Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ABSTRACT
Objective: The experiment was aimed at performing in-vitro studyobjective of this study to
evaluate antiviral activity of leaf extract of Cassia alata and Cosmos caudatus against dengue
virus serotype-2 (DENV-2) in vitoHuh7it-1 cell culture.
Methods: We used Huh7-it-1 cell line and DENV2 strain New Guinea C. The tested
concentrationvarious concentration of each separate leaf extract were 10, 20, 40, 80, 160, and
320 g/mL Extracts inhibitory capability and toxicity were evaluated by focus assay and MTT
assay, respectively. Focus assay measured the decrement of virus titer after DENV2 were treated
with various concentration of the extracts and then were added to Huh7it-1 monolayer to
generate concentration-mean infectivity percentage curves. Meanwhile, MTT assay was
performed by exposing various concentration of the extracts to the cell culture and then
quantified cells viability by absorbance reading to obtain concentration-mean percentage of cell
viability. Nonlinear regression analysis was performed upon concentration-effect curves of
infectivity and viability to determine half-inhibitory concentration (IC50) and half-cytotoxic
concentration (CC50), respectively.
Results: The Cassia alata leaf extract had the IC50, CC50 and SI of <10 g/mL, 323.45 g/mL,
and >32.3 respectively. Meanwhile, the IC50, CC50, and SI of Cosmos caudatus leaf extract were
12.2 g/mL, 187.1g/mL and 15.4 respectively.
Conclusion: Given their high selectivity indices, Cassia alata and Cosmos caudatus leaf extract
showed potent antiviral activity against DENV2. Further studies are required to to identify active
compound of Cassia alata and Cosmos caudatus leaf that have potency as antiviral for DENV and
their mechanism of inhibition.
INTRODUCTION
Dengue virus (DENV) infection is still a major health problems worldwide, especially in tropical
and sub-tropical countries. WHO estimated that the number of dengue infection reached 390
million cases (95% CI, 284 - 528 million) with 95 million (95%CI, 67-136 million) clinically-
manifested cases in 2010 globally [1]. Meanwhile in Indonesia, according to Ministry of Health
Republic of Indonesia, there were more than 100.000 people diagnosed with dengue fever and
the disease have appeared in more than 80% of nations region [2].
In line with extensive studies for the development of dengue vaccine, the search of substances Formatted: Space After: 12 pt, Line spacing: At least
17 pt, No widow/orphan control, Don't adjust space
for a breakthrough of novel antiviral drug against dengue virusDENV has been attempted. To between Latin and Asian text, Don't adjust space
between Asian text and numbers
date, there is no clinically-approved DENV dengue antiviral drug to treat as the treatment for
broad spectrum of DENVdengue infection disease. The treatment is essentially
supportive. severity is predominantly supportive. Formatted: Font: (Default) Times, Font color: Black
More attention has been given to natural sources especially herbal medicinemedicinal plants in
the search of novel substances for drug development considering its abundant availability, lower
cost, and potentially lower toxicity hence lower risk of adverse effects. To mention, artemisinin
which initially was discovered from herb rooting from Chinese traditional medicine was a
notable success story of the search of drug materials from traditional medicinal plants. Numerous
herbs with potential health benefits grow well in Indonesia yet their potentials have not been
studied extensively. Cosmos caudatus is an edible plant popular as a dish in Malayan and is
believed having various health benefits. Recent study discovered that it had high antioxidant
contents [3] and some other reviews stated that it had antibacterial, antifungal, antiosteoporotic,
antidiabetic, and blood-pressure lowering effects [4]. On the other hand, Cassia alata has long
been used as source of traditional remedy for various ailments in many regions of the world
especially in Asian and African countries. Recent studies found that extract of Cassia alata had
immunostimulant [5], antirotaviral [6] antiinflamatory, and antioxidant activity [7]. The purpose
of this study is to investigate antiviral property of leaf extract of Cassia alata and Cosmos
caudatus for dengue virus serotype-2 (DENV2 ) strain New Guinea C in Huh7it-1 cell. culture.
We used DENV serotype 2 strain NGC adapted in HuH7it-1 human hepatocellular carcinoma
cells1. A monolayer of Huh7it-1cell in T-75 flasks were infected with DENV-2 NGC at MOI of
0.5 PFU/cell and then the flask was incubated at 37oC with 5% CO2 for 5-7 days. During the
viral propagation period, the FBS concentration of the cell culture medium was reduced to 2%.
Supernatant was harvested and centrifuged at 1000 g for 5 minutes and then were filtered using a
syringe driven 0.22 mm (Millipore Co. Bedford USA). Culture supernatant was stored at -80oC
and checked for the titer of dengue virus by focus assay as previously performed by Igarashi et
al, 1995[8].
Data analysis
Mean difference of percentage of cytotoxicity and infectivity between treatments group and
negative control was analyzed using One-way ANOVA using SPSS version 23 with p value less
than 0.05 (p<0.05) considered as statistically significant difference. The value of CC 50 and IC50
were determined using simple arithmetical calculation on regression equations obtained from
concentration-percentage of viability and concentration-percentage of inhibition. Then,
selectivity index for each extract was derived from the ratio of CC50 to IC50.
RESULTS
Cytotoxicity of Cassia alata and Cosmos caudatus leaf extract on HuH7it-1 cell culture
Cytotoxicity of leaf extract of Cassia alata and Cosmos caudatus on Huh7it-1 cells were
measured using MTT assay. The mean percentage of Huh7it-1 viability for each concentration
that were tested in triplicate were calculated. A nonlinear regression curve of each extracts
concentrations and cells viability was made and then the graph formula was made using
Microsoft Excel 2013. Half-cytotoxic concentration (CC50) of Cassia alata and Cosmos caudatus
were determined from the equations obtained from respective graph. Half-cytotoxic
concentration is defined as extracts concentration that gives rise to the decrement of cell culture
viability by 50% with respect to the negative control cells percentage of viability.
Inhibitory effects of Cassia alata and Cosmos caudatus leaf extract against DENV2
Antiviral activity of Cassia alata and Cosmos caudatus leaf extracts were evaluated by focus
assay. Number of foci formed in each well including in negative control well was counted
manually using microscope after staining. Each concentration of extracts were tested in triplicate
hence the mean value of percentage of infectivity for each concentration was calculated. The
difference of number of foci formed in each test well and control well were calculated and then
its value were compared to absolute number of foci in control well to obtain the percentage of
DENV2 inhibition by that respective extract concentration. The mean percentage of DENV2
inhibition was for each concentration triplicate was then calculated. Finally, a regression curve of
extract concentration-DENV2 inhibition percentage was made using Microsoft Excel 2013 and
formula for the graph was generated. Half-inhibitory concentration of each extract was
calculated from its respective formula. Half-inhibitory concentration is defined as extracts
concentration that brings about inhibition of viral replication by 50% with relative to the negative
control cells percentage of inhibition (0%).
320 100
100
160 100
100
80 100
98.8
40 98.7 91.8
20 92
62.6
10 87.5 48.9
0
DMSO 0,1%* 0
*DMSO 0.1% was used as the negative control to which number of foci formed on each well
containing a certain amount of extract compared to obtain the value of inhibition percentage.
(a) (b)
Fig. 1: Regression curve for concentration-mean percentage of DENV2 post-treatment of
(a) Cassia alata; (b) Cosmos caudatus. From the regression equation obtained from
corresponding curve, the iC50 of Cassia alata and Cosmos caudatus were 0,04 g/ml and 12.2
g/ml respectively
DISCUSSION
One-way ANOVA with Tukeys multiple comparison showed that percentage of viability
differed significantly (*p <0,05) one another for every concentration of the extract except for
among concentration of 10, 20, and 40 g/mL and control. Meanwhile, mean difference of
percentage of inhibition did not show statistical significance. The regression formula for Cassia
alata is y = 6.3628 ln(x) + 73.277 thus if we substitute y with 50 to earn concentration that will
bring about half-inhibitory concentration, we will get x=0.04 which is a very low value. Thus,
we could only confidently say that the IC50 value of Cassia alata was below 10 g/mL as the
lowest concentration tested yielded more than 50% inhibition. Given that the CC50 and IC50 of C.
alata were 323.45 g/mL and <10 g/mL, hence the selectivity index of Cassia alata was >32.3.
Meanwhile, the CC50, IC50, and selectivity index of Cosmos caudatus is 187.1g/mL,
12.2g/mL, and 15.4 respectively.
In this study, the half-cytotoxic concentration of Cassia alata leaf was 323.45 g/mL. In a study
by Shaheen et al using similar MTT assay, the methanol, chloroform, butanol, and aqueous
fraction of Cassia alata gave no toxic effect on MA 104 cells with CC50 exceeded 1000 g/ml
while its ethyl acetate extract showed slight toxicity with CC 50 of 826 g/ml. The half-inhibitory
concentration of its methanol fraction was 74, hence the selectivity index of C. alata against
rotavirus was 22.8 [6]. Besides, root parts of Cassia alata Linn. contains considerable amount of
phenolic compounds, anthraquinons (rhein, chrysophanol, and aloe-emodin), and flavonoid
(kaempferol)[14]. Qualitative estimation of cassia alata partially purified flower extract found
that it contained considerable amount of flavonoids (72.9+0,061), phenols (49.4+0.04), and
tannins (18.12+0.30) [15]. The high bioflavonoids and phenolic compounds contents of Cassia
alata probably associates with its antiviral properties against DENV2.
Cosmos caudatus leaf contains flavonoids (such as cathecin, quercetin) and phenolic acids
(ferulic acid, caffeic acid, chlorogenic acid, etc) while its whole plants contains the other
flavonoids (naringenin, rutin, formic acid, kaempferol), monoterpenes, sesquiterpenes,
diterpenes, carbohydrates, quaternary ammonium salts, and carboxylic acids [4]. Study of
antiviral activity against DENV2 NGC strain in C6/36 cell culture of three compounds (rutin,
ellagic acid, and quercetin) obtained from extraction of Spondias mombin and Spondias tuberosa
resulted in finding that the CC50 values of all those compounds exceeded 1000 g/mL while
their IC50 were 362.68 g/mL for rutin and 500 g/mL for quercetin [10]. Although the
selectivity indices of rutin and quercetin were relatively low, we hypothesized that those
bioflavonoids contributed to antiviral activity of C. caudatus leaf against DENV2.
Several studies had evaluated antiviral activity of a certain kind of substance or extract of
medicinal plant with similar methodology as this study. Study of antiviral activity of three
compounds (rutin, ellagic acid, and quercetin) contained within Spondias mombin and Spondias
tuberosa against DENV2 NGC strain in C6/36 cell culture resulted in finding that the CC50
values of all those compounds exceeded 1000 g/mL while their IC50 were 362.68 g/mL for
rutin and 500 g/mL for quercetin[10]. Study by Zandi et al assessed antiviral activity of a
bioflavonoid substance, baicalein against DENV2 in Vero cells. The selectivity index of
baicalein was 21.3 (IC50 5.39) when the compound was added 5 hours before were treated before
viral infection and given continuously up to 4 days post-infection while the SI after viral
adsorption to the cells was 17.8 (IC50 6,46 g/mL). Baicalein possibly acted as direct virucidal
agent (IC50 of
1.55 g/mL) as well as anti-adsorption agent (IC50 of 7.14 g/mL) against DENV-2 and exerted
its effect by inactivating important structure and/or non-structural protein(s) of DENV-2 [11].
Another study with identical methodology that evaluate antiviral activity of quercetin showed
that the substance had the selectivity index of 35.7 g/mL when the substance was given right
after viral adsorption and of 28.9 g/mL for continuous administration from 5 hours before virus
infected the cell up to 4 days post-infection [12]. In a study conducted by Talarico et al with the
method plaque reduction and virus yield inhibition assays, two sulfated polysaccharides obtained
from the red seaweeds Gymnogongrus griffithsiae and Cryptonemia crenulata showed inhibitory
capability against DENV-2 in Vero cells with IC50 as low as 1 g/mL and selectivity index
exceeded 1,000 but it showed no antiviral activity against DENV1 and only moderate activity
against DENV 3 and DENV4. It is hypothesized that those sulfated compounds targeted virus
adsorption and internalization during virus binding to the host cell [13]. Compared to the other
substances which had been evaluated in several studies that have been mentioned above, the
selectivity indices of C. alata and C. caudatus were considered as high.Therefore, Both C. alata
and C. caudatus leaves had a potent antiviral properties in vitro for DENV2 with relatively low
toxicity against Huh7it-1 cells.
CONCLUSION
The leaf extract of Cassia alata and Cosmos caudatus had shown potent antiviral acitivity to
DENV2 in Huh7it-1 cell culture with half-inhibitory concentration and selectivity index of <10
g/mL and >32.3 for Cassia alata as well as of 12.2g/mL and 15.4 for Cosmos caudatus.
Further studies are needed to be done to confirm and utilize the findings for the development of
dengue antiviral agent. Among those required studies are in vitro study using the remainder
serotypes of DENV, in vivo study, and study to explore the bioactive compounds as well as
inferring its mechanism of action based on the treatment design of the research.
References
1. Bhatt S, Gething PW, Brady OJ, Messina JP, Farlow AW, Moyes CL et.al. The global
distribution and burden of dengue. Nature.2013;496(7446):504-3
2. Ministry of Health Republic of Indonesia. Indonesian Health Profile year 2014 [Internet].
Jakarta: Kemenkes RI; 2015. Available from:
http://www.depkes.go.id/resources/download/pusdatin/profil-kesehatan-indonesia/profil-
kesehatan-indonesia-2014.pdf
3. Andarwulan N, Batari R, Sandrasari DA, Bolling B, Wijaya H. Flavonoid content and
antioxidant activity of vegetables form Indonesia. Food Chemistry 2010;121:1231-1235
4. Bunawan H, Baharum SN, Bunawan SN, Amin NM, Noor NM. Cosmos caudatus Kunth:
a traditional medicinal herb. Global J Pharmacol 2014; 8(3): 420-6
5. Jayasree R, Prathiba R, Sangavi S, Krishnaveni R, Indumathi R. Immunostimulant
potency of Cassia alata petals in Garra rufa. J Env Biol 2016;37(special issue):1515-
1518
6. Shaheen M, Mostafa S, El-Esnawy N. In vitro and in vivo anti-rotaviral activity of C.
alata extracts. Journal of Research in Applied Sciences 2015:2(3): 63-71
7. Sagnia B, Fedelli D, Casetti R, Montesano C, Falcioni G, Colizzi V. Antioxidant and
anti-inflammatory activities of extracts from Cassia alata, Eleusine indica, Eremomastax
speciosa, Carica papaya and Polyscias fulva medicinal plants collected in Cameroon.
PLOS One 2014;9(8):e103999
8. Igarashi A,Mohamed H, Yusof A, Sinniah M, Tanaka H. production of type-2 Dengue
(D2) monoclonal antibody and cell culture derived D2 antigen for use in dengue IgM-
capture ELISA. Trop Med 1995;37(4):165-173
9. Payne AF, Binduga-Gajewska I. Quantitation of flaviviruses by fluorescent focus assay.J
Virol Methods 2006; 134(1-2):183-9
10. Silva AR, Morais SM, Marques MM, Lima DM, Santos SC, Almeda RR, et al. Antiviral
activities of extracts and phenolic components of two Spondias species against dengue
virus. J Venom Anim Toxins Incl Trop Dis 2011;17(4):406-413
11. Zandi K, Teoh BT, Sam SS, Wong SS, Mustafa MR, AbuBakar S. Novel antiviral
activity of baicalein agains dengue virus. BMC Complement Altern Med 2012;12:19.
12. Zandi K, Teoh BT, Sam SS, Wong SS, Mustafa MR, AbuBakar S. Antiviral activity of
four types of bioflavonoid against dengue virus type-2. Virology. 2011;8:560-11
13. Talarico, LB, Zibetti, RG; Faria PC, Scolaro LA, Duarte ME, Noseda MD et al Anti-
herpes simplex virus activity of sulfated galactans from the red seaweeds Gymnogongrus.
griffithsiae and Cryptonemia crenulata. Int J Biol Macromol 2004;34:6371
14. Fernand VE, Dinh DT, Washington SJ, Fakayode SO, Losso JN, van Ravenswaay RO,
Warner IM. Determination of pharmacologically active compounds in root extracts of
Cassia alata L. by use of high performance liquid chromatography. Talanta 2008;74:896-
902
15. Vijayarekha P, Sengottaiyan N. Phytochemical evaluation, antibacterial activity and
bioactive determination. Indian J Sci Technol 2016;9(5):1-6