You are on page 1of 6

JABFM

J Appl Biomater Funct Mater 2015; 13(3): e195-e200


DOI: 10.5301/jabfm.5000175

eISSN 2280-8000 ORIGINAL ARTICLE

Determination of the mechanical properties of lumbar


porcine vertebrae with 2D digital image correlation
Juan Pablo Campos-López1,2, Ariel Fuerte-Hernández1, Luis Héctor Hernández-Gómez1, Amalia Martínez-García3,
Juan Alfonso Beltrán-Fernández1, Guillermo Urriolagoitia-Calderón1
1
Postgraduate and Research Section, ESIME ZAC, National Polytechnic Institute, Federal District - Mexico
2
Polytechnic University of the Valley of Mexico, Mexico State - Mexico
3
Center for Research in Optics, Léon, Guanajuato - Mexico

Abstract
Purpose: To evaluate the strain fields and to calculate the modulus of elasticity and Poisson’s ratio of trabecular
bone of the 6 lumbar vertebrae of the porcine spine by a 2-dimensional digital image correlation (2D DIC).
Methods: This study was performed through a 2D DIC technique and the specimens were tested under compres-
sion. The resulting images were analyzed numerically by 2D DIC. Then, representative regions of interest were
examined. The strain fields were determined and stress-strain curves were obtained.
Results: The full field measurement of the strain in the lumbar bone spine was evaluated and with this data, the
Young�s modulus and Poisson�s ratio were determined.
Conclusions: This research highlights the potential applications of noninvasive acquisition techniques in biomechani-
cal analysis. This is useful in the mechanical characterization of bony structures and in the design of prostheses.
Keywords: Digital image correlation, Trabecular bone, Elastic properties, Field measurements

Introduction etry studies that validate this fact (12). Therefore, porcine mod-
els have been a good choice for predicting results related to
Different experimental techniques for exploring mechani- human cases in several reported studies (13-14).
cal features exhibited by animals in vitro and in vivo have The mechanical behavior of trabecular bone primarily
been developed. In certain cases, the intention is to under- depends on 3 parameters: the structure formed by its cells,
stand the biomechanical behavior of the human spine (1-2). the solid volume fraction, and the material properties in the
The knowledge of normal conditions of the human spine is an cell wall (15). It is a porous body that displays viscoelastic and
essential starting point for a better understanding of numer- anisotropic behavior, and these features complicate its study,
ous pathologies and injuries. To achieve this goal, the ana- making it advisable to assume some simplifications. To achieve
tomical analogy between quadrupeds and bipeds has been this objective, there are diverse mechanical tests to determine
studied by different authors (3-6). There are also mechanical the mechanical properties of trabecular bone (16-18). Some
tests that compare composite materials and natural bone, experimental works give punctual results but they cannot de-
which can solve orthopedic disorders (7). The relationships be- scribe the behavior of the whole body. Because most of the nu-
tween the 2 specimens allow results to be extrapolated from merical analysis of the spine visualizes it as a continuous body
1 kind to another. For instance, the pork spine exhibits a large and frequently as a homogeneous media, many researchers
morphological and biomechanical similarity with the human have chosen to obtain the properties at a macro level. It is
spine (8-10). One of these similarities is the orientation on the reported in the literature that there are strong variations in
arrangement of the trabecular morphology, which indicates the mechanical properties of porcine and human specimens
according to Wolff�s law (11) that the applied loads over the (19-23). Nevertheless, most of the authors agree regarding the
vertebral body are similar. This is in accordance with densitom- inherent properties of the specimens; moreover, experimental
procedures greatly influence the fluctuations in these results.
Characteristics such as race, age, weight, size, morphology,
Accepted: April 29, 2013 possible diseases, injuries, time of post-mortem testing, and
Published online: August 5, 2015 storage in different media before experimentation could have
an effect on the resulting evaluations.
Corresponding author: On the other hand, the 2D DIC technique has proven to
Juan Pablo Campos-López
21-A, Bosque de Monrovia be an efficient method for calculating deformations on flat
Nezahualcóyotl specimens. Multiple applications have been developed in
Estado de México 57170, México experimental mechanics fields for this purpose. Scientific re-
campos_juan_pablo@yahoo.com search associated with mechanical structures and material

© 2015 Wichtig Publishing


e196 Mechanical properties of lumbar porcine

characterization has been performed using this technique where ξd and ηd are polynomials of degree d. Since complex
because the displacement and strain fields can be analyzed deformations are likely to be found in trabecular bone, it is
without any contact with the specimen. With these objec- convenient to use second-order polynomials. In this way, it is
tives in mind, this work focuses on the identification of the possible to describe a more convoluted pattern of deforma-
mechanical properties for describing some global and local tions (27). When d = 2, equation 2 becomes
aspects of the entire surface of a sample. It was decided to
use 2D DIC to determine the Young’s modulus and Poisson’s x ′ = x + u + ux ∆x + uy ∆y +1 / 2uxx ∆x 2 +1 / 2uyy ∆y 2 + uxy ∆x ∆y
ratio. Of note, his noncontact optical method seems to be an
ideal candidate to describe deformation in the porcine tra- y ′ = y + v + v x ∆x + v y ∆y +1 / 2v xx ∆x 2 +1 / 2v yy ∆y 2 + v xy ∆x ∆y ,
becular bone of the vertebral column.  Eq. [3]

Theoretical basis of 2D DIC where, ux = ∂u / ∂x , uy = ∂u / ∂y and ∆x = xi - xo, etc. These


values are the argument of the correlation function (1), and
2D DIC can be defined as the search for a point p(x, y) in an is defined by
undeformed image, from a point p′( x ′, y ′) in a deformed im- P = {u, v , ux , v x , uxx , v xx , uyy , v yy , uxy , v xy } . Eq. [4]
age. This optical method compares images to obtain defor-
mation measurements without any contact with the body. In a next step, a P that satisfies C(P) ≈ 0 is sought. The
This advantage eliminates invasiveness from the experi- iteration process of equation 5 is performed until the limit
ment and it requires low cost equipment in comparison with of convergence is reached and an optimal P has been found.
interferometric techniques like electronic speckle pattern
interferometry (ESPI) or digital holographic interferometry P k +1 = P k - ∇∇C (P k )-1 ∇C (P k ).  Eq. [5]
(DHI).
Since the discretized value of p(x, y) can be repeated con- To reach a subpixel resolution, it is necessary to recon-
sistently in the distorted image, a small square subset with struct the deformed images from pixel integer values. In this
center in p(x, y) and dimensions of (2M +1) * (2M +1) is chosen work, bicubic splines were used for the interpolation of the
to find a solution. The reference subset is known as f(x, y) and deformed images through equation 6:
the deformed subset is named g( xi ′ , yi ′ ). In order to evaluate 3 3
the similarity between the 2 subsets, a criterion or correla- I( x , y ) = ∑ ∑ aij x i y i ,  Eq. [6]
tion functions are used. For this latter purpose, the zero-nor- i =0 j =0

malized sum of squared differences (ZNSSD) was considered. To ensure the performance of the programmed routines
It is defined as in MATLAB, a comparative experimental test was carried out
in order to calculate the deformation of a well-known sample.
M M  f (x ,y ) – f g( xi ′ , y j ′ ) – gm  This validates the proposed algorithm that is used in calibra-
C= ∑ ∑  i j m

∆f

∆g
 , Eq. [1]

tion of the acquired data. A tension test was conducted with
i =– M j =– M
  a universal Instron-8500 machine (Norwood, MA, USA). The
specimens were manufactured with 304L stainless steel and
1 M M M M an axial clip on an extensometer of 50 mm to 75 mm, adher-
where fm =
(2M +1) 2 ∑ ∑ f (x , y ) , ∆f = ∑ ∑ [ f ( x , y ) – f
i i i i m
]2 , ing to a resolution of 0.0001 mm. This transducer acquired
i =– M j =– M i =– M j =– M
the deformation data. The test was executed with a crosshead
and so on. When C ≈ 0, it can be said that f(xi, yi) ≈ g( xi ′ , yi ′ ) , velocity of 2.5 mm/min. Images were taken with an 8-bit Sony
and the difference between p(x, y) and p′( x ′, y ′) will define CCD camera (model GN258DNF; Sony, Tokyo, Japan), with
the displacement vector in the deformed images. The prob- continuous diffusive illumination provided by an LED source
lem is then reduced to finding the minimum of equation 1 installed at 1.25 m from the grips of the machine. A Computar
for obtaining the components of displacement u and v. In the Zoom lens with varifocal length 18 mm to 108 mm was em-
literature, a large number of possibilities for determining the ployed (Computar, Commack, NY, USA). The images were de-
minimum of this function are shown and an extensive review tected at 1 Hz and the resulting curve obtained by 2D DIC and
of these methods can be found in (24). For this work, the the extensometer are compared in Figure 1A; additionally the
Newton Raphson method was chosen and implemented in a resultant strain field is plotted in Figure 1B.
MATLAB software, as proposed by (25) and improved by (26), Figure 1A shows that the different techniques obtain re-
to determine the deformation in the vertebral bodies ana- sults that are in perfect agreement, giving an average strain
lyzed. The calculation time to reach a solution is shorter than error of 0.0016, a standard deviation (SD) of 0.0034, and an
other correlation algorithms. Moreover, it can be considered average relative error of 3.78%. The stress-strain curves of
that the deformation of the subset g( xi ′ , yi ′ ) allows the mea- porcine specimens were obtained with these confidence lim-
surement of larger deformations. its (CL). In addition, the Young’s modulus E and the compres-
Assuming that the deformed body behaves under the sive Poisson’s ratio were determined.
principles of a continuum solid, it is possible to say that the
relationship between x to x′ and y to y′ is Material and methods
x ′ = x + ξd Three spines of different pigs were chosen. Their race
y ′ = y + ηd , Eq. [2] was Pietrain and they weighed around 95 kg. They were

© 2015 Wichtig Publishing


Campos-López et al e197

A B

Fig. 1 - Strain in a 304 L stainless steel target. (A) Comparison between 2D DIC and extensometer data; (B) strain field in the specimen sub-
jected to 31 kN.

approximately 7 months old. After the animals were sacri-


ficed, they were refrigerated for 24 h at a temperature below
2°C. Having undertaken this process, 18 prismatic specimens
of 12 x 12 x 15 mm were taken from the L1 to L6 vertebrae.
It is necessary to chose prismatic specimens to implement
2D DIC, because the surface of the object to study must be
flat and parallel to the camera sensor. One side of the speci-
men was painted with a layer of white paint. Then, random
points of black paint were sprayed to attain a unique pat-
tern to correlate the surface. At the end of this preparation,
the specimens were tested in a universal machine (MTS 858
Table Top System; MTS, Eden Prairie, MN, USA), with a capac-
ity of 15 kN. The crosshead speed was 2 mm/min, and an ap-
proximately 30-N preload was applied. The period between
obtaining the specimens and testing them was not greater
than 8 h. To record the deformation of the compression test,
the optical setup shown in Figure 2 was employed. A diffuse,
Fig. 2 - Experimental setup.
white light illumination was used together with an 8-bit CCD
camera, equipped with an 18 mm-to-108 mm zoom lens and
a resolution of 754 x 480 pixels, at a distance of 60 cm from
the specimen. This distance was optimized to minimize the
errors introduced by out-of-plane deformation. The sampling
frequency of the load, the crosshead distance, and the image
acquisition were set at 2 Hz.

Determination of mechanical properties

Different regions of interest (ROI) were chosen in order to


determine the stress-strain curves. Figure 3 shows a typical
ROI that was selected. Within this area, measurement points
were generated at an interval of 5 pixels to find the displace-
ment fields u, v. The size of the square subset to evaluate the
correlation coefficient was 31 pixels per side.
It has been previously indicated that changes in the inten-
sity and poor interpolation algorithms (28) as well as the out-
of-plane displacement (29), the convergence of the method,
or the heating of the electronic systems introduce errors or Fig. 3 - ROI of the compression test.

© 2015 Wichtig Publishing


e198 Mechanical properties of lumbar porcine

A B

Fig. 4 - Displacement u in a lumbar specimen. (A) Raw displacement; (B) smooth displacement.

noise into the displacement field as shown in Figure 4A. A


simple but effective way to reduce this noise is proposed by
Pan et al (30): the ROI is approximated by small linear plane
subsection functions with equation 7. Figure 4B illustrates the
smoothed displacement field within a square window size of
17 elements per side.

us (i , j) = a0 + a1 x + a2 y
, Eq. [7]
v s (i , j) = b0 + b1 x + b2 y

Another important advantage of this method is that the


displacement field is derived without the need for subsequent
numerical derivation. This process is advantageous because it
avoids the numerical derivation that has been considered an
inconvenient, noisy process in the calculated displacement
field (30).
Strains were calculated with the Lagrangian formula-
tion, because the analysis starts with the undeformed body
and it progresses to the deformed state, leaving the tensor Fig. 5 - Typical strain-stress curve from trabecular compression test.
strain as

ε =1 / 2 F T F -1  , Eq. [8] the elastic region, the points were fitted to a straight line
by the method of ordinary least squares (OLS). To calculate
where F stands for the deformation gradient tensor and it can the longitudinal Poisson’s ratio, the same procedure was
be expressed in terms of the derivatives of displacement as followed, by averaging the strain transverse to longitudinal
strain.
ux + 1 uy 
F =  . Eq. [9] Results and discussion
 vx v y + 1
Eighteen strain-stress curves were calculated for the por-
To compare the engineering strain obtained by our MTS cine specimens. Figure 5 shows a typical case in which these
system and the strain field measured by the 2D DIC method, curves show the strain obtained by 2D DIC, the linear ap-
it was applied the equation (10) which allows a direct com- proximation for the OLS, and its counterpart delivered by the
parison between both methods, MTS-858. The difference by the method of 2D DIC and strain
was estimated by the MTS system. In this case a higher diver-
ε ing = 1+ 2ε yy - 1 . Eq. [10] gence than in the case of steel was observed; however, it is
still within reasonable parameters. The strain average error in
By using the average strain of the ROI (Fig. 3) the stress- this analysis was 0.0018 with a standard deviation of 0.0122
strain curves of the 18 specimens were obtained. Within and a relative error of 16.36%.

© 2015 Wichtig Publishing


Campos-López et al e199

A B

Fig. 6 - Transversal and longitudinal strain for a load of 810 N. (A) εxxstrain; (B) εyystrain.

Poisson’s ratio was calculated with the longitudinal εyy TABLE I - Average modulus E, ν, and standard deviation
(Fig. 6A) and transversal εxx (Fig. 6B) strains. The evaluations
were performed within the elastic region to obtain the aver- Porcine L1 L2 L3 L4 L5 L6
age Poisson’s ratio. This procedure was repeated in all cases vertebrae
to calculate the average of E, υ and the standard deviation
E [MPa] 234.67 212.29 273.50 276.51 183.119 322.119
among all. The results can be seen in Table I.
Important differences in the resulting parameters related v 0.294 0.389 0.326 0.251 0.177 0.402
to mechanical properties of porcine trabecular bone have
been reported (19-22). Since experimental techniques used STD 112.35 85.54 146.45 107.19 65.09 219.45
for their determination are diverse, different agents could be
responsible for these significant variations. For instance, some
systems for measuring strain require being in direct physical great level of geometrical detail. However, its weak point is
contact with the system, and it includes an additional param- that unlike interferometric techniques, the exact mechanical
eter that must be taken into account regarding the physical properties of the material cannot be introduced in small re-
properties of the surroundings for each experiment. Addition- gions (31). Therefore, usually it is assumed that the mechani-
ally, from punctual measurements, it is contemplated that cal properties are homogeneous (32). This situation is more
local results could be extended in order to give information complex when ceramic materials used as rehabilitation mate-
about the whole sample. The 2D DIC method shows an ad- rials, for instance, are introduced into the required numerical
equate convergence for the calculation of Young’s modulus, model (33).
not only for particular measurements but for all the select-
ed areas that were studied. The consulted literature reports Conclusions
Young’s modulus values within a range from 229 MPa to 1080
MPa, which is in good agreement with our reported average Results of a sensitive, noncontact technique for a highly
value of about 252 MPa. The variation in our reported study accurate determination of biomechanical properties are pre-
samples during the tests can be easily explained by inherent sented in this work. An important topic in biomechanics is
features in the specimen, such as age, pathology, nutrition, its the identification of the mechanical parameters of trabecular
conservation and storage, among others. bone for further investigation into the behavior of the spine
From the biomechanical point of view, an important topic under different types of load. In this work it is demonstrated
is the identification of the mechanical parameters of trabecu- that the 2D DIC method can be used to calculate the Young’s
lar bone in vertebral bodies. This would be useful in further modulus and the Poisson’s ratio for the trabecular bone of
research and would help to understand the behavior of the the spine column without being in contact with the body. It
spine under different types of load. From the obtained re- was also shown that this method can provide the behavior
sults, it can be observed that at similar levels of strain in the of the entire specimen surface in compression. From the
trabecular bone, a large heterogeneity is exhibited in com- presented results it can be observed that at similar levels of
parison with an isotropic material such as steel. When tra- strain in the trabecular bone a large heterogeneity is exhibit-
becular bone is considered as homogeneous in a numerical ed in comparison to an almost ideal material such as stainless
analysis, reasonable approximations to reality are obtained. steel. However, this resulting feature is not too far from the
It is now possible to develop finite element models with a ideal model, indicating that numerical analysis considered as

© 2015 Wichtig Publishing


e200 Mechanical properties of lumbar porcine

homogeneous trabecular bone can provide good approxima- 2010; 11(2):199-216. http://www.redalyc.org/articulo.oa?id=
tions of reality. 40412515007. Accessed July 22, 2015.
16. Borah B, Dufresne TE, Cockman MD, et al. Evaluation of Chang-
es in Trabecular Bone Architecture and Mechanical Properties
Disclosures of Minipig Vertebrae by Three-Dimensional Magnetic Reso-
Financial support: The authors would like to acknowledge the finan- nance Microimaging and Finite Element Modeling. J Bone Min-
cial support they received from the National Council for Science and er Res. 2000;15(9):1786-1797.
Technology, the National Polytechnic Institute, the Center for Re- 17. Goulet RW, Goldstein SA, Ciarelli MJ, Kuhn JL, Brown MB,
search in Optics, the Polytechnic University of the Valley of Mexico, Feldkamp LA. The relationship between the structural and
and the Institute of Science and Technology of the Federal District. orthogonal compressive properties of trabecular bone. J Bio-
Conflict of interest: None. mech. 1994;27(4):375-389.
18. Jaasma MJ, Bayraktar HH, Niebur GL, Keaveny TM. Biomechan-
ical effects of intraspecimen variations in tissue modulus for
References trabecular bone. J Biomech. 2002;35(2):237-246.
19. Lin R-M, Tsai K-H, Chang G-L. Distribution and regional strength
1. Alini M, Eisenstein S, Ito K, et al. Are animal models useful of trabecular bone in the porcine lumbar spine. Clin Biomech
for studying human disc disorders/degeneration? Eur Spine J. (Bristol, Avon). 1997;12(5):331-336.
2008;17(1):2-19. 20. Mosekilde L, Kragstrup J, Richards A. Compressive strength,
2. Jiang H, Moreau M, Raso VJ, Russell G, Bagnall K. A comparison ash weight, and volume of vertebral trabecular bone in experi-
of spinal ligaments—differences between bipeds and quadru- mental fluorosis in pigs. Calcif Tissue Int. 1987;40(6):318-322.
peds. J Anat. 1995;187(Pt 1):85-91. 21. Ryan G, Pandit A, Apatsidis D. Stress distribution in the inter-
3. Cotterill PC, Kostuik JP, D’Angelo G, Fernie GR, Maki BE. An ana- vertebral disc correlates with strength distribution in subdis-
tomical comparison of the human and bovine thoracolumbar cal trabecular bone in the porcine lumbar spine. Clin Biomech
spine. J Orthop Res. 1986;4(3):298-303. (Bristol, Avon). 2008;23(7):859-869.
4. Kumar N, Kukreti S, Ishaque M, Mulholland R. Anatomy of 22. Teo JCM, Si-Hoe KM, Keh JEL, Teoh SH. Relationship between
deer spine and its comparison to the human spine. Anat Rec. CT intensity, micro-architecture and mechanical properties
2000;260(2):189-203. of porcine vertebral cancellous bone. Clin Biomech (Bristol,
5. Boszczyk BM, Boszczyk AA, Putz R. Comparative and func- Avon). 2006;21(3):235-244.
tional anatomy of the mammalian lumbar spine. Anat Rec. 23. Di Mascio V, Bellini C, Galbusera F, Raimondi M, Brayda-Bruno
2001;264(2):157-168. M, Assietti R. Lumbar total disc replacement: a numerical study.
6. F. McLain R, Yerby SA and Moseley TA. Comparative Morphom- J Appl Biomater Biomech. 2010;8(2):97-101.
etry of L4 Vertebrae: Comparison of Large Animal Models for 24. Pan B, Qian K, Xie H, Asundi A. Two-dimensional digital image
the Human Lumbar Spine. Spine (Phila Pa 1976). 2002;27(8): correlation for in-plane displacement and strain measurement:
E200-E206. a review. Meas Sci Technol. 2009;20(6):062001.
7. Fuentes E, Sáenz VV, Igartua A, Martinetti R, Dolcini L, Barandi- 25. Bruck H, McNeill S, Sutton M, Peters W III. Digital image cor-
ka G. Structural characterization and mechanical performance relation using Newton-Raphson method of partial differential
of calcium phosphate scaffolds and natural bones: a compara- correction. Exp Mech. 1989;29(3):261-267.
tive study. J Appl Biomater Biomech. 2010;8(3):159-165. 26. Vendroux G, Knauss W. Submicron deformation field measure-
8. Bozkus H, Crawford N, Chamberlain R, et al. Comparative anato- ments: Part 2. Improved digital image correlation. Exp Mech.
my of the porcine and human thoracic spines with reference to 1998;38(2):86-92.
thoracoscopic surgical techniques. Surg Endosc. 2005;12(19): 27. Lu H, Cary P. Deformation measurements by digital image cor-
1652-1665. relation: Implementation of a second-order displacement gra-
9. Busscher I, Ploegmakers J, Verkerke G, Veldhuizen A. Compara- dient. Exp Mech. 2000;40(4):393-400.
tive anatomical dimensions of the complete human and por- 28. Schreier HW, Braasch JR, Sutton MA. Systematic errors in digi-
cine spine. Eur Spine J. 2010;19(7):1104-1114. tal image correlation caused by intensity interpolation. Opt
10. Yingling VR, Callaghan JP, McGill SM. The Porcine Cervical Spine Eng. 2000;39(11):2915.
as a Model of the Human Lumbar Spine: An Anatomical, Geo- 29. Sutton MA, Yan JH, Tiwari V, Schreier HW, Orteu JJ. The effect
metric, and Functional Comparison. J Spinal Disord. 1999;12(5): of out-of-plane motion on 2D and 3D digital image correlation
415-423. measurements. Opt Lasers Eng. 2008;46(10):746-757.
11. Goldstein SA, Matthews LS, Kuhn JL, Hollister SJ. Trabecular 30. Pan B, Asundi A, Xie H, Gao J. Digital image correlation using
bone remodeling: an experimental model. J Biomech. 1991; iterative least squares and pointwise least squares for displace-
24(Suppl 1):135-150. ment field and strain field measurements. Opt Lasers Eng.
12. Smit T. The use of a quadruped as an in vivo model for the study 2009;47(7-8):865-874.
of the spine - biomechanical considerations. Eur Spine J. 2002; 31. Morales-Bonilla S, Torres-Torres C, Urriolagoitia-Sosa G,
11(2):137-144. Hernández-Gómez LH, Urriolagoitia-Calderón G. Interfero-
13. Schmidt R, Richter M, Claes L, Puhl W, and Wilke HJ. Limita- metric laser detection of nanomechanical perturbations in
tions of the cervical porcine spine in evaluating spinal implants biological media under ablation conditions. J Phys Conf Ser.
in comparison with human cervical spinal segments: a biome- 2011;305:012124-012127.
chanical in vitro comparison of porcine and human cervical 32. Beltrán-Fernández J, Hernández-Gómez LH, Urriolagoitia-
spine specimens with different instrumentation techniques. Calderón G, González-Rebatú A, Urriolagoitia-Sosa G. Biome-
Spine (Phila Pa 1976). 2005;30(11):1275. chanics and Numerical Evaluation of Cervical Porcine Models
14. Tai C-L, Hsieh P-H, Chen W-P, Chen L-H, Chen W-J, Lai P-L. Bio- Considering Compressive Loads Using 2-D Classic Computer
mechanical comparison of lumbar spine instability between Tomography CT, 3-D Scanner and 3-D Computed Tomography.
laminectomy and bilateral laminotomy for spinal stenosis Appl Mech Mater. 2010; 24-25:287-295. http://www.scientific.
syndrome - an experimental study in porcine model. BMC net/AMM.24-25.287. Accessed July 22, 2015.
Musculoskelet Disord. 2008;9(1):84. 33. Hernández-Gómez LH, Beltrán-Fernández J, Urriolagoitia-
15. Ramírez-Díaz E, Ortiz-Prado A, Schouwenaars-Franssens R, Calderón G, González-Rebatú A, Galán Vera M, Urriolagoi-
and Ruiz-Cervantes O. Metodología para el modelado del tia-Sosa G. Biomechanical Characterization of a Cervical
comportamiento mecánico de hueso esponjoso a partir de Corporectomy Using Porcine Specimens, Following an Ex-
sus microestructuras. Ingeniería, investigación y tecnología perimental Approach. Key Eng Mater. 2011;478:103-111.

© 2015 Wichtig Publishing

You might also like