Minority Cosmopolitanism
SUSAN KOSHY
thni Canons and Cosmopolitan Fictions
HE GESTALT OF SCALE” THAT SHAPES OU
ty and the cosmopolitan is due
fh the global isconcsives
1st the former snd por
reston, past and present
roductonin networks al
ocala
sn sae f cosmopolitan,
coacinsgetleiumstenscnom ——apoitn fords are treated with salutary neglect—countedin bib
bterogen
cations th
ethnic
here she
diversity
born in
fewin Ha
Seo
cov
Twoductioing canons
icky business, bas only Become
topography ofliter
transformed a wt
taught and tranlted i
Sea Hagedon
“Asian American short tin, Cha
‘Dead (993), and a reviewer forthe Nev York
ofethni oversueth
hat herebecome aterm
can squeeze in under
o Biker i
word ertare—iteuntenaiity 25 tile for
first collection —auggerts the diiesly of
(general eader—revel the gap between then
ternatonaization ofthc erry produ
andthe nation enti eeterla for organizing
counapolitanism the
sequel volume, Charlie Chan Is Dead 2, pb
shed a decade ater. blazed ons cover
isthe subtitle At Home in the World. nthe
ig
ec etoanert and ex
plore wh we areas Aslans, Asian Americans,
Her persis:
tent engagement with cosmon
for reflect the continuing
his framework a
the cosmopolitan visions
“The ambivaes
analytics im ethnicthe marginalisation of race, elhnicity
‘non-Western cultures indi
ropolitanisi, The pos
of eos
the new
ifnatin
centrifugal energis—Is centripetal cap
inten afiiations of race
culture and ts centrifuga
versions of cosmopolitan
theorizt
though the main characters inthe
ores cover a range of eat
iran, refugee, reside
a racial minoritys
ion cin er dv he oppoion
between the ethnic anc va
thecale
tices oft
the storie
foeas 09
focus
ingore
“thenone
andthe
che
sndato
tunbor
‘on
Thee
erpthe everyday
ho ton,
snsetle the given mea
‘snd belonging (257)
ish
the ele traversing aspects of everday pro
(On the one and,
ft r00m in on sal happenings sod
Circumscribed settings, nantning a sata
yehorn and = formal and thematic
con the light, and lee
le Theylight up
seg). On the other
by racing indivdoal
sd storie agaist a ever siting cosmopel
tan horizon of meaning
ception ofits ootes osmopolitanism. Tae
locale shits constant offering glimpses of
constellation of characters Indian, Ame
‘an, and Indian America, living in or mov
ing between the Ualted State, India, and
Britain, Racal and national difleesces, often
‘etion, a
chance encounters,
exemplary
of Lahiri’:
stsof ethale orn
univer fects rviewer ki
To court
single lence, 2nd single fe
aris, dispersed
es have crated
the background for
ys experiences
een South Asi, ined, disp
permeates moderns
nity toan unusual degree,
's characters are educated
middleclass Indians who migrate to or a
ed in the
tween politcal mape and affective com,
niles and between places
places of belo
oatot
incongruence between
instead of being perceived at
refugees
Sacro forthe
asa resource for rethinking thet
tional membership. Inthe ein, another dia
spore Bengal writer, Amierpreter of Maladies,
respondence o lag betwee
hip characterize both ends
political body with sovereign
jon over a territory) in both locales
Js omphasizod in narratives of characters who
srhave formal cient
\ excluded from of tangeatal
sion, rac, class and vexulty configure the
oem of proper stirenship.
oe whose
sorbitan ctizens.
ginces of
ave typically been viewed
fs suspect by sates, 1 argue that exorbitant
titivenhip fers a
imaginings of commun
ing My use invokes the conntations
of wildness, extravagance, abrermality, ex
Tous instance ying
scope of law” (Exorbtat").
perience of spre
lata dap
of displacement
iter of Maladies, dasporlc
hip embodies a subseraatc alien
ss actoss generations and geog
ional identity. Thus, the dasporic
en becomes a vehicle for mi
sropolitanism by eeconfiguring "imperfect
rl mt isasa mode of
the earth. The stores train the
ie aspect of et
‘enship, on the processes of detachment and
reattachment o astaral
soto question the inDissporie citizenship offers Lah
cle for exploring emerge
as Bruce Robbins observe, toward emergent
forms of tanssatonal connectivity
hee field framce ate captured in
the unusual ven ec bec.
which many of het ons mach
dian American ke immigrant orf
Bangladesh visor ther home, ahondred- gee tate the subject of La
‘year-old White American landlady and her Labiet's stories explore naturalization
Indian tenant, an Indian img 0
sa formal proces by whi
ship is
that ext
shlepat
practic
nace
Havth
the piv
herfcthip is acquired but also a¢ 2 social process purpos
turns of cre
snd tonal
hee fiction: "Humao natare
any more than a potato,
replanted,
inthe sme worn-ot soil My
had other birthplaces, a
es the native-stranger binary sn
om af the passage s pensive, ing distinction between
ing Hawthorne's hopeful for place, 2 minority coe
stories in Unaceuconeed rounded in dasporc citizen
acer wo extend Oe
our guides, door
Tools into Wnaccustomed guests care workers, and tema
tarth”becomesin Lait space of uncertain
tlonay force undercut by theerated guest
‘whose welcome wens thin asthe community
ial stato is evident inher
is nat only an
2 figure eho exposes the het
gendered codes that structure
cyand agelaywastethe
iy, and her ob
Thowg ral ercumstances this
‘was no job fra worn, she honored there
mine Furthermore,
lyand possessions in thetur-
nd abt
ines of amily, rope
‘through which belonging
racraize, Her uproot
tthe storys
mobility, may belong to
‘nly in name. The
The ioe
ie further re
Sanjeev’
ought
the besa won
a perente ucging, balks
the ems out oftheir ome.
les delight in and Sanjecr’s aver:
1 0 the Christian knickkeacks disallow
Horward reading of naturalization
to cordon off and preserve his
ty his home while
‘outside tare defeated bh
tries and his wifes resistance. On the other
hhand, her giddy pleasure in the mementos
sd her img m suggest
‘svoidanc from the dilemmas of alien
|
|
L
reners Ch
the party b
matter int
espace a
other aust
Tome even
ndleavesti in which he
mn is negotiate. At the end, Sanjeev
is esignod to ving the thrty pound silver
displayed on their mantelpiece,
i confidence that ownership secures
og gives way toa weary ucktowledg
‘meat ofthe limits of his authority.
‘A seane of hosp
the paty begin,
an exhausted spectator.
ases on dramatic cognitions of
‘unhomelines expressed in shock tersoe,
expected “pang of fet
for Twinkle indicates bis revgoltion of the
mesy entanglements of tac
necessary imperction of sb
home even at home. ‘he feling of not being
thome isa marke of dasporic
Bork subjets inde
beewsen nations culturally. The
ste the latent
of displacement on
rangement aod
ordinary affect of everyday
stroctuzal shift associated wth gebliaton,
reer of Maladies, "The Third andSoy comepotanin [paca
i effete te
er modes of|
the pressures of accommodation of ctizenship
a tranogress the Is
les and strangers
through the familiar Kentty categories of
Ibu, wie mother, American, and whereas oma
charged “sexy” and “romantic”
“Sexy” the
and thvazt
the striking
married Indien lover compl
es of intercultural
invoked ony tobe undermined
the beterosexual
exemplary
relegated its
onsip to his
tion of one kind of inimacy (romantic love)
into tw others (hast tenant bond, arranged
cho
m8
fe The transport
es deny thematic cent
‘nd ironize its
palit the ethics of hos
Second, and more focuses naturalization through the cosmo:
obliquely, Lahr rerissthe narrative cone:
suse
aioturt
with a
bond w
‘sore
toothboth plots knew wl
involving Mes. Croft and Mala are point- caught up
but they ae nr describes the tnorofhis utter
{American fag moon landing) and swerves
its prefered abject.
hen
‘splendid The Wocut
rand takes the for
ae Bro
on when Mala tad up
“The quickening ofthe naseators sympathy
es hie days sa
ee action. Hs epiy
infuses with felng the word with which she
Int ever taught him to speak his admir
eA stunned as Twas, Tle
Iheambiguty of
ay” suggests oth the
mais ofthe repetition ofthe word (Uinew
‘what had tsp) andthe inner compulsion (tem ofer an allegory
for aecive energies it marks
the detached tone inhi
‘ives way tothe ebdued amazer
bes: "Tknoe tht my achlevemet is
have caten, each pes
inwhich have lepe As ordinary ast
98). The se of anapho
force of afets that sw
tween Mala and Mrs, Ce
counters the archetypal
grant love a romantic desire
‘hor for iseigrton
paturaliation ie establishes
“unvomantic—ala turns ava fom hi
her patents and he
reads his guidebook by asi
bers loving
sine qua non of mart
propriate exprestes individal rather than
that the indivi
attachment 10 is wife
{nd his new country have taken root from
ts beginnings. Te ten to other
scros diferences, an to chal
the implicit heteronormaivty of conven
jet force of her
fanates to scramble the
hierarchy of ales, bringing the sm
unexpected relation tothe
rowing ala expectations ox of iter. For
‘inal Continent
the epic short story Wit
toro stands in fora generat
flass pos-1965 Indian male immigrant,
y sccompaniedo followed by wives, the
sted mo
heme
sentoft
numerab
everyday
theteivla
ransore
posible
Sion tore
ssryaffe
the dase
sf ecoaor
or. Thgin their place “each mi
each pers
in which Iba let.”
This attention ko enexpay ie brings into
view the dislocations proguced by migratio
froma perspective far
rowers else, inthe
wold isnot de
everyday though typically as
‘he tril repetitive, and commonplace con
ity becauee it "eveals
transformed, reveals the tree,
tnd tensions ofthe prese
tary atlects a labor. She melds the
the daspoic citizen tothe figure o
worker to ender vse the urhomaly acs
‘economic migration and low-end affective
labor. The disporic citizen as care worker
apoting
ako eeval the centrality
structures tothe
mm by compasing
ndertheoried aspect ofthe 1985 Im
‘Act: the connection between the
inks the affective pre
le like the Seas to those o
and the sory probes the conta
fictions and displaced effects ofthese ar
rangements by considering who
Active labor at what cot, and fo
he new global economy. The mar
through which the subjective pres
Stes ofa postmodern economy ae exploreates unspo
kin and st
nd home
position as
of ahouse key marks
se mari hers. Ds
ft quinteseendally American form:
sympathe
story that
ing of age. The paral
‘hed
| foregroum
‘casing 3 shadow over Mrs. Sea,
ion to independence. The story | backgro
husband «
workin
workplace
Mrs Sen,
tal arang
Famosos
ial
Wee
nebneen Mis. Sen's |
sficaments i affirmed through the |
|
female heates unspoken
sification ofthis loss through the isltion of
the conjugal elaionship, which i masked by
snd homie are redrawn through Mrs. Sen's sporadic attentiveness, absence, an
rogate parent andhost.worker. Hee refusal. as
arged space ofthe home, two work
ing methers encounter each ather—one 8
mother who works, the other a worker who
mothers, The tensions of the exchange are
manage by the
ternative el
"Affective labor, pid
vides a
‘unpaid, pro
where the ethical and econor
Imperatives of care collide in x postmodera
productivity
as scemingly distant and
disparate as Et and Mrs, Sen
tral network
teen the home
kin and stranger. The jaxtape
ebrough ts cross-cutting pet
‘Mr. Sen's marriage Mir. Sen ana
changes, Mrs Sen and Eliot's mothers worl
Mes, Sen, the afestve ack
tal arrangements of
tfny kindy nother tendo word inthe
ening fr lhe seghtorbood women
brings josie thio and then ey it
nan enormous cide onthe et four bald
Inthsplcewhesbin eohestegitme 1 Hesbetween these character, Labi expha
‘ant wimetmes dein iomach sence” sizes the importance of mapping the
‘he darpted denies contained indi
renew word spd the inten- spor cizenship resident lien immigrant,tenon to the every
and aoc of ae shape the
ef natealization brings
of containing
fn etizensip without remainder. sted of
simply resolving the problem ofbelonging by
fserting a claim to ational membership het
Stories also ttend to the cosmopoltas ethical
ned in an unomely i
sMoaned cath” Reversing the ri
m embraces Being at
Works Creo163] Scmkaty Go
eg ty 5