Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Transmutation:
98 - 100 1.00
95 97 1.25
92 94 1.50
89 91 1.75
86 88 2.00
83 85 2.25
80 82 2.50
77 79 2.75
75 76 3.00
Below 75 5.00
XIV. References
Timmerhaus, K, et al. Plant Design and Economics for Chemical Engineers, 4th ed.Singapore:
McGraw Hill Inc.
Perrys Chemical Engineering Handbook. (2007). McGraw Hill Professional
BESA
DECAPIA
DIZON
ONG
CHENG
JUANGCO
TORRES
SAN JUAN
DE LEON
BARCELO
BARTE
FRANCISCO
LUDOVICE
GONZALES
MANAOIS
IGAYA
MAHINAY
II. ORAL DEFENSE (60%) POINTS 1 2 3 4
A. Understanding of the research work in
10
terms of findings and implications
B. Ability to understand the questions and
10
answering correctly
C. Ability to evaluate objectively
suggestions from the panel 10
POINTS 1 2 3 4
A. Design Presentation
1. Clarity of Presentation 10
2. Oral Discussion 10
B. Contents of the Design
(Continuity of ideas/information as
15
presented, accuracy of equipment
design and proper specifications)
C. Design Feasibility and Effectiveness
(Effective as of proof/application of the 15
process and content)
TOTAL 50
TOTAL 100
SAMPLE ONLY
Rubric for Plant Design Documentation
COMMENT:
SAMPLE ONLY
Rubric for Written Report (50% of the grade) Total of 40 points:
CRITERIA LEVELS SCORE
Beginning Developing Proficient Advance
(1) (2) (3) (4)
Topic have minimal relevance
CONTENT* Report topic lacks relevance or Topic is amply focused and Topic is significantly focused
and partially focused; some
Important topics are covered, direction; Focuses on definition relevant; facts are accurate and and highly relevant; contains
facts are not properly
relevant, updated and with accurate only; multiple factual omissions complete in general no factual error
supported
facts
O O O O
Text provides adequate depth;
Text does not provide adequate Requires additional depth in Text provides god depth and
major ideas are adequately
COMPLETENESS* depth; unclear or underdeveloped; some parts; lacks some details; ideas are well
developed and requires minor
Level of detail, depth, development report is too short or unnecessarily important details; report developed; report is of
reinforcement; report is proper
of ideas, appropriate length long maybe short appropriate length
length
O O O O
Majority of ideas in logical order Ideas are presented in
Ideas are not presented in order; Some ideas are not presented
ORGANIZATION/ CLARITY* with adequate transitions logical order with effective
No outline provided; text lacks in proper order; paragraph
Logical ordering of ideas, transitions between most paragraphs; text is transitions between
transition between ideas; text is too transitions needed in places;
between paragraphs, coherence, generally clear and paragraphs; text is clear and
wordy or unclear some text wordy and unclear
conciseness understandable concise
O O O O
Literatures are taken from
USE OF LITERATURE AND All resources taken from the Some resources from relevant Literatures are taken from
various updated types or
PERMANENT RESOURCES internet; Does not observe proper internet sites; some resources various types or resources;
resources; follows the
follows accepted format referencing format are properly formatted follows the acceptable format
acceptable format
conventions (APA, MSA, IEEE etc.)
O O O O
Text may contain some
Text has no serious spelling,
Text contains several spelling, spelling, grammar, punctuation Text contains no spelling,
GRAMMAR/ MECHANICS grammar or punctuation errors;
grammar or punctuation errors; use or sentence errors; phrasing grammar or punctuation
Correct usage, spelling, proper adequate word selection and
of fragments; poor phrasing; Table maybe improved; table and errors; clear sentence
sentence/paragraph structure, phrasing; Most tables and figures
and figures not labeled and cited figures improperly labeled or structure
formatting are properly labeled and cited
cited
O O O O
Report may address a unique or
Report addresses a unique
CREATIVITY AND Little support provided to major Report contains some original original topic; creative and well-
or original topic; Innovative
PRESENTATION ideas; inadequate use of tables, ideas; attempts to use some planned effort is evident;
approach is used; excellent
unique or original presentation of charts, graphs tables, charts, graphs significant use of tables, charts,
use of tables, charts, graphs
ideas graphs
O O O O
Document was submitted
Document was not submitted on Document was submitted after Document was submitted after
before the start of the
ON TIME SUBMISSION time the official class hour the oral report
presentation
O O O O
*weight is times two