CIVIL PROCEDURE

ASSIGNED CASES: JURISDICTION

I. Definition: Jurisdiction
1. People v. Mariano 71 SCRA 600
2. Auhiyong v. CBA 19 SCRA 10
3. Dacoycoy v. IAC 195 SCRA 645

II. Definition: Judicial Power

Art. VIII, Sec. 1 of the 1987 Constitution
4. Lopez v. Rojas 17 SCRA 756
5. Roberto v. Torres 100 Phil 1098

III. Distinction: Jurisdiction and judicial power (Who determines jurisdiction to be exercised by the court?)
6. Bacalso v. Ramolete 21 SCRA 519
7. Zamora v. CA 183 SCRA 279
8. De Jesus v. Garcia 19 SCRA 554
9. Amigo, et. al. v. CA 253 SCRA 382, GR. No. 102833, 1996
10. Francel Realty Corp. v. CA GR. No. 117051, January 22, 1996
11. Phil. Soap Derby v. CA GR. No. 108115, October 27, 1995
12. Malaloan v. CA 232 SCRA 249
13. Ramon Felipe v. Eleuterio GR. No. L-44640, May 20, 1952
14. Lions Club International v. Amores 121 SCRA 621
15. Calimlim v. Ramirez 118 SCRA 211
16. Tijam v. Sibonghanoy 533 SCRA 19
17. Santiago v. Vasquez 217 SCRA 633
18. Spouses Gonzaga v. CA GR. No. 144025, December 27, 2002
19. ___________________ GR. No. 139791, December 12, 2003
20. US v. Caete 58 SCRA 253

IV. Jurisdiction over subject matter

21. La Naval Drug Corp. v. CA GR. No. 103200, August 31, 1994
22. Reyes v. Diaz 73 Phil 484
23. ___________________ 72 Phil 511

V. What determines whether a court has jurisdiction?

24. Orosa v. CA 193 SCRA 391
25. Comart Phils. Inc. v. SEC 198 SCRA 73
26. Sumulong v. CA 232 SCRA 72
27. Bautista v. Fernandez 38 SCRA 553

VI. Jurisdiction over the issue

28. Reyes v. Diaz Supra (#22)
29. Viajar v. CA 168 SCRA 405

VII. Jurisdiction over the respondent

30. Rayray v. Chai 18 SCRA 450
31. Republic v. Ben Torang 17 SCRA 822 (322)?
32. Quasha v. Tuan 118 SCRA 505
33. Heirs of Banco Espaol Fil. v. Palanca 37 Phil 921

VIII. Jurisdiction over subject matter vs. jurisdiction over a particular case
34. Heirs of Banco Espaol Fil. v. Palanca Supra (#33)
35. Dumlao v. Quality Plastic Prods. Inc. 70 SCRA 475
36. Ching v. CA 181 SCRA 9

Ilya Kristine Rivera Ravanera

CIVIL PROCEDURE

IX. General jurisdiction

37. Davisa v. Montecillo 27 SCRA 822
38. La China v. Sales 71 SCRA 262

X. Limited special jurisdiction

39. Garcia v. Sandiganbayan GR. No. 114135, October 7, 1994
40. Hojas v. Grey 132 SCRA 75

XI. Original jurisdiction

41. Ong v. Parrel 156 SCRA 768

XII. Appellate jurisdiction

42. Villegas v. Legaspi 113 SCRA 39
43. Agustin v. Bacalan 135 SCRA

XIII. Exclusive jurisdiction

44. Ong v. Parrel Supra (#41)

XIV. Concurrent jurisdiction

45. St. Ann Medical Center v. Parrel 176 SCRA 785
46. Monsilac v. CA 178 SCRA 153

XV. Criminal, civil, terrestrial, extraterrestrial jurisdiction

47. ___________________ 16 Corpus Juris 147
48. Mendoza v. Batangas Transpo. Comp. 90 (19?) Phil 804
49. Republic v. Asuncion GR. No. 108208, March 11, 1992

XVI. Legal and equity jurisdiction

50. Heirs of Roman Soriano v. CA 198 SCRA 529
51. Portia v. Franco 41 Phil 280

XVII. Jurisdiction vs. exercise of jurisdiction

52. Lamayan v. Dela Cruz 40 SCRA 101 (11?)
53. Dela Cruz v. IAC 134 SCRA 41

XVIII. Errors of jurisdiction vs. errors of judgment

54. Pasingit v. Masabayan 2 SCRA 962
55. Day v. RTC of ZAmboanga City 191 SCRA 610

XIX. Jurisdiction vs. procedure

56. Hule/Cooley v. CA 74 SCRA 189
57. Manila ______ v. Attorney General 20 Phil 523

XX. Jurisdiction vs. venue

58. Consolidated Bank and Trust Company v. IAC 198 SCRA 34
59. Dacoycoy v. IAC Supra (#3)

XXI. Doctrine of hierarchy of court

60. Vergara v. Suelto 156 SCRA 753

XXII. Judicial stability

61. Algo Buntiong v. Savo 163 SCRA 237

XXIII. Supreme court jurisdiction

Ilya Kristine Rivera Ravanera

 CIVIL PROCEDURE

BP 129
Art. VIII, Secs. 1, 2 and 5 of the 1987 Constitution
62. Schneckenburger v. Moran 63 Phil 249
63. Vergara v. Suelto Supra (#60)
64. Filna Bank Employees v. Estanislao 227 SCRA 804
65. Commendador v. De Villa 200 SCRA 80
66. De Guzman v. Sandiganbayan GR. No. 103276, April 11, 1996
67. PNB v. CA GR. No. 108870, July 14, 1995

XXIV. Supreme court en banc

Art. VIII, Sec. 4 of the 1987 Constitution
68. Ortigas v. Velasco GR. No. 109645, March 4, 1996
69. Manalo v. Gloria GR. No.106692, September 1, 1994
70. Gelindon v. De La Rama GR. No. L-105072, December 9, 1993

XXV. Court of appeals jurisdiction

Sec. 9 of BP 129 as amended
71. Domingo v. CA GR. No. 102360, March 20, 1996
72. Mendoza-Parker v. CA GR. No. 109219, March 11, 1994
73. Morales v. CA GR. No. 126623, December 12, 1997

XXVI. RTC jurisdiction

Sec. 19 of BP 129
74. De Jesus v. Garcia 19 SCRA 554
75. Raymundo v. CA 213 SCRA 457
76. Singson v. Isabela Sawmill 68 SCRA 622
77. Bembo v. CA GR. No. 116845, November 29, 1995
78. PNB v. Pineda 197 Phil 1
79. Gutierrez v. CA 193 SCRA 437
80. Santos v. Bayhon 199 SCRA 523
81. Oblea, et. al. v. CA GR. No. 117389, May 11, 1995
82. Manliguez v. CA GR. No. 92598, May 20, 1994
83. Mendoza v. Teh GR. No. 122646, March 14, 1997
84. De Leon v. CA GR. No. 96107, June 19, 1995

XXVII. Family Court jurisdiction

RA 8369, Sec. 5

XXVIII. MTC jurisdiction

Secs. 33-35 of BP 129
85. RCBC v. The Hon. Isnani GR. No. 117383, March 5, 1995
86. Semira v. CA GR. No. 76031, March 2, 1994

XXIX. Concurrent jurisdiction of the SC, CA and RTC

Art. VIII, Sec. 5 of the 1987 Constitution
Secs. 9 and 21 of BP 129

XXX. Katarungang Pambarangay

Secs. 399, 408, 409, 411 and 412 of the LGU Code
87. Domingo v. Lucero 173 SCRA 135
88. San Miguel v. Gondola ? 173 SCRA 704
89. Beher v. CA 169 SCRA 566
90. Diu V. CA GR. No. 115213, December 19, 1995

Ilya Kristine Rivera Ravanera