Case Digest for the Shiftless: PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. EDWIN CABRERA [ G.R. No.

190175, November 12, 2014 ] 10/10/2017, 9)10 PM

Higit Pa Susunod na Blog Bumuo ng Blog

Case Digest for the Shiftless

Monday, July 20, 2015 Search This Blog

PEOPLE OF T HE PHILIPPINES VS. EDW IN

CABRERA [ G.R. No. 190175, November 12,
2014 ] Case Digests

2016 (56)
PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. EDWIN CABRERA
2015 (6)
[ G.R. No. 190175, November 12, 2014 ]
July 2015 (6)
Facts: FIGUERAS VS JIMENEZ
After receiving information from residents of Sitio Galaxy, Tangke, Talisay, Cebu and a report from a confidential asset DIZON VS CABUCANA
of the illegal drug activities of appellant, police officers conducted a buy-bust operation against appellant. At about 4:30 p.m.,
DOMINGUEZ VS AGLERON
poseur-buyer, together with the confidential asset, approached appellant who was standing outside his house. PO1 Palconit
gave appellant two marked P50.00 bills, while the latter handed to him two plastic sachets containing white crystalline BRUNET VS GUAREN
substance. Thereupon, PO1 Palconit made the pre-arranged signal by touching his head with his right hand. His back-ups then ONG VS DELOS SANTOS
rushed to the scene and simultaneously therewith PO1 Palconit arrested the appellant. He then put the markings "EC" on the
two plastic sachets and brought the same to the Philippine National Police (PNP) Crime Laboratory for forensic examination. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES
VS. EDWIN CABRERA [ G.R....
The chemistry report from the PNP Crime Laboratory later revealed that the white crystalline substance with a total
weight of 0.11 gram inside the two plastic sachets marked with "EC" tested positive for methylamphetamine hydrochloride or
2014 (47)
shabu, a dangerous drug.

Issue:
Whether or not there is compliance with Section 21 of the implementing rules of RA 9165 About Me

Ruling: hashy tags Case Digest

With regard to the non-compliance by the police officers with Section 21 of the Implementing Rules of RA 9165 as
alleged by appellant in his Supplemental Brief, particularly the lack of physical inventory of the seized specimen and the non- View my complete profile
taking of photograph thereof, the Court notes that appellant raised the same only in this appeal. The records of the case is
bereft of any showing that appellant objected before the RTC regarding the seizure and safekeeping of the shabu seized from
him on account of the failure of the police officers to maintain an unbroken chain of custody of the said drugs. The only time anything you want Labels
that appellant questioned the chain of custody was before the CA but not on the ground of lack of physical inventory or non- us to digest?
taking of photograph, but on the alleged gap between the time of confiscation of the specimen and the time of its submission 108811
to the PNP Crime Laboratory. But even then, it was already too late in the day for appellant to do so. 1967
Unsupported
Appellant should have raised the said issue before the trial court. In similar cases, the Court brushed aside the accused's
feature: 1978
belated contention that the illegal drugs confiscated from his person were inadmissible because the arresting officers failed to
[analytics]
comply with Section 21 of RA 9165. "Whatever justifiable grounds may excuse the police officers from literally complying 1983
with Section 21 will remain unknown, because [appellant] did not question during trial the safekeeping of the items seized
from him. Objection to evidence cannot be raised for the first time on appeal; when a party desires the court to reject the 1984
evidence offered, he must so state in the form of an objection. Without such objection, he cannot raise the question for the first
1987
time on appeal.
1988

199
Posted by hashy tags Case Digest at 6:09 PM
1990
Labels: 2014 ], case digest, criminal case, g.r. No. 190175, November 12, PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. EDWIN
1991
CABRERA [ G.R. No. 190175, People vs cabrera, people vs cabrera case digest, ra 9165 Total Pageviews
1992

No comments: 1994

36,958 1997

Post a Comment 1999

2003

2004
Enter your comment...
2005

2007

2008
Comment as: Google Account
2010

2011
Publish Preview
2012

2014

2014 ]

http://casedigestfortheshiftless.blogspot.com/2015/07/people-of-philippines-vs-edwin-cabrera.html Page 1 of 9
Case Digest for the Shiftless: PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. EDWIN CABRERA [ G.R. No. 190175, November 12, 2014 ] 10/10/2017, 9)10 PM

ABSCBN
Newer Post Home Older Post BROADCASTIN
CORPORATION
HONORABLE C
Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom) OF APPEALS

ACAIN vs. HON

INTERMEDIATE
APPELLATE CO

ACME SHOE
COURT OF APP

ACQUITTED

ADALIA B.
FRANCISCO and
MERRYLAND
DEVELOPMENT
CORPORATION
RITA C. MEJIA

ADELIO C. CRU
QUITERIO L.
DALISAY

Adonis Aradillos
Albino Galabo vs
of Appeals

ALBINO JOSEF
OTELIO SANTO

alhambra cigar vs

ALVIN JOSE vs.

PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES

and LUISA DE L
ROSA MENDOZ

and MARK MOL

vs. COURT OF
APPEALS

and THE PHILIP

ENGINEERING
CONSTRUCTIO
COMPANY

and/or AIDA M.
POSADAS vs.
HONORABLE C
OF APPEALS

ANDREW HARV

APOLINARIO
GONZALES vs.
HONORABLE C
OF APPEALS

ARB
CONSTRUCTIO

article 1332

article 1345

Avelina G. Ramo
Al vs. Court of A

AVELINO
CASUPANAN an
ROBERTO CAPI
vs. MARIO LLAV
LAROYA

AZNAR vs.
CHRISTENSEN
DUNCAN

balite vs lim

BANCO DE ORO
REPUBLIC OF T
PHILIPPINES

benjamin dacanay

BIBIANO O.
REYNOSO

borjal vs ca

Brunet vs guaren

BUENAFLOR C
UMALI vs. court
appeals

http://casedigestfortheshiftless.blogspot.com/2015/07/people-of-philippines-vs-edwin-cabrera.html Page 2 of 9
Case Digest for the Shiftless: PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. EDWIN CABRERA [ G.R. No. 190175, November 12, 2014 ] 10/10/2017, 9)10 PM

carmelo vs people

case digest

case igest

cases

casupan vs. laroy

cebu contractors v

CECILIO MEND
vs. THE HONOR
COURT OF APP

CHAN SAU WA
FU YAN FUN vs
MARTINIANO V

CHARLES W. M
vs. E. C.
McCULLOUGH

CILIA T. MORIN
HUSBAND vs. C
OF APPEALS an
ABDON GILIG
No. 108532 Marc

CIR vs kudos cas

digest

civil code

civil law

code of professio
responsibility

COMETA and ST
INVESTMENT T

cometa vs ca

conflict of law

conflict of laws

constitution

constitutional law

constitutional righ

CONSUELAO T.
SANTOS-GUER
and ANDRES
GUERRERO

contract

contract of adhesi

contracts

corporation law

Cresencio vs peop

criminal aw

criminal case

criminal due proc

criminal law

Criminal law case

criminal procedur

criminal procedur

CRISOLOGO

DE PEREZ vs.
GARCHITOREN

deed of sale

dela cruz vs sison

deoble jeopardy

Dizon vs cabucan

DIZON-RIVERA
ESTELA DIZON

Dominguez vs ag

http://casedigestfortheshiftless.blogspot.com/2015/07/people-of-philippines-vs-edwin-cabrera.html Page 3 of 9
Case Digest for the Shiftless: PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. EDWIN CABRERA [ G.R. No. 190175, November 12, 2014 ] 10/10/2017, 9)10 PM

double jeopardy

election law

EMILIO CANO
ENTERPRISES

ENRIQUE
SALAFRANCA
PHILAMLIFE
(PAMPLONA)
VILLAGE

ESTEBAN MOR

ET AL

ET AL.

Evangeline Ladon
People of the
Philippines

February 17

Figueras vs jimen

FLORANTE F.
MANACOP vs. C
OF APPEALS an
MERCANTILE

FRANCISCO
MOTORS
CORPORATION
COURT OF APP

freedom of expre

freedom of the pr

G.R. No. 100468

G.R. No. 107199

G.R. No. 108811

G.R. No. 117890.

September 18

G.R. No. 123298

November 27

G.R. No. 126466

g.r. No. 128096

G.R. No. 132537

October 14

G.R. No. 134787

G.R. No. 141882

G.R. No. 144463

January 14

G.R. No. 145391

G.R. No. 162052

January 13

G.R. No. 164584

G.R. No. 165060

November 27

G.R. No. 168660

G.R. No. 172263

G.R. No. 172697

September 25

G.R. No. 174016

G.R. No. 179859

G.R. No. 181701

January 18

G.R. No. 185920

20

G.R. No. 189328

February 21

g.r. No. 190175

G.R. No. 191721

January 12

http://casedigestfortheshiftless.blogspot.com/2015/07/people-of-philippines-vs-edwin-cabrera.html Page 4 of 9
Case Digest for the Shiftless: PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. EDWIN CABRERA [ G.R. No. 190175, November 12, 2014 ] 10/10/2017, 9)10 PM

G.R. No. 198756

G.R. No. 205015

G.R. No. 50720

26

G.R. No. 71092

G.R. No. 72706

G.R. No. 81756

G.R. No. 82544

G.R. No. 86355 M

G.R. No. 88232

G.R. No. 93239

18

G.R. No. 95902

February 4

G.R. No. 97898 A

11

G.R. No. L-13876

G.R. No. L-19550

G.R. No. L-22196

30

G.R. No. L-23102

24

G.R. No. L-23445

G.R. No. L-24365

G.R. No. L-24561

G.R. No. L-27155

18

G.R. No. L-31703

G.R. No. L-41971

G.R. No. L-47799

G.R. No. L-57848

G.R. No.135619
15

G.R. Nos. 140371

Gr 102485

Gr 128574

Gr 133643

Gr 3580

gr no 110672

Gr no 163770

gr no l-55201

gr no l-65366

GR no. 141066

Grace Christian H
School vs. CA

HARRY S.
STONEHILL

in behalf of the A
BASES COALIT
(ABC) vs. RAMO
BAGATSING G.
L-65366 Novemb

INC

INC.

INC. and JORGE

RAGUTANA

INC. vs. COURT

APPEALS

INC. vs. COURT

INDUSTRIAL
RELATIONS

http://casedigestfortheshiftless.blogspot.com/2015/07/people-of-philippines-vs-edwin-cabrera.html Page 5 of 9
Case Digest for the Shiftless: PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. EDWIN CABRERA [ G.R. No. 190175, November 12, 2014 ] 10/10/2017, 9)10 PM

INC. vs. THE

HONORABLE
HILARION U.
JARENCIO

innocent purchase

IV vs. HON. COU

OF APPEALS

J.L.T. AGRO

JOHN J. BROOK
KARL BECK vs.
JOSE W. DIOKN

JOHN SHERMA
ADRIAAN VAN
ELSHOUT vs.
HONORABLE
COMMISSIONE
MIRIAM DEFEN
SANTIAGO

JOSE B.L. REYE

JOSE MODEQU
vs. HON. AUGU
BREVA FRANCI
SALINAS

JOSE TANEO

jose vs people

JR.

JR. and DORIS A

KELLEY vs.
PLANTERS
PRODUCTS

JUANITA TRINI
RAMOS vs. DAN
PANGILINAN

Lacson vs. Execu

secretary

LAND BANK OF
PHILIPPINES V

land titles and dee

LAUREANO
INVESTMENT &
DEVELOPMENT
CORPORATION
THE HONORAB
COURT OF APP
and BORMAHEC

legal ethics

LEONARDO
CADEMAS AND
DOMINADOR
SORELA

Lim vs ca

Lim vs. CA

Loyola Grand vs.

LUXURIA HOM

MA. MIMIE
CRESCENCIO V
PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES

MANINANG vs.
COURT OF APP

MARY JOSEPHI
GOMEZ and EUG
SOCORRO C.
GOMEZ-SALCE
ROEL

MATTHEWS vs.
TAYLOR

MEAD vs. E. C.
McCULLOUGH

naguit vs nlrc

NATIONAL
MARKETING

http://casedigestfortheshiftless.blogspot.com/2015/07/people-of-philippines-vs-edwin-cabrera.html Page 6 of 9
Case Digest for the Shiftless: PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. EDWIN CABRERA [ G.R. No. 190175, November 12, 2014 ] 10/10/2017, 9)10 PM

CORPORATION
(NAMARCO) vs
ASSOCIATED
FINANCE COM

NENA T. CATUB
and HUSBAND

NERI

NESTOR MEDIC

NICANOR T. SA
vs. COURT OF
APPEALS

Nicodemes Silva
Presiding Judge

NOEL and JANN

BEVERLY STA.
and HINAHON S
INES

November 12

November 15

November 19

NUGUID vs. NU

obligation and co

obligations and co

October 21

Ons vs delos sant

ORENDAIN vs.
TRUSTEESHIP O
THE ESTATE OF
MARGARITA
RODRIGUEZ

PABLITO TANE

PCIB vs CA

PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES

PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES an
IMELDA CARAT

PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES vs
ARNOLD PELIS

PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES vs
RODRIGUEZA

PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES vs
EDISON SUCRO

PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES vs
EDUARDO
DOLLENDO AN
NESTOR MEDIC

PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES V
EDWIN CABRE
G.R. No. 190175

PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES vs
FRANCISCO L.
CALPITO

People of the
Philippines vs. Re
Villanueva y Mar

PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES vs
ROGELIO DOLO
y ESTRADA

People vs cabrera

people vs cabrera
digest

people vs eduarte

people vs tampal

http://casedigestfortheshiftless.blogspot.com/2015/07/people-of-philippines-vs-edwin-cabrera.html Page 7 of 9
Case Digest for the Shiftless: PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. EDWIN CABRERA [ G.R. No. 190175, November 12, 2014 ] 10/10/2017, 9)10 PM

people vs. marti

People vs. Rodrig

persons and famil

relation

petition for review

certiorari

PHILIPPINE
COMMERCIAL
INTERNATIONA
BANK) vs. COU
APPEALS

PHILIPPINE LO
DISTANCE
TELEPHONE CO
[PLDT] vs. THE
NATIONAL
TELECOMMUN
ONS COMMISS
AND CELLCOM

PHILIPPINE
NATIONAL BAN
THE COURT OF
APPEALS

PIONEER
INSURANCE &
SURETY
CORPORATION
THE HON. COU
APPEALS

pioneer vs ca

PISONARCEO
AGRICULTURA
DEVELOPMENT
CORPORATION
NLRC and NATI
FEDERATION O
SUGAR
WORKERSFOO
GENERAL TRA

Pita vs ca

PLAINTIFF-
APPELLEE

PMI COLLEGES
vs.NLRC

pnb vs ca

property

PSE vs. CA

ra 9165

resume practice o

Reyes vs bagatsin

reyes vs bagatsing
digest

reynoso vs ca

ROBERT P. BRO

Romeo Posadas v

ROMULO
VILLAROJO

Ruiz vs ca

Rural bank of sta

vs ca

sale

SAN JUAN
STRUCTURAL A
STEEL FABRICA

san juan structura

vs ca

SANTIAGO vs.
SANTIAGO

sarming vs dy

SEANGIO vs. RE

http://casedigestfortheshiftless.blogspot.com/2015/07/people-of-philippines-vs-edwin-cabrera.html Page 8 of 9
Case Digest for the Shiftless: PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. EDWIN CABRERA [ G.R. No. 190175, November 12, 2014 ] 10/10/2017, 9)10 PM

search and seizur

SENATOR ROBE
JAWORSKI vs.
PHILIPPINE
AMUSEMENT A
GAMING
CORPORATION
SPORTS AND G
ENTERTAINME
CORPORATION

September 30

SERGIO F. NAG
vs. NATIONAL
LABOR RELATI
COMMISSION

SEVERINO C.
BALTAZAR vs.
PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES an
ARMANDO C.
BAUTISTA

Social weather sta

comelec

social weather sta

comelec case dige

SOLANO vs. TH
COURT OF APP

SORIANO MATA
HON. JOSEPHIN
BAYONA

SPOUSES AUTH
KELLEY

stonehill vs diokn

succession

SY vs. Tyson.
corporation law

TAN BOON BEE

CO.

Tatad vs. Garcia

taxation

THE PEOPLE OF
PHILIPPINES vs
NORMANDO D
ROSARIO Y LO
G.R. No. 109633
20

TRADERS ROYA
BANK vs. COUR
APPEALS

ugdoracion vs com

universal robina v

vs. AKUTIN

VS. ANACLETO
OLVIS

VS. ANTONIO
BALANSAG

vs. DR. MANUE

SINGSON

WEST COAST L
INSURANCE CO
GEO. N. HURD

Ethereal theme. Theme images by Jason Morrow. Powered by Blogger.

http://casedigestfortheshiftless.blogspot.com/2015/07/people-of-philippines-vs-edwin-cabrera.html Page 9 of 9