You are on page 1of 6

I Fig. 4. Simple line section. R-resist- actually varies.

The reactive load current I, exists during time


ance; I-reactive load current; l- T1. Energy loss in this line section is found by adding the losses
R capacitor current during each small period of time:
EL =(I1-I,)2RT1+(I2-Ic)2RT2+. +(In-Ic)2RTn .
(14)
-C EL =I, 2RT1+I22RT2+ ... +In2RTn+2IlIcRT1+
2I2IcRT2+... +2InlcRTn+IC2R(T2+T2+... +Tn) (15)
The energy loss with no capacitor is equal to
z ,I22RT2+I22RT2+... +In2RTn
__________ Therefore, the reduction in energy loss afforded by the ca-
In pacitor is:
<
I2 S1 AEL =2IcR(I1T,+I2T2+. +InTn)-Ic2R(Tl+T2+ +Tn)
I (16)
aI If T2 +T2+ +Tn = T, the total period of the load cycle,
a: eTI-1 T2 -TnS then:
TI ME 12T, +12T2 +... +InTn = the average reactive current times the
Fig. 5. Reactive load cycle for circuit of total period of the load cycle
Fig. 4. Ii exists during Ti or
IT1+ 12T2+. InTn= [I avg (average)](T) (17)
However
The results of the computer calculations for the sample I avg = (Imax)(LF) (18)
feeder circuit are shown in Figs. 3(B) and 3(C). Note that Therefore:
the annual savings in energy and peak losses are of the same
order of magnitude of the total annual cost of the capacitors. aEL= [2(Imax)(Ic)(LF)(R)-(IC)2(R)1T (19)
Note also that the voltage regulation problem is solved by in watt hours.
the capacitors. The voltage profile print-out is arranged in On an annual basis
the same fashion as the feeder exists; that is, a main line shown AEL =8.76R[(2)(I.a-)(Ic)(LF)-(Ic)2] (20)
in the vertical position and lateral branches tapped off the
main line. in kwh.

Appendix References
Derivation of the simple energy loss reduction equation is 1. ANALYSIS OF CAPACITOR APPLICATION AS AFFECTED BY LOAD
given here. Refer to Fig. 4. The two components of reactive CYCLE, R. F. Cook. AIEE Transactions, pt. III-A (Power Apparatus
current in the line section are the load current that varies with and Systems), vol. 78, Oct. 1959, pp. 950-57.
time and the constant capacitor current. Assume that the load 2. OPTIMIZING THE APPLICATION OF SHUNT CAPACITORS FOR
current varies in an infinite number of discrete steps as shown REACTIVE-VOLT-AMPERE CONTROL AND Loss REDUCTION, R. F.
in Fig. 5, since this is the manner in which the load current Cook. Ibid., vol. 80, Aug. 1961, pp. 430-44.

Limitations on Stringing and Sagging Conductors


IEEE Committee Report

Summary: The subject of stringing and sagging conductors is gineer, formerly with the Aluminum Company of Canada, Ltd.
covered in three sections by three members of the Working Construction Practices, Section 3, was compiled by E. G. Lam-
Group. Section 1 deals with conductor CREEP, and was prepared bert, who is with the Pacific Gas and Electric Company.
by R. E. Larson, who is affiliated with the Rome Cable Division
of Alcoa. Section 2 concerns CLIPPING OFFSETS. It was written The authors treat the subject in a general way, and nothing
by H. B. White, who is pnresently a consulting transmission en- they say is to be interpreted as an attempt to set up specifica-
________________________________________ tions on stringing and sagging conductors. The paper
Paper 64-146, recommended by the IEEE Transmission and Dis- will have fulfilled its purpose, they believe, if the en-
tribution Committee and approved by the IEEE Technical Opera- . . . . . . .
tions Committee for presentation at the IEEE Winter Power Meet- gineer, in preparing his design, iS cognizant of the items out-
ing, New York, N. Y., February 2-7, 1964. Manuscript submitted lined and if the specification writer considers the points care-
November 11, 1963; made available for printing April 14, 1964. fully as he tackles each job in the relevant area.
Members of the IEEE Working Group of the Towers, Poles, and
Conductors Subcommittee of the IEEE Transmission and Distribu- Conductor Creep
tion Committee are: W. C. FREEMAN, Chairman; H. W. Adams, F. Thflwopasidermtnofaeilshchcus
W. Farr, R. E. Larson, E. G. Lambert, J. B. Roche, Lionel Swift, H. Thflwo ascdermtnofaerl hc cus
B. White, and R. W. Wood. with timeafter the initial deformation caused by application
1230 Limitations on Stringing and Sagging Conductors DECEMBER 1964
.0I 0

TENSION_____ _ ___________ l Tm
17,520 LBS 40% ULtIMATE STRENGTH_____ _ ______ _ ________ X
13,14 0 LB S..30% ULTIMATE STRENGTH___________________
|10,880 LBS 24.8% ULTIMATE STRENGTH| llllll l llllll ll ll llll

Z .001 .01 Z1
w IJ
a. a.
z z
a. 00 -
0.

* 1< IIIIII111 11tHu===X:ioool0


____LL
w

L
Z.000I ooo01 _

THE THESE TESTS WERE MADE AT ROOM -


TEMPERATURES VARYING FROM 69T092.5F.

.00 i IL I - .00001
0. 1 1. O 10 100 poo1 10,000
ELAPSED TIME - HOURS (42 DAYS) (417DAYS)
Fig. 1. CREEP versus time curves-long-time tensile tests of 1,590,000 CM ACSR 45/7

of load-is known as CREEP. The initial flow may include life of a transmission line on the basis of a relatively short
both elastic and plastic deformation, depending upon the period of tests. This straight-line relationship has been
amount of stress. Conductor stress-strain curves show the confirmed by tests continued for several years, in one case for
elastic deformation or elastic stretch and also the nonelastic nearly 9 years; see Figs. 1 and 2.
stretch or permanent increase in length resulting when the The amount and rate of CREEP varies with conductor type
load is first applied. CREEP, the additional nonelastic stretch, and stranding as well as with tension, time, and other factors.
develops gradually over a long period of time and without any CREEP of ACSR with higher percentages of steel and of 6201
increase in load. and 5005 alloy conductors, with each conductor stressed to the
The rate of CREEP varies with tension, time, and tem- same per cent of its ultimate strength, is less than CREEP of
perature. The higher the tension, the faster the rate. At ACSR with low percentages of steel and of all-aluminum
any given tension, the rate is at a maximum when the load is EC (electrical conductivity) conductors.
first applied, but this decreases rapidly. The rate would be- The CREEP of conductors in service varies with climatic
come greater with a temperature rise and no change in tension. and operating conditions. Since neither tensions nor tem-
However, in practice, a rise in temperature is offset by a peratures remain constant, certain assumptions must be made
lessening of tension, which decreases the rate of CREEP. With as to time and temperature as a basis for determining sags
ACSR (aluminum cable, steel-reinforced) and temperatures and tensions.
above 100 F (degrees Fahrenheit), the CREEP could actually The diminishing CREEP rate, everyday tension, and design
be minimal. The materials used also enter into the picture; of the line must be taken into account when deciding how
for example, the rate for steel is much less than that for alu- much correction to apply. Correction for CREEP that will
minum. But, by using ACSR, when temperatures increase, occur over a period of 10 to 30 years should be adequate with
most of the load shifts to the steel with little tension on the a period of 10 years normally used.
aluminum. CREEP is usually considered when preparing sag and
The relation between CREEP and time may be determined tension charts. If sag after CREEP is greater than it would be
from long-time tensile tests on samples of conductors in which after the maximum-design loading condition, then CREEP
the load is held constant for the duration of the test. When is the governing factor in determining final sags and tensions.
CREEP is plotted against time on logarithmic scales, a straight- When this is so, but when it has not been incorporated in
line relationship results for each test tension. In the normal specific sag and tension charts, allowance for CREEP during
range for conductors in service, the curves are substantially sagging can be made with a temperature-correction factor.
parallel. At very high tensions, however, the rate of CREEP The temperature used to select the conductor sag is the
may increase after the total elongation has reached a critical ambient temperature, minus a determined temperature
value, in which case, conductor failure can be expected. correction for CREEP. However, this method of CREEP com-
Since the curves have a straight-line relationship, a rea- pensation will result in higher initial tensions than specified
sonably accurate prediction may be made of the amount of and, depending upon the time relationship after stringing of
CREEP that a conductor might experience over the probable CREEP versus the occurrence of the maximum-design loading
DECEMBER 1964 Limitations on Strining and Saging Conductors 1231
.01 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

NOIA ULTImATE- 66:0 LBL|i4T <X :

Z ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~60, NCl A OTN>

1SI
Z00: .001 Z

W rrl llllJ~S^--II<1IC--0
(l

Li w

Zzz M g:e- m1*


z

1- I.-01-10 t

Z
=1
*o001 .00D
0. UU.

1.0 10 100 1000 10000 100,000


(APP.42 DAYS) (APP. '14 MOS.) (APP. 11 1/2YRS.)
ELAPSED TIME - HOURS
Fig. 2. CREEP versus time curves-long-time tensile tests of No. 8 ACSR

condition, the maximum conductor design tension could be continues to change when passing over the sheave into the ad-
exceede(l. jacent span; thus, if low points of adjacent spans are at differ-
The conductor, by the time it has been pulled out and ent elevations, there will be differences in horizontal tensions
brought up to sag, is treated as having undergone an equiv- in these spans. As all sagging work is based on uniform values
alent of 1 hour of CREEP. Therefore, the initial sag data of H (horizontal tension) throughout the stringing section, sags
used in stringing conductors have incorporated a 1-hour will not be consistent with calculated values. Minor variations
CREEP factor. Sag caused by CREEP can, however, amount to on reasonably level ground can be tolerated, but with the
several inches within only a day. Fig. 3 gives the increase in conductor on sheaves in hilly terrain, the large differences in
sag due to CREEP for 954,000-CM (circular mils) ACSR 48/7 elevation of the low points of successive spans can cause dif-
for two different stringing tensions, the time ranging from 1 ferences between HI of the lower span and H. of the upper
day to 30 years. span of several hundred up to 1,000 pounds.
If initial sag in the stringing data is to be the criterion, This large difference in horizontal tension of the conductor
ii spector checks should be made prior to CLIPPING IN. If I in sheaves will cause an error in sag and off-plumb insulator
or more days elapse between SAGGING IN and such checks, strings.
allowance should be made for increase in sag due to CREEP. As chart sags for a given section are based on a common
value of Ho, the sag in one span may be correct, but in another
Sagging Offsets will be too small -or too large. In hilly terrain, no amount of
WN'hen stringing conductor in hilly terrain, construction juggling of the conductors up or down while in the sheaves
crews frequently have difficulty in CLPPING IN the conductor will produce simultaneous correct sags in all spans.
so that the insulator strings remain in a vertical position. In the desired final CLIPPED IN state with insulator strings
The difficulty can be overcome by using OFFSETS which may be hanging vertically, only vertical forces can be applied through
estimated on the spot by experienced men if the situation is the clamps to the conductor. The values of the horizontal
not complicated and the end result not too critical, but which tensions in adjacent spans, Ho, therefore can be equal to each
require office preparation for more important lines. other and to the chart tensions and the desired sags in all spans
Fundamental to an understanding of the general problem inl the section can be realized simultaneously.
and its solution is a rope principle to the effect that, in a WVith the correct amount of conductor strung into the sec-
freely supported flexible rope (conductor in sheaves), the differ- tion, H5 will be greater than Ho and this greater than HI while
ence in tension between any two points equals the difference in the sheaves; and sags in the upper section will, therefore,
in elevation of the two points in feet, multiplied by the weight be less than charted while, in the lower section, they will be
per foot of the rope (parabolic derivation), more than charted.
Within a span, the tension will increase in moving from the The difference between IN-SHEAVE sags and the desired
low point of the sag towards the points of support, but this CLIPPED-IN or chart sags must be computed, therefore, for all
variation can be neglected in most conductor work. Of spans. This permits SAGGING IN, SO that the correct total
significance here, 'however, is the fact that the rope tension amount of conductor will be placed in the section. The next
1232 Limitations on Stringing and Sagging Conductors DECEMBEBR 1964
1000 1000

500 500

z
200 20 --- - 2O0: Z
r 6050 LBS. (12,000 LBS. MAX. TENSION-HEAVY LOADING)
- i3455 LBS. (8,000 LBS. MAX. TENSION-HEAVY LOADING)
CL !00-_' 0 a.

w w
o
50 1 1111111
11 Llili
111111II= i L___
=__ ._ _= =-
_ z50
0
I-

~~~~~w
1''20 r i3 f Si i 1 l f 1v IS20
OP

o IOO
000__~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 0 z
U3C C0-Cs4
Z~~~~~~~.000 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~4

IO z30 YEARS

Fig. 3. Conductor CREEP, 60 F, 17000-foot span-954,000 CM ACSR 48/7

step is to apply- clamps, OFFSET a calculated distance from a is only for individual span OFFSETS, not exceeding 15 inches.
verticalI throulgh the point of support, so that the conductor For more serious cases, the long-form technique is required.
is pulled up and out of the lower slack spans and put into the Even a quick inspection of these forms though-they are rela-
Eniner
overly ofteBneilwoe
tightnvr
upper spans. diitainhv vrtesevs
tively seilyweeeteedfeecsi
clear and concise, will indicate how time-consuming and
bult)ie og onanu eri ayyas
o the pnlntsocr of -OFFSETS will be for a hlong length
A.n individual
Coseunty 4hyhv ocs of
span is a measure
OFFSET for aeeoe aua chailge
eh expensive the calculation
fschPUBMRIGSaomloeain akn
niiqe
of slackfor
necessary therein to change tension from H,, ora Hio-
coptn-ohteOFESadrqie to andline.
of
otao
Even by5f
intllto
in written to
employing
tigig
one of several computer pro-
OFSTwi1adoltecsfclua
fastainrqie prcal
nAEin
tins Thes difference
Ho, this tension being 4n exlie
--r -rsne a function of difference grams perform these operations the cost is not
elevation. The OFFSET or change of slack will be small negligible.
if the coinductor is tightly strung and spans are small; con- Installation of OFFSETS in t-he field also can be time-con-
versely, it will be large with relatively low tensions and long suming and expensive. After SAGGING. IN, all towers must be
spans. climbed and at least PL-UMB MARKED before CLIPPING IN starts.
The gross or final insulator OFFSET at a tower is the algebraic There is strong support for PLUMB MAKING the conductor at
summation of the individual span OFFSETS to one side of the each support on the day of SAGGING IN, whether OFFSETS are
is
tower-representing, 3hage
accratenly fo for example, Fig. theCondulctor
amount CReEP 60orf,r 1,00-foo
of conductor to besa ne
used-95,00
or not.CMWhen 48/7tnrug
ACS lifting eran
the conductor off theceki
sheave
that must be taken out of all lower spans and passed uphill with a coffin hoist for armorino, the co-nductor will shift along
throulgh the mzedian tower to slacken the upper spans. the line because it must be grabbed ahead or back a sufficient
Several excellent
tep S o plyclmp,OFSERattempts have been made to solve
calulte disitatince fom ty an distance
this to clear the position
Saisnly forndidualorspa of the armor rods. Once dis-
OFSTS2o3ecein35inhs
problenm of cornputing offsets and as far back as 15 years ago, turbed, the conductor will not roll back within each span to its
short sections of line through very difficult terrain were correct position, and it may have moved as-much -as a foot
analyzed rigorously and correct offsets and sag adjustments at each support. Leaving the conductor in sheaves overnight,
computed. The methods proved rather unwieldy, however, without having it PLUMB MARKED, can result in clipping errors;
for long sections of line through mountains. also, temperature changes and winads can move the conductor
advisable to determine whether or not OFFSETS are required. methods of slack or little back tension, sock lines should, at
A stringing section which includes some of the larger changes least, equal the longest span so that the conductor will string
in elevation and some long spans can be checked in a few in position. Tension stringing requirements are for sock
hours by the short-form method. lines as long as the reel lengths, either single or spliced-joined.
There is some difference of opinion as to the limits below Sock lines should not rotate against stranded conductor lays.
which OFFSETS can be neglected. One utility, with possibly Swivels and other features should be used if necessary.
the most experience in stringing in very rough terrain, supplies Suitable Protection of Cable If Allowed to Drag on Ground
OFFSET and sag-correction data to the contractor if:
1. An individual spanOFFSETiSgreater than 2 inches. Lagging, if used, should be clean and free of nails, wire,
or any objects that could damage conductor. sap or resin-
No lagging
2. The summation of idividual span OFFSET IS greater than type lagging should be used. Avoid round-type as it
tends to roll away from the conductor.
3. Individual sag correction is greater thlan 1 foot.
Another utility considers their use only where the individual Limitations of Tension If Tension Stringing Is Used
span OFFSET exceeds 6 inches or the individual sag correction Creep characteristics of conductor should aid in determining
exceeds 2 feet, but this set of limitations was applied to a allowable maximum stringing tension. Normal tensions are
line built in a remote area where ground clearance was not necessary to clear obstructions or ground. If possible, less
critical. than half the normal sag is a good criterion.
In some cases, stringing and sagging operations can be
adjusted to eliminate the need for OFFSETS. A hypothetical Maximum Stringing Lengths Allowed
case would be a line running along a valley, climbing up the How many stringing sheaves the front of a conductor
side to the rim, and then going evenly at the higher level for travels through without damage to the cable, the condition
several miles. of stringing sheaves, tension allowable for stringing, type of
Differences in elevation may be modest, producing differ- terrain, and profile--all are factors that govern length. Even
ences between HX and HI of only a few hundred pounds and with the best of stringing sheaves, it is impossible to eliminate
limiting the individual OFFSETS or slack adjustment in each all friction. If very long pulls are made, over possibly 15 or
span to a few inches. 20 towers, tension near the pulling machines may be sub-
However, if the SAGGING-IN section should include six upper stantially higher than in the spans back at the tension-brake
spans as well as six lower spans, the gross or final OFFSETS at equipment. Attention must be given to this if great accuracy
towers on the top and bottom of the rise can be as much as is expected from the sagging work.
18 to 24 inches and, on adjacent towers, as much as 15 to
20 inches. Calculation and application of OFFSETS could be Splicing Conductors
avoided in this case if one SAGGING-IN section were terminated The installation of compression deadends or compression
just before the appreciable and continuing change in line eleva- splices will result in the squeezing out or loosening of the
tion. aluminum strands adjacent to the fitting. When the conduc-
A number of rule-of-thumb field techniques have been tor is subjected to tension, this normal amount of looseness
developed and are used with limited success to overcome this works itself out if there is sufficient space or distance to the
problem of inclined insulator strings. Most, if not all of them, next compression fitting. This necessary length varies with
are based on the geometry of the conductor and insulator conductor diameter. A minimum of 100 feet is required for
string at a given tower in the IN-SHEAVE condition. large 3-layer conductors and down to 50 feet for smaller sizes.
These techniques can provide a partial remedy in the hands Minimum distance of splice from a suspension point is that
of an experienced foreman when the problem is rather simple, which allows armor rods and dampers to be installed in their
such as when the stringing section contains a single hill or proper locations. A minimum of 25 feet represents good
change in elevation. As these methods take no account of practice. Manufacturers' recommendations for the installa-
changes in horizontal tension with elevation, and in slack tion of compression splices should be followed. The finished
that must be made to equalize such tensions, they cannot be splice should be smoothed to lower corona level.
considered reliable tools of the trade.
Repair or Cutting Out of Damaged Sections
Construction Practices
Manufacturers' recommendations for use of repair-type
HANDLING AND STRINGING CONDUCTORS accessories are adequate. If steel core damage occurs, re-
Come-Alongs pairs should consist of a full tension splice.
A COME-ALONG, or combination of COME-ALONGS, should be
capable of holding perhaps 50% over the sagging tension-- Limitations of Location of Stringing Equipment
including prestress--without slipping. The COME-ALONG Overloading of crossarms and equipment should be pre-
must fit exactly the size of the conductor in use. For bolted- vented where high stringing and sagging tensions are used.
type COME-ALONGS, the uniform installation torque of the eye- Stringing equipment installed too close to the tower base can
bolts should be specified, then obtained by making 3 to 6 impose loads on the tower crossarm that will easily exceed the
passes along the bolts, tightening them to an equal and slightly design strength.
higher torque with each pass. The bolts should be period-
ically retightened when load is applied or at certain intervals Sagging Conductors
if the load is held over a long period of time. Accuracy in computation should be imperative. Sags and
tensions are based on profiles, ruling spans, clearances, and
Sock-Line Length, Type, Etc. load conditions. Sags for long-span transmission construc-
Sock-line lengths will vary as to use and requirements with tion should be made with optical instrument methods. Per-
methods of stringing conductors. For regular stringing missible limits of sag lengths should be controlled by profile,
1234 Limitations on Stringing and Sagging Conductors DECEMBER 1964
terrain, and other elements to insure correct tensions in all 2. Avoid extrene be.nding of conductors.
spans. Sag checks should include front and back sections of 3. Avoid reel damuage.
pulls, including individual checks in adjacent spans of heavy 4. Choose type of COME-ALONG to use and method of attachment.
angles. 5. Decide on sock-line length and type.
Accuracy of Sags 6. Size, type, and condition of stringing sheave must be selected.
The longer spans in a sag section may be used for sagging 7. Hang sheave on crossarms in a position which will properly
the conductor in order to realize increased sensitivity. How- distribute load to arm.
ever, where a subsequent sag check involves appreciable 8. Locate place for sheave below crossarm.
changes in temperatures, the ruling span will prove most reli- 9. Provide suitable protection of cable if allowed to drag on
able. When checking sags, it should be remembered that CREEP ground.
of conductor will occur. 10. Limit tension if tension stringiing is used.
Sag Charts or Curves To Be Used 11. Specify maximnum allowable stringing lengths.
12. Specify minimum lengths of conductor to splice.
Sags computed by using stress-strain and CREEP relation--
Ship,bagsconmtenary psingstropess-strtis,areand
ship, based on catenary properties, are recommended.recomme13. bundleSpecify precautions in using running boards for stringing
conductors.
Offsets 14. Minimum time should be allowed before marking or CLIP-
PING IN.
In hilly terrain, OFFSETS are great assets. Profiles should
be checked for difficult sag sections. 15. Repair or cut out damaged sections.
16. Limit the amount of stringing equipment on each location.
Installing Armor Rods and Dampers
Armor rods should be centered in relation to support points,
and dampers installed exactly as recommended spacings call
When in- Cod uctor
for, being sure they are attached tightly to the conductor. 2. Decide on prestressing methods, if used.
3. Find location and number of spans to determine sag.
Spacers 4. Allow for tolerances for accuracy of sag.
Spacers, installed at locations specified, must be attached 5. Decide method of checking temperatures.
tightly to the conductors. Any slipping between spacer 6. Specify sag charts or curves to be used.
clamps and conductors will lead to rapid conductor wear. On
many lines, the spacer is needed to restore a bundle to its 7. Specify records to be checked.
normal position after twisting, caused by galloping or ice 8. UseOFFSETsags where applicable.
unloading, and the spacer cannot perform this function if When Handling Insulators and Hardware
there is any slip between it and the conductor.
1. Avoid breakage.
Method of Checking Temperatures 2. Be sure cotter keys are fully inserted in insulator caps.
Temperatures should be obtained by direct measurement 3. Avoid bending insulator string to the point of bending ball
with thermometer for all conductor sizes. Thermometers pins.
may be placed inside a short length of conductor or inside 4. Clean the insulators.
an aluminum tube of approximately the conductor diameter, 5. State which direction cotter k-eys should face.
hung at least 15 feet above the ground to eliminate ground 6. Check accuracy of plurmbing strings after CLIPPING IN.
effects. 7. Guard against nicks, scratches, or other flaws of corona rings,
ITEMS To BE CONSIDERED IN SPECIFICATIONS ON STRINGING if used.
AND SAGGING OF CONDUCTOR When Installing Armor Rods, Dampers, and Spacers
A check list of do's and dont's is provided so that no im- 1. Center rods on conductor.
portant feature will be neglected in any of the four categories 2. Avoid nicking conductor.
indicated by the four headings which follow. 3. Avoid distorting preformed rods.
When Handling and Stringing Conductors 4. Allow tolerances in location of dampers, if used.
1. Prevent damage to conductors and line structures. 5. Allow tolerances in location of spacers, if used.

DECEMBER 1964 Limitations on Stringing and Sagging Conductors 1235

You might also like