Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Open Access
Table 1 BP modulation by class action
Stroke type Time given Clinical
Trial (IS/ICH) Drug (hours) BP effect CBF effect outcome
α2 adrenoreceptor agonist Increase Neutral
(rats)
Lisk et al (1993)24 IS Clonidine <72 Mean reduction: SBP 13.6, DBP
2.1 mm Hg
ACEi Maintain/ Neutral
increase
CHIPPS 200925 All Lisinopril (PO/SL) <36 (mean 19) Mean reduction: SBP 14 mm Hg
DBP 7 mm Hg
PIL-FAST 201326 All Lisinopril (SL/PO) <3
ARA Neutral/ Neutral/poor
reduce
ACCESS 200327 IS Candesartan (PO) <36 (mean 29) No difference
PRoFESS 200928 IS Telmisartan (PO) <72 (mean 58) SBP: 6–7 mm Hg
DBP: 2–4 mm Hg
SCAST 201129
Appleton JP, et al. Stroke and Vascular Neurology 2016;1:e000020. doi:10.1136/svn-2016-000020
All Candesartan (PO) <30 (mean 18) Mean difference at 7 days: SBP
5 mm Hg
DBP 2 mm Hg
VENTURE 201530 IS Valsartan (PO) <24 (mean 12) Mean difference at 7 days: SBP
4 mm Hg
DBP 2 mm Hg
α and β-Blocker Neutral Neutral
CHIPPS 200925 All Labetalol (PO/IV) <36 (mean 19) Mean reduction: SBP 7 mm Hg
DBP increase 0.6 mm Hg
β-Blockers ?Reduce Poor
BEST 198831 Unknown Propranolol (PO), <48 Reduction: 6–9% vs 2% (placebo)
atenolol (PO)
CCA Reduce Poor
INWEST 199432 IS Nimodipine (IV) 1 mg/ <24 SBP low dose: 6.6%; high dose
hour (low dose), 2 mg/ 11.4%; placebo 2.1%
hour (high dose) DBP low dose 7.7%; high 14.1%;
placebo 1.7%;
VENUS 200133 All Nimodipine (PO) <6 No difference
Systematic review (Horn 2001)34 IS Poor
Diuretics Neutral Neutral
Eames et al (2005)35 IS Bendroflumethiazide <96 No difference
(PO)
Magnesium Increase Neutral
IMAGES 200436 IS Magnesium sulfate IV <12 (median 7) BP difference at 24: 4/3 mm Hg vs
bolus and infusion placebo
FAST-MAG 201537 All Magnesium sulfate IV <2 (median SBP difference at 24: 3 mm Hg
bolus and infusion 45 min)
Continued
Open Access
ACEi, ACE inhibitors inhibitors; ARA, angiotensin receptor antagonists; BP, blood pressure; CBF, cerebral blood flow; CCA, calcium channel antagonists; DBP, diastolic blood pressure; DCLHb,
angiotensin receptor antagonists (ARAs) have undesir-
Neutral ?early
Neutral/poor
able properties in acute stroke or that gradual and late
Unknown
outcome
diaspirin cross-linked haemoglobin; GTN, glyceryl trinitrate; ICH, intracerebral haemorrhage; IS, ischaemic stroke; iv, intravenous; po, orally; NO, nitric oxide; SBP, systolic blood pressure.
Clinical treatment of BP is ‘too little too late’, thus reducing
effect
cerebral perfusion and increasing brain injury.
Poor
(83)
β-blockers
The single-centre β-blocker stroke (BEST) trial31 rando-
CBF effect
Increase
Increase
Neutral
within 48 hours of onset to oral propranolol, atenolol or
placebo. There was a greater fall in mean BP in the first
24 hours of treatment (6–9% vs 2%) and an increase in
early and later death in those assigned to β-blockers
MAP at 2 increased by 21 mm Hg
compared to placebo. The negative inotropic effects of
SBP difference at 2: 18 mm Hg
No data
p=0.05) but the study was not powered for this outcome.
Time given
3–30 days
55 min)
All
IS
IS
IS
ENOS 201439
Broad categories of other potential effects of BP modulating agents, with over-arching beneficial and detrimental groups. ‘+’=Beneficial effects, ‘−’=Detrimental effects, ‘*’=In the context of ICH,
Stress hormone
trial was stopped early because a Cochrane systematic
review involving 7665 patients from 29 trials of calcium
attenuation
channel antagonists (CCA) in AIS revealed no treatment
effect on functional outcome or death at the end of
follow-up.72 Interestingly, a subgroup analysis of unpub-
−
−
−
−
lished and methodologically sound trials yielded a statis-
tically significant unfavourable treatment effect
indicative of publication bias (RR 1.14, CI 95% 1.0 to
Negative
Neuroprotection Antiplatelet* inotrope
−
−
CCA, especially nimodipine, was driven by early positive
data.67–69 73
ACEi, ACE inhibitors; ARA, angiotensin receptor antagonists; CCA, calcium channel antagonists; NO, nitric oxide; SNP, sodium nitroprusside.
(SNP)
Diuretics
There is limited data on diuretics in acute stroke.23 One
−
−
−
−
+
+
+
+
Magnesium
+
+
+
Magnesium58–61
ACEi52 53
magnesium bolus followed by infusion, or placebo. SBP Diaspirin cross-linked haemoglobin (DCLHb), a cell-
fell in both groups over the first 48 hours but those on free haemoglobin-based oxygen-carrying solution that
treatment had a significantly lower SBP (∼3 mm Hg differ- scavenges NO,81 was compared with saline in 85 patients
ence) at the end of the bolus dose and from 20 to with AIS within 18 hours of onset.42 DCLHb caused a
32 hours after starting the maintenance infusion. rapid rise in BP and more serious adverse events, disabil-
Although prehospital initiation of magnesium was safe, ity (BI), death and poor functional outcome (mRS) at
there was no significant shift in mRS at day 90 (primary 3 months than control. In a small RCT of 33 patients
outcome). within 1 month of IS,41 amphetamine raised BP and
heart rate but had no impact on motor function or
Nitric oxide donors functional outcome. Although amphetamine was asso-
In three small RCTs in acute stroke, transdermal glyceryl ciated with a trend to improved motor function after IS
trinitrate (GTN) lowered BP, pulse pressure and peak in a systematic review, there was a non-significant
SBP while maintaining CBF and improving arterial com- increase in death, raising doubts over its safety.82 Other
pliance.65 76 77 A small ambulance-based feasibility trial potential agents including norepinephrine (noradren-
of transdermal GTN administered within 4 hours of aline), epinephrine (adrenaline) and dopamine have no
symptom onset revealed an improvement in functional significant evidence base.79
outcome at 90 days, measured as a shift in mRS by 1
point ( p=0.04).38 None of these trials were powered for
functional outcome; this was assessed in the large TARGETTING BP IN ACUTE STROKE
Efficacy of Nitric Oxide in Stroke (ENOS) trial.39 An alternative avenue of research has focused on
ENOS randomised 4011 patients with AIS or ICH within whether aiming for a BP target in acute stroke, regard-
48 hours of onset and high SBP (140–220 mm Hg) to less of the agent(s) used, improves outcome.
transdermal GTN 5 mg patches or placebo for 7 days. In
addition, those participants on antihypertensive agents Ischaemic stroke
immediately prior to their stroke were randomised to stop The China Antihypertensive Trial in Acute Ischaemic
or continue their medication, in a partial-factorial Stroke (CATIS)83 recruited 4071 patients with AIS with
design.39 GTN significantly reduced both SBP and DBP raised SBP (140–220 mm Hg) within 48 hours of onset
day 1 after randomisation compared to placebo (mean dif- and randomised them to either BP lowering (SBP
ference: 7 and 3 mm Hg, respectively, p<0.001) but there 10–25% reduction within 24 hours and BP <140/
was no statistically significant difference from day 3 90 mm Hg within 7 days) or control (no antihypertensive
onwards. Overall, GTN was safe in both IS and ICH. medication). Although a specific BP-lowering regimen
Although the primary outcome of mRS at day 90 was was not being assessed they suggested first-line (intraven-
neutral (acOR 1.0, 95% CI 0.91 to 1.13, p=0.83), a prespe- ous ACEi), second-line (oral CCA) and third-line (oral
cified subgroup analysis found that in those recruited in diuretic) medications. Mean SBP fell by 13% within
<6 hours from ictus, GTN was associated with a favourable 24 hours of randomisation in the treatment group, com-
shift in mRS (acOR 0.51, 95% 0.32 to 0.8, p=0.004), less pared with 7% in the control population. At 7 days,
death and improved cognition, disability, mood and mean SBP in the treatment and control arms was 137
quality of life.77 Beneficial effects were seen in patients and 147 mm Hg respectively. The primary outcome of
with IS (including those receiving thrombolysis) and mRS ≥3 at 14 days or hospital discharge and secondary
ICH.78 outcome of mRS at day 90 were neutral. A subgroup
analysis of time to treatment found that those rando-
Pressor therapy mised to BP lowering 24 hours or longer after ictus had
Several small studies have assessed the role of pressor a significant reduction in death or dependency at
therapy in AIS.23 79 One trial assessed intravenous 3 months (OR 0.73, 95% CI 0.55 to 0.97, p=0.03).83
phenylephrine versus conventional management in 15 There are several points to mention. First, the recruits
patients with AIS within 1 week of ictus, >20% diffusion- had minor strokes (median NIHSS 4) resulting in 66%
perfusion mismatch on MRI and normotension (SBP of the control population being independent at 2 weeks
<140 mm Hg).40 Phenylephrine was titrated to increase and therefore reducing the potential for the interven-
MAP by 10–20% and maintained for up to 72 hours. tion to show benefit. Second, patients with large vessel
NIHSS and cognitive scores, and volume of hypoper- carotid disease were omitted from the trial. And last,
fused tissue on MRI, improved in the treatment group patients receiving thrombolysis were excluded, further
with no significant adverse events, but there was no limiting the trial’s generalisability.83
assessment of functional outcome. The aforementioned
CHHIPS trial had a pressor arm, which sought to assess Intracerebral haemorrhage
phenylephrine in hypotensive patients with IS, but In a small feasibility study of patients with ICH within
grossly under-recruited (one participant only, who 8 hours of symptom onset, aggressive BP lowering (MAP
received placebo).80 Similarly, an unpublished trial of <110 mm Hg) was safe with no difference in rates of
dobutamine only managed to recruit three patients. early neurological deterioration, haematoma expansion
stroke type, or drug class and BP target used.23 However, in systemic BP will result in a higher cerebral perfusion
those who received treatment within 6 hours of stroke pressure increasing the risk of cerebral oedema and
onset (INTERACT2 and RIGHT), there was a tendency potential for haemorrhagic transformation; while lower-
towards a shift to less death or dependency, and improved ing BP may reduce CBF resulting in infarct extension.6
quality of life.38 89 All drug classes described above lowered A prespecified subgroup analysis from SCAST of
BP, with greater reductions seen in ICH than patients with patients with carotid imaging (n=993 (57%)), revealed
AIS (−11.8/−5.1 vs −7/−3.1 mm Hg). Smaller BP changes that those with severe unilateral stenosis (≥70%) who
occurred in patients recruited after 48 hours of onset, received candesartan had a trend towards increased risk
while the largest BP reduction was seen in those recruited of stroke progression and poor functional outcome,
earliest. Importantly, large falls in BP (>20%), especially in although the CI were wide.107 Whether this was due to a
AIS, were associated with a poor outcome.23 specific effect of candesartan, or to BP lowering per se
A subsequent subgroup analysis of ENOS patients rando- remains unclear. Of the 2038 participants in ENOS with
mised to GTN within 6 hours adds weight to the argument carotid imaging data, GTN was safe with no evidence of
for early treatment with reduced death or dependency, less harm across all levels of ipsilateral carotid stenosis.39
death and improved cognition, disability, mood and quality Patients with bilateral severe carotid stenosis pose
of life.77 It is unclear whether this may represent a generic another dilemma. A meta-analysis of three trials found
effect of early BP lowering or a specific effect of GTN. In that in patients with bilateral severe stenosis (≥70%), a
contrast, other interventions namely ARA, β-blockers and lower BP was associated with higher stroke recurrence
CCA may be detrimental (table 2).29 31 34 45 72 (SBP <130 mm Hg: HR 5.97, 95% CI 2.43 to 14.68,
Time is important: ultra-acute treatment of BP (intensive p<0.001).106 Although bilateral carotid stenosis is
BP lowering or use of an appropriate agent) within the first uncommon, caution regarding BP lowering in this
few hours of symptoms in the prehospital setting is a vital group seems warranted pending further data.
avenue to explore further. Non-oral routes of administra- With the advent and proven effectiveness of endovas-
tion, such as transdermal, sublingual and intravenous, cular intervention for proximal anterior circulation
would be preferable in this context, given the need for a vessel occlusions in AIS,108 numerous questions remain
swallowing assessment to rule out dysphagia. Of these, trans- unanswered, including how BP should be managed
dermal GTN,38 sublingual lisinopril,26 and intravenous mag- before, during and after thrombectomy. At present this
nesium,37 have been assessed in the prehospital is an evidence-free zone. Retrospective data comparing
environment and found to be safe. While transdermal pre- general with local anaesthesia during the procedure
parations can be easily applied and removed according to found that general anaesthesia, which was often asso-
clinical need, intravenous administration of BP-lowering ciated with SBP <140 mm Hg, was associated with a poor
agents require intensive monitoring. On-going (RIGHT-2: functional outcome (mRS >2) at 90 days.109 Prospective
ISRCTN26986053) and planned trials of transdermal GTN research in this area should prove illuminating.
in ultra-acute stroke will assess efficacy in the field.
Continue or stop pre-stroke antihypertensives
BP management in carotid disease and large vessel Whether to temporarily stop or continue existing antihy-
occlusion pertensive agents early after a patient’s stroke is a
High BP is commonly seen in patients with AIS due to common clinical question. The Continue or Stop
carotid artery stenosis.106 Owing to dysfunctional cere- Post-Stroke Antihypertensives Collaborative Study
bral autoregulation concerns are twofold: a higher (COSSACS)110 randomised 763 patients within 48 hours
of stroke to either stop or continue their pre-existing are safe and associated with improved functional
antihypertensive medication for 2 weeks. Those who outcome. Whether these effects are mediated through
continued their medication had a lower BP at 2 weeks BP reduction or specific pharmacological effects incorp-
compared with those who stopped (mean difference orating neuroprotection and/or reperfusion is unclear.
13 / 8 mm Hg). Death or dependency at 2 weeks (mRS Time seems to be a key factor and so on-going and
>3, primary outcome), death, major cardiovascular future hyper-acute and ultra-acute trials are pivotal in
events and serious adverse events at 6 months did not testing this hypothesis.
differ between the two arms.110 Contributors JPA produced the first draft, which NS and PMB commented
The partial-factorial ENOS trial39 enrolled 2097 and amended. A final version was agreed by all authors. PMB is
patients within 48 hours of stroke onset to continue or corresponding author.
stop their pre-stroke antihypertensive drugs for 7 days. Funding JPA is funded by the Health Technology Assessment programme of
Although there was no effect on functional outcome the National Institutes of Health Research (TARDIS (10/104/24) and TICH-2
(mRS) at day 90, continuation of pre-stroke BP drugs (11/129/109) trials), and British Heart Foundation (RIGHT-2 (CS/14/4/30972)
increased the risk of pneumonia ( perhaps due to aspir- trial).
ation), worsened BI and increased cognitive impairment Competing interests PMB was/is chief investigator of the trials involving GTN
at 90 days. (RIGHT, ENOS and RIGHT-2), and was a member of the steering committee
of the IMAGES trial. He is Stroke Association Professor of Stroke Medicine.
When pooled data from COSSACS and ENOS were
reviewed, continuation of antihypertensives was asso- Provenance and peer review Commissioned; externally peer reviewed.
ciated with worse disability (BI) and quality of life but Data sharing statement No additional data are available.
no change in functional outcome (mRS).23 This incon- Open Access This is an Open Access article distributed in accordance with
gruity is perplexing, but may represent chance, outcome the Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial (CC BY-NC 4.0) license,
bias or indeed be real. If the latter is true and continu- which permits others to distribute, remix, adapt, build upon this work non-
ing medication is detrimental, what is the mechanism? commercially, and license their derivative works on different terms, provided
First, giving medication to dysphagic patients without the original work is properly cited and the use is non-commercial. See: http://
creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/
appropriate enteral access could lead to aspiration and
resultant pneumonia.39 Second, as ACEi, ARA and
β-blocker drugs attenuate stress hormones, are common REFERENCES
1. Mackay J, Mensah G. The Atlas of Heart Disease and Stroke.
preparations used prior to stroke, and are associated WHO Library. Geneva: Myriad Editions Ltd. 2004.
with harm when given acutely after stroke (ARA and 2. MacMahon S, Peto R, Cutler J, et al. Blood pressure, stroke and
β-blockers),29 31 it may be that continuing them in the coronary heart disease. Part I, prolonged differences in blood
pressure: prospective observational studies corrected for the
acute phase is potentially hazardous.23 It therefore regression dilution bias. Lancet 1990;335:765–74.
seems reasonable to pause existing antihypertensive 3. Kearney PM, Whelton M, Reynolds K, et al. Global burden of
hypertension: analysis of worldwide data. Lancet 2005;365:217–23.
medication during the acute phase of stroke until 4. Britton M, Carlsson A, de Faire U. Blood pressure course in
patients have suitable enteral access and are medically patients with acute stroke and matched controls. Stroke
1986;17:861–4.
and neurologically stable.23 5. Oppenheimer S, Hachinski V. Complications of acute stroke. Lancet
1992;339:721–4.
6. Willmot M, Leonardi-Bee J, Bath PMW. High blood pressure in
acute stroke and subsequent outcome: a systematic review.
CONCLUSION Hypertension 2004;43:18–24.
Despite the recent publication of several large clinical 7. Leonardi-Bee J, Bath PMW, Phillips SJ, et al. Blood pressure and
clinical outcomes in the International Stroke Trial. Stroke
trials and systematic reviews, there are no definitive 2002;33:1315–20.
recommendations that can be drawn regarding BP 8. Sprigg N, Gray LJ, Bath PMW, et al. Relationship between outcome
modulation in AIS. BP should be lowered rapidly in and baseline blood pressure and other haemodynamic measures in
acute ischaemic stroke: data from the TAIST trial. J Hypertens
patients with ICH. Although stroke is more common in 2006;24:1413–17.
the older population, trials to date have mostly involved 9. Manning L, Hirakawa Y, Arima H, et al. Blood pressure variability
and outcome after acute intracerebral haemorrhage: a post-hoc
patients with a mean age of ≤75 years. Despite this, analysis of INTERACT2, a randomised controlled trial. Lancet
there is no suggestion that older patients should not Neurol 2014;13:364–73.
10. Sare GM, Ali M, Shuaib A, et al. Relationship between hyperacute
have their BP lowered.89 In addition to age, further evi- blood pressure and outcome after ischemic stroke: data from the
dence is needed on whether time of onset, stroke VISTA Collaboration. Stroke 2009;40:2098–103.
subtype, severity, drug choice (dose, route and timing), 11. Geeganage C, Tracy M, England T, et al. Relationship between
baseline blood pressure parameters (including mean pressure,
and BP variability influence response to changes in BP. pulse pressure, and variability) and early outcome after stroke: data
Individual patient data meta-analysis is warranted to aid from the Tinzaparin in Acute Ischaemic Stroke Trial (TAIST). Stroke
2011;42:491–3.
patient selection by identifying groups who are more or 12. Robinson TG, James M, Youde J, et al. Cardiac baroreceptor
less likely to benefit and to establish whether a certain sensitivity is impaired after acute stroke. Stroke 1997;28:1671–6.
drug class, dose, route or BP target is optimal.23 13. Alqadri SL, Sreenivasan V, Qureshi AI. Acute hypertensive
response management in patients with acute stroke. Curr Cardiol
In summary, antihypertensives should be withheld Rep 2013;15:426.
after stroke until they can be given safely in patients who 14. Fodstad H, Kelley PJ, Buchfelder M. History of the Cushing reflex.
Neurosurgery 2006;59:1132–7.
are neurologically stable. Both early intensive lowering 15. Chamorro A, Amaro S, Vargas M, et al. Catecholamines, infection,
of BP in ICH and early nitrate use in all stroke subtypes and death in acute ischaemic stroke. J Neurol Sci 2007;252:29–35.