Premier Publishers

Share Your Scientific Discovery

www.premierpublishers.org

SECTION I
Kindly include your name, email and affiliations below.
Ms. Sakshi Gupta, Email id: dcesakshigupta@gmail.com
Department of Civil Engineering, Amity School of Engineering & Technology, Amity University Haryana

Manuscript ref no.

090620176728

Manuscript Title
Toxicity Analysis and Legislation for South African Waste Foundry Sand

Comment Section:
General comment
There is nothing new in this research. It has been found more than 40% plagiarized.

Introduction
1. Some of the sentences have directly been copied from other research papers/ articles.
2. There is not much discussed in the Introduction part and therefore needs revision.

Methodology
1. Classification of Foundry Sands, Waste Disposal, Waste management: all these sub topics have
been directly copied from one or other sources. This must be avoided and hence revised.

Results
There is almost similar that has been written in results and discussion and Conclusion.

 Copyright © 2014. Premier Publishers.

 Discussion
The conclusion must be drawn from the Results obtained and not the same as results and discussions.

Bibliography/References
No recent research has been referred i.e. 2014 onwards in the study. It is recommended to refer more
research papers/ articles/ books in the recent years (2014 to present)

Other Comments
Needs revision as mentioned.

Decision
Accept after the Revision

Please answer the following with YES/NO

Is this research original? : NO ( not exactly)

Does this (PAPER) contribute to the field of TOPIC described: YES

Recommendations
Accept without revision:

I recommend minor modifications:

I recommend moderate modifications: YES

I recommend major modifications:

Reject (reason):

Submit to another publication (specify):

Additional comments (Including comments/suggestions regarding online

supplementary materials, if any):

 Copyright © 2014. Premier Publishers.