Professional Documents
Culture Documents
!
"
#
$%
&
'$ !
()
400920134 :
*
,
-%
$
*
($3
3
-
(3
()4
2013/2012
ب
ج
د
-
1*2 )3 %, # 4' 5#, 6* 7. 8 #
.
1" # 6 ! <, 7#. 5#
, 1
#
! 1' 1 * # 7" 5#, 6* + 18 # #
=> ' > #. , 59 .#- =" <=9 =# . 5#, 6* 5!8#
#+ ? ?+ ,
#
6
7
5#/ # 2 C! 7# =##" " 7=#)
5"" 9 7# ' D# ", 7B* D3 7- 7.,
.<* " ! 5#, 6* +, 8 + #.A* 79!
#'
5" (
و
8
4)
9
5#,
% 5
# F3
G 5#, < #
9 !
H* =*;
7# I.'
+ 5A#8
# !2 5A#8
& 5"
5/#" J
5
; 5/#" J
$
:(3
()4
2 . 1K1
3 #.A, 5, 5 ! 2K1
4 5, :* 3K1
5 5, 5* 4K1
6 5, 7#)' 5K1
7 5, 6K1
7 5, 7 7K1
8 5A; 7#+@ 8K1
&
7
::
()4
11 &
0
:(3
;
11 . 1K2
13 ?8 :
2K2
15 ?8 :* 3K2
16 ?8 5* 4K2
ز
17 ?8 # 5K2
18 7#
#-
:
6K2
20 7#
5-
# ! 7K2
21 7#
5-
@#
8K2
23 (AIS) 5", 5",# 7#
-
9K2
26 7#
#"
; /! - ' ?8 10K2
28 7#
#"
; /! - ' ?8 53 ?#+
11K2
30 5", 5",# 5-
Q ?8 7= 12K2
31 5 5"#8 +") +# 13K2
5",# 7#
-
, +# 7#"+ +! 14K2
32
?8 5 < 5",
33 ?8 5 < 15K2
38
::
;
38 5"
5/#" 7#, 16K2
48 5
5/#" 7#, 17K2
55 59"#, 7#, 5# 5, # 18K2
:;:
()4
57 5, R.
1K3
57 5
5, ( 2K3
58 5, < 3K3
60 <2 7#"> ?@ 4K3
61 5A#@; 5#
5K3
61 7#
7#
#" ( %#, 6K3
62 5, 7/ 7K3
64 5, G
8K3
4
"
(
=> :<
()4
67 5, 5
JA#@ 1K4
ح
(
>
4)
(
!
$ (
*
58 5#@ <, 5 7#
#", C (1K3)
60 / ?#, 7#"> #
58 (2K3)
67 5'^
%, 5, 5
( ( 1 K4)
7#
9 ) 5#
7#'
5"#, 7#+, ( 2 K4)
71
(5",#
5
<" ) 5#
7#'
5"#, 7#+, ( 3 K4)
73
(5
+ ) 5#
7#'
5"#, 7#+, ( 4 K4)
75
(7#.
5 ) 5#
7#'
5"#, 7#+, ( 5 K4)
76
(++
7=; ) 5#
7#'
5"#, 7#+, ( 6 K4)
78
(5
= 5#' ) 5#
7#'
5"#, 7#+, ( 7 K4)
79
(?8 #
>B (Multiple Regression)
#" RA#
( 8 K4)
81
?8 < +") ' 7#
#
>B ( Simple Regression) +,"
#" RA#
(9 K4)
82
?8 < +") ' 5",# 7#
9
>B ( Simple Regression) +,"
#" RA#
(10 K4)
84
?8 < +") ' 5
5
<"
>B ( Simple Regression) +,"
#" RA#
(11 K4)
85
?8 < +") ' 7#. +
5
7#"# ' ?3 (One way Anova) #" RA#
(12 K4)
87
I
_
5,
ي
5
7#"# ' ?3 (One way Anova) #" RA#
(13 K4)
88
_
5,
5
7#"# ' ?3 (One way Anova) #" RA#
(14 K4)
89
*` _
5,
5
7#"# ' ?3 (One way Anova) #" RA#
(15 K4)
90
<" _
5,
5
7#"# ' ?3 (One way Anova) #" RA#
(16 K4)
91
5
. 7#.! _
5,
(-3
>
4)
(-
!
$ (-
*
64 5, G
(1K3) !
23 7#
#-
@#
,#,2 G
(1K2) !
ك
C"
"
!
<#
5#, ::!
.7 5 ' 5
. 5 " #. D, 5@ 5#
7! 5
#.
5, 7#
#" ( 5
#", , 52 7#
#"
5, 6* 7 8 .5,#" 5! %# '
#98 (125)
5A#@ 5 > 1 :#.* RA# 5, 7@
5 ' 7#"#, 98 - 5. 5 ?8 %# _ ?8 < +")
.7
ل
Abstract
$
. 1K1
(3 ()4
$
1D1
5",# 7#
7#
#" <8 5/#" 5* 7 7 5A#* 7#
#
#H ' + 5'#);#" 5# 58 59A#' 5," 5",# 7# #" /! <8
7 #,H8 ( +" 5 7# "! b 5# 5 7# "!
H =H 5# :+2#" 5 ! +" 5# 7# "!
#H H H 5 !H #H." 9 8 7# 5'#);#" *^ 5
#H.-
H+ H' #.# (" 7# ! "$8 #
6* , 7#
6H* H @ ?#3 ; * .- 5,'# < ?9 5
.#
?8 5
. 5" <) _ # #
6* 5 ! 7#
5+!
#
H H
5>, %#,B" 59 ."#, / 5* + * 98 7#"#,
3
5H#
' <=#H3 " ?8 5 3
59 5 %#,2 5> 5
%#,2
.(2009 6@) 5 <" - ?8 R" , & 5>2
5H #" GH H 1 52 ( )' #. < 1" ?8
>
- 2D1
#H 5'# <#3, ' 7#"#, ?8 <8 ' 5, 5 ! >
:5d 7`#, 5"#; 5, 6* F/ ?9
5H3 5AH, `#, * ?>" 8 e7 5 ' 7#"#, 98 - 5.
:5
4
%H# _H ?8 < +") ' 5",# 7# 9 > # :(3 $4 ( F
%H# _H ?8 < +") ' 7#. + > # :;: $4 ( F
H' 7#
#
5* ' 5A#@ 5 7 ?' * ::
(
F
_
7#"#, 98 -
5. 5 ?8 %# _ ?8 < +")
,
3D1
7#H8
5H'
& ?8 < +") ' 7#
#
5* :
K1
?8 ?8 < 6# 1* 1'* ?8#" 5+" *#3 * :
K2
.7#
.5
.5, #. 7@ RA# =) ' 5A 7#@ () K5
4D1
H H 5> 5",# 7#) # #. 5, 6* 5* ("
?
5",# ' < 5'#) ! # b#" %, #.
b" ?",
.7
5) 7"@ 7#
#
, 5* ` #*>B
#
RA# #" 5, 6* 4' g- & #*' ?8 5 < . +#
%H# 7#
#
, 7h!
#. 7@
' - & 5"#8 % ' <! 9 ' =, 7h! # ?8 ?8
#)H 5, , # 7h! & <#@ 5# 7# #" J' * d % #
..h! 7# :!; 5"#8 7#. 598 5# 7# #" ,
#H. H ?8 %# 98 ?8 C#+9" . ( & #
C#+9
5D1
7#"#,H 98 -
5. 5 ?8 %# _ ?8 < +") ' 7#
H- 5. 5 ?8 %# _ ?8 < +") ' 5",# 7# 9
( 0.05 ) 5H _, 5A#@ 5 > : : $4 4
5H. H 5 ?8 %# _ ?8 < +") ' 5
5
<"
( 0.05 ) 5H _, 5A#@ 5 > ::: $4 4
H- 5H. 5 ?8 %# _ ?8 < +") ' 7#. +
H' 7#
#
5* ' 5A#@ 5 7 ?' : :
4
_
7#"#, 98 -
5. 5 ?8 %# _ ?8 < +")
6D1
.2012 %i
7#H
#H
5H* H :
5, 6* 7@8 :5
K4
< H 5H
H' 7#H"# 5, 6* RA#
:5) K5
7D1
5H ' ?8 %# ( <# #'#) . #8 7"+ 5
5, 5
"+ K2
5AH,2 5"#;#" 5, 5
' 5! 7#A3 1" b#" ( #
_ K4
'H %,# 7# "! < . , 9 * : D
5H-
2#"
:. .' ' #, #.' <B #., ?8 5"+ 7#
5"H,# 7#H
#H-
, # # 52 9 ( 5 :
D
, #.'* ?9 #.# #" 5, ?9 5 ! @ 5# ' ., #.#9"+
H 5H
" j"
5 ! #*@ 5# 7#
#" #" B
@ <=#3 " #*
5# 7 ' ?8 ` 5",# 5 ! 1 D@ %,# * :
#9 ",#
. &, 8 5
#8 +! #9' 5# ^ 7
9
59H, 5H #2 :H* H9 k#H" 6* ",# # #@
.(,et..al .2005.p:15
#H
<; 7 B 59"#+ _ ?9 5) <@" 52 6* 9
: ()4
&
7
::
;
5"
5/#" 7#, 16K2
5
5/#" 7#, 17K2
59"#, 7#, 5# 5, # 18K2
11
: ()4
&
7
7#, F > ?8 < +") ' 7#
#
?8# < #
1D2
7#H
#" <; H .' 5 5"#8 7#9 _ * 5 5"#8 5#'
& 5
6*
#.
5"#8 5 ' #. ?8 53- `
58@ <# " #. 3 5+! 2 98 9 5=#, <9 <# "
7# :#! ( 5# #9 5* 58 #)" @ #' J# !" 5"#8
.5"#8 5 ' # ?8 53- 5*B" 5- 5 . 7#A. 7' 8
59,H # ?8 53- % #.'*2 53- 6* ?9 . l/
12
5H3- 6H* 59, 59 1 #' ##" #." J# (! , !" -
& :#) .<; I !#" !" ?8 5 #*#9 (' #
7#,#,H 5
5 5"#8 #-
59 > 5 !#" 5@# ##)8 5. 7#
7 5 # 1> # - <2 <3 ' " #*#" ?8 5 . 7- 8
1 I
# 7#"#, ?8 <#@ 5# #9 A9#" ?> +#"
' #. # 5 ! 99 # () 5# A9 5, 5@ '
' #. # b l/ % 7# 5# 7# #" 58 B
.(2007 #@8 ) 59 7 , ' 5 <9 # 5 ! " 7`" =
5# 7# 2 5 59> 9' 5 <2 7 , ' ?8 5 . 7. 8
>,
`#, _ !#" #
_, 5#@8
59+ 7# ! & J@" 7#! 98 =#+ %", & "
CH
( 5#
' 5= _ 9" 9 5 5"#8 5 1
B" ?8 :@
<#, :. ?8#' .#.4" 9 5-
' 58
7## 8
13
9 & #.=#3 #.# #" =#3; 2 #.#, ( ' <;
5H 5H, H ?9 :." & =#3, 9 7#
5 J'
7#H# IH
H 5H) #
+") 5 #9' 5# 7#
#"
.#,H 5H
:+2 * #@ <) ( 5# 7#
#" & ,
H' 5"H,# 5#@8 79 # :." 5# 7# #" & # _
, 2D2
5H3- 6* #.` 7# + 7" 5+ " ?8 .3 9
5H#.
H' .1H H #.#"" #9 7#-
' #
<; #, 5. <B
(+)H (H, H.3 f"@ ?8 59 53- 6* _
8
<> 9 @ 5" 5> 7+ ##, > !" <2 7 , ' ?8
"(," #*#
Audire 5
5 59! * Audit
j -3 6#
" ?8
5
) 5 5"#8 #-
5
# <8 & '
<B!
5# #9 5
.(2005
7#H
#" JH3 A#H, ( , J3 1
B" ?8 :
#H9 5 #9 58 ?A#> #' , #. 5# 7# #" #- 5
5-
2 C
F
" +9'
"9 8 J3 * B" 9 * #-
5A#.
<H9 #H
7 B & " ?"#+ B ' :." 5#@8 b
#' J3 :#* ,#, 3- ) ?8 (2006 5 #+ ) !
5
5'#) 59 b 7#"#, ?8 9 '
> ?8 A#.
R
#" ,
7#
5
< 9 8 # 7#
, <#, ' ?8
FH
" H' ,H !" 9 7#
?9 * ?8 b#" _
*#H"#" *#, #" 5 ! @2 5# @
' & #2
15
H # B!" =" ?8 * 5# 7# #" ?8 :* # .
5H# #9 ; ?"+ #+ %, 5* ( 5# 7# #"
,
3D2
:*2
&#
* (234J 2007
) (214J 2000 l* ) !
:* ?8 #.99
J3" 59
#9 .#`, = ' 5; 7#, ( <#, K1
7/> :
) +#9
5# '
"
8 !" .# RA#
9 ?+ #.'* ?9 5- <#, #.# , 5- 58 5'#) K2
+") 5i ?8 ?#+ ! 1 =# " 1 5"#8 + < 7# ,
.7#`,
7#
#" 7#
58 #" 5-
' 5# 2 , 5, 5@ B K3
.7#
5-
2
9 #.9"#+ _ 9 7, #' ' 5"> 5#
5-
2
9 #9' 58" 3
5# #>d 7 5; 79 B K4
.#."
16
# 5"#8 _ 5-
' 5 5"#8 #-
5#
' <=#3 K7
.7#
4D2
:5# 2 F
" ' ?8 5* #
< ' ##* ##., 5 5"#8 7# +# < , 5"8 K2
+# 6* >` .( Sarens 2009) ?8 53- < 1 ?+ # * 7# !
(2006 7 ) :5# :- /" / +# B!
9' 5 ! <8
17
.5
< 7#
5-
K%
I 5D2
' 3- "8 b % =#+2 :#! #" ?8 9 K1
.5 !
.#.#"#, ?8" #.#8 D)" 5.," 5 ! 5") K3
8 7#"#, 7, 5# ' 5.," #.A! > 5 ! (" K4
.#.98
.%
#9' 7, #'#" -#3#" 5 ! _ 5, )' * ?8 K7
(+, 7#"#, ?8" ,#" 9 ?8 7" 3, <B! K8
.<B!
73# 7 # 5 ! ` ##- 1 " # ?8 < * >
2 %8 I# #. B ##" (5# 5",# *#3 #+;) 5",# ,
.
I# ." d 59> 4' ##" 7#3# 5 %# .
7#
& 5
" 79
# J@
. !" #."8 7#
# 5
5",#
7#
#" <; ,#,2 @ 7#
#-
j
7#
#@ 5#
@#" f, <3 5
G#
5 :A#- = ' .#, %,# 78 ' A !#" ,
.(78J 2006 ,) " #*# 79 ' (8 #
#.)H
" ( #3 7=; 7#
#" '2 5 7#
5-
>
:H
H9 (
@ 7# 7#
9 7#
#" 5#
5-
59+" #)
"
7#H #" H8 7#" 7=; 7 . '2 5" #. &
H =H
A#H" 5)H (, 7# 9 7# 7
5H* 78 + (+, * > 2 " #.
2
Matta, et al, ) #.,H3
5#
@ ' 7#-
' <' ^ 5,'#
7 5-
+
.(2005, p:934
?,#
!" #
5#3 5+" (7#
7=; 7 .
++ . .# ., .8 59+" #- * 3,
9 #."#
, 5 #. *#3 7#
5-
# ! :
.5#! 7#
5-
5# 7#
5-
2 * :(
) 7
:
D1
* .5# @ #82 7 ; :#. > 59 _2 5d A#, 5'#);#"
5#
G; #; 7# ' 5
; < .2
7#
5-
" 7#
( 5#
( ' 59 72 7d F
" 58 5
H #H3 3 R" 7=; :*2 " # ?, ` 5#
#H.#
7#H
#" (H 5 %
* 5# 7#
-
5#/
59,H 7#
-
!
"' <9 <# :# F3 ` # #.
Denisi & ) 5!H" H + b" < 7# 5# <;
#@H ! #. # .#." <>B #.' <>` 7/ 5'# 5#! .#- '
5H 5H; 5!H" 5H 3 7#H"+ ( #. ' 5' 5- ,A
., <
:A#-" 9 5,A = 7#
#-
5#
7 (Input Devices) #; 7 :* 7 6* 7#-
Main ) 5 #> 5,A 7 (The Central Processing Unit) 5
< . (Output Devices) 7# 7 (and Secondary Storage Devices
(2003, p: 125-126
> #." %,# 7#
#" 5'# # #. * 7 6* .%,#
22
(Disk Drivers) J82 7/! (Mouse) <#3 (Key Board) f#3 5
7 7#
#. # 7#
#" 5#
:I
D2
( " ?,
%,# #-
' _2 = 2 8#" 5"#8 5
" 9 # <A#'
7
# =y , %,# 7# 5'# /!" <3
9 7 6* .1' 7#
7#
#" 5
" 9 5
#> < . # .5#
5 7#
7#
#"
.5#
5 =#
>
, R"
G4" f, 7 6* .%,# A#. , .3 !" #.) %,#
5!#! > 5, 5A 5" #9 ! #.9 %,# 7# #"
.7##, 5
"#+
5#
< " 7#@ 5"8 7#@ < . #, :0)0
I D5
,#,2 G (1K2) 8 ! " ., G; #; < . 5
.7#
-
@#
23
! I"
" + "
5#
#; 7 G; 7
Processing
Input Output
!
< 5
#
* (2010) * :
)
.@ :5 ,;
.(30J 2011
)
24
> 5-
2 6* 7^ 9' .A#.
, 3, "8 #. F
7#
#" _2 :+2 <; ; 5 7#"+ < 5",# -
* %,#
78 ' 9 5A 598 /"
< #*A' 7#
?9
##" * 7# #" & /! ' 58 5, 6' # & #.# #" /! '
.(121J 2008
) 79 # 5 ' > >
#. :#
5",# 9 #9' #' 7#
6* , 7# ! #.,#
7#
' , < 1
%
# "9, )# ' 1 -
f"@
) 5#
' 5"#8 ?9 #*" #, 5 5
"# #9 ' #, 79
.(31J 2011
BH" H#" 7## & ?9 ", 5'# #. ' <
7 ,
.7#
7#
#" K1
.
+! 7= K2
.#."8
+ (' 1 #- 5", - F/" # %", 2 #* # 5#@
H ",# #-
# #
f"@ 8 + * <#'
> 7
# "
H,
1
7#
-3 5-
7#
5", ' %,#
<#,H" #. #.-3 7# #" @ 7# ! 6* 53
7#H
H! 7# 5# 7# 5#
5#@8 5# 7#
#"
5# 7#
5'# .3 5
; 5",# 7#
-
@
5#
,H
5",# 7#
-
@" #* #"
#H H <9 <# #- ' 7=; <=#3 , 53 9 7# 5
7
( M-
(
10D2
H' #H* / b 2 * .,2 1A + 7/ & <#3,
#- @# " = #, ?8 R# " 5+ ' - <# K2
.59 52
" %
#" #.
@ ' 7#
.7#
7#
#" +") -
59 '
5> 7+ ( = #" ?8 #9 F ?+ ' - <# K5
.5*
7
( M-
(
4 11D2
H
H 7#
7#
#"
; /! - ' 1#* ?8
5
"# 5"8 5
, 7 ?8 ' & > :?"
.$
D1
:#H
5) 5 ! +! 5'# #.A#3, 7
, 7#
#" %#,
28
H* H' ,H A#, 7=; 5 fA - #9"+ #.
:#
.#.
7#
#" #.
` 7
, %" @K
.#." J# , 7# #" # ' 5,, #82 %, , KG
5H ; 7#",# ,9" 7# #" ,8 59 7# #" 5@ B K
5H'
" #."#, :, 2 7
#
>' 7
, #.
, 2 :! ' < 7# #" ?"#+ % 5# 6* 3' "
.2
7#H #" H B ?8 =#+ b l/ % 5 #, 5@' &# *
: # ?8 5# 6* ' @Q 59"#+ " 5
7#
29
#H9 5 %#,2 ,#" _ < #./! " 5" 7# #"
' ( : 4 $
! "
.$
D4
7#H H 5
8 @ 5#
% 7#
59"#+ K
.5
3
H' < 5H@ #H8 H , 6^ %,# ,3 B K%
H H-
7#
& ,3 ' % ' " 7#
H ?"#H+ . 5' #9 B % " # ' =" ,
(2009 5#^ ") : # ' 7# #" ; /! 5# ' ?8 7= >
H #.
" 5 7#
#" 5@ B :7
#
(
D1
=H) H' H /!H 5@ B :7
#
("
D2
H
; /!H H" /! " 5
#9 ?+ &
R#
"
.5 #9 = i " R# " ,#" 7# #" I3 /! 7# #"
: # #.
?8 7# F
" 3
'
;
.5"#, 7#
5@ ?9 K
H 5H# #H9 A9 ' ; %,# 7# # , KH*
.<@8 7'
.7#
#" 5,
5/ %, <#3, K
31
"
"
13D2
5"#8 +") 9 1 (11K10J 2005 " l* ) !
H.3 98 % 5++ ?8 A8 F3 :* #' !" 5
H^ @H 7# #" #' ^ @ ) :(- " :0
J9
7#3
D) J9
59, ^ 7#
#" 5@ ^ 7#3
7#8 =:
7# #" <#9 5"#8 +") ) : C" : :
7#H" 7#H
#" 5A#
> {,
5"#8 7=; ' / 7#
#2
5H# 6H* H' ?"+ (7# #" <#8 - <# f@ b2 > (" 5#
.<#
, 7= 7#
#" <#8 !' 7#++ 5
K6
.5
#@ + R.
5
K7
.5" -
#
" ?"#+ J' K11
.5" -
#
7#"+ K13
$
.$
5# +! ' " 1
(2011
#9 ",# "
() '
:+# &
#
' ##)9 + 5# #2 5)8 j
:Security
!3
D1
D@ ^ 7#8 #-
@ J#" & #.#+#!
5 ! 5,#
33
.3+ !
5#
*# #-
B#" & :Availability *
I D2
7#
B#" & :Online privacy -
.$ ))"
D4
< #.
) 7#,#, ( !# 7#
& , & #-
7#
=" 1, ( #-
?"+ 5 %8 #-
#" 58
7 7#.
$
15D2
!#" 7#'
:! =#+2 9 & < 7# 5
34
#- =2 ?8 < , .<; 7## 5" `
<=#3 5#3 @ ?"+ ",# #- 5A _ & 5 5"#8
5# #.'* 5 F/ 5-
) , !" 9 7#
' 5",#
+#H9 :#! ?8 <8 " #. ?8 < 7' 9' 5 . 5#
" #H.
B" ?8H < 7' 9' 5# 2 5#
# ."
5 ! 5
5
3
@8
<H 7H' # ."?8 5." #9 =#
>
. &, 8 ?8 #
"
#H9 5"+ #. ?9 9 5) < 7=; 7#,#,#"
H' ?8H 5 # 5) <@" 52 6* 9 5# 7# #" <;
H# H 3 1H @ 5- 7+ ?8 %+ #. (
"8 #. # 5 5# 7# #" ' 58> <# 4' & 5#>, 5#
?H+ H H ; " " #9 6* ( .(2003 7#" )
5H d "H H 98H (Web) % 7#3@ " 7#3
5# 7# #" ' 58> <# <+ %#, 5#" ?8 5 7 # #
5 ' 5# 7#. %+ # 5 7+ 5" 5#" "@ 98 #'
3 % ' > 7#. 6* (2006 ) ?8 5 ' #.3-
'H #) " 5
7# "! ' <#, 5
3 #,82 ' !" @
H 2 #9 ",# ( @ # .7+ 6* 5" #. 5",#
<H9 + :
#. <+ -
?' +A @ <9 K1
.
5 5"#8 #.' #" 5#! 5 5"#8 #- " #; .3 5'# <" 7#. K4
.%,#
.(2003 5
+) 5/! #.#
# #.3A#- #.#
%,# -
" 5,#, 5'
K5
98H H"8 H 598 5# 7# #" ' 58> <# 53 . 5, '
7# ! * 5# 7# #" 6* <3, _2 :+2 (2003 7#" )
5, 5",# # 6' # * #>, # 9 # ' 5,
5H <) f"@ ?8 #- ?8 #-
2 #.)
" %,# ?8 %, #.)
" b %, ?8 C
53- 6* = 53 %#, # R # %,# ,#" ?8
7#H
H
#."#^ b" %#,2 6* 7
%,#
78" 5., ,"
?8H 7H ; 5 "! ., ' % 98 5", #"
5H 5
" # . 7# #" =! ("
#" 7#
&#
*
* 7
; 5
; <# 5 "! ?8 5
i 5A" ' _
<#H ( #
+ * 5" #8
98 % #
(H 98 #, 8 <+ 5
; %#,2 A#, 4' & 5
;
37
7,H <,H 5"8 4' 78 79 ' %,#
78 ' 5"+ 7#
H ` 7#
5# <# # 78 ' * # <!
#.
<
7#H #" <H#8 =#! .# #> I , f"@ ?8 5- <, 5"8
! ?8 ( #` #9> ' 7# #" <#8 ' % ?8 {#
.(Grand, 2001) ?8 78 . ' ,#" bm 7#3 ' #." -3 {,
' 78 +") <+# @
& 7#3 6. 5@@ 5, #"
"
#
, ' 98 1)9 78 , #-
J@ 7# F
"
&# * #2 6* ?8 (#! ?8 R" ' * 78 & .",
=2 9 1 B! * #9 J @#3 ' 78 +") 5 5i
::
;
:
!3
* $ P
(2003) !9 5, K1
",# 7#
#-
" +" G
+ 7'* # 5
; <# ,
C +#" , R. 1>" ' b#" (" 8 5 ; <#
5, 7 5",# -
#" 7* 7#, b" 5"
2 5"
(
.2 '
H <H+ 5 9 5 ; <# :#. 7## , b#" @ 8
#. J# !" ?8 5",# . # !" 5 . 7# ( 7>
#H* ?8 5",# . #. ,A ! # ' !#" !" #*#, #.#
J@H 5Hi 5H ; <#H 7# ;#" : ?9 5i
.
3
-
39
5*#, 7# ! ' 5 5"#8 5- <8 I#8 5# 5, 6* 7'*
?8 A #. 5# 5*#, 7# ! &# * 7@ 5 2
7#"+ 5" <8 7##+9 > &
" C#+8 5
2 5#
5*#, 7# !
< 5A" 7#"+ 5" (+, ?8#" 5@# 7 =#!
4" 5
2 5#
.7#
#
7 , #.#
'
.:
*
"
(
5'
f) & 5#@8 7 ' 5> 7#
7#
9 A#, ,
#@#" 5
#
, 3@ R.
b" 8 .5> 7#
7#
9
7#
9 5'
< 5",# 7#
-
5@# b" C)" 58
7
.?
' 5, 7 7#
40
A#, A#9 5'# 5,#,2 7#"+ 5 <"
7#
#-
) 7#
5, #-
> 5",# 7#
-
#"
5
%#,Q
?"+ 5
# 4" ?
5
9 5'
5#@8 < '
.5",# 7#
-
' #.
5#@8 < # ' 5,
"
3
:0
Q "
#
_, 5, G
b 5
2 5#>, 5# &
" #
@ ?9 5 5"#8 5- 9 ++) # ?8 5 .'
7# #" 5, 7 b (9 @ ?8 5 # 7#"> 5
= 5 2 5#>, 5# & " ?8 5." 53 ?8 7# !
> 5, 7@ 7# #" ( 5 , 5A 5 #", (83) A#@;
!" 5
2 5#>, 5# &
" # ?8 5 7#
#
=#9"| 7#, ++ () #) * ' =#9" 5#" 7# ! 7#,,`
7#
#
' 7+ , # =) , 5
"
$ .$
* : :
" (2006) <#)9 5, K5
3
Q
5",# 5"#8 5#' - 6* > #" & 5 2 5# & "
#. 52 7# #" ( <B 5 #", 7, 5 2 5# & " ' 5
7#
#-
5, 7@ 5A#@; %#,2 (SPSS) ,#"
5"#8 5
#" 5
:+2 5'# 7## " b" 5
2 5# &
" '
.7#
.
3
,)
" M-
"
7#
#
5
9 5A" JA#@ F
" :
5, 6* 7'*
H' #*' _ I#8 (5, 2 JA#@ 5= JA#@ 5; JA#@)
42
5/! 5"#8 +# ' JA#@ 6* >B _ 5'#);#" 5 2 :#@
H' 5H, 5 =i ?' _ :#@ 6. # 98 5 2 :#@
7#H, - #+; # , (#",) 5, < +" b#" #8 8
A ' #
5, ( 5
5
#", (64) ( 59"#,
5A#@H 7 7 ?' 1 :#.* RA# 5, 7@ 8
6H. #H 98 5
2 :#@ ' 5 5"#8 A ' #
=i "
JA#@H) 7#
-
5
5
9 5A" JA#@ ' _ B!" :#@
7 ?H' 1 " # .5 2 :#@ ' (5, 2 5= 5;
5 9 5A" JA#@ >B _ B!" :#@ 6. 5, =i " 5A#@ 7
N ! N N
*
"
:
" (2007)
. 5, K7
.!
3
# - .$
R!
3
"
5H/#" 5H, 5 7 5 #", @ & ?9 2 ' ?8 7#
_H & @ 8 .5 #", 93 A#@; #. () #98 120
#H = <H H , # 5 7=;#" ?8 #8 , ?8 5
7#H
#
, 1 7#8
5, 7@ # #.9> ?8
H' 7#H
#
, ?8 _ <8 #.* ?8 7# '
7 =4H" 5
5",# 7#-
#8 <)" b#" @ 8 .?8 7#
N
:
"
":
" ( 2008 ) "#
'#
:5, K8
.
"!
! :F
(
' <>`
& .
#9 ",# %# 5+," <` ?8 5 <
y#H #.@ 5
#", 7#
#" #>" ( 8 .?8 % =
)3
:* 98 - 5.
&
" ' 5
7#
#" /! 5 5"#8 -
JA#@ :
5
;
5, ( /@ & #>" (83) 5, ( 5 5#
' <| 5) 53,' 5# & " ' 5/! 5"#8 7=; 5#3
/! < +# 5 7# #" /! /! #.
5 5; 7#+# <; 5 5# & " ' 7# #"
5#' <=#3 -
5 5"#8 -
7# ' <)" b#" @
y
.(
,
<) /! 7# (5#
!
* ,)
! $ .$
:7
7#
#" # F/ . 7 #", <#, 5+," ?
' :#@ <! 7!
5, 7@ .#.#"> 5)3 #" 5A#@ G#
, #i #.#
#./!
45
' 5 5"#8 :* 7/ 7}/ ( 5) , . 5#@8 5#3 <=#3
B" A#@; 5
7
# .:#@ ' 5 5"#8 5'
5
#", <#,
5H, 5",# 5; 7#,#,#" (! )' :#@ 7#.
!#" #. <#3, 5# 5+ 5A" ' @ 7/ & #" - "
%
:" :
" (2009) "# 5, K11
:
7#
#
# ' #
7#"#, 98 -
.
5, 7 b .5
; 5",# 5-
2 - ' ?8 #, 7#
5
"+
5A#@ 5 7 ?' 7@ b ' # :
@ 7 7#
.(
)
:
I 7
5",# 7#
-
5#
5"#8 +") > :
5, 7'*
-
H 5H#
5"#8 +") .3 :
> .#.@A#@ 5",# 7#
@ 5"#8 +") 5-
+") #.#
5
; 5",# 7#
5H, 7'* # .#- + ?> +") 7#3 5# 5"#8 +")
5"#8 +") > ?! 5
' # 7#"#,
:
5H
%H# H 7H 5
#", 7+ 5, :* ?9 .5, <
-
H 5H
"2 5H#
5H"#8 +") 5
#", 7
) 8 ?! 5
' 7#"#,
@ 5"#8 +") 5-
+") ' 5> 5
; 5",# 7#
47
<#H H' #*> 5," & g#- ?> + +") 7#3 5# +")
7#H
-
H 5#
5"#8 +") " >B &#
* 5, 7@
5H %,H 5, 5 ' - 5. # # #." RA# 5
7#H
-
5-
5"#8 +") > 5",# 7#
58> <# ' " >
7#
58> <# ' " > 5
; 5",# 7#
-
7#3 5#
.5",# 7#
58> <# ' +,
7
( J2 6 :
" (2011) " 5, K13
#- ' ; ?8 7#"+ # G =# " 5, 6* 7'*
#-
( # 7#"#, ?8 #! ' 5*#, ` ",# 7#
#- 7# < #) 5'#);#" ?8 5 ' . 78 ' ",#
5"#9 5 #", 7# #" (" b#" #8 5, :* ?9 .",#
5@! 5"#9 7 # 5 b#" 7#- & 5@!
<# 7#3!, ' % 98 ( 7"#9 = 7#
#", (
48
' J# #
#+9 3!, (20) H" 5> 5, 5
! A! !"
:#* "#, ?8 ,9 "#, ?8 5 #9 3 ?8 ,
–
3 ?8
" # – "@ " "#, ?8 5
#> 5 K%
?8 " . 78 G# 7 ' 59"+ 5# ?8 5- " K2
.5 5",# 5- 2 " #. " (+" ) # & 5#
:
" (Al-Jabari, 2004 ) 5, K1
?8 5 ' %,# , 53 %,#
",# #-
-
* n#" & 7,#' 5 ! ' 98 5'# ( 7"#9 = 5, 6* 7
" 1 2 A#, F3 ?/, 78 b 1#' G * 7"> b
5*2 7 +# ?8 ="" b#" @ #' ._@9 5*2 7 +##"
b <" <#, ' 5 ! C#9 ` #.' C8 2 #.*2 -
_@9
49
5*2 7 +# > < ' 5+! 2 > 7 5 ! ,9
:
" (Coram, et al , 2005) 5, K2
H
7
, 5+, 5
5A+# 7=#.
; =
53
) 7,3 "8
.5
#.' & !
" F'
:
" ( Elliot, et al. 2007 ) 5, K3
@ ?8#" ## + :# ##)9 5# 7#*# B 7 ;
7# ! ' 7#"#, 98 2 5 #", 7 b 5 7# #" ( #",
798 7# ! %54 5 #> 5 #", 7 #98 25 * n" ?8
59 B!" 98 7@ ' : RA# 7.- ,?8 5 5'#)
5
" ?8 59+ " !" >B#" & 7#"#, ?8 5#
' , `
5
++#" " G
b "9, ' 5# 5 7#"#, ?8
#*
"
7#
, () 7>B &
" 5
= > ?8
5
#
#*
" 7
=; 5
5/ 5
" 9 , * ('#
.
:
" (Sayana et al, 2008) 5, K4
H K 7#H
5
1
5, ' =#
; %,# <#," ?8
H, H" ?8 5 3 " ?8 #8 53 `#, & _ ?8
C#H" & b" 5^#@ ' 3@ R. b#" 8 e ; %,#
; %,# <#," ?8 %#, , 5, 7@
.7 R" #" 7#
#" 8 < -
9 5 "! 9 7#
#"
51
:
" ( Abu-Musa, 2008) 5, K5
5"
5 ' 5,A I ' (9 7#-
5
#A! 1
#",
98 7@ ., 5#@ 1
#", 218 ( b 5
,
,#, !" 98 .< #2 ?8 :!; 1
:
" (Whittington, 2008) 5, K6
H, H' <H" <#H 5# #. ?8 # <# 5", #2#"
H +#"
, R.
5, C)" 58 #. 59"#, 7#, (" #
52
=#@H; F3 5@ _ #" A9, R. F3 () 5, #
7#H H' 5H, 7 .7# #" ( ' 5A#@ <B 3@
5 7+ 5# , ?> #! 5, 7@
k#H" 7#">" ?
##)8 :*
, ?> #! * # ?8 5",# 5A" '
5@! 79 <, ^ #2 & D#@'; 5# A9#" 59
5",#
?"+" ?
<> 7#"
@ %", 7# #"
G# 7=;
5H"#8 ?8 9 ' ,#, !" :. , ?> " #
5. 9
{,
<
" -#3 %+
, ?> ?8 ##"
:
" (Grant, et al. 2008 ) 5, K7
> 9 & %, , 5 ! 278 5, 5 7 5 !
7@ :
) #." 7# ! 7#
#
5"#8 :
) #."
-
5-
2 6* ' :
) #.' 7# ! #9 < 8 5#
#" 7#
#
7+ 5" 7#"#,
% 1
B" >#" @
:
" (Tucker, 2010 ) 5, K8
= ?8 #" 5 5"#8 # >B #" 5, 6* 7'*
H H8 .9 53 ## ", 7#. J#!2 , ?8
7
%
# ' 5
#", 7, & 5 5"#8 5",# 7#
-
H' C#,H H :#* " RA# 5, 7@ .# #+" ' 5,
%#H, 7= 5" ?8 5 >B _ 7#
#" 5#
?H+ 5 5"#8 #- >` # .5> # 6. ?8
:
" (Salehi & Abdipour, 2011) 5, K9
7#H
H-
?"+ :! 5, 6* 7'*
5H@" H' 5 5 ! (100) 7 9' 5, 5 # 5, =# 5'# '
H 7#8
7.- # .7# ! ( ' 5. 5; 7#
#-
:
" ( Al-Eqab & Ismail, 2011) 5, K10
7#
#-
@ ' .,
:! 5, 6* 7'*
7, .2 ' # 5@" ' 5 5 ! (220) 5, 7 .",#
#
+ 5
"2 #
"2 " "# > 5, RA#
7.-
.5",# 7#
-
@ (5; 53- 5#
5
) 7#
55
.",# 7#
-
@
- @ + 5A" :- " 5A#@ 5 > 7.-
7#
#-
@ >B '
+ 5* > 7#
#
# 5, 5* > 53 <#8 5, 5, 7 " .",#
.",# 7#
#-
@ + " #*>B & # "
!$
I 18-2
5H # H 7 H 9' 5# 5, # ?8 5 5 =
;: ()4
5, R. 1K3
5
5, ( 2K3
5A#@; 5#
5K3
7#
7#
#" ( %#, 6K3
;: ()4
= 1D3
3H@ %H,2 bH#" #.' (" 5
7#, 5, 6* "
5'
& ?8 < +") ' 7#
#
5* :
:."
5, 7 5 ' 7#"#, 98 -
5. & #., 7#8
5H 7/ 5 ^ 7/ 5, 7/ 5 #9 7# #"
.A#@;
< 2D3
%H ( 43 ) #* 7 5 ' ?8 %# ( 5, (
.(2012 #
5
",# 5
#@ 7 5" 7#"#,
' #
( 7#
#", ( " b#" #8 b ?8 (200) * n#"
58
#H (%69.5) 5", " 5 #", (139) , #! f, 59+" %# 6*
&H" ,#H.A"
#
#.
5
#", 14 #
", #* '
" 5, 7#
#",
7
) 5,#" 5! %# '
?8 (125) 5
79,
CH ( 1K3) 8 f) <, 7# #", # (%89.9) 5", "
( 1D3 ) (
( )
$I
0
9
( )
0
0
$I
0
%
%
%
3D3
H H 7/ I#8 8 5, 7#)' ( +/ 5 #", @" b#" #8
*`
I
) > 5'^
:
J@ :(3
6I
D
.(14K1) 7#"
#" 1,#8 <#" ( 14 ) ! :
K
.(22K15) 7#"
#" 1,#8 7#" ( 8 ) ! :
"
D
.(28K23 ) 7#"
#" 1,#8 7#" ( 6 ) ! :
D
: 0
-F
(?" ! *
$
(34K29) 7#"
#" 1,#8 7#" ( 6 ) ! :
$ D
(38K35) 7#"
#" 1,#8 7<#" ( 4 ) ! :
6
0
$ D
K39) 7#"
#" 1,#8 7#" ( 4 ) ! :
($
6
$ D
.(42
(:
) +, #) * 7#, b> b#" 9' 5, G
' 7/
:5d 5#
=#
"
3
:
) 4D3
#H9' 5
#", 6* 5# 5 7/" 8 .I#9 < 7#"> _ I#9 #3 #"
#
#"
8 - .#. # < 5",
* (% 83.59) #3 #"
#
(2D3) (
M ( "
? :
(
%81.78 5
5
<" 22K15
5H# H
A#@H; R#H
" ) 5A#@; %#,2#" 5
#
, 7
5H>" 5
5
5, #. @ 7#
#" 5#
(SPSS)
.5'^
#9' 5,
H' 5, 7# #" ( < 5# _ #" & :T 4 " D4
H- #H+; #H.# H % 5'# #. +/ b" 5, 6* C)
5H
5" #@ #. @ 7 7#
#" * : :
.7#
#
?8 < ' b" 5@# 5
5",# % K1
?8 < ' 5@# 5, C) 7" 7! 5@@ 7# K3
.7#
#
.7#
#
?8 < ' b" 6 7#+ ,# A#, K4
M 7D3
H ",# #- 1> # # 6* #' ##" 58 5,#" # ("#+
>` #", ##- f"@ b" 5",# 5A" ' #., _, (' ' 7., 7/
H
7#
#
, # ?8 7# < , ' 7#
7#H
#H
5A" >B &#
* (2004) #", 5, 7#! &
#H 5HA" ' ?8 7#"+ 5" 5* 7 " & 5 5"#8 #-
(+,H H ?8#" 5@# 7 =#!
4" #9 <)" b#" @ & 7#
.7#
#
7 , #.#
'
< 5A" 7#"+ 5"
7#H)' ?#9H! H b 7 5 ' 7#"#, 98 - 5. ?8 <
.(?8 # = 5 7=; ?8 5) 7!`" ?8 5 <
64
J2 8D3
#H H b#" 9' < #.'* @ 5, F^ ?9
< M ( M
++ 5 K
5 7= K 5",# 7#
9 K
?8 # = < K 5
5
<" K
7#. + K
(1D3) (-
J2
b#" G
2 :@
65
< ()4
5H 7#"# ' ?3 (One way Anova) #2 #" RA# 4K4
5'^
#9' 5,
66
< ()4
H
5A#@; 5 R#
" ,#" < 5+," 7
7#
#"
(Simple +," + %, ,#" 7#)3 #" : 4 " D2
6H 9, / >B 5 # I9 T 8 %#," & Regression)
H"8 Ho 5H
5H)3 F' #" 9 <#8 J
("# /
59,H 7/ "8 6,3 ("# 5, / ' #" 5", >
$ C>)" 1D4
5, 5
' JA#@ (1K4) 8 ' < RA#
"
(1 D4) * (
U
(
#
$ < I
>4
M
>
80.0 100 I
20.0 25 b#
24.0 30 5
, 25 8
44.8 56 5
, 35 8 25
19.2 24 5
, 45 8 35
4.0 5 5
, 55 8 45
8.0 10 > B' 5
, 55
88.0 110 I# "
*`
8.0 10 ,#
4.0 5 # "
60.8 76 7
, 5 8 #H ' <" 7
,
16.0 20 5
, 10 8 5 ?8
15.2 19 5
, 15 8 11
4.0 5 5
, 20 8 16
4.0 5 > B' 5
, 21
4.0 5 (ACPA) "
#8 %,# 5
. 7#.!
4.0 5 (CPA)
#8 %,#
36.0 45 (ACCA)
#8 %,#
56.0 70 5
. <#.!
68
*`
I
) b 5'^
#" 5@# 5A,Q 5A
@ # #9' RA# 6. > (5 . 7#.! ?8 # ' <" 7 ,
: # " b (1K4) 8 ?"#, ' #.@ 5 #", 2
:8 D1
5 # %80 7@ 5", " 98 59+ 5",
,3 # * 5
# +9' %20 b#
; 5",
7/" ' 5>" 5,
.?8 5
. 5
"+" ?
: D2
%# '
!` * .%8 5",
" > B' 5
, 55 %4 5",
" 5
, 55
%# ' 5
, 59"#, 7" ' ?8 # ' :A#- ^#! %+ ?8
5"+ * 5
7#A3 6* 5'#);#" .53- 7#"" #9
5>#
5
7#A3 " %,
%#9 & :) &#.
; ?#*; %
#" I#,;
: (F D3
# %4 # " 5A' %8 ,# 5A' %88 I# " 5A' 5", 7/"
5",
" 7
, 5 8 5A3 5",
7
# ' ?8 # ' <" 7
,
5",
#"
C#3 - .%4 5", " > B' 5 , 20 5A' 5 , 20 8 15 5A3 5A' %60.8
'
#, ,#, %+ * 98
@ _, C#3 9
*` :#
%#, (I# ") 5",#
5 5 @ %+ %# 6*
:
( "
$ D4
5>" 5
# 5A# ' (60.8) .",
7 ! b 7
, 5 5 !
H' (16.0) 5", ! #", 20 (7 , 10K5) <" n" # "
(5 H, 20K16) 7 H, 20 H > A3 7#, # " 5A# ' (15.2) 5", "
( * ,3 .5A' 5A# ' ( 4.0) 5",
I3
", (5) 5A'
I3
"
:
-
D5
H 5H>" 5H
5"#^ ( 1 K4) 8 ?"#, "
7#.!H H 5@3 .A#+ 98 *B , * .5",# ' 5 . 7#.!
.?8 5 . =#"B" #9 5'#) 78 . 2 ?8 ' 5 .
A+ # 5, 5A, 5"# #8 5, 5 - # !"
M 4)
6)7
=> 2D4
H 5H H, H #.!8# 5, 7#)' #"#" b#" #8
#H 5H* 5# #. ) RA# " 7#)3 5A 7#"
& 7 5 ' 7#"#, 98 -
5. & ?8 < +") ' 7#
H H RA#H ## 5 #",; ' 5@@ 5A,2 5, 5 7#"#
:#. @
71
.N$ N
N $
0
0
1D2D4
(2D4) (
(
)
0
,
0
4
&
5#@8 < ' #
, ?8 (+, K1
5
3 0.67 4.30
.?8 5 ,
!" 7#
#
" 1'
, ?8 5
" ?8 #8 K2
5
3 0.87 3.85
.,#,
/! #-
5"#8 +") J3 () ?8 #8 K3
5
3 0.57 4.42
.7#
#"
1"+ %, #.@3 7#
#" 5
@ ?8 D#, K4
5
3 0.56 4.66
.5#3" ?8 5
" #9
5"#8
3 #
7#
9" ?8 %# #8 K5
5
3 0.74 4.21
.7#
#
5+, 1.01 3.06 .7#
#
, 5 =#
" ?8 <=#3 9 K6
5
3 0.90 3.80 .?8 5 #; <+ 7#" ,#" ?8 %# #8 K7
& 5# 7 # ",# #-
+ ?8 %# #8 K8
5
3 0.84 4.17
.?8 5 ,
#9 5",#
7= #. ' ?8 %# /"
K9
5
3 0.60 4.31
.?8 5
"
5, R" 5
"# 5 5
= ?8 %# #8 K10
5
3 0.65 3.96
.?8 5 '
5
3 0.76 4.11 .?8 5 ' 5, ?8 R"
98 &! K11
# ?8 R" " 5
#9 7# =4" ?8 %# #8 K12
5
3 0.72 4.05
.#.)'
5 , 5 ?8 #
, ?8 %# #8 K13
5
3 0.58 4.51
.?8
72
@ ?8 D#, %" (4) <93 7 # <9' (2K4) f)
%H# %" (13) <93 7=# 5
#> 5" ' (0.56) #
:
(4.66)
, ?8 %# %" (7) <93 7=# <2 "8 5" ' (0.58) #
#H H, 5 =# " ?8 <=#3 9 " (6) <93 7=# <2 5"
.(1.01) #
:
(3.06) "#, +," "7#
H 7 # #. @ 5"#, 7#+, ( # !" -
H' 7#
#
5* 7#"
( 5"# 7
# 5, 5
7#"#,
.5# 5" # 7 5 ' 7#"#, 98 - 5. & ?8 < +")
5H 7#"# ! 5)3 59 6* / I#8 ' 5, 793 (
#
, -
98 =`* 7#"#, 6* > I
H 5H#
' ., ##" ?8 < +") ' . 5",# 7#
9 7#
bH 5H 6* <#'| 5@' &# .' 5, _ # %, 5 5A" 5",#
N .N$
$ 0
0
2D2D4
(3D4) (
(
"
)
0
,
0
4
&
98 _ ' 5
9 5'
7#. K14
5
3 0.54 4.70
.?+ )'B" ?8 5 #
#,
# <
?8 #
" 5 5'
' K15
5
3 0.55 4.69
.?8 5
" #9
18# 5
5
7" ' K16
5
3 0.64 4.42
.?8 ' 5@@ 5" 7#"
98 #.'
5#@8 < %, K17
5
3 0.63 4.38
.?8 5 #; 5",#
:#
7"
#
; 7#, ?' 5
. 7#.! ' K18
5
3 0.74 3.93
.?8 5
18 , 5# 7*` ?8 @ K19
5
3 0.80 3.99
.?8 5
" #9
.*B 5@@ 7#" 98 ?# K20
5
3 0.72 4.36
.#
7+ % !"
5H'
7#. #," (14) <93 7
# <9' (3K4) f)
"#,H +H," "?H+ )'B" ?8 5 # 98 _ ' 5 9
'H /"
" (18) <93 <2 5" ' 7=# (0.54) #
:
(4.70)
74
(3.93) "#, +," "?8 5 # ; 7#, ?' 5 . 7#.! 98 _
.(0.74) #
:
H 7 # #. @ 5"#, 7#+, ( # !" -
H' 7#
#
5* 7#"
( 5"# 7
# 5, 5
7#"#,
.5# 5" # 7 5 ' 7#"#, 98 - 5. & ?8 < +")
5 7#"# ! 5)3 59 6* / I,#8 ' 5, 793 (
* # #.+ " 5 ! 52 5
#,82 A " 7#
#" 7#
.$
$ 0
0
3D2D4
( 4D4 ) (
(
)
0
,
0
N
N
4
&
H+ H 5H3 7' ' 98 G# K21
5
3 0.53 4.27
.?8 5 ' .#.
H+ 5H# 7H # ="#" 5
#
, K22
5
3 0.82 4.03
.98 7#.
7#H. H+ ' 5
b#"2 <#' K23
5
3 0.81 4.12
.5#@8 < ' 98
98 7#. + =4" #
7; #8 K24
5
3 0.71 4.23
.?8 5 ' 5/#" 5*2
H' . H! 98 7#. + K25
5
3 0.64 4.43
.53 7
7#!
98 7#. + 7)# #, K26
5
3 0.59 4.28
.# !"
7#H. H+ H " (25) <93 7 # <9' (4K4) .-
: (4.43) "#, +," "53 7 7#! ' . ! 98
.(0.82) #
:
(4.03) "#, +," "98 7#. + 5#
H 7 # #. @ 5"#, 7#+, ( # !" -
H' 7#
#
5* 7#"
( 5"# 7
# 5, 5
7#"#,
.5# 5" # 7 5 ' 7#"#, 98 - 5. & ?8 < +")
5 7#"# ! 5)3 59 6* / I,#8 ' 5, 793 (
7#. 6* ?+ )'B" ?8 5 # <9 . 98 _
7#@H 7#H
#
b 7#
#
' 5#
_9 <=#3
.,H
8 # 5 7#
& !" 3 . IA !"
.$
$
0
0
4D2D4
(5D4) (
( "
)
0
,
NN0
N
NN
4
&
5H" #* 5#3#" ?8 5 :@ K27
5
3 0.83 4.01
.++
, ' ., 7+ ) ?8 5 -
5#' K28
5
3 0.66 4.26
.?8 5
5
3 0.95 3.96 .5#3" ?8 5 ++ 5@@ 5. K29
5H , 53 5
7" 98 %#, K30
5
3 0.82 3.95
.?8
5
3 0.77 4.02 ?8 5 ' 5> 7#" ,#" 98 #8 K31
77
5 - B" 9 " (41) <93 7 # <9' (5K4) f)
5H3 5H
7" 98 %, %" (43) <93 7=# (0.66) #
.(0.82) #
:
(3.95) "#, +," <2 5" ' "?8 5 ,
H 7 # #. @ 5"#, 7#+, ( # !" -
H' 7#
#
5* 7#"
( 5"# 7
# 5, 5
7#"#,
.5# 5" # 7 5 ' 7#"#, 98 - 5. & ++ 5 5#'
5 7#"# ! 5)3 59 6* / I,#8 ' 5, 793 (
FH
" H :!H :. ?8 5 -
7#"#, 6* > I
<" 5* %, 7=; 6.' ?8 :* #., 78 :8 7!`
H, 9'2 < 5" +# 5, ' @ 5!
.5# A9
78
.N$ N
N $
0
0
5D3D4
6 7
(6D4) (
(
6
7
)
0
,
NN0
NN
4
&
3 ' ?8 5 RA#
5 #, K32
5
3 0.66 4.27
.5#@8 < ' ?8
H' ?8H 5H RA#
98
K33
5
3 0.58 4.23
.5-
7=; ' #9 6#, ?8 (+, K34
5
3 0.73 4.15
.?8 5
5
5
3 0.62 4.34 .5)#" ?8 5 7= :@ K35
7=H :@ %" (48) <93 7 # <9' (6K4) f)
.(0.73) #
:
(3.15) "#, +," <2 5"
H 7 # #. @ 5"#, 7#+, ( # !" -
H' 7#
#
5* 7#"
( 5"# 7
# 5, 5
7#"#,
5H" # 7 5 ' 7#"#, 98 - 5. & 5 7=; 5#'
.5#
79
5 7#"# ! 5)3 59 6* / I,#8 ' 5, 793 (
H * 5 7=; , ,A :. 7#"#, 6* > "
5
)# 7#.#" 5 5# 7#
#" ! #9 @ #! J!
?8 #9" ?
#' #@@ 58@ 59> 5, ) 5# 58@" 5"#8
.=2 ?8 #
6
.$
$ 0
0
6D2D4
($
(7D4) (
(
($ 6
$ )
0
,
0
N
N
4
&
#H
' ?8 #,
?8#" #9 K36
5
3 0.81 3.94
.@8 78" ?8 R"
7#
#
' #,
?8#" #9 K37
5
3 0.76 4.10
.)' !" 5"# 5"#,
H ' ?8 #,
?8#" #9 K38
5
3 0.67 4.23
.<| #.
' :, #9 A#,
H ?8 5 599 RA#
@ K39
5
3 0.72 4.04
.#. #
3 9+
?>
?8H#" #H9 #,H" (51) <H93 7 # <9' (7K4) f)
#,H
?8#" #9 " (49) <93 7=# (0.67) #
:
(4.23)
(3.94) "#,H +H," <H2 5" ' "@8 78" ?8 R" # ' ?8
.(0.81) #
:
H 7 # #. @ 5"#, 7#+, ( # !" -
H' 7#
#
5* 7#"
( 5"# 7
# 5, 5
7#"#,
5H" #H 7 5 ' 7#"#, 98 - 5. & ?8 # = 5#'
.5#
5 7#"# ! 5)3 59 6* / I,#8 ' 5, 793 (
&H 5H#
^ 7/ <@2 f@ !" `"
?8 5# <8
%,# #. @ # A#@; RA#
" (3) 8 ?
81
"
=> 3D4
7#H)3 #" RA# ,; =#@; %#, b#" ,
#" ' #. @ RA# 5# " 5# 5, #. 7 ,
:7#)3
( 0.05 ) 5H _,H H 5A#@ 5 > :1 5)3 6* J
98 -
5. 5 ?8 %# _ ?8 < +") ' 7#
#
5* I#9
+
,#" b#" #8 5)3 6* #"
98H -
5. 5 ?8 %# _ ?8 < +") ' 7#
#
.RA# 6* (8K4) 8 #. ) RA# " b 7 5 ' 7#"#,
( 8 D4) (
:V (Multiple Regression)
0
"
=>
F F
>)7
R2 Sig. (
M
NNNNNN
5
5)3 F' 3.84 4.62 .462 .000
4.62) * 5", F 58 (7 K4) ?"#, ' < 7# #" f)
6H* #H" H' #H. @ 9 5 #9" (3.84) 5 #.8 7/" #' (
5H)3 FH' H 1
4' & 5 59 " 5", 59 " 5)3
82
#H
5A#@H 5H > " 1
J
5" 5)3 "8 5
7#"#,H 98 -
5. 5 ?8 %# _ ?8 < +") ' 7#
! # %5 8 #. 3@ 5/#" (Sig.) 5 58 6 ` # * .7 5 '
<8 C#3 I
# .?8 < +") ' >` _ &#
*
* ?8
( 0.05 ) 5H _,H H 5A#@ 5 > " 1 5)3 6* J
98H H- 5. 5 ?8 %# _ ?8 < +") ' 5",# 7# 9
.5)3 6* #" #. @ RA# " ( 9K4 ) 8 #
( 9 D4) (
( Simple Regression)
0
"
=>
:V
T T
>)7
R2 Sig. (
M
5
5)3 F' .297 .000
1.679 7.590
83
#H" ' #. @ 9 5 #9" (1.679) 5 #.8 7/" #' (7.590)
5H)3 F' 1 4' & 5 59 " 5", 59 " 5)3 6*
+"H) H' 5",# 7#
9 >B " 1
J
5" 5)3 "8 5
"7H 5H ' 7#"#, 98 - 5. 5 ?8 %# _ ?8 <
#" ! # %5 8 #. b 3@ 5/#" (Sig.) 5 58 6 ` # *
IH
#H ?8 < +") ' #" (.297) 1",
# ,3 5",# 7#
9 '
?8 < +") / 5",# 7#
9 / ,3 5 58
<9 5+, 5
A#@; RA# " (3) 8 ? 7 5 ' 7#"#, 98 - 5.
( 0.05 ) 5 _, 5A#@ 5 > " 1 5)3 6* J
98 -
5. 5 ?8 %# _ ?8 < +") ' 5
5
<"
.5)3 6* #"
#. @ RA#
" ( 10K4 ) 8 #
84
( 10 D4) (
:V ( Simple Regression)
0
"
=>
"
T T
>)7
R2 Sig. (
M
5
5)3 F' 1.679 8.640
.526 .000
"
#H" ' #. @ 9 5 #9" (1.679) 5 #.8 7/" #' (8.640)
5H)3 F' 1 4' & 5 59 " 5", 59 " 5)3 6*
"7H 5H ' 7#"#, 98 - 5. 5 ?8 %# _ ?8 <
#" ! # %5 8 #. b 3@ 5/#" (Sig.) 5 58 6 ` # *
#H ?8H < +") ' #" ( .526) 1",
# ,3 5
5
<" '
A#@; RA# " (3) 8 ? 7 5 ' 7#"#, 98 - 5.
( 0.05 ) 5 _, 5A#@ 5 > : 1 5)3 6* J
98 - 5. 5 ?8 %# _ ?8 < +") ' 7#. +
.5)3 6* #" #. @ RA# " ( 11K4 ) 8 #
( 11D4) (
:V ( Simple Regression)
0
"
=>
T T
>)7
R2 Sig. (
M
5)3 F'
1.679 6.396 .417 .000
5
#" ' #. @ 9 5 #9" ( 1.679 ) 5 #.8 7/" #' (6.396)
5)3 F' 1 4' & 5 59 " 5", 59 " 5)3 6*
< +") ' 7#. + >B " 1
J
5" 5)3 "8 5
# * "7 5 ' 7#"#, 98 - 5. 5 ?8 %# _ ?8
' #" ! # %5 8 #. b 3@ 5/#" (Sig.) 5 58 6 `
C#3 I
# ?8 < +") ' #" (.417) 1",
# ,3 7#. +
?8 %# _ ?8 < +") 7#. + / ,3 5 58
<8
RA# " (3) 8 ? 7 5 ' 7#"#, 98 - 5. 5
U
(
59, 7/ >B ' 5A#@ 5 7 ?' _ :
N
2% N
4
( R
4
'" .$ 9 <#8 J
8 1D4D4
# 5* ' 5A#@ 5 7 ?' :1 5)3 6* J
7#"#, 98 -
5. 5 ?8 %# _ ?8 < +") ' 7#
.I
_
87
( 12 –4) (
(One way Anova) !
( =>
8
.% PI
$ % 4
5
F5HH8 _, F 5HH8 +H
H, 7#H
H C #" @
5 5
5", 7#
" 5 7#
"
Sig df
2.239 1 10.239 7# "
?' 7#
1.893 123 9.41
3.84 0.000 40.736
59 " 5", F 58 #. " 5 #9#" (3.84) 5 #.8 (40.736)
F 5H8 " 5", F 58 7 # " 1 J 9 <#9 #9' 5
H* I
_
7#"#, 98 -
5. 5 ?8 %# _ ?8 <
2D4D4
# 5* ' 5A#@ 5 7 ?' :1 5)3 6* J
7#"#, 98 -
5. 5 ?8 %# _ ?8 < +") ' 7#
.
_
88
( 13 –4) (
(One way Anova) !
( =>
.% PI
$ % 4
5
F58 _, F 58 +, 7# C #" @
5 5
, 7#
" 5 7#
"
Sig. 5" df
HHHHHH"
0.00 44.02 2.95 5 11.81 7#
3.84
?' H
HHHHH
0.07 119 8.05 7#
124 19.86 C
5H9 " 5", F 58 #. " 5 #9#" (3.84) 5 #.8 (44.02)
F 5H8 " 5", F 58 7 # " 1 J 9 <#9 #9' 5
# *
_
7#"#, 98 -
5. 5 ?8 %# _ ?8 <
# 5* ' 5A#@ 5 7 ?' :1 5)3 6* J
7#"#, 98 -
5. 5 ?8 %# _ ?8 < +") ' 7#
.
*` _
89
( 14 –4) (
(One way Anova) !
( =>
(F
.% PI
$ % 4
5
F58 _, F 58 +, 7# C #" @
5 5
, 7#
" 5 7#
"
Sig. 5" df
HHHHHH"
0.00 36.43 3.71 5 7.43 7#
?' 3.84 H
HHHHH
0.10 119 12.43 7#
124 19.86 C
5H9 " 5", F 58 #. " 5 #9#" (3.84) 5 #.8 (36.43)
F 5H8 " 5", F 58 7 # " 1 J 9 <#9 #9' 5
H*` _ H
7#"#,H 98 -
5. 5 ?8 %# _ ?8 <
" 4D4D4
# 5* ' 5A#@ 5 7 ?' :1 5)3 6* J
7#"#, 98 -
5. 5 ?8 %# _ ?8 < +") ' 7#
.<" _
90
( 15 –4) (
(One way Anova) !
( =>
"
.% PI
$ % 4
5
F58 _, F 58 +, 7# C #" @
5 5
, 7#
" 5 7#
"
Sig. 5" df
HHHHHH"
0.00 21.18 3.71 5 8.41 7#
?' 3.84 H
HHHHH
0.10 119 11.32 7#
124 19.73 C
5H9 " 5", F 58 #. " 5 #9#" (3.84) 5 #.8 (21.18)
F 5H8 " 5", F 58 7 # " 1 J 9 <#9 #9' 5
H* <" _
7#"#, 98 -
5. 5 ?8 %# _ ?8 <
-
5D4D4
# 5* ' 5A#@ 5 7 ?' :1 5)3 6* J
7#"#, 98 -
5. 5 ?8 %# _ ?8 < +") ' 7#
( 16 –4) (
(One way Anova) !
( =>
-
.% PI
$ % 4
5
F58 _, F 58 +, 7# C #" @
5 5
, 7#
" 5 7#
"
Sig. 5" df
5H9 " 5", F 58 #. " 5 #9#" (3.84) 5 #.8 (25.27)
F 5H8 " 5", F 58 7 # " 1 J 9 <#9 #9' 5
7#.!H _ H
7#"#,H 98 -
5. 5 ?8 %# _ ?8 <
8" ()4
) =>
RA# 1K5
7#@ 2K5
93
8" ()4
) =>
7#"#, 98 5, 5 7#"#; (" @3 ' =) '
5A,2 5"#4 ,b#" #. @ RA# #) # @3 * 4'
#H. 7H " 7#)3 #. ! 7> 5, 6* 2 @3 ' #.+
H H bH#" H8 5H# 5, ' #. @ RA# 6* =)
5H 7#H"# 1 @ # ?' 5, RA# * J 7#@
: #" 5,
=> 1D5
?8 %# _ ?8 < +") ' (7#. + 5
5
<" 5",#
3@ (Sig.) 5 58 7/" .7 5 ' 7#"#, 98 - 5. 5
.?8
94
?H' #. 7.- (2009) "# 5, 5 ( 5 6* ?3
5- 2 ?8 " +" #. 7.- (2011) " 5, 5 (
*#,H 7#
#
, ?8 & ,3
# ?8#" #9 7= +," 5> # A#, 2 & ?8 5#' , '
.?8 9 5"# # ; 5 7# #" @ ' ?8 . 78 9 #.
%# _ ?8 < +") ' 5",# 7# 9 >B 1 RA# 7#!
<H +"H) ' #" (.297) 1", # ,' 5",# 7# 9 ' #" 3@
.7 5 ' 7#"#, 98 - 5. ?8 < +") /
%, #.@3 7# #" 5 @ ?8 D#, 5* RA# " #
#H
H,#" ?8H %# 9 5#3" ?8 5
" #9 ' ., #9 1"+
H 5"#8 +") J3 () ?8 ?8 5 , 5 ?8
' #, ?8 _ 7#. 5 7# 9 & ,3
6H* 2
; ?8 5 ' 5. 7#
9 6* 2
?8 5
" #9
95
4' & ?8 5 # #. " ?8 5 ' 5. 7# 9
.D# " ?8 5 # ' #, ?8 _ 7# 9
5H 5H8 7/" 7 5 ' 7#"#, 98 - 5. 5 ?8 %#
5
5
<" / ,3 5 58
<8 C#3 I
* ?8 < +")
.7 5 ' 7#"#, 98 - 5. ?8 < +") /
?8H #H
" 5H 5'
' 5* " & ?+ )'B" ?8 5 #
7H#" 98 ?# 5* B ( ?8 _ ?8 5
" #9 # <
?H' #. 7.- (2009) "# 5, 5 ( 5 6* ?3
5- 2 ?8 " +" #. 7.- (2011) " 5, 5 (
?8H 5H
" #H9 *`H 7 ' 98 & ,3
H 6", # & 5 5 7" *
' # &
96
?8H 5H
" #H9 7H H' 98 <=#3 ` # ?8 ' . =#
> 7"
.
%# _ ?8 < +") ' 7#. + >B 1 RA# 7#!
(Sig.) 5 58 7/" 7 5 ' 7#"#, 98 - 5. 5 ?8
< +") ' #" (.417) 1", # ,' 7#. + ' #" 3@
.7 5 ' 7#"#, 98 - 5. 5 ?8 %# _ ?8
7 7#! ' . ! 98 7#. + 5* RA# " #
98 5# # # !" 98 7#. + #, 7)# 53
7#
#-
7@ (2006) <#)9 5
( 5
6* ?3
#. 5# 5*#, 7# ! &# * 7@ (2004) #", 5, 5
?8 < +") ' ., 7#. + #9 & ,3
#H 5H* H' 5A#@H 5 7 ?' RA# 7#! :
7#"#,H 98 -
5. 5 ?8 %# _ ?8 < +") ' 7#
?8 5
" #9 <=#3 7*` I3
.
& b I
:#" :
98 & . ?8 5 ' 5> 5 %#, C#"
+") ' ?8 , 5* ?8 ,# b# ;
#H 5H* H' 5A#@H 5 7 ?' RA# 7#! :# #>
7#"#,H 98 -
5. 5 ?8 %# _ ?8 < +") ' 7#
)H3 *#H :H 98 & ,3 .
_
1H ?8 , b 7 1" # # ?8 ,
H' 5H8 ?8 1" # # ?8 5 5#' <=#3 >
?8H 5H H,# *# : 98 & .#."" 7# #" G
#H > ?8 . 2 & 5#' "
#H 5H* H' 5A#@H 5 7 ?' RA# 7#! :#>#>
7#"#,H 98 -
5. 5 ?8 %# _ ?8 < +") ' 7#
H 5H'
H 6", # & 5#' <=#3 "
?8 5
"
%H# _ ?8 5 <=#3 & > ?8 , 5* .,
<H +") ' 1* ?8 , #+, #.
.?8 5
#
5* ' 5A#@ 5 7 ?' RA#
7#! :#
"
7#"#, 98 -
5. 5 ?8 %# _ ?8 < +") ' 7#
73 ?8 %# ' 98 & ,3 .<" _
?8 # 53 7" 98 # 5",# RA#
# 5* ' 5A#@ 5 7 ?' RA# 7#! :#,#
7#"#, 98 -
5. 5 ?8 %# _ ?8 < +") ' 7#
5
. .#.! : 98 & ,3 .5
. 7#.! _
RA# @ ?8 5 < +") ' ?8 , 5*
.?8 5 < +") > 1
?8 , 5",#
99
) 2D5
:
j 5 7#, = 7 5 ' 5#
?8 %# 5* K2
.7#
#
,#" 59
<9 +#9
:
) +#9
R" , #* % 7 5 ' 5#
?8 %# (! K3
7 .A#+ 7# ! ' ?8 5 5#' <=#3 <# 7#
#
.7#
#
7#"+ # ' 5 5"
5H#
?8 % #,8 ( ' #." 59 7
%,# < . ' 5* K5
7#
-
7#
(
7#
#
#-
" K6
<#8 I,B & % 5+! ( ' #. <#'; #.#" #*! 5",#
<#'; 7#
#
, # % 5+!
: 7#
#"
.#*#
100
.?8 5
" 5
:+2 5'# 7## "
5 =#9"| 7#, ++ () ' ?8 %# , 5* K8
5 . .- "8 , % #!; ?8 %# C#) 5* K9
:5"9, b#"2 5 7#. b#" D9 C) * => ' .,
.7#
#
.",# H
G
#.#,#
7#
#
5-
o
" > KG
5HA" '
5",# 7#
7#, b#" = K
.7#
#
1H 78+ C) I3 b#" 7#, =4" b#" @ KH*
RA#H #H.9"#+ _ B :." & 5>" 7/ I3 " 5# 5,
< >
.# %
N
:N
N"
(2008) , "#
'#
" K4
" & 5
# 5 !
! :F
(
.1
22 <; #@8 5
%
: (2009) ' ' "# K5
.2##
102
.?! 5'#9>
)0
* -
.(5
5,) 5",# 7#
58> <# '
" ! "
" *
:
(2010) 1 # I K11
.2 :" 5
# 5",# ,8 #2
5H
H #@H 7H 5" 7#"#, ?8 %# 7#"#, "8 K12
.2012 #
5
",#
N * (2010) # , # * K13
.268K203 J J I#
!
#> R
."5#
# 5
#<!
^ ,# 5#,"
Q
.$
" 0
* 7
( J2 6 (2011) " " K18
(H !H A I # R(2008) " K19
.# 5,#, 5
"+
!H
A
7
(2010) F# x#" = #, K20
-
5
# *
("
:
7
* (2010) *" #+, K21
.5 ,;
7H" 7H" N N N .(2006) " #!* , K22
N "
N
N
.(2001) , # D#3 " @ K23
> (
3
:F
(
.(2009) %" 6@ K24
K106 J J
#>
I! 5
#
)?
7#
.137
5H
#> 5H
"+ .5 5"#8 ?8 @ .(2009) ? " #> K26
! 5'#9> * (2008) ? " ,#8 K30
5
# 7!
:?! 2 5
"+ R& ("
.(2008) , )#9 K31
.#, ?!
105
N N $ .N$ * : (2006) 3+@ #,^ <#)9 K32
' 7#
#
5
9 5A" JA#@ > .(2007) #
#
+9 K34
13 R
5
2 :#@ ' 5 5," 5/! 5"#8 +#
.< –
" & 5
# < 5
" 5
%#
(
3
64 (2004) #, # 598 D36
.2 7" i 5
# <!
^ ,# 5#, R 7
3
2 %#H :<*#H9 . M *$ (2002) , 3+ K37
.( !
6
7N
# *
I
P
(2011) l# + K41
5H
#> 5
"+
!
!
R(2007)
K42
5 5"#8 (2009) "@ A#> #"/ 3+@ % i * K43
.39-1J 45
7 5
, % *$ ?
#,
N"
N N
*
"
(2007) #
. K44
5H
# !
3
N
# - .$
R!
3
*
.(2005) , -#
! !#* # K45
5
5
# 9 b" :
*
"
(
18- Sayana، S.، Vilhelmson B. and Thulin E.، (2008). " Using CAATs to
Support IS Audit "، Information Systems Control Journal, Vol. 1, No 3,
P: 1 – 5.
19- Schneider, A., (2010) , ASSESSMENT OF INTERNAL AUDITING
BY AUDIT COMMITTEES , Academy of Accounting and Financial
Studies Journal, Volume 14, Number 2, PP:19-26.
20- Sekaran, U. (2000), Research Methods For Business, A Skill-Building
Approach. John Wiley and Sons Inc, New York.
21- Tucker, H. (2001). "IT And The Audit", Journal Of
Accountancy,OnlineAvailableIssues,September.www.Aicpa.Org/Pubs/Jofa/
Sept2001/Tucker.Ht.
22- Tucker، George، (2010). ”IT and The Audit”، Journal of Accountancy،
Vol، 192، PP: 41-48.
23- Whittington، Ray، (2008)، New Audit Documentation Requirement;
SAS 96 Raise the Bar for Audit Documentation، Adding Specific
Requirement in Several Areas، Journal of Accountancy . Vol .65، pp. 72-
92.
110
* ! Y *
:5",
:%,
#
!
;
&
()
111
:I
K1
>
:
K2
5
, 35 8 25 5
, 25 8
5
, 55 8 45 5
, 45 8 35
> B' 5
, 55
:
*` K3
+, " I# "
# " ,#
6
U
/
U
/
4
*
' #
, ?8 (+,
.1
.?8 5 , 5#@8 <
1'
, ?8 5
" ?8 #8
.2
.,#, !" 7#
#
"
5"#8 +") J3 () ?8 #8
.3
.7#
#"
/! #-
7#
#" 5
@ ?8 D#,
.4
.5#3" ?8 5
" #9 1"+ %, #.@3
#
7#
9" ?8 %# #8
.5
.7#
#
5"#8
3
, 5 =#
" ?8 <=#3 9
.6
.7#
#
<+ 7#" ,#" ?8 %# #8
.7
.?8 5 #;
# ",# #-
+ ?8 %# #8
.8
.?8 5 , & 5# 7
5",#
7= '" ?8 %# #8
.9
.?8 5
" #9
#
5"#8
3" ?8 %# #8
.10
.<, <@" 7#
5
"# 5 5
=4" ?8 %# #8
.11
.?8 5 ' 5, R"
113
( 2 ) *
23
6
*0
3
(
5"
# 5
# #
" -
" !" #,2 1
5"
# 5
# #, i , #,2 2
5"
# 5
# , 3
5
# )#9 I#' 4
5
5
# )" >* 5
l 5
# #"
#> 6
117
SEX
Cumulative
Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent
Valid 1.00 9.7 80.0
100 80.0
2.00 16.6 100.0
25 20.0
Total 125 100.0 100.0
AGE
Cumulative
Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent
Valid 1.00 30 24.0 9.7 9.7
2.00 56 44.8 16.6 26.3
3.00 24 19.2 25 51.3
4.00 5 4.0 22.2 73.5
5.00 10 8.0 26.3 100.0
Total 125 100.0 100.0
EDU
Cumulative
Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent
Valid 1.00 0 0 0 0
2.00 110 88.0 4.2 87.5
3.00 10 8.0 2.8 89.3
4.00 5 4.0 9.7 100.0
Total 125 100.0 100.0
EXP
Cumulative
Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent
Valid 1.00 76 60.8 25 25
2.00 20 16.0 15.2 40.7
3.00 19 15.2 22.2 62.9
4.00 5 4.0 16.6 78.5
5.00 5 4.0 20.8 100.0
Total 125 100.0 100.0
118
Descriptive Statistics
Variables Entered/Removed(b)
Variables Variables
Model Entered Removed Method
1 TOTALQ(a) . Enter
a All requested variables entered.
b Dependent Variable: TOTALP
Model Summary
ANOVA(b)
Sum of
Model Squares df Mean Square F Sig.
1 Regressio 10.239 2.239 40.736
1 .000(a)
n
Residual 9.41 1.893
123
Total 19.380
124
a Predictors: (Constant)، TOTALQ
b Dependent Variable: TOTALP
Variables Entered/Removed(b)
Variables Variables
Model Entered Removed Method
1 TOTALG(a) . Enter
a All requested variables entered.
b Dependent Variable: TOTALP
Model Summary
ANOVA(b)
Sum of
Model Squares df Mean Square F Sig.
1 Regressio
44.02 .000(a)
n 11.81 5 2.95
Residual 8.05 119 0.07
Total 19.86 124
a Predictors: (Constant)، TOTALG
b Dependent Variable: TOTALP
Coefficients(a)
Unstandardized Standardized
Coefficients Coefficients
Variables Entered/Removed(b)
Variables Variables
Model Entered Removed Method
1 TOTALS(a) . Enter
a All requested variables entered.
b Dependent Variable: TOTALP
Model Summary
ANOVA(b)
Sum of
Model Squares df Mean Square F Sig.
1 Regressio
4 46.754 .000(a)
n 16.68 4.17
Residual 19.80 120 0.16
Total 36.47 124
a Predictors: (Constant)، TOTALS
b Dependent Variable: TOTALP
121
Variables Entered/Removed(b)
Variables Variables
Model Entered Removed Method
1 TOTALQ(a) . Enter
a All requested variables entered.
b Dependent Variable: TOTALP
Model Summary
Coefficients(a)
Unstandardized Standardized
Coefficients Coefficients