 2002 Around the World in Eighty Minutes: The Travel
2009 Unmixing the Chaos: African and Diasporic Art Lecture Film. Visual Anthropology 15(1):91114.
on Display in Global Context. Theme Issue, Inter- 2006 Show and Tell: The 16mm Travel Lecture Film.
rogating African Modernity: Art, Cultural Politics, In Virtual Voyages: Cinema and Travel. Jeffrey
and Global Identities. Critical Interventions: A Ruoff, ed. Pp. 217237. Durham, NC: Duke Univer-
Journal of African Art History and Visual Culture sity Press.
3/4:2137. 2007 Le tour du monde en quatre-vingts minutes: les
Pandian, Anand films-confrences. In Cinma et voyage actes des
2011 Landscapes of Expression: Affective Encounters in colloques internationaux dAix-en-Provence Cinma
South Indian Cinema. Cinema Journal 51(1):5074. et voyage 1 (7 et 8 novembre 2003) Voyage et
Perry, Sara Elizabeth aventure intrieure, Cinma et voyage 2 (4 et 5
2006 Picturing Prehistory Within (and Without) Science: novembre 2004) Imaginaires et figures du voyage
De-Constructing Archaeological Portrayals of the organises par le LESA, Laboratoire dtudes en Sci-
Peopling of New Territories. M.A. thesis, Department ences de lArt. Ren Gardis, ed. Pp. 145154. Paris:
of Anthropology, University of Victoria. Harmattan.
116 VISUAL ANTHROPOLOGY REVIEW Volume 28 Number 2 Fall 2012

Schachter, Judith Modell, and Charlee Brodsky Westmoreland, Mark


1994 Envisioning Homestead: Using Photographs in 2008 Crisis of Representation: Experimental Documentary
Interviewing (Homestead, Pennsylvania). In Interac- in Postwar Lebanon. Ph.D. dissertation, Department
tive Oral History Interviewing. Kim Rogers and Eva of Anthropology, The University of Texas at Austin.
McMahan, eds. Pp. 141161. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum. 2009 Post-Orientalist Aesthetics: Experimental Film and
Schachter, Judith Modell, with Charlee Brodsky Video in Lebanon. Special Issue, After Post Colo-
(photographer) nialism? Maia Dauner and Cynthia Foo, guest
1998 A Town without Steel: Envisioning Homestead. eds. Invisible Culture: An Electronic Journal for
Pittsburgh, PA: University of Pittsburgh Press. Visual Culture 13:3757. http://www.rochester.edu/
Scherer, Joanna C. in_visible_culture/Issue_13_/index.html, accessed
1988 The Public Faces of Sarah Winnemucca. Cultural October 23, 2012.
Anthropology: Journal of the Society for Cultural Williams, Drid
Anthropology 3(2):178204. 1995 Space, Intersubjectivity and the Conceptual
1997 A Preponderance of Evidence: The 1852 Omaha Imperative: Three Ethnographic Cases. In Human
Indian Delegation Daguerreotypes Recovered. Action Signs in Cultural Context: the Visible and
Nebraska History 78(3):116121. the Invisible in Movement and Dance. Brenda
Scherer, Joanna C., and Vicki Simon Farnell, ed. Pp. 4481. Metuchen, NJ: The Scare-
2005 Red Clouds Manikin and His Uncles Shirt: Histori- crow Press.
cal Representation in the Museum as Seen Thru 1996 Ceci nest pas un Wallaby. Visual Anthropology
Photo Analysis. In The People of the Buffalo, Vol. 2. 8(24):197217.
The Plains Indians of North America. Essays in Wolowic, Jennifer
Honor of John C. Ewers. Colin Taylor and Hugh 2008 Research Tools or Collaborative Toys? Participatory
Dempsey, eds. Pp. 88103. Wyk auf Foehr, Germany: Photography and Video with First Nations Youth.
Tatanka Press. M.A. thesis, Department of Anthropology, University
Sheets-Johnstone, Maxine of British Columbia.
1990 The Roots of Thinking. Philadelphia, PA: Temple Wood, William
University Press. 1989 The Visualization of Cultural Process. The Society
Sherlick, Lucille for Visual Anthropology Newsletter 5(1):2933.
2003 In Search of Peace: Israeli Womens Voices. Ph.D. Young, Katharine
dissertation, Department of Anthropology, State 2000 Gestures and the Phenomenology of Emotion in
University of New York, Buffalo. Narrative. Semiotics 131(12):79112.
Stern, Linda A. 2002 The Memory of the Flesh: The Family Body in
1999 Boundaries of Exile, Thresholds of Return: An Eth- Somatic Psychology. Body & Society 8(3):2547.
nography of Refugee Transformation. M.A. thesis, Zeller, Anne
Department of Anthropology, University of Florida. 1992 Grooming Interactions over Infants in Four Species
Stoller, Paul of Primates. Visual Anthropology 5(1):6386.
1992 The Cinematic Griot: The Ethnography of Jean
Rouch. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Torres, Carlos
2010 Torches for a New Dawn, Recomposition and Renais- Filmography
sance: Maya Media Production in San Cristobal de Las
Casas, Mexico. Ph.D. dissertation, Department of Aibel, Robert, Ben Levin, Chris Musello, and Jay Ruby
Anthropology, University of Colorado at Boulder. 1984 A Country Auction: The Paul V. Leitzel Estate Sale.
Tubutis, Todd J. 56 min. DVD. University Park, PA: Penn State Media
1998a Filming a Makah Village for Jim Jarmuschs Dead Sales.
Man. M.A. thesis, Department of Anthropology, Amidon, Audrey
University of British Columbia. 2010 The Far North: A Donald MacMillan Lecture Film.
1998b Film Review: Dead Man. Visual Anthropology 120 min. DVD, reconstructed with sound track of
11(3):249251. MacMillans 1959 lecture. Brunswick, ME: Peary-
Underberg, Natalie, and Kristin Congdon MacMillan Arctic Museum, Bowdoin College.
2007 Folkvine.org: Ethnographic Storytelling in Folk Balikci, Asen, Mark Badger, and Claudia Clark
Art Web Design. Visual Anthropology Review 1992 Siberia through Siberian Eyes. 52 min. VHS. Fair-
23(2):151161. banks: University of Alaska and KUAC-TV.
Ward, Leta Barr, Matthew
2002 Painting the Future and Reflecting the Past: Mural 2006 Wild Caught: The Life and Struggles of an American
Art in Two Communities. M.A. thesis, Department of Fishing Town. 90 min. DVD. Winston-Salem, NC:
Anthropology, San Francisco State University. Unheard Voices Project.
Society for Visual Anthropologys Visual Research Conference SCHERER 117

Bessire, Lucas Nakasako, Spencer


2005 Asking Ayahi. 42 min. DVD. Watertown, MA: Docu- 1998 Kelly Loves Tony: A Video Diary by Kelly Saeteurn
mentary Educational Resources. and Tony Saelio. 57 min. DVD. Wendy Wank and
Bishop, John Don Ahrens, eds. Muong Saeteurn, Mien transla-
2006 Gaishay Returns to !ao#a. 5 min. DVD. John Bishop tion. San Francisco: Center for Asian American
Short Films. Shot 1989, edited 2006. Peter Baker, Media.
sound. Watertown, MA: Documentary Educational 2003 Refugee. 63 min. DVD. Louella Lee and Glades
Resources. Perreras, executive producers. Jannette Eng,
Bishop, John, Nicholas Hormann, Harald Prins, producer. Aram Collier and Mike Siv, eds.
Adelaide De Menil, Edmund Carpenter San Francisco: Center for Asian American
2003 Oh, What a Blow That Phantom Gave Me! Edmund Media.
Carpenter. 54 min. DVD. Portland, OR: Media 2003 Who I Became. 18 min. VHS. Aram Collier and
Generation. Michael Siv, co-dirs. Produced for the Matters of
Boonzajer Flaes, Robert M. Race series (Orlando Bagwell, Executive Producer)
1986 See Rens, Maarten. broadcast on PBS, September 2003. 2-minute
Conklin, Harold excerpt available online: http://www.pbs.org/
1957 Hanuno, Yagaw Region, Southern Mindoro Island, mattersofrace/prog4-2.shtml, accessed May 23,
Philippines. 18 min. 16 mm film, available as DVD. 2012.
University Park, PA: Penn State Media Sales. Plath, David
Ferrero, Pat 1999 Makikos New World. 57 min. DVD. Chet Kincaid,
2001 Yield to Total Elation: The Life & Art of Achilles dir. Media Production Group. Urbana-Champaign:
Rizzoli. 50 min. DVD/VHS. New York: New Day University of Illinois.
Films. 2002 Preaching from Pictures: A Japanese Mandala.
Fink, Zachary 37 min. VHS. Media Production Group. Asian
2004 Dead Birds. 83 min. 2-disc DVD remastered with Educational Media Service. Urbana-Champaign:
extra features. Robert Gardner, original producer/ University of Illinois. Re-released in 2006. 157 min.
filmmaker. Harvard Film Study Center. Watertown, DVD with interactive features. Ronald P. Toby,
MA: Documentary Educational Resources. associate producer. Murayama Masami, director.
Garic-Humphrey, Nataa, ed. Keiji Yamaya, videographer. Kuroda Hideo, David
2010 NuWuuyoktiqee, I Have Grown Up. 6 min. DVD. Plath, and Ronald Toby, writers. Purchase online:
Anita Poleahla and Ferrell Secakuku, dirs. Polacca, Amazon.com.
AZ: Mesa Media. Plath, David and Jacquetta Hill
Heckman, Andrea, David Aubrey, Tad Fettig, Barrett Martin, 1993 Fit Surroundings. 30 min. DVD. Watertown, MA:
and Judy Walgren Documentary Educational Resources.
2006 Ausangate. 61 min. DVD. Watertown, MA: Docu- Prins, Harald
mentary Educational Resources. 2003 See Bishop, John.
Heider, Karl G., and Melissa Lefko Rens, Maarten, and Robert M. Boonzajer Flaes
1994 Teaching Videos from Java and Bali. 242 min. VHS. 1986 Polka: Roots of Mexican Accordion Playing in South
Columbia: Audiovisual Anthropology Lab, Univer- Texas and North Mexico. 50 min. DVD. London:
sity of South Carolina. Royal Anthropological Institute. Re-released in 2001
Kendon, Adam and 2007.
1990 Sign Languages of Aboriginal Australia: A Rollwagen, Jack
visual exposition. 48 min. Windows Media File, 2011 China Odyssey: Song of the Grasslands: Ethnicity,
probably available on DVD. Canberra: Australian Identity, Economic Development, Culture Change
Institute of Aboriginal and Torres Straits Islander and Music among the Horquin Mongols of Eastern
Studies. Inner Mongolia, China. DVD. Brockport, NY: The
Lefko, Melissa Institute.
1994 See Heider, Karl G. Stern, Linda
Maingard, Jacqueline, Sheila Meintjes, and Heather Thompson 1996 Testimonios. Hi8 video. Gainesville: University of
1995 To Walk Naked. 12 min. DVD. New York: Third Florida, Department of English.
World Newsreel. Takahashi, Masami
Martinez, Wilton 2007 The Last Kamikaze: Testimonials from WWII Suicide
1990 Viewing Cultures. 57 min. M.A. Research Video Pilots. 55 min. DVD. Watertown, MA: Documentary
Thesis. Los Angeles: University of Southern Califor- Educational Resources.
nia, Department of Anthropology. Wolowic, Jennifer
Musello, Chris 2008 For Our Street Family. 34 min. DVD. Watertown,
1984 See Aibel, Robert. MA: Documentary Educational Resources.
118 VISUAL ANTHROPOLOGY REVIEW Volume 28 Number 2 Fall 2012

Zeller, Anne Givens, David B.


1994 Primate-Human Interactions in Africa. 11 min. 2009 The Nonverbal Dictionary of Gestures, Signs,
DVD. Watertown, MA: Documentary Educational & Body Language Cues. http://www.center-for-
Resources. nonverbal-studies.org/6101.html (accessed October
1997 Images from the Field: Baboons. 24 min. DVD. 25, 2012).
Watertown, MA: Documentary Educational Hennessy, Kate, and Amber Ridington
Resources. 2008 Building Indigenous Agency through Web-Based
1997 Primate Patterns II. 31 min. DVD. Watertown, MA: Exhibition: Dane-WajichDane-zaa Stories and
Documentary Educational Resources. Songs: Dreamers and the Land. In Museums and
2001 Chimpanzees Today. 36 min. DVD. Watertown, MA: the Web 2008: Proceedings, Toronto: Archives &
Documentary Educational Resources. Museum Informatics. J. Trant and D. Bearman,
2008 Macaques. 15 min. DVD. Watertown, MA: Docu- eds. http://www.archimuse.com/mw2008/papers/
mentary Educational Resources. ridington/ridington.html (accessed October 25,
2012).
Holmes, Amanda D.
Electronic Media 2008 Yoruba Religion and Ecology in Cuba. Forum on
Religion and Ecology Newsletter. December. http://
Arango, Monica L. Espinosa fore.research.yale.edu/publications/newsletters/
2006 Entre El Encuandre y La Remembranza: El Lado December2008.html (accessed October 25, 2012).
Oblicuo de Las Memorias Indgenas (Between Piner, Judie
Framing and Recalling: A Glimpse of Indigenous 2006 Expressions of the Land: Personal Narrative
Memories). 14 mm. Centro para La Investigatin y Describing Verde Valley Land Use Issues. http://
La Creation, Universidad de Puerto Rico en Arecibo. www.landuse.roadmarks.net (accessed October 25,
http://antropolitica.uniandes.edu.co/ 2012).
spip.php?rubrique20, Scherer, Joanna
http://antropolitica.uniandes.edu.co/spip.php?site2, 2003 Red Clouds Manikin and His Uncles Shirt:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y8kRQDw8yS0 Historical Representation in the Museum as Seen
(accessed October 25, 2012). through Photo Analysis. http://anthropology.si.edu/
Biella, Peter redcloud/ (accessed October 25, 2012).
2000 Public Email on the Ax Fight Scandal. http:// 2012 A Preponderance of Evidence: The 1852 Omaha
online.sfsu.edu/~biella/biella2000a.html (accessed Indian Delegation Daguerreotypes Recovered. http://
October 25, 2012). www.indiana.edu/~aisri/Preponderance/
Biella, Peter, Napoleon A. Chagnon, and Gary Seaman nmnh_Preponderance_6_Article2.html (accessed
1997 Yanomam Interactive: The Ax Fight (book and October 25, 2012).
CD-ROM). Fort Worth, TX: Harcourt Brace. Scherer, Joanna, with Frank Goodyear
Collier, Malcolm, ed. 2003 Red Cloud Seen through Photographs. http://
2009 Asian American Experience: Personal Accounts with anthropology.si.edu/redcloud/bio_slideshow
Associated Essays. San Francisco State University. (accessed October 25, 2012).
http://online.sfsu.edu/~mcollier/page3.html Walsh, Daniel J.
(accessed October 25, 2012). 2009 The Palestine Poster Project Archives. http://
Coover, Roderick www.palestineposterproject.org (accessed October
2003 Cultures in Webs: Working in Hypermedia with the 25, 2012).
Documentary Image (CD-ROM) for Macintosh or
Windows. Watertown, MA: Eastgate Systems.
Farnell, Brenda
1995 Wiyuta: Assiniboine Storytelling with Signs (CD- Exhibits
ROM). Accompanying book, Do You See What I
Mean: Plains Indian Sign Talk and the Embodiment Dean, Sharon E. Weaving a Legacy: Indian Baskets and
of Action. Austin: University of Texas Press. the People of Owens Valley California. Cleveland Museum of
Fischer, Michael D. Natural History, Cleveland, then a traveling exhibit. Fall
1998 Counting Things and Interpreting Ideas. Anthropo- 2000Winter 2002.
logical Conventions in the Use of Hard versus Harriman, Kathryn. Naff? An Exploration of Value.
Soft Models. In Postmodern Applications to Marischal Museum at the University of Aberdeen, Scotland,
Natural Resources Development. M. Fischer, ed. United Kingdom, October 2007January 2008.
CSAC Monographs, Canterbury. http://lucy.kent. Heckman, Andrea. Andean Textiles and Rituals as Cul-
ac.uk/Postmodern/AAS97_Fischer_1.html (accessed tural Communication. Maxwell Museum of Anthropology,
October 25, 2012). University of New Mexico, Albuquerque, 200001.
Society for Visual Anthropologys Visual Research Conference SCHERER 119

Homiak, Jake. Discovering Rastafari! National Museum JuneNovember 1990; University of Pennsylvania, Philadel-
of Natural History, Smithsonian Institution, Washington, DC, phia, FebruaryMarch 1991; Michigan State University
November 2007November 2011. Museum, East Lansing, FebruaryMay 1993; Michael C. Carlos
Horiuchi, Lynne. Japanese American Family Albums: A Museum, Emory University, Atlanta, SeptemberJanuary
Los Angeles Family. The Japanese American Culture and 1998.
Community Center, Los Angeles, 1983. Levine, Suzanne. Spirit of Survival. Hohenthal Gallery,
. Turning Leaves: Photographs from Japanese Treganza Anthropology Museum, San Francisco State Univer-
American Families in Gallup, New Mexico. Maxwell Museum sity, SeptemberOctober 1994.
of Anthropology, University of New Mexico, Albuquerque, Naimark, Michael. Be Now Here. Yerba Buena Center
1984. for the Arts, San Francisco, 19951996; SIGGRAPH 96, New
. Turning Leaves: The Family Photograph Collec- Orleans, 1996; Creative Time, New York, 1997; International
tions of Two Japanese American Families. Lowie Museum of Film Festival Rotterdam, Netherlands, 1998; The Tech
Anthropology, University of California, Berkeley, then a trav- Museum of Innovation, San Jose 1998; The Presidio, San
eling exhibit, 198691. Francisco International Film Festival and San Francisco
Jacknis, Ira, George Blake (Hupa/Yurok), and Frank Gist Museum of Modern Art, 2001; Zentrum fur Kunst und Medi-
(Yurok). The Carvers Art of the Indians of Northwestern entechnologie (ZKM), Karlsruhe, Germany, 200203; Kiasma
California. Phoebe A. Hearst Museum of Anthropology, Ber- Museum of Contemporary Art, Helsinki, Finland, 2003; Alyce
keley, August 1995February 1996. de Roulet Williamson Gallery, Art Center College of Design,
Jacknis, Ira, with Therese Babineau. Field Sites: Portraits Pasadena, 2005; Helen Lindhurst Fine Arts Gallery, Roski
of UC-Berkeley Anthropologists, 19011995. Phoebe A. School of Fine Arts, University of Southern California, Los
Hearst Museum of Anthropology, Berkeley, November 1995 Angeles, 2008.
March 1996. Scherer, Joanna C. Picture Puzzles: Red Clouds Manikin
Kratz, Corinne. Okiek Portraits. National Museum, and His Uncles Shirt. Smithsonian Institution, National
Nairobi, Kenya, AugustOctober 1989; University of Texas at Museum of Natural History, Washington, DC, 200204.
Austin, November 1989; Sixth International Conference on Wilder, Laena. Portraits of Tradition: Portraits of
Hunting and Gathering Societies, Fine Arts Gallery, University Change: Featuring the Photography of Laena Wilder from
of Alaska, Fairbanks, MayJune 1990; National Museum of Tanzania, Africa. Chapel Hill Museum, Chapel Hill,
Natural History, Smithsonian Institution, Washington, DC, SeptemberNovember 2002.

You might also like