Professional Documents
Culture Documents
h i g h l i g h t s
We developed a new CRCP structure using a RCC basic course, a gravel cushion, and a cement concrete surface layer. In addition, an asphalt concrete
overlay is inserted between the base and surface to prevent scouring.
Continuous longitudinal and transverse steel and sliding supports are placed in traffic lanes and inside half the width of the hard shoulder.
There is an angle of 30–60° between the transverse and longitudinal steel supports, which are treated with epoxy coating.
Based on fracture mechanics, damage mechanics and numerical simulations, the results show that its fatigue-damage lifetime is substantially increased,
while the amount of crack propagation is greatly reduced.
The new CRCP structure is economical compared with the fiber-polymer steel used in recent years and provides an obvious reduction in construction
costs.
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: Due to the failure characteristics and imperfections of existing continuously reinforced concrete pave-
Received 18 March 2017 ment (CRCP), a new CRCP structure is developed. The base course uses roller compacted concrete
Received in revised form 13 September (RCC) over a gravel cushion. The surface layer is divided into two layers, where the upper layer is rubber-
2017
ized cement concrete, and the second layer is continuously reinforced concrete. An asphalt concrete layer
Accepted 15 September 2017
Available online 5 October 2017
is inserted between the base layer and the surface layer to act as an anti-scouring agent. Continuous lon-
gitudinal and transverse steel and sliding supports are placed on traffic lanes and inside half the width of
the hard shoulder, the other half of the width being plain concrete. Using concepts from fracture mechan-
Keywords:
Road engineering
ics, damage mechanics and numerical simulations, a study has been conducted to ascertain the damage
Continuously reinforced concrete pavement and fracture of the asphalt overlay in the new structure. The results show that the fatigue damage life-
Anti-erosion layer time of the overlay is substantially increased, while the crack propagation is greatly reduced. The new
Induced transverse joints CRCP was successfully applied to a civil road engineering project and was shown to provide a notable eco-
Pavement performance nomic benefit. Moreover, the new design can provide a theoretical basis for continuously reinforced con-
crete pavement and a useful reference for Chinese road development.
Ó 2017 Published by Elsevier Ltd.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.conbuildmat.2017.09.087
0950-0618/Ó 2017 Published by Elsevier Ltd.
1048 S. Li et al. / Construction and Building Materials 157 (2017) 1047–1052
this was the first and last time in which CRCP was used on a large- son’s ratio, and were obtained from Table 3.0.8 and Appendix
scale highway project in China. For the same reason, Chinese high- E.0.2 in the Chinese ‘‘Cement Concrete Pavement Design Specifica-
ways rarely use asphalt concrete pavements in contemporary pro- tions JTG D40-2011” [6], which are hereafter referred to
jects. However, cement concrete pavements can take full ‘‘specifications.”
advantage of abundant domestic resources such as cement, fly The composite elastic modulus of the foundation under the bot-
ash, gravel, and steel. Furthermore, the construction of concrete tom of the slab is calculated to be Et = 110 Mpa (specifications
pavement has the added benefits of reducing reliance on oil B.2.4-14). We then calculate the equivalent bending rigidity of
resources [2] and economic stimulation. Therefore, a new CRCP the composite slab of the surface course, D ~ c (specification B.6.1-
structure should be promptly developed to solve the practical 1). Next, the linear expansion coefficient of concrete is calculated
problems that currently prevent it from being used. as ac = 0.8 105/°C and the composite elastic modulus of the
top layer in the roadbed is found to be E2 = 65 MPa. Finally, we cal-
2. The structure and fatigue lifetime of a new CRCP culate the equivalent thickness of surface layer h ~ c (specification
B.6.1-2):
The purpose of developing a new CRCP structure is to find effec- 1
~ c ¼ Ec1 hc1 þEc22 hc2 þ ðhc1 þhc22 Þ2
3 3
tive solutions to the existing problems on the cement concrete D 12ð1mc2 Þ 4ð1mc2 Þ
1
Ec1 hc1
þ Ec21hc2 ¼ 39:151 MN m
pavement structure, to improve the performance of the pavement h i
structure and to achieve better social and economic benefits than dx ¼ 12 hc2 þ EEc1c1hhc1c1ðhþEc1c2þhhc2
c2 Þ
¼ 0:122 m
its predecessor. qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
~c ¼ 2:42 D~ c ¼ 0:246 m
h Ec2 dx
2.1. The structure of new CRCP
where dx is the distance (m) from the neutral axis of the composite
slab from the surface to the bottom of following surface. Next, we
In the new CRCP structure, the base course uses roller com-
calculate the bending rigidity of the base course Db0 (specification
pacted concrete with a thickness of 20–40 cm. The cushion uses
B.6.3-1), and the relative radius of the total pavement rg (specifica-
gravel with a thickness of 20–40 cm. The surface course uses
tion B.4.1-3):
cement concrete with a thickness of 20–28 cm. Furthermore, the
surface can be divided into two layers: the upper layer is rubber- E h3
Db1 ¼ Db2 ¼ 12ð1
b b
v 2 Þ ¼ 7:769 MN m
ized cement concrete with a thickness of 4–6 cm, and the second b
layer is continuously reinforced concrete. An asphalt concrete layer Db0 ¼ Db1 þ Db2 ¼ 15:538 MN m
consisting of a thin, dense grading asphalt concrete with a thick- ~ 1=3
rg ¼ 1:21 Dc þD b0
¼ 0:959 m
ness of 2–3 cm is sandwiched between the base course and the Et
Table 1
Basic parameters in fatigue life calculation.
The upper surface The following surface The gravel cushion The base course
Elastic modulus Ec1 = 31 GPa Ec2 = 27 GPa E1 = 220 MPa Eb = 27 GPa
Poisson’s ratio vc1 = 0.15 vc2 = 0.15 v1 = 0.35 vb = 0.15
corrosion at the location of transverse cracks, suboptimal steel ratio is only approximately 1/6 of the longitudinal steel ratio. There
ratio designs, scouring under the slab and other issues [7,8]. All is a 20-cm length extension at the end of the transverse steel per-
these issues have a direct impact on the service life of continuously pendicular to the longitudinal steel. The steel on slipping supports
reinforced concrete slabs and need to be optimized. is bundled by steel wires to create a continuous mesh, which
reduces warping. The cross-shaped slipping supports are made of
3.1. Settings of induced transverse joints U6 mm hot-rolled plain steel welded on a circular steel plate. Slip-
ping supports with a lateral spacing of 1 m are placed under all
Crack width and crack spacing are the main control indices in transverse steel. The steel connections and the position of the slip-
designing the CRCP-steel ratio. While small crack spacings are ping supports are shown in Fig. 4.
likely to produce punch-out, a large crack width generally leads The most commonly used slipping supports are unibody plastic
to a larger crack width, which may lead to moisture damage to products, such as those used in the road reconstruction project
the internal structure. As a result, the durability of CRCP is compro- from Xiangtan to Leiyang of the Beijing-Hong Kong and Macao
mised [9–14]. CRCP is a structure with high pro-phase investment. Expressway. The main problems with this type of support are as
Negative social impacts and failed investments may therefore follows: (a) the larger friction between the supports and their iso-
result from decreased durability due to improper control of crack lation layers prevents free-sliding; (b) the supports will incline
spacing. The average spacing of transverse cracks in CRCP should toward the side of the plain concrete due to temperature change,
be no more than 1.8 m (Specification [6]). However, punch-out impacting the implementation and stability of the steel; and (c)
resulting from a small crack spacing may be a more significant con- the concrete inside the hollow supports is inaccessible, and a
cern, especially when the average spacing is less than 1 m. In fact, considerable amount of supports are made of plastic, which will
statistics on the impact of punch-out in AASHN02 demonstrate this
notion [15], where punch-out accounted for 65% of the damage
when the crack spacing had a width of 30–60 cm.
The combination of construction experience and research has
been proven that setting induced transverse joints with a length
of 40–50 cm, a depth of 2–3 cm, and an interval of 1.2–1.5 m along
the left edge of the surface course can effectively control the crack
spacing. This is shown in Fig. 2.
Fig. 2. Diagram of induced transverse joints. Fig. 4. Diagram of reinforcement joint and sliding support.
1050 S. Li et al. / Construction and Building Materials 157 (2017) 1047–1052
later affect the strength and cracking of concrete [16]. Using the damage mechanics, we a use one-dimensional evolution equation
new sliding supports above, friction with the asphalt layer as well for fatigue damage proposed by Chaboche and Lemaitre [18]. This
as the random deformation of steel due to temperature changes is shown in type (1):
can be effectively reduced. Moreover, since a solid connection r p
exists between the sliding supports and the concrete, the strength
dD
dN
¼ a 1D ð1 DÞq
of CRCP structure will not be weakened.
where:
4.2. Durability analysis of reconstruction engineering 4.3. Economic and social benefits
4.2.1. The fatigue damage analysis of asphalt overlay Continuous longitudinal and transverse steel are reinforced in
Asphalt overlay is commonly used to maintain the pavement traffic lanes and inside half of the width of the hard shoulder, with
performance of cement concrete roads. Based on the theory of the other 1/2 width of the hard shoulder being plain concrete. In a
Table 2
The basic parameters of modified asphalt.
penetration (25 °C) softening point Viscosity (60 °C) Dynamical Viscosity (135 °C) PG Grade
Modified Asphalt 30–50 (0.1 mm) >70 °C 2000 Pas <3 Pas >PG76-22
S. Li et al. / Construction and Building Materials 157 (2017) 1047–1052 1051
Fig. 8. Relations between KII and thickness of asphalt overlay in new structure.
5. Conclusion
asphalt concrete overlay is inserted between the base and sur- References
face to prevent scouring.
2. In the new CRCP structure, continuous longitudinal and trans- [1] Yuan Jian-bo, Yao Jia-liang, Liu Jian-hua, et al., Old cement concrete pavement
reconstruction technology based on strong subgrade and pavement, J.
verse steel and sliding supports are placed in traffic lanes and Highway Transp. Res. Dev. 29 (12) (2012) 21–28.
inside half the width of the hard shoulder. The other 1/2 width [2] Li Sheng, Theory and Technology of Durability of Rigid-Flexible Composite
of the shoulder is plain concrete. Longitudinal joints are rein- Pavement, China Communications Press Co., Ltd., Beijing, 2014.
[3] Zhang Hong-liang, Zhuo Zhi-wu, Continuously Reinforced Concrete Pavement,
forced in the middle width of the hard shoulder, and transverse China Communications Press, Beijing, 2011.
joints are installed in the surface layer. There is an angle of 30– [4] Seongcheol Choi, Soojun Ha, Moon C. Won, Horizontal cracking of continuously
60° between the transverse and longitudinal steel supports, reinforced concrete pavement under environmental loadings, Constr. Build.
Mater. 25 (11) (2011) 4250–4262.
which are treated with epoxy coating.
[5] Jeffery R. Roesler, Jacob E. Hiller, Alexander S. Brand, Continuously Reinforced
3. The fatigue life and pavement performance in this new struc- Concrete Pavement Manual: Guidelines for Design, Construction, Maintenance,
ture can be effectively improved. Based on fracture mechanics, and Rehabilitation, U.S. Department of Transportation federal highway
damage mechanics and numerical simulations, we studied the administration, Washington, DC, 2016.
[6] JTG D40-2011, Specifications of Cement Concrete Pavement Design for
damage and crack propagation of the asphalt overlay; the Highway.
results show that its fatigue-damage lifetime is substantially [7] A.S. B., H.M. Mohamed, D. Thébeau, B. Benmokrane, Building Sustainable
increased, while the amount of crack propagation is greatly Continuously Reinforced Concrete Pavement Using GFRP Bars: case Study-
highway 40 WEST-MONTREAL,CANADA[C], CSCE annual conference, LONDON,
reduced. 2016, VOL.762:1–9.
4. The new CRCP structure is economical compared with the fiber- [8] M. Trevino, T. Dossey, B.F. Mccullough, Y. Yildirim, Applicability of asphalt
polymer steel used in recent years and provides an obvious concrete overlays on continuously reinforced concrete pavements, CTR: Center
Transp. Res. (2003).
reduction in construction costs. Although the pro-phase invest- [9] Jin-Hoon Jeong, Dan G. Zollinger, Characterization of stiffness parameters in
ment costs are higher than in a traditional pavement structure, design of continuously reinforced and jointed pavements, TRB: J. Transp. Res.
the improved durability can fully accommodate the conditions Board 1778 (2001) 54–63.
[10] Chetana Rao, Olga Selezneva, Michael I. Darter, et al., Calibration of a
of heavy traffic, which therefore leads to greater economic mechanistic empirical performance model for CRCP Punchouts, TRB: J.
and social benefits. Transp. Res. Board 1896 (2004) 15–22.
[11] Olga Selezneva, Chetana Rao, Michael I. Darter, et al., Development of a
mechanistic-empirical structural design procedure for continuously reinforced
The main research results have been authorized for a national
concrete pavements, TRB: J. Transp. Res. Board 1896 (2004) 46–56.
patent (Public on November 4, 2015, Publication Number: [12] Erwin R. Kohler, Jeffery R. Roesler, Crack width measurements in continuously
CN104988823A, the author is the first inventor). Partial research reinforced concrete pavements, J. Transp. Eng. 131 (2005) 645–652.
achievements have been successfully applied in the renovation [13] E. Kohler, J. Roesler, Non-destructive Testing for Crack Width and Variability
on Continuously Reinforced Concrete Pavements [M/CD], in: TRB 2006 Annual
project of Qingwang Road (the East Lake section in Wuhan), with Meeting CD-ROM, National Research Council, 2006.
a total length of 9.5 km. The whole road contains a continuously [14] D.P. Johnston, R.W. Surdahl, Influence of mixture design and environmental
reinforced concrete pavement and a cement concrete base, which factors on continuously reinforced concrete pavement cracking, Transp. Res.
Record 2020 (2007) 83–88.
includes an asphalt concrete overlay to prevent scouring between [15] AASHTO, Guide for design of pavement structure, Am. Assoc. State Highway
the surface and the base. In addition, there is a 300-m test road Transp. Officials (2002) 59–63.
with induced transverse joints installed. The joints have been in [16] K. Ouzaa, M.B. Benmansour, Cracks in continuously reinforced concrete
pavement, Arab. J. Sci. Eng. 39 (12) (2014) 8593–8608.
operation since March 14, 2016 and have achieved a satisfactory [17] Wang Bin, Huang Wei, Yang Jun, et al., Prediction and evaluation methods for
pavement performance. pavement performance of continuous reinforced concrete pavement, China J.
The new design principles and optimization method are Highway Transp. 25 (5) (2012) 24–29.
[18] Zhang Xing, Fracture and Damage Mechanics, Beijing University of Aeronautics
believed to have solved the problems that exist with continuously and Astronautics Press, Beijing, 2006. pp. 405–434.
reinforced concrete pavement. These problems include scouring [19] Sheng Li, Xingwu Liu, Zhaohui Liu, Interlaminar shear fatigue and damage
under the base, low load-carrying capacity, broken slabs, traffic characteristics of asphalt layer for asphalt overlay on rigid pavement, Constr.
Build. Mater. 68 (2014) 341–347.
noise, high construction costs, and short service lives. The results
[20] Li Sheng, Liu Zhao-hui, Li Yu-zhi, Fatigue damage characteristics and cracking
can also serve as a theoretical basis for the rational design of CRCP mechanism of asphalt concrete layer of rigid flexible composite pavement
and as a reference for Chinese road design. under load, J. Central South Univ. (Sci. Technol.) 44 (9) (2013) 3857–3862.
[21] Liao Gong-yun, Huang Xiao-ming, Application of ABAQUS Finite Element
Software in Highway Engineering, Southeast University Press, Nanjing, 2008.
Funding pp. 153–160.
[22] Li Sheng, Liu Zhao-hui, Li Yu-zhi, Crack propagation in AC layer of continuously
reinforced concrete composite asphalt pavement, J. Highway Transp. Res. Dev.
The authors acknowledge the assistance of the National Natural 28 (12) (2011) 1–9.
Science Foundation of China (51678078); and the Open Fund of [23] Li Sheng, Liu Zhao-hui, Li Yu-zhi, Influence of structure layer thickness of CRC
State Engineering Laboratory of Highway Maintenance Technology +AC composite pavement on temperature effect and rutting deformation,
China J. Highway Transp. 25 (1) (2012) 21–28.
(kfj150102).