Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Fueling Athletes
Facts Versus Fiction on Feeding Athletes
for Peak Performance
Copyr ight © Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Nutrition Behavior & Performance Feeding Athletes for Peak Performance
enough to fuel a 26-mile marathon if carbohydrate exercise, or recovery. Not all athletes need to be vigilant
was the only fuel available.3 Fortunately, carbohydrate about all 3 phases. Table 1 illustrates carbohydrate
may be the preferred fuel, but it is not the only fuel. At recommendations for athletes in selected situations.
low exercise intensities (approximately 40% of maximum
oxygen consumption), fat utilization from plasma free Pre-exercise Carbohydrate
fatty acids becomes the major fuel, and exercise can be
performed for many hours by drawing upon the body’s All active people should eat a carbohydrate-rich diet,
fat reserves.3 focusing on whole grains, fruits, and vegetables for
nutrient-dense carbohydrates. In certain circumstances,
eating a carbohydrate-rich meal or snack before
exercise can improve performance.4 Athletes who
Carbohydrate is the primary fuel began exercise with low glycogen stores can benefit
for working muscles. from pre-exercise carbohydrate. Low glycogen stores
can be the result of hard training, with inadequate
time to replenish liver and muscle stores or from
inadequate carbohydrate consumption in the usual diet,
Studies on carbohydrate use during exercise are especially when paired with overnight fasting. Liver
typically conducted on athletes who train and compete at glycogen can be depleted by a 15-hour fast, and an
high intensity (965% of maximum oxygen consumption), overnight fast can reduce stores significantly.5 Athletes
and recommendations for carbohydrate consumption who need to compete at high intensities may find
are made with the serious athlete in mind. The typical that their performance is limited if carbohydrate intake
US diet contains approximately 4 to 5 g of carbohydrate is not optimal. A pre-exercise feeding can help to restore
per kilogram of body weight, which is at the low end glycogen if consumed 2 to 4 hours before the activity
of recommendations even for recreational athletes. and is most helpful in endurance events that last more
Endurance athletes need even higher carbohydrate than 1 hour at high intensities. Recommendations
intake than recreational athletes do, and here is where on carbohydrate intake should be based on the total
the confusion lies. Research is usually conducted on amount of carbohydrate and the timing relative to
trained, elite athletes; but most of the active people exercise. If an athlete has only an hour to eat before
who seek nutrition advice are not at the elite level. an early morning event, then 1 g/kg carbohydrate
Many are exercising to lose or maintain weight and fear is recommended; if more time is available, more
that eating carbohydrate will undermine the benefits of carbohydrate can be consumed.
exercise. However, without adequate carbohydrate, Athletes are encouraged to try food or fluids during
exercise will be more difficult, so a vicious cycle of training to make sure no gastrointestinal upset occurs
underfueling can begin. Athletes, whether elite, during competition. Many athletes tell horror stories
recreational, or somewhere in between, can tailor their about eating a new or unfamiliar food in the hours
intake of carbohydrate fueling for pre-exercise, during before a competition, with negative results. Runners
Copyr ight © Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Feeding Athletes for Peak Performance Nutrition Behavior & Performance
are urged to use caution at the running expo when athletes rely on carbohydrate plus protein to aid
they go to pick up their race number. Here, they can recovery, but research is equivocal. Carbohydrate plus
find themselves surrounded by marketers giving samples protein will not improve muscle glycogen resynthesis,
of energy bars, gels, and drinks. If an athlete has never but protein may provide an anabolic stimulus to muscle.9
used a gel and tries it the morning of the event, he or Athletes who do not train hard every day do not need to
she is flirting with an upset stomach or diarrhea during be concerned with recovery strategies. Eating a
the race. When in doubt, leave it out, and go for the carbohydrate-rich meal after exercise will be sufficient to
tried and true foods and fluids that worked in training. begin the glycogen replacement process.
Athletes often believe that energy bars are the best
pre-event food, but Paddeon-Jones and Pearson6
debunked that myth when they gave athletes 4 different
Other Benefits of Carbohydrates
types of carbohydrate feedings (460 calories, with Recently, other benefits of carbohydrates have been
approximately 70% carbohydrate) 2 hours before a observed. Nieman10 has shown that carbohydrate
60-minute endurance cycling bout. They found that consumption may be beneficial to the immune system
all of the feedings offered a benefit to performance to ward off upper respiratory infections after strenuous
with no advantage to one type of feeding over another. exercise. It appears to reduce the level of stress hormones
The feedings ranged from an expensive energy bar (catecholamines, growth hormone, cortisol, and
at a cost of $2.60 to oat or wheat cereal at a cost of adrenocorticotropic hormone) and cytokines secreted
approximately $0.50. after exercise. Carbohydrate also helps prevent a
decrease in neutrophils that is commonly seen after
strenuous exercise. The effects of immunosuppression
Carbohydrate During Exercise
during exercise are exacerbated when exercising in a
The purpose a carbohydrate feeding during exercise carbohydrate-depleted state.11
is to maintain blood glucose levels to fuel long bouts Another benefit of carbohydrate intake appears to
of exercise, especially those activities that require a be an improved mood state. Achten et al12 fed trained
‘‘kick’’ or sprint at the end of exercise. Researchers runners diets containing 5.4 g of carbohydrate per
have also studied carbohydrate use during intermittent kilogram of body weight (41% of total energy) or 8.5 g
sports, such as basketball and soccer, and found that of carbohydrate per kilogram of body weight (65% of
the ability to perform activities for a longer period are total energy) and trained them intensively for 11 days.
achieved with carbohydrate compared with placebo.7 The crossover, randomized trial had performance
Based on observations by Nicholas et al7 and Coyle measures of 8-km all-out run indoors on a treadmill
et al,8 athletes are advised to consume small amounts and an 11-km all-out run outdoors. Athletes consuming
of carbohydrate (30 to 60 g) every hour during the higher level of carbohydrate performed better in
high-intensity endurance or intermittent activity. The the running trials and reported less fatigue and better
key is intensity; recreational athletes who play baseball mood, using the Profile of Mood States. The authors
for several hours at low intensity will not benefit from speculate that adequate carbohydrate consumption
additional carbohydrate. improved the runner’s mood and physical performance
Athletes who choose to include carbohydrate feedings by allowing them to train and compete without fatigue.
during exercise can achieve the recommendations
through solid food or through consumption of sports
drinks. A typical sports drink contains approximately
15 g of carbohydrate per 8 fl oz; thus, consuming 16 oz Carbohydrate offers additional
of sports drink every hour will aid both carbohydrate benefits to athletes; it aids in the
and fluid intake.
elevation of mood states and
Recovery Carbohydrate improves immune function.
Carbohydrate in the hours after exercise is important for
athletes who train every day. Elite-level athletes frequently
train hard several times a day, and these athletes have Are Protein Needs Significantly Higher
to work hard to replace glycogen used during training. for Athletes Than for Nonathletes?
The best strategy to aid in glycogen resynthesis is to
consume 1.5 g/kg of carbohydrate in the first hour after Protein has always been the most favored macronutrient
exercise and an additional 1.5 g/kg 2 hours later.3 Many in the sports world. Open any muscle and fitness
Copyr ight © Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Nutrition Behavior & Performance Feeding Athletes for Peak Performance
magazine and gaze at the muscle-bound men who Protein for Strength/Power Athletes
swear by amino acids in various combinations, as well as
Athletes who strength-train to increase muscle mass
protein isolates from casein to whey. The understanding
and strength need increased protein intake, along with
of the role of protein in sports performance has come
progressive resistance exercise. Protein is needed for
a long way from the days when an athlete’s training
muscle synthesis; when protein balance is positive, net
diet consisted of steak. Jack London wrote a short
protein synthesis occurs when muscle is stimulated. If
story on an aging boxer, Tom King, who ‘‘remembered
back into the fight to the moment when he had Sandel insufficient protein and energy are consumed, a catabolic
state occurs and muscle gains are limited. Protein needs
swaying and tottering on the hairline balance of defeat.
seem to be higher in the early phases of strength training
Ah, that piece of steak would have done it. He had lacked
just that for the decisive blow, and he had lost. It was (ie, 3 to 6 months) and are less when individuals are
trained, as protein efficiency improves with training. The
all because of the piece of steak.’’13 Today, an athlete
recommendation for strength training is 1.6 to 1.7 g/kg
is more likely to say, ‘‘Ah, I lost the fight/match/game
of body weight.
because I didn’t have a creatine-fortified, branched
However, it is important to consider that current
chain amino acidYsupplemented, whey protein shake.’’
methods for studying protein turnover in muscle are not
ideal. Early studies relied on nitrogen balance, which
Protein for Endurance Athletes is not a very sensitive measure for pinpointing protein
needs in the fed state or fasted state during activity. It
Although the protein needs of athletes is still an area of
generally leads to an overestimation of requirements.
emerging science, and experts do not all agree, protein
needs may be higher for athletes, but the quantity of Current research uses more sophisticated methods to
study protein utilization and turnover (whole-body
protein can be easily obtained in the diet. Lemon14 was
protein turnover using isotope tracers), but there are still
among the first to observe that the recommended daily
limitations to the research. Many things affect protein
allowance for protein of 0.8 g/kg of body weight was
needs: energy intake, protein intake, amino acid pool
established using sedentary subjects, and athletes might
availability during and after exercise, and fed or fasting
have greater requirements. In the 1970s, researchers
state. Given the limitations, it is generally accepted in the
began to study protein balance in athletes and observed
scientific community that protein intakes above 2 g/kg
that 2 amino acids, alanine and glutamine, were released
of body weight offer no additional anabolic benefit.16,17
from muscles during exercise. These early studies led
It is worth mentioning that sufficient energy intake is
researchers to believe that protein had a role as fuel in
exercise, not just as a building block for muscle growth critical for protein to be used for anabolism. Laboratory
studies on the assessment of protein needs for athletes
and strength.14 In endurance athletes, the need for
control for energy intake, but in the real world, athletes
increased protein is related to the need for increases
in hemoglobin to transport oxygen and enzymes for are frequently dieting to lose or make weight, and protein
needs may be higher than 1.7 g/kg of body weight in
synthesis and repair of muscle during training and
those individuals. Athletes would be well advised to seek
competition.15 Protein is used as a fuel in aerobic
the consultation of a sports dietitian to more accurately
exercise, but only approximately 3% to 6% of total
assess their protein needs. Table 2 summarizes protein
energy expenditure is from amino acid oxidation.16
recommendations for athletes.
Protein recommendations for endurance athletes are
suggested to be 1.2 to 1.4 g/kg of body weight.16
Timing of Protein Intake
Although it is fairly well established that protein needs
are higher for athletes, recently, there is interest in the
Protein maybe needed in amounts timing of protein intake to maximize muscle mass gains.
Rasmussen et al18 studied the effect of an oral amino
greater than the recommended daily acidYcarbohydrate supplement on protein anabolism
allowance of 0.8 g/kg of body weight, after a bout of strength training. Subjects were given a
but it is easy to get the recommended bolus of 6 g of essential amino acids and 35 g of sucrose
1 or 3 hours after an intense bout of weight training.
amount of protein from food Compared with placebo, muscle protein synthesis was
instead of supplements. increased (as measured using a 3-compartment model
of leg muscle protein kinetics) when subjects ingested
the beverage at 1 or 3 hours. Earlier studies showed
Copyr ight © Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Feeding Athletes for Peak Performance Nutrition Behavior & Performance
that amino acid infusion increases protein synthesis in disease, protein intakes within reasonable limits have
muscle, but Rasmussen et al showed that oral intake no effects on glomerular filtration.20
of essential amino acids could have a similar effect. The
amount of amino acids used in this study is small, but it
could be that a protein-rich snack containing essential Is Fat Loading the New Magic Bullet?
amino acids and carbohydrate could have a positive effect Stored fat is in great supply in the human body, and
on muscle accretion in athletes. More research is needed. athletes have sought ways to tap into fat reserves to spare
limited carbohydrate stores. During endurance exercise,
lipolysis of stored fat increases after approximately
20 minutes of exercise (this is where the popular idea
The timing of protein intake on that when one hits the magic mark of 20 minutes of
muscle anabolism may play a activity, fat is burned as a fuel and weight loss begins
comes from). However, although stores of fat may be
more important role than the plentiful, getting fatty acids to working muscles is not
quantity of protein. an easy task. Fatty acids must be transported to muscle
mitochondria for oxidation, and this is believed to
be the rate-limiting step in providing adequate fats to
working muscles.21 Aerobic or endurance training has
been shown to provide a carbohydrate-sparing effect,
Increased Dietary Protein and Kidney Function and a trained individual will burn more fat and less
carbohydrate at the same workload intensity.22
An important consideration in any discussion on protein Researchers and endurance athletes have tried to
intake in athletes is how much is too much. Will excess manipulate the diet to enhance fat oxidation and spare
protein increase glomerular filtration, setting the stage performance. In a meta-analysis of the ability of high-fat
for kidney disease? Poortmans and Dellalieux19 studied or high-carbohydrate diets to increase endurance
body builders and other trained athletes and measured performance, Erlenbusch et al23 concluded that
protein intake through 7-day dietary records and high-fat diets have not been consistent in their ability
renal clearance values to assess the effect of protein to prolong exercise in untrained individuals, but the
on renal function. The investigators found that studies on trained individuals are more difficult to assess.
consumption of up to 2.8 g/kg of body weight of protein Currently, it is advisable for athletes to consume
did not cause any harmful effect on clinical measures 20% to 35% of total energy as fat, with an emphasis
of renal function in healthy, well-trained athletes. on heart-healthy fats and reduced consumption of
Other research suggests that in people without kidney saturated fats.
Copyr ight © Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Nutrition Behavior & Performance Feeding Athletes for Peak Performance
Copyr ight © Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.