Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Anatomy
Title: Effect of sodium fluoride on the grey matter of spinal cord in the albino rat
and the protective role of green tea extract
1. Is the title clear and informative?
Yes, because the important contents in the paper was already summarized in the
title.
Abstract
2. Is there background information leading up to a statement of the problem?
Yes, there is a background information leading up to the statement of the
problem. In the paper they stated that researchers over the world felt that there is
a need to study the effects of fluorides on the other tissues of the body including
CNS, as the fluorides are known to cross blood brain barrier.
Introduction
6. Is there sufficient background information to understand the significance of the
problem?
Somehow they managed to give us sufficient information to understand the
significance of the problem. But, they should also cite some journals about the
effect of sodium chloride on the grey matter and the extract used was other plant.
7. Is the problem, objective, question, or hypothesis clearly stated?
Yes, but they should also include other plants other than the green tea. Because
green tea extract is widely used and there are plenty of plants to be extracted
that are rich in flavonoids such as catechins. In searching different extract other
than green may also give us another significance and may inspire others to
search for new medicinal plants.
Methods
8. Is the experimental procedure clearly described? Could an individual not familiar with
the lab understand the procedure?
It was clearly described. If a non-medicine field student will be reading this then
he or she will not understand the methodology. Understanding the protocols in a
research is a must to study because it is one of the most important part of a
research.
Results
10. Are the results described in a narrative fashion?
The results were described in order and photomicrographs are also included.
12. Are the results presented in a clear and logical fashion (general to specific)
Yes. They clearly stated the results from general to specific.
Discussion
20. Does the discussion show analysis, interpretation, and comparison of data
collected?
Yes, the researchers showed us clear analysis, interpretation and comparison of
the data they collected.
24. Does the discussion draw conclusions from the data analyzed?
They stated that they had many attempts for them to explain the changes of their
data.
Literature cited
25. Is literature cited appropriately throughout the report?
Yes it is clear and all of the literature cited are related to the research. They didnt
cite an article that was too old or published a very long time ago.
26. Are there at least five references, three of which are primary literature?
Yes there is, actually, they included numerous related literature which is a good
thing for us to understand their study and for additional purpose.
Overall
28. Is the writing clear, concise, and logical?
Yes it is clear and gave a lot of information clearly and in a few words, brief but
comprehensive.