You are on page 1of 133

 



        
   
  
    !  
" 

The importance of Information Technology in Controlling the


Quality of the Auditing and the difficulties of using it from
opinion of auditors in Kuwaiti

# 

$%
&  '$ ! 
() 
400920134 : *

, -%
 $   

    


.$ ()   0/     12 


 *
($3  
3 - 

(3 ()4
2013/2012
‫ب‬
‫ج‬
‫د‬

‫ ‪
  -‬‬

‫          


   ‬
‫   !   ‬

‫‪.& #+, - &.  /"  # %‬‬


‫ ‪$  #  !   &' ()  
 * #‬‬

‫‪1*2 )3 %,    #   4' 5#, 6*    7. 8 #‬‬

‫‪  )#3 '! 9 #,2 #'


   !  " 9  
, ' 1‬‬

‫ ‪  #9 1  7


 9' 5#, 6*  : !;#"  ! 1)3  $‬‬

‫‪. 
 1" #  6 ! <, 7#.  5#
 ,  1    #‬‬

‫!‪  1' 1 * # 7"  5#, 6*    + 18    # #‬‬

‫ !   ‪.   9‬‬

‫‪"9" )3  5!8#  5  =#) )#'2 <#, #'


   !#" 9 #‬‬

‫ ‪= > ' > #.  ,  59 .#- = " <= 9 =#  . 5#, 6* 5!8#‬‬

‫*‪.6  #   #, #." =#9  5#, 6‬‬

‫   
‪ #+ ? ?+  ,    #‬‬


6
7

 +   7"@ # > 


 "@  # ' #, "    #  

. 1-3    #A! B

5#/      # 2 C! 7#  =##" "  7=#)  

.#* '  #+

5""   9 7# ' D#  ",  7B* D3 7-  7.,  

.D#"@ 58 ! <)#  % 59'

.<*  " ! 5#, 6* +, 8 +  #.A* 79!  

()  . * 5@  #  '  ,#"


!       

5#, 6* * #


 .

#'
     5" (
‫و‬

   8 
4) 9
 5#,   
% 5
# F3
G 5#, < #
 9   !
H* = *;
 7# I.'
+   5A#8
 # !2 5A#8
& 5"
 5/#" J
 5  ; 5/#" J
 
 $ 
 :(3 ()4
2 . 1K1
3 #.A, 5,  5 ! 2K1
4 5,  : * 3K1
5 5,  5* 4K1
6 5,  7#)' 5K1
7 5,   6K1
7 5,  7  7K1
8 5A ; 7#+@ 8K1
  
 & 7 :: ()4
11 & 0 :(3 ;
11 . 1K2
13 ?8 :
 2K2
15 ?8 : * 3K2
16 ?8 5* 4K2
‫ز‬

17 ?8 #  5K2
18 7#
 #- :
 6K2
20 7#
 5-  # ! 7K2
21 7#
 5-  @#  8K2
23 (AIS) 5", 5",# 7#
 - 9K2
26 7# #"  ; /! - ' ?8 10K2
28 7# #"  ; /! - ' ?8 53  ?#+ 11K2
30 5", 5",# 5- Q ?8 7 =  12K2
31 5  5"#8 +" )  +# 13K2
5",# 7#
 -  , +#   7#"+  +! 14K2
32
?8 5 <  5",
33 ?8 5 < 15K2
38   
:: ;
38 5"
 5/#" 7#,  16K2
48 5   5/#" 7#,  17K2
55 59"#, 7#,   5# 5,   # 18K2
 
   :; : ()4
57 5,  R.  1K3
57 5 
  5,  ( 2K3
58 5,  <  3K3
60 < 2 7#"> ?@ 4K3
61 5A#@; 5#
 5K3
61 7#
  7# #" ( %#, 6K3
62 5,  7 / 7K3
64 5,  G  8K3
 4  "  (  =>  :<  ()4
67 5,  5  JA#@ 1K4
‫ح‬

71 5,  7 / 3@ =#@; RA# 2K4


81 5,  7#)' #" RA# 3K4
5H  7#H"# ' ?3 (One way Anova) #2 #"  RA# 4K4
88
5' ^  
 #9' 5, 
 )  =>  :8" ()4
93 RA#  1K5
99 7#@ 2K5
<  >
101 5"
 5/#" ( 
107 5  ; 5/#" ( 
? >

110 ‫ ( ا  ارا‬1 ) ‫ ر‬


116 5,  5 #",   <#,2 =#, ( 2 ) 8 ?
117 # !  $ () *  >)7 (  =>  ( 3 ) * 
‫ط‬

(
 >

4) (
 ! $ (
 *
58  5#@  <,  5  7# #", C (1K3) 
60 /     ?#, 7#"> #
 58 (2K3) 
67 5' ^  
 %, 5,  5  (  ( 1 K4) 
7# 9 ) 5#
 7#'    5"#, 7#+, ( 2 K4) 
71
(5",#
5
 <" ) 5#
 7#'    5"#, 7#+, ( 3 K4) 
73
(5
 
+ ) 5#
 7#'    5"#, 7#+, ( 4 K4) 
75
(7 #.
5 ) 5#
 7#'    5"#, 7#+, ( 5 K4) 
76
(++
7 = ; ) 5#
 7#'    5"#, 7#+, ( 6 K4) 
78
(5
=  5#' ) 5#
 7#'    5"#, 7#+, ( 7 K4) 
79
(?8 #
>B (Multiple Regression) 
    #" RA# ( 8 K4) 
81
?8 < +") ' 7#
 # 
>B ( Simple Regression) +,"    #" RA# (9 K4) 
82
?8 < +") ' 5",# 7# 9
>B ( Simple Regression) +,"    #" RA# (10 K4) 
84
?8 < +") ' 5
  5
 <"
>B ( Simple Regression) +,"    #" RA# (11 K4) 
85
?8 < +") ' 7 #. +
5  7#"# ' ?3 (One way Anova) #"  RA# (12 K4) 
87
I   _
 5, 
‫ي‬

5  7#"# ' ?3 (One way Anova) #"  RA# (13 K4) 
88

  _
 5, 
5  7#"# ' ?3 (One way Anova) #"  RA# (14 K4) 
89

 *`  _
 5, 
5  7#"# ' ?3 (One way Anova) #"  RA# (15 K4) 
90
<"  _
 5, 
5  7#"# ' ?3 (One way Anova) #"  RA# (16 K4) 
91
5 . 7 #.!  _
 5, 

(-3 >
4) (- ! $ (- *
64 5,  G (1K3)  !
23 7#
 #- @#
 ,#,2 G  (1K2)  !
‫ك‬

C"

 
"    

        

   
  
    !

+ F #" @' : 

<#
  5#,   :: !

< +") ' 7#


 #  5*  :
  5,  6* 7'*

?8 %#  ' #


 7#"#, 98 - 5.  #. , 7#8
 ?8

.7  5 ' 5 . 5 " #. D,  5@ 5#


5 #> 7# #" #* 7# #"   ( #


 b#" 4' :. * ?9

7! 5   #.
   5,  7# #" ( 5 #",  ,  52 7# #" 

 5,  6* 7 8 .5, #" 5! %#  ' 
 #98 (125)

.?8 < * ("# / ' 1* 7#


 #  * 9, /

5A#@ 5  >  1  :#.* RA#     5,  7@

' (7 #. + 5


  5
 <" 5",# 7# 9 ) 7#
 # 

5 ' 7#"#, 98 - 5.  5  ?8 %#  _ ?8 < +")

.7 
‫ل‬

Abstract

The importance of Information Technology in Controlling the


Quality of the Auditing and the difficulties of using it from
opinion of auditors in Kuwaiti

Prepared by: Faisal Debian Awad Al-Mutairi


Supervision of Dr.: Osama Omar Jaara

This study aimed to identify the importance of Information


Technology in controlling the quality of the auditing and the
difficulties of using it from opinion of auditors in Kuwaiti.
A sample study consisted of (125) auditors working in the
covered-by-the-present study offices. This study relied on
information technology as independent variable and its importance
in quality of the audit as dependent variable.
The study concluded the number of results: the impact of
Information Technology (computerize techniques, Scientific and
practical experience, and Skills development) in controlling the
quality of the auditing and the difficulties of using it from opinion
of auditors in Kuwaiti.
(3 ()4

 
 $ 


. 1K1

#.A, 5,  5 ! 2K1

5,  : * 3K1

5,  5* 4K1

5,  7#)' 5K1

5,   6K1

5,  7  7K1

5A ; 7#+@ 8K1


2

(3 ()4

 
 $ 



 1D1

6H* 1H> #H 7#


 #  ' 
 A#* + -  #
 ("# 

#H  6* 9 b 5",# 7#


 - 5A" ' 5* 7 /  # 

5",# 7#
  7# #"    <8  5/#" 5* 7  7  5A#* 7# # 

#H ' +  5'#);#" 5# 58 59A#' 5," 5",# 7# #" /!  <8

7   #,H8 ( +" 5  7# "!     b 5#  5  7# "!

.(Tucker, 2001) 5 ! C'

H =H  5# : +2#" 5 ! +" 5# 7# "!  

#H  H H 5 !H #H." 9 8  7#  5'#);#" *^ 5 

#H.-  H+ H' #.# (" 7# ! "$8  #  6*  ,  7#


6H* H @   ?#3 ;     * .- 5,'#  <  ?9 5 

.# 

5H 7#"#,H ?8 5 .   #


8  7#
 #  7)' # * 

?8 5 . 5"  <)  _ # #  6*  5 ! 7#
 5+!  #

H H
 5>, %#,B" 59 ."#, / 5* + * 98  7#"#,
3

5H#
' <=#H3 " ?8 5 3  59 5 %#,2  5> 5  %#,2

.(2009 6@) 5   <" -  ?8 R "  , &  5>2 

 ?"+ 5" :1" @9' ?8 5 ' 7#


 #   , 5", #" #

?H> 5"#8  ++ ' ?8 <#, 7#


 #   ,#" 5- 2  C

#H.   #H.#


 7#H
 ( 5   A#," #. B" :
 # ."?8 #

.(2003 7#"  ) #*! 

7#H, 8 5   5",# -  4' < ?8 5#   7 # #

5H #" GH H 1   52 ( )' #. <   1" ?8

5H H' 7#H


 #   , 5#
' _ 5, " #* " 9' & 5",# 

.(2003 7#"  ) ?8 # ' ?8 <#, ?8

 >  
- 2D1

#H   5'#  <#3, ' 7#"#, ?8 <8  ' 5,  5 ! >

H' ?8 5 3  5",# 7#


 - + ' #. ,  <+ 7#


.?8H 5H 5#'  ", >B  &    # 7#


 #  5A" -

:5d 7`#,  5"#;   5,  6*  F/ ?9  

5H  ?8 %#  _ ?8 < +") ' 7#


 #  > # :(3 ( F

5H3 5AH, `#, *  ?>" 8 e7  5 ' 7#"#, 98 - 5. 

:5
4

%H#  _H ?8 < +") ' 5",# 7# 9 > # :(3 $4 ( F

e7  5 ' 7#"#, 98 - 5.  5  ?8

_H ?8H <H +") ' 5


  5
 <" > # :: $4 ( F

e7  5 ' 7#"#, 98 - 5.  5  ?8 %# 

%H#  _H ?8 < +") ' 7 #. + > # :; : $4 ( F

e7  5 ' 7#"#, 98 - 5.  5  ?8

H' 7#
 #   5* ' 5A#@ 5 7  ?'  * :: ( F

 
 _
 7#"#, 98 - 5.  5  ?8 %#  _ ?8 < +")

e(5 . 7 #.! <"  


 *` 
 I  ) 98 =`. 5' ^

 
,
 3D1

:5# : *2 ?9  5,  6* 


,

7#H8
 5H'
 &  ?8 < +") ' 7#
 #  5*  :
 K1

.7  5 ' 7#"#, 98 - 5.  & #. ,

?8  ?8 < 6#  1* 1' * ?8#" 5+" *#3 *  :
 K2

#H " 5H+" *#H3 H* 5'


  5'#) 7# #"  ; /! - '

.7#


98 - 5.  7#


 #  5A" - ' ?8 < 9  5,  K3

.7  5 ' 7#"#,


5

?8H %H#  _H ?8 5


" #9  <#,  
 ' _  :
 K4

.5 

.5,  #. 7@  RA#  =) ' 5A 7#@ () K5

 
  4D1

H H  5> 5",# 7#)  #  #.   5,  6* 5* (" 

?
  5",#   ' < 5'#)  ! # b#"   %, #.  b" ?",

5H H' 5H#


 ?8H %#  ' ?8 < +") ' =#  7# 9  , 5 # 4"

.7 

 #H 7#"#,H ?8H 1H"


   5 5* 5,  6* %,  #

#H.   ! 6,B" #


     5# fA#)3  5# 7 #.  5,, 
" 5@#"


 5) 7"@  7#
 #   , 5*   ` #*>B  #


RA# #" 5,  6* 4'  g-  & #*'  ?8 5 < .  +# 

%H#  7#
 #  ,  7h!   
     #. 7@ 

'  -  & 5"#8 %  ' <! 9 ' = , 7h!  # ?8  ?8

#)H 5,  , # 7h!  &  <#@ 5# 7# #" J' * d % #

..h!  7#  : !;  5"#8 7#. 598 5# 7# #" ,

5#@H8 5H  5H H3  ' "  %


 ?8 %#   :
 

#H   ,4" 59


 7## !; 5#
  #' ##" 7  5 ' 5# 

#"H, >`H :, 7h!  #B" 59


 ?8 5 < +") ' #*> 7#

6

7#H : ' 


 _ 7##+8 1 !" .,     + #@8 

7#,H,` (H # 7# ! +3  7# ! 5


 7#,,`  5# & "#

#H. H   ?8 %#  98  ?8 C#+9" . ( &  #
 C#+9

.5,  6* RA#  3,  #)

 
  5D1

:5d 7#)3  5,  6*  ,

#H  ( 0.05 ) 5H _,H H  5A#@ 5  >   :. 3  4

7#"#,H 98 - 5.  5  ?8 %#  _ ?8 < +") ' 7#


:5 7#3 5)3 6*  ?>" 8 .7  5 '

( 0.05 ) 5H _,   5A#@ 5  >   :. 3  $4  4

H- 5.  5  ?8 %#  _ ?8 < +") ' 5",# 7# 9

.7  5 ' 7#"#, 98

( 0.05 ) 5H _,   5A#@ 5  >   : :  $4  4

5H. H 5  ?8 %#  _ ?8 < +") ' 5
  5
 <"

.7  5 ' 7#"#, 98 -

( 0.05 ) 5H _,   5A#@ 5  >   :: :  $4  4

H- 5H.  5  ?8 %#  _ ?8 < +") ' 7 #. +

.7  5 ' 7#"#, 98


7

H' 7#
 #   5* ' 5A#@ 5 7  ?'   : :  4

 
 _
 7#"#, 98 - 5.  5  ?8 %#  _ ?8 < +")

.(5 . 7 #.! <"  


 *` 
 I  ) 98 =`. 5' ^

 


 6D1

.7  5 ' ?8 %#   7@8 :5 #   K1

.!  2012 #, " # 5


8  <3  5,  6* =   :5 #   K2

.2012 %i

5H H' ?8 %#  ' #


 7#"#, 98  5  #  :5!"  K3

.?8 #B" 5'#  5'


 . ' .  7 

7#H
 #H  5H* H :
  5,  6* 7@8 :5
  K4

?8 < ' (7 #. + 5


  5
 <" 5",# 7# 9 ) #
"B" 5> 

.(?8 # =  < 5 7 =  ++ 5)H" 5> 

<  H 5H 
  H' 7#H"#   5,  6* RA#  :5)  K5

.F/ . <


 5, 

 


 7D1

:5,  3  ' b#" 7.   7  " 

5H ' ?8 %#  ' #


 7#"#, 98 )  <  b#"  K1

.%#  6* ' #


 ^ 98 59" !  7 
8

5H ' ?8 %#  ( <#  #'#) . #8 7"+  5  5,  5
"+ K2

# .# " #9 =# > ' 


 >"    # # 7# #", (  7 

.. <  >  <#  <#; b#" +)

7#Hd  7#H 9#" 5H,  5H  .!  F


" _ <"  5'
 5 K3

.?8 < J' ' 5, 7# 9 '  7#


 #  ?"+ ' 5,

5AH,2  5"#;#" 5,  5  ' 5! 7#A3 1"  b#" ( #
 _ K4

.5 #", ' 5+

 > 7 ) 8D1

:  # 5,  ' 5, 7#+@ 5A ; #


 " b#" #8

'H   %,# 7# "! < .  ,  9  * :    D

5H- 2#" 
  :. .' ' #, #.' < B #. ,  ?8 5"+ 7#


5H"  <) 5> #  #." 


  5A" .'  5'#) 5` 5",#

.( 6J 2008  "  ) #  6* ( #


  <9 5> 7#'#! 

5"H,# 7#H
 #H-  , #  #  52 9 ( 5 : 
D

, #.' * ?9 #.# #" 5,  ?9  5 ! @ 5# ' ., #.#9"+

H 5H 
" j"
 5 ! #*@  5# 7# #" #"  B  
 @ <=#3 " #* 

.(109J 2008  )#9 ) 59  #.#9' # #*  #.# 5

5# 7  ' ?8 `  5",# 5 !  1 D@ %,# * :


  #9 ",# . &,  8   5  #8 +! #9' 5# ^ 7  
9

59H,  5H #2 : H* H 9  k#H" 6* ",#  #  #@

Arens ) .5H 9 #H


  . &,  5,  5 . 5#
  <=#3   5) 

.(,et..al .2005.p:15

5H# 7#H #"  < ;  B" ?


 5  @ 5-  5 * : 



#H
 < ; 7  B 59"#+ _  ?9   5) <@" 52 6* 9

.(2003 7#"  ) 58


 7  : +Q RA#  :@ 5)
10

: ()4

  
 & 7

& 0 :(3 ;


. 1K2
?8 :
 2K2
?8 : * 3K2
?8 5* 4K2
?8 #  5K2
7#
 #- :
 6K2
7#
 5-  # ! 7K2
7#
 5-  @#  8K2
(AIS) 5", 5",# 7#
 - 9K2
7# #"  ; /! - ' ?8 10K2
7# #"  ; /! - ' ?8 53  ?#+ 11K2
5", 5",# 5- Q ?8 7 =  12K2
5  5"#8 +" )  +# 13K2
5"H,# 7#H
 H-  H, +#   7#"+  +! 14K2
?8 5 <  5",
?8 5 < 15K2

  
:: ;
5"
 5/#" 7#,  16K2
5   5/#" 7#,  17K2
59"#, 7#,   5# 5,   # 18K2
11

: ()4

  
 & 7

#    5,  C)" ?


 -  #+;  #' b#" F
,

7#,  F >  ?8 < +") ' 7#
 #  ?8# < #

:  #  59"#, # #. ' #    59"#,

& 0 :(3 ;


 1D2

 ?9 F/ < ; #.,  ?+  A#, *  # ?8 j




7#H
#" < ; H  .' 5  5"#8 7#9 _ * 5  5"#8 5#'

.(103J 2008  )#9 ) <,

& 5
 6*
 #.   5"#8 5 ' #.  ?8 53- `

58 @ <# " #. 3   5+! 2   98 9  5=#,  <9 <# "

 . #   ; #,3 +# 9 7# ! ' #


 3- &, , 5 


 * #+ ) 5"8  7#i  5. 5i 


 #    ?8  
 

7# :#!  (  5# #9 5*  58 #)" @ #' J#  !" 5"#8

.(Archambeault, 2002, p: 8)    l/

.5"#8 5 ' # ?8 53- 5*B" 5-   5 . 7#A. 7' 8

:#!H  (  ' ?8 5`, 5*  Cadbury committee "# 5  7  

59,H # ?8 53-    % #.' *2 53- 6* ?9 .   l/
12

5H3- 6H* 59, 59  1 #' ##" #." J# (!   ,   !" - 

   &  :#) .< ;  I !#"  !" ?8 5   #*#9 (' # 

H @H   ?8 & (   <#8   #  ?8 5  5#'   

7#,#,H 5  5  5"#8 #- 59 > 5 !#" 5@# ##)8  5. 7#


.(Cohen, 2004, p:33) 5, 5",#

7  5 #   1> # - <2 <3 ' " #*#" ?8 5 . 7- 8

1 I
   # 7#"#, ?8  <#@ 5# #9  A 9#" ?> +#"

' #. #    5 ! 99 # ()  5# A 9 5, 5@ '

' #. #  b l/  % 7#    5# 7# #" 58   B

.(2007 #@8 ) 59 7  , ' 5  <9  # 5 ! " 7 `"  = 

5# 7# 2   5 59>  9' 5  <2 7  , ' ?8 5 . 7.  8

>,  
 `#,  _   !#"  #
   _,  5#@8 

7# !  >  #.  I' 5 ) ."#@   #


   *#, 

 59+  7# ! & J@"    7 #! 98 =#+  %",  & " 

.(2011 + ) #.#


 5# 7# #" 58 # 98

C H  ( 5#
' 5= _ 9" 9 5  5"#8 5 1 B" ?8 :@

1H 5-  ' #


 < ; 5# #  5 + B!  5-  ' _2 5"#8

"  C#"! 


, ' >  5,A #.3A#- #  ' 1" 
, 5  5"#8 < B

<#,  :. ?8#' .#. 4" 9  5-  ' 58
  7##    8
13

9     & #.=#3  #.# #" =#3; 2 #.#, ( ' < ;

.(89J 2008   ) 7# 8  7#,   7 #!, 

1H :)   5",# 7#


 #@ #- 
  :.  ?8 

5H H> ?8   5",# 7#


 , ?8 " 5 #> #@ 5

5H  5H, H ?9 :." & =#3,  9 7#
  5 J'

7#H# IH
 H  5H) #
  +" )  5 #9' 5# 7# #"

.#,H 5H
 : +2   * #@ <) ( 5# 7# #" & ,

#H*' #H.  7#H


 6* < _  A#.   9  :8    

H' 5"H,#  5#@8 7  9 # :." 5# 7# #" &  # _ 

.(2007  #@8) %,#  78

 
,  2D2

5H3- 6* #.`  7# + 7"  5+  " ?8 .3  9

5H#. H' .1H H   #.#" " #9 7#-  ' #
 < ; #, 5. < B

.#. 5-  5 6 


 " +9' < ; 5 53- 6* :* ?m"  7# 
",

(+)H (H,  H.3  f"@ ?8 59  53- 6*  _
 8

Operational ) /! ?8 & (Comprehensive Audit) #! ?8 7#."

H.3 "  5-  #." 9  5+! 2  7#


 5'#  1!   (Auditing

<>  9 @ 5"  5> 7 + ##, >   !" <2 7  , ' ?8

.(45J 2008  )#9 ) 5#



14

"(," #*#
 Audire 5  5   59! * Audit
j -3 6#
" ?8 

7  , J' 5


' . 6#
" ?8 # ?8   7 # 7#"#, 2

'  = " 7#


 5@  ?9 # ##9 # ' #@' 5 ! 7, #'

5
) 5  5"#8 #- 5 # <8  & ' 
 <B!  5# #9 5 

.(2005

7#H #" JH3 A#H, (  ,   J3 1 B" ?8 :
  

#H9 5 #9 58 ?A#>  #'  ,   #.  5#  7# #"  #-  5

 5- 2 C   F
" +9' 
 "9   8 J3 * B" 9   * #-  5A#. 

H <#" " 1 B" ?8 .)


" : .#. 5
"+ %, & #.' 7# #" 5 #9 .,

7#'@H" 5H@# 7  B" ?


 K )  !" K 7#"> 5 9 ( 5-  5

<H9 #H
  7  B & " ?"#+    B ' :." 5#@8 b 

.(18J 2002  3+ ) 


 ,  RA#  & n"

#' J3 :#* ,#, 3- ) ?8   (2006 5 #+ ) !

# * ?8 5  ?o8 #. @  7#


 #@ 7  ,  7, 

5
 5'#) 59   b 7#"#, ?8 9 ' 
 > ?8 A#.  R #" ,

 7#
 5  < 9  8 #  7#
 , <#, ' ?8

.?8 9 #. )

FH
" H' ,H  !" 9  7#
  ?9 * ?8  b#" _

*#H"#" *#,  #" 5 ! @2 5# @  '   & #2
15

H  # B!"  = "  ?8   * 5# 7# #" ?8 :*  # .   

5H# #9  ; ?"+ #+ %, 5*    (  5# 7# #"  

5H  #  5 


" > 5# 7# #"    B 5 * 5# 7# #" ?8

.59  7#9'  #2

 
,
 3D2

: *2  
 &# *   (234J 2007  )  (214J 2000 l* ) !

: * ?8 #.99 

J3" 59
 #9   .#`, = ' 5 ; 7#, ( <#, K1

7 />  :
) +#9  5# '   
"
8   !" .# RA# 

.C#)2 6* f@ 5#


 7#@ 9 <#
 3' 5 


9 ?+  #.' * ?9  5-  <#, #.# , 5-  58 5'#) K2

+") 5i ?8 ?#+ ! 1 =# " 1  5"#8  + <  7# ,

3  ' = 2 _, 9 1  9 5"#8 #- 5#


' <=#3 , 9

.7#`,

7# #"  7#
 58 #"  5-  ' 5# 2 , 5, 5@   B K3

.7#
  5- 2   9 #.9"#+ _ 9 7,  #' ' 5"> 5#


 5- 2   9 #9' 58" 3  5# #>d 7  5 ; 7  9    B K4

.#."
16

=,  5-  7  5#  5'#. 7 = ; 5


"# 5 ; 7  9 ?8 K5

.C#)  :  #


,

"8  ?"+ 5 5#, 7  9  7#


  5- 2   9 5'#    B K6

.5-  ' #


 (

 # 5"#8 _  5-  ' 5  5"#8 #- 5#
' <=#3  K7

.7#


   @2 6*   ?9  ( 7#  ) @2 5# A#, 5


  K8

.5) 7 = ;  7#,#,#"

.#  l/ :#!  (  + +   7##/  : *2  @ K9

#' < : *2 ( ,  RA#  7 #  #'  B R "  7#


 5
  K10

.#. ++ * #  #*3   8 R "  7#


 7 # 

 
  4D2

:5# 2 F
" ' ?8 5* #  

98 9 . 5  5"#8  7#


 #. @ "
 ?8 #9  K1

.( Schneider, 2010 ).?8 #*@  5 , #9 5


 " #

<  ' ##* ##.,     5  5"#8 7# +# <  , 5"8  K2

 +# 6* >` .( Sarens 2009) ?8 53- < 1 ?+ # * 7# !

#", >` 8 :- 5  5# b B" 59


 +# 6*   8 5 ! : *

(2006 7  ) :5# :- /" /  +# B!  9' 5 ! <8 
17

.#2 5A" ' 7 / K

.5
  < 7#
 5-  K%

.5 ! 5 * <#.(< 7# 9 ) (,   KG

.5 . 7#A*  < 5",# 7  @ K

.7# ! 1   5 , +#  K3

 
 I 5D2

:  # ?8 #  *    (2006 5 #+) !

' 3- "8  b      %  =#+2 :#! #" ?8 9 K1

.5 !

.598 #.#"#, 7 #  5.," :,  F9  @  <B!    K2

.#.#"#, ?8" #.#8   D)" 5.," 5 !   5")    K3

 8 7#"#, 7,  5# ' 5.," #.A ! >    5 ! ("   K4

.#.98

2  #


  5 ! " : =! 5# ' 598 7#"#, #, K5

.%  

1 4' (#*^ 7# #)3 ? ) 5


"+ b   5 A#, 5 ! F
 5# ' K6

.5 ! ' #.98  7#"#,    7#)


  B 5 !  .,

#9' 7,  #'#" -#3#" 5 !   _    5, )' * ?8 K7

.5 ! 5 ' #." 


 7#
!   9  5 5",# #

18

(+, 7#"#, ?8"  ,#" 9  ?8 7 "  3,  <B!    K8

 ;  ",# #-  ' :


) +    J #' <!  f@  9

.<B! 

73#  7  # 5 !   ` ##- 1  " # ?8 <  * >

2 %8   I# #. B ##" (5# 5",# *#3 #+; ) 5",# ,

8- 1 B" d  " 1  #.


  (+,  1   7#3# 5  no" %> 

 
 .
 I# ." d 59> 4' ##" 7#3# 5 %#   .

7#
 &  5 " 7  9 
 # J@ .  !" #."8   7#


.(129J 2009 #>) 5


# 7  8

 * ,  6D2

# 5
 5",#  7#
#" < ;   ,#,2 @ 7#
 #- j


-   !" #.)


" ( 5+"  7#       5 * 7#
 #-   9

 7#
 #@   5#
  @#" f, <3 5
 G#   

5  :A#- =  ' .#,   %,#  78 ' A  !#" ,

.( 19J 2008 ,#8 ) .

7#  #8  ! '   8 5-  ^ ?A#9 5" #.   7# #" :




" #."9,H H &H, H >`H  99 


 #. I  #. " 58   

(41J 2010 #+, )


19

7#H #" " > 7#


  * 7#
 5-  5  7#
 :
 &# *

 , ' 5  58 # #.  #."9, 3 #


3 >   ! ' f"@ #*   

.(78J 2006 , ) " #*#   7  9 '  (8  #

#.)H
" ( #3 7 = ;  7# #"   '2  5 7#
 5-  >

:H
  H9 ( @ 7#   7#
 9 7# #" 5#
 5-  59+" #)
"

7#H #" H 8 7#"  7 = ;  7 .   '2 5" #.   &

"3, #.>" >  #.#


 #.   7#
 (  #i  #  #   # 


.(34J 2008 5 , )

H H' .,H #.  #2 7#-  5,A    7#


 - j


 H =H
  A#H"  5)H (,  7# 9 7#  7

5H* 7 8 + (+, *   > 2 "    #.
  2 

Matta, et al, ) #.,H3 5# @ ' 7#-  ' <'  ^ 5,'#  7  5-  +


.(2005, p:934

?A#>  7 = ;  7 . "  <#" #.   7#


 5-  .)
" :


+H+ 5H H' #. H, 7# #"   R#


 J (  7#@ 

.(19J 2010 x#j"   #, )"_2 7#


  <+,  7#"#,  5  

 '2 ) = 2  5    7#


 5-   b#" _

 ?,#   !" #
 
  5#3  5+"  (7#
  7 = ;  7 . 

7# F ( 5#


   () 5-  7#
  5 
20

RA#    4" (7#++ 7#, # ! #9 ) 7#


 53 # !2#" RA#  

++  .  .# ., .  8   59+" #-  *  3,

.5-  7#+#!  5"#8 

  (- 7D2

9 #."#
, 5 #.   *#3  7#
 5-  # ! :

5-  5 7#


 5-  5> 7#
 5-   #.,9     

.5#! 7#
 5-  5#  7#


 
  5- 2 * :( )    7  :
   D1

(Electronic Data Processing) 7# #" 5  ; 5#


  5",# < .2

*  .5# @ #82 7  ; :#. > 59 _2 5d A#,  5'#);#"

5#
 G ;  #; 7# ' 5  ; < .2  
  7#
 5- 

.(Laudon & Laudon, 2002, p:79) 5  ; 7##


  ,#" #.# #"

A#,  ,#,  !" 


  7#
 5-  * : 
  D2


" 7#
 (  5#
 ( ' 59 7 2  7d F
" 58 5

   !" G  5#


 #  #.# (   5- 2 * i

.(Ball, 2003, p: 677) 5  <    ,

- =# " 1    7#


 5- 2 b .3 * :    D3

  H   #H3 3  R " 7 = ;  : *2 " #   ?,  ` 5# 

5H-  H'   #-  >      ?"+ 


    5  ' ?# 
21

#H.#
 7#H #" (H 5    %  * 5#  7#
 -  5#/  

59,H 7#
 -  !  
 "' <9 <#  :#  F3  ` # #.
 

Denisi & ) 5!H"  H  +  b" <  7#   5# < ;   

(Griffin, 2010, p:97

' 5- 2  <" 5 ?"+  7#


 5-  * :5#! 7#
 5-  K4

7 H < 7#


  ,    %  7#-  <  <  5-    78 I3

#@H ! #.  # .#." <>B  #.' <>` 7 / 5'#  5#!   .#-  '

#H-  H! H 5@   < # F ^2 <


 7#
 R  5  7#


5H  5H ;  5!H"  5H 3 7#H"+ ( #. '  5' 5-  ,A

.(Laudon, & Laudon, 2002, p:80)

  )$ 8D2

  
 ., <
 :A#-" 9 5,A =   7#
 #-  

5#
 7  (Input Devices) #; 7  : * 7  6* 7#- 

Main ) 5 #>  5,A   7  (The Central Processing Unit) 5 

< . (Output Devices) 7# 7  (and Secondary Storage Devices

Williams & Sawyer, ) : * 7  6* (Communications Devices) 7#@

(2003, p: 125-126

#-  #.#;    !  #. 7# #" +#9  


 :("
7 
 D1

> #." %,#  7# #" 5'# # #.    * 7  6* .%,#
22

(Disk Drivers) J 82 7/! (Mouse) <#3  (Key Board) f#3 5

._2 #; < .  #*^

7  7#
  #. # 7# #" 5#
  
 :I   
 D2

( " ?,   %,# #- ' _2 = 2 8#"  5"#8 5
" 9 # <A#'

7 # =y , %,# 7# 5'# /!" <3  9 7  6* .1'   7#


(8  * 7, ?+   %#, <    59+   5"#, 7#




.(Control Unit)   < 5 #>  5,A -3

78`   5


" 5,A   < 9 : :   > ! I" 
 D3

7# #"   5
" 9 5 #>   < . # .5#
 5  7#
  7# #"

.5#
 5 =# > 
,   R " 

#-  5#  5  ; 7# #"   G ; 7  


 :J "7 
 D4

G 4" f, 7  6* .%,# A#.  , .3  !" #.) %,#

5!#! > 5,  5A  5"  #9  !  #.9 %,#  7# #"

.7##, 5
"#+

5#
 < " 7#@ 5"8   7#@ < . #, :0) 0 I  D5

,#,2 G  (1K2) 8  ! " .,  G ;  #; < . 5 

.7#
 - @#

23

(1D2) * (-

 * ) 3 J2

! I" 

" +  "

5#

#; 7  G ; 7 
Processing
Input Output

  

!  < 5
#      * (2010)   * :
)

.@ :5 ,;

(AIS)     * 9D2

  5#


 /! ' #.  5", 5",# 7#
 - %


A#, %,    5-  f#@ 5# 7#


  7# #" J,  9 

/!" 5",# 7#


 5-  9 .7 
  #*^ +" 7# "! #@

7 8 .7#


 6* 7#  3,  , #.9 7# #"

, 7## 5" #" - " 5",# 7#


 5-  ' 5@# 7 +

.(30J 2011  
 )
24

7#    , 5"#9  5   5",# 7#


 5-  1" ( # - 

 7# 5.   #2 7#-  J 


 F ^2 <
 7#9"+

 >  5- 2 6* 7^ 9' .A#.  ,  3, "8  #. F


.(24J 2009 " ) 5",#  5 ; *#3

 #. ' #,#, # # 9 5#   #.  59 #


  -
 
 #

 5@#  5  < .2 -


 ' -  6* #; 
, 5",# 7#
 -

7#
#" _2 : +2  < ;  ; 5  7#"+  < 5",# -  

.(56J 2005 ,) 7#


 ##- 6#"#" 7  9 #  #2  5"+

# ' <3 7#


 9 ' 5"# <@" 5",# 7#
 #- .,

 #.# 5-    7#.  ' ?+  7  9 #  5"#8  ++

* %,#  78 ' 9 5A 598    /"  < #*A ' 7#
 ?9

5  ; 7#",# 7#-  ,  7#


 5",#  5 9 b B" 2 <)


##" * 7# #" &   /! ' 58 5,  6' # & #.# #" /! '

.(121J 2008  
 ) 7  9 # 5 ' > >

# ("#+ 7  7#


 5
"+ #" <   )# ' ",# #-  # 8

#. :#
 5",#  9 #9' #' 7#
 6* , 7# ! #.,# 

7#
 ' , <  1  % #  "9,  )# ' 1 -  f"@  

C  : # %+ I#,2 ' 5  5",# 7#


 G# ; #- 1  
25

 
 ) 5#
' 5"#8 ?9  #*" #, 5 5
"# #9   ' #, 7  9

.(31J 2011

5H# 7H   i  !" #.# #" 1#


 5i 5-    7#,,` G#

BH"  H#"   7## & ?9 ", 5'# #. ' <
 7   ,

:(67J 2001 #  @ ) * 5,A =     5  ; -  (

.7#
  7# #" K1

.
 +! 7 =  K2

.7# #" 5#


 + R# " K3

-   R "  7# "!  5,A  5@! 7#",# ) #  5 5 " K4

#./!H #. ; ,  7#,  5- 2 6* G# # .(#* 

.#."8 

=  5>>    #." J# #- " 5  _2 


  #*/ 5",##'

7 = H 7#H,#, <H 1  i #- B  .7#  5#


  7 :5,A

+ (' 1  #-  5",  -  F/" # %", 2 #* #   5#@

7H. #@ A#, 7#


 #  # ' A#. + ( #  !" 


+ * "  7. 


  #*/ 5",#  + * 5"   
 5'#

H ",# #- # #   f"@ 8 + *  <#' 
 >   7 # "

.(142J 2006 , ) 5+,  <"  7#-  ' 5@#


26

< H. H 5H> #   


 5", 5",# 7#
 #- 

 H,
 1   7#
 -3  5-    7#
 5", ' %,#

7# !H  7#H-  H' 7#


 5-  ( #
  7#
 #; %,# < .

<#,H" #. #.-3 7# #"  @  7# ! 6*     53

.(Dalci & Tanıs, 2009, p:89)%,# < .

#H-  H"9  5",# .3  1 =  , 5  ; -   C  *

7#H
  H!  7#   5# 7#  5# 5#@8  5# 7# #"

5# 7#
 5'# .3  5  ; 5",# 7#
 - @  
  5#

H >   5   5  ; 5",# 7#


 -   8 #." 59
 7 = ; 

.5@ 53-  5A  R#


 #-    B"    #-

,H  
 5",# 7#
 - @" #*   #"  

#H H <9 <#  #-  ' 7 = ; <=#3 , 53  9 7# 5

_ 5,,` " -   . #" -  5'


 #" <#  
  7  9

>`H #H 5H  ; 5",# 7#


 - @  ,#,  !" >`  2

H <' 7#


 #  5 5 " _, #. , 5,,`  59+

.(152J 2007  * ) -  & @

    7 ( M- (   
10D2

?8  7#


 5# @ "  #  ' 5
, 7 + 7)' 9

<H) 1" 5+ 7 /  1-  6 3 59+ 


 <) #. "  7#
27

H' #H* / b 2 * .,2  1A  + 7 / &  <#3,

.(106J 2006 


@ ) : #    ?8 5. 

7#H,#,B" # #; %  ( 


 *B ) ?8 5'
 5'#9> ' / K1

7#H/" 5H#  5,   7#


 5# @ #  7# #"  ; /!

.<+ "  A#, R "

#-  @#   " =   #,  ?8 R# " 5+ ' -  <# K2

.#9  A 9  7  ,  #' > "  #.    ",#

bH" %#H, H"   <#3,  7#">; 5 5


"+ ' -  <# K3

.59 52  
 "  % #" #.     @ ' 7#


 H  5H"8    <#3,     +") - 5i ' -  <# K4

.7#
  7# #"   +") - 59 '  

5> 7 + ( =  #" ?8 #9 F   ?+ ' -  <# K5

A#,H H" =# >H,#" 5H"#8 H" ?"+ #


 < ; 5.   ' '

.5*

    7 ( M- (   
 4   11D2

 H  H 7#
  7# #"  ; /! - ' 1#* ?8 

(2009 5#^ ") :5d

5
"#  5"8  5 , 7  ?8 ' & > :?"
 .$   
D1

:#H
 5)  5 ! +! 5'#  #.A#3,  7  ,   7# #" %#,
28

H* H' ,H  A#,  7 = ;  5  fA   -  #9"+ #.

:#

.#.
  7# #" #.  `  7  , %" @K

.@#3  #; " 5 #9 K%

.#." J# ,   7# #" # ' 5,, #82 %,  , KG

.A, J!  5.  5  7# #" ?> K

:  #  ?8  :   . % "


  .$  
D2

5H  ; 7#",# ,9" 7# #"   ,8  59 7# #" 5@   B K

5H'
" #."#,  :, 2 7 #  
 >' 7  ,  #.
   

,  2 :! ' <  7# #" ?"#+  % 5# 6* 3' " 

.2

7# #" /!" #9   #.#" %+ 7#


  7#
 5@   B K%

.#.,  # A+  "  R " 5,  1  %+ *

R#H " H 73) 8 5  7# #" ' 7#'#);  7


    B KG

.&" 5 7#. 59'  


" "  '  

:N '$ (     ( M-  


"     =  .$  
D3

    R# "  =y # "  #.' 


 %
@ 1 B' "   7# #"  # 

7#H #"  H  B ?8   =#+ b  l/  % 5 #, 5@' &# *

:  #  ?8  5# 6* ' @Q 59"#+ "    5  7#
 
29

.R# " @ 5@ K

.  ; %,# =  5, K%

. ",# -   ( /!   ) 7#


   2 5, KG

R# "       A#,  K

."  R "  5  7


 5@ KH*

#H ?H+ H 5 ! #.,  "  R " #" ?8   K

#H9 5 %#,2  ,#" _ < #./! "   5" 7# #"

.# 7# "

' (    : 4   $    ! " .$  
D4

:  #  5 6*

7#H H 5
8   @ 5#     %  7#
 59"#+ K

.5
3

H' <  5H@ #H8 H  , 6^  %,# ,3    B K%

H H-
   7#
 & ,3 ' % ' "  7#

H ?"#H+ . 5' #9   B % "  # ' = " ,

H8 .#H 8   "  7#  <  7#


 5) 5# 

._ < 7# #" /!   7


30

   O  


 6 % 12D2

(2009 5#^ ") :  # ' 7# #"  ; /! 5# ' ?8 7 =  >

H #.
 " 5  7# #" 5@   B   :  7 # (  
D1

.5)  5,   B 5# 7#


 ?8 &  7  ,

=H) H'  H /!H 5@   B   :  7 # ("
 
D2

H  ; /!H H"  /! " 5 #9 ?+  &  
 R# "

.5 #9 =  i " R# "  ,#" 7# #" I3 /!  7# #"

%H,# 7#H #   H, ?8H (+,  :  7 # *


"   
D3

:  # #.  ?8 7# F
" 3  '  ;

.5"#, 7#
 5@  ?9 K

<#! <@2 G , K%

.J3    #.A#+; < #8  9     <@2  KG

.5 #,  5A+"  5  > <@2 F


"  K

H 5H# #H9  A 9   '  ; %,# 7# #   , KH*

.<@8 7 '

.7#
#" 5,
 5/ %,  <#3, K
31

 "
     " 13D2

5"#8 +" ) 9   1   (11K10J 2005  " l* ) !

H.3 98  % 5++ ?8 A 8 F3 :*   #'  !" 5 

:  # * +# 5"#8 5,A 5  5"#8 *#3

H^ @H 7# #"    #' ^ @ ) :(-  "      :0

J9 7#3
  D) J9 59, ^ 7# #" 5@ ^ 7#3
 7#8 =:

.(5",#  5  J9 7# #" 5@ 5,

7# #" <#9 5"#8 +" ) ) :  C"           : :

.(#   5 #2 7 #" 5`,  7# #" 5  7#">;    8 7#3 

H' !3 #'  =: ^ =  ) :(-    


$     " :: :

1H" D@ ^  5


 5 #2  5-'# ' !3   b 5"#8

.(("  5`, J9 <#


,  <9  7# #"

@ 7#"  @' ) :(-        


$  $     : 

7 #H" 7#H #" 5A# > {, 5"#8 7 = ; ' / 7#
   #2

5H# 6H* H' ?"+ (7# #" <#8 -  <# f@ b 2 > (" 5#

(11J 2005  " l*) :  #" > ?8 5 3 %#,2

.?8 7  7# #" <#8 <  #-  , K1

.7#" 5 9 %#,2 ?8 K2

.7# #" <#8 7 #   5


  K3
32

._ 5@  ?9 K4

.7# #" <#8 ?8 5/! 7 = ; 5


  K5

.<#
, 7 =  7# #" <#8 !' 7#++ 5
  K6

.5 #@  + R.  5
  K7

.5  5"#8 +" ) 5= 5


  K8

.#." 7 8 , 7## 7 #  #  K9

.-  + 5


"    ?"#+ J' K10

.5"  -  #
"    ?"#+ J' K11

.5"#8 %#,  <! 9 K12

.5"  -  #
 7#"+  K13

.5#! -  + 5 9 K14

.#. #@ -  + '   ?8 +#" _ 5,  K15

 N N * *


"  " !
    - 14D2

 
 $ 
 .$ 

 5# +! '  "  1  (2011   #9 ",# "
 ( ) ' 

:+# & 

#
 ' ##)9 +  5#  #2 5)8 j
 :Security    !3 D1

#  #"#" #* /"   5. 2  5# 7#


 B 
  5 "! 

D@ ^ 7#8   #-  @  J#" & #.#+#!  5 ! 5,#
33

^ @  5 i 7#


 6*    5# # 1 B!  #  "  #."

.3+ !

5#   
 *# #-     B#" & :Availability *  I D2

.5) 7#,#, #9'

:Processing Integrity ( M-  (?"  6 7 (  ? D3

D@ 598 7#


 ' ++ * # %,  /! 7 =     B#" &

.%,#  78 ' #."

7#
    B#" & :Online privacy - .$  ))" D4

<  #.
)  7#,#, ( !# 7#
 &  , &  #-  7#

.*^  =  #.


 #
 5@@ @  B 7h! 

5, 3   +! '   B   :Confidentiality   D5

.F/ . < 5 ; 7#,#, ( !# #" 7#




 #*^ 5# < ;  5 ! <  J  


" :Monitoring   D6

 =" 1 ,   (  #-  ?"+ 5 %8   #- #" 58
 7  7#.

.7# 5  


 @ 7# #" & /! 5"  7# #" # 5

 
 $ 
 15D2

Conformance to " 7#"+ ( 59"#+ _ #.   < 7'

@ 5 #2  5+! 2  = 2 5"8   7#-  


, b "Requirement

 !#" 7#'   :!  =#+2 9   & < 7#  5  
34

#-   = 2    ?8 <  , .< ; 7## 5"  ` 

<=#3   5#3  @ ?"+ ",# #-  5A _ &  5  5"#8

5# #.' * 5 F/ 5-  ) ,  !" 9  7#
 ' 5",# 

.(103J 2008  )#9 ) @2

+#H9 :#!  ?8 <8 " #.   ?8 < 7' 9' 5 . 5#  

?H9 5H #  #.    #.#


 7#@ 9    5"#8 #- ' :
)

" #H. B" ?8H < 7' 9' 5# 2 5#   # ."
 5 ! 5  5
3  @8

<H 7H' # ."?8 5." #9 =# > . &,  8  ?8 #
"  

 H H H B  ?8H #


 ?' !  = 2 ?9   B " #. B" ?8

#H9  5"+ #. ?9  9   5) < 7 = ;  7#,#,#"

.(40J 2010 I ) ?8 5


"

7 H B" 5H9


 * H"  52  @ 5-  5 7#"#, ?8 

H' ?8H 5   # 5) <@" 52 6* 9 5# 7# #"  < ;

H# H 3 1H  @   5-  7 + ?8  %+ #.  (

.(Bamber, 2007) 5 . <@"

.  H8 # ' # : + #. 


  #.  ?8 5 . "


"8  #. # 5 5# 7# #" ' 58> <# 4' & 5#>,  5#

H' 5H"+ 59> <# ' _@8 5* 7  "


   &  # ,

#. 6   %@   %   #!  %8  5. 7#


 '  ?8 9
35

?H+ H  H  ; " " #9 6* (      .(2003 7#"  )

5H d " H H  98H  (Web) % 7#3@ "  7#3 

.(Grand, 2001)#9 6* 5, )  5",# 

5# 7# #" ' 58> <#  <+ %#,  5#" ?8 5 7 # #

5 ' 5# 7 #. %+ # 5  7 + 5"   5#" "@ 98 #'

3 % ' > 7 #. 6*  (2006   ) ?8 5 ' #.3-  

'H  #) " 5   7# "! ' <#, 5 3 #,82 ' !" @


#H   H, H 98 % "


 &" (2004 598 ) 5",# 5- 2

H 2   #9 ",# ( @ # .7 + 6* 5"  #.  5",#

(2007 i #9, ) :5d 7 =#3 #" ?8 ( <)"

<H9 +   :
 #. <+ -  ?' +A   @  <9 K1

. 

.5" 7#/" 5# < K2

.#",# ?8 %#,B" # K3

5  5"#8 #.' #" 5#! 5  5"#8 #- " #;  .3 5'#  <"  7 #. K4

.%,# 

.(2003 5  + ) 5/! #.# #  #.3A#- #.#   %,# - " 5,#, 5'
 K5

#H 5,H #H. H "


 ?8 5
 5  5 3 7# '  #

H2 6H* 5' (...?> 5"#8 ++ ) ?8 5


 5"+ 5-  7#

36

98H H"8 H 598 5# 7# #" ' 58> <#  53   .  5, '

 7# ! * 5# 7# #" 6*  <3, _2 : +2   (2003 7#"  )

. H 7#H #" 6H* ( d #


  5   <,#,  # ?, ?8

 5, 5",# #  6' # * #>,  #  9 # ' 5,

.98  ?8 %#  "8

5H <) f"@   ?8 #-   ?8 #-   

_ %H,2 ' / *  7#


 #  @ 1 ?8 5 ." F. 

R H" 7 =  7   ,  +# 9 ' ?8  5


  %#, : 

 7# .- 8    ?8 5 # , ' 7#


 #  ' 5@@

2 #.)
" %,#  ?8 %,  #.)
"  b %, ?8 C  

53- 6* =     53 %#, #  R  # %,#  ,#" ?8  

7#H
 H 
 #."#^  b" %#,2 6* 7  %,#  78" 5., ,"

.(Kalaba ,2002) 5#


 < 7  5 

?8H 7H  ; 5 "! . , '       % 98 5", #"

5H  5  "  # . 7# #" = !  ("    #"  7#


&# * 
 * 7  ;  5  ; <#  5 "!  ?8 5 i 5A" ' _

.(Abo-Mosa, 2004) # 98  

<#H ( #
  + * 5"   #8     98  % #

(H  98 #, 8 <+ 5  ; %#,2  A#, 4' & 5  ;
37

9 5 <, 5"8  >#


  ,#" & 5 i ?8 %#,  ,#" 7#,

 @ 5# b      C#,  7#


  5"8  5

7,H <,H 5"8  4' 78  7 9 ' %,#  78 ' 5"+ 7#


 H ` 7#
  5# <#  # 78 ' * # <!     #.  <

7#H #" <H#8 =#!  .# #>   I , f"@ ?8 5-  <, 5"8 

 !  ?8   ( #` #9> ' 7# #" <#8 ' % ?8 {#

%H 98 ?  -


 4' &  5'#) <+# 7#  59
  #! (

.(Grand, 2001) ?8 78 . '  ,#" bm 7#3 ' #." -3 {,  

d ( (Web) %H 5H3@ " 7# #"     7#


 -  

' 78 +") <+# @  &  7#3 6. 5@@  5, #" 
"

#
, ' 98 1)9  78 ,   #- J@   7# F
"

&# * #2 6*   ?8 (#! ?8 R "  ' * 78 &  .", 

= 2 9  1 B!  * #9  J @#3 ' 78 +") 5  5i

.(Mark, 2001) .?8 5 5 ' %+ 78 9


38

  
:: ;

#  5# 5,  C) 7#   5" 2  5"


 59"#, 7#,  F  #'

: 

  M   


16D2


  !3       *  $ P
 (2003)  !9 5,  K1

.   7  (   : 

- ' 5",# 7#


 5-  1    #!  :
  5,  7'*

",# 7#
 #- " +" G +  7'* # 5  ; <#  ,

 C   +#" , R.  1>"   ' b#" (" 8 5  ; <# 

5,  7 5",# - #" 7*  7#,   b"  5" 2  5"
 ( 

.2 '

H <H+ 5 9 5  ; <#  :#.  7## ,  b#" @ 8

#.  J#  !" ?8  5",#  .  #  !" 5 . 7# (  7>

%H^2 ?H> %#H^ 5  ; <# 5, ^ 5


"+  .<' 5A" ' 


#H* ?8  5",#  . #.  ,A  ! # ' !#"  !" #*#, #.#

J@H 5Hi 5H  ; <#H 7#    ;#" :   ?9 5i

.5  ; <# 7# 7   7#


"  %A )

    .$  "


  
 8  : 
" (2004) #", 5,  K2

. 
3   -     
39

5*#, 7# ! ' 5  5"#8 5-  <8 I#8 5#  5,  6* 7'*

7# #" ( 5 #", 7, 7#


 #  7#"+ 5"   5 2 5#


5#@8 7##+9 :  #  #98 (135) 7/"  5,  5   5 

   ?8 A  #.   5# 5*#, 7# ! &# *   7@ 5 2

' 5  5"#8 #-  7#


 #  5A" >B &# *    98

7#"+ 5"   <8 7##+9 >  & " C#+8  5 2 5#
 5*#, 7# !

5*#, 7# ! #8 <)" b#" @ 7#


 #  5A" ' ?8 

 < 5A" 7#"+ 5"  (+,  ?8#" 5@# 7   =#! 4" 5 2 5#


.7#
 #  7   ,  #.# ' 


 *    


    : 
" (2005) !  5,  K3

.:
    *
"  (   

  #" - " #* 5* 5 9 5'


 .3   5,  6* 7'*

5'
  f) & 5#@8 7  ' 5> 7#
 7# 9 A#,  ,

-   A#9 <8 _ f)   5",# 7#


 - /! ' 5 9

 , - ' 5",# 7#


 -  5# 7#   /! ' 5",# 7#


#@#" 5 #
,   3@ R.   b"  8 .5> 7#
 7# 9

7# 9 5'
 <  5",# 7#
 - 5@# b" C)" 58
 7 

.? 
 ' 5,  7 7#

40

*B  5 " 5 9 5'


  ! :#.* RA#     5,  7@

A#,   A#9 5'#  5,#,2 7#"+  5  <"  
  


 5",# 7#


 -  ' 5#@8 7  ' 5> 7#
 7# 9

7#
   #-  ) 7#
 5, #- > 5",# 7#
 -  #"

5
 %#,Q 
 ?"+ 5 # 4" ?
 5 9 5'
  5#@8 <  '

.5",# 7#
 -  ' #.  5#@8 < # ' 5,

 $ .$     : 8  J2 6" : 


" (2005) %
 5,  K4

" 
3  : 0    Q "  

?8 5  7#


 #  > I#9 G +  5,  6* 7'*

#
 _,  5,  G  b 5 2 5#>,  5# & " #

?8 %#  _ 7#


 #  #
 _,  & " _ 7#
 # 

("# / # 5,  ' 9, / "  7#


 #  #
 _, >

@  ?9 5  5"#8 5-  9 ++ ) # ?8 5   .'

7# #"  5,  7 b (9  @ ?8 5 # 7#"> 5 

%#  ' 


  #98 (87)  #.
    5 #",;   7
 

 =   5 2 5#>,  5# & " ?8 5." 53  ?8 7# !

>   5,  7@ 7# #" ( 5 , 5A 5 #", (83)  A#@;

 !" 5 2 5#>,  5# & " # ?8 5  7#
 # 

 , <)" 7#


 #  C#, + - ' b#" @ +
41

=#9"| 7# ,  ++ () #) * ' =#9" 5#" 7# !  7#,,`

 7#
 #  ' 7 +  , # =)  ,  5 

. , #. ) #*  5-'#   

 "
  $ .$    * : : 
" (2006) <#)9 5,  K5

 
3   Q 

' 5  5"#8 5#'  ",# 7#


 #- > #"  5,  6* 7'*

5",# 5"#8 5#'  -  6* > #"   & 5 2 5# & "

5"#8 <A  ' #


  '2 ' 
 > 5,  ( #     +")  5 ; 

#.  52 7# #" ( < B 5 #", 7,  5 2 5# & " ' 5 

7#
 #-   5,  7@ 5A#@; %#,2   (SPSS)  ,#"

5"#8 g5# g598 7#


 '  
 b 5",# 5"#8 5#'  >` ",#

g5'@ #2  7#


 (  5# 5," 5 5
"# #9   g5 #9

## 1" 


 ",# #-  , + <)" b#" @ .@2 5#

 5"#8 5
#" 5
 : +2 5'# 7## " b" 5 2 5# & " '

.7#


N        >  C>)" : : 


" .(2007)  # +9 5,  K6

. 
3 ,)      
"   M-  "

7#
 #  5 9 5A" JA#@ F
"  :
  5,  6* 7'*

H' #*'  _ I#8 (5,  2 JA#@ 5= JA#@ 5 ; JA#@ )
42

5/! 5"#8 +# ' JA#@ 6* >B _   5'#);#" 5 2 :#@

H'  H ?8  5"#8 A  ' #


   - 5.  5 2 :#@ '

H' 5H,  5  = i ?'  _ :#@ 6. # 98  5 2 :#@

.5,  7`#,  5"#;

7#H,   -  #+;  # , (#", ) 5,  <  +" b#" #8 8

A  ' #
     5,  (  5   5 #", (64) (   59"#,

.:#@ 6. # 98  5 2 :#@ ' 5  5"#8

5A#@H 7 7  ?'  1  :#.* RA#     5,  7@ 8

6H. #H 98  5 2 :#@ ' 5  5"#8 A  ' #
 = i "

JA#@H ) 7#
 -  5   5 9 5A" JA#@ '  _ B!" :#@

7  ?H'   1  " # .5 2 :#@ ' (5,  2 5= 5 ;

5 9 5A" JA#@ >B _ B!" :#@ 6. 5,    = i " 5A#@ 7

.5 2 :#@ ' 5/! 5"#8 +# ' 7#


 -  5  


N ! N N     *
"  
: 
" (2007)  . 5,  K7

.!
3    
#  - .$  
  
R!
3   

"

<H ,H H' 7#


  ,   :
  5,  6* 7'* 8

5H/#" 5H,  5   7  5 #", @  & ?9 2 ' ?8 7#

_H &    @  8 .5 #", 93 A#@;  #.  () #98 120

7#H <H ,H ' 7#


 #   , 5*2 2 ' 7#"#, 98
43

+H+ 5H < ,  


 7#
 #   ,  # ?8

#H =  <H H , # 5 7 = ;#" ?8 #8 , ?8 5


7#H
 #   , 1  7#8
   5,  7@ # #.9> ?8

H' 7#H
 #   ,  ?8 _ <8   #.* ?8 7# '

7  = 4H" 5
 5",# 7#-  #8 <)" b#" @ 8 .?8 7#

7# ' 7#


 #  
3  , 5*B" 98 5   5 5"

.#. , 53  ." ?8

N 
  
:  

" 
 ": 
" ( 2008 )  "#
'#     :5,  K8

. 
     "! 
    !   :F (    

H H >B 7   


  98 = i 5'
  5,  6* 7'*

' <>`  
  &  .  #9 ",# %#  5+, " < ` ?8 5 <

y#H #.@  5 #",   7# #" #>" ( 8 .?8 %  =
 )3

7#,  #. ?+    >B 5  


 F
" 5'#) ( 59"#, 7#,  

?8 < ' y>B  


 5>> >  B" #>#" f) #  RA# 7 #  .59"#,

: * 98 - 5. 

.?8 # ' ?8 %  =#)2 5


 <" K1

.#.  9 5"#  5# A 9 9 J'   5) K2

.5# 2 7 #.!#" 5> ?8 %  =#)2 5


 <=#3  K3
44

  ( M- .$  "


 * *  " : 
" (2009) ! 5,  K9

. "    Q .$  


R   7

7# #" /! 5  5"#8 - 9  :


  5,  6* 7'*

& " ' 5   7# #" /! 5  5"#8 - JA#@  :
  5  ;

5,  (  /@ & #>" (83)  5,  (   5  5#

  7@ b 7  ' 5#


 5  5# & " '   98 *

' < | 5)  53,'   5# & " ' 5/!  5"#8 7 = ; 5#3

/!   < +#   5   7# #" /! /! #.

5  5 ; 7#+#  < ;  5  5# & " ' 7# #"  

5  ; 7# #" /! -  5  5"#8 - 5#' <=#3  


3 <) " b

5#' <=#3  -  5  5"#8 - 7# '   <)" b#" @
y 

9 ) 7# (7  , ) 7    5  ; 7# #" /! -

.( , 
 <) /! 7# (5#

 * (   "


 
: 
" (2009) #"/   * 5,  K10

  ! 
 *   ,) !  $ .$     
:  7 

H' #.*#, _ #" #."#, 5  5"#8  :


  5,  6* 7'*

5  5,  =     ; ",# 7#


 #- - ' 5'@ 5, ?9

7# #" #  F/ . 7 #", <#, 5+, " ? 
 ' :#@ <! 7!

 5,  7@ .#.#"> 5)3 #" 5A#@ G#  ,  #i #.#
 #./!
45

 .,   !#" 7#


 #  5A" ' 7 + %  5#
' 5  5"#8 5#

5 #  '  ,#" b" %+ # 5#  5 ; 5#


 5- 2 ( #.#  7# # 

   # @8 ?9 53   .  78 #


 ) #.' * ?9 #*+ #.>

' 5  5"#8 : * 7 /  7} / ( 5)  , . 5#@8  5#3  <=#3 

B" A#@;  5 7 #  .:#@ ' 5  5"#8  5'
 5 #", <#,

#H) H' 7#9"+  5"#8  5#


 5"#8 %#,2 5A#@ 5  #
  &# *

7#H"  ' 5# ; 5#3  5  % #" :#@ "8  <


 7#
 58 @ 5@

5H, 5",#  5 ; 7#,#,#"    (!  )'  :#@ 7#.

lH/  =#+2 :!  :#@ ' 7#


  7#3  7  5# < ; "8 

2 B" #.  %+ 2 4' 53 5-  * 5",# 7#


 -  #" .% 

  !#" #.  <#3, 5# 5+ 5A" ' @  7 / & #" - "

+# 9 > 5"#8 5A"  =" 5#


' 5  5"#8 =# " ' #.#' #.=#3 ?9 ' .,

., 5"8 #" =#.  5"#8 5+!  7#


  7#@ 5- B" #* 

 
%       :" : 
" (2009) "# 5,  K11

."    (  !    


    !  

 ?8 #, 5  ' 5",# 7#


 5-   5'
  5,  7'*

 :
  7#
 #  # ' #
  7#"#, 98 - .

5,  7 b .5  ; 5",# 5- 2 - ' ?8 #, 7#   5
"+

 1 B" 5,  (  #.


   b 5  7# #" ( ' 5 #", <  
46

#  # ' 5#


 7# !  5 ! (13) 7#"#, ?8 7# ! (4)   

5A#@ 5 7  ?'   7@ b  ' # : @ 7  7#


 -#3 #. B!   ?8 #, 5  " 5",# 7#


 5-  5", " #

" b 5",# 7#


  b 2 , %9
 ("  , ?> @  5 

&  ?8 #, 5  5*B" -   @ 5'


 <)" 1#@ ' &

.5"#8  <+, 7#"+ 5'# '  `

   *      : : 


" .(2010) <# 5,  K12

.( 
  
)     : 
 I     7

5",# 7#
 -  5#
 5"#8 +" ) >  :
  5,  7'*

58> .3  :


   & 5",# 7#
 58> <# ' 5  ;

- H 5H#
 5"#8 +" ) .3  :
 >  .#.@A#@ 5",# 7#


@  5"#8 +" ) 5-  +" )  #.#   5  ; 5",# 7#


5H,  7'* # .#-  + ?> +" ) 7#3 5#   5"#8 +" )

5"#8 +" ) >  ?! 5  ' # 7#"#,
    :
 

H & 5",# 7#


 58> <# ' 5  ; 5",# 7#
 -  5#


5H
  %H#  H 7H  5 #", 7+ 5,  : * ?9 .5,  <  

- H 5H
"2 5H#
 5H"#8 +" ) 5 #", 7 ) 8 ?! 5  ' 7#"#,

@  5"#8 +" ) 5-  +" ) ' 5> 5  ; 5",# 7#

47

<#H H' #*> 5, " & g#-  ?> + +" ) 7#3 5#  +" )

.7# ! ' 5",# 7#


 58>

7#H
 - H 5#
 5"#8 +" ) " >B &# *   5,  7@

5,  7@ # .7# ! ' 5",# 7#


 58> <# ' 5  ; 5",#

5H %,H 5,  5   ' - 5.  # #  #."   RA#   5 

#H-  + ?>  5"#8 +" ) ) :  # 5",# 7#


 58> ' #*>

7#H
 -  5-  5"#8 +" ) > 5",# 7#
 58> <# ' " >

 5"#8 +" ) > 5",# 7#


 58> <# ' " > 5  ; 5",#

7#
 58> <# ' " > 5  ; 5",# 7#
 -  7#3 5# 

H> 5H  ; 5",# 7#


 -  @  5"#8 +" )  5",#

.5",# 7#
 58> <# ' +,

   7  
  (  J2 6 : 
" (2011) "  5,  K13

  *

#- '  ; ?8 7#"+ #  G =# "  5,  6* 7'*

#-  ( #   7#"#, ?8  #!  ' 5*#,  ` ",# 7#


#-  7# < #)  5'#);#" ?8 5 ' .  78 '  ",#

5"#9  5 #",   7# #" (" b#" #8 5,  : * ?9 . ",#

 5@! 5"#9   7 #  5  b#" 7#- &  5@!

<# 7#3!, ' %  98 (   7"#9 =  7# #", ( 
48

' J#  #
 #+9  3!, (20) H" 5> 5,  5   ! A !  !"

: 5,  7@ 8 

?8 : * ",# 7#


 #- '   ?8 5,#,2 7#"+ #" K1

:#*   "#, ?8 ,9  "#, ?8  5 #9  3 ?8   ,

. , ?8 


" # – "%#, " "#, ?8  2 5 K

– 3 ?8 
" # – "@ " "#, ?8  5 #> 5 K%

?8 " . 78  G# 7  ' 59"+ 5# ?8 5-   " K2

< 7  ",# #-   7# ' ' 5- 2 6* :


) 5# 7#


.5   5",# 5- 2 " #. " (+" ) #    & 5#

 I 0 M   


17D2

: 
" (Al-Jabari, 2004 ) 5,  K1

The Impact of Information Technology on the Internal Audit Process


in Jordan
' 5
' ?8 5
" #9   7 +  G ()  5,  6* 7'*

?8 5  ' %,#  , 53  %,#  
 ",# #- -

* n#"  &  7,#' 5 ! ' 98 5'# ( 7"#9 =   5,  6* 7

",# #- ) ?8 5


" #9 G ()  5,  7@ b 98 (10)

" 1 2 A#, F3 ?/, 78 b  1#' G  * 7"> b  

5*2 7  +#  ?8 ="" b#" @ #' ._@9 5*2 7  +##"

 b <" <#, ' 5 ! C#9  ` #.' C8 2 #.*2 - _@9
49

5*2 7  +#  > <  ' 5+! 2   > 7   5 ! ,9

.+# 6*  ?8  & 


" 5+! 2 6* ' _@9

: 
" (Coram, et al , 2005) 5,  K2

Auditing in an IT Environment: Its Impact in Saudi Arabia


<  F3  7# , b  (  82 ,_, >B 7# 

<  F3  &, (  %#    5,  7  5


  5 = 2

H 1H   5,  7@  2 5  8  &, "


 5
  5

H' !H3 : H* 5


  5 <  8;  1` * %  7# , 5
",

 5 ' 5#, ' b" ' !3 5 


 '  "  #"   #.' & !  " 5
"#

 H
 7  , 5+, 5
  5A+# 7 =#. ; =
  53
) 7 ,3 "8

.5 
  #.' & !  " F'

: 
" ( Elliot, et al. 2007 ) 5,  K3

An improved process model for internal auditing


59 , 1 B!   ?8 5
  R.  G ()  5,  6* :.

7#"#, ?8 5 #+ ' 5+! Q F 


,  b ,   ?8 5
3

(8  7 7#9 7 ` ?  7)


, #) 5
 7#++  <#'; 

@  ?8#" ## +  :#  ##)9  5# 7#*#   B 7  ;

7# ! ' 7#"#, 98  2 5 #", 7  b 5  7# #" (  #",

798  7# !  %54  5 #> 5 #", 7  #98 25 * n" ?8

59 *@  7#"#, ?8 5#


' B!" *- 7#.  @ .#"#,
50

59 B!" 98 7 @ ' : RA#  7.- ,?8 5  5'#)

 G   5


 6. 5,A   F
" ' #,  ?8#" 5@# 5'#)

5
" ?8 59+  "  !" >B#" & 7#"#, ?8 5#
' ,  `

5
 ++#" " G    b "9, ' 5#  5  7#"#, ?8

 #*
" 
 7# , ()  7 >B  & 
" 5
 =   > ?8

 5
 #
 #*
" 7
 = ; 5
  5/ 5
" 9 , *  ('# 

.

: 
" (Sayana et al, 2008) 5,  K4

Using CAATs to Support IS Audit


%#H,  ,#" 5",# 7#
 - ?8 5   5,  6* 7'*

H K 7#H
  5 1  5,  ' =#    ; %,# <#," ?8

H 5 !H  ; 7#


 #-   K 5
  5
" 1#8   ?8 #.#

 H, H" ?8 5 3 " ?8 #8 53  `#,   & _ ?8

C#H" & b" 5^#@ ' 3@ R.   b#"  8 e  ; %,#

.# #+" ' 5,  7 .5,  C)" 58


 7  5
 %  

  €  ; %,# <#," ?8 %#,  ,   5,  7@

H ' # 7 8  1  # 5  ; 5",# 7#


 - ?8 5 

.7    R " #"  7# #"  8 <  -  9 5 "!  9 7# #"
51

: 
" ( Abu-Musa, 2008) 5,  K5

Auditing E-Business: New Challenges for External Auditors


  98 5+!   7#
 #  >  #" ?9  7'*

%, : 5


, 7#-  ' <3  7#
 #  9 #  #  # #" 

700 7  b 52 7#


 ( 5 #",  , 5-  JA#@ 9 :*

5"
 5  ' 5,A  I ' (9  7#-   5   #A ! 1 #",

  98   7@ . , 5#@ 1 #", 218 (  b 5
,

++ F ^2 &   ; 7#


 #- ' . #. .'
 
  5#"

,#,  !"     98  .<   #2  ?8  : !;  1 

#.  #., 7# #" 5@@ > 5"#8  7#


 #  59 +# 

?8 =   .< 5+!  %#,  #-  + ##* +


  @2 5#

7#"#, ?8 : * : #.    <


" +" 7#
 #  #- 9 '  

.?8 ?' ' 7#


 #  ?8 ' @@  5# @ C 

: 
" (Whittington, 2008) 5,  K6

New Audit Documentation Requirement; SAS 96 Raise the Bar for


Audit Documentation، Adding Specific Requirement in Several Areas
?H
  ,H ?H> 7#"+ 7 =   :
  5,  6* 7'*

 H, H' <H"  <#H   5#   #. ?8 # <#  5", #2#"

R. H H bH#" H .5#


 5,'#   7# ! 5+!  # 
 # 

H +#" , R.   5,  C)" 58 #.  59"#, 7#,  (" #
52

=#@H;  F3 5@ _ #" A 9, R.   F3 () 5,  #

7#H H' 5H,  7 .7# #"  ( ' 5A#@ < B   3@

.5  <

5  7 +  5#   , ?>  #!   5,  7@

k#H" 7#">" ?
 ##)8 : *  , ?>  #! * #  ?8  5",# 5A" '

5@! 7 9  <, ^ #2 &  D#@';  5# A 9#" 59
 5",#

H 5H# A H9 !` +


  ?8 7 =  RA# #" . B  :-

?"+" ?
 <> 7#"
@  %",  7# #" 
  G#  7 = ;

.5) ?8 #*   ?8 7 = 

5H"#8  ?8 9  ' ,#,  !" :.  , ?>  " #

H.- %"H, .3  ?"+ b  #'


 #
 *    ?8 5 

%H,# #." 9  #2 9


 C  5  5"#8 #-  5  7 +

 5. 9
  {, <
" -#3 %+  , ?>    ?8 ##"

.5. 7#+#!  7#"#, 9  ?8  

: 
" (Grant, et al. 2008 ) 5,  K7

The effect of IT controls on financial reporting


<# 5# #9  #*> 7#
 #  5"#8 :
) J'  7'*

_ 5  5"#8  *  7#


 #  5"#8 :
) > (,  ?#+   B

> 9 &    %,  ,  5 ! 278  5,  5  7   5 !

7# ! " 5. 7#'  5# #9  7#


 #  5"#8 :
)
53

7@ :
) #."    7# !  7#
 #  5"#8 :
) #."  

#9 R  5   5"#8 5+!  ' :


) #.'   7# !   5,  6*

-
  5- 2 6* ' :
) #.'    7# ! #9  < 8   5#

. d #-  ' 7#


  7#" 5+" 5A,   7#
 #  5"#8

#" 7#
 #  7 + 5"  7#"#,
   % 1 B" >#" @

.5# #9  >  #. # 7#


 #  5"#8" +"

: 
" (Tucker, 2010 ) 5,  K8

"IT And The Audit."

=  ?8  #"  5  5"#8  #  >B #"  5,  6* 7'*

 ?8H 5H.  


  #  6*  <+,  7#
 #  

H H8 .9   53  ## ",  7 #.  J#!2 , ?8

5@# b" C)" 58


 7  #@#" 5 #
,   3@ R.   b"

7 
 % # ' 5 #", 7, & 5  5"#8 5",# 7#
 -

H' C#,H H   :#* " RA#     5,  7@ .# #+" ' 5, 

H' 5> 7# 9 #


,  I'#  #.# :" (#! 5"#8 7#
 # 

%#H, 7 =  5"    ?8 5  >B  _ 7# #"    5#


?H+  5  5"#8 #-  >` #   .5> #  6. ?8

.5  5"#8 #- J' ' ?8 "8  5


"
54

: 
" (Salehi & Abdipour, 2011) 5,  K9

A study of the barriers of implementation of accounting information


system: Case of listed companies in Tehran Stock Exchange "

7#H
 H- ?"+       :!   5,  6* 7'*

: # @ C#+8 (36)  5 ! (406)  5,  (   . .+ ' 5",#

5H@" H' 5 5 ! (100)  7   9' 5,  5  # 5,  =#  5'# '

.5 #", %, 5,  7, . .+

H' 53 -   <  * 5",# 7#


 -  5,  RA# 7.-

H 7#8
   7.- # .7# ! ( '  5. 5 ; 7#
 #-

+H, < ; ) H*  H.+ 5H@" ' 5",# 7#


 - ?"+  

.(5-  5'#9>  5# A#,  5A"  


   -   .  5!"   

: 
" ( Al-Eqab & Ismail, 2011) 5,  K10

"Contingency Factors and Accounting Information System

Design in Jordanian Companies "

7#
 #- @ ' .,   
  :!   5,  6* 7'*

7, .2 ' # 5@" ' 5 5 ! (220)  5,  7 . ",#

.5 #", %, 5, 

#  + 5
"2 #
"2 " "#   >  5,  RA# 7.-

.5",# 7#
 - @ (5 ;  53-  5#
  5  ) 7#

55

(# "  #  <#9 53 ) #2 7# , 


" " 5  > &# * 

. ",# 7#
 - @

- @ + 5A" :- " 5A#@ 5  >   7.-

< ; 3-  7#


   ; +  5,  RA# 7.- . ",# 7#


7#
 #- @  >B '   +  5* >  7#
 # 

# 5 ,  5* >  53  <#8 5 ,  5,  7 " . ",#

. ",# 7#
 #- @ +  "  #*>B & # " 

  
!$    
I   18-2

7#H 9  #."#^ ' 7    7#)  


 59"#, 7#,  7# 

 bH#" - #  7#


 #   ,  5,  6* 7  # " 7#


 ?8 5  7#


 7# 9  , > I#8  7  59"#, 7#,  -


5H #  H 7 H  9' 5# 5,  # ?8 5    5  =  

7  5 ' 5#


 ?8 %#  ' ?8 < +") ' 7#
 #   ,

.< 5 5'#)  ! #


56

; : ()4

 
  

5,  R.  1K3

5 
  5,  ( 2K3

5,  <  3K3

< 2 7#"> ?@ 4K3

5A#@; 5#
 5K3

7#
  7# #" ( %#, 6K3

5,  7 / 7K3

5,  G  8K3


57

; : ()4

 
  

5H,  7  5H,  5H  ( 5,  R.  b#" F


,  #'

:  #  #.' 5, 5A#@; %#,2  #. = 

 
=  1D3

3H@ %H,2 bH#" #.' ("  5  7#,   5,  6* "


5'
 &  ?8 < +") ' 7#
 #  5*  :
 :."  

 5,    7  5 ' 7#"#, 98 - 5.  & #. , 7#8


5H 7 /  5  ^ 7 /    5,  7 / 5 #9 7# #"

5H,  7#@ RA# #" 7#)3 #" ' #.


 #
 :." & I#9 5"#8

5H` H :H


   5* &    !" :
 # 5# ##"

H #.#)H #H ;#" 7#H #" H @   #.


 #
  >"

. A#@;

    
<  2D3

%H  ( 43 ) #* 7  5 ' ?8 %#  (  5,  (  

?8 %#  7#"#, "8   ) .#98 ( 200 ) #.' 


 5 .   J ?8

.(2012 #
 5  
   ",# 5
  #@ 7  5" 7#"#,

%H#  6* ' #


 # 98  5  #  9' 5,  5  #

' #
 (  7# #", ( " b#" #8 b ?8 (200)   * n#" 
58

#H  (%69.5) 5", " 5 #", (139)  ,  #! f, 59+" %#  6*

&H" ,#H.A"
 # 
 #.  5 #", 14 #
",  #* ' 
" 5, 7# #", 

 7
)   5, #" 5! %#  ' 
 ?8 (125)  5 
 79,

CH ( 1K3) 8  f) <, 7# #",  #  (%89.9) 5", "

H #H  5A %,   A#@;  5#@  <,  5  7# #",

.5  7# #",

( 1D3 ) (


(    )  
   $I  0 9

(    )   0 
    0 $I   0

%

 %

 %

%89.9 125 %69.5 139 %100 200

.b#"     :


)

 

 3D3

H H 7 / I#8  8 5,  7#)' ( +/ 5 #", @" b#" #8

: * ,A    5 #", 7   8 ", 7#"# _, 9 7 #"

*` 
 I  ) > 5' ^  
  :
 J@ :(3 6I D

.(5 . 7 #.! ?8 # ' <" 7  ,  




# " 5> 5,  7 / +/  7 #"


 J@ :: 6I D#

:  #  #.,#8 53  7#



59

.(14K1)  7 #"
#" 1,#8  <#" ( 14 ) ! :    K

.(22K15)  7 #"
#" 1,#8  7 #" ( 8 ) ! :     " D

.(28K23 ) 7 #"
#" 1,#8  7 #" ( 6 ) ! :     D

: 0  -F (?" !    *   
 $ 
 

(34K29) 7 #"
#" 1,#8  7 #" ( 6 ) ! : 
  $ D

(38K35) 7 #"
#" 1,#8  7 <#" ( 4 ) ! :    6 0  $ D

K39)  7 #"
#" 1,#8  7 #" ( 4 ) ! : 
($ 6
 $ D

.(42

"#, +,  ?


   5,  6* #.  #" ?
 #'

(:
) +, #) * 7#, b> b#"  9' 5,  G ' 7 /

:5d 5#
  =# "

7#,  /("  2  – " 2  ) = 5A3 +

: ## 7#,   &" .1.33 = 3/4 = 3/(1K5)

.(2.33)  8 K(1)  :


)

.(3.56) – (2.34)  +,

.(5)  (3.57)  #


60


3 : 
) 4D3

#H ' @@  5 2 7#


# <#,    5 #", F 

#H. 9'  .  59 7


 =   .#@ .#9" 2  5",#

.5 #",   =#, " (2) 8 ? 

 H,#" 7# #" ( <   5# _ 5'


   ?#, #"  #

#H9' 5 #", 6* 5# 5 7/" 8 .I#9 <  7#"> _ I#9 #3 „#"  #


„#"  8  - .#. #   < 5", * (% 83.59) #3 „#"  #


< 7 # 5,  7 / ( 7#"> 7#


 B" (2K3)  ' f) * # #3

.5,  F ^2 5",#  *

(2D3) (


 M  ( "
 ? : (  

4  T (  M  *  4 (

% 82.39 5",# 7# 9 14K1

%81.78 5
  5
 <" 22K15

%78.98 7 #. + 28K23

%81.19 ?8 5 5#' 34K29

%88.57 5 7 =  5#' 38K35

% 81.43 ?8 # =  5#' 42K39

% 83.59 : ( * (


 42D1
61

 >)7   5D3

5H# H
 A#@H; R#H " ) 5A#@; %#,2#" 5 #
, 7

5H>" 5 
 5  5,    #. @   7# #" 5#
 (SPSS)

:5# 5A#@; %#,2 , b#" #' #"

:@ & 5A %,   7     "#, +, > : I $I 8  D1

&  5 #", ' <  7 #"


 5*  5,  7 /  5,  5  = i

. "#, #.+,  7#"#; 7! _ #" #


 :  

 >B #"   & ( Simple Regression )   " 


0 (  D2

.?8 < * ("# / ' 9, /

5  7#"# ' ?3  :


 Q 2 :(One way Anova) &
3 !  (  D3

.5' ^  
 #9' 5, 

H' 5, 7# #" ( <   5# _ #" & :T 4   " D4

.5,  #. 7!  7 / I#8

    < #  6D3

5H2 #@H #* 7#


 #@    5,  6* ' # 

:  #  5 #> #@ 

5H@# 5 #"H, @H   #. @   7# #" & * : 3  

H-  #H+; #H.#  H %  5'# #.   +/ b" 5,  6* C)

.5,  #. 7 ,  7#)3  7`#, 


62

5H
   5"  #@  #. @ 7  7# #" * : :  

:> 5,  6. -  #+;  5


 I,2 ()   59"#, 7#,  5"2

.7#
 #  ?8 < ' b"  5@# 5
    5",# % K1

.7  5 ' 5#


 ?8 %#   <#@ 5, 7 =#@;  #9 K2

?8 < ' 5@# 5,  C)  7"  7 !   5@@ 7# K3

.7#
 # 

.7#
 #  ?8 < ' b"  6   7#+ ,# A#, K4

 
  M  7D3

b 9, / 7#


 #  7 /  5,  6* ' b#" 

7  5i 5",# < 3  


 ",# #-  ' #.3- #  6*  , 

H ",# #-   1> # #  6* #' ##" 58  5,#" # ("#+

>` #", ##- f"@ b" 5",# 5A" ' #. , _, (' ' 7., 7 /

.?8 < +") '

<H +"H)  


 #…
3  , I#,2 3) 7 / 6* ?"+  #

#H H' #.#  7#


#" < ;   ' #  6* 5*2 -  ?8

7 #. + 5


  5
 <"  5",# 7# 9 #' %,#  78 ' 7  9

5   5#' ,  


 7 !`   ?8 5 < +") ' >`

.?8 # =  5 7 = ;  ?8


63

H <#3H, H 7# ! 7@ 9' 7#


 #   , #  (

 5 !H 5HA"  =  7#


 #  7"@ b" #   7# #" 5#


FH3 #.# #" 5#


 53 7# ! 7#  #*>B 7#
 #  @ 

.7 + 6* 5"  5  5"#8 5-  

#H   , 5* (2007)  . 5,  #. 7@  5  7 " 8

H
 7#
 #   ,  # ?8 7# < , ' 7#


# 5 7 = ;#" ?8 #8 , ?8 5


 ++ 5 < , 

.#.9> ?8 # =  <  ,

7#H
 #H  5A" >B &# *   (2004) #", 5,  7#! &

#H  5HA" ' ?8  7#"+ 5"  5* 7 " & 5  5"#8 #- 

(+,H H ?8#" 5@# 7   =#! 4" #9 <)" b#" @ & 7#


.7#
 #  7   ,  #.# ' 
  < 5A" 7#"+ 5" 

#H  %  J #*/ ?8 %#   #" 7#8


 6*  =# "

+"H) H' 7#


 #  5* ' b" 5,  6* 7=# #. ,  7#


7#H)' ?#9H! H b 7  5 ' 7#"#, 98 - 5.  ?8 <

H/ >BH H" 7#+


 ?' #. " 7#8
 5
"+ f)  G  =# " 5, 

+"H) H' (7 #. + 5


  5
 <"  5",# 7# 9 )H" > 9,

.(?8 # =  5 7 = ;  ?8 5) 7 !`" ?8 5 <
64

 
J2 8D3

#H H b#"  9' < #.' *  @  5,  F^ ?9

7 H/  59,H 7 / " RA#  ' >B &# * 7 #  #' :


 #." # @#

.7 / 6* 7#8 (1K3) 8  ! f) 5


"#

<  M  (   M 

 

     

++ 5 K
5 7 =  K 5",# 7# 9 K
?8 # =  < K 5
  5
 <" K
7 #. + K

R (F R R8


   
 - R"

(1D3) (-
 
J2
b#"    G 2 :@
65

<  ()4

 4  "  (  => 

5,  5  JA#@ 1K4

5,  7 / 3@ =#@; RA# 2K4

5,  7#)' #" RA# 3K4

5H  7#"# ' ?3 (One way Anova) #2 #"  RA# 4K4

5' ^  
 #9' 5, 
66

<  ()4

 4  "  (  => 

H
 5A#@; 5  R# "  ,#" <  5+, " 7
  7# #"  

:  #  5",#  5A#@; %#,2 %, .(SPSS) 5#

5"#,H 7#+H,  5HA %,H   7  H  #4" & :4) 6)7 D1

.5,  5 #",#" <  7 93  <9'   5#


 7#'   

(Simple +," +    %,  ,#" 7#)3 #"  : 4  " D2

6H 9, /   >B  5 #  I9  T 8 %#," & Regression)

H"8 Ho 5H
 5H)3 F'  #"  9 <#8 J  ("# / 

_,H   & 5 #.8  "  5", ( T) 8 7 #  Ha 5" 5)3

.%95 59> _, %5 (Sig.) 5




Coefficient Of Multiple Determination (R2) H


  #
 %#,  K3

59,H 7 / "8  6,3     ("# 5,  / ' #" 5", >  

(Malhotra, 2003)    G ' 58


 <8 I9
67

 
 $ C>)" 1D4
5,  5   ' JA#@ (1K4) 8  ' <  RA#  "
(1 D4) * (

  U
(  #  
 $ < I

  >4  M 
 >
80.0 100   I 
20.0 25 b# 
24.0 30 5 , 25  8 

44.8 56 5 , 35  8  25
19.2 24 5 , 45  8  35
4.0 5 5 , 55  8  45
8.0 10 > B' 5 , 55 
88.0 110 I# " 
 *`
8.0 10 ,#
4.0 5 # "
60.8 76 7  , 5  8 #H ' <" 7  , 
16.0 20 5 , 10  8  5 ?8
15.2 19 5 , 15  8  11
4.0 5 5 , 20  8  16
4.0 5 > B' 5 , 21
4.0 5 (ACPA) "  #8 %,# 5 . 7 #.!
4.0 5 (CPA)   #8 %,#
36.0 45 (ACCA)    #8 %,#
56.0 70 5 . <#.!  
68

=#@; %,  ,#" 53-  5@! 7 /  5 5,  7

%,   7    G ,#" & 5A3 6." 59


 ?A#9 F
" #"    3@

 
 *` 
 I  ) b  5' ^  
#" 5@# 5A,Q 5A

@  # #9' RA#  6.  > (5 . 7 #.! ?8 # ' <" 7  ,

=    #. @    7#"#; 6*  #' 98 7#"#  1

:  # " b (1K4) 8 ?"#,  ' #.@    5 #",  2

:8 D1

5   #  %80  7@ 5", "    98 59+ 5",  

,3 # * 5 
  #  +9' %20 b# ; 5", 7/"  ' 5>" 5, 

2 - b# ;  >  53 %#",2 ?8 # ' 


  "9 #  

.?8 5 . 5
"+" ?


: D2

35  8  25  5


 5A3  %24 5 , 25  8 5
 5A3 5", 7/"

 8  45  %19.2 5 , 45  8  35  5


 5A3  %44.8 5", " 5 ,

%#  ' 
   !` * .%8 5", " > B' 5 , 55  %4 5", " 5 , 55

%#  ' 5
,  59"#, 7 " '  ?8 # ' :A#- ^#!  %+ ?8

5"+ * 5
 7#A3 6*   5'#);#" .53- 7#" " #9     5>#

7#A,  


 G)   8   B" . 
 # ?8 %# 

   #* '   8 5 


 ' %#"!  <" 5",  .. ' _" 
69

 A   !" ?8 %#  ' 


 .
  #,   3  * +#! 

5
 7#A3 " %,  %#9  &  :) &#. ;  ?#*;  %
#" I#,;

.%#"! "8  5 . 6*  #"8;  ,#"  !` +




: (F D3

# %4 # " 5A' %8 ,# 5A' %88 I# " 5A' 5", 7/"

5", " 7  , 5  8 5A3 5",  7 # ' ?8 # ' <" 7  , 
 5", #"

C#3 -  .%4 5", " > B' 5 , 20 5A' 5 , 20  8  15 5A3 5A'   %60.8

.7  ' 


 9 #* <# %"," 5,  5  _ 
 @ _,

' 
  #,  ,#, %+ * 98 
 @ _, C#3  9  

*` :#
 %#,  (I# " ) 5",#  5 5  @ %+ %#  6*

...  ##)9 : ( #


 


: 
(  "  

$ D4

' ." 7  , 9 5,  5   #", ( 76 )  (1K4)   f)

5>" 5 
  #  5A# ' (60.8) .", 7 ! b 7  , 5  5 !

H' (16.0) 5",  ! #", 20 (7  , 10K5)  <"     n" # "

#",H (19) 5 , 15K10 <"     n"  ' 5 


  #  5A#

(5 H, 20K16)  7  H, 20 H >  A3   7#, # " 5A# ' (15.2) 5", "

(  * ,3 .5A'   5A# ' ( 4.0) 5",  I3  ", (5) 5A'   
 I3 "

.. 5  #2#" #9 5'# <"" 


 5,  5     5 

70

:   
 - D5

H  5H>" 5H 
 5"#^  ( 1 K4) 8 ?"#,    "

7 #.!H H  5@3 .A#+ 98 *B , * .5",# ' 5 . 7 #.!

.?8 5 . =#"B" #9 5'#) 7 8 .   2 ?8 ' 5 .

A+ # 5,  5A,  5"#  #8 5,  5   - #  !"

.. 5. 7# #", 5A"


 ' b#" <#, .*`  5
 <9 .  b#"

 
  M  4) 6)7 =>  2D4

H 5H  H, H  #.!8#  5,  7#)' #"#" b#" #8

#H  5H* 5#   #. )  RA#  "  7#)3 5A 7 #"

& 7  5 ' 7#"#, 98 - 5.  & ?8 < +") ' 7#


H H RA#H  ## 5 #",; ' 5@@ 5A,2  5,  5  7#"#  

:#. @
71

.N$ N 
N $
  0     0      1D2D4

    

(2D4) (

(    )     0     
, 0   

4
&  
 5#@8 < ' #   ,   ?8 (+, K1
5
3 0.67 4.30
.?8 5  ,
 !" 7#
 # " 1'
  , ?8 5
" ?8 #8 K2
5
3 0.87 3.85
. ,#,
/! #-  5"#8 +" ) J3 () ?8 #8 K3
5
3 0.57 4.42
.7# #"  
1"+ %, #.@3 7# #"  5   @ ?8 D#, K4
5
3 0.56 4.66
.5#3" ?8 5
" #9
 5"#8 
3 #  7# 9"   ?8 %#  #8 K5
5
3 0.74 4.21
.7#
 # 
5+, 1.01 3.06 .7#
 #   , 5  =# " ?8 <=#3 9 K6
5
3 0.90 3.80 .?8 5 #; <+ 7#"  ,#" ?8 %#  #8 K7
&  5# 7 # ",# #-  + ?8 %#  #8 K8
5
3 0.84 4.17
.?8 5 ,
#9 5",#  7 =   #. '   ?8 %#   /"  K9
5
3 0.60 4.31
.?8 5
"
5, R " 5
"# 5 5
  =  ?8 %#  #8 K10
5
3 0.65 3.96
.?8 5 '
5
3 0.76 4.11 .?8 5 ' 5, ?8 R " 
 98 & ! K11
# ?8 R " " 5 #9 7# = 4" ?8 %#  #8 K12
5
3 0.72 4.05
.#.)'
5 , 5 ?8 #
  , ?8 %#  #8 K13
5
3 0.58 4.51
.?8
72

@ ?8 D#, %" (4) <93 7 # <9'   (2K4)   f)

"#,H +H," "5H#3" ?8 5


" #9 1"+ %, #.@3 7# #"  5  

%H#   %" (13) <93 7=# 5 #> 5" ' (0.56) #
 :   (4.66)

:   (4.51) "#, +," "?8 5 , 5 ?8 #


  , ?8

 , ?8 %#   %" (7) <93 7=# <2 "8 5" ' (0.58) #


' (0.90) #


 :   (3.80) "#, +," "?8 5 #; <+ 7#"

#H   H, 5  =# " ?8 <=#3 9 " (6) <93 7=# <2 5"

.(1.01) #
 :   (3.06) "#, +," "7#


H  7 # #. @   5"#, 7#+, (  #  !" -

  ! * 5"#, 7#+,  ?


   5,  #.   +,

H' 7#
 #  5*  7 #"
 (  5"# 7 # 5,  5  7#"#,

.5# 5" # 7  5 ' 7#"#, 98 - 5.  & ?8 < +")

"#,H +,  / * 8 7! _  ! 5#


 7#'    #

5H  7#"#   ! 5)3  59 6* / I#8 ' 5, 7 93 (

.#   5."#! 5"#9 5, 

#   ,   -  98 =`*   7#"#, 6* > I


H 5H#
 ' ., ##" ?8 < +") ' . 5",# 7# 9  7#


#H  H # H,  # > 2  


#" )'  !" 5+#;  @9 
73

bH 5H  6*  <#'| 5@' &# .' 5,  _ # %, 5  5A" 5",# 

.#.  


 #." 59 7 
  <+ 7# 9 '   7 

N .N$  
 $  0     0      2D2D4

     "

(3D4) (

(     " )     0     
, 0  

4
&  
98 _ '  5 9  5'
 7 #. K14
5
3 0.54 4.70
.?+ )'B" ?8 5 #  #,
# <
 ?8 #
" 5  5'
 ' K15
5
3 0.55 4.69
.?8 5
" #9
18#   5
  5
 7 " ' K16
5
3 0.64 4.42
.?8 ' 5@@ 5" 7 #"
98 #.' 
  5#@8 < %,  K17
5
3 0.63 4.38
.?8 5 #; 5",#  :#
 7 "
# ; 7#,  ?' 5 . 7 #.! ' K18
5
3 0.74 3.93
.?8 5
18  , 5# 7*`  ?8 @ K19
5
3 0.80 3.99
.?8 5
" #9 
.*B 5@@ 7 #" 98 ?# K20
5
3 0.72 4.36
.#  7 + %   !"

5H'
 7 #. #," (14) <93 7 # <9'   (3K4)   f)

"#,H +H," "?H+ )'B" ?8 5 #  98 _ '  5 9 

' H  /" " (18) <93 <2 5" ' 7=# (0.54) #
 :   (4.70)
74

(3.93) "#, +," "?8 5 # ; 7#,  ?' 5 . 7 #.! 98 _

.(0.74) #
 :  

H  7 # #. @   5"#, 7#+, (  #  !" -

  ! * 5"#, 7#+,  ?


   5,  #.   +,

H' 7#
 #  5*  7 #"
 (  5"# 7 # 5,  5  7#"#,

.5# 5" # 7  5 ' 7#"#, 98 - 5.  & ?8 < +")

"#,H +,  / * 8 7! _  ! 5#


 7#'    #

5  7#"#   ! 5)3  59 6* / I,#8 ' 5, 7 93 (

.#   5."#! 5"#9 5, 

  ( 5) 7"@ 5


  5
 <"   7#"#, 6* > I


#H" 8#  5 , #)   & 7#


 #   #  5#

 *  # #.+ " 5 ! 52 5   #,82  A  " 7# #"  7#


.?8 < +")  


 1 #!
75

 .$  
 $  0     0      3D2D4

    

( 4D4 ) (

(     )     0     
, 0 N
N 

4
&  
H+ H 5H3 7 ' ' 98 G# K21
5
3 0.53 4.27
.?8 5 ' . #.
H+ 5H# 7H # = "#" 5 #
, K22
5
3 0.82 4.03
.98 7 #.
7 #H. H+ ' 5
 b#"2  <#' K23
5
3 0.81 4.12
.5#@8 < ' 98
98 7 #. + =4" #
 7  ; #8 K24
5
3 0.71 4.23
.?8 5 ' 5/#" 5*2
H' . H!   98 7 #. + K25
5
3 0.64 4.43
.53 7    7#!
98 7 #. +  7 )# #, K26
5
3 0.59 4.28
.#  !"

7 #H. H+ H " (25) <93 7 # <9'   (4K4)   .-

:   (4.43) "#, +," "53 7    7#! ' . !   98

7H #H = "#" 5 #


, " (22) <93 7=# <2 5" ' (0.64) #


.(0.82) #
 :   (4.03) "#, +," "98 7 #. + 5#

H  7 # #. @   5"#, 7#+, (  #  !" -

  ! * 5"#, 7#+,  ?


   5,  #.   +,
76

H' 7#
 #  5*  7 #"
 (  5"# 7 # 5,  5  7#"#,

.5# 5" # 7  5 ' 7#"#, 98 - 5.  & ?8 < +")

"#,H +,  / * 8 7! _  ! 5#


 7#'    #

5  7#"#   ! 5)3  59 6* / I,#8 ' 5, 7 93 (

.#   5."#! 5"#9 5, 

'H  7#"#9  7 9  7 #. +   7#"#, 6* > I




   7 #. 6*   ?+ )'B" ?8 5 #  <9 .  98 _

7#@H  7#H
 #  
 b 7#
 #  ' 5#
 _9 <=#3

.,H 
  8 # 5  7#
 &  !"  3  .  IA  !"

.?8 < +") '

.$  
 $
  0     0      4D2D4

 "  

(5D4) (

( "  )     0     
, NN0 N
NN 

4
&  
5H" #*   5#3#" ?8 5 :@ K27
5
3 0.83 4.01
.++
, ' ., 7 + ) ?8 5 -  5#' K28
5
3 0.66 4.26
.?8 5
5
3 0.95 3.96 .5#3" ?8 5 ++ 5@@ 5.  K29
5H , 53 5  7 " 98 %#, K30
5
3 0.82 3.95
.?8
5
3 0.77 4.02 ?8 5 ' 5> 7#"  ,#" 98 #8 K31
77

5 -  B" 9  " (41) <93 7 # <9'   (5K4)   f)

:   (4.26) "#, +," "?8 5 , ' ., 5#


' 7 + ) ?8

5H3 5H  7 " 98 %,   %" (43) <93 7=# (0.66) #


.(0.82) #
 :   (3.95) "#, +," <2 5" ' "?8 5 ,

H  7 # #. @   5"#, 7#+, (  #  !" -

  ! * 5"#, 7#+,  ?


   5,  #.   +,

H' 7#
 #  5*  7 #"
 (  5"# 7 # 5,  5  7#"#,

.5# 5" # 7  5 ' 7#"#, 98 - 5.  & ++ 5 5#'

"#,H +,  / * 8 7! _  ! 5#


 7#'    #

5  7#"#   ! 5)3  59 6* / I,#8 ' 5, 7 93 (

.#   5."#! 5"#9 5, 

FH
" H :!H   :. ?8 5 -   7#"#, 6* > I


<" 5* %,  7 = ; 6.' ?8 : *  #. , 78 :8  7 !`

 ++ 5 , 


 _ 5.  7#"#, 5
  5
 ++ 5 '

H,   9'2   < 5"  +# 5,  ' @   5!

.5# A 9
78

.N$ N 
N $
  0     0      5D3D4

    6 7 

(6D4) (

(    6 7 )     0     
, NN0 NN 

4
&  

3 ' ?8 5  RA#   5 #, K32
5
3 0.66 4.27
.5#@8 < ' ?8
H' ?8H 5H RA#   98 
 K33
5
3 0.58 4.23
.5- 
7 = ;  ' #9 6#,  ?8 (+, K34
5
3 0.73 4.15
.?8 5
 5
5
3 0.62 4.34 .5)#" ?8 5  7 =  :@ K35

7 = H :@  %" (48) <93 7 # <9'   (6K4)   f)

7=# (0.62) #


 :   (4.34) "#, +," "5)#" ?8 5 

H' "?8 5


 5 7 = ;  ' #9 6#,  ?8 (+," (47) <93

.(0.73) #
 :   (3.15) "#, +," <2 5"

H  7 # #. @   5"#, 7#+, (  #  !" -

  ! * 5"#, 7#+,  ?


   5,  #.   +,

H' 7#
 #  5*  7 #"
 (  5"# 7 # 5,  5  7#"#,

5H" # 7  5 ' 7#"#, 98 - 5.  & 5 7 = ; 5#'

.5#
79

"#,H +,  / * 8 7! _  ! 5#


 7#'    #

5  7#"#   ! 5)3  59 6* / I,#8 ' 5, 7 93 (

.#   5."#! 5"#9 5, 

H * 5 7 = ;  , ,A :.  7#"#, 6* > "

5
)# 7#.#" 5  5# 7# #" !  #9  @    #! J!

?8 #9" ?
 #' #@@ 58 @  59> 5, ) 5# 58 @" 5"#8

.= 2 ?8  #

6
  .$  
 $  0     0      6D2D4

 
($

(7D4) (

( 
($ 6
  $ )     0     
, 0 N
N 

4
&  
#H ' ?8 #,   ?8#" #9 K36
5
3 0.81 3.94
.@8 78" ?8 R "
7#
 # ' #,   ?8#" #9 K37
5
3 0.76 4.10
.)'  !" 5"#   5"#,
 H ' ?8 #,   ?8#" #9 K38
5
3 0.67 4.23
.< | #.
'  :,  #9  A#,
H ?8 5  599 RA#  @ K39
5
3 0.72 4.04
.#. #
3  9+  ?> 

?8H#" #H9 #,H" (51) <H93 7 # <9'   (7K4)   f)

"#,H +," "< | #.


'  :,  #9  A#,   ' ?8  
80

#,H   ?8#" #9  " (49) <93 7=# (0.67) #
 :   (4.23)

(3.94) "#,H +H," <H2 5" ' "@8 78" ?8 R " # ' ?8

.(0.81) #
 :  

H  7 # #. @   5"#, 7#+, (  #  !" -

  ! * 5"#, 7#+,  ?


   5,  #.   +,

H' 7#
 #  5*  7 #"
 (  5"# 7 # 5,  5  7#"#,

5H" #H 7  5 ' 7#"#, 98 - 5.  & ?8 # =  5#'

.5#

"#,H +,  / * 8 7! _  ! 5#


 7#'    #

5  7#"#   ! 5)3  59 6* / I,#8 ' 5, 7 93 (

.#   5."#! 5"#9 5, 

%H+ 5H#' <=#3 " 7#


 #   ,  7#"#, 6* > I


&H 5H#
 ^ 7 /  <@2  f@  !" `"   ?8  5# <8

# ' ?8 <"  &  


 7 / %#",  ?9 5"+ 7#">; 5 

?  !" 5"+ 7#">; 5 5#


 ^ 7 /  7#8
  # ?8 <" 7

.?8 5 5#' <=#3    6"   )'

%,#  #. @  # A#@;  RA# " (3) 8 ? 
81

 
   " =>  3D4

7#H)3 #"  RA#   ,; =#@; %#,   b#" ,

#" ' #. @   RA#  5#   " 5# 5,  #. 7 , 

:7#)3

:. 3  >  4  " 1D3D4

( 0.05 ) 5H _,H H  5A#@ 5  >   :1   5)3 6* J 

98 - 5.  5  ?8 %#  _ ?8 < +") ' 7#
 # 

.7  5 ' 7#"#,

5* I#9 
 +      ,#" b#" #8 5)3 6* #"

98H - 5.  5  ?8 %#  _ ?8 < +") ' 7#
 # 

.RA#  6* (8K4) 8  #. )  RA#  " b 7  5 ' 7#"#,

( 8 D4) (

 :V (Multiple Regression)

  
0  " => 
 

      
F F
>)7   R2 Sig. (   M 
 
 
NNNNNN  
5
 5)3 F' 3.84 4.62 .462 .000


4.62) * 5", F 58  (7 K4) ?"#,  ' <  7# #"  f)

6H* #H" H' #H. @   9 5 #9" (3.84) 5 #.8 7/" #' (

5H)3 FH' H 1 4' & 5 59  "  5", 59  " 5)3
82

#H  5A#@H 5H  > " 1  J   5" 5)3 "8 5


7#"#,H 98 - 5.  5  ?8 %#  _ ?8 < +") ' 7#


! # %5  8 #.  3@ 5/#" (Sig.) 5 58 6 ` # * .7  5 '

< +") ' #"  (.462) 1", # ,3 7#


 #  ' #"   RA# 

<8 C#3 I
 # .?8 < +") ' >` _   &# * 
 * ?8

(3) 8 ?  .?8 < +") / 7#


 #  / ,3 5 58


.%,#  #. @  # A#@;  RA# "

:. 3  $4  4  " 2D3D4

( 0.05 ) 5H _,H H  5A#@ 5  >   " 1  5)3 6* J 

98H H- 5.  5  ?8 %#  _ ?8 < +") ' 5",# 7# 9

.7  5 ' 7#"#,

(Simple Regression) +,"    #"  ,  9' 5)3 6* #"

.5)3 6* #"   #. @   RA#  " ( 9K4 ) 8 #  

( 9 D4) (

( Simple Regression)   
0  " => 
 

        :V

T T
>)7    
  R2 Sig. (   M 

5
 5)3 F' .297 .000    
1.679 7.590
83

H* 5",H T 5H8  ( 9 K4) ?"#,  ' <  7# #"  f)

#H" ' #. @   9 5 #9" (1.679) 5 #.8 7/" #' (7.590)

5H)3 F'  1 4' & 5 59  "  5", 59  " 5)3 6*

+"H) H' 5",# 7# 9 >B  " 1  J   5" 5)3 "8 5


"7H  5H ' 7#"#, 98 - 5.  5  ?8 %#  _ ?8 <

#"   ! # %5  8 #.  b 3@ 5/#" (Sig.) 5 58 6 ` # *

IH
 #H ?8 < +") ' #"  (.297) 1", # ,3 5",# 7# 9 '

?8 < +") / 5",# 7# 9 / ,3 5 58
 <9 5+, 5

A#@;  RA# " (3) 8 ?  7  5 ' 7#"#, 98 - 5. 

.%,#  #. @  #

: :  $4  4  " 3D3D4

( 0.05 ) 5 _,   5A#@ 5  >   " 1  5)3 6* J 

98 - 5.  5  ?8 %#  _ ?8 < +") ' 5
  5
 <"

.7  5 ' 7#"#,

(Simple Regression) +,"    #"  ,  9' 5)3 6* #"

.5)3 6* #"   #. @   RA#  " ( 10K4 ) 8 #  
84

( 10 D4) (

 :V ( Simple Regression)   
0  " => 
 

        "

T   T  
>)7   R2 Sig. (   M 
 
 
5
 5)3 F' 1.679 8.640
.526 .000      "

H* 5",H T 5H8  ( 10 K4) ?"#,  ' <  7# #"  f)

#H" ' #. @   9 5 #9" (1.679) 5 #.8 7/" #' (8.640)

5H)3 F'  1 4' & 5 59  "  5", 59  " 5)3 6*

+") ' 5


  5
 <" >B  " 1  J   5" 5)3 "8 5


"7H  5H ' 7#"#, 98 - 5.  5  ?8 %#  _ ?8 <

#"   ! # %5  8 #.  b 3@ 5/#" (Sig.) 5 58 6 ` # *

#H ?8H < +") ' #"  ( .526) 1", # ,3 5
  5
 <" '

?8 < +") / 5


  5
 <" / ,3 5 58
 <8 C#3 I


A#@;  RA# " (3) 8 ?  7  5 ' 7#"#, 98 - 5. 

.%,#  #. @  #

:: :  $4  4  " 4D3D4

( 0.05 ) 5 _,   5A#@ 5  >   : 1  5)3 6* J 

98 - 5.  5  ?8 %#  _ ?8 < +") ' 7 #. +

.7  5 ' 7#"#,

(Simple Regression) +,"    #"  ,  9' 5)3 6* #"


85

.5)3 6* #"   #. @   RA#  " ( 11K4 ) 8 #  

( 11D4) (

 :V ( Simple Regression)   
0  " => 
 

       

T   T  
>)7    
  R2 Sig. (   M 

5)3 F'
1.679 6.396 .417 .000     
5


* 5", T 58  ( 11 K4) ?"#,  ' <  7# #"  f)

#" ' #. @   9 5 #9" ( 1.679 ) 5 #.8 7/" #' (6.396)

5)3 F'  1 4' & 5 59  "  5", 59  " 5)3 6*

< +") ' 7 #. + >B  " 1  J   5" 5)3 "8 5


# * "7  5 ' 7#"#, 98 - 5.  5  ?8 %#  _ ?8

' #"   ! # %5  8 #.  b 3@ 5/#" (Sig.) 5 58 6 `

C#3 I
 # ?8 < +") ' #"  (.417) 1", # ,3 7 #. +

?8 %#  _ ?8 < +")  7 #. + / ,3 5 58
 <8

 RA# " (3) 8 ?  7  5 ' 7#"#, 98 - 5.  5 

.%,#  #. @  # A#@;


86

 $ %  4 (One way Anova) &


3 !  (  =>  4D4

  U
(    

 59, 7 / >B ' 5A#@ 5 7  ?'  _  :


H H9' ", 5' ^  


 :#" ( ?8 < +") ) * ("# /

.(One way Anova) #2 #"  #"  ,

N 2% N
  4 ( R 
  4 '" .$  9 <#8 J 

".05 ! ( Sig.   P   


 F   !   F  

.(Sekaran, 2000: 317)

:1  5)3 6* J 

?8 < +") ' 7#


 #   5* ' 5A#@ 5 7  ?'  

=`. 5' ^  


 _
 7#"#, 98 - 5.  5  ?8 %#  _

5)3 6* ,9  8 .(5 . 7 #.! <"  


 *` 
 I  ) 98

: * 53 7#)3   

8 1D4D4

#   5* ' 5A#@ 5 7  ?'   :1  5)3 6* J 

7#"#, 98 - 5.  5  ?8 %#  _ ?8 < +") ' 7#


.I  _

87

( 12 –4) (

(One way Anova) !  (  => 
8 . % PI  
 $ %  4
5  F5HH8 _, F 5HH8 +H
H, 7#H
H C #" @
5 5
 5", 7#
" 5 7#
"
Sig df
  2.239 1 10.239 7# "
?' 7#  
1.893 123 9.41
3.84 0.000 40.736

124 19.380   #"

H* 5",H F 5H8  6  ' <  7# #" 5


#+   "

59  "  5", F 58   #. " 5 #9#" (3.84) 5 #.8 (40.736)

F 5H8  "  5", F 58 7 #  " 1  J    9 <#9 #9' 5

+"H) ' 7#


 #   5* ' 5A#@ 5 7  ?'   1 #' 5

H* I  _
 7#"#, 98 - 5.  5  ?8 %#  _ ?8 <

H RA#H H" (3) 8 ?  %5  8 * 0.000 5


 _, 6 ` #

.%,#  #. @  # A#@;

 2D4D4

#   5* ' 5A#@ 5 7  ?'   :1  5)3 6* J 

7#"#, 98 - 5.  5  ?8 %#  _ ?8 < +") ' 7#


.
 _

88

( 13 –4) (

(One way Anova) !  (  => 
 . % PI  
 $ %  4
5  F58 _, F 58 +, 7# C #" @
5 5
 , 7#
" 5 7#
"
Sig. 5" df
HHHHHH"
  0.00 44.02 2.95 5 11.81 7#
3.84
?' H
HHHHH 
0.07 119 8.05 7#
124 19.86 C

H* 5",H F 5H8  6  ' <  7# #" 5


#+   "

5H9  "  5", F 58   #. " 5 #9#" (3.84) 5 #.8 (44.02)

F 5H8  "  5", F 58 7 #  " 1  J    9 <#9 #9' 5

+"H) ' 7#


 #   5* ' 5A#@ 5 7  ?'   1 #' 5

# * 
 _
 7#"#, 98 - 5.  5  ?8 %#  _ ?8 <

H RA#H H" (3) H8 ?  %5  8 * 0.000 5


 _, 6 `

.%,#  #. @  # A#@;

 (F 3D4D4

#   5* ' 5A#@ 5 7  ?'   :1  5)3 6* J 

7#"#, 98 - 5.  5  ?8 %#  _ ?8 < +") ' 7#


. 
 *` _

89

( 14 –4) (

(One way Anova) !  (  => 
 (F . % PI  
 $ %  4
5  F58 _, F 58 +, 7# C #" @
5 5
 , 7#
" 5 7#
"
Sig. 5" df
HHHHHH"
  0.00 36.43 3.71 5 7.43 7#
?' 3.84 H
HHHHH 
0.10 119 12.43 7#
124 19.86 C

H* 5",H F 5H8  6  ' <  7# #" 5


#+   "

5H9  "  5", F 58   #. " 5 #9#" (3.84) 5 #.8 (36.43)

F 5H8  "  5", F 58 7 #  " 1  J    9 <#9 #9' 5

+"H) ' 7#


 #   5* ' 5A#@ 5 7  ?'   1 #' 5

H*` _ H
 7#"#,H 98 - 5.  5  ?8 %#  _ ?8 <

RA# " (3) 8 ?  .%5  8 * 0.000 5


 _, 6 ` # *  


.%,#  #. @  # A#@; 

" 4D4D4

#   5* ' 5A#@ 5 7  ?'   :1  5)3 6* J 

7#"#, 98 - 5.  5  ?8 %#  _ ?8 < +") ' 7#


.<" _

90

( 15 –4) (

(One way Anova) !  (  => 
" . % PI  
 $ %  4
5  F58 _, F 58 +, 7# C #" @
5 5
 , 7#
" 5 7#
"
Sig. 5" df
HHHHHH"
  0.00 21.18 3.71 5 8.41 7#
?' 3.84 H
HHHHH 
0.10 119 11.32 7#
124 19.73 C

H* 5",H F 5H8  6  ' <  7# #" 5


#+   "

5H9  "  5", F 58   #. " 5 #9#" (3.84) 5 #.8 (21.18)

F 5H8  "  5", F 58 7 #  " 1  J    9 <#9 #9' 5

+"H) ' 7#


 #   5* ' 5A#@ 5 7  ?'   1 #' 5

H* <" _
 7#"#, 98 - 5.  5  ?8 %#  _ ?8 <

H RA#H H" (3) 8 ?  .%5  8 * 0.000 5


 _, 6 ` #

.%,#  #. @  # A#@;

   
 - 5D4D4

#   5* ' 5A#@ 5 7  ?'   :1  5)3 6* J 

7#"#, 98 - 5.  5  ?8 %#  _ ?8 < +") ' 7#


.5 . 7 #.! _



91

( 16 –4) (

(One way Anova) !  (  => 
   
 - . % PI  
 $ %  4
5  F58 _, F 58 +, 7# C #" @
5 5
 , 7#
" 5 7#
"
Sig. 5" df

0.00 25.27 4.17 4 16.68 7# "


  3.84
0.16 120 19.80 7#  
?' C
124 36.47

H* 5",H F 5H8  6  ' <  7# #" 5


#+   "

5H9  "  5", F 58   #. " 5 #9#" (3.84) 5 #.8 (25.27)

F 5H8  "  5", F 58 7 #  " 1  J    9 <#9 #9' 5

+"H) ' 7#


 #   5* ' 5A#@ 5 7  ?'   1 #' 5

7 #.!H _ H
 7#"#,H 98 - 5.  5  ?8 %#  _ ?8 <

RA# " (3) 8 ?  .%5  8 * 0.000 5


 _, 6 ` # * 5 .

.%,#  #. @  # A#@; 


92

8" ()4

 )  => 

RA#  1K5

7#@ 2K5
93

8" ()4

 )  => 

7#"#, 98  5,  5  7#"#; ("  @3 '    =) '

  5A,2  5"#4 ,b#" #. @  RA#   #) #  @3 * 4'

#H. 7H "  7#)3  #. ! 7>   5,  6*  2 @3 ' #.+

H H bH#" H8 5H# 5,  ' #. @   RA#  6* =) 

5H  7#H"#   1 @  # ?' 5,  RA# * J   7#@

:  #" 5, 

=>  1D5

:5 RA#   5,  7@

:. 3  >  4  " =>  1D1D5

7# 9 ) 7#


 #  5A#@ 5  >  1  RA#  7#!

?8 %#  _ ?8 < +") ' (7 #. + 5
  5
 <" 5",#

 3@ (Sig.) 5 58 7/" .7  5 ' 7#"#, 98 - 5.  5 

?8 < +") ' #"  (.462) 1", # ,' 7#


 #  ' #" 

< +") / 7#


 #  / ,3 5 58
 <8 C#3 I
 *

.?8
94

?H'  #. 7.-   (2009) "# 5,  5 ( 5  6* ?3

: .?8 #, 5  " 5",# 7#


 5-  5", " # 5A#@ 5 7 

5- 2  ?8 " +"    #. 7.-   (2011) "  5,  5 (

.5   5",#

*#,H 7#
 #   ,   ?8    & ,3  

# ?8#" #9 7 =  +," 5> #  A#, 2 & ?8 5#' , '

.?8 9 5"#  # ; 5  7# #"  @ ' ?8 . 78  9 #. 

:. 3  $4  4  " =>  2D1D5

%#  _ ?8 < +") ' 5",# 7# 9 >B  1  RA#  7#!

(Sig.) 5H 58 7


" "7  5 ' 7#"#, 98 - 5.  5  ?8

<H +"H) ' #"  (.297) 1", # ,' 5",# 7# 9 ' #"   3@

5"H,# 7#H 9 H/ ,3 5 58


 <9 5+, 5 I
 * ?8

.7  5 ' 7#"#, 98 - 5.  ?8 < +") /

%, #.@3 7# #"  5   @ ?8 D#, 5* RA#   " #

#H
  H,#" ?8H %#  9   5#3" ?8 5
" #9 ' ., #9 1"+

H 5"#8 +" ) J3 () ?8    ?8 5 , 5 ?8

.7# #"   /! #-

' #, ?8 _ 7 #. 5  7# 9     & ,3  

6H* 2   ; ?8 5 ' 5. 7# 9 6* 2    ?8 5
" #9
95

 4' & ?8 5 #    #. "   ?8 5 ' 5. 7# 9

.D# "   ?8 5 # ' #, ?8 _ 7# 9

: :  $4  4  " =>  3D1D5

_H ?8 < +") ' 5


  5
 <" >B  1  RA#  7#!

5H 5H8 7/" 7  5 ' 7#"#, 98 - 5.  5  ?8 %# 

H' #"  ( .526) 1", # ,' 5


  5
 <" ' #"   3@ (Sig.)

5
  5
 <" / ,3 5 58
 <8 C#3 I
 * ?8 < +")

.7  5 ' 7#"#, 98 - 5.  ?8 < +") /

H #, 98 _ '  5 9  5'


 7 #.  RA#   " #

?8H #H
" 5H  5'
 '  5* " & ?+ )'B" ?8 5 #

7 H#" 98 ?# 5*   B ( ?8 _ ?8 5
" #9 # <


.#  7 + %   !" .*B 5@@

?H'  #. 7.-   (2009) "# 5,  5 ( 5  6* ?3

: .?8 #, 5  " 5",# 7#


 5-  5", " # 5A#@ 5 7 

5- 2  ?8 " +"    #. 7.-   (2011) "  5,  5 (

.5   5",#

?8H 5H
" #H9 *`H 7  ' 98    & ,3  

H 6", #   & 5 5 7 "  *  '  # &  
96

?8H 5H
" #H9 7H  H' 98 <=#3  ` # ?8 ' . =# > 7 "

.  

:: :  $4  4  " =>  4D1D5

%#  _ ?8 < +") ' 7 #. + >B  1  RA#  7#!

(Sig.) 5 58 7/" 7  5 ' 7#"#, 98 - 5.  5  ?8

< +") ' #"  (.417) 1", # ,' 7 #. + ' #"    3@

< +")  7 #. + / ,3 5 58


 <8 C#3 I
 # ?8

.7  5 ' 7#"#, 98 - 5.  5  ?8 %#  _ ?8

7    7#! ' . !   98 7 #. + 5* RA#   " #

98 5#  # #  !" 98 7 #. +  #, 7 )#   53

+ = #


 7  ;  %+ ?8 5 ' . #. +  53 7 ' '

.?8 5 ' 5/#" 5*2 98 7 #.

7#
 #-   7@   (2006) <#)9 5 ( 5  6* ?3

( : 598 7#


 '  
 b 5",# 5"#8 5#' ' >` ",#

#.   5# 5*#, 7# ! &# *   7@   (2004) #", 5,  5

.  98    ?8 A 

?8 < +") ' ., 7 #. + #9    & ,3  

A#,  :-  b" #3 ++    ?8 5


" #9 "  1  b

.   ?8 5 D# ; 5 


97

: :  >  4  " =>  5D1D5

#H   5H* H' 5A#@H 5 7  ?'    RA#  7#! :

7#"#,H 98 - 5.  5  ?8 %#  _ ?8 < +") ' 7#


  ?8 5


" 7  ' 98 #8    & ,3   .I  _


 ?8 5
" #9 <=#3   7*` I3 .   & b I  :#" : 

   98  & .   ?8 5 ' 5> 5  %#, C#" 

+") '   ?8  , 5*     ?8 ,#   b# ; 

.?8 5 <

#H   5H* H' 5A#@H 5 7  ?'    RA#  7#! :# #>

7#"#,H 98 - 5.  5  ?8 %#  _ ?8 < +") ' 7#


 )H3 *#H :H  98    & ,3   .
 _


1H   ?8  ,  b 7   1" # #   ?8 ,

H' 5H8    ?8 1" # #   ?8 5 5#' <=#3  >

?8H 5H H,# *# :  98  & .#."" 7# #" G 

#H   >     ?8    . 2 & 5#'  "  

.?8 5 < +") #.     

#H   5H* H' 5A#@H 5 7  ?'    RA#  7#! :#>#>

7#"#,H 98 - 5.  5  ?8 %#  _ ?8 < +") ' 7#


H9 .*` :  98    & ,3   . 


 *` _

98

H 5H'
 H 6", #   & 5#' <=#3  "   ?8 5
"

%H#  _ ?8 5 <=#3  & >   ?8  , 5*  ., 

:H H 98H   . H


 *` / #
" 98 "8  5  ?8

#+; * ' :#


 :#
  6", #     ?8 ,# .*`

<H +") ' 1*     ?8 ,  #+, #.   

.?8 5

#   5* ' 5A#@ 5 7  ?'    RA#  7#! :#
" 

7#"#, 98 - 5.  5  ?8 %#  _ ?8 < +") ' 7#


73  ?8 %#  '   98    & ,3   .<" _


@   & 5#


'  "   ?8 5
" 9  
+, . 4' . "

   ?8 #   53 7 "  98  # 5",#  RA# 

.?8 5 5#' <=#3 , ' 5*

#   5* ' 5A#@ 5 7  ?'    RA#  7#! :#,#

7#"#, 98 - 5.  5  ?8 %#  _ ?8 < +") ' 7#


5 . . #.! :  98    & ,3   .5 . 7 #.! _


RA#  @  ?8 5 < +") '   ?8  , 5*  

.?8 5 < +")  > 1     ?8  ,   5",# 
99

 ) 2D5

:  #" b#" @ 5,  RA# =) '

%#  _ ?8 < +") ' f)  #*>2 7#


 #   ,  
 K1

.7#"#, 98 - 5.  5  ?8 %#  _ 5  ?8

 :
j  5 7#,  =   7  5 ' 5#
 ?8 %#    5* K2

.7#
 #   ,#" 59
 <9 +#9  :
) +#9

R "  ,  #*  %  7  5 ' 5#
 ?8 %#  (! K3

#@@ Computerized Audit Assested Techniques (CAAT)  ; ?8

.5", 5",# -  ,  =


 7#"#, ?8 _

 , 5*B" 5  <=#3  98 


" 7  ' 5#
 ?8 %#  #8 5* K4

7  .A#+ 7# ! ' ?8 5 5#' <=#3 <#  7#
 # 

.7#
 #  7#"+ # ' 5  5"

5H#
 ?8 %  #,8 ( ' #." 59 7 
  %,# < . ' 5* K5

H' #H,#, =  "


 #.  7#
  7# #"   5# #9   7# #"

.?8 < +") ' #.*2 5   5# 7#


 #

7#
 -  7#
 (  
 7#
 #  #- " K6

<#8 I,B   & %  5+!  ( ' #.  <#';  #.#" #*!  5",#

 <#';  7#
 #   ,   † # %  5+! :  7# #"

.#*# 
100

b"   ?8 %#  _ 1" 


 ",# #-  , + 5* K7

.?8 5
" 5
 : +2 5'# 7## "

 5  =#9"| 7# ,  ++ () ' ?8 %#   , 5* K8

5-'#     7#


 #  ' 7 +  , # =)  ,

.#* ,  #* 

5 . .-  "8  , %  #!;  ?8 %#  C#) 5* K9

.J#@  <" %#@ ( #


#"

 H  #.   5# 5,  # ' 5"9, b"    = 4"  , K10

:5"9, b#"2 5 7#. b#" D9  C) * = > ' .,

5H-  H " H  5H# ?8 #


 5  ?8 #
 " ?'  K

.7#
 # 

.?8 5 < , ' #*> 7#


 #   , 7#8 @ K%

. ",# H
 G  #.#,#
 7#
 #  5-  o " > KG

5HA" ' 
  5",# 7#
   7#,  b#" =     K

.7#
 # 

1H 78+  C) I3  b#" 7#,  = 4" b#" @ KH*

RA#H  #H.9"#+ _   B :." & 5>" 7 / I3 " 5# 5, 

.5# 5,  #. 7@ 


101

<  >

  <  :0/ 

N   7 O      :


  0 (2009) , 5#^ " K1

.<*#9 * 2 <# %  (   

R    # #  7#


 # /, : .(2009)  # " D2

.39K24J    "


 !  5@ 5 ! 2 5 ,  #> 


         ! : 


. % ("
 .(2008) #*   K3

.# % 

N 
:N  
N" 
 (2008) ,  "#
'#    "  K4

 
 " & 5
# 5 !      !   :F (      


.1
 22 < ;  #@8 5

 
%       : (2009) '   ' "# K5

5#H, N    (  !    


    !  

.2 # #


 7#,  5 5 2 5
# <!  ^ ,#

.2 /(   !  =#3@   ;


  
. % ("
  (2005)    5
 K6

N  .N$  "


  
 8  (2004) ,   #+ #", K7

H^ 6   5+  


3   -       

5H ;  5H# 7#H,  5H #H


 7#H,  5H"
 #H 5
# <! 

.2 ##

102

  R($3     


7     .(2005)  , , K8

.2 :# (   !  =#3@

<  7 !H  N


) 0 ;
 ) * 4 .(2008) , 5 , K9

.?! 5'#9>

5  ; 5",# 7#


 -  5#
 5"#8 +" ) > .(2010) #! <# K10


) 0 * -
  .(5  5, ) 5",# 7#
 58> <# '

.334K 305 J J 2 


 26    


   "   ! "
 

" *
 : (2010) 1 # I K11

5H ,# 5#, R 


  
:!$ )  
 -  "
 

.2 :"    5
# 5",# ,8 #2

5H
 H #@H 7H  5" 7#"#, ?8 %#  7#"#, "8   K12

.2012 #
 5  
   ",#

   N  * (2010) # ,   #  * K13

.@ :5 ,; !  < 5


#

N>  N "


N  
     .(2005) :#3  " 
l* K14

#@H8 5H  I#  ,  


 `  9 b" R   

(5#@H8 5   5'


 #@8 ) #
! 7 5 2 5   5
# 5 ; 
 

.26K3J 2 #


103

 ' 5A# ; (#! 5#


' = 2 <=#3 9 ?8" .(2000).
l* K15

.268K203 J J I# 
 ! #>  R 
 ."5# 

' ?8 5 ' 7#


 #   , 5#' _ ".(2003)  7#"  K16

.268 – 253J 12 :


 30 : R 
  "2

  ( M- .$  "


 * *  R(2009) #' , ! K17

# 5
#<!  ^ ,# 5#,"    Q .$  
"    0

.2 # #


 5 ;  5# 7#,  5 #
 7#,  5"


*    7  
  (  J2 6 (2011)   "  "  K18

.2 # 5"


 # 5
# <!  ^ <   5+  

(H   !H  A    I    # R(2008)   "  K19

.# 5,#, 5
"+

!H  A     
7    (2010) F# x#"  =  #, K20

.# (  

-  5
#   * ("
 : 
7  * (2010) * " #+, K21

.5 ,;

7 H" 7H" N N   N  .(2006)   " #!* , K22

.5 ,; "  7 #!,

  N "
N   N .(2001) , #   D#3 " @ K23

.5 ,; !  < 5


#
104

>  (   
    3

  :F (  .(2009) %" 6@ K24

H^ ,H# 5#H, N    


    !    

.2 ?3 7" i 5


# <! 

5H#  5  ; 5- 2 5


  #
 #
 #+; (2006) * " 
@ K25

K106 J J  #> 
 I!  5
#  
) ?    7#


.137

5H #> 5H
"+ .5  5"#8  ?8 @ .(2009)  ?  " #> K26

.!   5#"+ %    :@ 5


#

4N N-    *  $ 64 8  (2011) @   


 K27

.2 # 5"


 # 5
# R<!  ^ ,# 5#, (  
)  

.N$ N    : 8  J2 6 (2005) -'# " #* %


 K28

<!  ^ 6   5+  


3  : 0    Q "  
 $

.2 # #


 5 ;  5# 7#,  5 #
 7#,  5"
 # 5
#

!  <,   1+  


% . % ("
 ( 2008) #, "  
 K29

.# 5#"+  (  

!  5'#9>        * (2008)  ?  " ,#8 K30

.2 :# (  

5
# 7 !  :?! 2 5
"+ R& ("
  
.(2008) ,  )#9 K31

.#, ?!
105

N N $ .N$    * : (2006) 3+@ #,^ <#)9 K32

# 5 7" i 5


# <!  ^ ,# 5#,  
3   Q   "

.2 ?3 #2 

      *  $ P


 (2003) :, *#! *#-  !9 D33

<!  ^ 6   5+ .   7  (   :  


  !3

.2 # :#


 7#,  5"
 # 5
#

' 7#
 #  5 9 5A" JA#@ > .(2007)  #  # +9 K34


 13  R  5 2 :#@ ' 5 5, " 5/! 5"#8 +#

.43K9 J J 2 ?3 7" i 5


# .2

 59"+ 5,  5 5


  %#, (2007)  I#" , #@8 D35

.< – 
 " & 5
#     < 5 " 5
  %# 

(   
3       64 (2004)  #, # 598 D36

.2 7" i 5
# <!  ^ ,# 5#, R   7   3

2 %#H    :<*#H9 . M  * $    (2002)  ,   3+ K37

.(   ! 

.# 5# #9 5 #


 (2011 )   #9 ",# "
 ( K38

  #H .    )   


.(2006) D' #,^ 5 #+ K39

.(   !  <,


106

5H  H  5H #> 5


"+  
7  * (2006) #. " , K40

.5 ,; !  5 ;

 6 7N    
  
#  * I P
 (2011) l#  + K41

5#H, N   N 


(520) *N  
 
    $ C)   

.2 # +,2 ?! 5


# <!  ^ ,#

5H #> 5
"+      !  !    R(2007)   K42

.# " 5


#   :7"

5  5"#8  (2009)   "@ A#> #"/  3+@ % i  * K43

H8 ' :#@  5   59"+ 5,  :  ; ",# 7#


 #- - '

.39-1J 45 
 7 5 ,  % *$  ? 
 #,


N" 
N N     *
"  
(2007)  #   . K44

5H
# !
3 N   
#  - .$  
  
R!
3   

.2 59"+ =#9"

*    
    .(2005) , -# ! !#* #  K45

5   5
#  9 b" :
    *
"  (    

.2005 #, I#  , 


 ` 5 ; 
  #@8 5 5 2
107

 3 <  : :

1- Abu-Musa, Ahmad A.(2004), "Auditing E-Business: New Challenges for


External Auditors". Journal of American Academy of Business, Vol. 4, No
1/2, pp28-41.
2- Al-Eqab، M. & Ismail، N. (2011). Contingency Factors And Accounting
Information System Design In Jordanian Companies، IBIMA Business
Review،Vol(9)،No(11) 2011: 1-13.
3- Al-Jabari, T. (2004), The Impact of Information Technology on the
Internal Audit Process in Jordan, Master Degree, Amman Arab
University for Graduate Studies, Faculty of Managerial and Financial
Graduate Studies, Amman, Jordan.
4- Archambeault، Deborah S.، (2002). " The relation between Corporate
Governance Strength and Fraudulent Financial Reporting: Evidence
from SEC Enforcement Cases " ، USA: Prentice-Hall International، Inc.
5- Arens, A.A., Elder, R.J., and Beasley, M.S. (2005). Auditing and
Assurance Services, An integrated approach. 11 Edition. Prentice-Hall.
6- Ball، K.، (2003)، The Use of Human Resource Information Systems: A
Survey، Personnel Review، Vol. 30، No. 6، pp: 677-693.
7- Coram , P., Ng, J., and D. Woodliff, A survey of time budget pressure
and reduced audit quality among Australian auditors, Australia- Al-Fehaid,
A. And Higson, A., (2008) Auditing in an IT Environment: Its Impact in
Saudi Arabia The Icfai Journal of Audit Practice, Vol. V, No. 1, 2008,
PP:7-23.
8- Cohen، Jeffrey، (2004). " The Corporate Governance Mosaic and
Financial Reporting Quality " ، Journal of Accounting Literature، Vol.
43, Issue 1، PP: 33-34.
108

9- Dalci، I & Tanıs، V (2009). Benefits of Computerized Accounting


Information Systems on the JIT Production Systems، Review of Social،
Economic & Business Studies، Vol.2، 45-64.
10- Denisi، A. S.، and Griffin، R. W.، (2010). Human Resource
Management، Houghton Miflin Company، Boston، 2001. p: 97.
11- Elliott, M., Edwards, J. And Dawson, R. (2007), An improved process
model for internal auditing, Loughborough University, Department of
Computer Science, Managerial Auditing Journal, Vol. 22 No. 6, 2007, pp.
552-565.
12- Grant, G.H, Miller, K.C And Alali, F. (2008), The effect of IT controls
on financial reporting, Managerial Auditing Journal, Vplume:23,
Issue:8, pp:803-823.
13- Laudon، K.، and Laudon، J.، (2002). Organization and Technology in
the Networked Enterprise، 4th Edition، Printice Hall، New Jersy.
14- Malhotra، N. K. (2003)، Marketing research، New Jersey: Prentice
Hall.
15- Matta، F.J. and Fuerst، W.L. and Barney، J.B.، (2005).” Information
Technology and Sustained competitive Advantage”، A Resource-Based
Analysis، MIS Quarterly، 19 (4). P: 934.
16- Salehi، M. & Abdipour، A. (2011). A Study Of The Barriers Of
Implementation Of Accounting Information System: Case Of Listed
Companies In Tehran Stock Exchange، Journal Of Economics And
Behavioral Studies، 2 (2): 76-85.
17- Sarens , G., (2009) , Internal Auditing Research: Where are we
going? Editorial , International Journal of Auditing , Université
Catholique de Louvain , University of Antwerp. 13: 1-7 .
109

18- Sayana، S.، Vilhelmson B. and Thulin E.، (2008). " Using CAATs to
Support IS Audit "، Information Systems Control Journal, Vol. 1, No 3,
P: 1 – 5.
19- Schneider, A., (2010) , ASSESSMENT OF INTERNAL AUDITING
BY AUDIT COMMITTEES , Academy of Accounting and Financial
Studies Journal, Volume 14, Number 2, PP:19-26.
20- Sekaran, U. (2000), Research Methods For Business, A Skill-Building
Approach. John Wiley and Sons Inc, New York.
21- Tucker, H. (2001). "IT And The Audit", Journal Of
Accountancy,OnlineAvailableIssues,September.www.Aicpa.Org/Pubs/Jofa/
Sept2001/Tucker.Ht.
22- Tucker، George، (2010). ”IT and The Audit”، Journal of Accountancy،
Vol، 192، PP: 41-48.
23- Whittington، Ray، (2008)، New Audit Documentation Requirement;
SAS 96 Raise the Bar for Audit Documentation، Adding Specific
Requirement in Several Areas، Journal of Accountancy . Vol .65، pp. 72-
92.
110

(1) * 

 
 

3 - 

 ‫  ا‬/ ‫آ


 ال‬

*  ! Y *

:5", 
:%, 

,,,9   5

:C)  5 #",


  !  
"    

        
   
  
 

?8 < +") ' 7#


 #  5*  :
  5,  6* :.
   5*2 7  5 ' 7#"#, 98 - 5.  #. , 7#8

6* ( #
 , 1 B" # 59' 5A,2  5"#;#"    ,5,  C)
.+9' 
 b" F ^; 5# 5," 7# #"

 #
  !
;

&  () 
111

  :(3 *

:*+,-. ‫اه‬%1 234‫* ا‬5$6‫! ا‬5%. 27 (×) ‫ و"! إرة‬#$%&

:I  K1
>  

:
 K2
5 , 35  8  25 5 , 25  8
5 , 55  8  45 5 , 45  8  35
> B' 5 , 55 

: 
 *` K3
+, " I# "
# " ,#
6  

:?8 # ' <" 7  ,  K4


5 , 10  8  5 7  , 5  8
5 , 20  8  15 5 , 15  8  10
> B' 5 , 20

:5 . 7 #.! K5


(ACPA) "  #8 %,# (CPA)   #8 %,#
_ (ACCA)    #8 %,#
112

:    :(3 

   U

/
   U
/
  

 



4 *

 
' #   ,   ?8 (+,
.1
.?8 5  ,  5#@8 <
1'
  , ?8 5
" ?8 #8
.2
. ,#,  !" 7#
 # "
 5"#8 +" ) J3 () ?8 #8
.3
.7# #"   /! #-
7# #"  5   @ ?8 D#,
.4
.5#3" ?8 5
" #9 1"+ %, #.@3
#  7# 9"   ?8 %#  #8
.5
.7#
 #   5"#8 
3
 , 5  =# " ?8 <=#3 9
.6
.7#
 # 
<+ 7#"  ,#" ?8 %#  #8
.7
.?8 5 #;
# ",# #-  + ?8 %#  #8
.8
.?8 5 , &  5# 7
5",#  7 =   '" ?8 %#  #8
.9
.?8 5
" #9
#   5"#8 
3" ?8 %#  #8
.10
.<, <@" 7#

5
"# 5 5
  = 4" ?8 %#  #8
.11
.?8 5 ' 5, R "
113

5, ?8 R " 


 98 & !
.12
.?8 5 '
" 5 #9 7# = 4" ?8 %#  #8
.13
.#.)' # ?8 R "
5 ?8 #
  ,#" ?8 %#  #8
.14
.?8 5 ,
     "
_ '  5 9  5'
 7 #.
)'B" ?8 5 #  #, 98 .15
.?+
?8 #
" ?8 _ 5   5'
 '
.16
.?8 5
" #9 # <

  5
  5
 7 " ?8 %, 
.17
.?8 ' 5@@ 5" 7 #" 18#
98 #.' 
  5#@8 < %, 
.18
.?8 5 #; 5",#  :#
 7 "
 ?' 98 _ 5 . 7 #.! ' 
.19
.?8 5 # ; 7#,
 , 5# 7*`  ?8 @
.20
.?8 5
" #9  18
.*B 5@@ 7 #" 98 ?#
.21
.#  7 + %   !"
*#, # 5> ?8 ?+" 98 #
.22
.?8 5 , 
    
+  53 7 ' ' 98 5#
.23
.?8 5 ' . #.
+ 5# 7 # = "#" 5 #
,
.24
.98 7 #.
114

7 #. + ' 5


 b#"2  <#'
.25
.5#@8 < ' 98
98 7 #. + =4" #
 7  ; #8
.26
.?8 5 ' 5/#" 5*2
' . !   98 7 #. +
.27
.53 7    7#!
98 7 #. +  7 )# #,
.28
.#  !"
 
 $ 
 : 
 "   $
#*   5#3#" ?8 5 :@
.29
.++ 5"
' ., 5#
' 7 + ) ?8 5 - 
.30
.?8 5 ,
?8 5 ++ 5@@ 5. 
.31
.5#3"
?8 ' 5 9 5'
 7 #. 98 %#, 
.32
.5#3" ?8 5
" #9
53 5  7 " 98 %#,
.33
.?8 5 ,
 5> 7#"  ,#" 98 #8
.34
?8 5
    6 7
' ?8 5  RA#   5 #,
.35
.5#@8 < ' ?8 
3
' ?8 5 RA#   98 #8
.36
.5- 
 ' #9 6#,  ?8 (+,
.37
.?8 5
 5 7 = ;
115

?8 5  7 =  :@


.38
.5)#"
 
($ 6

# ' ?8 #,   ?8#" #9
.39
. @8 78" ?8 R "
# ' #,   ?8#" #9
.40
.)'  !" 5"#   5"#, 7#

  ' #, ?8   ?8#" #9
.41
.< | #.
'  :,  #9  A#,
 ?8 5  599 RA#  @
.42
.#. #
3  9+  ?> 
116

( 2 ) * 

 
   2 3 6

 *0   
3   (

5"
 # 5
# # " -
 " !"   #,2 1

5"
 # 5
# #, i ,   #,2 2

5"
 # 5
#  ,    3

 5
# )#9 I#'   4

5   5
# )" >*   5

l 5
# #"  #>   6
117

(3) * 

# !  $ () *  >)7 (  => 

SEX

Cumulative
Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent
Valid 1.00 9.7 80.0
100 80.0
2.00 16.6 100.0
25 20.0
Total 125 100.0 100.0

AGE

Cumulative
Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent
Valid 1.00 30 24.0 9.7 9.7
2.00 56 44.8 16.6 26.3
3.00 24 19.2 25 51.3
4.00 5 4.0 22.2 73.5
5.00 10 8.0 26.3 100.0
Total 125 100.0 100.0

EDU

Cumulative
Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent
Valid 1.00 0 0 0 0
2.00 110 88.0 4.2 87.5
3.00 10 8.0 2.8 89.3
4.00 5 4.0 9.7 100.0
Total 125 100.0 100.0

EXP

Cumulative
Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent
Valid 1.00 76 60.8 25 25
2.00 20 16.0 15.2 40.7
3.00 19 15.2 22.2 62.9
4.00 5 4.0 16.6 78.5
5.00 5 4.0 20.8 100.0
Total 125 100.0 100.0
118

Descriptive Statistics

N Minimum Maximum Mean Std. Deviation


Q1 125 3.00 5.00 4.30 0.67
Q2 125 2.00 5.00 3.8567 0.8782
Q3 125 3.00 5.00 4.4266 0.5756
Q4 125 2.00 5.00 4.6634 0.5678
Q5 125 1.00 5.00 4.2156 0.7490
Q6 125 1.00 5.00 3.0678 1.0155
Q7 125 1.00 5.00 3.8077 0.9068
Q8 125 3.00 5.00 4.1789 0.8409
Q9 125 2.00 5.00 4.3188 0.6090
Q10 125 3.00 5.00 3.9676 0.6571
Q11 125 2.00 5.00 4.1134 0.7623
Q12 125 1.00 5.00 4.0556 0.7245
Q13 125 1.00 5.00 4.5169 0.5863
Q14 125 1.00 5.00 4.7090 0.5457
Q15 125 1.00 5.00 4.6923 0.5587
Q16 125 2.00 5.00 4.4254 0.6488
Q17 125 2.00 5.00 4.3878 0.6378
Q18 125 2.00 5.00 3.9323 0.7455
Q19 125 1.00 5.00 3.9943 0.8099
Q20 125 1.00 5.00 4.3651 0.7201
Q21 125 1.00 5.00 4.2769 0.5356
Q22 125 1.00 5.00 4.0309 0.8271
Q23 125 1.00 5.00 4.1278 0.8156
Q24 125 1.00 5.00 4.2356 0.7178
Q25 125 2.00 5.00 4.4313 0.6499
Q26 125 2.00 5.00 4.2843 0.5999
Q27 125 1.00 5.00 4.0156 0.8355
Q28 125 1.00 5.00 4.2671 0.6643
Q29 125 2.00 5.00 3.9666 0.9547
Q30 125 1.00 5.00 3.9577 0.8267
Q31 125 1.00 5.00 4.0281 0.7743
Q32 125 2.00 5.00 4.2760 0.6656
Q33 125 3.00 5.00 4.2346 0.5866
Q34 125 1.00 5.00 4.1534 0.7390
Q35 125 2.00 5.00 4.3467 0.6291
Q36 125 3.00 5.00 3.9478 0.8166
Q37 125 2.00 5.00 4.1089 0.7666
Q38 125 3.00 5.00 4.2380 0.6788
Q39 125 2.00 5.00 4.0416 0.7290
Valid N (listwise) 125
119

Variables Entered/Removed(b)

Variables Variables
Model Entered Removed Method
1 TOTALQ(a) . Enter
a All requested variables entered.
b Dependent Variable: TOTALP

Model Summary

Adjusted R Std. Error of


Model R Square Square the Estimate
1 .462 .202 .47953
a Predictors: (Constant)، TOTALQ

ANOVA(b)

Sum of
Model Squares df Mean Square F Sig.
1 Regressio 10.239 2.239 40.736
1 .000(a)
n
Residual 9.41 1.893
123
Total 19.380
124
a Predictors: (Constant)، TOTALQ
b Dependent Variable: TOTALP

Variables Entered/Removed(b)

Variables Variables
Model Entered Removed Method
1 TOTALG(a) . Enter
a All requested variables entered.
b Dependent Variable: TOTALP

Model Summary

Adjusted R Std. Error of


Model R Square Square the Estimate
1 .297 .241 .46758
a Predictors: (Constant)، TOTALG
120

ANOVA(b)

Sum of
Model Squares df Mean Square F Sig.
1 Regressio
44.02 .000(a)
n 11.81 5 2.95
Residual 8.05 119 0.07
Total 19.86 124
a Predictors: (Constant)، TOTALG
b Dependent Variable: TOTALP

Coefficients(a)

Unstandardized Standardized
Coefficients Coefficients

Model B Std. Error Beta t Sig.


1 (Constan 8.640
1.951 .310 .000
t)
TOTALG .462 .077 .498 8.640 .000
a Dependent Variable: TOTALP

Variables Entered/Removed(b)

Variables Variables
Model Entered Removed Method
1 TOTALS(a) . Enter
a All requested variables entered.
b Dependent Variable: TOTALP

Model Summary

Adjusted R Std. Error of


Model R Square Square the Estimate
1 .526 .294 .45101
a Predictors: (Constant)، TOTALS

ANOVA(b)

Sum of
Model Squares df Mean Square F Sig.
1 Regressio
4 46.754 .000(a)
n 16.68 4.17
Residual 19.80 120 0.16
Total 36.47 124
a Predictors: (Constant)، TOTALS
b Dependent Variable: TOTALP
121

Variables Entered/Removed(b)

Variables Variables
Model Entered Removed Method
1 TOTALQ(a) . Enter
a All requested variables entered.
b Dependent Variable: TOTALP

Model Summary

Adjusted R Std. Error of


Model R Square Square the Estimate
1 .462 .202 .47953
a Predictors: (Constant)، TOTALQ

Coefficients(a)

Unstandardized Standardized
Coefficients Coefficients

Model B Std. Error Beta t Sig.


1 (Constant 6.396
1.723 .306 .000
)
TOTALS .553 .081 .548 6.396 .000
a Dependent Variable: TOTALP

You might also like