Template- Analysis of an Argument

Paragraph 1- Introduction

Dissection of argument (i.e., name the parts of the argument: premises that you want to criticize such as
premises, conclusions, and assumptions)

Thesis statement: The argument that is flawed because (paragraph 2 overview) and (paragraph 3 overview)

Paragraph 2 First Point (Lack of evidence: i.e., first reason argument is flawed) How you can explain it is
unrelated or confusing, choose one assumption that has few or no supportive evidence

Transition Phrase: First,

Statement of Point

Example

Relate the example

Paragraph 3 Second Point (Weak evidence: i.e., second reason argument is flawed) choose one assumption
that has few or no supportive evidence

Transition Phrase: Second,

Statement of Point

Example

Relate the example

Paragraph 4 Third Point (Vague language: i.e., second reason argument is flawed) Attack the specific
terminology the author uses. how many is many Who exactly does he mean by the most?

Transition Phrase: Second,

Statement of Point

Example

Relate the example

Paragraph 5- How to fix argument

Transition Phrase: More, However, in addition

How to fix the argument

Paragraph 6- Conclusion

Transition Phrase: To conclude, in conclusion

Recap of Thesis Statement

Summary of Outline