1/1/2018 The magic of Encyclopedia Britannica's 11th edition | Books | The Guardian

The magic of Encyclopedia Britannica's 11th

edition
Representing a peak of colonial optimism before the slaughter of war, the 1910/11 edition has acquired an
almost mythic reputation among collectors

Nate Pedersen
Tue 10 Apr ‘12 13.15 BST

As the last sets of the Encyclopedia Britannica prepare to sink into obscurity, there's one edition
that will always remain a collector's item: the 11th.

Published between 1910 and 1911, the 11th edition continues to inspire a religious reverence
from its loyal adherents. The siren call of its 28 leather-bound volumes works a subtle magic on
antiquarians, historians, booksellers, and scholars around the world.

So, why the appeal? AJ Jacobs, an American journalist, read his way through the entirety of the
15th edition of the Encyclopedia Britannica published in 2002. He wrote about his experience in
the well-received book The Know-It-All: One Man's Humble Quest to Become the Smartest Person
in the World. I spoke with Jacobs about the lasting appeal of the 11th. He said that "compared to

https://www.theguardian.com/books/booksblog/2012/apr/10/encyclopedia-britannica-11th-edition 1/3
1/1/2018 The magic of Encyclopedia Britannica's 11th edition | Books | The Guardian

more modern editions, reading the 11th is like reading a Faulkner novel instead of an instruction
manual."

The 11th is exceptionally well written, the first encyclopedia where readability was courted in
addition to scholarship. But its durability goes deeper than that.

Jacobs continued, "I think Hans Koning of the New Yorker nailed the appeal 30 years ago. He said
it was the last great work of the age of reason, the final instance when all human knowledge could
be presented with a single point of view. Four years later, the confidence and optimism that had
produced the 11th would be, as he puts it, 'a casualty in the slaughter at Ypres and the Argonne.'"

And he's right. To open an 11th edition of the Encyclopedia Britannica is to open a worldview lost
forever in the staggering slaughter of the first world war. The 11th edition of the Britannica
represents the high tide of optimism and belief in human progress that had dominated the Anglo-
Saxon vision since the Enlightenment.

Unabashed optimism – and unabashed racism – pervades many entries in the 11th, and provide
its defining characteristics. The Edwardian world was finely ordered in the way an encyclopedia
needs the world to be finely ordered: everything, and everyone, in their place. Interpreted for you
by the rich, the white, and the expensively educated.

The entry on antisemitism states that it is "a passing phase in the history of culture". This was
written 30 years before the horrors of Nazi Germany. The Vietnamese are the "worst-built and
ugliest of all the Indo-Chinese," while the Chinese are "inferior in character" to Europeans. Arabs
are noted for a propensity to be "cruel" and "crafty," and Africans "appear to stand on a lower
evolutionary plane than the white man".

Despite its occasional ugliness, the reputation of the 11th persists today because of the staggering
depth of knowledge contained with its volumes. It is especially strong in its biographical entries.
These delve deeply into the history of men and women prominent in their eras who have since
been largely forgotten – except by the historians, scholars, and antiquarian booksellers who
champion the 11th for this quality.

It's among antiquarian booksellers that the 11th enjoys its highest reputation. Norman Kane, an
American rare book dealer of over 50 years experience, only recently parted ways with his 11th,
and that decision was a reluctant result of a cross-country move. "The [index] is full of names that
resonate in all fields of the arts and sciences. People whose books we sell every day. More recent
editions have lost, I believe, much of the antiquarian flavour that recommends it to us. We are
after all more interested in the out-of-date than in the up-to-date."

Among those resonating names are TH Huxley, Alfred North Whitehead, Algernon Swinburne and
Peter Kropotkin. Fifteen hundred men and an impressive (by Edwardian standards) 200 women
contributed articles to the 11th edition, which was edited by Hugh Chisholm. Under his
editorship, the Britannica combined scholarship and readability in a way no previous
encyclopedia ever had – and, arguably, no encyclopedia has been able to repeat. Chisholm also
revolutionised encyclopedia publishing by releasing the first 14 volumes in the autumn of 1910
and the second 14 volumes, along with an index, in the spring of 1911. The volumes in previous
editions were released as they were completed, with years passing between publication of the
first and final volumes. Under the new model, the entire Britannica was assembled before crucial
articles went out of date.
https://www.theguardian.com/books/booksblog/2012/apr/10/encyclopedia-britannica-11th-edition 2/3
1/1/2018 The magic of Encyclopedia Britannica's 11th edition | Books | The Guardian

With the publication of the final volumes of the 11th, in the spring of 1911, came the last stand of
the Enlightenment. One year later the Titanic would strike an iceberg. Three years later, Franz
Ferdinand was assassinated. Five years later, a staggering 1.25m people would die in the Battle of
the Somme. And the world would never be the same.

When viewed in that light, the worn leather volumes of the 11th acquire an almost mythic
quality. Its pages contain all the knowledge of a world on the brink of deep and everlasting
change. And that is why the 11th edition of the Encyclopedia Britannica will outlast all the others.

Topics
History
Books blog
Reference and languages
blogposts

https://www.theguardian.com/books/booksblog/2012/apr/10/encyclopedia-britannica-11th-edition 3/3