[ 2 ] Jobsite details

DEMO product Comparison product

Brand DOOSAN Brand _________________________

Type of product WEX Type of product BHL

Model name / year DX55W / 2012 Model name / year _________________________

Operating hour _________________________ Operating hour _________________________

Type of work _________________________ Type of work _________________________

Type of Material _________________________ Type of Material _________________________

Working hour / day _________________________ Working hour / day _________________________

Fuel consumption / day _________________________ Fuel consumption / day _________________________

BHL DX55W DX55 SSL

0
[ 3 ] Conceptual Comparison

WORKING RANGE at open area

EXCAVATOR Backhoe Loader

DX55
DX55W 360o

Both cabin swing and boom Only boom swing available

swing are available

Wider working area Less work area

Less re-positioning Need to change the working

position more frequently
[ 3 ] Conceptual Comparison

WORKING RANGE next to wall

EXCAVATOR Backhoe Loader

Combination of cabin swing and boom swing Only boom swing available
are available
Need to change the working
Better productivity at limited space position more frequently

Less re-positioning BHL can use only one outrigger

when working next to wall
 [ 3 ] Conceptual Comparison

WORKING RANGE - general

DIMENSION

DX55W
Does machine satisfy jobsite
STANDARD (3.0m BO
OM, 1.6m ARM)
requirement?

Max. Digging Depth

A Max. Digging Radius 6,110 mm
Jobsite required ( )m

B Max. Digging Depth 3,495 mm DX55W (YES or NO)

Backhoe (YES or NO)

C Max. Digging Height 5,980 mm Max. Dump height

Jobsite required ( )m
D Max. Dump Height 4,265 mm

DX55W (YES or NO)

Backhoe (YES or NO)
E Min. Swing Radius 2,445 mm
 [ 3 ] Conceptual Comparison

Lifting Capacity

DOZER DOWN, 1.6M ARM (unit. ton)

A(m)
2 3 4 5 Max.
B(m)

4 *0.98 *0.87

3 *1.14 *0.96 *0.89

2 *2.33 *1.90 *1.44 *1.27 *0.96

1 *1.19 *2.61 *1.76 *1.42 *1.10

Does machine satisfy jobsite

0 *2.14 *2.95 *1.97 *1.42 *1.35 requirement?

-1 *3.38 *2.93 *1.99 *1.67 Lifting capacity

-2 *4.20 *2.52 *1.94

Jobsite required ( )m

DX55W (YES or NO)

Backhoe (YES or NO)
[ 3 ] Conceptual Comparison

RE-POSITIONING - Steps

1
7
2
6

3
1 3 4 5
2

Step 1 : Dozer up Step 1 : Seat rotation

Step 2 : Re-position Step 2 : Bucket up
Step 3 : Dozer down TIME Step 3 : Outrigger up
Step 4 : Re-position
Step 5 : Outrigger down TIME
Step 6 : Bucket down
Step 7 : Seta rotation
[ 3 ] Conceptual Comparison

TURNING RADIUS

DX55 (Crawler excavator) can

rotate at same position

DX55W (Wheel excavator) turning

radius is relatively smaller than
BHL

Space required
MEX MEX << WEX, BHL
[ 3 ] Conceptual Comparison

SPACE REQUIRED

EXCAVATOR Backhoe Loader

[ 3 ] Conceptual Comparison

VISIBILITY

EXCAVATOR Backhoe Loader

Offset* No Offset

There is offset* between Boom and Seat position, There is no offset between Boom and seat position,
so we see the bucket in comport so you have to tilt your neck to see the bucket

Better visibility Relevantly poor visibility

[ 3 ] Conceptual Comparison

OFFSET DIGGING

EXCAVATOR Backhoe Loader

Combine cabin swing Offset digging is

+ boom swing enable possible only after
wider trending work re-positioning
without re-positioning
Required more time
Faster and convenient 7 steps for re-
positioning is
required at every
offset digging
[ 3 ] Conceptual Comparison

LOADING ON THE TRUCK

EXCAVATOR Backhoe Loader

Truck can park anywhere around Limited parking area

the machine for loading. More
flexibility on truck loading position
Cabin swing is faster and more
accurate than boom swing
available when loading
Boom swing is slow and not
accurate
Relevantly small working
range
[ 3 ] Conceptual Comparison

TRACK vs TIRE

Crawler Excavator Backhoe Loader

Can easy drive across ground High potential for damaging

without damaging utilities underground utilities

Lower ground pressure Higher ground pressure

(4~6 psi) (30+ psi)

Risk of plat tire

[ 3 ] Conceptual Comparison

LOADING ON THE TRUCK

EXCAVATOR Backhoe Loader

Truck can park anywhere around Limited parking area

the machine for loading. More
flexibility on truck loading position
Cabin swing is faster and more
accurate than boom swing
available when loading
Boom swing is slow and in
convenient
Relevantly small working
range
[ 3 ] Conceptual Comparison

BHL advantage

EXCAVATOR Backhoe Loader

Excavating Excavating Excavating Dozing

DX55W BHL

Only dozer
blade is
available

Limited usage
[ 3 ] Conceptual Comparison

DX55W + Skid Steer Loader 2 x Backhoe Loader

Excavator Loader Excavator Loader

Not
BHLin use
DX55W SSL
VS Excavator Loader

Not
in useBHL

BHL have both function, but cannot work together

WEX+SSL can work together (x2 faster than BHL)

Also DX55W and SSL can work at different jobsite

 [ 3 ] Conceptual Comparison

PRODUCTIVITY

Which one of faster ? Portion of your work (100%) Base on my experience

Digging _______ % WEX is ____% faster than BHL

Loading _______ % WEX is ____% faster than BHL

Trenching _______ % WEX is ____% faster than BHL

Lifting _______ % BHL is ____% faster than WEX

DX55W advantage / YOUR JUDGEMENT BHL advantage / YOUR JUDGEMENT

Please add your feedback here Please add your feedback here
 [ 3 ] Conceptual Comparison

TRANSPORTATION

Which one is faster?

DX55W
Fuel Cost? BHL
Without truck

Transportation Cost?

DX55W
10t
BHL
6t
With truck
 [ 3 ] Conceptual Comparison

ATTACHMENT?

Available Not available Quick Coupler Available Not available

Available Not available Breaker Available Not available

Available Not available Others Available Not available

DX55W advantage / YOUR JUDGEMENT BHL advantage / YOUR JUDGEMENT

Please add your feedback here Please add your feedback here