Professional Documents
Culture Documents
10 October 2005
PRACTICE OF MEDICINE
continued from page 1
is worth reviewing the first reported diately or was deferred. Of patients ASSOCIATE MEDICAL EDITOR, What’s New in
ACP Medicine: Wendy Levinson, M.D., F.A.C.P.,
analysis of a randomized, unmasked, randomized to deferred treatment, Toronto
pragmatic trial comparing immediate between 60% and 70% of those who
EDITORIAL BOARD:
treatment with deferred treatment, had an additional seizure on follow-up Karen Antman, M.D., Bethesda; John P.
which was conducted by the Medical did so within 6 months of study entry; Atkinson, M.D., F.A.C.P., St. Louis; Christine K.
Cassel, M.D., M.A.C.P., Philadelphia; Mark
Research Council Multicentre Study of the risk of an additional seizure was Feldman, M.D., F.A.C.P., Dallas; Raymond
Early Epilepsy and Single Seizures 1.7-fold higher in patients who experi- Gibbons, M.D., Rochester, MN; R. Brian
Haynes, M.D., F.A.C.P., Hamilton, Ontario; Janet
(MESS) Study Group.1 enced more than one seizure before B. Henrich, M.D., New Haven, CT; William L.
Of 1,847 patients invited to partici- randomization. Henrich, M.D., F.A.C.P., Baltimore; Michael J.
Holtzman, M.D., St. Louis; Mark G. Lebwohl,
pate in this trial, 1,443 were random- What does this mean for decision- M.D., New York; Wendy Levinson, M.D., F.A.C.P.,
ized either to receive immediate treat- making? Clearly, little is lost in the Toronto, Ontario; Lynn Loriaux, M.D., PH.D.,
M.A.C.P., Portland, OR; Shaun Ruddy, M.D.,
ment with an anticonvulsant chosen long run by deferring treatment in F.A.C.P., Richmond,VA; Jerry S. Wolinsky, M.D.,
by the treating physician or to have patients who present with a first idio- Houston
treatment deferred pending the devel- pathic seizure. Seizures are defined as
opment of subsequent seizures or DIRECTOR OF PUBLISHING:
idiopathic when the patient has not Cynthia M. Chevins
other indications for initiating therapy. had significant previous head trauma DIRECTOR, ELECTRONIC PUBLISHING:
Nearly half of the patients were or a precipitating metabolic derange- Liz Pope
recruited in the United Kingdom; the ment; has a normal neurologic exami- EDITORIAL DEPARTMENT:
remainder were seen at centers scat- nation; and, when appropriate, has a Erin Michael Kelly, Managing Editor; Nancy R.
Terry, John Heinegg, Development Editors;
tered across Europe, Israel, Brazil, and normal result on a cerebral imaging John J. Anello, Senior Copy Editor; David
Chile. The overwhelming majority of study. When immediate therapy is Terry, Copy Editor; Stephen D’Agostino,
Editorial Coordinator
patients in the study were in their late undertaken, about 14 patients must be ELECTRONIC PUBLISHING DEPARTMENT:
teenage years or were young adults. In treated to prevent one additional Janet Zinn, Electronic Projects Manager;
all cases, the patient had an adequate- patient from having a second seizure Betsy Klarfeld, Art and Design Editor;
ly documented history of one or more Diane Joiner, Jennifer Smith, Derek Nash,
within the next 2 years. Whether ther- Associate Producers
clinically definite, spontaneous, and apy is immediate or deferred, the
unprovoked epileptic seizures; the patient should receive careful follow-
ACP Medicine (ISSN 1548-9345) (USPS 482-310), for-
merly WebMD Scientific American® Medicine, is pub-
patient had not been treated with anti- up evaluations at progressively longer
lished monthly by WebMD Professional Publishing,
111 Eighth Avenue, Suite 700, New York, NY 10011.
convulsants before, except for acute intervals over the first several years
Copyright © 2005 by WebMD Inc. All rights reserved.
No part of this issue may be reproduced by any mech-
management of the presenting event; after presentation. Although few pa- anical, photographic, or electronic process or in the
form of a phonographic recording, nor may it be stored
and both the treating physician and tients in this study were treated with in a retrieval system, transmitted, or otherwise copied
for public or private use without written permission of
the patient were uncertain whether to newer anticonvulsants, none of the the publisher. Periodical postage paid at New York, NY,
and at additional mailing offices. Individual subscription
initiate long-term therapy.
currently available anticonvulsants are rates–USA, its possessions, and Canada: $329 for the
When immediate therapy was first year ($219 for residents and students) and $289 for
universally effective; therefore, drug renewals ($219 for residents and students). Institutional
given, carbamazepine and valproate subscription rates–USA, its possessions, and Canada:
selection is unlikely to result in out- $429 for the first year and $349 for renewals. Separate
were the most frequently selected anti- shipping and handling apply. POSTMASTER: Send
comes that differ from those described address changes to ACP Medicine,WebMD Professional
convulsants. Immediate therapy Publishing, WebMD Inc., P.O. Box 1819, Danbury,
in this large pragmatic trial.2,3 CT 06813-9663.
increased the time to the first seizure,
the second seizure, and the first tonic- References
FOR ASSISTANCE WITH YOUR SUBSCRIPTION
clonic seizure; and it reduced the time 1. Marson A, Jacoby A, Johnson A, et al: Immediate Please address all inquiries to Fulfillment Department,
versus deferred antiepileptic drug treatment for early WebMD Professional Publishing, WebMD Inc., P.O. Box
to achieve a 2-year remission of 1819, Danbury, CT 06813-9663, or call 800-545-0554 or
epilepsy and single seizures: a randomized controlled 203-790-2087, fax us at 203-790-2066, or e-mail us at
seizures. Early treatment did not influ- trial. Lancet 365:2007, 2005 [PMID 15950714] acpmedicine@webmd.net. For change of address, please
ence the proportion of patients who 2. French JA, Kanner AM, Bautista J, et al: Efficacy and provide both your new and your old addresses (include
your update mailing label if possible); be sure to notify us
were seizure free 3 and 5 years after tolerability of the new antiepileptic drugs I: treatment of at least six weeks before you expect to move to avoid in-
new onset epilepsy. Report of the Therapeutics and Tech- terruptions in your service.
randomization. Two years after ran- nology Assessment Subcommittee and Quality Standards
domization, about equal numbers of Subcommittee of the American Academy of Neurology YOUR FEEDBACK IS WELCOME
and the American Epilepsy Society. Neurology 62:1252,
patients in the immediate-treatment 2004 [PMID 15111659] • E-mail: whatsnew@webmd.net
group and the deferred-treatment • Write: WebMD Professional
3. Wilby J, Kainth A, Hawkins N, et al: Clinical effective-
Publishing
group (just under 10% of respondents ness, tolerability and cost-effectiveness of newer drugs for
111 Eighth Avenue, Suite 700
epilepsy in adults: a systematic review and economic eval-
to a quality-of-life questionnaire) uation. Health Technol Assess 9:15, 2005 [PMID New York, NY 10011
reported that they were not in school 15842952]
full-time or employed because of jerrywolinsky@webmd.net
www.acpmedicine.com ACP Medicine 3
factor (bFGF), are undergoing inten- of 90%.1 Patency rates after 4 to 5 Slowing Progression in
sive investigation for their potential years are approximately 60% to 80% Patients with Hepatitis
efficacy in patients with peripheral and are even higher with implantation
n patients with compensated cirrho-
arterial disease. These angiogenic fac-
tors may be delivered parenterally as
of a stent. The success rate of PTA of
femoral and popliteal arteries is lower
Isis, specific therapies prevent the
development of clinical complications
recombinant proteins or through gene than that of PTA of iliac arteries.
and therefore delay the need for liver
transfer using intra-arterial catheter Patency rates at 1, 3, and 5 years are
transplantation. Treatment with pegy-
techniques or intramuscular injection. approximately 60%, 50%, and 45%,
lated interferon plus ribavirin should
Both VEGF and bFGF increase collat- respectively. The patency rate is better
be considered in patients with com-
eral blood vessel development and when PTA is performed for relief of
pensated cirrhosis from hepatitis C
improve blood flow in experimental claudication rather than for limb sal-
virus infection, although the rate of
models of hindlimb ischemia. The effi- vage and is also better in patients with
sustained response is lower than in
cacy of angiogenic growth factors in good runoff (i.e., in patients with open
noncirrhotic patients.1 Moreover,
patients with intermittent claudication distal vessels). Stents have not been
antiviral treatment may worsen exist-
or critical limb ischemia is an active shown to improve the patency rates of
ing anemia or thrombocytopenia, and
area of investigation. Several placebo- femoral and popliteal arteries over
drug discontinuance is frequent. In
controlled trials in patients with claudi- PTA alone. PTA of tibial and peroneal
patients with cirrhosis related to
cation have been reported. In one trial, arteries is associated with poorer out-
hepatitis B virus (HBV) infection,
intra-arterial infusion of recombinant come than PTA of more proximal
lamivudine appears to be a safe and
FGF-2 resulted in a significant increase lesions and is usually performed in
effective antiviral agent that may
in peak walking time at 90 days.1 In patients with critical limb ischemia
improve or stabilize liver disease in
another study, intramuscular adminis- who are considered at high risk for
selected patients with advanced cirrho-
tration of VEGF did not improve exer- vascular surgery. Limb salvage rates of
sis and active HBV replication.2
cise performance.2 1 to 2 years range from 50% to 75%.
1. Wright TL: Treatment of patients with hepatitis
Autologous implantation of bone 1. Kanani RS, Garasic JM: Lower extremity arterial occlu-
C and cirrhosis. Hepatology 36:S185, 2002 [PMID
sive disease: role of percutaneous revascularization. Curr
marrow mononuclear cells is a Treat Options Cardiovasc Med 7:99, 2005 [PMID
12407593]
promising area of study. These cells 15935118] 2. Lai CJ, Terrault NA: Antiviral therapy in patients
with chronic hepatitis B and cirrhosis. Gastroenterol
have the potential to promote angio- Clin North Am 33:629, 2004 [PMID 15324948]
genesis, because they can supply
endothelial progenitor cells and they 4 GASTROENTEROLOGY
secrete angiogenic factors.3 Who Are Candidates for Liver
1. Lederman RJ, Mendelsohn FO, Anderson RD, et IX Cirrhosis of the Liver Transplantation?
al: Therapeutic angiogenesis with recombinant RAMÓN BATALLER, MD
rthotopic liver transplantation
O
fibroblast growth factor–2 for intermittent claudica- PERE GINÈS, MD
tion (the TRAFFIC study): a randomised trial. (OLT) is a central tool for the man-
Lancet 359:2053, 2002 [PMID 12086757] Liver Unit, Institut de Malalties
2. Rajagopalan S, Mohler ER 3rd, Lederman RJ, et Digestives i Metabòliques, Hospital agement of advanced cirrhosis.1 In the
al: Regional angiogenesis with vascular endothelial Clinic, Barcelona, Catalonia, Spain United States, more than 3,000 liver
4 What’s New in ACP Medicine • October 2005 www.acpmedicine.com
transplants are performed each year. resources/MeldPeldCalculator.asp? of acute diverticulitis of colon. Dig Liver Dis
34:510, 2002 [PMID 12236485]
However, because there are many index=98).
more candidates for transplantation 1. Brown KA: Liver transplantation. Curr Opin
than there are available donor livers, Gastroenterol 21:331, 2005 [PMID 15818154]
2. Freeman RB Jr: MELD and liver allocation: con-
Diagnosing Acute
the selection and timing of patient tinuous quality improvement. Hepatology 40:787, Diverticulitis
referral are critical. The general indica- 2004 [PMID 15382164]
he diagnosis of acute diverticulitis is
tions for OLT are broadly categorized
as clinical and biochemical [see Table, T often made on the basis of the histo-
below]. 4 GASTROENTEROLOGY ry and physical examination, which
Contraindications for OLT include includes abdominal, rectal, and pelvic
severe cardiovascular or pulmonary XII Diverticulosis, Diverticulitis, examinations; imaging studies are
disease, active drug or alcohol abuse, and Appendicitis used to confirm the diagnosis. Com-
malignancy outside the liver, sepsis, or WILLIAM V. HARFORD, MD, FACP puted tomography has become the
psychosocial problems that may jeop- University of Texas Southwestern optimal method of investigation for
ardize a patient’s ability to follow Medical Center at Dallas and Dallas patients suspected of having divertic-
medical regimens after transplanta- Veterans Affairs Medical Center ulitis. The modified Hinchey classifica-
tion. The presence of HIV infection tion, which takes into account both
was considered a contraindication to Preventing Diverticulitis clinical and CT findings, is useful for
transplantation, but successful liver hanges in bacterial colonic microflo- prognosis and management [see Table,
transplantations are now being per-
formed in patients in whom antiretro-
C ra have been reported in patients
with diverticulosis. It has been pro-
page 5].1
1. Kaiser AM, Jeng-Kae J, Lake JP, et al: The man-
viral therapy has eliminated any agement of complicated diverticulitis and the role of
posed that these changes may lead to computed tomography. Am J Gastroenterol 100:910,
detectable HIV viral load. Additional low-grade chronic inflammation, pre- 2005 [PMID 15784040]
clinical study is required before OLT disposing to the development of diver-
can be offered routinely to such ticulitis. Long-term intermittent use of
patients. Suspected Appendicitis? Don’t
oral rifaximin, a poorly absorbed
In the United States, the Model for antibiotic, and mesalazine, an anti-
Hold the Morphine
End-Stage Liver Disease (MELD) is he abdominal examination is very
the scoring system used by most liver
transplant centers for determining pri-
inflammatory agent, appears to reduce
the risk of diverticulitis in patients T important for the diagnosis of
appendicitis. This has led some physi-
with uncomplicated diverticulosis.1-4
ority for OLT.2 MELD relies primarily cians to delay the administration of
1. Tursi A: Preventive therapy for complicated
on the bilirubin level, international diverticular disease of the colon: looking for a cor- narcotic analgesics until a surgeon has
normalized ratio, and creatinine level rect therapeutic approach. Gastroenterology
had the opportunity to examine the
to determine a patient’s risk of dying 127:1865, 2004 [PMID 15578538]
2. Tursi A: Acute diverticulitis of the colon: current patient. It has been proven that this
within 3 months if OLT is not per- medical therapeutic management. Expert Opin practice is unnecessary: morphine does
formed. Patients’ scores are calculated Pharmacother 5:55, 2004 [PMID 14680435]
not change the physical examination in
3. Latella G, Pimpo MT, Sottili S, et al: Rifaximin
continuously while they are on the improves symptoms of acquired uncomplicated acute appendicitis, and early pain relief
waiting list for OLT. Scores typically diverticular disease of the colon. Int J Colorectal does not affect the decision for surgery
range from 6 (less ill) to 40 (gravely Dis 18:55, 2003 [PMID 12458383]
4. Tursi A, Brandimarte G, Daffina R: Long-term in adults.1
ill). A MELD calculator is available on treatment with mesalazine and rifaximin versus 1. Wolfe JM, Smithline HA, Phipen S, et al: Does
the Internet (http://www.unos.org/ rifaximin alone for patients with recurrent attacks morphine change the physical examination in
patients with acute appendicitis? Am J Emerg Med
22:280, 2004 [PMID 15258869]
Indications for Liver Transplantation
Both hepatocellular
Recurrent or severe hepatic encephalopathy
Refractory ascites
P variety of scientifically validated
assessment tools. The Numeric Pain
and cholestatic liver Spontaneous bacterial peritonitis
disease Intensity Scale, in which the patient
Recurrent portal hypertensive bleeding
Progressive malnutrition
rates his or her pain on a scale from
zero to 10 (0 = no pain, 10 = worst
< 3 nodules pain imaginable), allows for quantifica-
Hepatocellular
No nodule > 5 cm
carcinoma tion of pain severity, evolution over
No portal invasion
time, and response to treatment. Use of
www.acpmedicine.com ACP Medicine 5
reduced inflammatory changes in the rical polyarthritis in these patients may individual patients—sometimes over
spine and peripheral joints, as evi- resemble rheumatoid arthritis, tests for and over again, because laypersons
denced on MRI; and lowered acute- rheumatoid factor, antinuclear anti- may be less apt to recognize that
phase reactants such as erythrocyte body, and antibodies to cyclic citrulli- guidelines for clinical practice must
sedimentation rate and C-reactive pro- nated peptides (anti-CCP) should be remain just guidelines. Because more
tein. Long-term efficacy and modifica- negative. Anti-CCP is a newly discov- and more physicians are salaried and
tion of disease progression and out- ered autoantibody marker for rheuma- are thus bound to the needs of popula-
come have yet to be determined.1-3 toid arthritis that is 65% sensitive and tions of patients, physicians face the
Treatment with TNF-α antagonists 96% specific. Synovial fluid shows problem of balancing the needs of
also has been shown to halt progres- nonspecific inflammatory changes. individual patients with the expecta-
sion of secondary amyloidosis.4 tions of the employer. This is a delicate
Because of the high cost of these and, in some places, even fragile bal-
agents and still-unanswered questions
about their long-term safety, guidelines
CLINICAL ESSENTIALS ance. To serve both patients and the
employer well, a physician must devel-
have been developed by international I On Being a Physician op good judgment in managing patient
consensus to facilitate the judicious DAVID C. DALE, MD, FACP care under conditions in which the
use of TNF antagonists.1 Many allocation of resources is conservative.
University of Washington School of
patients with mild disease may never Medicine
require TNF antagonists.
1. Reveille JD, Arnett FC: Spondyloarthritis:
DANIEL D. FEDERMAN, MD, MACP CLINICAL ESSENTIALS
update on pathogenesis and management. Am J Harvard Medical School
Med 118:592, 2005 [PMID 15922688] II Contemporary Ethical and
2. Gorman JD, Sack KE, Davis JC Jr: Treatment of
ankylosing spondylitis by inhibition of tumor
Essential Skills Social Issues in Medicine
necrosis factor alpha. N Engl J Med 346:1349, he physical examination remains a
2002 [PMID 11986408]
3. Braun J, Brandt J, Listing J, et al: Treatment of
active ankylosing spondylitis with infliximab: a
T fundamental skill; the ability to rec-
ognize the difference between normal
CHRISTINE K. CASSEL, MD, MACP
University of Pennsylvania and
American Board of Internal Medicine
randomised controlled multicentre trial. Lancet
359:1187, 2002 [PMID 11955536]
and abnormal findings, adjusting for RUTH B. PURTILO, PHD
4. Fernandez-Nebro A, Tomero E, Ottiz- age, sex, ethnicity, and other factors, Creighton University Center for Health
Santamaria V, et al: Treatment of rheumatic is crucial. Good record keeping is Policy and Ethics
inflammatory disease in 25 patients with sec-
ondary amyloidosis using tumor necrosis factor essential—with regard to both a writ-
alpha antagonists. Am J Med 118:552, 2005 ten record and a mental record—so Values, Clarified
[PMID 15866260] that the circumstances of visits are thical dilemmas must be clarified
The Laboratory Picture of
remembered and changes in a
patient’s appearance or other charac-
E and presented clearly to all those
involved in the decision-making
Psoriatic Arthritis teristics that may not have been process. For example, a spouse of an
aboratory testing in patients with recorded can be recognized. With incompetent patient who argues for
L psoriatic arthritis may show eleva-
tions in the erythrocyte sedimentation
practice and attention, these skills—
history taking, physical examination,
aggressive, clinically futile treatment
in the face of an imminently terminal
rate or C-reactive protein level, anemia, and record keeping—can grow and untreatable illness can present the
and hyperuricemia. Although symmet- throughout a professional lifetime. physician with a conflict between
Other aspects of care, such as select- respecting the considered wishes of
ing and performing diagnostic tests, family members and doing what the
procedures, and treatments, require physician judges is best for the
evolving expertise. For all physicians,
Coming in November it is necessary both to practice medi-
cine and to study regularly to main-
patient. Sometimes, enhanced com-
munication between physician,
Clinical Essetials
patient, and family helps bring the
tain all of these essential skills. matter to resolution. For example,
VI Occupational Medicine
having a discussion with the family
2 Dermatology Coping with Managed Care that is focused on the likelihood that
X Malignant Cutaneous Tumors
he development of managed care in aggressive measures would only pro-
4 Gastroenterology
VI Gallstones and Biliary Tract Disease T the United States has created a new
challenge for physicians: to serve as
long the suffering of the patient may
convince them to end life-prolonging
7 Infectious Disease interventions. In other circumstances,
advocates for their patients. In this
XXXIX Infections Due to Mycobacteria
leprae and Nontuberculous Bacteria role, physicians are responsible for however, the patient’s and family’s
overcoming organizational, geograph- beliefs may necessitate that the physi-
13 Psychiatry
ic, and financial barriers to the provi- cian take aggressive measures to pre-
IX The Eating Disorders
sion of services that are important for serve life at all costs. It may be impor-
14 Respiratory Medicine their patients. In organizations in tant to discuss the spiritual and moral
IV Focal and Multifocal Lung Disease
which guidelines for care have been dimensions of the impending decision
16 Women’s Health established, it may be necessary for a explicitly. It is often helpful to involve
XXI Musculoskeletal Problems in the
physician to explain to administrators other physicians or nonphysician
Female Athlete
the specific needs and problems of mediators, such as the hospital ethi-
www.acpmedicine.com ACP Medicine 7
The role of live, attenuated influenza vaccine (LAIV) during vaccine shortages
Use of both available vaccines (i.e., both inactivated vaccine and LAIV) is encouraged for eligible persons every
influenza season, especially persons in recommended target groups. During periods when inactivated vaccine is in
short supply, the use of LAIV is especially encouraged when feasible for eligible persons (including health care work-
ers) because use of LAIV by these persons might considerably increase the availability of inactivated vaccine for per-
sons in groups at high risk.
Vaccine supply
The CDC and other agencies will assess the vaccine supply throughout the manufacturing period and will make rec-
ommendations preceding the 2005–06 influenza season regarding the need for tiered timing of vaccination of differ-
ent risk groups. In addition, the CDC will publish ACIP recommendations regarding inactivated vaccine subprioriti-
zation (tiering) on a later date.
Source:
Prevention and control of influenza: recommendations of the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP). MMWR Recomm Rep
54(early release):1, 2005
(http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/rr54e713a1.htm)
cists, patient advocates, social work- would persist through subsequent States, interest in the clinical promise
ers, and clergy members, in the deci- generations. However, research has of stem cell technology continues to
sion-making process.1 Once values are now progressed to the point of grow- grow. Legislators in California and
explicitly discussed and differences ing human stem cells under laborato- Massachusetts have created and fund-
clarified, a plan may be agreed upon ry conditions, and stem cell research ed state-level research centers, and
by which all parties can abide. is thought to be one of the most other states are considering whether
1. DuVal G, Clarridge B, Gensler G, et al: A national sur-
promising new areas for clinical inter- to undertake similar initiatives.
vey of U.S. internists’ experiences with ethical dilemmas ventions.1 Although the debate has 1. Daar AS, Bhatt A, Court E, et al: Stem cell
and ethics consultation. J Gen Intern Med 19:251, 2004 research and transplantation: science leading ethics.
[PMID 15009780]
become intensely political and nation-
Transplant Proc 36:2504, 2004 [PMID 15561296]
al funding of stem cell research by the
National Institutes of Health is strict-
Stem Cell Research ly proscribed, many in the scientific 12 ONCOLOGY
urrent research in genetics chal- community are actively supporting
C lenges traditional assumptions of
the uniqueness of individual identity
stem cell research and are taking steps
to address some of the ethical con-
XVIII Head and Neck Cancer
EVERETT E. VOKES, MD, FACP
and the acceptability of genetic inter- cerns raised by the use of these cells. University of Chicago Pritzker School
ventions. Germline interventions were This shift has occurred in part of Medicine
considered completely ethically unac- because stem cell techniques do not
ceptable just a few years ago because create permanent germline changes. Risks Held in Patients’ Hands
of the reluctance on the part of Scientific research is ongoing, espe- he primary risk factors for develop-
geneticists to create changes that cially in other countries; in the United T ment of squamous cell carcinoma
8 What’s New in ACP Medicine • October 2005 www.acpmedicine.com
(SCC) of the head and neck are the 1. Pytynia KB, Grant JR, Etzel CJ, et al: Matched- chemotherapy followed by radiation
pair analysis of survival of never smokers and ever
use of tobacco and alcohol. Tobacco smokers with squamous cell carcinoma of the head therapy was the standard of care for
use has clearly been demonstrated to and neck. J Clin Oncol 22:3981, 2004 [PMID organ preservation2; however, the
15459221]
be an independent risk factor. The 2. Talamini R, Bosetti C, La Vecchia C, et al: Com-
findings of a large randomized multi-
likelihood of a malignancy increases bined effect of tobacco and alcohol on laryngeal can- center trial indicate that concomitant
with the duration and extent of expo- cer risk: a case-control study. Cancer Causes Control chemoradiotherapy is superior to
13:957, 2002 [PMID 12588092]
sure. Cigarette smoking, in particular, induction chemotherapy for organ
is an important risk factor for laryn- preservation.3
geal cancer. Cigar smoking has been Starting Off with 1. Pignon JP, Syz N, Posner M, et al: Adjusting for pa-
associated primarily with cancers of Chemotherapy tient selection suggests the addition of docetaxel to 5-flu-
orouracil-cisplatin induction therapy may offer survival
the lip and oral cavity, presumably he administration of two or three in squamous cell cancer of the head and neck. Anti-
because cigar smoke is not typically
inhaled. When inhaled, cigar smoke
T cycles of chemotherapy before
surgery and radiotherapy, usually uti-
cancer Drugs 15:331, 2004 [PMID 15057136]
2. Vokes EE, Stenson KM: Therapeutic options for la-
ryngeal cancer. N Engl J Med 349:2087, 2003 [PMID
places the smoker at risk for other lizing cisplatin and fluorouracil, has 14645634]
3. Forastiere AA, Goepfert H, Maor M, et al: Concur-
head and neck malignancies. There is been shown to result in tumor shrink- rent chemotherapy and radiotherapy for organ preserva-
also concern about the use of smoke- age in as many as 90% of patients tion in advanced laryngeal cancer. N Engl J Med
349:2091, 2003 [PMID 14645636]
less tobacco as a risk factor for malig- with head and neck cancers. Never-
nancies of the oral cavity. After discon- theless, randomized trials have dem-
tinuance of the use of tobacco, the risk onstrated that overall survival rates Treating Salivary Gland Tumors
of SCC of the head and neck diminish- are not increased through the use of reatment of salivary gland tumors
es gradually over time. Evidence, how-
ever, suggests that the risk does not
induction chemotherapy, because local
and regional control is not better than
T is predominantly surgical, which
leads to a proper definition of local
decline to the level associated with that achieved with surgery and radia- and regional tumor stage. Surgery
persons who never smoked.1 tion alone. The addition of a taxane combined with radiotherapy, either
Alcohol use is also associated with to induction regimens has resulted in adjuvant or postoperative, appears to
SCC of the head and neck. By itself, high 2-year survival rates; however, a increase survival.1,2 For unresectable
alcohol use is a smaller risk factor meta-analysis of six trials could not salivary gland tumors, neutron irradi-
than tobacco use and is of particular determine whether improved survival ation can be used instead of conven-
importance for malignancies of the rates were the result of the pharmaco- tional radiotherapy. Chemotherapy is
oral cavity, oral pharynx, and logic effect of the taxane or that of reserved for patients with recurrent or
hypopharynx. However, the use of uncontrolled prognostic factors across metastatic disease.
alcohol and tobacco in combination the various trials.1 1. Terhaard CH, Lubsen H, Van der Tweel I, et al: Sali-
results in a multiplicative risk of SCC; Induction chemotherapy can be vary gland carcinoma: independent factors for locoregion-
al control, distant metastases, and overall survival: results
in persons who are both heavy smok- considered a standard treatment of the Dutch Head and Neck Oncology Cooperative
ers and heavy drinkers, the risk of option for patients with locoregional- Group. Head Neck 26:681, 2004 [PMID 15287035]
2. Mendenhall WM, Morris CG, Amdur RJ, et al: Radio-
SCC may be 200 times that of per- ly advanced laryngeal or hypopharyn- therapy alone or combined with surgery for salivary gland
sons who neither smoke nor drink.2 geal cancer. Until recently, induction carcinoma. Cancer 103:2544, 2005 [PMID 15880750]