Professional Documents
Culture Documents
An Acupuncture Technique
by Subhuti Dharmananda, Ph.D., Director, Institute for Traditional Medicine, Portland, Oregon
Piercing a vein or small artery at the tip of the body-finger tips, toes, or top of the
ears-is a technique well-known among acupuncturists. To the uninitiated Westerner,
this therapy may seem even stranger than standard needling that is explained as a
method of adjusting the flow of qi in the vessels. In this case, a few drops of blood let
out from one or more peripheral points by quickly stabbing the skin with a lance is
said to have significant effects. As mentioned in Fundamentals of Chinese
Acupuncture (1), "The procedure should be thoroughly explained to the patient
before it is performed to allay his or her fears."
Letting out blood is among the oldest of acupuncture techniques. Indeed, it has
been speculated that acupuncture started as a method of pricking boils, then expanded
to letting out "bad blood" that was generated by injuries or fevers, and finally
allowing invisible evil spirits and perverse atmospheric qi (most notably "wind")
escape from the body (2). Only later, perhaps as the needles became more refined and
as scholars developed of a more subtle theoretical framework, were thin filiform
needles used as the primary acupuncture tools for the purpose of adjusting the flow of
qi and blood, without necessarily releasing something from the body.
The Lingshu (Spiritual Pivot) and its companion volume, the Suwen (Simple
Questions), written around 100 B.C., established the fundamentals of traditional
Chinese medical ideas and acupuncture therapy (3, 4). Originally, there was a set of 9
acupuncture needles, which included the triangular lance, sword-like flat needles, and
fairly large needles (see Figure 1). In the Lingshu (3) these ancient needles are
numbered and the needle designs and qualities are associated with what the numbers
represent. Regarding the fourth needle, which has a tubular body and lance-like tip,
the text states: "This can be used to drain fevers, to draw blood, and to exhaust
chronic diseases." The seventh needle is described as being hair fine (corresponding in
form to the most common of the current needles); it is said to "control fever and chills
and painful rheumatism in the luo channels." In modern practice, using the lance as a
means to treat chronic diseases has been marginalized (except to treat acute flare-ups
of chronic ailments), while the applications of the hair-fine needle has been greatly
expanded beyond malarial fevers and muscle and joint pain.
The Lingshu has several references to the use of blood-letting. In the chapter on
hot diseases, it states:
For a hot disease with frequent frights, convulsions, and madness,
treat the blood channels. Use the number four lance needle. Quickly
disperse when there is an excess. When there is insanity and a loss of
hair, treat the blood and the heart.
The use of the lance needle to treat the blood channels is a reference to blood-
letting. The indications of blood-letting for alleviating heat, convulsions, and mental
distress has persisted to modern times. For example, when treating the jing (well)
points at the beginning or end of the meridians, the general indication that has come
down to us today is for fevers and mental illness.
The lance needle is also recommended, in the same chapter of the Lingshu, for
treatment of a hot disease where the whole body feels heavy and the center of the
intestines is hot, and when there are spasms around the navel, and the chest and ribs
are full. Among the points suggested to be bled are "those points on the cracks of the
toes." Drawing blood, which is mentioned repeatedly in this chapter of the Lingshu, is
usually accompanied by instructions that one should drain it from the luo vessels,
which are described in this text as visible vessels, apparently corresponding to veins.
For example, it is said that one should examine above the anklebone to see if
the luo channels are full; if so, drain until blood is seen.
An entire chapter of the Lingshu is devoted to the luo vessels in which questions
are answered about blood-letting therapy. It is said that: "When the blood and qi are
both abundant and the yin qi is plentiful, the blood will be slippery so that needling
will cause it to shoot out." On the other hand, "When much bleeding takes place with
needling, but the color does not change and there are palpitations and depression, it is
because needling the luo channel causes the channel to empty." The change in color
that is anticipated occurs when the bad blood, which is described as thick and black,
has been eliminated and normal red blood appears.
The Suwen (4) also has a chapter on treating the luo vessels. It makes three
references to blood-letting, all in association with the point ranggu (KI-2); in general,
the ranggu point is needled, and then the capillary in front of the point is to be bled.
This is used in treatment of swollen throat and for abdominal swelling and fullness
that accompanies either heart pain or injury. Similarly, in the Lingshu chapter on
water swelling, a case of abdominal swelling-where the skin is tight like a drum-is
described; the therapy recommended is to draw blood from the luo channels. The
location of blood-letting is not specified, though it is stated that the problem should be
treated in the lower part of the body.
In the Suwen chapter about needling of the channels properly, it is said that:
When one administers acupuncture during the spring, it is
appropriate to needle shu (stream) points. In fact, bloodletting is a
preferred technique....In the summer, one can also practice
bloodletting, but it is preferable to use superficial luo points. Allow
the bleeding to stop by itself, so that the pathogen will be completely
eliminated."
Thus, one looks for those specific veins that are congested in order to apply this
therapy, rather than picking certain points or channels theoretically. The particular
practice described here, of trying to avert the flare-up by locating the stagnation and
draining the blood is described as "ambushing the enemy before being confronted."
The approach to making the veins stand out is one that is still mimicked today, with
massaging and pressing to assure that when the vein is lanced blood will flow out,
though the original purpose was also diagnostic-determining which vessel had the
pathogen to be let out.
As with the earlier texts, blood-letting is mainly recommended in Jia Yi jing for
conditions of abdominal swelling, malarial-type diseases with alternating fever and
chills (Chinese: nue), and certain painful conditions, particularly lower back pain. The
main idea is to eliminate bad blood, as in this case of treating an injury:
The unraveled vessel causes people to suffer from splitting lower
back pain with irascibility....Needle the unraveled vessel
at weizhong (BL-40), pricking the binding connecting vessel there
which is like a millet grain. Upon being pricked, the vessel will
ejaculate black blood and, once the blood turns red, the treatment
may be stopped.
In sum, for excess type syndromes, bleeding is recommended because it can drain
the excess, alleviate congestion and stasis, and remove the pathogens. As described
in Fundamentals of Chinese Acupuncture, the function of blood-letting therapy is
"to drain heat or quicken the blood and qi and relieve local congestion." The method
of carrying out blood-letting is described:
This procedure is done by first applying pressure to restrict the blood
flow of the area, to increase the visibility of the veins and to cause
the blood to flow out more easily when the vein is pricked. The point
is then swiftly and decisively pricked to a superficial depth of about
0.1 cun and a few drops of blood are allowed to escape. Lastly, the
point is pressed with sterile cotton until the bleeding ceases.
The last instruction, which is a modern practice, differs from the ancient one in
which the bleeding is allowed to continue until it stops on its own. In the Jia Yi jing,
there is a discussion of treating alternating chills and fever, in which blood-letting is
recommended and the amount of blood to be let out is "appropriate to the fatness or
thinness of the patient," thus a relatively larger amount for heavier persons.
Similarly, at the tips of the fingers are the shixuan points, located 0.1 cun behind
the nails (see Figure 3). Pricking these points to let out blood is said to be useful for
coma, epilepsy, high fever, and sore throat. A little further down, at the finger creases
(the lower of the two creases along the finger joints), are the sifeng points (four wind
points; the thumb, which has only the one crease, is not included; see see Figure 4).
Pricking these to let out plasma fluid that is yellowish white, is said to treat
malnutrition and indigestion in children and whooping cough. Finally, points between
each pair of fingers, at the top of the webbing joining the fingers, are the baxie points
(see Figure 5). These can be acupunctured with shallow insertion of 0.5-0.8 cun depth
or pricked to cause bleeding, used to treat snakebite of the hand.
The terminal jing points, known by some as ting points, are also pricked to let out
blood. These "well" points, of which there are 12, are mainly located at the tips of the
fingers and toes (the exception is KI-1); below are some of the indications for
bleeding these points:
Finally, there is pricking of the ear apex (tubercle) to let out blood, as a
similar basic technique. All these peripheral point bleeding treatments
are used for heat and excess syndromes. As an example, treating the
ear apex by bloodletting has been recommended to treat hordeolum, an
eye infection (8).
MODERN VIEWS
Blood-letting is a method of therapy that is difficult to explain in modern
terms. Aside from the traditional theoretical basis for these treatments
in letting out heat and excess factors, a key issue is whether it actually
produces the claimed effects. Many Western acupuncturists have stated
informally that they get dramatic results from this treatment method,
but, unfortunately, there is no evidence presented to support such
contentions. Despite the frequent mention of treating peripheral points
by blood-letting in both ancient and modern Chinese medical texts,
there is little reference to this technique in Chinese medical journal
reports. Very few articles focus specifically on use of this technique.
Further, descriptions of therapies for the disorders that peripheral
blood-letting is supposed to successfully treat rarely include that
method. Instead, standard acupuncture techniques without blood-
letting, as well as herbal therapies, are described. Therefore, the
effectiveness of the technique must be questioned, at least until further
evidence has accumulated.
Today, we know that the peripheral blood has the same content as
the rest of the blood that circulates in the body, and that there is no
reason to expect that the blood let out by this method is "bad blood,"
other than in a purely symbolic role. While standard acupuncture
therapy is depicted as being effective, in part, by releasing various
transmitter substances (e.g., endorphins), by stimulating local blood
flow (e.g., by dilating vessels), and by producing changes in the brain
that may have both systemic and highly specific effects, letting out a
small amount of blood (usually just a few drops) remains without a
suitable explanation for the potent effects claimed. The technique used
to let out the blood is one of quick and light pricking to pierce the skin
and vein. Unlike standard acupuncture, this method does not involve
getting a qi reaction or other evidence that the body is responding on a
deep level.
Blood-letting occurs in numerous contexts in the modern world.
Millions of people donate a pint of blood, sometimes regularly;
millions more prick fingertips every day to get a blood sample for
diabetes testing. While these experiences are not as specific as aiming
for certain acupoints to release blood, the large number of points at the
periphery indicated for blood-letting in the Chinese literature, often
with overlapping indications, suggests that the technique does not
necessarily require a high degree of specificity for the location. Do
diabetics and blood donors suffer substantially less from syndromes of
heat and excess?
SUMMARY
Blood-letting is an ancient therapy that was an essential part of traditional
acupuncture practice described in the original texts and which persists
today, particularly for treatment of emergency cases, such as loss of
consciousness, high fever, and swellings. Most of the blood-letting
therapy relies on treating peripheral points of the fingers and toes. Its
purpose is to alleviate excess conditions, particularly heat syndromes
and fluid swelling, and to promote resuscitation. A traditional concept
was that the release of blood would draw out the excess. This therapy
is somewhat difficult to explain in modern terms, and, therefore,
requires some investigation and research before any substantial claims
of effectiveness can be made. Practitioners often note what appear to
be prompt and dramatic results from the therapy, suggesting that its
efficacy should be easy to confirm using short-term trials. In most
cases, peripheral blood-letting (or other blood-letting therapy) is
accompanied by standard acupuncture, especially with points that are
not far from the blood-letting points, such as the hand/wrist points LI-
4, LU-7, and PC-6 and the foot/ankle points LV-2, LV-3, and KI-3,
suggesting that these other points may contribute significantly to the
observed therapeutic outcome. As a symbolic therapy-of letting out
excess, bad blood, toxins, or heat-blood-letting is a potent technique
for both the practitioner and the patient, and its use represents a
continuation of the earliest traditions of acupuncture.
The following report (15) includes the full text of the physician's
instructions on treatment, and then his case reports, which are
shortened considerably for presentation here.
REFERENCES
August 2002
Figure 1: The nine original acupuncture needles.
Figure 2: The qiduan and bafeng points.