You are on page 1of 7

2016 Intl. Conference on Advances in Computing, Communications and Informatics (ICACCI), Sept.

21-24, 2016, Jaipur, India

Finite Element Analysis of Composite Overwrapped


Pressure Vessel for Hydrogen Storage
Takalkar Atul S.1, Shantanu S Bhat, Shubham S Chavan, Swapnil B Kamble, Arpit P Kulkarni, Sandesh B Sangale
Department of Production Engineering
KIT’s College of Engineering, Kolhapur, India
1
takalkaratul6070@gmail.com

Abstract—This paper investigates the effect of winding angle on length of vessel to radius of vessel. The study on elastic stress
composite overwrapped pressure vessel (COPV) manufactured by distribution was done at cylinder to cylinder junction which is
filament winding process where continuous fibers impregnated in caused due to misalignment in circumferential joints [2]. The
resin and wound over a liner. Three dimensional shell model is cylindrical pressure vessel was considered with shell structure for
considered for the structural analysis of pressure vessel. The study finite element analysis. The stress measurement was done by
on COPV is carried out by considering carbon T300/epoxy Yashar Javadi et al [3] through thickness of stainless steel
material. The thickness of composite vessel is calculated by using pressure vessel by using ultrasonic method. The ultrasonic
netting analysis. The study focused on optimum winding angle, transducers are used for evaluation of Hoop and axial residual
total deformation, stress generation and failure analysis of
stresses. The welding residual stresses were measured by
composite pressure vessel. The failure of COPV is predicted by
using Tsai-Wu failure criteria. The classical laminate theory (CLT)
employing longitudinal critical refracted waves.
and failure criteria is considered for analytical method and The failure prediction of composite laminate was done by
obtained results are compared with numerical results which are using Tsai-Wu failure criteria. E.S. Barboza Neto et al [4] carried
obtained from ANSYS workbench (ACP) for validation. This out the study on behavior of pressure vessel liner which was
comparison further helps in predicting behavior of COPV for made up of 95 wt.% low liner density polyethylene (LLDPE) and
change in winding angle and operating internal pressure. 5 wt.% high density polyethylene, under burst pressure testing.
The actual liner models were used for experimental tests and
Keywords—Composite overwrapped pressure vessel, classical
laminate theory, angle ply, winding angle, stacking sequence
failure prediction of polymeric liner and composite laminate shell
was done by using Von Mises and Tsai-Wu criteria. The same
failure criteria can be applied on filament wound composite
I. INTRODUCTION pressure vessel. The orientation of optimal angle-ply of
Pressure vessel is a closed container to store the liquid or symmetric and anti-symmetric shell design was studied [5] for
gases at higher pressure which had application as space habits, maximum burst pressure. The alternating internal pressure was
nuclear reactors and submarines etc. The pressure vessels are applied on filament wound composite pressure vessel and the
manufactured by considering a higher factor of safety so as to effect of temperature and winding angle was studied. The burst
prevent the bursting which is caused by material failure. Now a failure of pressure vessel was predicted by using Lekhnitskii’s
day, the pressure vessels are used in automotive sector to large theory where as burst failure pressure of tubes was predicted by
extent to carry the hydrogen gas. To fullfil the requirement such Tsai-Wu failure criterion. The non-linear axial behavior of
as light weight and high strength, the composite materials are composite filament wound pressure vessel due to thermal
used for the manufacturing of pressure vessel. The composite expansion was demonstrated by P. Nimdum et al [6]. The
overwrapped pressure vessel is specially designed to sustain the experimental and numerical simulation was performed to
fluid pressure. The manufacturing of such kind of pressure vessel investigate the effect of initial pressure loading and local bending
is carried out by using liner which is inner part to avoid the on dome area. The different test were carried out on composite
leakage on which filament is wound. The strength of composite pressure vessel to check its rigidity and mode of failure. Jerome
material can be maintained by proper selection of layups and Mespoulet et al [11] carried out numerical study to analyze the
fiber orientation. From last decade lot of research work had been effect of hypervelocity impact on pressurized composite-Al
carried out on the design and manufacturing of pressure vessel. vessels. The numerical investigation of various impact conditions
Shafique M.A. Khan [1] investigated the effect of various for carbon-fiber overwrapped pre-stressed Al vessel was done
geometric parameters and changing load on stress distribution in which were difficult to analyze by experimental test. The analysis
horizontal pressure vessel and saddle support. The of space debris of Aluminum composite vessel is done by Pierre-
recommendations were made to optimize the ratio of distance of Louis Hereil et al [12] which is subjected to high velocity impact.
support from end of vessel to length of vessel and the ratio of The pressure vessel was made up of CFRP (carbon fiber

978-1-5090-2029-4/16/$31.00 @2016 IEEE 430


2016 Intl. Conference on Advances in Computing, Communications and Informatics (ICACCI), Sept. 21-24, 2016, Jaipur, India

reinforced plastics) overwrapped technique. The obtained result dimensional finite element model to calculate stress value due to
implies that the failure of composite pressure vessel was due to orthotropic behavior. B. Gentilleau et al [23] presented a
catastrophic damage. composite behavior law to account the variability of material
parameters used in type IV hydrogen storage vessel. The
In many cases the failure of pressure vessel is caused due to experimental results were used to compare the model with the
bursting. The manufacturing of high pressure vessel was carried behavior of composite with wound notch structure to verify the
out by Yongzheng Shao et al [13] from vinylester and epoxy capabilities of law. Parametric identification, modeling and
reinforcement with carbon fibers. The pressure vessel with experimental validation of type IV hydrogen high pressure
winding lamination of 90ࡈ and ±15ࡈ was tested experimentally up storage vessel was done by B. Magneville et al [24]. The thermo-
to burst pressure. The obtained result shows that the higher mechanical behavior law is used to predict the burst behavior to
ultimate pressure obtained for carbon/vinylester than epoxy account several physical phenomena. The experimental tests
reinforced. The experimental study on effect of repeated loading were carried out on wound carbon-epoxy samples and validation
was done by Ibrahim Demir et al [14] on composite pressure of wound carbon-epoxy semi-structures was done. The present
vessels to test burst pressure. The manufacturing of vessel was study concentrate on the effect of change in winding angle on
carried out by using filament winding method where epoxy resin type IV composite overwrapped pressure vessel for storage of
and E-glass was used for glass fiber reinforced vessels. The result hydrogen. The purpose of this study was to design a COPV with
indicates that the burst pressure increases with increase on impact increased storage capacity and burst pressure by altering the
load and water temperature. The experimental and numerical stacking sequence, winding angle and shell thickness keeping the
simulation of high pressure hydrogen storage vessel was done by dimensional constraints constant. The method opted was to use a
Juan Pedro Berro Ramirez et al [15]. The burst simulation was numerical simulation to design and alter the parametric entities of
further used for the prediction of behavior of pressure vessel and the COPV and later validate the results using analytical method.
damage modes at the ply scale. The obtained result predicts the
non linearity and leaks due to gap between liner and composite
shell. The burst simulation was carried out by D. Leh et al [16] II. METHODOLOGY
on hydrogen pressure vessel which is manufacture by using The procedure followed for numerical analysis is as shown in
filament winding. Fig.1. where FE software tool is used to generate the results for
In filament wound composite the stacking sequence is altered various parameters like winding angle, stacking sequence,
to increase the mechanical properties. The investigation of stack- thickness, pressure. Further the results are evaluated by varying
based layering was done by Hassen Taher Dorrah et al [17] the parameter values to optimize the results.
during system change pathway. The stack based configuration in
multi stacking network was proposed. The study on effect of
stacking sequence on behavior of filament wound composite
cylinder was done [18] which were subjected to impact loading.
The carbon fiber reinforced plastics was used for the
manufacturing of cylinder which was further used to relate the
damage with the absorption energy and damage depth ratio.
Maxime Bertin et al [19] investigated the effect of thermo-
mechanical cyclic loading on stacking sequence of
polymer/composite multilayer. The quasi-static tensile tests and
fatigue test of staking sequence was carried out to analyze the
behavior of material under cyclic loading. The composite made
up of filament winding method with an optimum stacking layer
has a vast applications in automotive industries for storage of
hydrogen. The multi-sequence dome lay-up simulation by
changing the winding angle and thickness was carried out for
hydrogen hyper-bar composite pressure vessels [20]. The method
was proposed for the calculation of prediction of geometrical
characteristics of the end-closures which is used for hydrogen
storage. The optimization of the composite stacking sequence
was investigated by D. Leh et al [21] for type IV hydrogen
pressure vessel which is manufactured by using filament winding
technique. The different optimization methods were applied by
considering composite damage and dome multi sequencing.
Benoit Gentilleau et al [22] studied the stress analysis in multi-
layer polymer/composite of type IV high-pressure hydrogen Fig. 1. Methodology for pressure vessel analysis
storage vessel. Tsai-Wu criterion is applied on a three-

431
2016 Intl. Conference on Advances in Computing, Communications and Informatics (ICACCI), Sept. 21-24, 2016, Jaipur, India

III. GEOMETRY FOR PRESSURE VESSEL node which possess six degrees of freedom at each node. By
using SHELL181 element type free meshing is carried out. Two
The pressure vessel with a single port as shown in Fig. 2 (a) is cylindrical fixed type supports are used as a boundary condition
consider for structural analysis. The single port with a diameter to constrain the displacement of pressure vessel as shown in Fig.
of 34 mm [4] functions as a both inlet and outlet port. Two fix 3. The internal pressure of 40 MPa is applied on inner wall of
supports are used to provide stability to pressure vessel. To avoid pressure vessel which is equally distributed and normal to the
leakage, liner is used as inner element of pressure vessel where as surface of the walls.
shell forms the outer layer to sustain the inner pressure.
V. THEORETICAL ANALYSIS

A. Thickness Calculation
The cylindrical filament wound pressure vessel consists of
helical and hoop layers. For cylindrical part helical and hoop
layers are used whereas only helical layers are used for end
domes. Further netting analysis is used to determine the
(a) minimum thickness by considering inner pressure loading. The
effect of the matrix is not considered while calculating thickness.
The calculation of thickness for helical layer [25] which is wound
on cylindrical and dome part is as shown below
Pi .r
t fθ =
2.σ f θ .cos 2 θ
(1)
also the thickness for Hoop layer which is wound on cylindrical
(b) part can be calculated as below
Fig. 2. Axis-symmetry model of the pressure vessel, (a) Schmetic diagram, P .r
(b) Dimensioned diagram [4] t f 90 = i .(2 − tan 2 θ )
2.σ f 90
(2)
The simulation is carried out by using T300 carbon/epoxy Finally the total thickness by considering the fiber volume ration
material. The material properties for analytical calculation are can be calculated as below
referred from composite material data book. The liner is wound
with 10 helical winding layers and 20 Hoop layers. The thickness t fθ t f 90
tc = +
for helical winding layer and Hoop layer is calculated by using f v ( helical ) f v ( hoop )
Eqn. 1, 2 and 3. The simulation is carried out by varying stacking (3)
where R- inner radius of filament wound cylinder (mm), Pi -
sequence which is in order of [( ±θ )/90t/90t] as shown in Fig 7.
internal pressure (MPa), (±ș) - winding angle ( ࡈ ), (tfș) - helical
IV. FINITE ELEMENT MODEL OF PRESSURE VESSEL fiber thickness (mm), fV - fiber volume fraction.

B. Laminate Theory
The structural analysis of composite laminated is done by using
Classical Lamination Theory (CLT) [10]. As per the theory each
ply is assumed to be in state of plane stress and inter laminar
stresses are neglected. To obtain stress transformations, the
engineering stress & strain based matrices are used. The
stress/strain transformation matrix are as follows

§ cos2 α sin2 α sin2α ·


¨ ¸
M(α) = ¨ sin α
2
cos2 α −sin2α ¸
¨ −cossinα cosα sinα cos2α ¸
© ¹ (4)
Fig. 3. Finite element model of the pressure vessel (section view)
§ cos 2 α sin 2 α cos α sin α ·
The pressure vessel is categorized under thin type of ¨ ¸
structures. For the analysis of such structures SHELL181 element N (α ) = ¨ sin 2 α cos 2 α − cos α sin α ¸
type is used as it is well suited for linear, large rotation and large ¨ − sin 2α sin 2α cos 2α ¸¹
© (5)
strain nonlinear applications. The selected element is of four

432
2016 Intl. Conference on Advances in Computing, Communications and Informatics (ICACCI), Sept. 21-24, 2016, Jaipur, India

The manufactured laminate by using filament winding is further controlled which leads to reduction of weight and can be used in
considered as angle ply. By using stress/strain transformation vehicles for hydrogen storage. The FE simulation in ANSYS
matrix, compliance matrix (C) of a single orthotropic layer is workbench is performed by using ACP tool to analyze the stress
calculated as below and deformation. The preliminary structural analysis is
§ 1 − v1 2 · performed by using both isotropic and composite material. The
¨ 0 ¸ total displacement (mm) for varying pressure (MPa) observed in
¨ E1 E1 ¸
¨ − v1 2 1 ¸ case of composite material was much low as compared to the
C =¨ 0 ¸ isotropic material (Steel and Copper alloy) which can be
¨ E1 E2 ¸
¨ 1 ¸
identified from Fig.4.
¨ 0 0 ¸
© G1 2 ¹
(6)
The corresponding stiffness matrix S is obtained by inversion of
compliance matrix. The stiffness matrix of the resulting angle ply
laminate is calculated as below
1
S = ª¬ S (α ) + S ( −α ) º¼
2 (7)
The resultants of the stress components are further calculated by
the ABD matrix as follow
­ N ½ § A B · °­ ε 0 ½
® ¾=¨ ¸® ¾
¯ M ¿ © B D ¹ °¯ K ¿ (8)
Fig. 4. Effect of pressure (MPa) on total deformation (mm) for different
where Aij - extension stiffness matrix, Bij - extension bending materials
coupling matrix, Dij- bending stiffness matrix. This relationship The validation is carried out by using Tsai- Wu failure criteria
determines the mechanical behavior of fiber reinforced angle ply for selected geometry. The analytical results obtained for
laminate. different winding angle had good correlation with numerical
results. Form Fig.5. it is identified that the obtained curve for
C. Failure Theory
both Tsai- Wu (analytical) and Tsai- Wu (numerical) are within
The failure of orthotropic lamina is predicted by using Tsai Wu the limits. As the applied failure criteria consider stresses
Failure Criteria and Tsai-hill failure criterion. The Tsai-Wu developed lateral and longitudinal, it is preferred.
theory [7-9] predict the failure in orthotropic lamina under plane
stress condition as shown below
F11 ı12 + F22 ı22 + F66 IJ122 + F1 ı1 + F2 ı2 + 2F12 ı1ı2 = 1 (9)
Where Xt - longitudnal tensile strength (MPa), Yt - transverse
tensile strength (MPa), Xc - longitudnal compressive strength
(MPa), Yc - transverse compressive strength (MPa), S - in plane
shear strength (MPa). Also the elastic characteristics consist of
four independent elastic constants as E11, E22, G12, Ϝ12.
The strength coefficients are calculated by using the tensile,
compressive and shear strength properties in the principal
material directions as shown below Fig. 5. Effect of change in winding angle ( ࡈ ) on total deformation (mm)
1 1 1 1 1 1 F = 1
F1 = − F = F2 = − F =
X t X c ’ 22 YtYc ’ Yt Yc ’ 66 X 2 , 11 X t X c
1
F12 = − ( F11.F22 )
2 (10)
VI. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Earlier the pressure vessels were manufactured of isotropic
materials like Steel and Copper alloy. As this pressure vessels
were having redundant material along the longitudinal axis which
results in excess weight. This limitation is overcome by using
composite materials where filament winding is used for the
manufacturing of pressure vessel. The deposition of material is
Fig. 6. Effect of change in winding angle ( ࡈ ) on maximum failure stress (Pa)

433
2016 Intl. Conference on Advances in Computing, Communications and Informatics (ICACCI), Sept. 21-24, 2016, Jaipur, India

For determining the optimum winding angle the parametric calculated and minimum stresses are developed for winding
study is carried out for different winding angles. It is observed angle ±35ࡈ as shown in Fig.6. The optimum winding angle is also
that the deformation is maximum at the ends of pressure vessel determined for the stress distribution for various winding angles
and minimum at the cylindrical portion which can be identified which are calculated numerically. Increase in winding angle
from Fig.8. The deformation observed at the fixed support is 0. results in decrease in stress distribution which can be observed in
For selected geometry of pressure vessel, inlet and outlet is Fig.10. The obtained stress distribution contours for various
carried out by using same port. Hence it is identified that the winding angles are shown below in Fig.9. where maximum stress
maximum deformation is at the inlet/outlet port. The total distribution is obtained for winding angle ±10ࡈ and minimum is
deformation is minimum for winding angle ±35ࡈ with the stacking obtained for winding angle ±35ࡈ. Further ply-wise analysis was
sequence of [±35ࡈ/90ࡈ/90ࡈ]. The numerical simulation is carried out carried out to reduce the stress distribution by changing the ply
for composite pressure vessel for different winding angles. The orientation (Rosettes) for the helical layer, which improved the
obtained maximum failure stresses for different angles are results.

Fig. 7. Schematic diagram of different winding angle ( ࡈ ) sub laminates for COPV

(a) (b)

(c) (d)
Fig. 8. Deformation for variation winding angles ( ࡈ ) of COPV (a) 10ࡈ, (b) 35ࡈ, (c) 45ࡈ, (d) 70ࡈ

434
2016 Intl. Conference on Advances in Computing, Communications and Informatics (ICACCI), Sept. 21-24, 2016, Jaipur, India

(a) (b)

(c) (d)
Fig. 9. Stress distribution for various winding angles ( ࡈ ) of COPV (a) 10ࡈ, (b) 35ࡈ, (c) 45ࡈ, (d) 70ࡈ

maximum deformation at winding angle ±70ࡈ as shown in


Fig.11. After evaluating different numerical results a trade off
was taken between the total deformation and stresses
generated. Hence the optimum winding angle from overall
investigation is ±35ࡈ.

VII. CONCLUSION
The FE analysis is carried out for composite overwrapped
pressure vessel (COPV) by using ACP pre-post. The aim of
study was to design a COPV for hydrogen storage which had
application in fuel cell car. The operating pressure for
Fig. 10. Stress (Pa) generation for different winding angles (ș) of COPV hydrogen storage tank was 20 MPa. Hence to be on safer side
the COPV was designed to sustain the pressure of 40 MPa. The
analytical results were accompanied with numerical simulation
to predict the complex mechanical failure of COPV more
accurately. Analytical results and numerical results showed a
good co-relation for Tsai Wu failure criteria. Altering the
stacking sequence by considering various ply angle was carried
out to find the most suitable ply angle for selected design. The
minimum stress and minimum total deformation is obtained for
winding angle of ±35ࡈ. The increase in winding angle results in
decrease in stress generation. The total deformation remains
constant as the winding angle increases till ±35ࡈ and further
increases with increase in winding angle. After carrying
analysis of various stacking sequence the optimum sequence
was ±35ࡈ. The analysis carried out ply wise which further
Fig. 11. Total deformation (mm) for different winding angles ( ࡈ ) of COPV helped in reducing the stress and total deformation for selected
design.
Same parametric study is carried out to find the total
deformation for various winding angles. The minimum
deformation is observed for winding angle ±35ࡈ where as

435
2016 Intl. Conference on Advances in Computing, Communications and Informatics (ICACCI), Sept. 21-24, 2016, Jaipur, India

REFERENCES [14] Ibrahim Demir, Onur Sayman, Akar Dogan, Volkan Arikan, Yusuf
Arman, “The effects of repeated transverse impact load on the burst
[1] Shafique M.A. Khan, “Stress distributions in a horizontal pressure pressure of composite pressure vessel”, Composites: Part B 68 (2015)
vessel and the saddle supports”, International Journal of Pressure 121–125.
Vessels and Piping 87 (2010) 239-244.
[15] Juan Pedro Berro Ramirez, Damien Halm, Jean-Claude Grandidier,
[2] T. Aseer Brabin, T. Christopher, B. Nageswara Rao, “Finite element Stephane Villalonga, Fabien Nony, “700 bar type IV high pressure
analysis of cylindrical pressure vessels having a misalignment in a hydrogen storage vessel burst-Simulation and experimental validation”,
circumferential joint”, International Journal of Pressure Vessels and international journal o f hydrogen energy 40(2015)13183-13192.
Piping 87 (2010) 197-201.
[16] D. Leh, P. Saffre, P. Francescato, R. Arrieux, S. Villalonga, “A
[3] Yashar Javadi, Hamed Salimi Pirzaman, Mohammadreza Hadizadeh progressive failure analysis of a 700-bar type IV hydrogen composite
Raeisi, Mehdi Ahmadi Najafabadi, “Ultrasonic stress evaluation through pressure vessel”, international journal o f hydrogen energy
thickness of a stainless steel pressure vessel”, International Journal of 40(2015)13206-13214.
Pressure Vessels and Piping 123-124 (2014) 111-120.
[17] Hassen Taher Dorrah, “Consolidity: Stack-based systems change
[4] E.S. Barboza Neto, M. Chludzinski, P.B. Roese, J.S.O. Fonseca, S.C. pathway theory elaborated”, Ain Shams Engineering Journal (2014) 5,
Amico, C.A. Ferreira, “Experimental and numerical analysis of a 449–473.
LLDPE/HDPE liner for a composite pressure vessel”, Polymer Testing
30 (2011) 693–700. [18] Satoshi Kobayashi, Mari Kawahara, “Effects of stacking thickness on
the damage behavior in CFRP composite cylinders subjected to out-of-
[5] Aziz Onder, Onur Sayman, Tolga Dogan, Necmettin Tarakcioglu, plane loading”, Composites: Part A 43 (2012) 231–237.
“Burst failure load of composite pressure vessels”, Composite Structures
89 (2009) 159–166. [19] Maxime Bertin, Fabienne Touchard, Marie-Christine Lafarie-Frenot,
“Experimental study of the stacking sequence effect on
[6] P. Nimdum, B. Patamaprohm, J. Renard, S. Villalonga, “Experimental polymer/composite multi-layers submitted to thermo-mechanical cyclic
method and numerical simulation demonstrate non-linear axial behavior loadings”, international journal o f hydrogen energy 35(2010)11397-
in composite filament wound pressure vessel due to thermal expansion 11404.
effect”, international journal o f hydrogen energy 40(2015)13231-
13241. [20] D. Leh, P. Saffre, P. Francescato, R. Arrieux, “Multi-sequence dome
lay-up simulations for hydrogen hyper-bar composite pressure vessels”,
[7] Michael A. Conteh, Emmanuel C. Nsofor, “A Symmetric Angle-Ply Composites: Part A 52 (2013) 106–117.
Composite Flywheel for High-Speed Energy Storage,” Journal of
Engineering Materials and Technology, APRIL 2016, Vol. 138, [21] D. Leh, B. Magneville, P. Saffre , P. Francescato, R. Arrieux, S.
Copyright © 2016 by ASME. Villalonga, “Optimisation of 700 bar type IV hydrogen pressure vessel
considering composite damage and dome multi-sequencing”,
[8] W. Van Paepegem, J. Degrieck, “Calculation of damage-dependent international journal of hydrogen energy 40(2015)13215-13230.
directional failure indices from the Tsai–Wu static failure criterion,”
Composites Science and Technology 63 (2003) 305–310. [22] Benoit Gentilleau, Maxime Bertin, Fabienne Touchard, Jean-Claude
Grandidier, “Stress analysis in specimens made of multi-layer
[9] Albert A. Groenwold, Raphael T. Haftka, “Optimization with non polymer/composite used for hydrogen storage application: Comparison
homogeneous failure criteria like Tsai–Wu for composite laminates,” with experimental results”, Composite Structures 93 (2011) 2760–2767.
Struct Multidisc Optim (2006) 32: 183–190.
[23] B. Gentilleau, S. Villalonga, F. Nony, H. Galiano, “A probabilistic
[10] J. Majak and S. Hannus, “Orientational design of anisotropic materials damage behavior law for composite material dedicated to composite
using the hill and tsai–wu strength criteria,” Mechanics of Composite pressure vessel”, international journal of hydrogen energy
Materials, Vol. 39, No. 6, 2003. 40(2015)13160-13164.
[11] Jerome Mespoulet, Fabien Plassard, Pierre-Louis Héreil, Patrick Thiot, [24] B. Magneville, B. Gentilleau , S. Villalonga, F. Nony, H. Galiano,
“Numerical Investigations of Hypervelocity Impacts on Pressurized “Modeling, parameters identification and experimental validation of
Aluminum-Composite Vessels”, Procedia Engineering, 103 ( 2015 ) composite materials behavior law used in 700 bar type IV hydrogen
373 – 380, © 2015 Published by Elsevier Ltd. high pressure storage vessel”, international journal of hydrogen energy
[12] Pierre-Louis Hereil, Jerome Mespoulet, Fabien Plassard, “Hypervelocity 40(201 5)13193-13205.
Impact of Aluminum Projectiles Against Pressurized Aluminum- [25] Rifat Hossain, Jason P. Carey, Pierre Mertiny, “Framework for a
Composite Vessel”, Procedia Engineering 103 (2015) 181 – 188, © CombinedNetting Analysis and Tsai-Wu-Based Design Approach for
2015 Published by Elsevier Ltd. Braided and Filament-Wound Composites,” Journal of Pressure Vessel
[13] Yongzheng Shao, Andrea Betti, Valter Carvelli, Toru Fujii, Kazuya Technology, JUNE 2013, Vol. 135, Copyright © 2013 by ASME.
Okubo, Ou Shibata, Yukiko Fujita, “High pressure strength of carbon
fibre reinforced vinylester and epoxy vessels”, Composite Structures
140 (2016) 147–156.

436

You might also like