Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Sci Forschen
Open HUB for Scientific Researc h Open Access
*
Corresponding author: Erin Cassidy-Eagle, Department of Psychiatry & Behavioral Sciences, Stanford University School of Medicine, USA, Tel:
(650)736-7350; E-mail: ecassidy@stanford.edu
Introduction
Citation: Cassidy-Eagle E, Siebern A, Unti L, Glassman J, O’Hara R More than 50% of adults over the age of 65 report serious
(2018) Cognitive Behavioral Treatment for Insomnia in Older Adults problems with sleep [1]. Sleep disturbance increases with age,
With Mild Cognitive Impairment in Independent Living Facilities:
A Pilot Study. J Sleep Disord Med Care 1(1): dx.doi.org/10.16966/ particularly among women and those with concurrent medical
jsdmc.105 or psychiatric conditions [2]. Further, the presence of sleep
Copyright: © 2018 Cassidy-Eagle E, et al. This is an open-access disturbance is a risk factor for declining health status [3].
article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Specific aspects of sleep that are significantly worse in older
Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and adults with insomnia include increased sleep latency, number
reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source
of awakenings after sleep onset, and overall sleep efficiency
are credited.
[4]. Such problems are frequently secondary to medical,
Abstract psychological, environmental and behavioral causes, as well
Objectives: Sleep disturbance is common in older adults and is one as complications that can result from prescription and non-
of the most frequent symptoms observed in older adults with Mild
prescription medications [5]. Notably, sleep disturbances are
Cognitive Impairment (MCI). Older adults in residential care settings
are more likely to suffer from psychiatric, medical and cognitive (i.e., more prevalent and severe in those with MCI compared to those
MCI) impairments than those still independent in the community. with no impairment [6,7]. Growing evidence suggests that
Interventions targeting insomnia are ideal given the evidence that sleep problems may reflect an intermediary state of cognitive
treatments are very successful for a broad range of individuals;
improvements have the potential to broadly impact public health;
functioning between normal and cognitive impairment, and
and further, sleep represents a modifiable risk factor for a range may be predictive of progression to dementia [8,9].
of other disorders, such as declining cognition, depression, and
functional impairment. What remains to be established is whether or
Several meta-analyses of sleep interventions, such as
not established treatments, specifically Cognitive Behavioral Therapy CBT-I, support the finding that sleep disturbance is very
for insomnia (CBT-I), can be successfully used with older individuals amenable to change [10,11] with treatment resulting in robust
who have both impaired sleep and MCI. This study aims to test improvements in functioning across the lifespan. Morin et
whether CBT-I is effective in improving the sleep of older adults with
insomnia and mild cognitive impairment. al. [12] found that an 8-week CBT intervention with older
adults in the community resulted in significant improvements
Methods: A six-session, adapted version of a cognitive behavioral
intervention for insomnia was administered to older adults (N=28) that were maintained even a year later, including decreases
across two residential facilities. Participants were randomly assigned in sleep latency, Wake After Sleep Onset (WASO), and early
to either the sleep intervention or an active control group. morning awakenings, as well as an increase in sleep efficiency.
Results: The intervention had a highly significant (Cohen’s d ≥ 1.9, Discussion of ‘sleep hygiene’ can be useful to make sure that
p<0.001) effect of improving sleep outcomes for 4 of the 5 outcome individuals are behaving in ways that promote good sleep,
variables at both follow up time points, measured by actigraphy.
from how much alcohol they consume and when, to making
Conclusions: Nonpharmacological interventions such as CBT-I may be sure the temperature is somewhat cool in their bedroom.
beneficial for people with MCI. Targeting sleep has the potential to
broadly impact public health, including in people with MCI.
The interventions also include the well-supported behavioral
components, like stimulus control and sleep restriction
Keywords: Insomnia; MCI; Older adults; CBT-I; Residential care
procedures, which set a consistent rise time, designating a sleep
opportunity window and recommending that patients get out
of bed if unable to sleep (instead of staying in bed and being that those with cognitive impairment can benefit from
frustrated), in addition to other instructions. CBT can also structured psychotherapy, such as CBT [25], Interpersonal
include relaxation to help manage physiological arousal and [26] or Problem Solving Therapy [27,28], much remains to be
cognitive therapy (restructuring) to address the thoughts and learned about how MCI may moderate the effects of CBT-I for
beliefs that serve to perpetuate the insomnia such as “everyone sleep and what adaptations are needed to maximize the effects
needs 8 hours of sleep”. of treatment. Adaptations of CBT interventions targeting other
Residential Care Facilities for the Elderly [RCFEs] e.g., behaviors (e.g. anxiety) among older adults with MCI have
Independent Living Facilities (ILF) strive to provide an proven to be successful [29]. This study contributes new data on
environment that allows and cultivates independence, while the degree to which adaptations to CBT, such as repetition and
simultaneously providing assistance for those residents with increased opportunities for practice, aid older adults in RCFE
functional and cognitive limitations. Residents may present settings who have MCI and sleep disorders.
with multiple medical and psychological co-morbid disorders, Our hypotheses
and appear to be more likely to suffer from both disturbed
From baseline (T1) to the 4 month-follow-up (T3) time
sleep [13] and Mild Cognitive Impairment (MCI) [14] than
points, ILF residents with both sleep disturbances and
skilled nursing facility or home-dwelling adults. Thus, RCFEs,
MCI assigned to receive the adapted CBT-I will exhibit: 1)
particularly ILFs, are an ideal and critical setting in which
significant improvements in objective measures of sleep-onset
to develop effective interventions for sleep disturbance in
latency, wake time after sleep-onset, total sleep time, and sleep
residents with MCI. There is evidence that CBT-I is effective in
efficiency, as measured by actigraphy, compared to the delayed
the geriatric population although studies are limited in the area
treatment group, and 2) significant decreases in self-reported
examining CBT-I and its effectiveness in a geriatric population
frequency and severity of insomnia symptoms, as measured
with MCI residing in residential care facilities, specifically
by the Insomnia Severity Index (ISI), compared to the delayed
independent living facilities.
treatment group.
Is CBT effective in those with MCI?
Methods
The success of CBT relies on certain cognitive processes,
The study employed a two-arm Individual Randomized
including one’s ability to process and incorporate new
Group Trial (IRGT) with residents from two RCFE (N=28), with
information in order to subsequently shift one’s behavior and
randomization at the resident level to the adapted intervention
mood. Although complaints of attention and concentration
or delayed treatment group. Participants were randomized to
are common amongst those with insomnia, complaints of
either a 6-session CBT-I intervention group or an active control
memory or executive functioning are less common [15].
nutrition class. The active control group was a nutrition class
Sleep latency, night time awakening, duration of sleep and
as it would not have an impact on sleep parameters and was of
sleep efficiency were all compromised in patients with MCI,
interest for participant recruitment.
even when analyses were controlled for clinical levels of
anxiety and depression [16]. Cognitively, deficits in executive The sample (N=28) included participants from two local
processes (e.g., planning, problem solving), memory and Independent Living Facilities (ILF) in the Santa Cruz area from
language functions also occur more frequently in MCI and 2014-2015. Recruitment was facilitated by flyers in all resident
are particularly important to assess in light of their potential mailboxes and at in-person talks by the PI about common sleep
impact on treatment given the cognitive processing involved changes with age.
in CBT. MCI affects 15-25% of adults over the age of 70, with Participants were 28 older adults (24 females-4 males; mean
about 10% of this group progressing to dementia each year [17- age, 89.36 years), meeting the key inclusion criteria of meeting
19]. There is growing evidence that a bidirectional relationship diagnostic criteria for insomnia according to the DSM-IV [30],
between sleep disturbances and cognitive impairment exists and the core clinical criteria for MCI used by healthcare workers
[20]. Prospectively, sleep disturbance has been linked to the without access to advanced imaging techniques [31] (i.e.,
emergence of cognitive deficits [6], and has been identified subject memory complaints, preservation of independence in
as a risk factor and/or prodromal syndrome of various functional abilities, performance on at least one of the cognitive
neurodegenerative diseases [21]. For example, recent work by
tests at 1.5 SD below published age/educational matched
Diem et al. [22] found that lower sleep efficiency and longer
normative means, and no major neurocognitive disorder).
sleep latencies in older women were associated with a 1.5 and
Out of the 46 potential participants identified, 18 participants
1.4 greater odds of developing MCI or dementia within five
were excluded from the study due to acute stressor (n=6),
years.
not meeting insomnia diagnostic criteria (n=6), unwilling to
Patients with executive dysfunction, often present with commit time to study (n=2), screened positive on apnea screen
MCI [23], have also been identified as poor responders to and were unwilling to treat (n=1), unwilling to do apnea screen
pharmacotherapy, such as anti-depressants [24], creating a (n=1), unable to reach/make contact (n=1), and one that was
need for therapeutic alternatives. Although there is evidence determined to be intoxicated at screening visit (n=1).
Citation: Cassidy-Eagle E, Siebern A, Unti L, Glassman J, O’Hara R (2018) Cognitive Behavioral Treatment for Insomnia in Older Adults
With Mild Cognitive Impairment in Independent Living Facilities: A Pilot Study. J Sleep Disord Med Care 1(1): dx.doi.org/10.16966/ 2
jsdmc.105
Sci Forschen
Open HUB for Scientific Researc h
Journal of Sleep Disorders and Medical Care
Open Access Journal
Citation: Cassidy-Eagle E, Siebern A, Unti L, Glassman J, O’Hara R (2018) Cognitive Behavioral Treatment for Insomnia in Older Adults
With Mild Cognitive Impairment in Independent Living Facilities: A Pilot Study. J Sleep Disord Med Care 1(1): dx.doi.org/10.16966/ 3
jsdmc.105
Sci Forschen
Open HUB for Scientific Researc h
Journal of Sleep Disorders and Medical Care
Open Access Journal
adjustments were made to bring the marker within 5 minutes sample t-tests for baseline differences between treatment and
of the shift in activity level. Total sleep time, sleep latency, control group means. There were no statistically significant
wakefulness after sleep onset, and sleep efficiency (time in bed/ differences in any factors across arms, so randomization efforts
total sleep time) were then calculated using ActiLife 5 Software were successful in balancing the groups on a wide range of
that uses Cole and Kripke’s 1992 sleep scoring algorithm. characteristics. The only variable that was close to significance
Actigraph data was reviewed and scored separately from all is the SF-36 Physical quality of life rating, with a p=0.11;
other data and randomized group assignment reports, with the therefore it was included as the only covariate besides baseline
exception of sleep logs and subject ID (which was a consecutive, outcome in the regression analyses (a cutoff of p<0.15 was used
temporally assigned number). for concluding covariates were “imbalanced”) [35]. Table 2
Data analysis shows the means and standard deviations for all of the sleep
parameters as measure for both T1 and T3. The effect of the
Multilevel analyses were used to provide estimates of the intervention on the secondary neuropsychological outcome
intervention’s effect on the outcomes of interest, adjusting for variables are reported elsewhere [36].
the correlation between residents within the same treatment
delivery groups. Stata was used to conduct the multilevel Table 3 shows that the intervention had a highly significant
analyses. In these analyses the outcome variable was regressed, (p<0.005) effect in the desired direction of improving sleep
using linear multilevel regression models (all outcomes are outcomes for 4 of the 5 outcome variables at both follow up
continuous variables), against the following independent time points. In other words, sleep latency; wake after sleep
variables: indicator variable denoting intervention condition, onset, sleep efficiency, and insomnia severity all were improved
baseline measure of the dependent variable; and covariates that significantly in the treatment groups relative to the control
were imbalanced across arms. Cohen’s d was computed from groups. Effect sizes were large, with absolute values of Cohen’s
the regression coefficient t-statistics as a measure of effect size d greater than 1.
[33,34], and p-values were from the Wald test for significance
Discussion
of a regression coefficient.
Results of our current investigation, utilizing an adapted
Results CBT-I intervention with older adults in ILFs who suffer from
Table 1 includes baseline means for selected demographic, sleep disturbance and MCI, indicate that we have been able to
covariates and primary outcomes by treatment arm for all improve both objective and subjective ratings of sleep quality. At
participants. The table also displays the p-values for independent this stage it appears that this 6-session CBT-I group intervention
Citation: Cassidy-Eagle E, Siebern A, Unti L, Glassman J, O’Hara R (2018) Cognitive Behavioral Treatment for Insomnia in Older Adults
With Mild Cognitive Impairment in Independent Living Facilities: A Pilot Study. J Sleep Disord Med Care 1(1): dx.doi.org/10.16966/ 4
jsdmc.105
Sci Forschen
Open HUB for Scientific Researc h
Journal of Sleep Disorders and Medical Care
Open Access Journal
Table 2: Primary Sleep Outcomes: Means and Standard Deviations by Treatment Relative to Active Control
Time 1 Time 3
Treatment Control Treatment Control
Variable n Mean (SD) n Mean (SD) n Mean (SD) n Mean (SD)
ISI 14 15.29 (2.33) 13 14.85 (3.85) 12 3.25 (2.05) 11 12 (3.11)
LATENCY 11 11.03 (11.69) 13 11.23 (9.45) 12 1.93 (3.57) 10 12.52 (9.84)
WASO 11 104.24 (38.21) 13 104.42 (70.68) 12 46.95 (25.09) 10 81.70 (44.49)
TST 11 434.61 (51.53) 13 422.22 (63.97) 12 379.50 (75.13) 10 432.15 (46.82)
EFFICIENCY 11 79.20 (7.44) 13 78.94 (12.02) 12 88.04 (7.19) 10 82.30 (7.82)
has led to significant improvements in sleep parameters in older 6. Beaulieu-Bonneau S, Hudon C (2009) Sleep disturbances in
adults in residential settings who also frequently suffer from older adults with mild cognitive impairment. Int Psychogeriatr
21: 654-666.
mild cognitive deficits. This study was a small pilot study and
future research should include a randomized controlled study. 7. Bombois S, Derambure P, Pasquier F, Monaca C (2010) Sleep
Further limitation is the sample overall included healthy and disorders in aging and dementia. J Nutr Health Aging 14: 212-217.
highly educated participants and further study should examine 8. Geda YE, Roberts RO, Knopman DS, Petersen RC, Christianson TJ,
additional demographics. Future study is needed to further et al. (2008) Prevalence of neuropsychiatric symptoms in mild
explore the possible impact on cognitive functioning that result cognitive impairment and normal cognitive aging: population-
based study. Arch Gen Psychiatry 65: 1193-1198.
from CBT-I.
9. Lyketsos CG, Lopez O, Jones B, Fitzpatrick AL, Breitner J, et al.
This study examined whether or not CBT-I, an effective
(2002) Prevalence of neuropsychiatric symptoms in dementia
nonpharmacological intervention, is effective at improving the and mild cognitive impairment: results from the cardiovascular
sleep of older adults experiencing insomnia and mild cognitive health study. JAMA 288: 1475-1483.
impairment. These promising results support the need for
10. Irwin MR, Cole JC, Nicassio PM (2006) Comparative meta-
more work with individuals suffering from mild cognitive analysis of behavioral interventions for insomnia and their
impairment to explore the extent that sleep treatments could efficacy in middle-aged adults and in older adults 55+ years of
result in improved health. Nonpharmacological interventions age. Health Psychol 25: 3-14.
that may extend the functional window experienced by older 11. Morin CM, Culbert JP, Schwartz SM (1994) Nonpharmacological
adults exhibiting mild cognitive impairment have the potential interventions for insomnia: a meta-analysis of treatment
to profoundly impact quality of life. efficacy. Am J Psychiatry 151: 1172-1180.
12. Morin CM, Kowatch RA, Barry T, Walton E (1993) Cognitive-
References behavior therapy for late-life insomnia. J Consult Clin Psychol
1. Foley DJ, Monjan AA, Brown SL, Simonsick EM, Wallace RB, 61: 137-146.
et al. (1995) Sleep complaints among elderly persons: an
13. Mitchell JM, Kemp BJ (2000) Quality of life in assisted living
epidemiologic study of three communities. Sleep 18: 425-432.
homes: a multidimensional analysis. J Gerontol B Psychol Sci Soc
2. Mellinger GD, Balter MB, Uhlenhuth EH (1985) Insomnia and its Sci 55: P117-P127.
treatment. Prevalence and correlates. Arch Gen Psychiatry 42:
14. Elliott AF, Horgas AL, Marsiske M (2008) Nurses’ role in
225-232.
identifying mild cognitive impairment in older adults. Geriatr
3. Ford DE, Kamerow DB (1989) Epidemiologic study of sleep Nurs 29: 38-47.
disturbances and psychiatric disorders. An opportunity for
15. Morin CM, Espie CA (2004) Insomnia: A clinical guide to
prevention? JAMA 262: 1479-1484.
assessment and treatment, Kluwer academic publishers,
4. Morin CM, Gramling SE (1989) Sleep patterns and aging: Springer, New York, USA.
comparison of older adults with and without insomnia
16. Yu J, Mahendran R, Rawtaer I, Kua EH, Feng L (2017) Poor sleep
complaints. Psychol Aging 4: 290-294.
quality is observed in mild cognitive impairment and is largely
5. Guilleminault C, Silvestri R (1982) Aging, drugs and sleep. unrelated to depression and anxiety. Aging Ment Health 21: 823-
Neurobiol Aging 3: 379-386. 828.
Citation: Cassidy-Eagle E, Siebern A, Unti L, Glassman J, O’Hara R (2018) Cognitive Behavioral Treatment for Insomnia in Older Adults
With Mild Cognitive Impairment in Independent Living Facilities: A Pilot Study. J Sleep Disord Med Care 1(1): dx.doi.org/10.16966/ 5
jsdmc.105
Sci Forschen
Open HUB for Scientific Researc h
Journal of Sleep Disorders and Medical Care
Open Access Journal
17. Petersen RC (2009) Early diagnosis of Alzheimer’s disease: is MCI 27. Alexopoulos GS, Raue P, Arean P (2003) Problem-solving therapy
too late? Curr Alzheimer Res 6: 324-330. versus supportive therapy in geriatric major depression with
executive dysfunction. Am J Geriatr Psychiatry 11: 46-52.
18. Busse A, Hensel A, Gühne U, Angermeyer MC, Riedel-Heller
SG (2006) Mild cognitive impairment: long-term course of four 28. Mackin RS, Areán P, Elite-Marcandonatou A (2006) Problem
clinical subtypes. Neurology 67: 2176-2185. solving therapy for the treatment of depression for a patient
with Parkinson’s disease and mild cognitive impairment: a case
19. Di Carlo A, Lamassa M, Baldereschi M, Inzitari M, Scafato E, et al.
study. Neuropsychiatr Dis Treat 2: 375-379.
(2007) CIND and MCI in the Italian elderly: frequency, vascular
risk factors, progression to dementia. Neurology 68: 1909-1916. 29. Mohlman J, Gorenstein EE, Kleber M, de Jesus M, Gorman JM,
et al. (2003) Standard and enhanced cognitive-behavior therapy
20. Guarnieri B, Sorbi S (2015) Sleep and Cognitive Decline:
for late-life generalized anxiety disorder: two pilot investigations.
A Strong Bidirectional Relationship. It Is Time for Specific
Am J Geriatr Psychiatry 11: 24-32.
Recommendations on Routine Assessment and the Management
of Sleep Disorders in Patients with Mild Cognitive Impairment 30. APA (2013) Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental of
and Dementia. Eur Neurol 74: 43-48. mental disorders. 5th Edition, American Psychiatric Association,
Arlington.
21. Postuma RB, Gagnon JF, Vendette M, Fantini ML, Massicotte-
Marquez J, et al. (2009) Quantifying the risk of neurodegenerative 31. Albert MS, Dekosky ST, Dickson D, Dubois B, Feldman HH, et
disease in idiopathic REM sleep behavior disorder. Neurology al. (2011) The diagnosis of mild cognitive impairment due to
72: 1296-1300. Alzheimer’s disease: recommendations from the National
Institute on Aging-Alzheimer’s Association workgroups on
22. Diem SJ, Blackwell TL, Stone KL, Yaffe K, Tranah G, et al. (2016) diagnostic guidelines for Alzheimer’s disease. Alzheimers
Measures of Sleep-Wake Patterns and Risk of Mild Cognitive Dement 7: 270-279.
Impairment or Dementia in Older Women. Am J Geriatr
Psychiatry 24: 248-258. 32. Morin CM (1993) Treatment manuals for practitioners.
Insomnia: psychological assessment and management. Guilford
23. Griffith HR, Hollander JA, Okonkwo O, Evanochko WT, Harrell LE, Press, USA.
et al. (2007) Executive function is associated with brain proton
33. Feingold A (2013) A Regression Framework for Effect Size
magnetic resonance spectroscopy in amnestic mild cognitive
Assessments in Longitudinal Modeling of Group Differences. Rev
impairment. J Clin Exp Neuropsychol 29: 599-609.
Gen Psychol 17: 111-121.
24. Alexopoulos GS, Meyers BS, Young RC, Kalayam B, Kakuma T, 34. Rosenthal R, Rosnow RL (1991) Essentials of behavioral
et al. (2000) Executive dysfunction and long-term outcomes of research: Methods and data analysis. 2nd edition, McGraw Hill,
geriatric depression. Arch Gen Psychiatry 57: 285-290. The University of Michigan, USA 692.
25. Mohlman J, Gorman JM (2005) The role of executive functioning 35. Hosmer DW, Lemeshow S (2004) Applied Logistic Regression. 2nd
in CBT: a pilot study with anxious older adults. Behav Res Ther Edition, John Wiley and Sons, New York, USA.
43: 447-465.
36. Cassidy-Eagle E, Siebern A, Unti L, Glassman J, O’Hara R (2017)
26. Miller MD, Reynolds CF 3rd (2006) Expanding the usefulness of Neuropsychological functioning in older adults with mild
Interpersonal Psychotherapy (IPT) for depressed elders with co- cognitive impairment and insomnia randomized to CBT-I or
morbid cognitive impairment. Int J Geriatr Psychiatry 22: 101-105. control group. Clin Gerontol 41: 136-144.
Citation: Cassidy-Eagle E, Siebern A, Unti L, Glassman J, O’Hara R (2018) Cognitive Behavioral Treatment for Insomnia in Older Adults
With Mild Cognitive Impairment in Independent Living Facilities: A Pilot Study. J Sleep Disord Med Care 1(1): dx.doi.org/10.16966/ 6
jsdmc.105