2017-06-12 A scholar in the desert

Obituary: Patricia Crone

A scholar in the desert
Patricia Crone, scholar of early Islam and campaigner for medical marijuana, died on
July 11th, aged 70

Print edition | Obituary Aug 1st 2015

ISLAM arose with remarkable speed and mystery. Patricia Crone’s well-stocked
mind, clear prose and unflinching intellectual honesty were devoted to explaining
why. She had little time for Islam’s own accounts of its origins: “debris” as far as
historians were concerned, and hopelessly inconsistent. Far better, she reckoned,
to fill the gap with contemporary sources and knowledge of other cultures, from
messianic Maoris to Icelanders.

That required both personal and intellectual bravery. The central beliefs of Islam,
such as the way the Koran took shape, the life of Muhammad and Islam’s relations
with other religions, are sensitive subjects. Outside scrutiny can make tempers
flare, especially when the conclusions are expressed in a witty and sardonic style.  
http://www.economist.com/news/obituary/21660065-patricia-crone-scholar-early-islam-and-campaigner-medical-marijuana-died-july-11th 1/4
2017-06-12 A scholar in the desert

That is one reason why copies of

Latest updates “Hagarism”, Ms Crone’s first book, long out
A new paper rekindles a tiresome debate on of print, now sell for hundreds of dollars. It
immigration and wages
FREE EXCHANGE
was published in 1977, the year she whirled
like a tornado into Oxford, terrifying the
Artists grapple with the meaning of Luther
PROSPERO dusty dons. (The Oriental Institute was
Poland’s liberal opposition is re-establishing itself then a notable source of spies for MI6,
EUROPE
despite the fact that the history syllabus for
See all updates
the BA in Arabic ended at 1258, the year the
Mongols sacked Baghdad.) Her book drew
on Armenian, Coptic, Greek, Persian and Syriac sources, as well as archaeology, to
argue that Islam started as an Arab-Jewish tribal rebellion against the Byzantine
and Persian empires. The Arab “Hagarenes”—a reference to Abraham’s concubine
Hagar—reinvented themselves as a separate monotheistic religion only after they
dumped their original messianic Judaism.

Ms Crone took a breezy attitude to religious sentiment. Her book was written “by
infidels, for infidels” and no Muslim with faith the size of a mustard seed was likely
to believe its thesis. It drew praise, but also a serious scolding from some
academics: too conjectural, they said. Ms Crone removed her name, and that of her
co-author Michael Cook, from the doorbell of their flat in Marylebone—though, in
pre-fatwa days, they did not need to go into hiding.

The authors later distanced themselves from some of the book’s more speculative
arguments. But that was the result of conviction, not compromise. Ms Crone’s
steely blue eyes and steelier brain shunned any temptation to turn to safer topics,
or to cloak her critiques of Islamic tradition in the jargon used by more cautious
scholars. She simply refused to treat the Arabs as an exception to the normal rules
of history; and something was badly wrong in Islamic studies, she said, if she had
to justify that.

Not that she wanted to undermine Islam for the sake of it. She had no time for the
extreme revisionists, who argued that Muhammad never existed, or that the Koran
was a garbled translation of Aramaic Christian texts. She just wanted to find out
what earthly factors and influences might have shaped Islam and fuelled its
success. She might not turn up the right answers; but it was right to ask the
questions.

http://www.economist.com/news/obituary/21660065-patricia-crone-scholar-early-islam-and-campaigner-medical-marijuana-died-july-11th 2/4
2017-06-12 A scholar in the desert

The widely held idea of a lucrative spice trade centred on Mecca, for example, was
an “orientalist invention” to her. The city was just a desert oasis in Muhammad’s
time, with perhaps a modest leather trade. If the Koran called Muhammad’s
opponents “olive-growers”, perhaps Islam sprang up farther north. Then came more
questions. Why did military slavery play such a distinctive role in Islam? What was
the real state of religious freedom in the early years of Islamic conquest? How did
the idea of jihad arise? These were puzzles; they did not need to be mysteries.

Smoke and fire

Ms Crone’s erudition was intimidatingly displayed in scores of articles and books.

But in person she was fun and unassuming, with a love of cycling and distaste for
hierarchy that showed her Danish origins. She made puppet theatres for children,
held spectacular New Year parties for her friends, delighted to dance polkas and
Strauss waltzes, and at Princeton, New Jersey, where she worked at the Institute for
Advanced Study after 1997, assiduously tended both her own garden and a
neighbour’s. (Her sorrow when the plants withered was a necessary part of love, she
said; a love she also found with a another co-author, Martin Hinds, who died before
her.)

A diagnosis of incurable cancer in 2011 turned that comfortable life upside down.
She forswore whole-brain radiation, which would have prolonged her life at the
risk of dulling her faculties. Instead she turned her formidable mind to the body’s
biochemistry. Could medical marijuana, as research suggested, stimulate the
body’s endocannabinoid system to delay or even beat the disease? She quizzed
scientists, visited labs to see the effects of cannabis on tumour-laden mice, and
travelled to Oregon to buy enough dope to make capsules of cannabis oil for her
own use.

She had never puffed pot before (prodigious quantities of cigarettes had been her
vice). The stuff made her nauseous and forgetful. But it may have helped hold off
the cancer: the tumours grew more slowly than expected, giving her precious time.

A documentary film, “For the Life of Me”, funded in part by her friends, charted her
battle with the disease and her frustration at America’s prohibitionist laws, which
delayed research, wasted effort and sapped hope. It was just the sort of lazy
dogmatism she had been battling for decades. Why rely on belief and tradition,
when you can search for evidence?

http://www.economist.com/news/obituary/21660065-patricia-crone-scholar-early-islam-and-campaigner-medical-marijuana-died-july-11th 3/4
2017-06-12 A scholar in the desert

http://www.economist.com/news/obituary/21660065-patricia-crone-scholar-early-islam-and-campaigner-medical-marijuana-died-july-11th 4/4