Professional Documents
Culture Documents
B. Chapters
I. ABSTRACT
This study tackles about the effects of Christianity to the culture and beliefs of the
people in Vietnam especially the ethnic Hmong citizens. This study aims to provide a
descriptive analysis on the issue about the Vietnams problem regarding to the diffusion
of Christianity. It focuses on the ideas that can affect the beliefs of the Hmong ethnic
groups to completely convert to the world of Christianity. Due to the short period of time
that has been given to make this paper, the descriptive analysis of this issue shall only
be done through searching in the internet about the struggle of Vietnam with
Christianity. To some Hmong who chose to stick on their beliefs tends to be afraid of
what might happen to their traditions if the Christianity will continue to grow in their
country. This study will also provide the insights of both Christian and non-Christian
Hmongs about the very confidential issue of the country.
INTRODUCTION
The very essence of religion is the beliefs and practices which is agreed from
one person to another. It is an act of faith where a person shows his or her willingness
towards to what he or she believes. Religion always gets into conflict when it comes to
the culture and tradition. Some traditional acts are way more far from the deeds of the
religion. A lot of people always contest their insights about these two but no one wins
because it is indeed a complicated issue.
The well-known religion in the whole world is the Christianity which is believed
that it is a personal relationship with the creator of heaven and earth; God. Christianity
is one of major problems of Vietnam in these days. Hmong ethnic citizens and even the
youths of Vietnam are already converting to the world of Christianity. Non-believers are
afraid that their traditions might get lost to the eyes and heart of their fellowmen as well
as the upcoming generation of their nation.
Buddhism is the leading or the main religion of Vietnam and was first handled by
the Ly Dynasty (1010-1214) it is also believed that Buddhism is one of the worlds great
religions.1It is clear that Christianity is not for the Vietnamese people, it is not the belief
that their nation was known. But for the 3 decades,Hmongs and other resident of the
country had been converted to the Christianity and it is one of the huge problems that
make other Vietnamese worried about. Hmongs are enlightened with the beliefs of the
Christianity that made them influence more people but this doesnt mean that they are
already a bad and an anomalous people to their own country as well as to their own
culture and tradition.
II.
A. STATEMENT OF THE PROBLEM
1. How did the Hmong ethnic group engage to the realm of Christianity?
2. What are the effects of the Christianity to the tradition and cultures of the
Hmongs or the Vietnamese people?
3. Are there any propaganda that Vietnam proposed to prevent the growth of
Christianity and the transformation of religion?
B. METHODOLOGY
Method
This study is a descriptive research analysis about the issue of Christianity in the
country of Vietnam.
Data Gathering
The researcher used only the internet resources such as Google, Youtube and other
legitimate websites.
Data Gathering Procedure
The gathered data or information from different internet resources shall be used to
provide the claim of the study regarding the issue about the struggle of Vietnam in
the sense of religion.
Scope and Limitation
The research will only focus to the explanations and deeds of the converted
Christian Hmongs on how they were enlightened to the art of Christianity as well as
1
Te, H. D., Religion of the Vietnamese, http://www.vietspring.org/religion/religioninvn.html,
Accessed November 20, 2017
will focus to the concerns of the Non-Christian Hmongs to the tradition and cultures
of their native land.
III.
REVIEW OF THE RELATED LITERATURES
2
Philippine Demographics Profile 2017,
http://www.indexmundi.com/philippines/demographics_profile.html, Accessed November 20,
2017
3
Russell, S., Christianity in the Philippines,
http://www.seasite.niu.edu/crossroads/russell/christianity.htm,
Accessed November 20, 2017
just based on the aptitude of a religion in order to provide an answer to all questions of
a person regarding to the concerns and needs in different aspect of cultural settings.
4
Religious practices in the Philippines,
http://www.philippines.abouttravelingtheworld.com/philippines-culture/philippines-
religion/religious-practices-in-the-philippines/, Accessed November 21, 2017
when it became the leading religion in the country. It influences Filipinos in different
aspects.5
Literature and Drama, Architecture and Sculpture, Music and Dance and the form
of society are some of the influences of Christianity to Filipino culture. Christianity
inspired most of the Filipino people to learn how to write profoundly, it helps the Filipinos
to engage in writing about churches and religions. Christianity also influenced Filipinos
in Architecture and Sculpture. Most of the works of the Filipinos are churches of course
as well as schools and houses. The art of Music and Dance were already in the tradition
of the country Philippines but Christianity made it more meaningful. Chants, songs such
as pasyon, and dances in every feast are one of the influences of Christianity in the
world of music and dance. Lastly, is the form of society which focuses on our everyday
lives and traditions we have witnessed such as weddings, burials, house blessings,
family orientations and a lot more.
Truly it is that the Filipinos are really religious. The combination of animism and
Christianity made a great outcome in our country. The influences of the Christianity to
the Filipino culture gave a lot of transformation not only in the country itself but also In
the lives of the Filipinos.
5
Delgado, K., Influence of Christianity to Filipino culture,
https://www.scribd.com/doc/20517008/Influences-of-Christianity-to-Fil-Culture, Accessed
November 21, 2017
that time until now the reason why we cannot blame our fellowmen who are still
practicing their own religions.6
6
The spread of Christianity in the Philippines, Pro Essay, professional writing service,
http://www.proessay.com/buy-essay-on-the-spread-of-christianity-in-the-philippines/, Accessed
November 21, 2017
Pew noted that Christianity had grown enormously in sub-Saharan Africa and the
Asia-Pacific region, as their Christian populations climbed from nine percent in 1910 to
63 percent in 2010 in the former, and from three percent to seven percent in the latter.
Christianity today, unlike a century ago, is truly a global faith, Pew said.7
7
De Guzman, L., Philippines still top Christian country in Asia, 5th in world,
http://globalnation.inquirer.net/21233/philippines-still-top-christian-country-in-asia-5th-in-world,
Accessed November 23, 2017
8
Fukui, M., The rise of Christianity in Asia,
http://www.abc.net.au/radionational/programs/encounter/the-rise-of-christianity-in-asia/5934564,
Accessed November 22, 2017
The continuous rise of Christianity in Asia is booming and many Asians have
already converted as Christians but it is really difficult to distinguish the total number or
percentage of converted Christians in Asia because most of the churches are still hiding
and practice the religion in different places just to be safe. But Christianity can be seen
as the key role in Asian countries to become economically and politically assured and it
might be better described as the Asian Christian Century.
9
Tracy, K., Muslim Nation Bans Christians from Using 19 Religious Words,
http://www.christianitytoday.com/news/2014/february/muslim-nation-bans-christians-words-
brunei-malaysia-allah.html, Accessed November 22, 2017
Vietnams minority groups are hungry for the gospel
Open doors
Christians in Vietnam are being subjected to increased persecution. Historical
Christian communities experience arrests and land-grabbing by the authorities.
Converts to Christianity from Buddhist or ethnic-animist backgrounds face the strongest
persecution, which comes not only from the authorities, but also from families, friends
and neighbors.
Protestant Christian believers tend to gather in house-churches, and their
members face discrimination at various levels of society. The Catholic Church is by far
the largest Christian community in the country, but the government sees it as being tied
to foreign powers, and as a remnant from French colonial days. On November 18, 2016,
the communist government adopted a new Law on Belief and Religion, which limits
freedom of religion considerably. To stand with persecuted believers in Vietnam, Open
Doors provides them with trainings for ministry workers, discipleship programs, Bible
and literature distribution, literacy trainings, advocacy and more.10
10
Vietnams minority groups are hungry for the gospel, Open doors,
https://www.opendoorsusa.org/christian-persecution/world-watch-list/vietnam/, Accessed
November 23, 2017
Religious groups have to formally register with the government, but are routinely
denied. The Hmong Protestants have experienced particular persecution in the last few
years, and Vietnam has been named a 'country of particular concern' every year by the
USCIRF since 2001.CSW has urged the Vietnamese government to ensure that
registration is not a pre-requisite for the exercise of freedom of religion or belief.The UN
special rapporteur on freedom of religion or belief previously made a similar
request.Chief executive of CSW Mervyn Thomas said: "When the possibility of a law on
religion was first mentioned, some were hopeful that it would address the obstacles to
freedom of religion or belief in the existing regulations. Unfortunately, throughout the
drafting process the law continued to focus on the control and management of religious
activities, rather than the protection of religious freedom."Basic guarantees of the right
to freedom of religion or belief must not be undermined by onerous registration
requirements, and groups which cannot or choose not to register must not be excluded
from the enjoyment of this right. We urge the Vietnamese government to guarantee in
law and in practice the right to freedom of religion or belief for all people in Vietnam in
line with Article 18 of the ICCPR."
Of the 93.4 million Vietnamese, more than half identifies with Buddhism. Roman
Catholics make up seven per cent, Cao Dai between 2.5 and four per cent; HoaHao, 1.5
to three percent; and Protestants, one to two percent.11
Despite U.S. efforts to warm relations with Vietnam, there have been some
incidents of concern over the last couple of months, according to International Christian
Concern. Will Stark, ICC's regional manager for South Asia, tells OneNewsNow
the incidents include the arrest and torture of an imprisoned pastor's wife; and the
assault and arrest of a 14-year-old Christian following an attack on a church in northern
Vietnam."Unfortunately it shows that Vietnam is very concerned and very aggressive
towards Christians," he shares. "And unfortunately, so far the U.S. steps in Vietnam
have not had positive results for the Christians there."12
11
Lodge, C.,Christianity At Risk In Vietnam Amid Restrictions On Religious Freedom,
https://www.christiantoday.com/article/christianity-at-risk-in-vietnam-amid-restrictions-on-
religious-freedom/102095.htm,Accessed November 23, 2017
12
Bumpas, B.,Crackdown on Christians in Vietnam,
https://www.onenewsnow.com/persecution/2016/06/24/crackdown-on-christians-in-vietnam,
Accessed November 23, 2017
Stark explains the U.S. probably thought if it reached out to Vietnam, the country
would work to improve its human rights record."The arms embargo is lifted at this point,
so we've lost a significant bargaining chip," he laments. "And what Vietnam is actually
doing now is flexing its muscles and persecuting even more the Christians who are
there in Vietnam."Stark says the recent attacks show the true colors of Vietnam's
leadership.
14
Rumsby, S.,Vietnam Wrestles With Christianity, https://thediplomat.com/2017/11/vietnam-
wrestles-with-christianity/, Accessed November 19, 2017
Religious Population Population Population
group % 2009 % 2010 % 2014
From 7.3% to 8.2% up to 8.3% of the total rates, the Christianity was indeed growing
moderately. Even before the ratio of Christians in Vietnam was already high in numbers
the reason why the government until now are afraid of what might happen if Christianity
will continue to grow.15
In the year of 1980s, Christianity started to blowout in the country of Vietnam but
the unexpected part is that there were no Christian foreigners who made an introduction
about Christianity, meaning, ethnic Hmongs were just only influenced by the other
countries and platforms that is related to the religion such as the evangelistic radio
program that had been broadcasting all the way from Manila Philippines. Ethnic
Hmongs were fascinated by the program of the said radio station because they were
hearing their own language on air about the teachings of Christianity, so they voiced out
to their other ethnic Hmong neighbors about the good news. And because of that
incidentHmongs were totally influenced until now. In todays situation, young Hmong
students are studying not only for the necessity of education as well as they are
studying more theology in order for them to be more assured in dealing to an urban
environment together with the new ways and ideas on how to live by their own and work
for their own. The transition of religion in Vietnam in the ethnic group of Hmongs
became very tragic to the eyes and minds of Non-Christians. They think and fear that
Christianity might damage their culture because there are rules that Christians are
implementing that can affect the culture of country such as drinking alcohol and
smoking cigarettes. These two acts are strongly advised to the converted Christians to
quit doing these completely. But drinking liquors or alcohols is one of their traditions
which symbolize an important form of male bonding so if the converted Christian
Hmongs will refuse drinking and smoking there will be a huge gap between Christians
and Non-Christians that can cause misunderstanding with each other also issues in
religions might get worse. Traditional rituals and ceremonies are being rejected by the
Hmong Christians as well as the usage of traditional musical instruments are prohibited
in the teachings of the new generation who are going to convert with the Christianity.
These are some of the problems and fears that Vietnam is facing, as we can see,
Vietnam is giving importance to what things they have as a country which are the
customs, culture and traditions.
15
Religion in Vietnam, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Religion_in_Vietnam, Accessed November
22, 2017
Frightened is the exact word for the Vietnams situation. The authorities of the
country published an anti-Christian propaganda for the Christians that restrict a religious
freedom in their state. Cruelty among the citizen and authorities of Vietnam to the
believers of Christianity like making them intimidated, beaten, fined, property
confiscation, etc led to the Christian Hmongs fly away from their own country to other
places and states in order to have better life. A lot more negative things and
punishments are being given to the people who are accused of being a Christian. But
Christianity also had a great impact to the lives of the believers especially to the
Hmongs. ethnic group of Hmong is in the highest level of poverty and in the lowest level
of education in the country of Vietnam, meaning to say, they cant get a chance or
privileges to the country as well as they cant get enough benefits from the economic
growth of the country. So when the Christianity was introduced to them, it became an
open helping hand to their group. Because of Christianity and converting to the
Christian world, thru this, they are now able to learn how to grow funds, access new
sources and information in a very easy ways. Even the education of the young Hmongs
had a chance to level-up by offering small fees in order for the students to continue their
study despite of poverty. In spite of the struggles that Hmong Christians and their
churches are facing they are still developing and in progress on how they will spread the
good news regarding the faith in their religion. The contradictions between the Vietnam
governments against Christianity gave more the issue to grow more than it is expected
because as long as the Christianity will stay in the said country the more the Vietnam
will be frightened.
RECOMMENDATION
1. Unity. There should be unity in the country of Vietnam when it comes to the
religion even though they have different beliefs.
2. Cruelty must stop. Christianity or being converted to other religion is not a crime.
Beating ethnic Hmongs or Christian converted person, confiscating their
properties and other more punishments are not a good example of treating a
person just because they have different beliefs.
3. Empower the native tradition. Vietnam is being really frightened by the existence
of Christianity because this religion might damage their culture and tradition. The
country should think of ideas that can help them to preserve their culture and
traditions without mocking the other religion.
4. Limitations for Christians. Christians especially the ethnic group of Hmong who
are still living in the land of Vietnam should make limits in their action. Like the
thought of putting away some of the important traditions in the minds of the new
generations.
5. Filling the gap. The relationship between Christians and Non-Christians should
remain in peace and there must no gap in it in order to prevent the
misunderstandings within each other and the misinterpretation in each others
beliefs.
VI. REFERENCE
Russell, S., Christianity in the Philippines,
http://www.seasite.niu.edu/crossroads/russell/christianity.htm,
Accessed November 20, 2017
Philippine Demographics Profile 2017,
http://www.indexmundi.com/philippines/demographics_profile.html, Accessed
November 20, 2017
The spread of Christianity in the Philippines, Pro Essay, professional writing service,
http://www.proessay.com/buy-essay-on-the-spread-of-christianity-in-the-philippines/,
Accessed November 21, 2017
Vietnams minority groups are hungry for the gospel, Open doors,
https://www.opendoorsusa.org/christian-persecution/world-watch-list/vietnam/,
Accessed November 23, 2017