You are on page 1of 4

Proceedings of the 19th IAHR-APD Congress 2014, Hanoi, Vietnam

ISBN xxx-xxxx-xx-x

ARSENIC CONTAMINATION IN SHALLOW AQUIFERS OF DONG THAP PROVINCE, VIETNAM:


SOURCE, DISTRIBUTION, SPECIATION AND RELEASE MECHANISM

QUYEN. DO THI THUY (1), AVNER. VENGOSH (2), BRITTANY MEROLA (3), HIEN. TO THI (4)

(1) University of Science Vietnam National University, Ho Chi Minh city, Vietnam, email: dttquyen@hcmus.edu.vn
(2) Nicholas School of the Environment, Duke University, North Carolina, USA, email: vengosh@duke.edu
(3) Nicholas School of the Environment, Duke University, North Carolina, USA, email: rose.merola@duke.edu
(4) University of Science Vietnam National University, Ho Chi Minh city, Vietnam, email: tohien@hcmus.edu.vn

ABSTRACT:

This study investigated the source, release mechanism and speciation of geogenic Arsenic in shallow aquifers in Dong Thap
Province, Mekong delta, Vietnam. The rural areas in Thanh Binh isle and Tan Hong border district were chosen since drilled
wells remain the major fresh water source for drinking and irrigating at these areas. A total of 60 groundwater samples were
collected in February and March, 2012. Field parameters (pH, temperature, DO, EC, Eh) were measured on sites using
portable devices. Water samples were analyzed in laboratory for major ions, total As, As speciation, Fe, Mn and stable
isotopes. The analysis result showed the entirely difference between groundwater chemistry of Thanh Binh and Tan Hong.
Water type in Thanh Binh was Ca(Mg)-HCO3 while the composition in Tan Hong water samples showed variety of types
but mostly Na-Cl. Groundwater in Thanh Binh was predominantly reducing, contrary to the oxidizing condition of Tan
Hong aquifer. Arsenic concentrations also showed spatially heterogeneous distribution over the whole study area.
Groundwater from the shallow aquifers in Thanh Binh was far exceeding the permissible WHO Standard limits as well as
the Vietnam Standard limit of 10 g/L for As. As(III) species was dominant and made up 70% of total As concentration. In
contrast, 100% water samples in Tan Hong contained less than 10 g/L As. Stable isotope 2H and 18O analysis technique
firstly introduced in this area also provide valuable evidence for the difference recharges for groundwater in two research
sites. The reducing condition, high concentration of Fe and HCO3- and the depletion of SO42- indicated reductive dissolution
of the Fe oxyhydroxide as the significant mechanism that released As to Thanh Binh groundwater.
Keywords: arsenic, Dong Thap, groundwater, release mechanism, source.

1. INTRODUCTION groundwater exploited from shallow aquifers as the major


source for drinking and irrigating.
Arsenic poisoning due to drinking groundwater with high
As concentration was considered the most serious disaster
in the history, in term of the number of people exposed. A
2007 study found that over 137 million people in more than
CAMBODIA
70 countries are probably affected by arsenic poisoning of
drinking water. High concentrations of arsenic in
Tan Hong
groundwater are found in various parts of the world,
especially in Ganges delta (India) and Brahmaputra delta
(Bangladesh) where scientist detected the first case of Hong Ngu
chronic As poisoning.
Similarities in geological feature of the fluvial delta in
Vietnam and the delta in India and Bangladesh has initiated Tien River
various research on arsenic in Vietnam since 2000. The Tam Nong
arsenic problem in Red River Delta had been studied in
detail level (Micheal Berg et al. (2001); Flemming et al.
(2008); Pham Quy Nhan (2008)). However, arsenic
Hau River
investigations in Mekong Delta had just initiated recently.
The lack of research and knowledge about the release Thanh Binh
mechanism and source of arsenic in groundwater of this
area has led us to conduct this study.
Cao Lanh
2. MATERIALS AND METHODS

2.1. Research sites 15 km

This study was conducted in March, 2012 in Dong Thap


province, where several previous research in Mekong delta
has reported the high level of As in groundwater. Two Figure 1. Spatial distribution of Arsenic in
selected research sites were Thanh Binh isle and Sa Rai groundwater at research sites
commune, Tan Hong districts. Local people here use

1
The total 55 samples was collected at household wells, all of an absolutely different geological sub-unit. It is located
are at the depth smaller than 80m. 34 samples in Thanh in the outermost of the backswamp and belongs to the high
Bnh isle with the depth from 12-60 m (Holocene and steep natural bank. This feature is also an evidence for
Pleistocene aquifers) gather in the research area of 10 km x arsenic release mechanism in groundwater at Thanh Binh
20 km, all wells are located near Tien River (Figure 1) district, which will be discussed in the following part.
within the average distance of 1 km. The other 21 samples
3.2. Distribution and speciation of arsenic
in Sa Rai commune, Tan Hong district was taken from 15-
73 m deep wells (Pleistocene aquifer) in the area of 10 km x The spatial distribution of the sampling locations as well as
15 km. The average distance from those wells and Tien the As concentrations are shown in Figure 1 Arsenic
River is 15 km. concentrations showed spatially heterogeneous
distribution over the whole study area. Groundwater from
2.2 Sampling and analytical methods
the shallow aquifers in Thanh Binh was far exceeding the
Information on the well depth, the installation year, and its permissible WHO Standard limit of 10 g/L for As (n=34;
geographic coordinates were recorded. To ensure the ranging from 3.22 981.43 ppb; mean value 408.16 ppb). In
oxygen concentration in the water was stable, samples of contrast, 100% of water samples in Tan Hong contained less
groundwater were only taken after 15 min of continuous than 10 g/L As (n=21; ranging from below limit of
pumping. Groundwater were collected following the USGS detection-8.91 ppb; mean value 2.63 ppb).
Protocols. Parameters measured in the field include pH,
Arsenic in all groundwater samples at Thanh Binh was
temperature, conductivity (EC), dissolved oxygen (DO),
composed of a mixture of As(III) and As(V) species. On
and oxidation-reduction potential (ORP).
average, As (III) constituted 79% of the total As, while As
Samples to be analyzed for trace metals were filtered at the (V) consists of only 21% of the total As. This is consistent
site using 0.45 m syringe filters and preserved using nitric with the dominant reduced condition of Thanh Binh
acid. Samples were analyzed for major elements using groundwater when considering the oxidation state of
direct current plasma optical emission spectrometry (DCP- Arsenic from the Eh-pH diagram.
OES), anions by ion chromatography (IC), and trace metals
by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-
MS). Speciation of As was separated in the field and
preserved according to methods in Bednar et al. (2002).
Water was transferred to 60 mL high-density polyethylene
(HDPE) bottles and shipped to Earth and Ocean Sciences
Laboratory, Duke University, USA for chemical analysis.

3. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION


3.1. Field parameters

Table 1. Field parameters data

Thanh Binh (n=34) Tan Hong (n=21)


Parameter
Mean Range Mean Range

pH 7.0 6.7 7.7 6.1 5.8 6.6

Temp oC 29.5 28.7 30.6 29.8 29.3 30.2


Figure 2. As-O-H Eh-pH diagram
EC S/cm 1312 382.6 6330 1540 304.2 3035 3.3. Arsenic release mechanism
DO mg/L 2.1 0.7 4.0 1.32 0.2 3.7 As concentration and Eh value correlation
Eh mV -93 -139 149 182.2 60 261 There is a significant negative Pearson correlation between
total As concentration and Eh value (r= -0.713). Due to the
pH value of all samples range in the normal from 6 - 8.5. fact that As is sensitive with the groundwater oxidation-
Samples taken from Tan Hong are relatively more acidic in reduction potential, it is highly likely that the reduced
comparison to Thanh Binhs. environment is the key factor control the arsenic release in
Thanh Binh shallow aquifer.
There is a remarkable difference in oxidation-reduction
potential value between 2 sampling sites. The shallow 300
aquifer in Thanh Binh District is in reduced condition, 250
ranging from -139 mV to -28 mV. In contrast, the oxidation 200
150
condition is predominant in Tan Hong groundwater, with
100
Eh (mV)

the ORP values range from 60 to 261 mV. The disparity in 50


As (g/L)
geological features of two research sites is supposed to be 0
one of the reasons for this interesting contrast. Thanh Binh -50 0 200 400 600 800 1000 1200

is an isle and belong to the floodplain of Tien River. It -100


receive fluvial sediment annually from Mekong flood -150
-200
during rainy season. The large amount of organic sediment
in alluvial deposit is an appropriate environment for Tn Hng Thanh Bnh
reduced microorganisms to develop and caused the
reduced condition underground. Tan Hong district is part Figure 3. As and Eh value correlation

2
Fe concentration in groundwater isotopes are stable, their concentrations do not change over
the time or through transport processes. As the result, the
High Fe concentration were found in most of the
stable isotope level in specific aquifer is similar to the
groundwater samples of Thanh Binh district, ranging from
recharge water which is, in most of the cases, precipitation
0.36 12.68 ppm, average value is 4.45 ppm. All is above
(e.g. rainwater or snow). Stable isotope research require a
the QCVN 01:2009/BYT standard for drinking water.
large hydrometeorology base data to provide exactly
Meanwhile, the Fe concentration in Tan Hong groundwater
conclusion. However, the only isotope monitoring station
is much lower, ranging from under detection limit to 2.66
of Vietnam is located in Ha Noi and owned by the Global
ppb. The average value is 0.4 ppm, which is ten times lower
Network of Isotope in Precipitation IAEA (working from
in comparison to Thanh Binh.
2004-2007). Thus, research in this field has been limited due
It is obvious to identify the relationship between total As to the shortage of base data. This study is one of the initial
and Fe at two research sites. Pearson statistic showed the research on isotope and aimed to provide several useful
significant positive correlation between Fe and As evidence for the arsenic source in Mekong delta.
concentration (r = 0.708). To be more specific, the
correlation between Fe concentration and As speciation, -30 Variable

e.g. As (V) and As (III), have been examined. Apparently, Thanh Binh
Tan Hong

the correlation between Fe and As (V) is more substantial


-40
than Fe-As(III) correlation.

2H (per mil)
As - Fe -50
1200

1000
-60
800
As (g/L)

600 -70
As total
As tng -10 -9 -8 -7 -6 -5
400 18O (per mil)
As (III)
200
As (V)
0 Figure 5. D and 18O relationship
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14

Fe (mg/L)
Isotope composition of precipitation from all over the
Figure 4. As and Fe correlation world, plotted in 2H versus 18O graphs, are strongly
correlated according to the equation:
This could be explained by the reactions in shallow aquifer D (per mil) = 8. 18O + 10 (Global Meteoric Water Line)
where the reduced condition is predominant:
D and 18O of Tan Hong and Thanh Binh groundwater are
- The dissolution of As (V) from oxyhydroxide Fe (III) well correlated and obtained data fit to the GMWL, shown
in figure 5. This indicates the source of both sites from
- Solid Fe (III) was reduced to soluble Fe(II)
modern rain water. Nevertheless, there is a notable
- Arsenate As (V) was reduced to Arsenite As (III) which disparity in the distribution of D and 18O on the GMWL.
is in non-charged state and therefore, more mobile in The stable isotope concentration in Tan Hong groundwater
aqueous phase. is relatively richer than Thanh Binhs. The average value of
D and 18O is -39 and -5.68 at Tan Hong and
The reduction process is summarized in the following
55.63 and -7.99 at Thanh Binh.
reaction:
Stable isotope concentration in groundwater samples are
4FeOOH(As)+CH2O+7H+ Fe2++HCO3-+6H2O+As(III)+As(V)
similar to local rain water and the evidence of oxidized
As a result of this process, As (V) and Fe (II) were released groundwater in Tan Hong indicated that water is recently
concurrently into groundwater. For that reason, the Fe As recharged, probably from annual flood from July to
(V) correlation is stronger than Fe As (III). November. In contrast, low concentration of stable isotope
and reduced condition of groundwater illustrated the long-
Previous studies have suggested that As release from the
term process groundwater exposed to geological
delta sediments is due to the reductive dissolution of the
components. The isotope value in Thanh Binh is similar to
iron bearing minerals. The As contents of groundwater in
that of Hymalayan rainwater. It is highly likely that
this study were consistently associated with low ORP
groundwater in Thanh Binh is the mixture of surface water
values, which infer reducing conditions. It has been
and groundwater from high altitude area.
demonstrated that during sediment transport under oxic
conditions oxyanion, As species are bound to Fe-oxides, This result is consistent with the research on arsenic source
peat, clay, and other humic substances. Under the delta in Red River Delta (Pham Quy Nhan, 2008), which
reducing conditions As is mobilized to the ambient suggested that As in Himalayan rock and minerals was
groundwater (Micheal Berg et al. 2001; Nguyen Kim dissolved and released to the groundwater through
Phuong 2008; Nickson et al. 2000; Smedley et al. 2002). weathering processes. It is transported to lower terrain
through downstream and underground flows. This is
supported by the distribution of arsenic in groundwater at
3.4. Stable isotope result
the fluvial delta in the southern of Hymalaya Mount.
Stable isotope is a state-of-the-art technique to identify the
groundwater recharge source. The isotope used to discuss
in this study is Deuterium and Oxygen -18. Because those

3
4. CONCLUSION Nguyen Kim Phuong (2008), Geochemical study of arsenic
behavior in aquifer of the Mekong delta, Vietnam, Doctor
Tan Hong and Thanh Binh are much different in geological
Thesis, Kyushu University, Japan.
features and it affects the distribution and speciation of
Arsenic in Dong Thap groundwater. Nguyen Viet Ky (2009), Arsenic Contamination in
groundwater of Mekong Delta, Journal of Science and
Arsenic in Thanh Binh is released from reduction-
Technology Development, Vol.12 (05), 101-121.
dissolution iron oxyhydroxide mechanism. This is
supported by evidences such as groundwater reduced Nickson, R.T., McArthur, J.M., Ravenscroft, P., Burgess,
environment, dominant As (III) speciation, high Fe W.G., Ahmed, K.M. (2000), Mechanism of arsenic
concentration. release to groundwater, Bangladesh and West
Bengal, Applied Geochemistry, 15, 403-413.
The stable isotope result indicated that groundwater in Tan
Hong and Thanh Binh probably have different recharge Pham Quy Nhan (2008), Source and distribution of Amoni
sources. Tan Hong shallow aquifer is recharged by local and Arsenic in aquifers of red River Delta, Report, Ha
rain water. Meanwhile, Thanh Binh groundwater is Noi University of Science.
recharged from different source. It is probably derived Postma, D., Larsen, F., Nguyen Thi Minh Hue, Mai Thanh
from the rain water from Hymalaya mountain. Duc, Pham Hung Viet, Pham Quy Nhan, Jessen, S.,
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS Jakobsen, R. (2007), Mobilization of arsenic in Red
River floodplain, Vietnam: Controlling geochemical
This research was conducted thanks to the cooperation processes and reactive transport modeling,
project between HCMVNU University of Science and Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta, 71, 5054-5071.
Duke University. We are grateful for the valuable guidance
and support form Prof. Avner Vengosh and all the effort in Ravenscroft, P., Burgess, W.G., Ahmed, K.M., Burren, M.,
lab work of Dr. Brittany Merola. Perrin, J. (2005), Arsenic in groundwater of the
Bengal Basin, Bangladesh: Distribution, field relations
REFERENCES and hydrogeological setting, Hydrogeology Journal,
Dowling, C. B., Poreda, R. J., Basu, A. R., Peter, S. L., 13, 7272-751.
Aggarwal, P. K. (2002), Geochemical study of arsenic Smedley, P. L., Kinniburgh, D.G. (2002), A review of the
release mechanisms in Bengal Basin groundwater, source, behaviour and distribution of arsenic in
Water Resource Research, 38, 1-20. natural waters, Applied Geochemistry, 17, 517-568.
Flemming Larsen, Pham Quy Nhan, Nhan Duc Dang, Susan Murcott (2012), Arsenic Contamination in the World:
Dieke Postma, Soren Jessen, Hung Viet Pham (2008), An International Sourcebook, IWA Publishing, USA.
Controlling geological and hydrogeological
processes in an arsenic contaminated aquifer on the UNICEF (2008), Arsenic Primer Guidance for UNICEF
Red River Flood plain, Vietnam, Applied Country Offices on the Investigation and Mitigation of
Geochemistry, 23, 3099-3115. Arsenic Contamination, New York.

Gordon Stanger, To Van Truong, Le Thi My Ngoc, T.V World Bank Technical Report (2005), Towards a more effective
Luyen, Tuyen Tran Thanh (2005), Arsenic in operation response: Arsenic contamination of groundwater
groundwater in the Lower Mekong, Environmental in South and East Asia Countries.
Geochemistry and Health, 27, 341-357.
Hugh Brammer, Peter Ravenscroft (2009), Arsenic in
groundwater: A threat to sustainable agriculture in
South and South-East Asia, Environment
International, 35, 647-654.
Hoang Thi Hanh, Sunbaek Bang, Kyoung-Woong Kim, My
Hoa Nguyen, Duy Minh Dang (2010), Arsenic in
groundwater and sediment in the Mekong River
delta,Vietnam, Environmental Pollution, 158, 2648 -
2658.
IAEA (2001), GNIP Maps and Animations, International
Atomic Energy Agency, Vienna.
Joseph D. Ayotte, Denise L. Montgomery, Sarah M.
Flanagan, Keith W. Robinson (2003), Arsenic in
Groundwater in Eastern New England: Occurrence,
Controls and Human Health Implications,
Environmental Science and Technology, 37, 2075-2083.
Michael Berg, Caroline Stengel, Pham Thi Kim Trang,
Pham Hung Viet, Mickey L. Sampson, Moniphea
Leng, Sopheap Samreth, David Fredericks (2006),
Magnitude of arsenic pollution in the Mekong and
Red River DeltasCambodia and Vietnam, Science
of the Total Environment, 372, 413425.