Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Please cite this article in press as Gayathri Devi et al., Comparative Study of the Efficiency of Branded and
Generic Drugs on Anaemia, Indo Am. J. P. Sci, 2018; 05(01).
A 1990 study by FDA laboratories from all over the There is a strong misunderstanding and belief among
country found that for those classes of prescription the Medical Practitioners that Branded drugs are
drugs that theoretically could be most likely to pose more therapeutically efficient than Generic by
extension drugs. Some surveys have revealed that as an estimate of their quantity. A meal-by-meal
though Generic drugs are safe and cheap but not description is necessary to obtain appropriate
effective as branded drugs [2,3,4]. estimates. Even then, patients frequently attempt to
deceive the physician because of embarrassment
ANAEMIA regarding dietary idiosyncrasies or financial
Anaemia is not one disease, but a condition that restrictions. In these circumstances, a close and
results from a number of different pathologies. It can concerned family member participating in the dietary
be defined as a reduction from normal of the quantity history can often be helpful, because this person is
of hemoglobin in the blood. The World Health usually more objective than the patient. Changes in
Organisation defines anaemia in adults as body weight are important with regard to dietary
hemoglobin levels less than 13g/dL for males and intake and can suggest the presence of malabsorption
less than 12g/dL for females. Anemia ( in Greek, or an underlying wasting disease of infectious,
meaning lack of blood) is a decrease in number of red metabolic, or neoplastic origin. Anaemia can be
blood cells (RBCs) or less than the normal quantity classified in associated with Iron Deficiency, Chronic
of hemoglobin in the blood [5,6]. Renal Disease, Folate Deficiency, Acute Blood Loss,
Vitamin B12 Deficiency, Chemotherapy Induced,
drug-induced immune hemolytic Anaemia etc.
requirement for iron is greater (20-25 mg). An used only when dietary measures have failed
erythrocyte has a lifespan of 120 days so that 0.8% of [11,12,13,14,15] .
red blood cells are destroyed and replaced each day.
A man with 5 L of blood volume has 2.5 g of iron MATERIALS & METHODS:
incorporated into the hemoglobin, with a daily The prescription was given by Registered Medical
turnover of 20 mg for hemoglobin synthesis and Practitioner to all the subjects who were grouped into
degradation and another 5 mg for other requirements. group 2 and group 3 on their name.The blood
Most of this iron passes through the plasma for samples were collected by a qualified lab technician.
reutilization. In healthy people, the body RBC diluting fluid (Indian Fine Chem), N/10
concentration of iron (approximately 60 parts per Hydrochloric acid (Span Diagnostics Ltd).
million [ppm]) is regulated carefully by absorptive Disposable needles 24GX1/0.56 ×25 mm (Dora
cells in the proximal small intestine, which alter iron single use hypodermic needles).
absorption to match body losses of iron.Oral iron Disposable Syringes 3m– 517506 l (Oyster
supplements are the best way to restore iron levels for hypodermic syringes with needles).
people who are iron deficient, but they should be Haemo Meter (Superior, Germany),
Neubauer Chamber, R.B.C. Pipette (Mico Glass
Industries).
Table 1: Generic and Branded Iron formulations used in the study
Zinc sulphate
monohydrate USP
61.8mg
METHOD
Estimation of Haemoglobin (Sahli’s method) haemoglobin in acid to convert into haematin. Now
With the help of a dropper, N/10HCLwas taken in dilute the acid haematin by adding distilled water in
the graduated haemoglobin meter tube up to its drops. The dilution was continued till its colour
lowest mark( usually 10% or 2%),the finger was matches with that of the standard. The reading of the
pricked under aseptic precautions. When a drop of meniscus from the scale provided on the
reasonable size has collected, hold the pipette haemoglobin meter tube were noted which express
horizontally, apply its tip to the drop and draw the haemoglobin content as gm per 100ml of blood.
exactly 20 cumm of blood with no air bubbles. The
pipette was taken and wiped off the blood adhering RESULTS AND DISCUSSION:
to the tip.Immediately the blood was transferred from We have done the haemoglobin content under the
the pipette into N/10 HCL in the graduated supervision of registered medical practitioner and a
haemoglobin meter tube and rinsed several times by qualified lab technician. The haemoglobin content
drawing the N/10 HCL which is used for mixing the values were given in the table 2.Using these values
blood, foaming should be avoided.The contents were the subjects were categorized into three groups
mixed thoroughly and solution was allowed to stand namely Group 1 which are selected for control.Group
for about 10 minutes for the maximum of 2 for generic formulation and Group 3 for branded
formulation.
Table 4: Haemoglobin estimated in Group 2 before and after 15 days treatment with Generic drug
( Glowfol )
S.No Patient ID No Hb% before Rbc count Hb% after Variation
(gm/ml) (mil/cu mm) (gm/ml
Table 5:Haemoglobin estimated in Group 3 before and after 15 days of treatment with Branded drug (Fefol)
Table 6: Statistical Analysis of Control Group 1 before and after 15 days without any treatment.
Note: Anaemic subjects less than 11g% were selected and were grouped in to three.
Table 7: Statistical Analysis of Generic drug treated Group 2 before and after 15 days treatment.
Note: To study the effect of ferrous salt formulation Glowfol, a Generic drug costs Rs. 12/- per strip was
administered one tablet a day after lunch daily for 15 days to Group 2 subjects. Their hemoglobin levels of blood
were estimated before and after treatment. The results obtained were presented in Table 4 and its statistical analysis
was in Table 7.
The mean Haemoglobin value and SDs of individuals before treatment was 8.55±1.51% and after treatment was
10.13±1.7. Table 7 indicated that the mean difference was statistically significant at P value 0.0001. The treatment
with Generic formulation Glowfol, in Group 2 subjects had increased hemoglobin level. The improvement is
statistically significant.
Table 8: Statistical Analysis of Branded drug treated Group 3 before and after 15 days treatment
Vedavathi et. al [15] carried out a comparison of of 12 Years of Bioequivalence Data from the United
quality of life and improvement in blood pressure and States Food and Drug Administration. Ann
blood glucose values of patients using branded and Pharmacother. 2009, 43 (10): 1583-1597. 10.
generic medicines for hypertensive and diabetes 5."What Is Anemia? – NHLBI,
treatment. They concluded that there is no difference NIH". Www.nhlbi.nih.gov. 2016-01-31.
between the therapeutic efficacy of the selected 6. Stedman's medical Dictionary (28th ed.).
products of branded generic medicines and generic Philadelphia: Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. 2006.
medicines. They found that there was good p. Anemia. ISBN 978-0-7817-3390-8.
correlation between improvements in biochemical 7. Recommendations to prevent and control Iron
values. deficiency in the United States. Archived 2007-04-20
at theWayback Machine. MMWR 1998;47 (No. RR-
Govt. Cooperative Medical Stores and Life-line drug 3) p. 5
stores (run by Jeevanadhara in Andhra Pradesh) 8."Iron Deficiency --- United States, 1999–
provide low cost medicines of well reputed 2000".MMWR. 51 (40): 897–899. October 11,
companies. Pharmacists also play a vital role in 2002. Archived from the original on 5 May 2012.
educating the doctors about the availability of generic Retrieved 21 April 2012.
drugs. Thus the right medication could be given to 9. Halterman JS, Kaczorowski JM, Aligne CA,
the patients at the best possible price. Generics are as Auinger P, Szilagyi PG (June 2001). "Iron deficiency
good as branded drugs. Thus if generic drugs are and cognitive achievement among school-aged
bought by the patient, the patient may not lose money children and adolescents in the United
by going in for branded drugs, which are too costly. States". Pediatrics. 107 (6): 1381–
6. PMID 11389261.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS: 10.Grantham-McGregor S, Ani C (February
We are very much thankful to the Registered Medical 2001). "A review of studies on the effect of iron
Practitioner, Lab technician, management of deficiency on cognitive development in
Viswanadha Institute of Pharmaceutical Sciences for children". The Journal of Nutrition. 131(2S-2): 649S–
their support to carry out the work and providing us 666S; discussion 666S–668S. 2012-12-23.
the required materials. 11. "Iron Deficiency Anaemia: Assessment,
Prevention, and Control: A guide for programme
REFERENCES: managers" 2011-05-16.
1. Generic Drug Facts, Center for Drug Evaluation 12. Mentzer WC (April 1973). "Differentiation of
and Research, U.S. Food and Drug Administration, iron deficiency from thalassaemia
2017-10-06, retrieved 2017-11-11. trait". Lancet. 1 (7808): 882.
2.Cameron A, Mantel-Teeuwisse AK, Leufkens HG, 13. eMedicine – Vitamin B-12 Associated
Laing RO. Switching from originator brand Neurological Diseases : Article by Niranjan N Singh,
medicines to generic equivalents in selected MD, DM, DNB ,2007-03-15 at the Wayback
developing countries: How much could be Machine. July 18, 2006
saved? Value Health. 2012;15:664–73. 14. "Physiology or Medicine 1934 – Presentation
3. Center for Drug Evaluation and Research (2003). Speech". Nobel prize.org. 1934-12-10. 2010-08-24.
"Guidance for Industry: Bioavailability and 15. Vedavathi T , Sadagam N , Ayyagari RK , Vijaya
Bioequivalence Studies for Orally Administered Ratna J, Comparison of quality of life and
Drug Products — General Considerations". United improvement in B.P and blood glucose values of
States Food and Drug Administration. patients using branded generic and generic medicines
4.Davit BM, Nwakama PE, Buehler GJ, Conner DP, for hypertensive and diabetes treatment Indian J.
Haidar SH, Patel DT, Yang Y, Yu LX, Woodcock J: Pharm. Pract. 3(1), Jan-Mar, 2010, 31-42.
Comparing Generic and Innovator Drugs: A Review