Professional Documents
Culture Documents
&
CO-FIRING
IN
SUGAR MILLS
PROJECT SYNOPSIS
As a Curriculum of
MASTER OF TECHNOLOGY
(Energy Engineering)
GURU NANAK DEV ENGINEERING COLLEGE, LUDHIANA
The energy is supplied to the sugar cane factory mainly as fuel or bagasse to the
power house and bagasse drying plant. The power house typically incorporates a
steam boiler and a back-pressure steam turbine. When burning fuel in the boiler
furnace, live steam is produced and supplied to the turbine. The turbine drives an
electrical generator which generates power for the factory and the steam leaving
the turbine exhaust flows to the heating equipment for sugar manufacture. This is
known as co-generation of heat and power or Combined Heat and Power (CHP).
Co-Firing with Rice Husk: Small economic size and co-firing with other fuels
has opened up additional applications. Co-firing (or co-combustion) involves
“supplementing existing fossil-based (mostly pulverised coal) power plants with
biomass feedstock” (IEA Bioenergy, 2009).
Similarly in sugar mills during the the off seasons, some other biomass solid fuel
can be used , so that the power generation can be continuously generated from the
co-generation plant.
Rice Husk can be the better alternative as a solid fuel during the off seasons. At
present the number of rice mills in the Punjab state is stated to be more than 3000.
Rice husk from these mills is available in plenty but it is utilised in-efficiently in
furnaces and low efficiency boilers by most of the textile and paper industries in
Punjab for meeting their steam requirements. So if the sugar mills generating
electricity have jointed with the rice mills located within a radius of 60 kms from
the site ,co generation still would be economical during off seasons also. This leads
to far better efficiency in terms of power generation.
Notably, when a sugar mill does not produce enough bagasse to meet its power
requirements and has to source it from rice husk, the cost is still usually less than
Rs 1 per unit. In comparison, if the plant has to use diesel, the unit cost could be
higher than Rs 2.75 and Rs 3.20 per unit depending on the state.
1.(Frisch, 1993) For electricity generation, two most competitive technologies are
direct combustion and gasification. Typical plant sizes at present range from 0.1 to
50 MW. Co-generation applications are very efficient and economical. Fluidized
bed combustion (FBC) are efficient and flexible in accepting varied types of fuels.
Gasifiers first convert solid biomass into gaseous fuels which is then used through
a steam cycle or directly through gas turbine/engine.
Gas turbines are commercially available in sizes ranging from 20 to 50 MW.
Technology development indicates that a 40 MW combined cycle gasification
plant with efficiency of 42 percent is feasible at a capital cost of 1.7 million US
dollars with electricity generation costs of 4 cents/ KWh .
4. Performance :
(S. C.Kamate & P.B.Gangavati 2009) The most important performance parameters
used to assess the steam turbine cogeneration plants in general and sugar mill
cogeneration plants in particular are defined and developed. Criteria such as energy
utilization factor, heat-to-power ratio, fuel energy savings ratio, exergetic
efficiency and power generated per tonne of cane is be more important.
The existing modern, high pressure, high efficiency, steam turbine cogeneration
plants generate 115–120 kWh/tc, while BIG-GT and BIG-STIG are potentially
capable of generating up to 270–275 kWh/tc. Cogeneration plants using
backpressure and condensing steam turbines perform with energy (First Law) and
exergetic (Second Law) efficiency of approximately 60–70 % and 22–25%,
respectively. The steam consumption in sugar mills at present varies from 480–550
kg/tc, while electricity consumption ranges between 16–22 kWh/tc (32–40 kWh/tc
for electrified mills).
New Initiatives
The Ministry of India has continued the existing scheme with two modification
related to :
(a) Cogeneration projects through BOOT model in cooperative sugar mills.
(b) Boiler upgradation of cogeneration projects in cooperative sugar mills.
Rice husk can be used for power generation through either the steam or
gasification route. For small scale power generation, the gasification route has
attracted more attention as a small steam power plant is very inefficient and is very
difficult to maintain due to the presence of a boiler. In addition for rice mills with
diesel engines, the gas produced from rice husk can be used in the existing engine
in a dual fuel operation.
The importance of Rice Husk and Rice Straw as an attractive source of energy can
be gauged from the following statistics:
Rice Straw
Rice Husk
Backpressure Technology:
The first type of technology in cogeneration available was the Backpressure, where
combined heat and power (CHP) is generated in a steam turbine.
The Fig. shows the process flow of backpressure type cogeneration (CHP).
6. Advantages :
Increased income and jobs in the agriculture and forestry sectors, which now
supply part of the feedstock used in power and heat production (agricultural
and forest residues)
Job creation in the industrial sector for designing, building and operating the
plants.
Increasing inclusion in the economic system: well-organized farmers unions
can gain access to energy markets.
Economic development:
Environmental benefits:
Reduced GHG emissions from the power sector. Many agricultural and
forest residues can be assumed to be carbon neutral, which leads to
significant attributable GHG emission reductions.
Reduced NOX and SOX emissions compared to coal combustion. NOx
emissions can be further reduced by implementing primary and secondary
emission reduction measures.
Energy Conservation:
Apart from saving costs using cogeneration, sugar manufacturers have also
taken steps to conserve energy. Some energy conservation measures include
recirculating fly ash which contains unburnt carbon in the boiler to release more
heat energy; installing star–delta-star unit for motors running with less than 50
per cent load, energy–efficient cooling towers for cooling water, and hydraulic
drives by replacing gear boxes; providing variable frequency drives for weighed
juice pumps and cane carriers; replacing conventional gear trains in the mills
with a planatory gear box; mixing the excess condensate of vapour with cold
water in the evaporator instead of using just cold water; installing a spray pond
system for condenser water cooling; installing auto transformers for factory
lighting; optimizing the cooling tower pump; using low-loss chokes and high–
output lamps; installing energy-efficient motors; and installing falling film
evaporators .
OBJECTIVES:
To study the barriers for co generation plant.
To study the efficiency of the plant.
To study the economy of the plant.
2.http://www.mnre.gov.in/schemes/grid-connected/biomass-powercogen/
3.http://www.energymanagertraining.com/Journal/24092005/ProfitsfromCoge
neration.pdf
4.http://www.energymanagertraining.com/announcements/issue25/winners_p
apers_Issue25/08_PandurangSJalkote.pdf
5.http://peda.gov.in/eng/cogeneration.html
6.http://www.me.iitb.ac.in/~rangan/publications/recent%20papers%20publis
hed_homepage/Cogen%20for%20sugar%20factory.pdf
7.http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bioenergy#Electricity_generation_from_biomas
s
8. http://www.bioenergyconsult.com/tag/rice-husk/
9. http://www.resourcesaver.com/file/toolmanager/O105UF1139.pdf
10.http://www.business-standard.com/india/news/power-through-co-
generation-for-full-season-now/396279/