Professional Documents
Culture Documents
EUR 226
OFFSHORE
PETROLEum
EXPLOSION PROTECTION FOR DIESEL ENGINES OFFSHORE conFEREnCE
&EXHIBITion
152
flammable in question. One could argue that this d) Exhaust system requires no protection if led
specification is self contradictory in the sense to safe a~ea and fitted with and efficient
that if surface temperatures should be limited spark arrestor. However, a flammable" gas
to the auto-ignition temperatures of the flammable sensor may be required (See (b) above) [lOJ
present, then this criterion should apply to the
entire temperature range. e) An exhaust flametrap is not required if (d)
above is satisfied but precautions should be
STARTING SYSTEMS taken to limit surface temperatures particu-
larly if the exhaust ducting leaks through a
Normally non-electric starting systems are hazardous area. This could be accomplished by
preferred (pneumatic, hydraulic, mechanical). means of engine shutdown on high exhaust duct
Flameproof electric starting is occasionally used temperature.
but is limited in choice. On mobile equipment
slave electric starting may be used involving f) Access through an air lock system.
the removal of starter battery and wiring of the
standard starter motor to a plug and socket MOBILE DIESEL ENGINES
connection for use in a safe area.
Examples of these would include forklift trucks,
ANCILLARY EQUIPMEN'l2. portable compressors, etc. Ideally these items are
restricted for use in designated safe areas only
1. Turbochargers: Normally aspirated engines are but allowed in Zone 2 open deck areas if protected.
preferred but if turbochargers are called for The protection requirements for the engine are as
they should be water cooled. follows:
2. Exhaust Discharge: This should occur at a a) Surface temperature should be limited to a value
safe height and preferably into a safe area. less than the auto-ignition temperature of the
flammable media in question.
3. Fan Belts: These should be of the anti-static
type. b) Starting systems are preferably non-electric
or flameproof IJ.1J
4. Crankcase Explosion Relief: A relief valve
is not called for on engines h~ving a c) The use of electrical equipment, for example,
crankcase volume smaller than O.5m . lights, gauges etc., is acceptable if the
equipment complies with the relevant onshore
OFFSHORE GUIDELINES [2 ] specification for electrical equipment in
hazardous areas D-1J and if the equipment is
For offshore installations, ideally the engine installed in accordance with the Code of
is not placed in an area designated as hazardous. Practice [12J
Where it is necessary to use a space in a hazardous
area to house combustion equipment or engines, d) An exhaust flametrap is recommended as well as
then pressurisation of this space is acceptable a spark arrestor.
to make it safe. The other guidelines regarding
inlet and exhaust systems and the cooling of hot e) An inlet air shutdown control system should
surfaces are similar to those for onshore operation. operate on engine oversp~ed, high exhaust gas
temperature, high coolant temperature, or, in
There has been a tremendous advance in the the case of engines which are not continually
thinking behind protecting diesel engines operating manned, on detection of flammable gas by a
in hazardous areas offshore and in the technology detector placed on the equipment.
available to achieve these ends. Current thinking
in the Department of Energy and Lloyds Register f) A fire extinguisher should also be added to the
of Shipping distinguishes between fixed and mobile equipment.
diesel equipment [, ~. A brief description of
these points is given below. g) Consideration should be given to the use of
double walled, high pressure fuel injection
STATIONARY DIESEL ENGINES pipes to eliminate the possibility of a pipe
fracture spraying diesel fuel over the engine
Ideally fixed installations are sited in a surfaces.
pressurised room [2J. The following specifi-
cations should also apply: h) Provision of maintenance in accordance with the
manufacturer's handbook.
a) A shutdown device to prevent overspeeding
HOW THE GUIDELINES ARE MET IN PRACTICE
b) A flammable gas sensor in the engine intake
air system, if flammable gas is suspected in From what has been stated above it should be
this region. The gas sensor should be capable clear that there are no hard and fast rules regarding
of activating engine shut down. the specification of diesel engines operating in
c) Temperature limitation is not required if the hazardous areas offshore. This leaves the designer
engine can be placed in a pressurised room. and offshore engineer with considerable scope to
achieve a safe operating system. Ultimately, however
153
an acceptable specification must be achieved within form a hazard, there are other factors which need
the practical guidelines of cost and time and when consideration. One of these is whether or not the
these two additional factors are fed into the equipment will be constantly attended or unattended
equation, the specification itself becomes of para- in normal operation. A number of standard systems
mount importance. Bearing in mind the almost are available ranging from the basic to the fully
unlimited range of engine sizes and manufacture, with comprehensive. The simplest system for use in
both fixed and portable installations operating areas nominally designated as "safe", having no
offshore, it is important to attempt some higher than a TI rating~ includes a manually operated
rationalisation in the design of safety systems for induction air shutdown valve, inlet flametrap and
diesel engines. Superimposed on the guidelines exhaust spark arrestor.
referred to above will be the operational problems
and constraints the diesel engine must meet. For unattended equipment in Zone 2 areas having
Fortunately with modern designs a wide variety of no higher than a T3 rating, two automatically
engine protection systems are available. operating systems are available. On both, the shut-
down is automatically effected when the engine
For operating in designated safe areas a diesel exceeds (typically) 20% above the rated speed or the
engine requires no particular additional form of exhaust gas temperature attains the critical level.
protection to make it acceptable. If the safe area All of the features mentioned in the previous
is created by virtue of ventilation or pressurisation paragraph are incorporated plus exhaust system
then the precautions referred to above should be surface temperature Ilmltatlon and flametrap.
observed [2] . It is frequently advantageous, for Alternative control systems are available. One
purely operational reasons, to fit some form of uses engine oil pressure to provide a failsafe
overspeed protection and engine manufacturers often activating source. The other employs a low voltage
provide such a device as part of the engine itself. intrinsically safe electrical activation, and is
required where CO introduction to the induction
For operation in Zone 2 hazardous areas, one system is require~. Where protection to temperature
must distinguish between mobile and fixed equipment class T3 is required, the additional protection
and give some consideration to the area in which the dictated by the lower temperature limit, is achieved
equipment will operate (for example, on the open by the introduction of a water cooled exhaust
deck or in a sheltered area). manifold and exhaust gas heat exchanger along with a
larger radiator. An example of this system is shown
STATIONARY DIESEL ENGINES in Figure 3.
Stationary engines are normally larger than EXHAUST GAS HEAT EXCHANGE SYSTEMS
75 kW and examples of these are shown in Figures 1
and 2. Figure 1 shows a General Motors 8V 92 engine It is appropriate at this stage to comment in
rated at 215 kW at 35 rev/s operating a screw type some detail on the design of cooling systems for
air compressor. Surface temperatures have been diesel engines operating in hazardous areas offshore.
limited to 250 0 C by the addition of specially Normally shell-and-tube heat exchangers are used to
designed shell-and-tube heat exchangers and water lower the exhaust temperature to a safe level and to
cooled bellows and manifolds. No inlet flametrap resist internal explosions, they are frequently
is provided at the request of the client company, required to pass a 1 MPa hydraulic test. Considerable
as it is considered that the Roots type scavenge care is required in designing component installation
blower used on this engine acts as an effective and layout within usually confined engine compart-
flametrap. No exhaust flametrap is provided since ments. Heat exchangers are normally of single pass
the exhaust is led to a safe area. This system construction but two pass systems have been used,
will automatically shut down in the event of over- where a higher specific heat exchange/bulk perfor-
speeding, high exhaust temperature, loss of engine mance is required. Due to the requirement for
coolant, or low oil pressure. explosion resistance, exhaust gas is piped through
the tube side and the shell is filled with cooling
Figure 2 illustrates a Caterpillar 3412 engine water connected to the engine coolant system.
rated at 375 kW at 30 rev/s operating an offshore Modified radiators and cooling fans are usually
crane. Parallel inlet flametraps are provided along necessary to dissipate the extra heat rejected to
with a heat exchanger and exhaust system spark coolant, which can attain levels 100% above those
arrestors. emanating from the basic engine cooling requirements
alone.
Each of the engines in Figures I and 2 were
limited to surface temperatures of 250 0 C. To Heat transfer between gas and water is a
achieve this specification has meant the special function of heat transfer coefficients occurring
design and construction of heat exchangers. If the in the following places:
specification had allowed for a surface temperature
of 450 0 C, then it is very likely that an exhaust a) Between gas and tube,
gas heat exchanger would not have been required
and the overall engineering cost/time parameters b) Through the metal of the tube,
would have been considerably reduced.
c) From the tube to the water.
MOBILE DIESEL ENGINES
Suitable allowance in the design must be made
Having established the zone classification. of the for the effect of fouling on the heat transfer
area in which the equipment is to be'operated and coefficient. The first of the above items is the
the T rating of the gases or substances liable to controlling factor. The principal variables
154
affecting thermal performance of heat exchangers and reduce cost of temperature limitation.
are as follows:
USE OF FLAMMABLE GAS DETECTORS
1. The logarithmic mean temperature difference
between the gas and water. In practical terms The offshore guidelines referred to above
this means that the gas is progressively more call for the positioning of flammable gas detectors
difficult to cool as its temperature has in areas where gas may be present due to leaks or
dropped so that for an inlet temperature of, abnormal operating conditions. Stationary engine
o
say 550 C, an exit temperature of 200 0 C is shut down, upon detection of flammable gas, may
dis-proportionately more difficult to achieve occur through the platform fire and gas detection
than 250C. It is therefore important to system or through a dedicated gas detector placed
avoid specifying lower temperatures than in the vicinity of the engine. Which system is
necessary. preferred depends upon detailed considerations.
For example individual flammable gas detectors and
2. The tube surface area. This is directly related control units have been supplied to operate shut-
to the size, weight and cost of the cooler. down systems on platform cranes as these are under
Size can be particularly critical in mobile the direct control of the operator (Figure 4).
applications. Operational reasons dictate that the crane operator
should have control over the engine at all times,
3. The Reynolds number of the gas flowing in the for example, during a lift operation. In these
tube. The Reynolds number is a function of cases a manual override and alarm are provided.
the mass flow and is related to the number,
diameter and length, of the tubes. There is a For mobile equipment the preferred method is
trade off to be obtained between high Reynolds for a dedicated gas detection and shutdown system
number (and therefore high heat transfer) and to be fitted. Such equipment must be designed and
low exhaust back pressure (which is specified installed to withstand the obvious harsh environ-
by the engine manufacturer). This requirement ment in offshore conditions and must be compatible
can be difficult to meet when a flametrap and with the automatic shutdown control system operating
spark arrestor or water bath conditioner, are by overspeed, high exhaust temperature, etc. An
incorporated in the exhaust system. In order example of such a system is shown in Figure 5.
to achieve a back pressure within the limits
specified by the engine manufacturer, the Field trials on this system [14J show that the
Reynolds number is frequently lower than one gas detector, when it is properly located, can
would hope for and consequently the tube surface detect gas and shut dOvm the engine well before
area must be increased. explosive concentrations are reached and that this
is a viable system of protection. Reliability
As we have seen on small engines (Figure 3) studies [15J indicate that an improvement in safety
it is usual to mount a heat exchanger rigidly to by several thousand times is possible by the
the engine whilst on larger engines (Figures 1 and 2) addition of such a system.
size and weight considerations may dictate a chassis
mounting. In the latter case the connection from RECENT DEVELOPMENTS
engine to cooler is via a double skinned, water-
jacketed, stainless steel bellows unit, which High Risk Areas: Engines operating in Zone I
isolates the heat exchanger from engine vibrations areas offshore are not permitted at the current time
and accommodates relative movement due to thermal but it is appropriate here to illustrate some of
expansion. Frequently the bellows units are the advances in technology in engine design that
themselves subject to complex loadings and have are occurring. Figure 6 shows a 38 kW power pack
become themselves items of specialist design. modified to comply with Testing Memorandum
No. 12 [7J for operation in coal mines. Major
One additional feature is the pulsating effect engine redesign has taken place to achieve the high
of the gas as it passes through the heat exchanger. standards of flameproofing including stringent
Whilst this is smoothed out for large engines, for exhaust emission standards and surface temperature
small engines, as commonly found in forklift limitation to l50 0 C. Engines are now available to
trucks, this pulsating effect creates a varying this specification and could find use in the future
Reynolds number and therefore varying heat exchanger with regulating authority approval, in operating
performance. as portable power pa'cKs in higher risk areas
offshore, and incidentally in confined areas due
The example in Figure 2 shows the heat ex- to the low level of toxic exhaust emissions.
changer which consists of approximately 300 tubes
l6mm diameter fitted into a shell approximately SUMMARY
500mm diameter and l700mm long, weighing 600 kg.
A heat exchanger of this kind will reduce the Diesel engines operating in hazardous areas
0 o offshore normally divide into one of two categories:
exhaust temperature from 450 C to 250 C, while
maintaining engine manufacturers back pressure mobile equipment and fixed equipment.
requirements. Test results indicate that an Specifications for protection systems divide
enhancement of approxiamtely 25% is achieved in
into the following areas: inlet system, exhaust
heat exchanger performance compared with calcu-
system, shutdown control system, cooling system
lations [2J. In applications where a water supply
and starting system. A further area embracing
is readily and continuously available, alternative
ancillary equipment should also be considered.
methods of temperature reduction involving water
Exhaust systems consist normally of spark arrestors
injection systems are available which can simplify and flametraps unless the exhaust can be ducted to
155
a safe area. A shutdown control system may
operate upon engine ovcrspeed~ high exhaust gas 6. Imperial Chemical Industries: "Specification
temperature, high coolant temperature or low engine for the Protection of Diesel Powered Mobile
oil pressure. In most cases the positioning of Equipment for Use in Zone 2 (Vapour and Gas)",
one or more flammable gas detectors dedicated to Imperial Chemical Industries, Wilton,
the function of engine shutdown and protection, England, 1977.
should be carefully considered. Test results show
that such systems can provide a viable form of 7. Health & Safety Executive: "Testing
diesel engine protection. Memorandum No. 12, Test and Approval of Diesel
and Storage Battery Powered Locomotives and
The design of heat exchangers requires special Trackless Vehicles and Diesel Powered
consideration and is usually a major item in terms Equipment for use in Underground Mines",
of cost and time. It is therefore important to Health and Safety Executive, London,
assess very carefully, the requirement for surface England, 1977.
temperature limitation.
8. Marguerie,N. Senior Mechanical Inspector,
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT Petroleum Engineering Division,Department of
Energy, London, England.
We gratefully acknowledge many useful discussions
with The Department of Energy, L10yds Register of 9. Crawford, J., Senior Engineer Surveyor,
Shipping, Det Norske Veritas, Health & Safety MDAPAD~ L10yds Register of Shipping,
Executive, and wish to thank our colleagues in London, England.
the Engineering Department ofPyroban Ltd., for
their assistance in the preparation of this paper. 10. "Offshore Installations: Guidance on Fire
Fighting Equipment", Department of Energy
Her Majesty's Stationery Office, London, '
REFERENCES England, 1980.
2. "Offshore Installations: Guidance on Design 12. BS5345:Part 1:1976 "Code of Practice for the
and Construction~ Department of Energy, Her Selection, Installation and Maintenance of
Majesty's Stationary Office, London, England, Electrical Apparatus for Use in Potentially
1977, p.113, 114. Explosive Atmospheres", British Standards
Institution, London, England, 1976.
3. BS5908:l980: "Code of Practice for Fire
Precautions in Chemical Plants", British 13. Georgian, J.C. "Some Experimental Results from
Standards Institution, London, England, 1980. a Two-Cycle Diesel Engine Exhaust Waste Heat
Exchanger", Paper No. 60-0GP-13, ASME, New York,
4. Oil Companies Materials Association Publication U.S.A., March 1960.
MEC-l: "Recommendations for the Protection of
Diesel Engines Operating in Hazardous Areas", 14. Grayson, S.J. "Testing of Pyroban Autosense
Oil Companies Materials Association, London, Syste.Jl1" Technical Report No.1, Pyroban Ltd.,
England, 1977. Shoreham, Sussex, England, 1978.
5. BP Standard 200: "Requirements for the 15. Raafat, H.M.N.: "Reliability Study on Pyroban
Protection of Diesel Engines Operating in AS-lOOO system", Technical Report No. 10,
Zone 2 Hazardous Areas", BP Trading Ltd., Pyroban Ltd., Shoreham, Sussex. England, 1980
London, England, 1980.
156
1. AIR CLEANERS
2. WATER COOLED DETROIT
MANIFOLD V8 ENGINE
10
3. WATER COOLED
BELLOWS
4. AFTERCOOLERS
5. FUEL TANKS
6. EXHAUST PIPES
7. SHUT DOWN VALVE
8. SPARK ARRESTORS
9. RADIATOR
10. RADIATOR BAFFLES
11. EXHAUST TEMPERATURE
SWITCHES 4
5
Fig. 2 - PROTECTION OF STATIONARY DIESEL POWERED CRANE. INLET SYSTEM CONTROL SYSTEM (Automatic) OPTIONAL
1 Plate type Inret Ilame trap wIth 7 Engine speed sensor + 20% Mechanical Slal1lng
Integral poppet type aIr shut down 8 Exhaust gas temperature sensor Compressed air starting
valve 195C Hydraulic startIng
2 Fabricated alf Inlet manIfold 9 Coolanllemperature sensor 100C COOLANT SYSTEM
EXHAUST SYSTEM 10 all operated Inlet air shut down 12 Exira capacity radiator
3 Water COOled exhaust manilold actuator 13 Non metallic Ian
.. Tubular exhausl gas heat Emergency overnde val....e 14 Anti slatlc fan belts
exchanger STARTING SYSTEM NOTE: lIems 1, 2. 3, 4, 5 are
Ptate type exhaust llame Irap 11 Slave electriC starter wired to plug pressure tested to 10 Bar
Dry cyclone spark arrestor ~nd socket connection for starting
In safe area
Inert
Gas