A Comparative Study and Implementation of Real Time Home Automation System

2013 IEEE 10th International Conference on Ubiquitous Intelligence & Computing and 2013 IEEE 10th International Conference
on Autonomic & Trusted Computing
A@FDA>3@675;E;A@)KEF7?8AD)?3DFG;>6;@9E
>3G6;A3D;3E"G5;&;D?7L>3H;37>;53FA "G;L(3D?A
7@D;CG7)A3D7E3@69AD"6AE)3@FAE $3F;A@3>@EF;FGF7A8#7FDA>A9K'G3>;FK3@6*75:@A>A9K
&&+( (;A67 3@7;DAD3L;> (;A67 3@7;DAD3L;>
M5?;57>;83D;3E:7@D;CG7G8D<>G5;B;D?7L >8DGEF;@?7FDA9AH4D
867>;53FA;9AD>E3@FAEN9?3;>5A?

4# '*&)2' (- )! )(-+)& ( $,$)( *+) ,, D7EAGD57 5A@EFD3;@76 67H;57E 7CG;BB76 I;F: E7@E;@9
,.**)+- 20$+ & ,,, (,)+(-.-)+( -0)+%,,$, 53B34;>;F;7E3@6I;D7>7EE>;@=E-)$E5A@F3;@3>3D97@G?47D
*+)'$,$("02-)$'*+)/ ( +"2 !!$$ (2)!'+- .$&$(", A8 E7@EAD 3@6 35FG3FAD @A67E IAD=;@9 5A>>34AD3F;H7>K FA
*+ , (- ( /&.- (-+&$3 ,2,- ' !)+ ?A@;FAD F:7 F3D97F 3D73 3@6 B7D8AD? F3E=E F:3F ?3K 35F;H7>K
$,$)( ( )(-+)& !)+ '+- .$&$(" **&$-$)(, , )(
38875F F:7 B:KE;53> 7@H;DA@?7@F 12 *:7D78AD7 3 -)$ ;E
, +!)+' 1* +$' (-, ,#)0( -#- ,$( - $,
*+) ,, 0$-#$(-# ( -0)+%$(,- )!-+(,'$-- -) (-+& 34>7 FA B7D8AD? F:7 I:A>7 675;E;A@?3=;@9 BDA57EE 8AD E?3DF
&)-$)(-# + $,"$($(- +',)!-# ,2,- '+ ,*)(, -$' ( 4G;>6;@9 3BB>;53F;A@E ;@5>G6;@9 35F;A@E EG5: 3E 5:3@9;@9 3@
+ ,).+ )(,.'*-$)( # + !)+ $'*+)/ , -# ( +"2 3;D5A@6;F;A@7DF:7D?AEF3F355AD6;@9FAF:7@G?47DA8B7AB>7;@
!!$$ (2 )! )-# -# ')($-)+ .$&$(" ( -# 3 B>357 FGD@;@9 A88 >;9:FE ;@ 7?BFK DAA?E AD 35F;H3F;@9 83@E
$(!+,-+.-.+ 0# ( )'*+ -) (-+&$3 **+)# , I:7@7H7D3;DCG3>;FK;E5A@E;67D76;@367CG3F7
)+ )/ + $- 1*&)$-, $(- "+-$)( )! **&$-$)(, - -# $,$)( #AEF A8 E?3DF 4G;>6;@9 3BB>;53F;A@E 43E76 A@ -)$E
& / &-)!.+-# +$'*+)/ -# ,2,- ' !!$$ (2 8AG@6 ;@ F:7 >;F7D3FGD7 12 ?3=7 GE7 A8 57@FD3>;L76
3D5:;F75FGD7E I;F: E7@E;@9 @A67E FD3@E?;FF;@9 ?7EE397E FA 3

4'+- .$&$(",( +"2!!$$ (2
43E7 EF3F;A@ I:7D7;@ F:7 5A@FDA> 3@6 675;E;A@ BDA57EE7E
$*(%+*%$ 78875F;H7>K :3BB7@ *:7 ?3<AD 6D3I435= A8 F:AE7 FKB7E A8
3D5:;F75FGD7E ;E 3@366;F;A@3>67>3K A@ FABA8 5A@FDA>D7EBA@E7
@H;DA@?7@F3> 679D363F;A@ 3@6 9>A43> I3D?;@9 3D7 ?3<AD
F;?7 3E 5A@E7CG7@57 A8 F:7 399D793F76 5A??G@;53F;A@ 67>3K
5:3>>7@97E F:3F ?3@=;@6 8357E @AI363KE )G5: 5:3>>7@97E 3D7
47FI77@E7@E;@93@65A@FDA>@A67E@AD67DFAAH7D5A?7EG5:
F3D97FEA8;@F7@E7D7E73D5:3@6;@H7EF?7@F4K9AH7D@?7@F3>3@6
3D5:;F75FGD3>D7EFD;5F;A@F:7BDABAE763BBDA35:B7D8AD?EE?3DF
BD;H3F7 AD93@;L3F;A@E ;@ E73D5: A8 EFD3F79;7E FA ?;@;?;L7
4G;>6;@95A@FDA>3@6675;E;A@?3=;@9BDA57EE7E;@E;67F:7AI@
9D77@:AGE7 93E 7?;EE;A@E 3@6 FA ?3=7 7@7D9K 5A@EG?BF;A@
E7@EAD @A67E %4H;AGE>K 4K F3=;@9 F:7 5A@FDA> 3@6 675;E;A@
?AD7788;5;7@FD7E73D5:8;7>6F:3F?3=7EGE7A8@8AD?3F;A@
?3=;@9 BDA57EE7EA88 F:757@FD3>;L;@97@F;FK 3@6 ;@5ADBAD3F;@9
3@6 A??G@;53F;A@ *75:@A>A9;7E *E 8AD BDAH;6;@9
F:7? ;@FA F:7 -)$ @A67E F:7 EA 53>>76 044,9<571
EA>GF;A@E FA F:7E7 7@H;DA@?7@F3> 5:3>>7@97E ;E F:7 SE?3DF
BDA57EE;@9 @7I 5:3>>7@97E 3D;E7 =7K 5:3>>7@97 ;E :AI FA
4G;>6;@9T8;7>655AD6;@9FA12E?3DF4G;>6;@9E3D77CG;BB76
?3J;?;L7 -)$ >;87F;?7 I:;>7 ?3;@F3;@;@9 F:7 8G@5F;A@3>;FK
I;F: E?3DF 67H;57E67E;9@76 FA ?;@;?;L7 7@7D9K 5A@EG?BF;A@
A8 3BB>;53F;A@E 3;?76 3F ;?BDAH;@9 F:7 7@7D9K 788;5;7@5K A8
I;F:AGF 5A?BDA?;E;@9 B7DEA@@7> 5A?8ADF 3@6 E387FK 3@
E?3DF4G;>6;@9E12%@778875F;H7EA>GF;A@8ADEG5:5:3>>7@97;E
;?BADF3@FEF7BFAI3D6E3EGEF3;@34>7>;87EFK>7
FA36ABF?7F:A6E8AD;@87DD;@9675;E;A@E>A53>>K;7I;F:;@F:7
*:7D73D7E7H7D3>AB7@;EEG7E;@F:7E?3DF4G;>6;@9D7E73D5:
AI@ E7@EAD @A67E D76G5;@9 F:7 3?AG@F A8 D7CG;D76 D36;A
8;7>6 %@7 A8 F:7? 5A@57D@E F:7 7@7D9K I3EF7 53GE76 4K F:7
FD3@E?;EE;A@E FA F:7 ) 8AD ?3=;@9 675;E;A@E F:7D78AD7
;@6;E5D;?;@3F7 GE7 A8 5A@FDA> 7CG;B?7@F 8AD 4G;>6;@9
BDA>A@9;@9 F:7 -)$ >;87F;?7 I:;>7 EF;>> 7@34>;@9 5A@FDA> 3@6
3GFA?3F;A@ EG5: 3E 67H;57E 8AD F7?B7D3FGD7 3@6 >;9:F;@9
675;E;A@?3=;@98ADE?3DF4G;>6;@93BB>;53F;A@E
5A@FDA> *:7D78AD7 E7H7D3> E?3DF 4G;>6;@9 3BB>;53F;A@E
@ F:;E 5A@F7JF F:7 ?3;@ 9A3> A8 F:;E B3B7D ;E FA BD7E7@F
BD7E7@F76 ;@ F:7 >;F7D3FGD7 E77= FA D76G57 7@7D9K I3EF7 A@
%$ 3 6757@FD3>;L76 5A@FDA> 3@6 675;E;A@?3=;@9 EKEF7?
5A@FDA> 67H;57E GE76 8AD ; ?3@39;@9 F7?B7D3FGD7 >;9:F 3;D
8AD E?3DF 4G;>6;@9 3BB>;53F;A@E GE;@9 -)$E I:;5:
CG3>;FK 3@6 @3FGD3> H7@F;>3F;A@ ;; ?A@;FAD;@9 3@6 E:GFF;@9
5A@FD;4GF7EFA;?BDAH;@9F:77@7D9K788;5;7@5KA8F:74G;>6;@9
6AI@ G@3FF7@676 67H;57E 3@6 ;;; DG@@;@9 E75GD;FK
%$;E36757@FD3>;L76EKEF7?4753GE7F:7I:A>7675;E;A@
3BB>;53F;A@E )?3DF 3BB>;53F;A@E A8F7@ ?A@;FAD B:KE;53>
?3=;@9 BDA57EE 8AD E?3DF 4G;>6;@9 3BB>;53F;A@E ;E B7D8AD?76
H3D;34>7E7JFD35F768DA?F:7F3D97F7@H;DA@?7@FEG5:3E>;9:F
I;F:;@F:7-)$*:7D78AD7F:7D7;E@A@776A8FD3@E?;FF;@9
F7?B7D3FGD7 E?A=7 3@6 7>75FD;5 HA>F397 #AEF A8 7J;EF;@9
D3I63F3FA357@FD3>;L767@F;FKF:73E7EF3F;A@A@3:AB4K
IAD=E;@F:78;7>6BDABAE757@FD3>;L76EA>GF;A@EFA5A@FDA>3@6
:AB43E;E@7;F:7DF:78;@3>675;E;A@E435=FAF:7-)$F:GE
?A@;FAD F:7 4G;>6;@9 GE;@9 I;D76 3@3>A9 E7@EADE I:;5: :3H7
D76G5;@9F:7@776A8D36;AFD3@E?;EE;A@E3@6E3H;@97@7D9K8AD
>;?;F76 E53>34;>;FK 3@6 3D7 :3D67D FA ;@EF3>> 3@6 ?3;@F3;@ 12
F:7 -)$ #AD7AH7D E;@57 ;@ AGD EA>GF;A@ F:7 675;E;A@
(757@F IAD=E 1
2 BD7E7@F EA>GF;A@E FA 5A@FDA> 3@6 ?A@;FAD
?3=;@9 BDA57EE ;E ;@5ADBAD3F76 ;@FA F:7 -)$ F:GE 97FF;@9
4G;>6;@9E GE;@9 -;D7>7EE )7@EAD 3@6 5FG3FAD $7FIAD=E
5>AE7D FA F:7 35FG3FADE I7 35:;7H7 ; 83EF7D 7J75GF;A@ A8
-)$E12-)$E3D75A?BAE76A8>AI5AEF7@7D9K3@6
!)*36/2+*30#24,73500/24'&$74)'2#8*,*#.5.&*.(('.%*'31#.&5.&'2(2#.43.5-$'23

!!!" ! #.&

978-1-4799-2481-3/13 $31.00 © 2013 IEEE 254

DOI 10.1109/UIC-ATC.2013.108
675;E;A@E ;; 47FF7D B7D8AD?3@57 A8 F:7 E?3DF 4G;>6;@9 3@6 67F7D?;@7 F:7 >A53F;A@ A8 3 H;E;FAD ;@ F:7 4G;>6;@9 9G;6;@9
5A@E7CG7@F>K;;;7@:3@5767@7D9K788;5;7@5K :;? :7DFAF:767E;D7667EF;@3F;A@7F5
*:7 ?3;@ BGDBAE7 A8 ;@F79D3F;@9 3BB>;53F;A@E A@ E?3DF *:7 IAD= ;@ 12 BDABAE7E 3 BDAFAFKB7 F:3F GE7E 3 -)$
4G;>6;@9E ;E FA E3H7 7@7D9K 4K D76G5;@9 IADF:>7EE F3E= I;F:;@ F:7 E5AB7 A8 S?476676 )KEF7?E 8AD @7D9K 88;5;7@F
D7B7F;F;A@E3@68AEF7D;@95A>>34AD3F;A@47FI77@3BB>;53F;A@EFA G;>6;@9ET 7$ BDA<75F %@7 A8 F:7 ;@@AH3F;A@E ;@
35:;7H7 5A??A@ 9A3>E )G5: ;@F79D3F;A@ 8GDF:7D ?;@;?;L7E 7$;EF:75D73F;A@A87@7D9K5A@EG?BF;A@BDA8;>7EFA735:
7@7D9KI3EF74K3HA;6;@9G@67E;D34>7EF3F7E8AD;@EF3@57FGD@ FKB7 A8 3BB>;3@57 ;@ E?3DF 4G;>6;@9E *:7 EKEF7? 3D5:;F75FGD7
A88F:7>;9:FE3@6F:73;D5A@6;F;A@7DI:7@BD7E7@573BB>;53F;A@ BDABAE76;@7$;ECG;F7E;?;>3DFA%$3D5:;F75FGD7
@AF;8;7E 3@ 7?BFK DAA? 1 2 @ 366;F;A@ ;@F79D3F;A@ 3>EA *:7 ?A@;FAD76 7@H;DA@?7@F ;E 6;H;676 ;@FA 57>>E I:7D7 735:
;?BDAH7E5A@FDA>47:3H;AD3E8AD7J3?B>7;@F:77?BFKDAA? 57>> ;E DG>76 4K 3 7>> 7H;57 A@57@FD3FAD 3@6 :3E
7J3?B>7>;9:F;@95A@FDA>53@@AF;8KF7?B7D3FGD75A@FDA>34AGF E7H7D3> B7D;B:7D3> @A67E 35: 57>> ;E ;@67B7@67@F FA ?3=7
F:77?BFKDAA? 675;E;A@43E76A@63F35A>>75F764KF:7B7D;B:7D3>@A67E;@E;67
@ EG??3DK %$ ?3;@ 5A@FD;4GF;A@E 3D7 ; F:7 F:3F57>>ADA@6;D75F;H7EE7@F4K343E7EF3F;A@53>>76#35DA
6757@FD3>;L3F;A@ A8 F:7 5A@FDA> 3@6 675;E;A@?3=;@9 BDA57EE7E 7>>A@57@FD3FAD#*:7IAD=67E5D;476;@12;EEF;>>;@
8AD E?3DF 4G;>6;@9 3BB>;53F;A@E 3?A@9 -)$ @A67E E3H;@9 3@73D>KEF3973@6@AD7EG>FED7>3F76FA35FG3>7@7D9KE3H;@9A@
7@7D9KA84AF:F:7-)$3@6F:74G;>6;@93@6;;;@F79D3F;@9 F:74G;>6;@93D7BD7E7@F76?3=;@9;F;?BAEE;4>7FA5A?B3D7FA
3BB>;53F;A@E F:DAG9: 5:3;@;@9 675;E;A@E 47FI77@ 3BB>;53F;A@E AGDD7EG>FE 7E;67E 6;887D7@F>K 8DA? %$ F:7 BDABAE3>;@
I;F:;@F:7-)$3>EAE3H;@97@7D9KA84AF:F:7-)$3@6 1283;>EFA?7@F;A@3BB>;53F;A@;@F79D3F;A@
F:7 4G;>6;@9 *:7 D7?3;@67D A8 F:;E B3B7D ;E AD93@;L76 3E +@>;=7 F:7 IAD=E 67E5D;476 ;@ 1 2 %$
8A>>AIEE75F;A@BD7E7@FED7>3F76IAD=E75F;A@BD7E7@FE3 EKEF7? ;E 6757@FD3>;L76 3@6 ;FE AB7D3F;A@ ;E 8G>>K B7D8AD?76
67E5D;BF;A@A8%$E75F;A@,BD7E7@FEF:7D7EG>FEA4F3;@76 I;F:;@ F:7 -)$ 3?A@9 ;FE @A67E *:7E7 6;887D7@57E 4D;@9
;@7JB7D;?7@FE5A@6G5F76I;F:%$3@6E75F;A@,BD7E7@FE 36H3@F397E;@F7D?EA8D7EBA@E7F;?73@67@7D9KE3H;@9E4AF:
5A@5>GE;A@E3@68GFGD7IAD= FAF:7E?3DF4G;>6;@93@6F:7-)$;FE7>8F:GE?3J;?;L;@9;FE
AB7D3F;A@3> >;87F;?7 *34>7 EG??3D;L7E F:7 8;@6;@9E A8 F:;E
("*-%(! E75F;A@ *:7D7 3D7 E7H7D3> D757@F EFG6;7E F:3F ?3=7 GE7 A8
@ 12 F:7 BDABAE76 EKEF7? GE7E 3 -)$ FA E7@E7 3@6 -)$E ;@ F:7 5A@F7JF A8 E?3DF 4G;>6;@9 3BB>;53F;A@E
FD3@E?;F 63F3 I:7@7H7D D7CG7EF76 4K 3 -74 E7DH;57 35: AI7H7D FA F:7 47EF A8 AGD =@AI>7697 @A@7 A8 EG5: IAD=E
E7@EAD @A67 :3E 3 G@;CG7 & 366D7EE 3@6 ;?B>7?7@FE 3 ?;@; 673>EI;F:3>>F:7;EEG7E366D7EE764K%$
**& E7DH7D F:3F GE7E &H *& 3@6 **& BDAFA5A>E *:7 & $( -.+ ,)!(+ &- 0)+%,
5A@FDA> 3@6 675;E;A@?3=;@9 BDA57EE7E 8AD E?3DF 4G;>6;@9
73FGD7E );@9>73BB>;53F;A@ #G>F;B>7BB>;53F;A@E
3BB>;53F;A@E 3D7 7H7@FAD;7@F76 3@6 9AH7D@76 4K E;?B>7 DG>7E
@ 12 F:7 3GF:ADE BDABAE7 3@ 3D5:;F75FGD7 8AD 7H7@F43E76 7@FD3>;L76 12 12
?A@;FAD;@9A8BG4>;5EB357E;@E?3DF5;F;7EGE;@9:7F7DA97@7AGE 757@FD3>;L76 1
23@6%$
E7@EADE *:7 ?3;@ 9A3> ;E FA BDAH;67 3 8D3?7IAD= 8AD F:7
;?B>7?7@F3F;A@ A8 ?A@;FAD;@9 E7DH;57E 8AD BG4>;5 3D73E AD @F79D3F;A@ %$
;@8D3EFDG5FGD7E ;@ 97@7D3> *:7 BDABAE76 3D5:;F75FGD7 GE7E F:7
BG4>;E: EG4E5D;47B3D36;9?I:7D77>7?7@FE53>>76!@AI>7697 %$R%$*(%"$)%$#!$)/)*#
&DA57EEADE !&E BDA6G57 3@6 5A@EG?7 7H7@F @AF;8;53F;A@E %()#(*+"$)
)G5: @AF;8;53F;A@E ?3K 47 FD3@E?;EE;A@E A8 E7@E76 63F3 AD %$ >A9;53> 3D5:;F75FGD7 ;9GD7 ;@5>G67E ; 8AGD
5A??3@6EFA477J75GF76$AF;8;53F;A@E3D76;EFD;4GF76FA!&E EA8FI3D7 5A?BA@7@FE ,*08054 (104. (4(.,7 54095704.
F:3F EG4E5D;476 FA EG5: 7H7@F FKB7 F:DAG9: )7?3@F;5 (4(.,7 *9:(9054 (4(.,7 3@6 %! (4(.,7 ;; F:7
@8AD?3F;A@DA=7DE)EF:3FB3EEF:77H7@F ;@8AD?3F;A@FA 4-,7,4*, !:)8>89,3 7@5A?B3EE;@9 F:7 4-,7,4*, ,9/5+
3BB>;53F;A@E @ EG5: IAD= -)$E 3D7 GE76 A@>K 3E FAA>E FA 5A?BA@7@F 3@6 F:7 4-,7,4*, (7(3,9,78 +(9()(8, ;;; F:7
?A@;FAD B:KE;53> CG3@F;F;7E 4GF F:7 E7@EAD @A67E 6A @AF 49,.7(9054 !:)8>89,3 7@5A?B3EE;@9 F:7 49,.7(9054 ,9/5+
B7D8AD?3@KA8F:767E5D;476DA>7E;7F:7-)$;E@AF3B3DF 5A?BA@7@F3@6F:749,.7(9054(7(3,9,78+(9()(8,3@6;H
A8F:7BDABAE763D5:;F75FGD7 F:76620*(90548+(9()(8,
@ 12 3@ 3BB>;53F;A@ ;E BDABAE76 FA 5A@FDA> >;9:F;@9 *:7 75;E;A@ #3=;@9 #3@397D ?3@397E F:7 AB7D3F;A@ A8
EKEF7?E 3@6 F:7 EF3F7 A8 7CG;B?7@F 3@6 EFDG5FGD7E EG5: 3E F:7 AF:7D 5A?BA@7@FE EG4EKEF7?E 3@6 5AAD6;@3F7E 35F;A@E
I;@6AIE)G5:BDABAE3>;E6;H;676;@FIA?3;@B3DFE*:78;DEF B7D8AD?76 ;@ F:7 4G;>6;@9 F ;E 3>EA D7EBA@E;4>7 8AD E7>75F;@9
A@7 ;E D7EBA@E;4>7 8AD ?A@;FAD;@9 B:KE;53> 7H7@FE F:DAG9: 3 E7@E7663F3E7@F4KF:7#A@;FAD;@9#3@397D8AD735:675;E;A@
-)$*:7E75A@6I:;5:;E>A53F76AGFE;67A8F:7-)$;E ?3=;@9 BDA57EE A8 735: 3BB>;53F;A@ EA>H;@9 5A@8>;5FE 3?A@9
D7EBA@E;4>78ADBDA57EE;@9;@5A?;@963F38DA?F:78;DEFB3DF3@6 675;E;A@E?3674KF:7@F79D3F;A@)G4EKEF7?3@68ADE7@6;@9
5A@F3;@E F:7 5A@FDA> 3@6675;E;A@?3=;@9 BDA57EE7E 3E76A@ F:7EA>H76675;E;A@EFAF:75FG3F;A@#3@397D*AB7D8AD?F:;E
;@BGF 63F3 BDAH;676 4K F:7 -)$ F:7 3BB>;53F;A@ ;E 34>7 FA E7@E76 63F3 E7>75F;A@ F:7 75;E;A@ #3=;@9 #3@397D CG7D;7E
79 E7F 3>3D?E A88 ;8 3@K ?73EGD7?7@F 7J5776E 3 9;H7@ F:7 BB>;53F;A@E 63F343E7 I:;5: 5A@F3;@E 3>> 3BB>;53F;A@
F:D7E:A>6 ?A@;FAD D7EAGD57E GE76 4K GE7DE 3BB>;53F;A@E B3D3?7F7DE EG5:3E F:7;D ;67@F;8;7DE FKB7EA8D7CG;D76 E7@EADE
67F7D?;@7 I:;5: 5A?BGF7DE 3D7 3H3;>34>7 ;@ 3 >34AD3FADK 3@6 F:7 8D7CG7@5K I;F: I:;5: 735: 3BB>;53F;A@ 675;E;A@
255
?3=;@9 BDA57EE I;>> 47 FD;997D76 *:7 8D7CG7@5K 8AD D3F7E*:7D78AD7%$GE7EF:7:;9:7D8D7CG7@5K;@AD67DFA
E7@E;@9 E7@6;@963F3FAF:775;E;A@#3=;@9#3@397D;EE7F3F ?77F 3>> 3BB>;53F;A@E D7CG;D7?7@FE #AD7AH7D E7@E76 63F3 ;E
F:7 #A@;FAD;@9 #3@397D A@8>;5FE 3?A@9 675;E;A@E :3BB7@ 5A>>75F76 D793D6>7EE A8 F:7;D E7?3@F;5 H3>G7 8AD ;@F7@676
4753GE7 735: 3BB>;53F;A@ ;E 7H3>G3F76 E7B3D3F7>K ;@ F:7 3BB>;53F;A@EAD7J3?B>7I:7@F:7#A@;FAD;@9#3@397D97FE
@F79D3F;A@ EG4EKEF7? )A I:7@ F:7@F79D3F;A@ )G4EKEF7? 3 D736;@9 8DA? 3 BD7E7@57 E7@EAD ;F ;@6;53F7E I:7F:7D
5:3;@E 675;E;A@E 8DA? 3 8;DEF 3BB>;53F;A@FA 3 E75A@6 EA?7F:;@9 ;E ;@ ?AF;A@ B7AB>7 H7:;5>7E 7F5 ;@ 3 9;H7@
3BB>;53F;A@ ;F 6A7E @AF 5A@E;67D 3@K AF:7D 675;E;A@E I:;5: 7@H;DA@?7@F %@>K I:7@ F:;E D736;@9 ;E E7@F FA F:7 75;E;A@
I7D7AD?;9:F47?3674K3@KAF:7DF:;D63BB>;53F;A@I:;5: #3=;@9 #3@397D 3@6 3EEA5;3F76 I;F: 3@ 3BB>;53F;A@ ;F ?3K
?;9:F;@F7D87D7;@F:78;DEF3@6E75A@63BB>;53F;A@E;@HA>H76;@ ;@6;53F77H7@FEA8?AD75A?B>7J?73@;@9EG5:3ESF:7D7;E3@
F:7 5GDD7@F 5:3;@;@9 E 3@ 7J3?B>7 >7FOE 5A@E;67D F:D77 ;@FDG67D ;@ F:7 7@H;DA@?7@FT AD S6A @AF FGD@ F:7 7>7H3FAD A88
3BB>;53F;A@E3@6 >EA5A@E;67DF:3F3E3?7E7@E76 E;@57 F:7D7 3D7 B7AB>7 ;@E;67 ;FT *:;E E7?3@F;5 H3>G7 ;E A@>K
63F3 FD;997DE 3 675;E;A@ D7>3F76 FA 3@6 3@AF:7D 675;E;A@ F3=7@ ;@FA 355AG@F 6GD;@9 F:7 ;@87D7@57 BDA57EE ;@ I:;5:
D7>3F76 FA );@57 F:7 @F79D3F;A@ EG4EKEF7? :3@6>7E E7@E76 63F3 ;E 3EEA5;3F76 I;F: 3 EB75;8;5 3BB>;53F;A@ *:7
3BB>;53F;A@EE7B3D3F7>K3EBD7H;AGE>K?7@F;A@765A@E;67DF:3F #A@;FAD;@9 #3@397DB7D;A6;53>>K E7@6E F:7 E7@E76 63F3 FAF:7
;E:3@6>768;DEF3@6F:7D7;E3DG>78AD5:3;@;@93675;E;A@ 75;E;A@#3=;@9#3@397D@AD67DFA?;@;?;L7F:7@G?47DA8
8DA? ;@FA GF D;9:F 38F7D I:7@ :3@6>;@9 3@AF:7D FD3@E?;EE;A@E F:GE E3H;@9 7@7D9K F:7 #A@;FAD;@9 #3@397D
DG>77J;EFE8AD5:3;@;@93675;E;A@8DA?;@FA @53E7A8 EFAD7E F:7 >3EF D736;@9 E7@F 8DA? 735: E7@E;@9 G@;F 3@6
4AF:675;E;A@E47;@9F:7E3?7F:775;E;A@#3=;@9#3@397D 5A?B3D7E735:@7ID736;@9FAEG5:H3>G7*:;E@7ID736;@9;E
6A7E@AF@776FA673>I;F:3@K5A@8>;5F%F:7DI;E7;F@776EFA A@>KE7@FFAF:775;E;A@#3=;@9#3@397DI:7@7H7DF:7D7;E3
EA>H7 F:7 5A@8>;5F ?3=;@9 3 8;@3> 675;E;A@ E;@57 5AG>6 E;9@;8;53@F H3D;3F;A@ 34AH7 3 67F7D?;@76 F:D7E:A>6 47FI77@
B7D8AD? 6;EB3D3F7 35F;A@E 3E 3 D7EG>F A8 F:7 5A@8>;5F;@9 F:7 EFAD76 63F3 3@6 F:7 @7I D736;@9 *:7 5FG3FAD #3@397D
675;E;A@EAD;@EF3@57;@34G;>6;@9I;F:FIA3BB>;53F;A@E8;D7 ?3@397E F:7 EKEF7? 35FG3F;A@ A@ F:7 ?A@;FAD76 7@H;DA@?7@F
67F75F;A@ 3BB>;53F;A@ 3@6 , 3BB>;53F;A@ F:7 A55GDD7@57 ;7 ;F ;E ;@ 5:3D97 A8 7J75GF;@9 F:7 675;E;A@E F3=7@ 4K F:7
A8 3 8;D7 H3>G7 A8 E7@E76 63F3 ;@6;53F;@9 :;9: F7?B7D3FGD7 75;E;A@#3=;@9#3@397D*:;E5A?BA@7@FE:AG>647>A53F76
FD;997DE 675;E;A@E A8 F:7 ;D7 67F75F;A@ 3BB>;53F;A@ EG5: 3E ;@ 3 B:KE;53> 67H;57 I:;5: ;E 34>7 A8 35F;@9 ;@ F:7 E?3DF
FGD@;@9A@F:7E75GD;FK3>3D?3@6FD;997D;@9F:7EBD;@=>7DEGF 4G;>6;@953>>7635FG3FADF:3F;@5>G67E7>75FD;5EI;F5:7ED7>3KE
3675;E;A@53@475:3;@768DA?F:78;D767F75F;A@3BB>;53F;A@FA "E 7F5 *:7;D DA>7 ;E FA FGD@ A@ A88 >3?BE D78D;97D3FADE AD
F:7 , 3BB>;53F;A@ I:;5: ;E E:GFF;@9 6AI@ F:7 AF:7D67H;57E;@F:74G;>6;@9*:75FG3F;A@#3@397DD757;H7E
H7@F;>3F;A@ 3;D5A@6;F;A@7DEKEF7?I:;5:B7DF3;@EFAF:7, 8DA? F:7 75;E;A@ #3=;@9 #3@397D 3@ 3BB>;53F;A@ ;67@F;8;7D
3BB>;53F;A@E;@57=77B;@9F:73;D5A@6;F;A@7DA@6GD;@938;D7 3@6 AGFBGF H3>G7E 8DA? F:7 @87D7@57 EG4EKEF7? *:7 -)$
5AG>6D7EG>F;@;7J5:3@9;@9F:7E?A=73?A@9AF:7DDAA?EA8 #3@397D ;E F:7 5A??G@;53F;A@ ;@F7D8357 47FI77@ F:7 -)$
F:7 4G;>6;@9 F:DAG9: F:7 H7@F;>3F;A@ EKEF7? ;; EBD736;@9 F:7 3@67JF7D@3>@7FIAD=E8ADI3D6;@9?7EE397E8DA?A@7@7FIAD=
8;D7;@F:75GDD7@FDAA?AD7H7@;;;EF3DF;@93@7I8;D7EBAF6G7 FA F:7 AF:7D *:;E 5A?BA@7@F ;E GE76 FA ?A@;FAD F:7 EKEF7?
FA E:ADF 5;D5G;FE 53GE76 4K ;FE AB7D3F;A@ G@67D :3DE: AB7D3F;A@ 8AD ?3;@F7@3@57 AD 3G6;F;@9 BGDBAE7E 3@6 FA E7@6
7@H;DA@?7@F3> 5;D5G?EF3@57E 7JFD7?7>K :;9: F7?B7D3FGD7 5A??3@6E FA F:7 75;E;A@ #3=;@9 #3@397D 8DA? AGFE;67 A8
@AF:7D BAEE;4>7 675;E;A@ ;E FA FGD@ A@ F:7 7J:3GEF 83@ 8AD F:7-)$
FD3@EBADF;@9F:7E?A=7AGFA8F:74G;>6;@9F:DAG9:3676;53F76 # $ # $ # $

H7@F;>3F;A@ EKEF7? GF E;?G>F3@7AGE>K F:7 E3?7 E7@E76 63F3
;@6;53F;@9:;9:F7?B7D3FGD7FD;997DE3675;E;A@A8F:7,
3BB>;53F;A@ I:;5: ;E FA FGD@ A@ F:7 H7@F;>3F;A@ 3;D 5A@6;F;A@7D
EKEF7?I:;5:5A@8>;5FEI;F:7H7DKBAEE;4>7675;E;A@A8F:78;D7
3BB>;53F;A@@F:;E53E7F:7D7E:AG>6473BD787D7@57FAF:7;D7 # $

67F75F;A@ 3BB>;53F;A@ 8AD ?3=;@9 F:7 8;@3> 675;E;A@ 3@6 @A
BA;@F;@35F;H3F;@9F:73;D5A@6;F;A@7D6GD;@938;D7EA>H;@9F:7

5A@8>;5FE3EA>GF;A@8AD:3@6>;@95A@8>;5FE;@F:;EIAD=I7 # $ #

$ # $

:3H75:AE7@3EBD;AD;FKDG>7F:78;DEFFA3BB73D;@F:7@F79D3F;A@
&3D3?7F7D3F343E712+E;@9F:77J3?B>734AH7I7E:AG>6 #
$ #
$
B>357 F:7 ;D7 67F75F;A@ 3BB>;53F;A@ DG>7E 478AD7 F:7 ,

3BB>;53F;A@ DG>7E *:7 #A@;FAD;@9 #3@397D 5AAD6;@3F7E F:7 ;9%$3D5:;F75FGD7
F3E=A8?A@;FAD;@9B:KE;53>H3D;34>7EA8F:74G;>6;@9F:GEF:;E
5A?BA@7@F ?GEF 47 67B>AK76 ;@ 3 B:KE;53> 67H;57 7@6AI76 *:7@87D7@57EG4EKEF7?;ED7EBA@E;4>78AD675;6;@943E76
I;F: E7@E;@9 G@;FE *:7 5A?BA@7@F ;E 43E;53>>K 3@ & A@ E7@E76 63F3 D757;H76 8DA? F:7 #A@;FAD;@9 #3@397D 3@6
BB>;53F;A@ BDA9D3??;@9 ;@F7D8357 FA F:7 E7@E;@9 G@;FE ;@ 3 8ADI3D676 4K F:7 75;E;A@ #3=;@9 #3@397D I:;5: 35F;A@E
@A6735:@A6753@:3H7A@7AD?AD7E7@E;@9G@;FE53B34>7 I;>>47B7D8AD?764KF:75FG3FAD#3@397D75;E;A@E?367;@
A8 ?A@;FAD;@9 6;887D7@F H3D;34>7E EG5: 3E >;9:F F7?B7D3FGD7 F:;E @87D7@57 EG4EKEF7? 3D7 8ADI3D676 FA F:7 @F79D3F;A@
7F5 F ;E @AF76 F:3F 6;887D7@F3BB>;53F;A@E ?3K D7CG;D7 E7@E;@9 )G4EKEF7? F:3F I;>> 67F7D?;@7 ;8 3@AF:7D 675;E;A@ 53@ 47
63F3 A8 F:7 E3?7 FKB7 4GF ;@ 6;887D7@F 8D7CG7@5;7E E7@E;@9 5:3;@76FA;F;@3>>KF:7@F79D3F;A@)G4EKEF7?;ED7EBA@E;4>7
256
8AD B7D8AD?;@9 ;@F79D3F;A@ 3@6 5AAB7D3F;A@ 47FI77@ 6;887D7@F 49,.7(9054!:)8>89,3,8*7069054
3BB>;53F;A@E ;@ AD67D FA ; 7>;?;@3F7 63F3 E7@E76 4K 83G>FK *:7 @F79D3F;A@ )G4EKEF7? ;E D7EBA@E;4>7 8AD ;@F79D3F;@9
E7@EADE 3@6 ;; 7@34>7 E7@E76 63F3 E:3D;@9 3@6 675;E;A@ H3D;AGE3BB>;53F;A@E;@F:7E?3DF4G;>6;@94K5:3;@;@9675;E;A@E
5:3;@;@9 F3=;@9 ;@FA 355AG@F F:7 EF3F7 A8 7CG;B?7@F 3@6 F:7 8DA? A@7 3BB>;53F;A@ FA 3@AF:7D A@7 *:7 ;@BGF 63F3 8AD F:7
675;E;A@E ?367 4K 735: 3BB>;53F;A@ 3>A@7 *:7 675;E;A@E @F79D3F;A@#7F:A65A?BA@7@F;E7J35F>KF:7AGFBGF63F3A8F:7
FD;997D764KF:7@F79D3F;A@)G4EKEF7?3@6F:7675;E;A@E?367 @87D7@57)G4EKEF7?;7F:7675;E;A@E?3674KF:7@87D7@57
4K F:7 @87D7@57 )G4EKEF7? 3D7 E7@F FA F:7 75;E;A@ #3=;@9 )G4EKEF7?;@A@7A8F:735F;H73BB>;53F;A@E*:75:A;57A8F:7
#3@397DI:;5:8ADI3D6EF:7?FAF:75FG3F;A@#3@397D 35F;A@EFA47FD;997D76;E43E76A@B3D3?7F7DE3@6E;?B>7DG>7E
@ F:;E IAD= I7 5A@E;67D 3 -)$ 5A?BAE76 A8 E7H7D3> EFAD76 ;@ F:7 @F79D3F;A@ &3D3?7F7DE 63F343E7 )G5: 63F343E7
E7@EAD@A67E35FG3FAD@A67E3@6A@743E7EF3F;A@-73EEG?7 678;@7E F:7 @3FGD7 A8 F:7 ;@F79D3F;A@ 47FI77@ FIA AD ?AD7
FIADA>7E8ADE7@EAD@A67E67@AF;@9F:7;DD7EBA@E;4;>;F;7E;@F:7 3BB>;53F;A@E AD ;@EF3@57 >7FUE 5A@E;67D F:3F ;@ 3 9;H7@
@7FIAD=; $,$)(%$(" (,)+) #)$3@6;; ?A?7@F3675;E;A@;E?3674KF:7@87D7@57)G4EKEF7?;@F:7
+$(+2 (,)+ ) %)$ *:7 35FG3FAD @A67E 3@6 F:7 ";9:F;@9 3BB>;53F;A@ FA FGD@ F:7 >;9:FE A88 ;@ 3 DAA? *:;E
43E7 EF3F;A@ 53@ B>3K 735: A@7 3 G@;CG7 DA>7 F:7 -.-)+ 675;E;A@ FD;997DE A@7 DG>7 A8 F:7 @F79D3F;A@ &3D3?7F7DE
) *$3@6 , --$)() )$D7EB75F;H7>K*:7 63F343E7FAFGD@F:7F7?B7D3FGD73@6H7@F;>3F;A@EKEF7?EA88;@
38AD7?7@F;A@76 EA8FI3D7 5A?BA@7@FE I7D7 ;?B>7?7@F76 ;@ F:7,3BB>;53F;A@*:7?73@;@9A8F:;EDG>7;EF:3FF:7D7;E
B:KE;53> 67H;57E 3E 67E5D;476 ;@ ;9GD7 *:7 #)$ DA>7 @A4A6K ;@ EG5: DAA? 3@6 F:7@ F:7D7 ;E @A @776 FA =77B ;F
5A@F3;@E F:7 75;E;A@ #3=;@9 #3@397D F:7 BB>;53F;A@E D78D;97D3F76F:GEF:735F;A@FA47FD;997D76;@F:;E5A@F7JF;EFA
63F343E7 F:7 @87D7@57 EG4EKEF7? 3@6 F:7 @F79D3F;A@ FGD@ F:7 3;D 5A@6;F;A@7D A88 *:7 BD7E7@57 A8 EG5: DG>7 ;@ F:7
)G4EKEF7? *:7 %)$ *$ 3@6 )$ 5A@F3;@ A@>K 3 E;@9>7 @F79D3F;A@ 63F343E7 ;@6;53F7E F:3F F:7 ";9:F;@9 3@6 ,
5A?BA@7@F 735: F:7 #A@;FAD;@9 #3@397D 5FG3FAD #3@397D 3BB>;53F;A@E3D7;@F79D3F76;@F:7675;E;A@5:3;@;@9>7H7>
3@6 -)$ #3@397D D7EB75F;H7>K *:7 %)$ DA>7 ?GEF 47
3EE;9@76FAE7@EAD@A67EF:3F5A@F3;@E7@E;@9G@;FE*:7%)$E A!>89,36,7(9054
5A>>75F63F38DA?F:7?A@;FAD767@H;DA@?7@F3@6E7@6F:7?H;3 %$ 5A@FDA> 8>AI ;E 6;H;676 ;@ B:3E7E EF3DFGB 3@6
D36;A355AD6;@9FAF:7#A@;FAD;@9#3@397DDG>7E)7@EAD@A67E EKEF7? AB7D3F;@9 5K5>7 @ F:7 !$+,- *#, 63F343E7E 3D7
3EE;9@76 3E #)$E 3D7 @AF D7CG;D76 FA :3H7 E7@E;@9 G@;FE 5D73F763@6BABG>3F76I;F:63F3D7CG;D76FAAB7D3F7F:7EKEF7?
*:7KD757;H7E7@E7663F38DA?F:7%)$E?3=7675;E;A@E3@6 F:7 3BB>;53F;A@E FA 47 35F;H7 ;@ F:7 E?3DF 4G;>6;@9 3D7
FD3@E?;F F:7? FA *$E 3@6 F:7 )$ GDF:7D?AD7 #)$E 5A@8;9GD76 3@6 F:7 ;@87D7@57 3@6 ;@F79D3F;A@ ?7F:A6E FA 47
?;9:FD757;H75A??3@6E8DA?AGFE;67F:7-)$F:DAG9:F:7 GE76 3D7 678;@76 3E I7>> 3E F:7;D B3D3?7F7DE 3D7 E7F
)$ *:7 35FG3FAD @A67E 3EE;9@76 3E *$E A@>K D757;H7 @8AD?3F;A@ A@ F:7 3BB>;53F;A@E 3@6 F:7;D B3D3?7F7DE 3D7
?7EE397E E7@F 4K 3 #)$ 3@6 35F A@ F:7 E?3DF 4G;>6;@9 67B>AK76 ;@ F:7 E7@EADE 8>3E: ?7?ADK *:7 E7@EADE FA 47
355AD6;@9FAF:75A@F7@FEA8EG5:;@5A?;@9?7EE397E)$;E3 35F;H3F76 67B7@6 A@ I:;5: 3BB>;53F;A@E 3D7 DG@@;@9 ;@ F:7
43E7EF3F;A@F:3F5A>>75FEF:763F3E7@F4KF:7-)$8ADEKEF7? -)$ @ F:7 , )( *#, F:7 75;E;A@ #3=;@9 #3@397D
?3;@F7@3@57 3@6 3G6;F;@9 BGDBAE7E 3@6 ;E 34>7 FA E7@6 D757;H7E 8DA? F:7 #A@;FAD;@9 #3@397D F:7 63F3 5A>>75F76 4K
5A??3@6EFA#)$E8DA?AGFE;67F:7-)$ E7@E;@9G@;FE3@63EE;9@EF:;E63F3FA3BB>;53F;A@E@F:753E7
EFG6KB7D8AD?76FA3EE7EE%$AB7D3F;A@E7@E;@9G@;FEF:3F
4-,7,4*,!:)8>89,3,8*7069054
?A@;FAD F7?B7D3FGD7 3@6 BD7E7@57 3D7 3EEA5;3F76 FA ,
AD 735: 35F;H7 3BB>;53F;A@ ;@ F:7 -)$ 3@ 3BB>;53F;A@ 3BB>;53F;A@ 3@6 E7@E;@9 G@;FE F:3F ?A@;FAD >;9:F 3@6 BD7E7@57
F:3F:3E477@67B>AK763@6;E47;@97J75GF76;@F:7E7@EADEF:7 3D7 3EE;9@76 FA ";9:F;@9 A@FDA> 3BB>;53F;A@ @ F:7 ,*08054
@87D7@57)G4EKEF7?;ED7EBA@E;4>78ADBDA57EE;@9E7@E7663F3 (104.(4(.,7E7@E7663F38DA?6;887D7@FE7@E;@9G@;FE3D7
3@6 ?3=;@9 675;E;A@E *:7 @87D7@57 #7F:A6 5A?BA@7@F 9DAGB76355AD6;@9FAF:7D7CG;D7?7@FEA8735:3BB>;53F;A@3@6
678;@7E :AI E7@E76 63F3 I;>> 47 BDA57EE76 ;@ AD67D FA ?3=7 E7@F FA F:7 @87D7@57 )G4EKEF7? I:;5: BDA57EE7E F:7? 3@6
675;E;A@E A@ 47:3>8 A8 3BB>;53F;A@E *:7E7 675;E;A@E 3D7 ?367 ?3=7E 675;E;A@E FA 735: 3BB>;53F;A@ E7B3D3F7>K %@57 F:7E7
43E76A@3E7FA8B3D3?7F7DE3@6DG>7EEFAD76;@F:7@87D7@57 675;E;A@E3D7?367;@F:7@87D7@57)G4EKEF7?;F3EEA5;3F7E3@
&3D3?7F7DE63F343E7F:3FD79G>3F7F:7675;E;A@?3=;@9BDA57EE 3BB>;53F;A@;67@F;8;7DFA;FED7EB75F;H7675;E;A@3@6E7@6EF:7?
A@735:3BB>;53F;A@*:7@87D7@57&3D3?7F7DE63F343E7678;@7E 3E3?7EE397FAF:7,*08054(104.(4(.,7AD7J3?B>7;@
F:7 E7?3@F;5E A8 ;@BGFE 3@6 AGFBGFE A8 F:7 5:AE7@ ;@87D7@57 3 , 3BB>;53F;A@ 3 ?7EE397 5A@F3;@;@9 ; F:7 3BB>;53F;A@
?7F:A6@BGFH3D;34>7EA8F:7;@87D7@57?7F:A63D7E7@E7663F3 ;67@F;8;7D;;3H3>G7F:3F;@6;53F7E3F:7D?AEF3F36<GEF?7@FFA
5A>>75F76 4K E7@E;@9 G@;FE 3EEA5;3F76 I;F: 735: 3BB>;53F;A@ 35:;7H7 3 @7I F7?B7D3FGD7 3@6 ;;; 3 H3>G7 ;@6;53F;@9 F:7
I:;>7 AGFBGF H3D;34>7E 5A@E;EF A8 675;E;A@E F:3F 3 9;H7@ ;@F7@E;FK F:3F F:7 H7@F;>3F;A@ EKEF7? E:AG>6 IAD= 4AF: H3>G7E
3BB>;53F;A@?;9:F?3=7AD7J3?B>78AD3,3BB>;53F;A@ 678;@76 4K F:7 EKEF7? ?3@397D ;E 5D73F76 3@6 E7@F FA F:7
;@BGFH3D;34>7E3D7F7?B7D3FGD73@6BD7E7@573@6F:7AGFBGF;E 75;E;A@ #3=;@9 #3@397D *:7 75;E;A@ #3=;@9 #3@397D
F7?B7D3FGD7H3D;3F;A@3@6H7@F;>3F;A@;@F7@E;FK*:GE675;E;A@E 8ADI3D6E F:;E ?7EE397 FA F:7 @F79D3F;A@ )G4EKEF7? *:7
;@F:;E,3BB>;53F;A@53@4736<GEF;@93@3;D5A@6;F;A@;@9 @F79D3F;A@ )G4EKEF7? 355AD6;@9 FA F:7 ;@F79D3F;A@ ?7F:A6
F:7D?AEF3FFAF:7;673>F7?B7D3FGD7355AD6;@9FA3H3>G7EFAD76 5:AE7@ 4K F:7 EKEF7? ?3@397D CG7D;7E F:7 @F79D3F;A@
;@ F:7 63F343E7 3@6 AD FD;997D;@9 F:7 H7@F;>3F;A@ EKEF7? I;F: &3D3?7F7DE 63F343E7 8AD 35F;A@E FA 47 FD;997D76 AD 7J3?B>7
F:7E3?7BGDBAE7 >7F GE 5A@E;67D FIA 3BB>;53F;A@E ";9:F;@9 3@6 ,
257
3BB>;53F;A@E@53E7A8F:775;E;A@#3=;@9#3@397DE7@63 ;@38>3F@7FIAD=FABA>A9K#LE7@EAD@A67E3D77@6AI76
?7EE397 FA F:7 @F79D3F;A@ )G4EKEF7? ;@6;53F;@9 F:DAG9: 3 I;F: = A8 (# = A8 8>3E: ?7?ADK 8AD BDA9D3?
;67@F;8;7DF:73BB>;53F;A@FA475A@E;67D76;@F:;E53E7, EFAD3973@6=8AD63F3EFAD3973@6BAI7D764KFIA
3@6 F:7 675;E;A@ ;@ F:;E 53E7 FA FGD@ F:7 F7?B7D3FGD7 3@6 43FF7D;7E
?: I:;5: FA97F:7D 5A@F3;@E 3BBDAJ;?3F7>K
H7@F;>3F;A@EKEF7?EA88);@57F:7,3BB>;53F;A@675;676
A8 7@7D9K 12 %$ I3E 4G;>F 4K GE;@9 *;@K%)

FA FGD@ A88 F:7 H7@F;>3F;A@ 3@6 :73F;@9 EKEF7? F:7 >;9:F;@9 12 67H7>AB?7@F 7@H;DA@?7@F 3@6 @7E 12
3BB>;53F;A@?GEF3>EAFGD@F:7>;9:F;@9EKEF7?A88D793D6>7EEA8 BDA9D3??;@9 >3@9G397 );?G>3F76 7JB7D;?7@FE I7D7
>;9:FE7@EADD736;@9E?73@;@9F:3FF:7DAA?;EBDA434>K7?BFK B7D8AD?76 ;@ F:7 HDAD3 E;?G>3FAD 12 I:;5: 36ABFE 3
EA F:7D7 ;E @A @776 FA ?3;@F3;@ F:7 >;9:FE A@ *:7@ F:7 D73>;EF;57@7D9K?A67>12*:7HDAD37@7D9K?A67>355AG@FE
FD;997D76 35F;A@E 675;E;A@E 3D7 E7@F FA F:7 75;E;A@ #3=;@9 F:7 7@7D9K 5A@EG?76 I;F: BDA57EE;@9 FD3@E?;EE;A@ 3@6
#3@397D I:;5: I;>> 8ADI3D6 F:7? FA F:7 5FG3F;A@ #3@397D D757BF;A@A8B35=7FEGE7A8"E3@68>3E:?7?ADK3557EE7E
3@6 F:7 -)$ #3@397D *:7 5FG3F;A@ #3@397D D757;H7E 7E;67EF:77JB7D;?7@FE7J75GF76;@3E;?G>3F767@H;DA@?7@F
EG5:8ADI3D676675;E;A@EAD;9;@3F767;F:7D8DA?F:7@87D7@57 %$ 5A?BA@7@FE I7D7 3>EA ;?B>7?7@F76 ;@ D73> #;530
AD 8DA? F:7 @F79D3F;A@ )G4EKEF7?E 3@6 7J75GF7E F:7? *:7 E7@EAD @A67E FA H3>;63F7 F:7 B7D8AD?76 E;?G>3F;A@E %$
-)$ #3@397D D757;H7E F:7 675;E;A@E E7@F 4K F:7 75;E;A@ 36ABFEF:7A>>75F;A@*D77&DAFA5A>12FADAGF763F3FAI3D6E
#3=;@9 #3@397D 3@6 8ADI3D6E F:7? AGF A8 F:7 -)$ F:7 43E7 EF3F;A@ 3@6 @F79D3F76 A@5GDD7@5K 3@6 @7D9K
D75AD6;@9F:735F;A@)G5:AB7D3F;A@3;?EFA5A@FDA>F:7EKEF7? #3@397?7@F 12 FA EK@5:DA@;L7 63F3 FD3@E?;EE;A@ ;@ F:7
47:3H;AD 3@6 FA 3G6;F F:7 675;E;A@ BDA57EE @ 366;F;A@ FA F:;E -)$*:7EK@5:DA@;L3F;A@;E8;DEFB7D8AD?76I:7@735:@A67
I:A>7BDA57EE?3@39764KF:775;E;A@#3=;@9#3@397DF:7 ;E 35F;H3F76 3@6 ;E B7D;A6;53>>K D7H;E76 )# I3E GE76 3E
-)$#3@397D53@3EK@5:DA@AGE>KD757;H7?7EE397E5A?;@9 ?76;G?3557EE5A@FDA>BDAFA5A>12
8DA?AGFE;67F:7-)$*:7E7?7EE397E5A@E;EFA@5A??3@6E
,8*70690545-9/,0362,3,49,+4-,7,4*,,9/5+
E7@F4K3EKEF7?AB7D3FADI:;5:3D78ADI3D676FAF:775;E;A@
#3=;@9 #3@397D *:;E BDA57EE ;E GE76 FA 36<GEF %$ AD F:7 ;?B>7?7@F3F;A@ A8 %$ GE76 ;@ F:7
AB7D3F;A@ J3?B>7E A8 BAEE;4>7 36<GEF?7@FE 3D7 ; 5:3@9;@9 7JB7D;?7@FEF:7@87D7@57#7F:A65A@E;EF76A8E7FEA8E;?B>7
F:7 E3?B>7 D3F7 3F %)$E 3@6 ;; 7@34>;@9 6;E34>;@9 3@ DG>7EF:3F3EE;9@675;E;A@E67B7@6;@9A@F:7;@BGFA@78AD735:
3BB>;53F;A@I:AE763F343E7;E3>D736K>A3676;@%$ 3BB>;53F;A@ DG@@;@9 ;@ F:7 -)$ @ EG5: ?7F:A6 F:7 ;@BGF
EB357 ;E 6;H;676 ;@FA 8;J76 E;L7 EG4EB357E 3@6 8AD 735:
,.&(#$*","+*%$ EG4EB3573E7FA8675;E;A@E;E3EE;9@76@AF:7DIAD6E8AD3@K
E7F A8 7JB7D;?7@FE I3E B7D8AD?76 FA 3EE7EE %$ ;@BGF H3>G7E F:3F 47>A@9 FA F:7 E3?7 EG4EB357 F:7 @87D7@57
D793D6;@9 ; F:7 873E;4;>;FK A8 67B>AK;@9 ;FE 5A?BA@7@FE ;@ #7F:A6I;>>3>I3KE:3H7F:7E3?7D7EBA@E7?3=;@9F:7E3?7
-)$ @A67E ;@ F7D?E A8 &+ 3@6 ?7?ADK GE397 7@7D9K 675;E;A@*:7D78AD78AD735:35F;H73BB>;53F;A@F:7D7;E3E7FA8
5A@EG?BF;A@ A8 F:7 E7@EAD @A67E 3@6 @7FIAD= 3H7D397 DG>7E GE76 4K F:7 @87D7@57 #7F:A6 35: DG>7 5A@E;EFE A8 3@
>;87F;?7 3@6 ;; F:7 47@78;FE 4AF: ;@ F7D?E A8 F:7 7@7D9K ;@BGF ;@F7DH3> ;7 3 D3@97A8H3>G7E F:3F 3 9;H7@ H3D;34>7 ;@ 3
5A@EG?76 4K F:7 E?3DF 4G;>6;@9 3@6 4K F:7 -)$35:;7H76 9;H7@ 3BB>;53F;A@ 53@ :3H7 79 F7?B7D3FGD7 ;@ , 53@
8DA? %$ 6757@FD3>;L76 67E;9@ 3@6 ;FE 3BBDA35: A8 D3@97 8DA?
FA 679D77E 7>E;GE AD 735: 35F;H7
3BB>;53F;A@ ;@F79D3F;A@ *IA 3BB>;53F;A@E I7D7 5A@E;67D76 ;@ 3BB>;53F;A@F:73EEA5;3F76675;E;A@E3D7EFAD76;@F:7@87D7@57
F:7 B7D8AD?76 7JB7D;?7@FE , 3@6 >;9:F;@9 *:7 E7@E;@9 &3D3?7F7DE 63F343E7 %$ ?3=7E 675;E;A@E 4K 5A?B3D;@9
G@;FEGE76I7D7F7?B7D3FGD7>;9:F3@6BD7E7@57*:735FG3F;A@ ;@BGF63F3I;F:B3D3?7F7DE;@F:763F343E7-:7@7H7D3@;@BGF
35F;H;FKI3E7?G>3F764K"EA@F:7*$E5FG3FAD$A67 63F3 E3F;E8;7E F:7 5A@6;F;A@E A8 3 B3DF;5G>3D DG>7 F:7 675;E;A@
D793D6>7EEA8F:7D73>35F;A@47;@9B7D8AD?76 3EEA5;3F76I;F:EG5:DG>7;EFD3@E?;FF76FAF:775;E;A@#3=;@9
@ 3>> F:7 5A@6G5F76 7JB7D;?7@FE I7 3EEG?76 F:3F F:7 #3@397D AD 7J3?B>7 F7?B7D3FGD7 ?73EGD76 ;@ 7>E;GE
EF3DFGB B:3E7 A8 %$ I3E 3>D736K B7D8AD?76 ;7 3>> 679D77E 3@6 BD7E7@57 ?73EGD76 ;@ A55GB3F;A@ D3F7 F:7 D3F;A
63F343E7E:363>D736K477@BABG>3F76F:73BB>;53F;A@E, 47FI77@F:73D73A55GB;764K3@G?47DA8B7AB>73@639;H7@
3@6 >;9:F;@9 I7D7 67B>AK76 ;@ F:7 @7FIAD= 3@6 F:7;D FAF3>3D73Q5A@E;67D;@9F:73D73A55GB;764K3E;@9>7B7DEA@3E
B3D3?7F7DEI7D75A@8;9GD763@6F:7;@87D7@573@6;@F79D3F;A@ J ?7F7DE?73@;@9F:73D73A55GB;764K3@A88;5767E=3@6
?7F:A6E:363>D736K477@678;@763EI7>>3EF:7;DB3D3?7F7DE 8ADF:77?B>AK775;D5G>3F;A@3D7;@BGFH3D;34>7E3EEA5;3F76FA3
:36 477@ E7F *:7 , 3@6 >;9:F;@9 3BB>;53F;A@E I;>> 47 ,3BB>;53F;A@3@6FA735:A8F:7?F:7;@F7DH3>EM
FA
N
35F;H7 ;@ F:7 -)$ E;@57 F:7 479;@@;@9 A8 F:7 EKEF7? 3@6 M
FA
N 3D7 3EEA5;3F76 D7EB75F;H7>K *:7 AGFBGF

AB7D3F;@95K5>7B:3E73@6D7?3;@5A@EF3@F>K35F;H7@63>EA H3D;34>7E D7BD7E7@F BAEE;4>7 35F;A@E F:3F 53@ 47 FD;997D76 FA
8AD F:;EB:3E73@ ;?BADF3@FB3D3?7F7D FA47 5A@E;67D76 ;EF:7 735:675;E;A@A83E;@9>73BB>;53F;A@EG5:3E36<GEF;@93@3;D
8D7CG7@5K 8AD F:7 63F3 5A>>75F;A@ E7@E;@9 3@6 FD3@E?;EE;A@ 5A@6;F;A@;@9 F:7D?AEF3F ;@ 3 57DF3;@ @G?47D A8679D77E*:GE
E7@6;@9 FA F:7 75;E;A@ #3=;@9 #3@397D 63F3 3@ 7J3?B>7 A8 3 DG>7 A8 3 , 3BB>;53F;A@ ?;9:F 47
E7@E;@9 E7@6;@9 D3F7E )G5: 8D7CG7@5K ;E 678;@76 B7D ?",36,7(9:7, ę &
&@ ?7,8,4*, ę
3BB>;53F;A@3@6EFAD76;@F:7BB>;53F;A@E63F343E7 &
&@" ?"/,73589(9 @ ?$,4902(9054

@ *:7 8A>>AI;@9 BE7G6A5A67 E:AIE F:7 8G@5F;A@;@9 A8
4;07543,49!,9904. F:7;@87D7@57#7F:A6
@3>>5A@6G5F767JB7D;?7@FE3-)$5A?BAE76A8EF3F;5 F3E=HA;6@87D7@57)KEF7?7F5:(G>7E
#LE7@EAD@A67EI3E5A@E;67D76*:7@A67EI7D73DD3@976
258
8AD735:(G>7;@@87D7@57&3D3?7F7D3E76A >35=A87@7D9KEAF:7")$;E43E76A@F:7)$5A?B3D;@9
;8 BB>;53F;A@ 53@ 47 7H3>G3F76 4K 3 DG>7 ;@ I;F: F:7 3?AG@F A8 7@7D9K 5A@F3;@76 ;@ F:7 FIA 43FF7D;7E
@87D7@57&3D3?7F7D3E7F:7@BB>KF:;EDG>7 GE76 ;@ #;530 F ;E ;?BADF3@F FA @AF;57 F:3F F:7 )$ 3@6
")$ 8AD 3 E7@EAD @A67 67B7@6 A@ F:7 DA>7 3EE;9@76 FA ;F
,8*70690545-9/,0362,3,49,+49,.7(9054,9/5+
F:7D78AD7F:7)$3@6")$I7D75A?BGF768AD3>>DA>7E
@ F:7 ;?B>7?7@F3F;A@ A8 %$ F:7 ;@F79D3F;A@ ?7F:A6
5A@E;EFEA8E7FEA8E;?B>7DG>7EF:3F?3K5:3;@675;E;A@EFAF:7
675;E;A@ A4F3;@76 4K F:7 ;@87D7@57 EG4EKEF7? *:7 ;@BGF 63F3

"

8AD F:7 @F79D3F;A@ #7F:A6 3D7 F:7 675;E;A@E BD7H;AGE>K ?367
!

4K F:7 @87D7@57 )G4EKEF7? 35: ;@BGF 675;E;A@ ;E :3@6>76

;@6;H;6G3>>K 4K F:7 @F79D3F;A@ #7F:A6 7H7@ ;8 FIA AD ?AD7

;@BGF 675;E;A@E 47>A@9 FA F:7 E3?7 3BB>;53F;A@ 3@6 :3H7 477@ ;93DAA?A8)57@3D;A4>AADEI;F:#)$;@)57@3D;A
?367E;?G>F3@7AGE>K);?;>3D>KFAF:7@87D7@57#7F:A6;@F:7
@F79D3F;A@ #7F:A6 F:7 ;@BGF EB357 ;E 6;H;676 ;@FA 8;J76 E;L7 *:7 ?7FD;5E GE76 FA 7H3>G3F7 %$ ;@ F7D?E A8 ;FE
EG4EB357E3@68AD735:EG4EB3573E7FA8675;E;A@E;E3EE;9@76 BDAH;676 47@78;FE I7D7 ; ,*08054 ,2(> ;; 4,7.>
GF;@F:7@F79D3F;A@#7F:A6F:7;@BGFEB357;E5A?BD;E76A8 !(;04.8 04 9/, !3(79 :02+04. !! 3@6 ;;; 4,7.>
F:7 675;E;A@E BD7H;AGE>K ?367 4K F:7 @87D7@57 #7F:A6 @ 548:3,+)>9/,%!%*:7?7FD;5;E678;@763E
AF:7D IAD6E 8AD 3@K ;@BGF 675;E;A@ F:3F 47>A@9E FA F:7 E3?7 F:7 F;?7 7>3BE76 E;@57 F:7 ?A?7@F F:3F F:7 E7@E;@9 63F3 ;E
EG4EB357 F:7 @F79D3F;A@ #7F:A6 I;>> 3>I3KE :3H7 F:7 E3?7 5A>>75F76 4K 3@ %D6;@3DK )7@EAD $A67 G@F;> F:7 ?A?7@F 3
D7EBA@E7*:7D78AD78AD735:35F;H73BB>;53F;A@F:7D7;E3E7FA8 675;E;A@ ;E 7J75GF76 ;@ F:7 4G;>6;@9 *:;E ?7FD;5 ;E GE76 FA
DG>7E GE76 4K F:7 @F79D3F;A@ #7F:A6 35: ;@F79D3F;A@ DG>7 ?73EGD7:AI83EF3675;E;A@;E?3673@6F:7?7FD;5;EGE76FA
5A@E;EFE A8 3@ ;@BGF 675;E;A@ 3@6 AGFBGF 675;E;A@E AD 3EE7EE F:7 36H3@F397E A8 GE;@9 3 6757@FD3>;L76 EKEF7? AH7D 3
7J3?B>7 S;8 F:7 3DF;8;5;3> >;9:F;@9 ;@F7@E;FK >;9:F;@9 57@FD3>;L76 A@7 ;@ F7D?E A8 D7EBA@E7 F;?7 AD 678;@;@9 F:7
3BB>;53F;A@;E;@39;H7@;@F7DH3>F:7@>;9:F;@F7@E;FK;ED76G576 )) ?7FD;5 8;DEF 5A@E;67D F:7 @7D9K A@EG?BF;A@ 4K F:7
;@ A8 F:7 35FG3> H3>G7 3@6 E:GF F:7 ;6>7 G@3FF7@676 )?3DFG;>6;@9)?73EGD76;@=;>AI3FFE:AGD=-:3E
7CG;B?7@F 6AI@ 7CG;B?7@F ?A@;FAD;@9 3BB>;53F;A@T *:;E F:77@7D9K5A@EG?764KF:77>75FD;53>67H;57E;@39;H7@F;?7
7J3?B>7 53@ 47 D7BD7E7@F76 3E ?20./949,4809> ę & ;@F7DH3>6GD;@9I:;5:F:7KI7D7FGD@76A@;@F:74G;>6;@9*:7

&@ " ?0./904.
@ );E53>5G>3F76GE;@9F:73H7D3977>75FD;53>BAI7D=-A8
!#"%'$" #*:7E7DG>7E3D7EFAD76;@F:7 F:7 7>75FD;53> 67H;57E ;@EF3>>76 ;@ F:7 E?3DF 4G;>6;@9 EGBB>;76
@F79D3F;A@ &3D3?7F7DE 63F343E7 -:7@7H7D 3@ ;@BGF 675;E;A@ 4K F:7;D D7EB75F;H7 ?3@G835FGD7D 63F3E:77FE*:7@ F:7 ?7FD;5
E3F;E8;7EF:75A@6;F;A@EA83DG>7F:7AGFBGF675;E;A@3EEA5;3F76 !! ;E 678;@76 3E F:7 B7D57@F D76G5F;A@ ;@ F:7 ) I:7@
I;F:EG5:DG>7;EFD3@E?;FF76FAF:775;E;A@#3=;@9#3@397D 36ABF;@9 3 5A@FDA> 3@6 675;E;A@?3=;@9 EKEF7? 8AD E?3DF
4G;>6;@9 3BB>;53F;A@E 5A@E;67D;@9 F:7 D787D7@57 E;FG3F;A@ 3E
,8*70690545-,970*8(4+!*,4(705 I:7@ @A EKEF7? I3E 36ABF76 *:7 )) ;E F:7 6;887D7@57
*:7?7FD;5EGE76FA7H3>G3F7%$;@F7D?EA8;FE;?B35F 47FI77@ ) I;F:AGF 3 5A@FDA> EKEF7? 3@6 ) I;F: 3
;FE AH7D:736 A@ F:7 -)$ @A67E I7D7 ; # :8(., 5A@FDA> EKEF7? 6;H;676 4K ) I;F:AGF 3 5A@FDA> EKEF7?
##;; :8(., #;;;75.7(3-2(8/3,357> D7BD7E7@F;@9F:73?AG@FA87@7D9KE3H768ADF:7E?3DF4G;>6;@9
:8(.,#;H!957(.,-2(8/3,357>:8(.,!#H I:7@ 36ABF;@9 3 5A@FDA> EKEF7? 6;H;676 4K F:7 ) ;@ F:7
4,7.> *548:369054 5- 9/, 8,4857 45+, ! 3@6 H; D787D7@57 E;FG3F;A@ @A 5A@FDA> EKEF7? AD 735: E7@EAD
(;,7(.,20-,903,5-9/,8,485745+,!EE7EE;@9%$ 35FG3FAD3@643E7EF3F;A@@A67EF:7%?7FD;5;E678;@763E
AH7D:736 ;E 5DG5;3> FA BDAH7 F:7 873E;4;>;FK A8 ;FE F:77@7D9K5A@EG?764K735:A8F:7??73EGD76;@ AG>7E
;?B>7?7@F3F;A@ ;@ D73> -)$ @A67E ;@ 8357 A8 F:7;D >;?;F76 *:7%?7FD;5;E?73EGD764KF:77@7D9K?A67>BDAH;6764K
5A?BGF3F;A@3> 3@6 7@7D9K D7EAGD57E *:7 ## ?7FD;5 ;E F:7HDAD3E;?G>3FAD>>7JB7D;?7@FEI7D7D7B73F76
F;?7E
678;@763EF:73?AG@FA8F;?7;@B7D57@FA8F:7FAF3>6GD3F;A@ 8ADA4F3;@;@935A@8;67@57;@F7DH3>8ADF:75:AE7@?7FD;5E
F;?7 A8 3@ 7JB7D;?7@F 3 @A67 EB7@6E 3F 735: 7@7D9K ?A67 @AGD7JB7D;?7@FEI75A@E;67D76F:D77E57@3D;AE)57@3D;A
5F;H7 6>7 AD &AI7D )3H7 ?A67E *:7 # ?7FD;5 ;E I3E GE76 8AD F:7 43E;5 5A@8;9GD3F;A@ 7JB7D;?7@FE 3@6
678;@76 3E F:7 3?AG@F A8 (# ;@ B7D57@F A8 F:7 FAF3> (# )57@3D;AE3@6 I7D7GE768ADF:7?3;@7JB7D;?7@FE3@63D7
3H3;>34>7;@F:7@A673@A675A@EG?7E6GD;@9F:77JB7D;?7@FE 43E76 A@ F:7 67E5D;BF;A@ 36ABF76 ;@ 12 @ )57@3D;A I7
*:7#?7FD;5;E678;@763EF:7BADF;A@A88>3E:?7?ADK;@ 5A@E;67D763D75F3@9G>3D3D73A8J?7F7DE3@6F:7#)$
B7D57@FA8F:7FAF3>8>3E:?7?ADK3H3;>34>7;@F:7@A67GE76FA I3E>A53F763FF:757@F7DA8F:;E3D7335:@A67:36;FEG@;CG7
EFAD7 F:7 A4<75F 8;>7 A8 F:7 EA8FI3D7 67H7>AB76 *:7 !# ;67@F;8;53F;A@ 3@6 3 8;J76 A?@;6;D75F;A@3> D36;A D3@97 A8
?7FD;5;E678;@763EF:7BADF;A@A88>3E:?7?ADK;@B7D57@FA8 ?7F7DE *:7D7 I3E @A ;@F7D87D7@57 6GD;@9 F:7 E;?G>3F76
F:7FAF3>8>3E:?7?ADK3H3;>34>7;@F:7@A67GE76FAEFAD763F3 7JB7D;?7@FE @ )57@3D;A I7 5A@E;67D76 3 :AGE7 I;F: FIA
A8 3@K =;@6 FA 47 GE76 4K %$ 6GD;@9 ;FE 7J75GF;A@ *:7 DAA?E J ?7F7DE 3@6 735: DAA? ;9GD7 3 :36 3
!?7FD;5;E678;@763EF:73?AG@FA87@7D9KEB7@F4K F:7 #)$3@6%)$E*:7D7;E3E;@9>7)$;@F:7:AGE7*:7
E7@EAD @A67 6GD;@9 F:7 7JB7D;?7@F ;@ AG>7E *:7 ! )$;E>A53F76AGFE;67F:7:AGE74GF735:#)$53@D735:F:7
?7FD;5;E678;@763EF:73H7D3973?AG@FA863KEA85A@F;@GAGE )$;@E;@9>7:AB@F:7)57@3D;A I75A@E;67D7634G;>6;@9
AB7D3F;A@35:;7H764KF:7E7@EAD@A67478AD7;FEF3DFE83;>;@98AD I;F:
8>AADEI;F:#)$>A53F76;@8>AADE3@6
259
;9GD7 4 35: #)$ 53@ D735: A@7 3@AF:7D 35: 8>AAD 67H;57E 7J5776E F:7 = (# 3H3;>34>7 (793D6;@9 F:7
J ?7F7DE :36 %)$ *:7D7 ;E 3 E;@9>7 )$ ;@ F:7 &#+ 4K 735: E7@EAD @A67 DA>7 *$ GE7E
)$ GE7E
4G;>6;@9 *:7 )$ ;E >A53F76 ;@ F:7 8;DEF 8>AAD 4GF 3>> #)$ #)$GE7E 3@6%)$GE7E 3FAF3>A8=
53@D735:;F;@3E;@9>7:AB@)57@3D;AE3@6 3>>%)$53@ (# I3E 3H3;>34>7 ;@ #;530 @A67E (793D6;@9 FA )#+
D735: F:7;D D7EB75F;H7 #)$ >A53F76 ;@ F:7 E3?7 8>AAD ;@ 3 H3>G7E 8AD735:DA>7F:7 *$)$3@6%)$GE7
I:;>7
E;@9>7:AB@4AF:E57@3D;AEF:7DAA?EI7D7?A@;FAD766GD;@9 #)$GE7E>>63F343E7EI7D7EFAD76;@F:763F3EFAD397
3 :AGDEB7D;A6I;F:3B7D;A6;5;FKA8
?;@ 8>3E:?7?ADK3@63E3>>63F343E7EI7D7>A53F76;@F:7#)$
A@>KF:7#)$GE7E;F(793D6;@9!#)$EEB7@6?AD7
(80*54-0.:7(9054=6,703,498
7@7D9K
F:3@F:7*$ 3@6%)$
*:7)$
*IA E;?G>3F;A@ 7JB7D;?7@FE GE76 F:7 43E;5 5A@8;9GD3F;A@ 3E 7JB75F76 EB7@6E?AD7 7@7D9K F:3@ F:7 AF:7D DA>7E
E57@3D;A I;F: 6;887D7@F BGDBAE7E *:7 8;DEF 7JB7D;?7@F I3E *:;E :3BB7@E 4753GE7 F:7 )$ @A67 ;E @7H7D ;@ BAI7D E3H7
B7D8AD?76 ;@ AD67D FA 8;@6 F:7 E7@E;@9 E7@6;@9 D3F7 3E ?A67 3E BD7H;AGE>K 7JB>3;@76 J57BF 8AD F:7 )$ 8AD F:7
?7@F;A@76;@F:7479;@@;@9A8)75F;A@,I:;5:?;@;?;L7EF:7 F:D77 D7?3;@;@9 DA>7E #)$ *$ 3@6 %)$ F:7 7@7D9K
-)$ D7EAGD57 5A@EG?BF;A@ - -7 H3D;76 F:7 E3?B>7 5A@EG?BF;A@;EEG7;E5DG5;3>*:GE3?A@9F:7E7F:D77DA>7EF:7
D3F7 8DA? FA E3?B>7E E75A@6 3@6 I7 :3H7 8AG@6 F:3F ;@ #)$ E:AI76 F:7 :;9:7EF )$
3@6 355AD6;@9>K ;F
F7D?E A8 - P F:7 47EF E3?B>7 D3F7 ;E 3>EA E:AI76 F:7 >AI7EF ")$ 63KE A8 5A@F;@GAGE
E3?B>7E E75A@6 AB7D3F;A@ 8 3@ *$ )$ AD %)$ @A67 83;>E 8AD >35= A8
*:7E75A@67JB7D;?7@F I3EB7D8AD?76FA8;@6F:7@G?47D 7@7D9K AD 3@K AF:7D D73EA@ %$ ;E @AF 5A?BDA?;E76
A8 %)$E B7D #)$ I:;5: IAG>6 7@EGD7 9AA6 I:;>7 AI7H7D;83#)$@A6783;>E%$IAG>683;>;@F:73D73
?;@;?;L;@9 -)$ D7EAGD57 5A@EG?BF;A@ -7 H3D;76 F:7 5AH7D764KF:3F#)$-7F:7D78AD75A@E;67D76F:3FF:7-
@G?47DA8%)$EB7D#)$8DA?FA
;@AD67DFA;67@F;8K ;E 5A@EFD3;@76 4K F:7 ")$ A8 F:7 #)$ 8 %$
F:7 47EF @G?47D A8%)$E4K #)$ GE;@9 F:7 E3?B>7D3F7 A8 AB7D3F;A@ ;E D7EFD;5F76 FA 8AD ;@EF3@57 A@>K 6GD;@9 4GE;@7EE
E3?B>7E E75A@6*:7%)$EI7D73DD3@976D3@6A?>KAH7D :AGDE F:7 ")$ A8 F:7 #)$ DA>7 3@6 5A@E7CG7@F>K F:7
3D75F3@9G>3D3D7335:@A67:36;FEG@;CG7;67@F;8;53F;A@3@6 >;87F;?7A8F:7I:A>7-)$F7@6EFA;@5D73E7FA63KE
38;J76A?@;6;D75F;A@3>D36;AD3@97A8?7F7DE*:7D7I3E@A & ,--$,-$,
;@F7D87D7@57 6GD;@9 F:7 E;?G>3F76 7JB7D;?7@FE -7 5D73F76 3 )7@EAD$A67E *$ )$ #)$ %)$
4G887DE3?B>;@9G887DFAEFAD7F:7E7@E7663F3;@#)$;@
AD67D FA 3HA;6 F:3F F:7 63F3 FD3@E?;EE;A@ 8DA? 3 83G>FK E7@EAD 5F;H7#A67

5A?BDA?;E7F:7675;E;A@?3=;@9BDA57EE*:7E3?B>;@9G887D 6>7#A67

?GEF478G>>478AD7F:7;@87D7@57BDA57EEEF3DFE;FEBDA57EE;@9
&AI7D)3H7#A67

*:7D78AD76G7FAF:7D76G@63@5K;@E7@E7663F3A4F3;@76I:7@
GE;@9 F:7 E3?B>;@9 G887D F:7 ?AD7 63F3 D757;H76 F:7 >7EE 536(70854),9<,,4(4+59/,78>89,38
>;=7>K;EF:3F%$IAG>6?3=73IDA@9675;E;A@*:747EF
D7EG>F8AD
?EI3EA4F3;@768AD8AGDAD?AD7%)$EB7D @ F:;E E7F A8 E;?G>3F76 7JB7D;?7@FE %$ I3E
#)$*:GE;@F:;EIAD=I736ABF768AGD%)$EB7D#)$ 5A?B3D76I;F:FIAAF:7DEA>GF;A@E;@F7D?EA8;F:7F75:@;53>
H;34;>;FK A8 B7D8AD?;@9 F:7 I:A>7 675;E;A@?3=;@9 BDA57EE A8
=6,703,4995;(2:(9,%! ,85:7*,548:369054 E?3DF4G;>6;@93BB>;53F;A@E4K3-)$3@6;;F:7;@F79D3F;A@
@ F:;E E;?G>3F76 7JB7D;?7@F I7 5A@E;67D76 )57@3D;A A8 6;887D7@F 3BB>;53F;A@E I;F:;@ F:7 -)$ *:7E7 EA>GF;A@E
;9GD7 4 8AD ;@H7EF;93F;@9 F:7 ;?B35F A8 %$ ;FE I;>>477H3>G3F76;@F7D?EA8))3@6
AH7D:736A@F:7-)$@A67E%$I3E67E;9@768ADF:7 & )'*+$,)(**+)#0$-#
(
@A67E FA EB7@6 3E ?G5: F;?7 3E BAEE;4>7 ;@ 3 BAI7D E3H7 JB7D;?7@FE %$ 12 12
?A67BDAH;676F:3FF:7E3?B>;@9D3F7D7CG;D764K3>>DG@@;@9 ))

3BB>;53F;A@E ;E ?7F (793D6;@9 &++ *34>7 E:AIE F:3F
?E ?E ?E
*$E#)$E3@6%)$EEB7@F
3@6
A8E;?G>3F;A@F;?7A@3&AI7D)3H7#A67D7EB75F;H7>KI:;>7 *34>7 E:AIE F:7 A4F3;@76 D7EG>FE A8 3@6 )) 8AD
F:7)$;E@7H7D;@BAI7DE3H7?A67*:;E6;E5D7B3@5KA55GDE %$3@68ADIAD=E;@123@612@F7D?EA8));F53@
6G7 FA F:7 835F F:3F F:7 )$ :3E 3 E7D;3> ;@F7D8357 I:;5: ;E 47 A4E7DH76 F:3F %$ B7D8AD?76 47FF7D F:3@ 12
3>I3KE 35F;H7 EA F:7 &+ D7?3;@E BD787D34>K ;@ 6>7 #A67 3@6 47FF7D F:3@ 12@ F7D?E A8 F:7 F:7D7EG>F8AD
;@EF736 A8 &AI7D )3H7 #A67 I:;5: 7JB3@6E ;FE BDA57EE;@9 %$ ?E;E?G5: E?3>>7DF:3@F:7A4F3;@76D7EG>FE
53B34;>;FK 4GF 7JB7@6E ?AD7 7@7D9K *:;E 47:3H;AD A8 F:7 8AD IAD= ;@ 12 ?E 3@6 ;@ 12 ?E *:7E7
)$IAG>6475D;F;53>A@7@7D9K5A@EG?BF;A@4GFF:7)$;E :3BB7@ 6G7 FA FIA D73EA@E ;DEF 6;887D7@F>K A8 F:7 IAD= ;@
BAI7D6 4K F:7 E7D;3> ;@F7D8357 EA F:7 6>7 #A67 ;E @AF 3 12 F:7 675;E;A@?3=;@9 BDA57EE A8 F:7 IAD= ;@ 12 3@6
BDA4>7?8ADF:7)$ %$;EB7D8AD?76044,9<571)A;@4AF:IAD=EF:7D7;E@A
(793D6;@9 FA (#+ H3>G7E 3 FAF3> A8 = (# I3E @776A8FD3@E?;FF;@9F:7D3I63F3FAF:7)$A@3/56)>/56
3H3;>34>7;@#;530@A67E8AD735:DA>7*$GE7E)$ 43E;E B7D8AD?;@9 F:7 675;E;A@ ;@ F:7 )$ 3@6 E7@6;@9 F:;E
GE7E #)$GE7E3@6%)$GE7E*:7H3>G7A8 675;E;A@ FA F:7 )$ E F:7 >A53> I:7D7 F:7 675;E;A@?3=;@9
(#+8AD735:DA>7;E6;D75F>KBDABADF;A@3>FA;FE5A?B>7J;FK BDA57EEF3=7EB>3573@6I:7D7675;E;A@E3D77J75GF763D75>AE7
F?3K47@AF76F:3F@A@7A8F:7*$)$#)$3@6%)$ FA 735: AF:7D F:7 675;E;A@E 53@ 47 3BB>;76 83EF7D ?;@;?;L;@9
260
F:7 67>3K F;?7 3@6 E3H;@9 7@7D9K A8 F:7 E?3DF 4G;>6;@9 12 7L7DGD3FF;SL;9477E?3DF7@7D9K;?B>7?7@F3F;A@8AD
)) *:7 E75A@6 D73EA@ ;E F:3F %$ 6;887D7@F>K 8DA? 7@7D9K 788;5;7@F 4G;>6;@9ET ;@ &DA5776;@9E A8 F:7 D6
F:7 IAD= ;@ 12 BDA?AF7E F:7 ;@F79D3F;A@ A8 6;887D7@F ,7:;5G>3D*75:@A>A9KA@87D7@57
BBQ
3BB>;53F;A@E3FF:7675;E;A@>7H7>EF:7;@F79D3F;A@5A?BA@7@F 12 ADF;@A G7DD;7D; S757@FD3>;L76 3@6 7?476676
A8%$3>>AIEF:7675;E;A@5:3;@;@947FI77@3BB>;53F;A@E ?3@397?7@F 8AD E?3DF 4G;>6;@9ET ;@ &DA5776;@9E A8 F:7
F:7675;E;A@E3D77J75GF767H7@83EF7D8GDF:7D?;@;?;L;@9 -AD=E:ABA@BB>;53F;A@EA8)A8FI3D797@FE
BB Q
3@6;@5D73E;@9)) 12 / )G@ 0:3A "GA S)?3DF 4G;>6;@9 5A@FDA> 43E76 A@
I;D7>7EE E7@EAD35FG3FAD @7FIAD=ET :;@7E7 AGD@3> A8
=6,703,49<09/(62(9-5735-7,(28,485745+,8 >75FDA@;5E
HA>
BB Q
@ F:;E 7JB7D;?7@F I7 GE76 )57@3D;A ;9GD7 3 -7 12 ADF;@A G7DD;7D; %U3D7 (GLL7>>; S 8>7J;4>7
3;?76 FA H3>;63F7 F:7 D7EG>FE A4F3;@76 8DA? E;?G>3F;A@E 4K 4G;>6;@9 ?3@397?7@F 8D3?7IAD= 43E76 A@ I;D7>7EE E7@EAD 3@6
5A?B3D;@9 F:7? I;F: F:7 D7EG>FE A4F3;@76 8DA? 3 D73> -)$ 35FG3FAD @7FIAD=ET AGD@3> A8 $7FIAD= 3@6 A?BGF7D
BB>;53F;A@E HA>
BB Q
B>3F8AD? %GD 9A3> I3E FA 5A@8;D? F:3F F:7 D7EG>FE A4F3;@76
8DA? E;?G>3F;A@E 35FG3>>K D7BDA6G57 F:7 D7EG>FE F:3F IAG>6 47 12 "G7F3>SG;>6;@93@;@F7>>;97@F:A?7EB3578ADE7DH;57DA4AF
D7FGD@76 ;8 3>> 7JB7D;?7@FE I7D7 B7D8AD?76 A@ 3 D73> -)$ 43E76 A@ ?G>F;B3FF7D@ ;@8AD?3F;A@ ?A67> 3@6 I;D7>7EE E7@EAD
@7FIAD=ET @F7>>;97@F A@FDA> 3@6 GFA?3F;A@ HA>

B>3F8AD? *:;E D73> 7JB7D;?7@F I3E B7D8AD?76 ;@ 3 5A@FDA>>76 BB
Q
7@H;DA@?7@F AGD >34AD3FADK 3F +( @ F:;E53E7 F:7 @A67E
1
2#3?;>;3D #3DF@7L""AB7LS&7DH3E;H7E?3DFEB357E3@6
I7D7 =7BF EF3F;A@3DK 3@6 6;EBAE76 A@ F:7 8>AAD *:7 A4F3;@76 7@H;DA@?7@FE E7DH;57AD;7@F76 ?;66>7I3D7 3D5:;F75FGD7 8AD
3H7D397D7EG>FE;@F:77JB7D;?7@FE I;F:3D73>E7@EAD@A678AD I;D7>7EE 36 :A5 3@6 E7@EAD @7FIAD=ET @F7D@3F;A@3> AGD@3> A8
P ?E 3@6 8AD - P 53@ 47 ;EFD;4GF76)7@EAD$7FIAD=E

5A@E;67D76E;?;>3DFAF:AE7;@F:7E;?G>3F767JB7D;?7@F8AD 12 =K;>6;L !3E;?A9>G S-;D7>7EE E7@EAD 3@6 35FAD
P ?E 3@6 8AD - P A@E;67D;@9 F:7 @7FIAD=E (7E73D5: 5:3>>7@97ET 6 A5 $7FIAD=E

5A@8;67@57 ;@F7DH3> A8 F:7 A4E7DH766;887D7@57E47FI77@ Q
F:7A4F3;@76D7EG>FE;@F:7D73>3@6E;?G>3F767JB7D;?7@FEI7D7 12# ";G 7F 3> S)?3DF5;E @F79D3F;@9 6;9;F3> 3@6 B:KE;53>
6G7 FA ;?BD75;E;A@E ;@ HDAD3 3@6 ;@ D73> 7JB7D;?7@FE 7@H;DA@?7@FET)#%(75AD6 HA>

BBQ
*:7D78AD7F:7E7D7EG>FEH3>;63F7F:77JB7D;?7@FEB7D8AD?76;@ 1 2 "77 &3D= S&AI7D "A36 ;EFD;4GF;A@ 8AD -;D7>7EE )7@EAD
F:7E;?G>3F767@H;DA@?7@F 3@6 5FG3FAD $7FIAD=E ;@ )?3DF D;6 G;>6;@9ET @F7D@3F;A@3>
AGD@3>A8;EFD;4GF76)7@EAD$7FIAD=EHA>
BB
,%$"+)%$
12";>;BBA@;7F3>S)?3DF5;FK @7H7@F6D;H7@3D5:;F75FGD78AD
%$ 7JB>A;FE F:7 ;@@7FIAD= BDA57EE;@9 53B34;>;FK A8 ?A@;FAD;@9 BG4>;5 EB357E I;F: :7F7DA97@7AGE E7@EADET ;@
-)$E3@6BDA?AF7EF:7;@F79D3F;A@A86;887D7@F3BB>;53F;A@E &DA5776;@9E A8 F:7 F: @F7D@3F;A@3> A@87D7@57 A@ )7@EAD
I;F:;@F:7-)$;@AD67DFA35:;7H77@7D9K788;5;7@5K8ADF:7 *75:@A>A9;7E3@6BB>;53F;A@E

BBQ
E?3DF 4G;>6;@9 3@6 F:7 @7FIAD= 5:;7H76 D7EG>FE A8 F:7 12, " D;5=EA@ 7F 3>S@7D9K 788;5;7@F 4G;>6;@9 7@H;DA@?7@F
B7D8AD?76 7JB7D;?7@FE E:AI F:3F F:7 GE397 A8 %$ ;@ 5A@FDA>EFD3F79;7EGE;@9D73>F;?7A55GB3@5K?73EGD7?7@FET;@
4G;>6;@9E 53@ ;@ 835F 5A@FD;4GF7 FA D76G57 93E 7?;EE;A@E F:GE &DA5776;@9E A8 F:7 EF # -AD=E:AB A@ ?476676 )7@E;@9
BDA?AF;@9 7@H;DA@?7@F3> EGEF3;@34;>;FK E 8GFGD7 IAD= I7 )KEF7?E8AD@7D9K88;5;7@5K;@G;>6;@9E+)

I;>> ;@H7EF;93F7 ; F:7 5A@57BF;A@ A8 5A>>34AD3F;A@ 12# !D3?7D 7D3>6K S@7D9K ?73EGD7?7@FE 8AD ?;53L
?75:3@;E?E 47FI77@ F:7 #)$E ;; F:7 5D73F;A@ A8 83G>F @A67T ;@ * !G,)35:97EBD5:S3:F>AE7)7@EAD@7FL7T
+@;H7DE;FF)FGFF93DF
BBQ
FA>7D3@57 ?75:3@;E?E 8AD %$ 3@6 ;;; @7I ?AD7
EAB:;EF;53F76 EA>GF;A@E FA EA>H7 5A@8>;5FE 3?A@9 -)$ 12(67&3L>47DA>3&7E5:SHDAD3LJF7@6;@93HDAD3I;F:
3BB>;53F;A@E 3@;777
5A?B>;3@FD36;A5:;B?A67>T;@&DA5776;@9EA8
F:7 @6#&#-$$/+)
BB Q

(($) 12*/G3@=;5;%L9G@7DS@7D9K5A@EFD3;@76F3E=?3BB;@9
3@6E5:76G>;@9;@I;D7>7EEE7@EAD@7FIAD=ET@F7D@3F;A@3>
12 " )5:AD & )A??7D ( -3FF7@:A87D S*AI3D6E 3 L7DA
A@87D7@57 A@ #A4;>7 6:A5 3@6 )7@EAD )KEF7?E
5A@8;9GD3F;A@ I;D7>7EE E7@EAD @7FIAD= 3D5:;F75FGD7 8AD E?3DF
A@87D7@57%:;A+)$AH

4G;>6;@9ET;@&DA5776;@9EA8F:7EFG;>6)KE+)

12% @3I3>; ( A@E753 ! 3?;7EA@ #%)) & "7H;E
12 ):G 7F 3> SG;>6;@9 3GFA?3F;A@ EKEF7?E GE;@9 I;D7>7EE
SA>>75F;A@ FD77 BDAFA5A>T ;@ &DA5776;@9E A8 F:7 F: #
E7@EAD @7FIAD=E (36;A 5:3D35F7D;EF;5E 3@6 7@7D9K 788;5;7@F
)7@)KEU

BBQ
5A??G@;53F;A@ BDAFA5A>ET >75FDA@;5 AGD@3> A8 )FDG5FGD3>
@9;@77D;@9 )B75;3> EEG7 Q )7@EAD $7FIAD= A@ G;>6;@9 1
2! !>G7E 7F 3>S@F79D3F;@9 5A@5GDD7@5K 5A@FDA> 3@6 7@7D9K
#A@;FAD;@98DA?*:7ADKFA(73>BB>;53F;A@
BBQ ?3@397?7@F ;@ 67H;57 6D;H7DET ;@ # )%&) %B7D3F;@9
)KEF7?E(7H;7I)%)&U

BBQ
1 2 KG@ ) &3D= S7H7>AB?7@F A8 3 E7>8363BF;@9 ;@F7>>;97@F
EKEF7? 8AD 4G;>6;@9 7@7D9K E3H;@9 3@6 5A@F7JF3I3D7 E?3DF 12! *E3; 7F 3> -;D7>7EE )7@EAD $7FIAD=E 3@6 )7@EAD GE;A@
E7DH;57ET *D3@E35F;A@EA@A@EG?7D >75FDA@;5E HA> *75:@A>A9K 8AD +4;CG;FAGE )?3DF ";H;@9 )B357 BB>;53F;A@E

BB
Q )+
B

12 :DG@9AA7F3>S%@363BF;H7:H3543E76A@36757@FD3>;L76 12 "GBG # )>A?3@ A@8>;5FE ;@ BA>;5K43E76 6;EFD;4GF76
3>9AD;F:? GE;@9 = FD3@E?;EE;A@ BDAFA5A> 8AD 3GFA@A?AGE EKEF7?E ?3@397?7@F *D3@E35F;A@E A@)A8FI3D7
I;D7>7EEE7@EAD@7FIAD=TF:@F7D@3F;A@3>A@87D7@57A@ @9;@77D;@9HA>@ABB
-;D7>7EEA??G@;53F;A@3@6)7@EAD$7FIAD=E
BBQ
261

A Comparative Study and Implementation of Real Time Home Automation System

Uploaded by

Document Information

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

A Comparative Study and Implementation of Real Time Home Automation System

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

2013 IEEE 10th International Conference on Ubiquitous Intelligence & Computing and 2013 IEEE 10th International Conference

on Autonomic & Trusted Computing

978-1-4799-2481-3/13 $31.00 © 2013 IEEE 254

5A@8>;5FE3EA>GF;A@8AD:3@6>;@95A@8>;5FE;@F:;EIAD=I7 # $ #

A8 7@7D9K 12 %$ I3E 4G;>F 4K GE;@9 *;@K%)

N 3D7 3EEA5;3F76 D7EB75F;H7>K *:7 AGFBGF

675;E;A@ A4F3;@76 4K F:7 ;@87D7@57 EG4EKEF7? *:7 ;@BGF 63F3

You might also like

A Comparative Study and Implementation of Real Time Home Automation System

Uploaded by

Document Information

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

A Comparative Study and Implementation of Real Time Home Automation System

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

2013 IEEE 10th International Conference on Ubiquitous Intelligence & Computing and 2013 IEEE 10th International Conference

on Autonomic & Trusted Computing

978-1-4799-2481-3/13 $31.00 © 2013 IEEE 254

5A@8>;5FE3EA>GF;A@8AD:3@6>;@95A@8>;5FE;@F:;EIAD=I7 #  $ # 

A8 7@7D9K 1 2 %$ I3E 4G;>F 4K GE;@9 *;@K%)

N 3D7 3EEA5;3F76 D7EB75F;H7>K *:7 AGFBGF

675;E;A@ A4F3;@76 4K F:7 ;@87D7@57 EG4EKEF7? *:7 ;@BGF 63F3

You might also like

5A@8>;5FE3EA>GF;A@8AD:3@6>;@95A@8>;5FE;@F:;EIAD=I7 # $ #

A8 7@7D9K 12 %$ I3E 4G;>F 4K GE;@9 *;@K%)

N 3D7 3EEA5;3F76 D7EB75F;H7>K *:7 AGFBGF

675;E;A@ A4F3;@76 4K F:7 ;@87D7@57 EG4EKEF7? *:7 ;@BGF 63F3