You are on page 1of 37

Ad quadratum; a study of the geometrical bases of classic & medieval

religious architecture, with special reference to their application


in the restoration of the cathedral of Nidaros (Throndhjem) Norway,
by Fredrik Macody Lund; profusely illustrated by plans, sections,
views and details of notable temples, churches, cathedrals & other
buildings in Greece, Italy, Germany, Denmark, France, England &
Norway.
Lund, Fredrik Macody, 1863-1943.
London, B. T. Batsford, 1921.

http://hdl.handle.net/2027/mdp.39015011423970

Public Domain
http://www.hathitrust.org/access_use#pd

We have determined this work to be in the public domain,


meaning that it is not subject to copyright. Users are
free to copy, use, and redistribute the work in part or
in whole. It is possible that current copyright holders,
heirs or the estate of the authors of individual portions
of the work, such as illustrations or photographs, assert
copyrights over these portions. Depending on the nature
of subsequent use that is made, additional rights may
need to be obtained independently of anything we can
address.
-

- -
(* -

(
-

-

2 "
| LIBRARY / OFTHE |

UNIVE"l6
&AZ M
*
- *ſ A
*
*
●^ - -
*N
Q

* ○○]
|
Q
*
-
- B

--
-

-
-

r}
*2Kwarat

J*

--
-

-t
-
-
“=
*

--
--
-

--
\ -
-

-
-
-

-- -

“ --
-

--
-E

--
L

-
-

- n
VmH
-

#
-
-
-

-
--

-
-
----
-
--

-%

--
--

--
-

-
A
N

-
--

-
-

-
* N

-- %-
----
=

----
-

-
-
-2
--
Notre-Dame-tirche
zuPar* IF
- -*
-

//
3 //*
)*
"*"
* P
--

(Der
B
.
--
- --
-

W ſ)ww.} U
N-W-",1-** * **

We
se

Fig
of

Cathedral Notre-Dame Paris


in

West front
of

Fig. 55. Dathedral Notre-Dame Paris.


in

3°Y33○
Planche II.
/ g
/*
*-
V
- -
/* - **
/ ***
-
|
| *
| ca
VN
|
-

-
- *
- -
N/
/ *

*
-●- * \| /
-
S/ *
--
\\
- 2.

/
-
-*-- --- -
*
*
-
*-
N
--
-
--
-
--- ;
-
/ -> -

- - 2. ea
**
-
X
-

**-* * - -*
*/
-
/
- -
**
*
- '-'-*-
\
- . -
CX - N
;
:] e *** * *=4→L
-
-
*
-
-* a*/ſig.
C -

Fig 57 Cathedral of Notre-Dame in Paris Westfront


Planche III.

-2

/ *
--
-

s
Z
| |
-
*

"
-

/*
*

'
~ *
*

- -"-- - - -
/| -

- -
W
-
*
/
* ※*
*<ſ>3×
4/N)*
N -
* -
|

*
/

IY|| >> -
s-**
/
ſ

&
*○
*
X○
/

-
>/
*
|-
S

*
/* -
N NN --
;!||
N

N by
d ||

-
N
-

-
-

-
N

Fig 5S Diagram Paris,


of

of

in

the Cathedral Notre-Dame


Dlanche IV.

///?

// // ///// / //
*
-* --*
2
* / - -
2/ ///// - -
?2/ſ&g/?
"
Fig.59. Cathedral in Paris.Northelevation
of Notre-Dame afterViollet-le-Duc
andLassus
Dlanche V.

//

%
-

-
-
}
-

--
- -
--

-- ---
----
--
T
%

-
/

-
% /
%

-
*
%
%

-
\

-
-

- -
|-- -
-

-
-

---
-
\
"

--"

---
-
-

--
-

-
--->
// /////

-
-
-
○ %/ // //
- -
-

*/ /////

17
/
(

*
//
/
//

/
/

Fig.GO.Cathedralo Notre-DameParis. Longitudinal


f

section.
in
Planche VI.

ZuS.279.

Vom Dom zu Köln.


Querfchnitt.
a-* /?/C.

"ſeso
w Gr*

Fig.71. The cathedralof Cologne TransverseSection.


planche VII.

62 ?

* Z2
a 3

22” * 277

Fig.72a The cathedralof Cologne 2"/2trestleof the interior. Fig.72b The cathedralof Cologne 2"2 trestleof the exterior.
Dlanche
VIII.

/
-
>*

||
-
Pha oel // ]
e" E [**

-*-
-
--
-

*
*
|
-"" " ^ -
- T

---
-- "

- - - \-
*

"**
-

-
-

*/
|-
.-

-
- ||
-

-N - |-
-/
-
--
"
*||

/% -
-

-- - - -- --
- |
*
---

-
--|Il|
- |-
||-| - |

*-
-- |

- -
/--
L

| -
-
||
*
\

\//
a

&e/
ſé


-?S ſſ%
- - - - *
-
--

-
-
L ||-- "-
||

|
|-
|-/*----| ■*
-

-
|
\ſ

|■

■|

-/| |
||| *

|
--

-
-*
*

- -
”||
|*2%***--

-
-J||-|■*
--|-
-
] --
- - |-|| *■-
|-M
W-7- --
||
■-|-
-||-||■ -

- * -
--

"
-
%|- -
-

----/ -- -
-|||

/////
////
- ■ - -

-/
>

|| *|
*
- *-

- -
-
"
-

- - --
| ■|
--

-
*-
-

| |-|■- |

- -
*-

-
-
*- - T -

-
-

-
| -- - ---
-

|--
/
-/

- | | --

/// -
B3 -
!

|
[

J -2a - de4
Weſiasficil 2 - mar &xa *Na
“ loya-a *
|ſ

% % % % % ** *
)* %
%

%- /xfgaza (ir
-
[M
-

L>le aear *
w -

- akf-Repr
nach
Scuxtor
CH.WFakfimilienwon
Regensburguſw
II
4

Handbuch
der
Archiektur
(4-Autl)-
Q% ” a- /
Fig. The
cathedral
Cologne
Analyse
theoriginal
medievaldrawing
thefront.
of
of
of

| |
- ***
●● ●""
-●-* --
-- ● -*--●
-● -

---
--
"- -
- -- -
-

-*

->

-- -
-// -

*
- -1

--
- -
N

-- - \)

--
X.
Planche

//
,ſ
--

-
-
-
|

-
-

- -

-
-

DomzuCö
●●●●●
Z

Weflanficht.
der
Zeichmg
Urſprungliche
Gr
w

dcr
Architek"
ndbuch
- - * -* - -* mach: WFakimia
ScifMIDT CH
von et
Regensburg
2

244a ſa/
--

front
the ●●●●
in

medieval
the
distribution drawing
of

Thecathedral the
Analvse
Cologne anddecorative
architectural
of

Fig.78
of

-----
Planche
XI.

- -
-
- - - - ●---

Fig.79.The of Cologne
cathedral Diagrammatical
drawing
'ueld
oSISAIeuV ölg
V"e!pJOOuO○
“Seöel O
●Idual
ouI J OZI
OJ 3! oueuöep
'ueld Ieloua○
V“epuoouo
seöel ○ooldual
oul695!

*T--- / - - --
N
- V/
/

| |
| |
{ I |
>~l l l "|
9○ 1- / / | | | -IIXGUIOueld
*-
- - | | |
| - | |
| >* | | |
- | Ti |
.l
|
|
ſ
ſ
/
/ |
! //
/ /
//
/ / =
| /
|
| //
/ - - - - - -
|| - /
- -* jE
-
-
-

|
< + {
- | s Planche
XII.
- - l
1
M- - | -* -- C |
- -y *-- - - - - -* - +| /*
VX - *
|-
< |
| \
|
| ○@ T_Q | * /| *
< % / | ※- | /Y || | > /
N N
○ ●
- \
/ TZ N |- / \-
/? 2// -/ /* - - - - ※ N
2 ſ* - | N\ſ ** \
*#5 *4 / * / / /
/ // * N\
3.| 3 - -*
N N | / / / * N\
- TV/ - ○\| - - /- /

\
|
* ál g /WKRxl' | / /
//
NN /1
K* /
/ / NN \ \
\N
|
* "U<
/ /
- *
- *
| /
/ -Z| * \

//
* N "
* * / -■ NN|
\ \
/
?|

-| < E
D
/ A
- *y \\Wl -
M
IN |
|
)
-N* M* 4- B4
N
-H
| / /
/ - -~ \ ^\\
W
/
|H
{
=:

*X
/
\
T* =
=-4= ○
*
-
/ |
L____]
N
* /
2 3 ____ / |
Z /
/
/ /
-
/
-
N
\ \
N/ - - L - -
- // e " 7 Fig174")
Fig175 -
")Inthe
textfigure
this has wrongly
been marked
174a.
Dlanche XIII.

N
N
-; >

-
W
-

- /
-

-
*~ { -
* /
< - & /> A VNIN
| - k| ) *

V/
/ W / * 2

\ | **
●●

---
-●●2

*****
--
* **
-

W
\ ||)
-
* ."
|N
*
-| "-
-
WW
|{
-
/-
-

/ \- V -※","
W
*
,","
\ "|

| %/%
W -/
” \
ſ
) "|", *W -
/
/ \\
y//
-
|

●*
* /
M

/
/
/ N

N

* N /ſ %) * /3

*
| />
* ) <
y
-
-
/
| / ] -

a
Fig 175. The temple of Concordia ARragas Collective result of analysis plate XII.
Dlanche
XIV.

|
Fig.177Thetemple ARragas.
of Concordia Analysis
ofthefront.
Planche XV.

------
-----

Fig.179. The templeof Concordia ARragas. Plan and elevationof the front.
- Dlanche
XVI.

A >

//X
-

M
L-
ö
4/ ^
é
/

*/ VS ※ S/T
V - ※ M S* ( -->
>| V*W * |N%
2 V 7
|
N
\ - | | |


#P

Fig 181.TheParthenon of theplan


Analysis

NB. In parſ of föis plan reprodacedpageZ75cercſe/ 5as peen■2r●mgſy


markedſ/
----
-----
::. *----
**●-●●
THE DILGRIM CATHEDRAL ○F ○LAF KYRRE
compared
to previous
contemporary
andlatercathedrals
andchurchesof pilgrimage
of NorwayDenmarR andEngland
France
All theplansafthesame scale. Dlanche XVII.

-d
ENGLISH CATHEDRALS.
NORWEGIANCHURCHESAND CATHEDRALS
DANISH CATHEDRALS
●- |
| ●)
| | |

r^ SE
:- * * |
* ..- ● |
- ///T M|
. *xs* | * ■
------→ * "="*""""""" V0 m
*Z -
> a a a a a a a ●
24

-
- - y ○
Fig.225.Churchof ARr,○slo, Fig 226.ChurchofSt NicolasGran, Fig 227.Churchof St.Maryof ><>s
fylRechurch fylRechurch ■ ● ● ● ● ● ●● ● P ● ●● ○ ○ oc"
"
of 11thcent. of 11thcent. HaraldHaardraade
Oslo 1C5O 65. * > * ●
● | | | I - TI
Fig 257 Cathedral
of Dalbyprevious
to 1C76. - || I
I ET )
*---- Fig.245 Cathedral
ig 245 of Canterbury,

* ● After1096.
ii * : before
1C96.
*" * -
------- Imm
@s
Fig 25C. Pilgrim ><
cathedral
of |
Fig 22S Churchof St.Olafof Fig 229.Churchof St.MaryofHarald
MagnusOlafsonNidarosprevious Haardraade Nidarosprevious
Olaf K\rre
according
1C67 95
to theHoyer-Munch X X X
* *
><■>< -

tO1C5O. tO1C5O.
X XX X

-
Fig.258.Cathedral
of Lund towards
1C87.
IX >< D

*
FRENCH CHUlRCHES AND CATHEDRALS
○F DILGRIMAGE. Fig 242.Cathedral
of Durham 1C95.

Fig 251.
-
|

I Fig 241.Abbeyof St.BenoitsurLoire 1C62 11C5.


[] *
Fig
g 259.Cathedral
of Chartres 1C2C-57.
^
*
- -" -
Fig 252.ChurchoffylRe Vernaes Fig 255.Cathedral
of St. Halvard, Fig 254.Cathedral
of Stavanger, M]
by HaraldHaardraade originally |
1OG7 95. ○slo founded fylRechurch, ● ●
OT○lafKyrre
Yrretowards
towards1
1Co
C5O 7C.
11thcent.
| | ● ● ● ● ● ● ● ● ● ● ●
aſ ■ ● ●●■ ● ● ● ● ● ● ● ● ● ● ● ●

||
● ●

* )
●●●●● " ● ● ● ● ● ● ● ● ● ● ●●● V
-■ - - - ● ● ● ● ● ● ● ● ● ● -
#

- / N
N
Fig 255.Cathedral
of St.MagnusKirRjuvaag 1157. Fig 256.Cathedral
of Hamar 1152. Fig 24C.Abbeyof Cluny 1C89. -
C

Scala
affed
*○○
* -X
- *V
---
Bn -a

D
C
h
e
* **

●○
-


Sc

*
Y**

opriabeſqrC
*

Cag
o
F
éP

ffaſſaarneſs
202
VeShsióe

-
--
--

Fig 286.CathedralNidarOS. Analvsis


f

Transverse
sectiono chancel. -
of

I.
Dlanche
XVIIIb.

-
-
*●Wo
- DV
@
R DHI
RO
○ ○○El e

#
#

C
PrindelgrC
5po
C.●4 rattaayſe
Weshsidg

--

-
-

- -
-
-

- 7 -
- -
}

-
-
*ſ*
-
)- -

- - - - - - --
Fig287 Transverse Analysis Fig288.Transverse
section Analysis
ofchancel III. Architectonic ofthegable
distribution
of

section chancel.
II.
Planche XIX.

I
JDet 9 e ○nt anyeabtpaa e
bestaaca e @ollske Deleſra Röbetalbere
-
|
|| |||
|||
| ||
ſ|||
|

FooK ○ KFT :>R=


NG
MQ
:MN=MN:M○
:QP=QP:MP
○R:RT
-(
-
LM:LK*LK:KM - - |
& a=&a
c : :

Hva -og-Klerestortehö
eterSystemet
e
*
/
/|
*
|
- -

*
*

Q D221H Hg="a:aI
J'JH“J "
- --i-|
|| - - - -
-
-

Fig 297 Cathedralof Nidaros Longitudinalsectionof the cathedralby Christie analysis


- ---

--

- -
-

-
Planche XX.

~~
--
-

----
/~~7→----
----
--
-
-

|
|
|

||

*++++='
- ++++)
- ==
=

-- *

-
Fig. 510. Cathedral .
Nidaros. Longitudinalsectionreconstructed„ad quadratum".
of

Co
ºf /*?
c{-/-~~~~~ /-6?
Ź2

/
;
-
Dlanche
XXI.
** -
- {
- - - ○
CB: A=BA:CA.
- IH:H@=H@I ○.
- FE:ED=FD:DF.

:C pg:
; B ;
- :43

|
ertratv
Pa?
~/-

- -

- ***

*
2 - - 0

Centralwinéuct P m *
**"-

*

Fig.307Cathedral
of Nidaros Analysis
of Christies
measurements
oftheremains to theengraving
ofthefrontin relation of Maschius

- -
-- -*-- -------

-●
-● *-- "."
● -- - ●
"e"
------ ---- -"
-
Planche
XXII.
-- -------- ---- -
| - - |
- - | -
~*
|- \ * --

-
) | - ||/. || |-
|- -| -* ~ -/ /
||| \| - ~- - | | -
|\ . ~

- →´
||| || --~~ -
...--ED = E-DA-D- \ |

-
cc cÀ =ca: da. | -* ~- ~ -- | -
----
E
CD = CD-5D-
- ). ~ /- | -
--F---G-F
=F G-EG-
-------- | ).
-~ /
H-1:1x= --1 :M-N- -
+x
L-1-MN
OFº, PC)
MN-L-N
=PC •C.C. / 7 |
/ /-
T5:SR =SR :TR - / | ․ ºd=ed
UvV X
=~x -UX- - . -/ - fø
|- . . -. -Ilúl(ı

ºg
19
zy =zy-A-y.

tºt
Æz / ºg

af
Høiðen
aaben
Kolonnaða.

.
gºstºret -

7.
***

|
7
fºst

&
-








→#—
7-5
‫؟‬arabet. - -- - - -

3(
1

2
}{oveðgesims,

\
-
|
«—

Þ/.- - - - - - - ----

2. \.
A

- ■ Nº.

| -. ..․
_____H.
-|- |

|-

..
|-

*
-*
\** - »&\!-

||
-

**
*

| |-||
-
--|
-

\
\

| |
***
|| ||
*
||||

*
||| *
!
||||
|

||
-
|

--
||

|
Fig.309.CathedralNidaros.Theoretical
raising thewestfront„adquadratum".
of
of

-
-- -
----
-----
-

-- -
-------
-
----- -----
----
-- ----

------ --
-----
--- - -
-

--
- |
Planche
XXIII.

-- --

-
- --/ - -

-
-

-
|

-
--
--

A5 DD
Q--
B

CA*A -
-e
DC:
EF:FG *
HI IL L:"L
=
;
I

LJK:KH-H:HL
IK:KL= L:L
I

:IH 1H:HK
=

MN:NP= NP:MP
N○:○P ○P:NP
N○:NM=NM:
OM
-----
---
- --

-
*

-
--
zygyggys
s
-
c zgg
-- 3**
7yr
-
※ c

g7
-**
--

g
g
gc
/
-

g
--

7 /- AN/
c_ _{L-■
---
-
●●●●

/
%

\
1 ○

Fig514.CathedralNidaros, icalraising towerandSpire


of

of
C
T

-
-

:●●●●●
●●●e
Planche
XXIV.

Fig.315.Thefrontwithtransverse
f

sectiono naveintroduced.
●●●●●

-
--
●●●●●
●●●●●

●●●●●
●●●e
●●●

●●●
●●●
-

Planche
XXV.

-
_
- -

Q
-
*

*
*


*
-
-
W

* N
-

*
a-

-
-

|
|
** *)* *

"

-
--
”\ -

*○
W

)-
^- -

-
*/
-

-

|
● *
g

-&
-

---

9**s Q
*
***
*
** *
--

*
-
=
-
--

*○ e5H (en.
5
J

Fig 516.CathedralNidaros.
of

Thereconstructed
screen
front.
-
Dlanche
XXVI.

-
}
%

*
=#
#
---
-

- -D * * * *○ **aen
.

*
Fig.317Cathedral -
,adquadratum".
Westfrontwithtowers
ofNidaros. towerreconstructed
andcentral
-
* a/-co -
Dlanche
XXVII.

-
--
-- - X
*

*
"- -*

-
°
-YYY\ - --*
Y
*

@%*

*-- **

- -
Fi○. 525.Thefront.North Reconstruction
elevation. bvMacod
- Y Lund. ○K-A* /*ſ○
* 2/
/
IIIAXX
Quoueld

- ------ - - *}- k--


*

-
\

-
C

-
*
*

*
-

?
)

“g 40 sse
- )-
rg
*BQ
*
C
C

C)
D

-
-*- -
*
--
-*
*

-
-
"
*

-
-

-
//

--
*}-
*

--**-- -
-
*

-
-
-

--

- “
--

-
-
- -
--

- --

- -
-

* -
-44

-
*

)
-
/
>

-/*
-- }y "- --< -<\** -
*

} -- } * } *
-

- i -

uneupenbpe”uoueAgouou ouomonusuooguspunT
ApoogN
sougpN olgupoug○
gg
Dlanche
XXIX.

Fig 552.Cathedral
ofNidarosMacody
,adquadratum"
Lund'sreconstruction in
alltheplans.
*-*
*
2
2P

-*
*-
-
*-

2
-

"eXXX
ououeld * **

Planche
XXX
a.

--- -
--
*
G

XXX
guoueld
XXXD1anche
-
1s.21.

b,
Fig 16 22 Examples Nordhagens 44 Cy17
freemattempt
of

iF
.

●●●●●

Fig 18.
- *- - - - - * - --** ° *- -** - - - -

■-

|
-

-
- ■

-