Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Management
Compiled by: Mr. Laxmi Raj Joshi, A Student of M.Sc. Forestry, Office of the Dean, Pokhara
(2010-2012)
Resource Persons:
1
Unit 1. Introduction
Biodiversity: Extraordinary variety of life on Earth
From genes and species to ecosystems and valuable function they perform
E.O. Wilson, Biologist coined the word “Biodiversity” and explains it as “the very stuff of
life.”
For at least 3.8 billion years, a complex web of life has been evolving here on Earth.
Biodiversity is the variety of all these living things and their interactions.
Ecosystem diversity
In effect, these levels cannot be separated. Each is important, interacting with and influencing the
others. A change at one level can cause changes at
the other levels Biodiversity Status World
Bacteria 25,000 species
Species Diversity: In all shape and size (tiny
organisms to huge one): includes bacteria, Virus 6,000 species
protozoan, fungi, flowering plants, ants, beetles,
butterflies, birds, reptiles and large animals Fungi 70,000 species
Most of insects, fungi and microscopic creatures remain unidentified. Their existence is a
mystery. Known Species are:
Genetic Diversity: every individual inherits genes from its parents and passes on to the next
generation. Biodiversity is more than the variety of species. Genetic diversity everywhere (songs,
feather colors, taste and texture). Genetic variation is extremely important to the survival of
species. Genetic variability, responsible for these different traits, interact with local
environmental conditions to determine the extent to which populations can adapt to
environmental changes and survive exposure to new diseases.
Isolated populations in small patches of habitat cut off from the surrounding environment tend to
have less genetic variation than populations in large, intact ecosystems. Therefore, those isolated
populations are more susceptible to extinction.
Produces goods and services for the most fundamental of our needs- clean air, fresh water, food,
medicines and shelter, recreational, psychological, emotional and spiritual enjoyment
Moral responsibility to protect biodiversity simply because all organisms have value
Direct Products:
Food- more than 90% of the calories consumed by people worldwide come from 80 plant
species
Medicines- 4.5 billion people (80%) of the world use plants as their primary source of medicines
3
Ecosystem Services: Pollination, Air and Water Purification, Climate Modification, Drought and
Flood Control, Cycling of Nutrients, Habitat, Economic Values- priceless (in billions)
Two-thirds of all species were lost along with dinosaurs probably the result of a large asteroid
crashing into Earth about 65 million years ago. Paleontologists- on average two species go
extinct every year as part of the natural process but the current extinction rate is several hundred
times higher.
Primary causes:
9 billion by 2050
4 Butterflies
Algae 640 species
687
species
Moths 600 Species
Unpredictable impact
Transitional location between Paleartic and Indo-Malayan Realm: Meeting point of Eastern
& Western Himalayas. Diverse topography (75m - 8848m). Climatic zone (Tropical to
Arctic). 11 bio-climatic zones from tropical to nival (Dobremez)
In Nepal, there are 35 Forest types, 75 Vegetation types and 118 Distribution of Rangelands
Ecosystems types (T10, S13M MH 52, M 38, O5 ) in different Regions (12% of
land area is covered by
Nepal- harbors 0.09% of World’s landmass. rangeland)
Nepal is exceptionally diverse in bird species. 193 species of Terai: 3%
birds are wetland dependent 172 plant species of major wetlands
have been identified by IUCN, 1000 plant species are of known Siwalik: 1%
use and 375 plant species are endemic to Nepal.
Mid-mountain: 16%
Cheer pheasant and swamp francolin are globally threatened
High Mountain: 29%
species
High himal: 15%
Existing mechanisms for Conserving Biodiversity Distribution of Wetlands in
different Regions (2.6% of
1. Protected Areas 2. Forests 3. Rangelands 4. Wetlands land area is covered by
rangelang)
5. Agro biodiversity (42% GDP): Crops and Livestock (6OOO
vascular plants, 550 species and subspecies have food value, 200 Rivers: 53%
species are cultivated
Paddy fields: 44%
6. Mountain biodiversity (83%) (ICIMOD, PA, WHS, Eco-tourism)
1992 UNCED- Attention to Mountain issue (Agenda 21), CBD- Lakes: 1%
CoP4 (1998, Bratislava)- Mountain Ecosystem
Village ponds: 1%
Marshland: 1%
5
Tiger: 120 Tiger: 39
Rhinoceros: 80 Rhinoceros: 18
Sloth bear: 15
Leopard: 28
Sloth bear: 16
Crocodile: 11
Tiger: 17
Rhinoceros: 10
Leopard: 2
Sloth bear: 2
c. Indigenous knowledge
d. Gender equality
e. Building materials
f. Water resources
g. Aesthetic and cultural well being of the society Wetlands type in Nepal
Cross-sectoral Strategies (17)
Threats to Biodiversity
1. Landscape planning approach
Low levels
2. Integrating localofparticipation
public awareness and participation
High population
3. Institutional pressures and prevailing poverty
strengthening
Weak
4. In-situ institutional, administrative, planning and management capabilities
conservation
Lack of integrated
5. Strengthening landBiodiversity
the National and water use planning
Unit
Inadequate data and information management
6. Increasing support of biodiversity Sectoral Strategies (6) Institutional arrangements:
Inadequate policies and strategies for biodiversity conservation
research and conservation
A number of Sub- NBCC
7. Endorsing Indigenous knowledge and strategies
Biodiversity Unit
innovations
Protected Areas Biodiversity Coordinator
8. Cross-sectoral coordination and (8)
implementation of policies Thematic Sub-committees:
Forests (9)
1. Forest biodiversity
9. Enhancing national capacity Rangelands (4) including PA ecosystems and
10. Ex-situ conservation and biotechnology Species (in and ex- situ)
Agro biodiversity
(3) 2. Agricultural biodiversity
11. Securing intellectual property and
farmers property rights Wetlands (1) 3. Sustainable Use of
8
TAL Implementation Plan, 2006 (2004-014)
Old Constitution: State shall give priority attention to the conservation of the environment
and also make special arrangement for the conservation of rare animal species, the forests
and the vegetation of the country
Nepal Environmental Policy and Action Plan, 1993: Preservation of endemic and
endangered species and their habitats; the promotion of private and public institutions for
biological resources inventory and conservation; and the strengthening of the capacity of the
DNPWC.
National Conservation Strategy, 1988: Stresses on Sustainable use of natural resources and
compatible land-use.
Master Plan for Forestry Sector, 1988: representative examples of ecosystems unique
to Nepal, areas of Special scientific, scenic, and recreational or cultural values will be protected.
Maintenance of the ecological and environmental balance and biological diversity is needed for
the sustained well being of the nation. Tourism that affects protected areas will be regulated and
kept within the carrying capacity of the local ecosystems.
Plan for the Conservation of Ecosystems and Genetic Resources, 1988: In-situ and ex-situ
conservation of biodiversity. Formulated the relevant policies on biodiversity conservation
and designed programs for effective management of protected areas.
9
Species Action Plans
Contracting the management of National Parks, Reserves and Conservation Area to NGOs
2003
Major legislation
• National Parks and Wildlife Conservation Rules, & Natural Landmark III
2030
• Wildlife Reserve
• Wildlife Reserve Rules, 2034
& Wildlife Sanctuary IV
• Mountain National Park Rules, 2036
(Habitat/Species Management Area)
• Buffer Zone Management Rules, 2052
• Protected Landscapes/Seascape V
Specific
Guidelines:
Feature:
Protected species
Quasi-judicial power
Regulation of Hunting
PA categories
IUCN VI
12
Rhino Population in Nepal and in Chitwan National Park
• Species Conservation
• Habitat Conservation
• Conservation Education
13
• Infrastructure development
• Research
• Tourism
Legal provision: Park staffs and Nepal Army, Chief Warden/Wardens with Judicial power
(Highest penalty (5-15 years of jail and Rs. 50000-100000 Fine or both)
Protected area is source of rural livelihood ( Firewood, Fodder, grass, Grazing area,
Timber, NTFP, Water, Culture, religion)
• Restriction on resource use, Lack of alternatives, Crop damage by wildlife, Loss of life and
property by wildlife, Illegal use of resources and poaching etc.
In last 27 years: 27 Tiger were victims, 9 Removed from natural habitat, 15 Killed by the
authority, 3 Poisoned, 97 People killed (3.6 per year) and 2923 livestock killed in last 8
years(365 per year)
Relief fund
Problems:
14
CHALLENGES
Habitat destruction
Compensation/relief? )
Problems:
Tourism and Protected Areas: Major source of Attractions for tourist. More than 60%
tourists visit protected areas.
Tourism Economics
Conservation
Benefit of tourism
15
• Non-consumptive use of PAs is a priority
Paradigm shift
1972: National Parks and Wildlife Conservation Act (Wildlife Section in Department of Forest)
1974: NP&WL Conservation Regulation placed restriction on use of resources in Terai PAs
1979: Mountain NP Regulation provided right to local community on use of forest resources
1989: Amendment in the Act (provision of Conservation Area)- A national NGO received
Management responsibility of the ACA
1992: The 4th Amendment of the NPWC Act, Buffer Zone concept
Buffer zone
Protective layer
Impact zone
Strategies
PA Revenue sharing (30-50-% of Park revenue channeled back to the buffer zone)
17
Community mobilization
• Government
• INGO/NGO
• Local community/individuals
Overall somewhere between 20-32% of earth resources are for human use.
It would take 4 earths to support the world’s population at the current level of consumption
level of US citizens.
1900-7.91 ha ,
19
30 percent of all known amphibians
28 percent of reptiles
70 percent of plants
In the end we will conserve only what we love, we will love only what we understand and we
only understand what we are taught” (Baba Dioum)
Equity - inter generational equity and efficiently – resource should not be used wastefully.
In 2008, 18,225 new species of animals, plants, algae, fungi and microbes were found
(http://fcmdsc.wordpress.com/2010/06/02/top-10-new-species-discovered-in-200/)
Over 350 new species in the Eastern Himalayas over the past ten years (1998-2008).
(Source: Eastern Himalayas -Where Worlds Collide)
Between 1999 and 2009, more than 1,200 new species of plants and vertebrates were
discovered in the Amazon biome – or one new species every 3 days.
Current conservation efforts represent a more balanced view than the extremes
20
John Muir Pinchot Leopold Wilson
Biodiversity includes diversity within species populations (genetic variation); the number
of species, and the diversity of ecosystems.
21
Developing compromises between conservation and human needs.
• Pollution
• Overexploitation
• Invasive Species
• Anthropogenic Climate
Change
• Disease
Synergistic Effects of
Threats
Objectives of conservation
biologist
and their resiliency and ability to endure over time (ecological health)
Biological diversity is a measure of the diversity of all life at all levels of organization.
Prevent the establishment of non-native species, and eliminate non-native species that have
become established.
Conservation Biology
Environmentalism
Conservation Biology is
23
Principle 1: Evolution is the basic axiom that unites all biology
Take evolution into account when trying to develop solutions to ecological problems
E.g. the genetic composition of populations is dynamic. Thus, it is not the goal to stop the
changes, but rather ensure they have the ability to change and adapt
It is important to remember that just because systems are in non-equilibrium, that does
not mean species are either unpredictable or ephemeral
Any conservation efforts that do not account for humans (either as the cause of the
problem or part of the solution) are not possible.
Human being have been an integral part of earth’s biodiversity for more than 10 000 yrs
Conservation Biology:
The goal is to simply retain the diversity of structure and function, forever
24
Key conservation approaches: En -situ and ex- situ
Ecosystem approach
Ex-situ conservation
Current conservation efforts represent a more balanced view than the extremes
Biodiversity are under threat, from habitat loss and degradation, invasive species, climate
change, pollution and over-exploitation
Biodiversity patterns are not uniformly distributed. Need to know where to preserve and
manage it!
The design of protected areas and reserve networks should foster representation of
biodiversity and its persistence.
Size, shape and connectivity of reserves and relationship with the surrounding
landscape matrix are essential considerations for biodiversity persistence.
Larger size à
Larger populations –
CONNECTIVITY
26
Preventing access to multiple habitat types needed for different life stages
DISTURBANCE REGIME
• Natural landscape/protective
landscape – forest/wildlife ecology
Urban landscape
• Urban ecosystems differ with natural one in several respects: in climate, soil, hydrology,
species composition, population dynamics, flow of energy and matters.
• The term “urban ecology” has been used variously to describe the study of humans in
cities, of nature in cities, and of the coupled relationships between humans and nature.
early 1960s
• Human alteration of Earth is substantial and growing. Between one-third and one-half of
the land surface has been transformed by human action.
• The future of Earth’s ecosystems is increasingly influenced by the pace and patterns of
urbanization.
• Cities are both drivers of, and driven by, ecological processes within and beyond their
boundaries.
28
• Urbanization change natural habitat and species composition alters hydrological cycle
and modifies nutrient cycles and energy flow.
• Urban population will reach 60% by the year 2030 (4.9 billion).
• Just over half the world now lives in cities but by 2050, over 70% of the world will be
urban dwellers.
• By 2050, only 14% of people in rich countries will live outside cities, and 33% in poor
countries.
• Nepal has now 58 urban centers located in various districts of Nepal with a total urban
population 14 per cent in 2001 which will be nearly 50% by 2050.
Importance of urban ecology Global urban and rural populations trend (1950-2050)
• Urban development produces
some of the greatest local
extinction rates and frequently
eliminates the large majority of
native trees.
29
• Understanding how urban ecosystems function is integral to mitigating their negative
effects on ecosystem services, the study of the relationship between organisms and
environment.
• Interest has been growing about sustainable urban landscapes and the conservation of
Urban population trend, Nepal ('000)
indigenous vegetation within urban environments.
• Study of UE helps develop the management of healthy and biodiverse urban ecosystems.
• Quality in the urban environment will also lead to long-term social gains.
Urban ecology
• Urban ecology is a new branch of environmental studies that seeks to understand the
natural systems of urban areas and the threats that face them.
• Urban ecologists study the trees, rivers, wildlife and open spaces found in cities to
understand the extent of those resources and the way they are affected by pollution, over-
development and other pressures.
• The term is also applied to the sum of societal relations with nature, and the restoration of
non-human nature in cities.
(1) Ecology and evolution of organisms that happen to live within city boundaries;
(2) Biological, political, economic, and cultural ecology of Homo sapiens in urban settings;
(3) Cities as emergent phenomena of coupled human and natural processes with implications
for evolution and survival of our own and other species.
(5) Human factors are not isolated from other biotic or abiotic factors - together, as coupled
human-natural systems; they both drive and are affected by the patterns and processes
they create.
(6) Urban ecology has been criticized for focusing too much on competition at the expense of
the cultural and subjective forces which shape the city.
(7) Needs to take into account the dynamic and heterogeneous physical and social
characteristics of an urban ecosystem.
30
Urban adaptation
• Buildings and quarries act as cliffs for nesting and roosting birds;
• Although species in urban sites are not usually unique, they may form interesting
communities which exploit the special conditions in these disturbed environments.
• Novel combinations of characteristics lead to some urban sites having a high nature
conservation value: in 1990 nearly 30 per cent of all Sites of Special Scientific Interest
(SSSI) in England were classed as urban or urban fringe.
• In many cases, native species have given way to exotic species, especially along streets
and in urban parks.
The physical, ecological and geographical make up of urban sites influence the species
• Urban green space is vital for the inhabitants of urban areas, because it provides benefits
as recreational and educational opportunities, aesthetic experiences – not to mention
human health benefits.
• The biodiversity of urban green spaces is essential for the provision of ecosystem
services. Moreover, habitats and species in urban green space can have significant
conservation values, as rare and endangered species are often encountered in urban green
space.
• In order to sustain biodiversity and maintain the provision of ecosystem services in urban
areas, it is vital to conserve habitats of adequate size and ecological quality.
• Urban ecology helps understand structure, function and planning of urban ecosystems
and lead to ways of sustainably managing and maintaining urban ecosystems while
increasing quality of life for people living in urban areas.
Urban forestry
31
• Urban forests play a fundamentally important role in building ecological cities.
• Urban forests improve the environmental quality of the urban environment and the
aesthetics of urban landscapes, and in many developed and developing countries,
• Local authorities in Canberra have planted 400,000 trees to regulate microclimate, reduce
pollution and thereby improve urban air quality, reduce energy costs for air conditioning
as well as store and sequester carbon.
• These benefits are expected to amount to some US$ 20-67 million over the period 2008-
2012, in terms of the value generated or savings realized for the city.
32
Unit 2: Biodiversity status at global, regional, national level with
special focus to Himalayas
2.1 Status of Biodiversity at global, HKH region and Nepal
• Global biodiversity
• WWF has identified 825 terrestrial eco-regions across the globe, and a set of 426 freshwater
eco-regions
• Global 200 -- the most biologically distinct terrestrial, freshwater, and marine eco-regions of
the planet.
These hotspots cover only 2.3 percent of the Earth's land surface.
Each hotspot faces extreme threats and has already lost at least 70 percent of its original
natural vegetation.
Over 50 percent of the world’s plant species and 42 percent of all terrestrial vertebrate
species are endemic to the 34 biodiversity hotspots
• Approx. 10–30% of
mammal, bird, and
amphibian species are
currently threatened with
extinction. Approx 10% of
the terrestrial biodiversity
could be lost by 2050
(CBD, 2008)
• The global area of forest systems has been reduced by one half over the past three centuries.
• Human activity has caused between 50 and 1000 times more extinctions in the last 100 years
than would have happened due to natural processes
• Scientists estimate the loss of biodiversity between 5,000 and 30,000 species a year.
• Habitat fragmentation
• Invasive species
• Climate change
Habitat destruction,
Invasive species,
Pollution,
Overharvesting
Habitat destruction,
Overkill,
Introduced species,
Secondary extensions.
Conservation
Sustainable use
2020 PA target:
• 10% of the world's oceans (up from about 1 percent now) under protection;
35
• And protecting 17% of the
world's terrestrial environments
(up from 12% currently).
• The HKH region is highly heterogeneous with wide range of habitats, varied micro-climates,
and ecological conditions.
• Overall there are approximately 25,000 known species of angiosperms, 75,000 species of
insects, 1,200 species of birds, and many ‘wild’ relatives of modern day crops.
• Biodiversity conservation is a priority for the eight regional member countries of the HKH,
who have established 488 PAs over the last 89 years (1918 to 2007).
• The eight countries sharing the HKH have committed 39% of this total geographical area to
the PA network and 11% to IBAs, which is quite significant when compared to the global
target of 10%.
36
• There has been an increasing trend in PA establishment over the last four decades.
• The PA coverage within the HKH of China alone is significant (35.5%), followed by India
(1.46%) and Nepal (0.58%).
• The majority of PAs belong to Category V (39%), followed by Category IV (29%). Only
0.6% of PAs are managed as Category I.
• Of the total HKH geographical area, 32% is covered by four global biodiversity hotspots and
62% by the Global 200 Ecoregions.
• Only 25% of the global biodiversity hotspots and 40% of the Global 200 Ecoregions are part
of the PA network.
• There are still numerous gaps in conservation in the HKH. Coordinated and committed
efforts are required to bring other critical habitats within the PA network in the HKH.
• The major challenge is to balance ecosystem conservation with the sustainable use of
biodiversity resources by poor and marginalized mountain communities.
Likely losers:
Likely winners:
• Mid-slope species
K – Strategies
• Growth Pattern - large body, long juvenile period; population grows exponentially and
then stabilizes around a max value
• Reproductive strategy - mate choice, pair bonds, large investment, parental care, few
offspring
Characteristics of offspring - not sure what this means. They're born more dependent on the
parents and stay that way longer; later onset of repro maturity Examples - elephants, humans,
oak trees
R- Strategies
• Growth Pattern - small body, rapid maturation; population grows exponentially then
crashes
• Nepal’s location in the centre of the Himalayan range places the country in the
transitional zone between the eastern and western Himalayas.
38
• Nepal’s rich biodiversity is a reflection of this unique geographical position as well as its
altitudinal and climatic variations.
• It incorporates Pala arctic and Indo-Malayan bio- geographical regions and major
floristic.
39
Gap in biodiversity conservation in Nepal
• More than two thirds (67.84%) of the total area of (PAs) is in high mountains, although
this region accounts for only 23.92% of the country's total area.
• The hills comprise the highest proportion (29.17%) of the country's area but currently
have the smallest proportion (1.33%) of PAs.
• The altitudinal zones between 200–400 m are well represented with PAs;
• The ecoregions that have high conservation priority at global scale are poorly represented
in protected areas of Nepal.
• Existing PAs include 39.62% of flowering plants, 84.53% of mammals, 95.73% of birds,
and 70.59% of herpetofauna of the country.
• Threatened animal species are well protected, whereas a large number of threatened plant
species are not represented by the current PA system.
40
• Biophysical changes: Climate change, conversion and fragmentation of natural habitats,
hydrological change, invasive alien species, and biodiversity loss;
Values of biodiversity
41
Biodiversity is life. Biodiversity is our life.
Conventions signed- 16
• Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD): (to sustain the rich diversity of life on earth)
• Member: 1993
Fundamental principle:
42
Biodiversity Registration
• Ensure the safe handling, transport and use of living organism (LMO)
• (Modern biotechnology may have adverse effect on biodiversity and risk to Human
health)
• Focus on: Capacity building, Public Awareness and Participation, Risk Assessment and
mgmt
• Socio-economic condition
Convention Bodies:
Loss at global, regional and national levels as a contribution to poverty alleviation and for
the benefit of all life. Revision of Nepal Biodiversity Strategy 2002 in 2010.
43
Member: 1994
• KYOTO Protocol- 1997, reduce by 5% of 1990 levels Of GHG (Co2, N2o, CH4)
(2005) by 2012, CDM, Carbon – as trading commodity, Carbon- 15-20% emission
from forest
State Members: 84
INGOs : 97
Affiliated: 32
Union Bodies
• Environmental Laws
• Ecosystem Management
Member: 1978
Authorities:
1. Major stages of earth history (record of life, significant on-going geological processes
in the development of landforms, or significant geomorphic or physiographic features
45
2. On-going ecological and biological processes in the evolution and development of
terrestrial, fresh water, coastal and marine ecosystems and communities of plants and
animals
Convention Bodies:
• General Assembly
• Operational Guidelines
• Reactive Monitoring: Kasara & Syngboche airport, Kwande Hotel, Site in Danger
Background:
Uses: Food, pet, traditional Chinese medicine, fashion, and research. Much of the trade is from
developing countries, which contains most of the world’s biodiversity
Purpose:
46
Member: 1975
Convention Bodies:
• Standing Committee
• Animals Committee
• Plants Committee
• Nomenclatures Committee
IUCN
TRAFFIC Network
WWF
Standing Committee
47
Management Authority: Department of Forest, Department of National Parks and
Wildlife Conservation
National Legislation
Annual Report
but for which trade must be controlled to avoid their becoming threatened, Includes
species that resemble species already included in Appendix I or II
Appendix III: Includes species for which a country is asking Parties to help
Other provisions:
Faunal total 597 spp. + 36 spp. 4359 spp. + 23 spp. 152 spp. + 8 spp.
GRAND TOTAL 892 spp. + 39 spp. 33033 spp. + 26 161 spp. + 9 spp.
spp.
In Nepal:
Mammals
Appendix I 52 spp
Plants (orchids)
Appendix II 3spp.
National Parks and Wildlife Conservation Act 2029, Forest Act, 2049, Environment
Protection Act, 2053, Custom Act, 2021, Export Import (Control) Act, 2015, Police Act,
2013; Postal Act, 2019; Plant Protection Act, 2029; Aquatic Life Protection Act, 2018
Regulations:
49
General
Specific
Nepal- 1975
CITES Implementation
NTCC & WCCB (APO, Intelligence network system), Tran boundary and Regional
Cooperation
50
• Regulate domestic trade
Convention Bodies:
• CoP
• Standing Committee
• Montreux record
• Administrative Authority-DNPWC
• Nepal- 2002
Membership criteria
• Non-Range Country
Forum bodies:
• Executive Committee
Accomplishments
Issues:
Policy
International
National
Backdrop
• Staff casualty, rhino from Babai, Ghunsa, Parsa, Sukla and Koshi
• Restructuring of State
Policy
53
International
Obligations/Legislation:
• NAPA
• Wetland Policy
• Identification Manuals
• Annual Reporting
• Annual Fee
• Site Plans
Funding sources
Institutional
• Additional staff
• Master Plan for Forestry Sector/Plan for cons of Ecos and Gen. Res. (expired), DFCC
National level
Paradigm shift
Species- Ecosystems-Landscape
• No capacity building
• No institutional development
Chronic Issues:
• PA Boundary dispute
55
• Conflict of Institutional Interest & Priority (Inter and Intra)
Legislations:
• National Parks and Wildlife Conservation Act and Regulations (No timely amended)-
• BZ institutions
Research follow up
Research priority
Legislations:
56
Management:
• Buffer Zone Program (Social change, less income PAs, weak CBOs)/tourism
• Drift Wood
• Rescue animals
• Problem animals
• Concessionaires in PAs
• Research policy
• Monitoring
Paradigm shift:
• Disparity in CA modality: ACA (100%) & KCA (50%)- NPWCA (25ka), KCA (5 yrs) &
GCA (20 yrs)
57
Legislations:
• ShNP regulations
Security posts
• Concessionaires in PAs
• Gender Mainstreaming
• Enhancing Livelihood
• Governance (Principle Centered Leadership, Good Governance Act, Code of Ethics Tok
Aadesh) (Mann, Bachan & Karma)
• Instability in leadership
• Misconception about PA (Dislocation, Against local people, PAs is for Human Well-
being)
• Climate Change
Metapopulation:
Fragmentation
• Habitat fragmentation is the process whereby a large, continuous area of habitat is both
reduced in area and divided into two or more fragments (Shafer, 1990)
59
• Natural communities are fragmented and continue
Metapopulation Theory
Levins Model
• Subpopulations
• re-colonization
Diversity
• Isolation, in addition to area, determined the diversity (MacArther and Wilson, 1967)
• Concerned with the distribution of plants and animals on island and island like areas
• The number of species is highly predictable and dependant on the size of the island and
its relative remoteness from colonising sources
61
Implications Better Worse
Corridors No corridors
Landscape ecology
Although these region differ in major faunal distribution, there are strong similarities
among the major ecosystem occurring within them
Each biogeographical realm contains number of biomes (large ecological units that are
identified on land on the basis of dominant type of vegetation –eg. Conifer forest biome;
and in the sea on the basis of ocean currents and spatial pattern of primary productivity-
Bay of Bengal, Gulf of Thailand)
Earths biomes divided in to terrestrial ecoregions (above 867 terrestrial)- relatively large
area containing a distinct assemblage of natural communities, ecological conditions
characterized by a dominant and widespread assemblage of species
WWF map of ecoregion has been widely accepted for high level landscape planning
Hotspots
Hotspot approach prioritized areas that are most significant in terms of biodiversity
34 areas (15.7% of land surface with 77% vertebrate species and over 300000 plant
species)
62
Based on this “Global 200” ecoregions-233
Landscape and therefore saving single patches of “critical habitat” will rarely be enough to
maintain population.
Concept:
Human population increases less and less surface remain free from human interference
Human activities have modified the environment to the extent that the most common
landscape pattern are mosaics of human settlement, farm land and scattered fragments of
natural ecosystem
Corridors
Connectivity
The concept of connectivity is used to describe how the spatial arrangement and the
quality of element in the landscape affect the movement of organism among habitat
patches
Is 'the degree to which the landscape facilitates or impedes movement among resource
patches
63
The landscape:
A landscape is a mosaic of habitat patches across which organism move, settle, reproduce
and eventually die
Benefit?
Maintaining specific habitats that assist movement through some patterns. Stepping
stones of various shape and size.
Maintenance of ecological process in landscape that have been disturbed and fragmented
by human activities
64
Movement through linkages can take place at all scales, from local (e.g. the need to cross
a road) to regional or even intercontinental ( the migration routes of Dolphin)
Concept of Metapopulation:
Major ecoregions:
What is the most effective patterns of habitats to ensure ecological connectivity for
species, communities and ecological processes?
Increase exposure of animal to predators, hunting or poaching by humans, road kills etc.
Land scale level of conservation can only be enhanced by careful analysis and modeling
Invasive species
WWf Nepal
Integrated watershed management project launched in Indrawati and Dudh Koshi river basins
in the Eastern Nepal
Goal: To conserve the biodiversity, forests, soils and watersheds of the Terai and Churia
Hills in order to ensure the ecological, economic, and socio-cultural integrity of the
region.
Thematic areas
Sustainable livelihood
(Sustainable forest management, Forest Restoration in the corridors and bottlenecks e.g.
LAMAHI BOTTLENECK, Grassland restoration in priority sites, Molecular genetics of
snow leopard piloted in Nepal, Tiger population monitoring {Chitwan: 125 adults
(2010), Parsa: 4 (2009), Bardia: 18, Suklaphanta : 8}, Gharial Conservation in Nepal
{81 Wild Gharial}
Sustainable livelihood: Income Generation Activities (forest based, agri based and off
farm based) - Over 3,000 HHs directly benefitted
Over 500 HHs directly benefitted from climate change adaptation activities (Community
awareness, Preparation of water smart communities, Seed banks, Disaster preparedness
WWF Nepal entered into a new partnership with the Ministry of Land Reform and
Management (MoRLM) by signing a 5- year MOU of joint cooperation with it (August
2).
This partnership is intended to develop a National Land Use Policy for the country.
This is by all means a path-breaking engagement for a conservation organizations like
WWF.
WWF country representative Mr. Anil Manandhar has been nominated as the member to
the 8 member Steering Committee formed under the leadership of the secretary of the
ministry. Other members are national experts, Director Generals (2) and joint Secretaries
(3) from the ministry.
67
5 members Executive Committee to support the drafting of the National Land Use
Policy has been formed by the ministry. Mr. Santosh Nepal nominated as a member to
the Executive Committee which is headed by the joint secretary functioning as member
secretary to the steering committee.
Biological Hotspots
• To qualify as a hotspot, a region must meet two strict criteria: it must contain at least
1,500 species of vascular plants (> 0.5 percent of the world’s total) as endemics, and it
has to have lost at least 70 percent of its original habitat.
• Norman Myers in 1988 first identified ten tropical forest “hotspots” characterized both by
exceptional levels of plant endemism and by serious levels of habitat loss.
Hotspots Revisited
68
• Hotspots: Earth’s biologically Richest and Most Endangered Terrestrial Ecoregions
(1999), and a year later in the scientific journal Nature (Myers, et al. 2000), 25
biodiversity hotspots were identified.
• The updated analysis (2005) reveals the existence of 34 biodiversity hotspots, each
holding at least 1,500 endemic plant species, and having lost at least 70 percent of its
original habitat extent.
Coverage
• Overall, the 34 hotspots covered 15.7 percent of the Earth’s land surface.
• In all, 86 percent of the hotspots’ habitat has already been destroyed, such that the intact
remnants of the hotspots now cover only 2.3 percent of the Earth’s land surface.
• Examples: ‘Western Ghat and Sri Lanka’ and ‘Eastern Arc Mountain and Coastal Forests’
are two examples of biological hotspots.
• Western Ghat and Sri Lanka is the home to 2180 endemic plants and 355 endemic
vertebrates whereas Eastern Arc Mountain and Coastal Forests supports 1500 and 121
endemic plants and endemic vertebrates respectively.
Hotspots are not the only system devised for assessing global conservation priorities
• BirdLife International has identified 218 “Endemic Bird Areas” (EBAs) each of which
hold two or more bird species found nowhere else.
• The World Wildlife Fund-US has derived a system called the “Global 200 Ecoregions”,
the aim of which is to select priority Ecoregions for conservation.
• All hotspots contain at least one Global 200 Ecoregion and at least one EBA;
• 60 percent of Global 200 terrestrial Ecoregions and 78 percent of EBAs overlap with
hotspots.
Grazing Effects
• Herbaceous (dicotyledonous) plants grow from meristems in the stem and grazing will
remove many or most of the meristems and thus severely hinder growth
• Monocotylenous species such as grasses grow meristems at the base of the plant and thus
are less affected by grazing
69
Grazing and diversity
• If the dominant species is palatable then grazing will increase the diversity by reducing the
abundance of the dominant species
• If the dominant species is unpalatable then grazing will reduce the diversity by making the
dominant species even more common
Grazing Species
• Sheep nibble the vegetation to a uniform sward and their scattered faces have little impacts
• Cattle pull clumps of vegetation, often break the sward, and their dung have grater impacts
Trampling effects
• High level of trampling will encourage those plant species which are resistant to
trampling
• Cattle are heavier than sheep, horses are active than cattle, youngs are active than old
Grazing Methods
Natural
Rotational
Continuous
70
• Keeping stock throughout the year
Seasonal
Spasmodic
Fire
• Breaking the seed dormancy, increased regeneration, reduce diseases, prevents large fires
Fire as a Tool
• Crown fires in coniferous forests due to resin smaller needles, branches etc
HABITAT MANAGEMENT
• Habitat constitutes the subset of physical environmental factors that a species require for
its survival and reproduction
71
Relative Terms used in Habitat ecology
• Biosphere: any part of earth where organism can exist, many biomes can be in one
biosphere
• Habitat selection: choice among those available (to perform many activities)
• Game management: “the art of making land produce sustained annual crops of wild game
for recreational use.” ALDO LEOPOLD (1933)
“PURPOSEFUL”
• Many human activities affect wildlife, but most aren’t purposeful, For example: Habitat
destruction affects many populations and communities, but it’s not done
with that objective
• Wildlife management is not an inadvertent activity; it has specific goals and objectives
“HUMAN BEINGS”
We set the goals, and they are usually intended to benefit us directly
Flagship
Project Tiger
Project Elephant
Multiple Use/Objectives
Habitat management: The art and science of creating, maintaining or enhancing conditions on
landscape to meet specified objectives for population of wildlife
The stability, increase or decline of wildlife species/or population depends directly on the
quality and extent of available habitat
“Wildlife management is the art and science of making decisions and taking actions to
manipulate wildlife to achieve specific human objectives.”
73
• Habitat evaluation: How good is the habitat for study?
• Water: it is crucial, available as open water, dew drops or at succulent plant parts, some are
water dependant
• Cover: essential factor-escape cover, reproductive cover, roosting cover, ambush cover or
for performing other behavioral activities
• To maintain and where necessary, restore the demographic indicators of growth relating
to populations of all endangered, endemic, rare, vulnerable species of plant and animal,
Species
• To establish mechanism & create opportunities for enhancing management capability and
knowledge in wildlife sciences. Institutional
• To secure the religious interest of the pilgrims and to maintain & restore where necessary
the integrity of cultural and historical monuments, Religious
• With sensitivity to cultural & economic well-being of the forest dwelling communities of
humans, to reduce their dependency on forest-based resources. Human beings
Site specific
• PA Management:
BZ activities
• Habitat amelioration:
consolidate of habitat,
weed eradication,
water development,
snags/logs
Habitat factors:
Various habitat factors provide resources necessary for an organism to meet the demands
of existence
those things which influence availability of resources like food, water, cover, etc are called
habitat factors
Linear relationship
Soil-Wildlife interaction
76
Management of water for wildlife
Water requirement depend on: ambient air temperature, solar & thermal radiation, metabolic rate,
forage intake, amount & distribution of activity, physiological/behavioral/anatomical/
morphological adaptation (e.g. Black buck, chinkara-increase body temperature) and brain
resistance to heat stroke
Sources of water
2. Preformed: in food
3. Metabolic water: formed in body as a result of oxidation of organic compound that contain H2
5. Mitigate the loss of naturally occurring water: check dams, anicut, water harvesting structures,
treatment of water catchment
77
3. Specify time-to use by livestock : mgmt strategies)
Extremely high grazing pressure by chittal, quick loss in post burn regeneration, severe
food shortage, regression in plant community
78
Immediately after burning: rhinos started to eat
Annual fires induces grass growth at a time when grazing conditions are least favorable
Fire: growth of tender grass-influenced movement of elephant & gaur and frequent use of burned
patches
Rangelands management
• Rangelands are among the most important ecosystems in the Himalayas (Blamont 1996)
• Rangeland comprise grazing area including grassland, alpine meadow, pasture, scrubland,
and other non-forest vegetation area used for animal grazing, in which cultivation is not
suitable due to its climatic, topographic and other physical limitations (Clement & Young
2003)
Inventory:
Developing a plan for using rangeland resources requires information about the
productive capability of the rangelands, current condition, intended use, and land owner
objectives
Practices:
The 1st consideration is management of the vegetation resource through the use of a
prescribed grazing system: periods of grazing, deferment, rest, animal impact, and levels of
use to bring about the desired changes
79
The 2nd consideration is identifying those practices necessary to implement the desired prescribed
grazing system.
These practices help control or influence the movement of livestock necessary for uniform
distribution of grazing. These practices may include water developments, fencing, salting, stock
trails, and herding
Some of the practices to consider are seeding, brush management, prescribed burning, fertilizing,
mechanical treatment, and water spreading
CC: "How many cattle, sheep, horses, etc. can I graze on this land?“
Stocking Rate: the number of specific kinds and classes of animals grazing or utilizing a unit of
land for a specified time period, or animal unit months or animal unit days per acre, hectare, or
section, or the reciprocal (area of land/animal unit month or day)
Grazing capacity: the total number of animals which may be sustained on a given area based on
total forage resources available, including harvested roughages and concentrates.
It is a team approach at the local level that promotes active participation and input from everyone
concerned,
It is used as a tool for coordinating resource planning, management and educational activities
with local agencies, private landowners and others
Monitoring:
Once a plan is developed & the identified practices are being applied, the resource needs to be
monitored to see if the desired changes are occurring
• Human-wildlife conflict
80
• Livestock disease and lack of veterinary services
• Herder-herder conflict
Strategies of RL Management
First Meeting of the South Asia Expert Group on Illegal Wildlife Trade Kathmandu, Nepal
81
CR CR CR CR CR CR CR CR
9 22 45 0 46 23 983 1128
32 32 7 3 1 1 76
Butterfly 3 3
Amphibians 1 1
Reptiles 8 10 18
Birds 16 94 1 111
Mammals 28 16 3 47
Nepal joined CITES on 18 June 1975 (entered into force on 16 September 1975)
82
Rhino Mortality in Nepal: Rhino Horn and hooves
Bear Bile
Otter Skin
Turtle Live
Birds Live
83
Confiscated wildlife Items by Nepal Police:
Otter 2 Pcs - -
84
Animal skin items 33 - -
Python skin 1 - -
- - 650 pcs.
Kutki (Dactylorhiza) 84 gm - -
Parrot 96 pcs. - -
Deer horn
National Parks and Wildlife Reserves, District Forest Offices, Nepal Army
Nepal Police, Armed Police Force , Customs Offices, Revenue Investigation Department,
Foreign Post Office, National Investigation Bureau, Nepal Army
Nepal Police, Armed Police Force, National Parks and Wildlife Reserves
Major Acts
85
Customs Act 2007
Any person committing an offence shall be punishable with a fine of up to NRs. 100
thousands, or imprisonment up to 15 years or both
Protected Animals:
Twenty seven Mammal Species, Nine Bird Species and Three Reptile Species
Law Enforcement
2002 to date: In Chitwan alone more than 400 poachers, mediators and traders of rhino horns,
tiger skin and bones were arrested and punished according to the NPWC act 1972.
PA Management Plan:
Bardia NP 2007-2011
Chitwan NP 2007-2011
Kanchenjunga CA 2006-2011
Rara NP 2009-2013
Sagarmatha NP 2007-2012
Annapurna CA 2009-2012
Krishnasar CA
Langtang NP
Parsa WR
Dhorpatan HR
Gauri Shankar CA, Api Nappa CA,
Manaslu CA
Species Period
Rhino 2006-2010
Tiger 2008-2012
Vulture 2010-2014
Elephant 2010-2019
Initiatives
To be chaired by Rt. Hon. Prime Minister of Nepal and comprises Hon. Ministers and
Secretaries of Home and Forests Ministry, COAS, IG of Nepal Police and Armed Police
and DG/DNPWC
Responsible for high level coordination, policy guidance, facilitate and support for Tiger
conservation
88
Amendment of NPWC Act 1972
Way Forward:
Cooperation and support among law enforcement agencies within and between country
Community stewardship
Umbrella species,
Status
Appendix I (CITES)
Distribution:
Tigers in peril
93% of the tiger’s original range has been lost in the past 150 years,
Main threats:
89
Tiger Conservation Action Plan
Goal
: to preserve, recognize, restore and increase the effective land base that supports
tigers in Nepal, to maintain a viable tiger population
Objectives
• Tiger and prey information
• Habitat management
• Conflict resolution
• Anti-poaching operations
• Trans-boundary cooperation
Objectives
Increase tiger population to at least 250 adults by 2020
Maintain, restore and conserve at least 6,500 km2 of additional tiger habitats
Reduce national and international trade of tiger parts and products and control poaching
Kathmandu Recommendations
Significantly reduce poaching and illegal trade Reduce demand for tiger parts
• National Tiger Conservation Authority and Wildlife Crime Control Bureau legally
approved on 17th of September 2006,
Core Tiger Breeding Areas as ‘No Go’ Zone for development projects,
National Park: 550 sq. km. & Buffer Zone 344 sq. km
Chaired by Prime Minister and Minister for Forests and Soil Conservation as Member
Secretary, Ministers of Home, Finance, Environment, Defense and Law and Justice
91
Ministries, Chief Secretary of GoN, two national/international tiger experts nominated by
the Committee and a high level representative of national/international organization
contributing to tiger conservation in Nepal nominated by the Committee
Central level body, Equipped mobile squad with full fledged legal authority
Transboundary Cooperation
• India and Nepal join hands for biodiversity conservation, 29 July 2010, Kathmandu,
Nepal
• At present, suitable habitat for wild tigers covers about 1.2 million km2 in 13 Tiger Range
Countries (TRCs) in Asia: Bangladesh, Bhutan, Cambodia, China, India, Indonesia, Lao
PDR, Malaysia, Myanmar, Nepal, Russian Federation, Thailand and Vietnam.
• Mostly forest, this habitat has been categorized as 76 Tiger Conservation Landscapes
(TCLs).
GTRP Goal
• To reverse the rapid decline of wild tigers toward extinction and to strive to double the
number of wild tigers (Tx2) across their range by 2022 (3,566 tigers to 5,835, 64%)
• The Tx2 goal embodies the larger goals of conserving and managing sustainably 1.2
million km2 of forest habitat and 115 inviolate core breeding areas, including 42 source
sites, covering about 135,000 s km2.
92
• 250 adult tigers by 2022
• Amend the NPWC Act 1973 and Forest Act 1993 to enable landscape conservation
• Gazette the TAL as a priority conservation landscape and place TAL conservation as a
high-profile feature in the political agenda
Restoration Ecology
Ecological Restoration
• Emulate the structure, function, diversity and dynamics of the specified ecosystem
Habitat Restoration
93
• Experience has shown that it recovers of its own
Restoration
• Restoration of the area to its original species composition and structure by an active
program of reintroduction, in particular by planting and seeding of the original plant
species
Rehabilitation
• To restore at least some of the ecosystem functions and some of the original species, for
example, replacing a degraded forest with a tree plantation
Replacement
Vegetation restoration
• Seeding
• Plantation of seedling: seedling 1m ht, less susceptible to fire, grazing etc. and grow
quickly
• Seed tree stands nearby –fruiting trees- all years round of wildlife
Translocation :
It is simply introduction of species into wild, generally, outside its range but into suitable habitat.
Conservation\Benign Introduction
• An attempt to establish a species for the purpose of conservation outside its recorded
distribution but within an appropriate habitat and eco-geographical area.
94
• This is a feasible conservation tool when there is no remaining area left within a species
historic range.
• Introduction may be useful in stocking new or artificially altered habitats for example where
dams or irrigation projects have created new lakes or swamps.
Reintroduction
• is an attempt to establish a species in an area which was once part of its historic range but
from which it has become extinct. The principle objective is to create new population.
Reestablishment
It implies that the reintroduction has been successful. Simply it is an introduction of species back
into the wild area that has been used by the species previously.
Reinforcement/Supplementation
Translocation
3 main circumstances:
• where land development is about to destroy wildlife habitat and translocation is seen as a
possible way,
• where a wild population is not faring well and the manager wishes to boost its numbers and
• Where a manager decides to split a population to reduce the risk of losing the entire
population.
Success:
• Greater for game species (86%) than for threatened, endangered and sensitive species (44%)
• Greater for release in excellent quality habitat (84%) than in poor quality habitat (38%)
• Greater in the core of the historic range (78%) than at the periphery of and outside the
historic range (48%)
• Greater with wild caught (75%) than with captive bred animals (38%)
(Source: Griffin et al 1989: 198 birds and mammals reintroduction program conducted between
1973 and 1986)
95
Examples:
• 83 Rhinos to BNP and 4 Rhinos to SWR have been translocated from CNP between 1986 and
2003 (DNPWC, 2007a).
Male Female
1 1986 8 5 BNP 13
2 1991 8 17 BNP 25
3 1999 4 0 BNP 4
4 2000.3 5 5 BNP 10
5 2000.11 3 3 BNP 6
6 2000.11 1 3 SWR 4
7 2001.3 2 3 BNP 5
8 2002.3 4 6 BNP 10
92003 4 6 BNP 10
TOTAL 39 48 87
• 43 Blackbuck Antilope cervicapra were translocated to Bagoura Phanta of BNP from Central
• 19 barking deer were translocated to Jaudhike and Panimuhan area of ShNNP from DRC,
Godawari in November 2007
• 81 spotted deer were translocated from DRC Godawari to PWR in November 2007
• More than 708 Gharial crocodiles were released in Koshi, Gandaki, Karnali, Babai, Rapti and
Narayani since 1978
96
Unit 5 Monitoring Biodiversity
4.1 Population Monitoring
4.1.1 Direct Method: Direct counts, Vantage point Sampling, Sweeping techniques,
flushing
• In traditional capture-recapture studies, target species (fish, birds, reptiles, mammals) are
usually marked using artificial tags or bands.
• However, tigers have natural body markings in the form of stripes, which allow us to
identify individually.
• In most camera trapping situations, it would be unwise to trap for only two sample
period. Traps are set for several consecutive days. Each day is considered as a sample
period.
97
Lincoln-Peterson 2-sample estimator:
• N= n1*n2/m
Where, N= total number in the sampled population, n1=Number of individuals caught and
released in occasion 1 (eg, 7), n2= Number of individuals caught and released on occasion 2 (eg
5), m= Number of animals recaptured in occasion 2 (animals caught at both occasions) (eg, 2)
• Then, N= 7*5/2 = 18
• Then, N=[(8*6)/3]-1 = 15
Assumptions
• These models are used when no gains to, or losses from the population occurred between
sampling occasions.
• Generally, these models applied for studies of shorter period, usually less than 90 days.
• It satisfied two conditions; demographically closed (no birth and no death) and
geographically closed (no emigration and no immigration).
• These models are used when there are gains, losses or both occurring between sampling
periods.
Density Estimation
• Where A is area of core camera trap polygon. Actually, it should be more than that. So,
the Density:
D= N/A*W
98
• Where W is effective strip width which is calculated by averaging the sum of mean
maximum distance traveled by tigers who have captured twice or more. AW is the
effective area for estimation of density.
Example:
• Suppose, camera trap polygon area (Minimum convex polygon method)=142.37 sq. km.
and mean maximum distance traveled by tigers is 4.31. Then effective strip
width=4.31/2=2.16
Time: keep it Short, so assumptions for closed population models not violate.
Space:
• Adequate number of camera +small area: Then camera traps can be spread throughput the
area
• No enough traps + very frequent (daily) movement of traps is possible: Then area divide
into grid cells, then X grids=Day 1, new X grids= Day 2 ………….
• No enough traps + moderate movement of camera is possible: then Block division e.g., 1-
4, Block 1:1-5 days, Block 2:1-5 days……
• No enough camera + movement is not possible: then Block A (5-15 days), Block B (5 to
15 days) then after……complete the area
Data Analysis
• Capture history is formed after individual identification of tigers and then the capture
history is fed into computer program CAPTURE.
CAPTURE
99
• Sources of variation in capture probability:
– individual heterogeneity,
– time
• Time variation: variation in capture probability from one sampling occasion to another
Models
• Mb permits a different capture probability for unmarked and previously marked animals
(trap-shyness and trap-happy)
CAPTURE
DISTANCE
Sign Survey
100
This is jungle, Barren yet beautiful; Quite but noisy; Peaceful but dangerous; Here, people speak
in whisper, Not out of fear but with respect.
Sign Survey
• Wildlife Biologist is first and foremost the good observer: Keen observation rather than
measurements
• Most often animals are not seen, but their signs are
• Depends on substrate conditions: easy in dusty road, sandy riverbed, alluvial soil but
difficult if unsuitable soil, rainfall and leaf litter
• Territorial animal leaves signs: not all animals are territorial and leave signs (anti-
predator strategy). Signs in breeding seasons.
• Age of sign: very fresh, fresh, old, very old (relic and non-relic site)
• Time of survey: Most of the animals active during early morning and late evening (Diurnal)
Field crew may not find any signs at all: pls recognize that such outcomes are not unusual
Not finding signs does not necessarily mean that the crew team is not doing its job
It also does not necessarily mean that animals are absent from the area
101
Presence-Absence Survey
Presence-absence survey
Presence is assumed to be determined without error, such that detection of sign of one
species are not confused with sign of other species
Absence can reflect either true absence OR presence with non-detection of sign
Types of Observation
3 Droppings (scats, dungs, pellets) Small Sambar =large chital, Goat pellet=chital pellet,
pugmark of adult leopard and tiger cub
Estimating Observability
Habitat Selection
What? Why?
Causes
– Microclimatic variations
Habitat Selection
• Some group of animals are much more habitat specific than others
• The extent to which a habitat can fulfill the requirements of an animal determine habitat
selection
• Habitat selection is affected by factors like abundance and quality of food, suitability of
weather, shelter against extremes of weathers, escape cover for predators etc
• Habitat use is the way an animal uses (or consumes) a collection of physical and
biological components in a habitat
Sexual Selection
• All sexually reproducing animals seek reproductive partners, or mates, who will enable
them to enhance their reproductive success.
• It is the selection of males (females) for trials which are solely concerned with increasing
mating success
• Reproductive behavior can favor the evolution of traits that the attractiveness of
individuals to members of other sex.
103
• Anderson (1982) explained that females of many species exhibit strong preferences for
particular male characteristics. Experiment on effects of tail length of widow-birds,
female choose male with long tail and found that success of mating was higher in birds
that had elongated tails.
Handicapped Principle
• Zohari (1975) postulated good genes hypothesis. He suggested that male display indicates
some components of male fitness. E.g., bright coloring or long tail in mail bird indicates a
lack of parasites. Display characters serve as a signal to females that this particular male
has good genes.
• Long tail of peacock is a handicap for day to day survival and it acts as an advertisement
of the quality of male for the female. Longer tails are preferred by females.
Requirements:
HSI
104
Model Applicability
• defined as the assessment of how well protected areas are being managed
• It includes:
– Design issues
– Delivery of PA objectives
Why MEE?
• Growing concern amongst PA professionals that some PAs are not achieving their
objectives and some losing the values
Context
• Assessment tools:
Identifying the site values, Identifying threats, Relationship with stakeholders, Review of
national context
Planning
Design assessment
Inputs, Proceeses
Inputs
• What do we need?
• Allocation of resources
Processes
Outputs
Outcomes
4. Compile and analyze worksheet through using data and meeting and consultations
Conflict management
– Instrumental value: We still value animals that are useful to us because they help us
achieve our own goals (an anthropocentric view)
107
– Intrinsic value: We also value animals in their own right, regardless of their usefulness (a
bio-centric view)
Socio economic
Policy
– beautiful, intelligent, related to us, large, useful, economically valuable, not threatening,
not predatory, graceful
• As the life style changes from rural to urban the dependence on wild resources reduced
Change in relationship
• Subsistence - commerce
Banana and rice are more grown in the agriculture field than in the wild
Buffalo, goat are more produced in the farm than in the forest
HISTORICAL CHANGES IN
ATTITUDES
Insurance against hunger: Acts as a buffer against drought and famine, food security
• Gross worth of a Lion in Amboseli National Park, Kenya – US$ 27, 000/year
• About 50, million worth of wild meat (pig) derived every year by Sarawak Villagers in
Indonesia.
• Use of wild resources in Tanzania in 1988 was estimated to US$ 120 million
Use of wildlife
• Liberia- 75% of the estimated total meat production approx. 105 000 tonnes/year
• Ghana – 75% of the populations depends on wildlife protein, 80% fresh meat consumed
from bush meat.
GENDER AND
ATTITUDES
• Christianity is more hostile to nature (believe on human supremacy on other living beings
(‘Be fruitful, and multiply, and replenish the earth, and subdue it’- genesis 1:28)
• Hinduism believes on the survival rights of all living beings (Basudhiva Kutumbakam)
• Buddhism believes on non valiance and considered to be the most eco friendly religion in
the world.
• Religion and cultural practices attach special values to different species. For example
elephant, rat, snakes, lion, tiger
• Wildlife plays a vital role in cultural activities e.g annual hunting of Satter tribes in
Nepal, Masai tribes in Kenya
111
• Over 8.5 million bison were shot dead in 1871-73. Boson population dropped from 60
million to 150 within 30 yrs, (1869-1889)
• Establishment of PAs
• Resettlements
– BZ programme
• Human beings as a supreme creature has responsibility to save other forms of lives or
not?
• Compassion to nature
• ‘Nature can fulfill everyone’s needs but not their greed’- Mahatma Gandhi
• ‘Humankind has not woven the web of life. We are but one thread within it. What ever we
do to the web, we do to ourselves. All things are bound together All things connect….”
Chief Seattle
112
• “Civilization is a state of mutual and interdependent cooperation, between human
animals, other animals, Which may disrupted at any moment by the failure of any of
them” Aldo Leopold
Human-wildlife relationship
• Education, Benefits
In CNP:
• All studies suggest that people are not against park. They are only unhappy with the
approach of park management
• People close to park are more negative towards park than distance inhabitants
In Africa:
• Reducing conflicts between wildlife and people is likely to reduce the negative attitudes
that many communities have towards wildlife and conservation.
• Improving food security by reducing wildlife related impacts on crops and livestock will
also reduce the need to seek alternative sources of food, such as hunting of wildlife.
2. Relocation - From Mugu district to Bardiya/Banke (about 20 thousand hh (?) were relocated
to establish various national PAs in Nepal).
113
3. Lives and property damage including livestock losses – free food
– more than 88% of all elephant sites are less than 500 m from the settlements
Intensity of crop damage is high within 0.5 Km from the park boundary
Out of 37, 4 VDCs loss 200 – 700 ton crop every year.
Farmer living close to the CNP lose about 800 kg crop /hh/year
SWR Deer
• 415 die/year
Vegetable - $ 53 million
• Between 1994 -2003, 54 people lost their lives in vehicle collisions with wildlife in
Ontario.
• The cost of wildlife damages on Ontario farms was over $41 million in 1998.
• On average, 100-150 elephants die every year in Sri Lanka due to intense human-elephant
conflict (source:http://www.elephantconservation.org/downloads/pdf/SaveElephants.pdf. 17
Dec 2009)
• Between 1979 and 2006, out of 37 tigers involved in killing people in CNP; 17 were
removed because of their man-eating behavior (Gurung et al 2006)
Conflicts
• Poaching/killing
115
The conflict between national park and local people is rooted in the conception of park as
areas without human habitation.
A study carried out by Machlis and Tchnell in 100 parks from 49 countries identified 1611
specific threats to parks. The fundamental issues in these conflicts is the customary rights of
use of park resources by the local people
Local people have seen the park as an attempt by the government to curtail their access to
traditional rights of resources use.
“Conflict is not necessarily a bad thing. It some times provide an opportunity to draw a range of
parties together to resolve issue, share information and come to understand each other’s hope and
aspirations. Compromises produced by conflict resolution may be better for the environment
than decision nobody respect”- Park for life
A good conflict resolution process is one in which stakeholders have the opportunity to really understand
each other’s needs, develop a range of alternatives for how to address those needs, and reach a
mutually agreeable solution.
116
Conflict management
• Reduction plans involve assumptions that conflicts are inevitable and that conflict-resolution
mechanisms should be established in advance to minimize the impact of wildlife-related
losses.
• Elimination means total removal of conflict, which is possible - but not without killing or
controlling all animals.
1. Provide benefits to local people – include the provision of benefits to local people as essential
elements of their support to protected areas
4. Plan protected area as a system – integrated in broader land use management planning
5. Define objectives for management – which category of PAs and define management
interventions
6. Plan site management individually with linkages to the system - No blanket approach
8. Foster scientific research – carry out ecological as well as socio economic research
117
9. Form networks of supportive institutions - a range of different institutional arrangements can
contribute to national conservation goals. Expand conservation constituencies
10. Build public support – ensure that information about how PAs are meeting society’s needs is
communicated to wider
Conflict to coexistence
Multiple strategies:
Multiple institutions:
• A united effort
– In order to be truly effective, prevention of HWC has to involve the full scope of
society: international organizations, governments, NGOs, communities, consumers and
individuals.
• Land-use planning
– If we plan properly, there's room for everyone. Ensuring that both humans and animals
have the space they need is possible. Protecting key areas for wildlife, creating buffer
zones and investing in alternative land uses are some of the solutions.
– The local community is key. If people are empowered to manage their relationship with
wild animals, these "unwanted" neighbors can become allies in bringing income and
promoting a better quality of life for all.
• Compensation / insurance
– In Kenya, US$ 545 for human death and US$ 273 for human injury
118
– West Bengal the relief rate per death by elephant is US$ 2051 (IRs. 100,000.00), US$
1021 (IRs. 50,000.00) for permanent disability.
– Nepal – Rs 150 000 for death, Rs. 50 000 in case of serious injury, max. Rs 10 000 for
livestock loss, max. Rs. 5000 for crop loss
– Payment for Environmental Services (PES) is a concept that has recently gained
popularity in the international development and conservation community. The most
popular of these is financial reward for the sequestering of carbon, but it is also seen as a
potential solution for HWC.
– This is where you can do your bit - from anywhere in the world. Always look for
products that are environmentally friendly and recognized by serious organizations.
– There are a number of practical field based solutions that can limit the damage done both
to humans and human property, and to wildlife.
• 1. Compensation is unable to decrease the level of the problem (because the cause of the
problem is not being addressed)
2. Compensation reduces the incentive for self-defense by farmers (and therefore could even
exacerbate the scale of the problem)
3. Compensation cannot address the unquantifiable social 'opportunity costs' borne by
people who are affected by the threat of problem animals
- annual grass cutting, rotational grazing, permits to collect NTFPs, for household
purposes, limited provision of timber and firewood in the Himalayan National Parks
119
• Sharing park revenue/benefits to adjoining communities to create alternative livelihood
and resource base
If we have to preserve biodiversity by keeping people poor, that is a poor choice to make’ - Prof.
Anil Gupta
120
7.1 Payment for environmental services (PES)
Key Messages
PAs are falling short of financing and too dependent on donor money
Need
for
Ecosystem Services
1. Carbon sequestration and storage (e.g. a Northern electricity company paying farmers in the
tropics for planting and maintaining additional trees);
2. Biodiversity protection (e.g. conservation donors paying local people for setting aside or
naturally restoring areas to create a biological corridor);
3. Watershed protection (e.g. downstream water users paying upstream farmers for adopting land
uses that limit deforestation, soil erosion, flooding risks, etc.);
4. Landscape beauty (e.g. a tourism operator paying a local community not to hunt in a forest
being used for tourists’ wildlife viewing).
What is PES?
4. Subject to the condition that the environmental service provider secures the agreed
environmental service provision standard
(Wunder 2005)
Principles of PES
122
• Participation is voluntary
Compensation of
ecosystem services
Advocates of sustainable
rural development who
believe that conservation
and poverty reduction are
inseparable
Anti-PES
Some critics reject PES altogether on grounds that it will further dispossess the poor
Additionality
Leakage
Permanence
Efficiency
Major Ecosystem Services under PES framework worldwide: Carbon, watershed, landscape
beauty, Biodiversity
123
Eco-labelling or certification (indirect)
• Free riding
• Leakages
PA Governance highlight
Centralized PA management and PA management lack autonomy for generation and use
of resources for PA management except in come CAs like ACA
Individual species and habitat focused management neglecting the overall ecosystem
management
Due to lack of tenure to local, no legitimate claim of local communities over income
except under buffer-zone and Cas
124
Funding limitations (limited government funding and in most cases donor dependent )
ES generated from the PAs are currently not accounted and used for FREE!
125
Sumberjaya, Indonesia
Problem:
Coffee farming
Policy considerations
Blue print model of PES mechanisms may not necessarily fit into local socio-economic
context and resource management institutions for the achievement of both ecological and
social outcomes
Nepal does not have sufficient policy and institutional infrastructure for implementing
PES
So, there is need for piloting of PES schemes, reflective learning and policy deliberation
126
Unit 8: Protected Area Planning and management
8.1 Planning Model: Conventional planning and modern planning
• Site conservation planning is a scale-independent process that defines the landscape within
which conservation targets (i.e., species and communities of concern) can persist
• The process integrates more traditional preserve design and land acquisition activities with
newer conservation biology and ecosystem management concepts into a single dynamic
framework
• Targets and goals What are the significant conservation targets and long-term goals
for those targets?
• Ecological information What biotic and abiotic attributes maintain the targets over
the long term?
• Human context information What are the basic characteristics of the human
communities at the site?
• Threats What current and potential activities interfere with the survival of
the conservation targets and the maintenance of ecological processes?
• Stakeholders Who are the organized groups and influential individuals at the
site, what impacts might we have on them, and how might they
help or hinder us in achieving our goals?
• Conservation zones What are the areas on the ground where we need to act?
127
• Implementation What kinds of actions are necessary to accomplish our goals, who
will do them, how long will they take, how much will they cost?
• Measures of progress How will we know if we are making progress toward our
goals and if our actions are bringing about desired results?
8.2
Components of plans
Plan
128
• A Plan tells about the state of resources, trends in the state of resources, objectives of
resource management, problems, different strategies and monitoring resources.
Planning
• Planning is the process of selecting objectives and then determining the means by which
those objectives will be achieved.
• Planning is the bridging activities that take us from where we are to where we want to be
in some future desired time.
• It is deciding in advance what to do, how to do it, when to do it and who is to do it.
• Planning is the conscious process of selecting and developing the best course of action to
accomplish an objective.
• Planning includes what we have (gathering background information), what we want (state
the goal and objectives) and how we do it (create realistic programme).
• It is a continuous process,
Steps
Planning Process
PA Management Plan
• Management plan is flexible plan that can be modified to reflect new information and
changing needs.
• Plan should be as simple as possible. The simpler the plan the easier it will be to develop
and implement. It should not be is a compendium of all existing biological information
and scientific descriptions about a given park.
Contents
• In any management plan document, it includes existing condition (description) and the
proposed management (prescription) followed by required forms, lists, maps in appendix.
• It also includes tourism plan, buffer zone plan and research monitoring and training plan.
• Objectives of management
131
Name of PA Management Plan Plan period
Shivapuri Nagarjun NP No
Langtang NP Draft
Parsa WR Draft
Approved
Species
Koshi Tappu WR Approved 2010-2014 Action
Plan
Species Period
Dhorpatan HR Objectives/
No Activities Cost (USD)
outputs
Rhino 2006-2011
Annapurna CA 9 94
Approved 29,00,000.00
2008-2012
Tiger 2008-2012 5 22 11,50,000.00
Snow 2004-2014
Manasalu CA 8 NO 44 29,20,000.00
leopard
Krishnasar CA Draft
Gauri Shankar CA No
Past and Present of PA Management
• Preservation to conservation,
• Conflicts to coexistence,
• Livelihood approach
• Fences/fine/forces to collaborative
PAs needs to expand in size, in concept and in the number of partners involved and cconnect to
each other, to the wider landscape, to the society and the economy to other countries
133