Professional Documents
Culture Documents
TABLE OF CONTENT
ITEMS PAGES
1.0 PREFACE 2
4.0 PROPOSAL 7
5.0 STRATERGIES 7
13.0 BENEFIT 29
14.0 CONCLUSION 30
1
UDM710: URBAN DEVELOPMENT PROJECT URBAN REGENERATION STUDY IN IPOH OLD TOWN - 25th JUN 2013
Development proposal report for urban regeneration of Ipoh Old Town is provided to
explain the analytically of building design location based on the selected concept plan. 1.4 DEVELOPMENT JUSTIFICATION
Besides that, it help to facilitate someone to understand the justification of the proposed
arrangement element in the study area refers to the site potential and output from the site i. Development on proposed site is do not conflict with surrounding area. These
analysis that been done before. ensure continuity of existing development and proposed development to be
proposed.
Proposal report will set out with clear and the details of the division layout plan that have ii. Proposed development is purpose to set up more job to local people much
been planned. The regeneration project will do according to the aim made .Apart from opportunity and surrounding area.
that, few ideas has been proposed and the best alternative is selected. The selected of iii. The development will enhance the economic thus will attract new investor to
alternative plan will be the main idea to regenerate Ipoh Old Town. invest within Ipoh Old Town
iv. Proposed development will allocate the area that suitable for the purpose of
The suggestions made to enable the local citizen enjoy the good facilities and also give preservation, conservation, new development to ensure its suit the proposal of
the opportunity to the citizen to take part in the economic activities. As result the Ipoh Old urban generation within Ipoh Old Town
Town will generate high income and enhance its economy and at the same time can be
attraction for tourist to invest in further development within Ipoh in the future.
1.2 METHODOLOGY
a. First Stage
1.2 AIM
This is the preliminary stage where the setting of goal has been made. In order to
The aim for the regeneration development in Ipoh Old Town is to create an economic achieve the goal few objectives is decided to ensure the proposal made in the proper
generate of Ipoh Old Town in addition to making Ipoh as one of the art and cultural city way and according to guideline .This will ensure next step will carry out properly.
area within sustainable development in order to fulfill the demand and better lifestyle.
2
UDM710: URBAN DEVELOPMENT PROJECT URBAN REGENERATION STUDY IN IPOH OLD TOWN - 25th JUN 2013
b. Second Stage
This is the stage where all the data is collected on the site. Data is divided into few major Term of Reference
sectors such as building and land use, urban design, transportation, infrastructure, Formed goal and objectives
Determined the study area
landscape and demographic within the area .Collecting data also can be define into two Determined the scope of study
main part that involve primary and secondary data. Most primary were collected through Formed the work schedule
First Stage
observation, interviews and from questionnaire given. While secondary data derive from
government and private agency that cover the Ipoh Old Town area. Second Stage
Data Collection
c. Third Stage
d. Fourth Stage
Few ideas will be generate and come out with the development plans. Evaluation then
made to find the best alternatives that suit the goal and the objectives. The selection idea
Third Stage
will be chosen as the main concept for the regeneration of the Ipoh Old Town. Data Analysis
Analysis primary and secondary
data
e. Fifth Stage Analysis the potential and
constraints
Determine the approach for the
This is the last stage where the general proposal of the regeneration of area will be issues
made. The proposal has been made based on analysis and the finding of study. Apart
from that, it become the solutions to the issues arise within the area. Fourth Stage
Development Proposal Report
Preparing Development Proposal
Report
Propose Urban Development Plan
a) Concept Plan
b) Master Plan
3
UDM710: URBAN DEVELOPMENT PROJECT URBAN REGENERATION STUDY IN IPOH OLD TOWN - 25th JUN 2013
Ipoh developed into one of Malaysia's main cities around the turn of the 19th century due to the
booming tin mining industry. During the British colonial era, Ipoh was Malaysia's second city for
administrative purposes. Architecturally, the city centre is characterized by colonial era Chinese
shop houses. There are also several impressive historical buildings from the British Colonial era
such as the Railway Station, the Town Hall and the Court House.
Nowadays, Ipoh Old Town getting less attractiveness because of the New Town development to
the east of Kinta River. Many people leave from Ipoh Old Town and move to the New Town.
This report will focus into urban regeneration in Ipoh Old Town that currently has existing
development. This chapter will cover more about the meaning of Urban Regeneration and also
about the background of the city, especially around the old town of Ipoh. Map 1: Key Plan (Not to Scale)
4
UDM710: URBAN DEVELOPMENT PROJECT URBAN REGENERATION STUDY IN IPOH OLD TOWN - 25th JUN 2013
Urban regeneration means physical, economic, social and environmental change in a The name Ipoh derives from a local tree, “pohon epu” or now more commonly known as
city/ town/ area. The initial definition of urban regeneration is based mainly on following “pokok ipoh”. The sap of this plant is poisonous and was used by Orang Asli (indigenous
themes: people) to coat the tips of the darts of their blowpipes. Ipoh was formerly known as
"Paloh" among local Chinese, referring to the gigantic mining pump used for early tin ore
a. The relationship between the physical condition evident in urban areas and the extraction. It was also called "the Town built on Tin" and "City of Millionaires", referring to
nature of the social and political response; the vast fortunes made during the boom of the tin mining industries. Other nicknames
b. The need to attend to matters of housing and health in urban areas; include "The Bougainvillea City" and "Shan Cheng" which means "The Hill City" in the
c. The desirability of linking social improvement with economic progress; Cantonese dialect.
d. The containment of urban growth;
e. The changing role and nature of urban policy. Ipoh city came into existence in the 1820s as a village on the banks of the Kinta River. It
was less prominent at that time as compared to the early mining town of Gopeng, 20 km
south of Ipoh. In 1946 -1954, Kinta Town Board was established under the coordination
These themes define urban regeneration as: “Comprehensive and integrated vision and of Major J.S. Drake, followed by G.S. Walker who became the chairman in the years
action which leads to the resolution of urban problems and which seeks to bring about a 1954 – 1956. Ipoh Menglembu Town Council was set up in 1957, and Encik Abdullah Bin
lasting improvement in the economic, physical, social and environmental condition of an Uni headed the council until 1962. On 31 May 1962, Ipoh was upgraded into a
area that has been subject to change.” (Roberts, P. and Sykes, H., 2000). municipality and was known as Ipoh Municipal Council, chaired by E.G. Walker. which
led to systematic planning of Ipoh, which was still seen today.
This definition has been widely used by scholars and politicians among nations, yet, only
very few places could put the idea into practice. Therefore, Turok (2005) has identified Fire in 1916, has resulted in Ipoh is divided into two new and old Ipoh. However, the
three characteristics of contemporary urban regeneration, including the intention to process of urbanization and development has combined both these areas and make it
change the nature of the place by involving the whole community and other stakeholders the capital of Perak. Ipoh old town is full with hundred years old buildings. Many of them
with the stake in its future, the multiple objectives and activities that focus on the area‟s are remained functional until today. Ipoh old town is mainly referred to the town area in
particular problems and potential which can cut across the responsibilities of Sentral between S.P. Seenivasagam Road and Leong Boon Swee Road, on the west bank of
government, and the partnership working among different stakeholders. Kinta River. Ipoh starts thriving in early 1900, when mining companies were set up at the
old town, covering an area around 1000 m x 250 m. Instead of monumental buildings
From the above definition, urban regeneration is a new generation of urban renewal that such as the town hall, railway station, the war memorial, St. Micheal Institution, and Birch
seeking a balance between „people‟, „businesses and „place‟. For people, regeneration Memorial which all of them located at the northern part of the old town, the rest of the
provides opportunities for people to participate in and gain benefits by enhancing their town is just old two storeys and three storeys shop lots. Most of the shops which are now
skills, capacities and aspirations. Meanwhile, according to Pavan Mehta in his journal located in the old town are operated by new owners.
“Titled the Impact of Urban Regeneration on Local Housing Markets – a case study of
Liverpool”, urban regeneration is a process to improve economical, physical, social and
environmental condition of an area.
5
UDM710: URBAN DEVELOPMENT PROJECT URBAN REGENERATION STUDY IN IPOH OLD TOWN - 25th JUN 2013
There are many problems that can be seen around the old town of Ipoh. This problem if not The main problems found in Ipoh Old Town are a traffic flow and the accessibility of
addressed and will give a bad impression of the old town Ipoh especially from the view of transportation mode especially linking in some tourism spots in the District of Ipoh Old
tourists and outsiders. If it is left to persist, tourist attraction and people from outside to Ipoh in Town. Traffic congestion is caused by poor traffic system of the internal road. The
the future will be affected. roads are been linked and blocked by the other roads that were made the system
being congested. The direction of the main road that connected to the road collector in
3.1 PHYSICAL ASPECT the town centre should need to be more systematic. Other than traffic congestion, the
other problem is lack of maintenance of the public facilities in the town centre. This
a. Landuse Distributor problem will make the traffic flows being congested because the vehicles will park
anywhere, not in parking area
More than 30% of the land is not develop with any development. Conflict on new
development and old development where new development gave impact.
3.2 ECONOMIC ASPECT
c. Public Facilities
a. The Impact of New Commercial Development
Public facilities and infrastructure such as pedestrian walkway, telecommunication,
electricity and others should be upgrade to ease the visitor in the town centre When the Ipoh new town area built such as, new shop offices and shopping complex
around there, we can see that old shop offices less attraction because people will go
d. Infrastructure to new commercial area that have more suitable and convenient.
The drainage systems in Ipoh Old Town have some lacking in it structure and the At the same time, commercial activities at existing old shop offices start vacant and
presentation of the structure as the tourism view. business activities moving to new commercial area. Business activities start moving to
the best spots and better place.
e. Urban Design
b. No Business Attraction for Investor
Ipoh Old Town does not have a clear image and identity of the city due to lack of
distinctive elements and characters that symbolizes the city. There is no continuity of Ipoh Old Town area especially at town center has no attraction to investor to come for
pedestrian walkways make it difficult for people to access to other public spaces. business activities. Existing business activities cannot attract external and internal
visitor.
f. Landscape
Study area should have core business related to the Ipoh Old Town like tourist
Urban landscape design at Ipoh Old Town town center has no local distinctiveness product, fish product and any local products to attract many people come. When the
character that can enhance the image of Ipoh Old Town as a tourism center study area can create many products will produce variety business opportunities to
people.
6
UDM710: URBAN DEVELOPMENT PROJECT URBAN REGENERATION STUDY IN IPOH OLD TOWN - 25th JUN 2013
3.3 SOCIAL ASPECT From here development proposal will be more focus on the main issues as
comprehensive as possible.
The social problems in town centre are criminal problems. The criminal cases such as
snatch, drugs and others can make the resident felt unsecured to go to anywhere in the
town centre. The town centre should be secure by the policeman to guard and supervise 4.0 PROPOSAL
the area so that the visitors will feel safe. The other issues are so many illegal foreigners
are doing business in the town centre. Some of them are involved in crimes and did not The purpose of this project is to regenerate the Ipoh Old Town and give a new perspective in
respect the visitor and local by showing bad habits such as drunk in public area. future planning. This project consists to expose the new principles, techniques and method in
developing new concept for a small town. This project also will provide the opportunity to apply
3.4 ENVIRONMENT theoretical knowledge into actual practice and to enhance creativity, innovative and ideas in the
analysis and preparation of a proposal plan.
Environmental sector study will include the study of the level of biodiversity; identify
sensitive environment area, threats and conservation measures in the study. Issues and 4.1 GOAL
problems for the environmental sector will be emphasized are:
“Enhancing Ipoh Old Town via distinctive and signature of urban character with
a. Polluted river or waterway full with solid waste and chemicals from development universally multi-modal accessibility for community, element of art, visitors, and service
activities such as industrial and commercial area especially along Sungai Galing providers consistently towards livable quality of life and sustainable city”.
affect on site area.
4.2 OBJECTIVES
b. Air pollution and noise levels in certain areas arising from the increasing traffic,
commercial area, the small and medium industry, and other development a. To promote functional elements of art that can enhance the physical Image of
activities that might affect human comfortable in future. Ipoh Old Town as a vibrant city
b. To integrate elements of art in urban landscape as it could provide a transparent
c. Irregular rubbish causing bad smell for certain area and affect to other one and image of a city‟s soul (spirit of the place) and also improve the quality living
another area. environment for the community
c. To preserve the cultural and heritage value of Ipoh Old Town through restoration
3.5 IMPORTANT ISSUES of old shop houses and heritage site by the element of art
7
UDM710: URBAN DEVELOPMENT PROJECT URBAN REGENERATION STUDY IN IPOH OLD TOWN - 25th JUN 2013
a. Landuse a. Create a new landmark that highlights the image and identity Ipoh Old Town
so that it will become an attraction for people to come to Ipoh Old Town.
Landuse development should be balanced with nature and emphasizes sustainable
characteristics to avoid environmental damage as happened now. Landuse class b. Refurbish the buildings and give a new image to it with the use of a uniformity
order should also be considered according to the needs and capabilities to boost the of color and lighting of the buildings in order to accentuate the local image of
economy in line with the idea to regenerate Ipoh Old Town. the city
Material that will be used in construction is high quality and according to the redevelopment, allowing a rapid response to the market. Placemaking –
8
UDM710: URBAN DEVELOPMENT PROJECT URBAN REGENERATION STUDY IN IPOH OLD TOWN - 25th JUN 2013
e. Ensure dynamic urban activities: Focused–on key centres in Ipoh Old Town perimeter drain. Conserve natural resources by carrying out a strategic green
Town inner 5km that offer redevelopment potential purchasing policy.
i. Natural resources for instance beach and sea water need to be monitored S1. Implement security To implement the strategy, which contributed to the
consistently especially at the sources of pollutant to make sure the pollution guidelines for enhancing high crime rate will be enhanced security system
will be prevented. the security level of City. according to city guidelines safe. The steps that we
can take are:
ii. Observe and monitor the degree of cleanness frequently of the drainage
system and monsoon drain in urban area to ensure zero impact to the
Separation of pedestrian and motor route. This step
environmental quality and visual quality. Underground drainage system will be
can be carried out by:
focus at the public area.
- Preparation of specific pedestrian
- Preparation Bollard
iii. Improving the drainage networking and system through environmental
- Preparation of guardrail
approaches. Determine the critical areas to improve the drainage system and
- Provision of landscaping
apply the high technology in the market to reduce the conflict of interest
- Preparation of special motorcycle route.
between the drainage system, road and pedestrian walkway.
iv. Raising the environment partnerships for growing forward to get better public Installation of closed circuit television cameras
health and environment. (CCTV) at the business and public places.
Clean and tidy bush areas covered.
v. Encourage the Ipoh Old Town stakeholders to spend budget for environment Provision of security mirror.
to up the Eco-tourism in Ipoh Old Town. Assist the local authorities and other Provision of warning signs of crime.
government‟s agency in carrying out and quantifying green initiatives by
providing support through, research, education, examples, etc. S3. Provide diversifying If social activities can be diversify, interaction
social activities to create between visitors and the people of the area can be
vi. Protecting the natural resources for environment and economy activities. interaction between improved. Among the measures to diversify the
people and outsiders. social activities are:
vii. Educate businessmen, food hawkers and other business related to avoid the
bad waste management and cannot simply discharge the wastes into the
Exhibition of traditional craft.
9
UDM710: URBAN DEVELOPMENT PROJECT URBAN REGENERATION STUDY IN IPOH OLD TOWN - 25th JUN 2013
Increase international sports activities such as water redevelopment is urban renewal or revitalization. Although, redevelopment always
sports and beach soccer (sport-tourism). involves urban revitalization, they do not always involve the demolition of existing
Providing military exhibition in Ipoh Old Town buildings. Instead, they rehabilitate all of the existing buildings or other neighborhood
b. Renewal
S5. Provide a conducive Activate rukun tetangga in local and regional areas Urban renewal is a program of land redevelopment in areas of moderate to high density
environment and of mutual cooperation activities; cooperate in holding urban land use. The urban renewal of centre is about building on the strengths of each
comprehensive and feasts and security patrols. place, transforming under-used or dilapidated areas, boosting local economies and
ensure the welfare of Unite the Malaysians who have a variety of people providing a mix of uses and activities which meet the needs of the community. According
resident through daily activities. to the book of “An Introduction to Urban Renewal” by Micheal S. Gibson and Micheal J.
Establish a friendly understanding and harmony, Lang staff, urban renewal often meant the displacement of an existing low-income
thus helping to attract tourists to come. population, creating space for more profitable office, commercial and luxury residential
Improving quality of life and well-being of a balanced development or the provision of transport facilities.
community through cultural and socio-economic
development There are five main phases in the development of national urban renewal policy. These
phases are slum clearance and redevelopment, the shift of emphasis to housing and
Table 1: Social Strategy
environmental improvement, the emergence of gradual renewal, urban deprivation and
concerns in economic renewal.
5.2 APPROACHES
Urban renewal may involve relocation of businesses, the demolition of structures, the
a. Redevelopment relocation of people, and the use of eminent domain as a legal instrument to take private
Redevelopment can be defined as any new construction on a site that has pre-existing property for city-initiated development projects. This process is also carried out in rural
uses. Redevelopment also refers to state and federal statutes which give cities and areas, referred to as village renewal, though may not be exactly the same in practice. In
counties the authority to establish redevelopment agencies and give the agencies the some cases, renewal may result in urban sprawl and less congestion when areas of
authority to solve problems of urban decay. Other terms that sometimes used to describe cities receive freeways and expressways.
10
UDM710: URBAN DEVELOPMENT PROJECT URBAN REGENERATION STUDY IN IPOH OLD TOWN - 25th JUN 2013
There are four principles of conservation that should be adopted in order to apply the
conservation in land use planning. The principles are to retain significant landscape,
ecological and geological attributes and heritage features as conservation zones, restrict
uses with conservation zones to those which sustain particular landscapes, ecological
and geological attributes and heritage features, control adjoining use to minimize adverse
impacts on conservation zones and optimize their conservation value also to create,
where possible, new conservation zones in compensation for areas of conservation value
which are lost to development.
d. Rehabilitation
Urban rehabilitation today goes beyond simply carrying out restoration work and Figure 2: Flow chart of development idea for Mural City Metaphor concept
encompasses ways of reviving and modernizing areas to the best advantage. There are
elements considered in rehabilitation which is heritage elements and cultural heritage
According to flow chart above, the concept of Mural City was purpose at Ipoh Old Town centre
elements. The examples of heritage elements are historical, paleontological,
because of Ipoh Old Town Centre is dominated by commercial area. Then, the visual sequential
architectural, artistic, ethnographic, scientific, social, industrial and technical. While in
and quality of the town are poor. On the other hand, there has a lot of void space for
cultural heritage element can be classified with monuments, groups of monuments or
developments. The Combination cultural and traditional value is main factor that contributing to
places, rustic, urban, other constructions, gardens and squares or paths.
be a mural city. After that, the location of Ipoh Old Town itself at Sungai Kinta was being spirit of
the place because it is one of the significant elements which are natural element.
d. Regeneration
Urban regeneration is at the core of city planning. Urban regeneration can be defined as
This concept metaphor will use variety of colors and to be use to form a mural that reflect to all
the integrated local redevelopment of deprived areas such as in neighborhood, city or
criteria. Various criteria need to be considering in an Ipoh Old Town and it can be „wide wall‟ that
metropolitan area. It covers many aspects of city life which is physical, social and
need to be painted to enhance the image. The concept based on color of Natural Living
environmental. Regeneration can be useful in solving problems in aspects of economy
elements to form an Urban Art which are Blue, Red, Yellow, Purple and Green.
and social. For example, a town that has less economy activity that cause increase in
financial problems can boost some other effective economic activity or urban activity. As
the economic status of the place is increasing, the social status will be also upgraded.
11
UDM710: URBAN DEVELOPMENT PROJECT URBAN REGENERATION STUDY IN IPOH OLD TOWN - 25th JUN 2013
A
B E
The metaphor of „Blue Water‟ is use to enhancing Kinta River as spirit of the place, then the
„Purple Air‟ is use to appreciative of air quality through floating and mobile elements. Besides,
the „Red Fire‟ is use to rejuvenating landmark, nodes and district by community artwork. The
Green Earth is metaphor of green technology and sustainable approach and lastly the Golden
C D
Memory is restoration of historical value.
Elements of the art are being implemented in order to improve the living quality and lifestyle for
the Urban Community. It bring sense of artistic vitality, fantasy and surprise into daily life and
commemorate a specific figure or significant event. Besides, it enlivens the quality of public
realm and encourages collaboration from the community.
12
UDM710: URBAN DEVELOPMENT PROJECT URBAN REGENERATION STUDY IN IPOH OLD TOWN - 25th JUN 2013
Figure 5: Flow chart of development idea for Metaphor Verdant City concept
According to flow chart above, the concept of Verdant City was purpose at Ipoh Old Town centre
because of Ipoh Old Town Centre is dominated by commercial area and to be as focus point. On
the other hand, there has Kinta River as Spirit of that place because Kinta River is the precursor
revolution of Ipoh history. The air quality, water and noise at Ipoh Old Town are worst and
should be to restore it. Verdant is use to generate the City to be more fresh and harmonies. The
balance ecosystem is keys of verdant city concept.
Verdant city can minimize negative impacts of the Ipoh Old Town Centre environment and
minimizing the use of resources by green technology. It also raises public awareness of Ipoh Old
Town unique heritage and natural resources while promoting and linking them for economic
development and tourism. Besides, it also endorses the community relationship with nature.
13
UDM710: URBAN DEVELOPMENT PROJECT URBAN REGENERATION STUDY IN IPOH OLD TOWN - 25th JUN 2013
NUP 5 : Optimal and balanced land use planning. Ipoh Old Town will be “polish” and regenerate as a night life city and eternity “breath” from a day
NUP 6 : urban renewal (regeneration). until night in order to formulate the more enjoyable urban environment to local community, user
NUP 9 : Open space and recreational areas. and tourist whilst to boost the Ipoh current economic situation. The night activities will be
NUP 15: Integrated, efficient and user-friendly public Transportation system. proposed to recover the living quality and lifestyle for the urban community. It will bring the
NUP 17: Improve accessibility and mobility. sense of excitement, happiness, delight and full of energy into daily life.
NUP 19: sustainable solid waste and toxic management systems.
NUP 21: Sufficient housing.
NUP 22: User friendly public amenities.
NUP 26: A sustainable and environmental friendly development.
NUP 30: innovative technology
Figure 6: Flow chart of development idea for Metaphor Verdant City concept
According to flow chart above, the concept of Sparkling Maneuver was purpose at Ipoh Old
Town centre because of Ipoh Old Town Centre is dominated by commercial area and to be as
focus point. The business activity in Ipoh Old Town is poor and most of the people were moved
to the new town. Sparkling Maneuver concept prepared to reanimate Ipoh Old Town into a lively,
energetic and functional through robust space with astonishing activities support for local
community, user and tourist.
Sparkling Maneuver concept use to enliven the night of Ipoh Old Town centre as a vibrant,
8.0 rejuvenate and energetic city that accompanied with local community and tourist and also create
robust activities based on the design that will connect every space of the proposed area. It can
boost up the current economy situation and job opportunities of Ipoh Old Town centre
community. Finally it able promotes various cultures and tradition of Ipoh itself through the night
CONCEPT life activities.
14
UDM710: URBAN DEVELOPMENT PROJECT URBAN REGENERATION STUDY IN IPOH OLD TOWN - 25th JUN 2013
15
UDM710: URBAN DEVELOPMENT PROJECT URBAN REGENERATION STUDY IN IPOH OLD TOWN - 25th JUN 2013
16
UDM710: URBAN DEVELOPMENT PROJECT URBAN REGENERATION STUDY IN IPOH OLD TOWN - 25th JUN 2013
17
UDM710: URBAN DEVELOPMENT PROJECT URBAN REGENERATION STUDY IN IPOH OLD TOWN - 25th JUN 2013
The study area is located in Mukim Hulu Kinta within the city centre of Ipoh, specifically at Ipoh
Old Town spans over 305.52 acres or 123.64 hectare, hence constituted the population density
of 15 persons per acre. The population source of the study area contributed by people living in
KTM Quarters, major source of population at Kinta Height Flat, and residents live in
shophouses.
According to the layout plan on Map 7, residential has increase by plotting another three
medium density residential areas on the previously KTM land reserved where the major part of
the land is meant to be Ipoh Sentral – a Centralized transportation hub for Ipoh. The Ipoh
Sentral on the other hand consist of bus terminal, KTM terminal, and taxi station facilitated by
commercial lots in the building such as bank, food kiosk, money changer, spa, boutique and the Map 9: Ipoh Central Development
most prominent sub lot is a hotel – proposed as a world class hotel where the orientation of the
building is erected to the sparkling lights of the old town at night. Ipoh Sentral is supported by a
centralized multi-level parking lots (which is previously was Ipoh Police Station) link the major
access to the town and Ipoh Sentral main building, through covered pedestrian walkway
linkages (refer to Map 9).
18
UDM710: URBAN DEVELOPMENT PROJECT URBAN REGENERATION STUDY IN IPOH OLD TOWN - 25th JUN 2013
Photo 5: Ipoh Central and Centre of Arts and Culture (CAC) previously known as Ipoh Railway Station
The previously called Ipoh Railway Station will become a Centre of Arts and Culture as the
theme and metaphor concept of the development is based on Mural and Arts. This building is
Photo 6: Ipoh Central Train Terminal
links to the adjacent old town commercial area by the existing upgrading landscape area in front
of (refer to Map 10).
19
UDM710: URBAN DEVELOPMENT PROJECT URBAN REGENERATION STUDY IN IPOH OLD TOWN - 25th JUN 2013
The mosque besides will becomes a node of muslim and people in the town so as to bring back
the muslim concentrated centre in the town. Pusat Penjaja Dato‟ Sagor however will be
upgraded as Kompleks Dato‟ Sagor (refer to Photo 8) equipped with a new trend building style
at the same time remaining the sellers. This commercial building will remained as Malay
ownership centre of food court and boutiques outlets in the old town. The Ibu Pejabat Polis
Trafik Ipoh area will be developed and re-plotted (where some parts of the land will be green) to
optimise the use of land within the area so as to inject new institutional government agencies
with more positive energy. It consists of the new medium density multi-level of PKNP building,
Balai Polis Trafik Ipoh and Ibu Pejabat Polis Ipoh. This area may looks much attractive with
concentrated government buildings development supported by good view of the linear green
facilitated by commercial outlets owned by Dewan Perniagaan Melayu (previously was situated
at old bus station (refer to Photo 8 and Map 11).
This open space is a part of the continuous green linear park of the town span over 15023sq.m
within the Ipoh old town (some parts of the previously was Ibu Pejabat Polis Ipoh land). This
green development is adjacent to the State mosque along Jalan Sultan Iskandar Shah. This
road will be a shared-street where pedestrian and vehicular traffic can run through contingent to Photo 8: Kompleks Dato’ Sagor Photo 9: Dewan Perniagaan Melayu and Commercial Lots
very minimum speed limit. This road will become a concentration development of „Mural on the
surface‟ concept (refer to Photo 7) which later attract street artists and art lovers to participate in
throughout the year arts programmed
20
UDM710: URBAN DEVELOPMENT PROJECT URBAN REGENERATION STUDY IN IPOH OLD TOWN - 25th JUN 2013
This area is link to the nearby Little India Street and the unique-old shop houses where it ends to
Taman Rekreasi Persisiran Sungai. This open space will become a major centre of leisure and
healthy activities so as to create a positive people lifestyle within the centre of Ipoh Old Town.
This green area hopefully benefits people live at the new redevelopment of Flat Bijih Timah. The
new development is remained residential with low density four storey‟s building limit. Although
high rise residential is desirable in the future however since the area is so close to the old
preserved shop houses adjacent to the land therefore low rise is much appropriate (refer to
Photo 10).
21
UDM710: URBAN DEVELOPMENT PROJECT URBAN REGENERATION STUDY IN IPOH OLD TOWN - 25th JUN 2013
The existing Rumah Pangsa Kinta Height will be re-painted with beautiful artistic Mural, since
the building is so high as compared to the neighboring areas; it has potential to emphasis on the
concept of Mural and Arts in Ipoh town. The Kinta Height community park will be upgraded a par
with the national standard of neighborhood park so as to increase the quality of livelihood and
children safety. The riverfront development corridor in which along the Kinta River within the
study area will be a continuous riverfront development where it connects to the adjacent pocket
parks acquired and existed such as Taman Rekreasi Persisiran Sungai changes the physical
environment to much attractive and useful space of social activities (refer to Map 13).
It later bring people from other parts of Ipoh to appreciate the sentimental value of arts
decorated within the riverfront and natural elements of purified river water quality and various
types of trees and flowers. The riverfront is not remain as node in day time but also at night,
where people all around the state come can enjoy the beautiful scenery of sparkling lights
riverfront development of Ipoh. The land uses adjacent to the riverfront are predicted to increase
in value as it becoming people concentration as it rejuvenate the old town in terms of
commercial activities led to social and economic wellbeing. The overall development of the study
area is shown in Overall Master plan.
22
UDM710: URBAN DEVELOPMENT PROJECT URBAN REGENERATION STUDY IN IPOH OLD TOWN - 25th JUN 2013
11.0 PROJECT CALCULATION COST AND DEVELOPMENT VALUE Sentral Hotel. The area is part of a mixed development project and will be joint ventured with
KTMB as the land owners and other feasible developers.
The cost of development is shown in the attached appendices of the report. The calculation for
development value and development costs is based primarily using the residual method. Other parts of Ipoh and Ipoh Old Town specifically will be refurbished and reconstructed where it
Residual method is a calculation that shows a developments value and development cost in is necessary. For example is the Police District Headquarters that will be moved to a nearby
details and shows what percentages of profit can the developer get from the project. area and built with more modern design. Other buildings such as Dewan Perniagaan Melayu
that will be relocated and replaced with buildings are in line with the proposed theme of Mural
From the calculation, it can be seen that development value from residential properties alone City.
brings about RM961, 600,000. The development value consists of newly proposed projects of
high rise apartments. The apartments are luxury apartments, medium cost apartments and In overall, the project of refurbishment and redevelopment of Ipoh Oldtown according to the
medium lower cost apartments. express proposal of Mural City will take approximately RM1.35billion to be constructed and will
generate value of development at approximately RM1.8billion. The profit can be shared
The development cost is highlighted in detail as it will portray the real need and items today‟s according to the shared ventures and definitely the newly developed and refurbished area can
property development condition. Item such as cost of approval layout, authority contribution, site contribute to the well being of residents, workers, and investors coming into the city.
preliminaries, site preparation, infrastructure, construction cost, landscaping, professional fees
and other are included.
The total development cost of the residential units will then be measured against the
development value and the remaining will become the developer‟s profit. For the purpose of this
proposal, such profit may be shared through privatization of public projects by the local and state
government.
As for the other proposed urban renewal projects, these are ready made projects and do not
require extensive and detailed development cost calculations. Most of them were calculated
from the total construction and refurbishment cost only. From the appendices, it can be seen
that properties such as Police District Headquarters, Perbadanan Kemajuan Negeri Perak and
others were calculated its value through construction cost.
It can also be seen that the major contributor for the development value is Ipoh Sentral. Ipoh
Sentral gross value is around RM454, 358,289 roughly. This high cost and high value project is
meant to revitalized the surrounding area of Ipoh and bring development into the underutilized
KTMB land reserves. As the land reserves have the most potential aspect, most of new
developments were Centralized there such as the residential apartments, Ipoh Sentral, and Ipoh
23
UDM710: URBAN DEVELOPMENT PROJECT URBAN REGENERATION STUDY IN IPOH OLD TOWN - 25th JUN 2013
24
UDM710: URBAN DEVELOPMENT PROJECT URBAN REGENERATION STUDY IN IPOH OLD TOWN - 25th JUN 2013
25
UDM710: URBAN DEVELOPMENT PROJECT URBAN REGENERATION STUDY IN IPOH OLD TOWN - 25th JUN 2013
26
UDM710: URBAN DEVELOPMENT PROJECT URBAN REGENERATION STUDY IN IPOH OLD TOWN - 25th JUN 2013
i. Economic Planning Unit (EPU) / Ministry of Finance (MOF), Prime Minister‟s Department 12.4 PRIVATE SECTOR
(PMD)
ii. Ministry of Transport, Keretapi Tanah Melayu Berhad (KTMB) Private sectors are responsible for the construction and planning costs with some
iii. Ministry of Works, Public Works Department subsidy by the government who wants to simulate the project, private sectors will then
iv. Ministry of Urban Wellbeing, Housing & Local Government gain part of the redeveloped land or building once they completed the project. Local
v. National Landscape Department government as the public sector will only act as a supervisor to protect the interest of all
vi. Ministry of Communications & Multimedia Malaysia, Department of National Heritage parties that involved in the redevelopment project.
While, at the state level, the efforts for the development of the old town of Ipoh will involve Public participation also plays an important role in urban redevelopment. It emphases on
several agencies, such as: citizen‟s continuing interests in the planning of a place. Some attractive locations may
draw more interest from a wide variety of people, and these places are usually lively for
i. Pejabat Setiausaha Kerajaan Negeri Perak, Local Government Division. both residents and visitors. Interests in these places take many forms including
ii. Department of Environment (DOE, Negeri Perak) shopping, sightseeing, visiting art galleries and museums, and other kinds of
iii. Federal Department of Town & Country Planning Peninsular Malaysia (JPBD Negeri entertainment. One of the greatest interests both the residents and the visitors are
Perak) concentrated on the history of the place.
iv. Department of Irrigation and Drainage (JPS Negeri Perak)
27
UDM710: URBAN DEVELOPMENT PROJECT URBAN REGENERATION STUDY IN IPOH OLD TOWN - 25th JUN 2013
Residents can participate in the development process through Local Agenda 21 platform where c. Medium Residential Area
it provides an opportunity for residents to speak out about their needs and interest for
Stage Agencies involved
development activities. This will ensure that development is done to meet the needs of local
Federal Level • Ministry of Urban Wellbeing, Housing & Local Government
residents. • National Housing Department
State Level • Federal Department of Town & Country Planning Peninsular Malaysia (JPBD Negeri Perak)
• Pejabat Setiausaha Kerajaan Negeri Perak, Local Government Division
12.6 SITE PROGRAMMING
• Public Works Department (JKR Negeri Perak)
Private Sector • SP Setia Sdn Bhd District Level • Ipoh City Council (Local Authority)
• Hilton Hotel & Resort
Private Sector • Persatuan Pelukis Perak
• Persatuan Pelancongan Negeri Perak
28
UDM710: URBAN DEVELOPMENT PROJECT URBAN REGENERATION STUDY IN IPOH OLD TOWN - 25th JUN 2013
District Level • Ipoh City Council (Local Authority) as apprentice artists to help with the planning and painting of murals.
A community mural can only achieve its intended goals through an emphasis on the art of mural
g. Green Park Development
creation. Everything from the design of the images to be placed on the wall to the activity of
Stage Agencies involved painting the mural is done with heavy community involvement, consultation, and participation. By
Federal Level • Economic Planning Unit (EPU) / Ministry of Finance (MOF), Prime Minister‟s Department engaging area residents in the process of mural development, it is believed that they will be able
(PMD) to gain social and artistic skills that can transcend the act of mural painting (Rice 1999). In a
• National Landscape Department
• Ministry of Urban Wellbeing, Housing & Local Government collaborative community effort, participants work with amateur and/or professional artists to
develop themes, acquire supplies, negotiate wall space, and paint a mural.
State Level • Federal Department of Town & Country Planning Peninsular Malaysia (JPBD Negeri Perak)
• National Landscape Department
• Department of Environment (DOE), Negeri Perak
District Level • Ipoh City Council (Local Authority) 13.3 ENHANCE TOWN ENVIRONMENT
Private Sector • Real Estate & Housing Developers' Association (REHDA) Negeri Perak
• Syarikat Perumahan Negara Berhad (SPNB)
• Sunway City (Ipoh) Sdn Bhd
• Pinji Botanics Sdn Bhd
29
UDM710: URBAN DEVELOPMENT PROJECT URBAN REGENERATION STUDY IN IPOH OLD TOWN - 25th JUN 2013
14.0 CONCLUSION
Urban Regeneration in Ipoh Old Town having a set of aims concept, objective concept,
strategies and concept proposal gives Ipoh Old Town a set of tools to work with when preparing
development at the strategic as well as the more detailed levels of planning.
The findings of survey report should always act as the basis for identifying issues and making
planning development concept for the future. While issues may be relatively easy to identify, at
the same time the choice of policies and strategies could be many and urban regeneration
needs to be implement.
Enhancing the Ipoh Old Town by Mural City metaphor concept will diversify the business
activities and social rehabilitation merging the existing physical condition of Ipoh Old Town with
future development for sustainable urban environment.
Transforming a successful Ipoh Old Town that links the public and private sectors in a strong
relationship which promoting heritage preservation, enhances tourism and encourage economic
development consistent with green initiatives ideal programs where it will assist to achieve
significant quality of life benefits for residents , seasonal residents and visitors.
30
UDM710: URBAN DEVELOPMENT PROJECT URBAN REGENERATION STUDY IN IPOH OLD TOWN - 25th JUN 2013
31