Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Are you willing to have your name used in the thesis and other publications and
presentations that may come from this research project?
Who explained this study to you?
_________________________________________________ 476
I agree to take part in this study: Yes No
Signature of Research Subject:
___________________________________________________
(Printed Name): ______________________________
Date: ______________________________________
I believe that the person signing this form understands what is involved in the study and voluntarily
agrees to participate ______________________________________
Signature of Investigator or Designee: ____________________ Date: __________________
THE INFORMATION SHEET MUST BE ATTACHED TO THIS CONSENT FORM AND A
COPY GIVEN TO THE RESEARCH SUBJECT 477
APPENDIX VI a: Information Letter for Interview(s) with Sister M. Simone Roach
Title of Research Study: Biography of Sister M. Simone Roach, CSM, Ph.D., Theorist and
Philosopher in the Area of Human Caring
Graduate Student: Margaret Elizabeth Myers, R.N., Ed.D.
707 James Street, Wallaceburg, Ontario, N8A 2P4
(519) 6277655; (519) 6273927
CoSupervisors:
Pauline Paul, PhD, RN Joanne Olson, PhD, RN
Associate Professor, Faculty of Nursing Professor & Associate Dean, Undergraduate Program
3134, Clinical Sciences Building, Faculty of Nursing, 3134, Clinical Sciences Building
University of Alberta University of Alberta, Edmonton, AB, T6G 2G3
Edmonton, AB, T6G 2G3 joanne.olson@ualberta.ca
pauline.paul@ualberta.ca (780) 4926252
(780) 4927479
Background: Over the past decade, I have become increasingly interested in your work and your
model/theory, The Human Act of Caring. I believe that your life and work is significant to the
profession of nursing and Canadian Nursing History. I believe that nurses, including nursing students
will benefit from a more indepth knowledge of you and your work, and that others may choose to
work with or build on the theory of caring you have developed. 478
Purpose: You are being requested to take part in a number of interviews (one or more), in which I
will ask you questions about your professional life and the events surrounding the development of the
model/theory, The Human Act of Caring. Of special interest to me are the aspect of relational
ethics, spirituality, and components of caring, the value of your model/ theory to present and future
nurses, and the depth to which this theory has been developed.
The will visit you at your place of residence, Bethany House, Sisters of St. Martha Convent,
Antigonish, Nova Scotia, Canada. I will interview you about your personal and professional life,
including the development of your model/ theory, The Human Act of Caring. This information will
be gathered for the purpose of writing a biography of your life and work. Interviews will be tape
recorded and transcribed to a print document which will be given to you to ensure that content is
correct. You will be given the opportunity to change any information provided at that time.
I believe that your life and work is significant to the profession of nursing and Canadian Nursing
History. I believe that nurses, including nursing students will benefit from a more indepth
knowledge of you and that others may choose to work with or build on the theory of caring you have
developed.
It is not expected that these interviews will negatively impact you. In fact, conversations with you in
the process of planning for this project has led me to believe that you enjoy talking about caring in
nursing, and that you believe in the benefits of sharing knowledge that will help future generations of
nurses.
As we have discussed, there is no pressure for you to take part in the project at all, and you can quit
at any time. There will be no consequences for quitting the project or refusing to answer any of my
questions.
Because of the nature of this project, the written report will be a public document. Your name will be
used in the report, as the purpose of the report will be to describe your life and work.
I am requesting you to read and sign a consent form prior to taking part in interviews. If you have
questions, you can address them to me at (519) 6277655. You can also contact Dr. Pauline Paul or Dr.
Joanne Olson.
Procedures: Participating in this study will involve: 479
a) Prearranged visits by me to your place of residence, for interviews (conversations) that will be
examined for content to include in the biography. In addition, I am asking that you allow me to
taperecord some of our telephone conversations.
b) Interviews will be taped, transcribed to text and given to you to examine for accuracy. At that
time, you will have the opportunity to change, delete or add any part of the transcript. Upon reading
the transcribed interviews, you may remember something not already included, which can then be
added.
Confidentiality: Because of the nature of this project, your name will appear in the final report and
any publications that may come from this study. However, you will have the opportunity to read and
comment on any and all contributions before publication.
Participant Initials: _________________________ Witness Initials: _________ 480
APPENDIX VI b: Consent Form for Interview(s) with Sister M. Simone Roach
Title of Research Study: Biography of Sister M. Simone Roach, CSM, Ph.D., Theorist and
Philosopher in the Area of Human Caring
Graduate Student: Margaret Elizabeth Myers, R.N., Ed.D.
707 James Street, Wallaceburg, Ontario, N8A 2P4
(519) 6277655; (519) 6273927
CoSupervisors:
Pauline Paul, PhD, RN Joanne Olson, PhD, RN
Associate Professor, Faculty of Nursing Professor & Associate Dean, Undergraduate Program
3134, Clinical Sciences Building, Faculty of Nursing, 3134, Clinical Sciences Building
University of Alberta University of Alberta, Edmonton, AB, T6G 2G3
Edmonton, AB, T6G 2G3 joanne.olson@ualberta.ca
pauline.paul@ualberta.ca (780) 4926252
(780) 4927479 481
Part 2 (to be completed by the research subject) Yes No
Do you understand that you have been asked to be in a research study?
Have you read and received a copy of the attached Information Letter?
Do you understand the benefits/risks involved in taking part in this research study?
Do you understand that we will tape your telephone interview?
Has the issue of confidentiality been explained to you?
Do you understand who has access to the information you provide?
Have you had an opportunity to ask questions and discuss this study?
Do you understand that you are free to withdraw from the study at any time,
without having to give a reason?
Are you willing to have the audiotape and typed version of your interview(s)
archived at the Archives of the Bethany Mother House?
Are you willing to have your name used in the thesis and other publications and
presentations that may come from this research project?
Who explained this study to you?
_________________________________________________ 482
I agree to take part in this study: Yes No
Signature of Research Subject:
___________________________________________________
(Printed Name): ______________________________
Date: ______________________________________
I believe that the person signing this form understands what is involved in the study and voluntarily
agrees to
participate ______________________________________
Signature of Investigator or Designee: ____________________ Date: __________________
THE INFORMATION SHEET MUST BE ATTACHED TO THIS CONSENT FORM AND A
COPY GIVEN TO THE RESEARCH SUBJECT 483
APPENDIX VII: Interview guide for Interview(s) with Sister Roach
1. Can you tell me about what it was like growing up in your hometown? In your family?
2. Did your family/school/others impact your decision to become a nurse?
3. Can you tell me about your nursing training? Why did you choose that particular school?
4. Did your family/school/others impact your decision to become a woman religious?
5. Why did you choose the community of St. Martha?
6. Can you tell me about your early nursing years?
7. You returned to school several times, to complete undergrad, masters and doctoral studies. I would
like to hear about your experiences and your commitment to continuing education.
8. Can you tell me about your teaching years? Your research? What was influencing your thoughts
and ideas?
9. I have been interested in your caring model since I first heard about it more than a decade ago. Can
you speak about how the model relational ethics? How it informs nursing ethics/ how it informs
spiritual care giving? 484
10. What are your views on spiritual assessment? Have you used your own model to do spiritual
assessment? Can you see the development of a spiritual assessment tool coming from your model?
11. You were involved with developing the first Code of Ethics for nursing in Canada. Can you tell
me about that process?
12. I believe your model informs whole person care. You were writing at a time when there really
wasnt much being said in the profession of nursing on whole person care? What people, writings,
philosophy informed your concepts?
13. You have spoken about your relationship to the International Center for Human Caring. How
would you say your own philosophy fits with the philosophy of the Center?
14. How did you become involved with the Center? How did the Center influence your thinking?
Your work? (I understand that your theory was already developed at the time you became involved
with the Center)
15. You have mentioned others who write and research in the area of human caring. However, much
of this is new to nursingin the past few decades. Why is there a focus on human caring in nursing
NOW, do you suppose, rather than earlier in the development of the profession?
16. In writing this biography, I am also looking at the history of St. FX and the history of the
community of St. Martha (in Canada and in Nova Scotia). Were you 485
especially influenced by the philosophy of the Marthas? By the philosophy of St. FX?
17. I am also looking at what else was happening in Canada and in Nova Scotia at the time you were
conceptualizing your theory. What do you see as national, provincial or local happenings that
impacted on your thinking?
18. In terms of scholarly writing in Canada in the 60s, 70s and 80s, can you think of anything that
impacted your own thinking?
19. How did you perceive yourself, ie, as a theorist, over the years? (I am thinking about myself as a
nurse and Anglican priest, and there is that voice inside the head that says, do not promote yourself
be humble, etc.) Can you relate to this at all, and how would it have influenced your thoughts of
yourself as a theorist?
20. I have heard lots of people say, Roach is a well kept Canadian secretyou hear about Roach
from American nursing leaders before you hear about her here in Canada. In fact, just about
everyone I know who has learned about the Roach theory has learned about it from someone in the
US. Why is this? What are your thoughts on this?
21. As nurses, we are aware of the predominance of US nursing theorists. I realize the implication of
publishing, however there really does not seem to be much happening to celebrate the work of
Canadian nurses. Would you agree with that statement? Why or why not? 486
22. I know that others have used your model in education and research. What is your vision for the
model/theory? 487
Appendix VIII: Interview Guide for Interview (s) with other Study Participants
Before the interview, it would be useful if you could spend some time reflecting on Sister Roach and
what you best remember about her. During the time of the interview, I do not expect to be asking a
lot of questions. Rather, I would like to listen, and allow you to express your thoughts. I may ask a
few occasions for clarity, or ask you to expand on something you have said. Here are some questions
that may help you in reflecting about Sister Roach before our interview.
1. When did you know Sister? What else was going on at that time in the organization? In the
province or state? In the nursing profession? In health care, or in the church?
2. If Sister was your leader (or teacher) when you knew her best, what thoughts come to mind about
her leadership? About her teaching?
3. When did you first lean about Sisters caring model? How would you describe this approach to
patient care? to people in relationships?
4. Did Sister influence any decisions youve made in your professional or personal life?
5. If you have been mentored by Sister Roach, can you describe this mentorship process?
6. If you worked with Sister Roach, how was your work relationship? How did Sister Roach present
her views? What kind of colleague was she?
7. Has your nursing care been impacted by Sisters model/theory? How?
8. In your opinion, how does Sisters work inform nursing ethics/ how does it inform spiritual care
giving?
9. What are your views on spiritual assessment. Do you (or have you in the past) conducted spiritual
assessment on your patients? Can you see the development of a spiritual assessment tool coming
from Sisters work?
10. Sister was involved with developing the first Code of Ethics for nursing in Canada. Were you a
nurse in Canada at that time? What do you know or remember about the reaction to her work? 488
11. Sister talks about whole person care. She was writing at a time when there really wasnt much
being said in the profession of nursing on whole person care. What are your thoughts on that?
12. How do you perceive Sister Roach, ie, as a theorist?
13. I have heard lots of people say, Roach is a well kept Canadian secretyou hear about Roach
from American nursing leaders before you hear about her here in Canada. In fact, just about
everyone I know who has learned about the Roach theory has learned about it from someone in the
US. Why is this? What are your thoughts on this?
14. As nurses, we are aware of the predominance of US nursing theorists. I realize the implication of
publishing, however there really does not seem to be much happening to celebrate the work of
Canadian nurses. Would you agree with that statement? Why or why not?
15. What do you think has been the most important contribution of Sister Roach?
16. Tell me about Sister Roach, the person. How would you best describe Sisters personality? 489
i Presentism is the philosophical doctrine that only events and entities that occur in the present exist. According to presentism, events and entities that
are wholly past or wholly future do not exist at all.
Appendix IX: Estimated Expenses for Research Project
Note that figures are Activity Estimated Cost
estimates only.
Approximate Date
Winter/Spring 2011 Travel to Nova Scotia (at 1,800.00
least 3 more times) 180.00
St. Francis Xavier 800.00
University Archives
College of Registered
Nurses of Nova Scotia
The Casket, Antigonish
Newspaper
Meet with James
Cameron, Historian
Interview Sisters at St.
Marthas Motherhouse
Nova Scotia Nurses
Union
Flight to Halifax
Bus from Halifax to
Antigonish
Acc
ommodations
Winter/Spring 2011 Travel to at least 5 4,000.00
Canadian/American 1,850.00
locations to interview
participants/searches
Flights
Accommodation
Winter/Spring 2011 Cost of Transcription of 1,500.00
Interviews
Throughout Books, photocopying, 800.00
other materials/expenses
Throughout Telephone costs 500.00
11,430.00