Professional Documents
Culture Documents
IN THE REGION
WITH REFERENCE TO
Assistant Professor
VISAKHAPATNAM
2016-2018
DECLARATION
Place:
R SUNIL KUMAR
Date:
ADITYA BIRLA RETAIL LTD 3
CERTIFICATE
Signature of Guide
DR SHAIK SHAMSHUDDIN
Assistant professor
Visakhapatnam
ADITYA BIRLA RETAIL LTD 4
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
I wish to express my gratitude to Mrs. Uma Devi, Associate Professor, GITAM Institute of
Management, GITAM University, Visakhapatnam, for giving this valuable opportunity to
observe the situations of real-time industrial scheme/program.
I wish to express my gratitude to, Mr. Rich Bowman, Neustar Inc, Louisville, Kentucky,
for giving the valuable input on NPS and opportunity to observe the situations of real-
time industrial scheme/program.
R SUNIL KUMAR
ADITYA BIRLA RETAIL LTD 5
Contents
1 INTRODUCTION 6-13
14-15
2 OBJECTIVES AND METHODOLOGY
4 31-52
REDUCEING DETRACTIONS OF FIVE HIGH
DETRACTION STORES IN THE REGION
5 FINDINGS 53
6 SUGGESTIONS 54
7 CONCLUSION 55
8 BIBLIOGRAPHY 56
ADITYA BIRLA RETAIL LTD 6
Introduction
Industry profile
The Indian retail industry has emerged as one of the most dynamic and fast-paced
industries due to the entry of several new players. It accounts for over 10 per cent of the
country’s Gross Domestic Product (GDP) and around 8 per cent of the employment.
India is the world’s fifth-largest global destination in the retail space.
Market Size
India’s retail market is expected to nearly double to US$ 1 trillion by 2020 from US$ 600
billion in 2015, driven by income growth, urbanization and attitudinal shifts. While the
overall retail market is expected to grow at 12 per cent per annum, modern trade would
expand twice as fast at 20 per cent per annum and traditional trade at 10 per cent#.
India’s Business to Business (B2B) e-commerce market is expected to reach US$ 700
billion by 2020 whereas the Business to Consumer (B2C) e-commerce market is
expected to reach US$ 102 billion by 2020.## Online retail is expected to be at par with
the physical stores in the next five years.
India is expected to become the world’s fastest growing e-commerce market, driven by
robust investment in the sector and rapid increase in the number of internet users.
Various agencies have high expectations about growth of Indian e-commerce markets.
Indian e-commerce sales are expected to reach US$ 120 billion! By 2020 from US$ 30
billion in FY2016.Further, India's e-commerce market is expected to reach US$ 220
billion in terms of gross merchandise value (GMV) and 530 million shoppers by 2025,
led by faster speeds on reliable telecom networks, faster adoption of online services and
better variety as well as convenience@.
India’s direct selling industry is expected to reach a size of Rs 23,654 crore (US$ 3.51
billion) by FY2019-20, as per a joint report by India Direct Selling Association (IDSA)
and PHD.
ADITYA BIRLA RETAIL LTD 7
Investment Scenario
The Indian retail trading has received Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) equity inflows
totaling US$ 537.61 million during April 2000–March 2016, according to the
Department of Industrial Policies and Promotion (DIPP).
With the rising need for consumer goods in different sectors including consumer
electronics and home appliances, many companies have invested in the Indian retail
space in the past few months.
International Finance Corporation (IFC), the investment arm of The World Bank,
plans to invest up to Rs 134 crore (US$ 19.86 million) in Kishore Biyani's Future
Consumer Enterprises Ltd, which is expected to aid the company in driving its
growth plans.
Amazon India has opened six new fulfillment centers across Chennai,
Coimbatore, Delhi, Jaipur and Mumbai, which will open up 5.5 million square feet
of storage space for sellers on the marketplace who use the ‘Fulfilled by Amazon’
service.
IKEA, the world’s largest furniture retailer, plans to invest Rs 10,500 crore (US$
1.56 billion) to set up 25 stores across India and hire over 15,000 permanent
employees and 37,500 temporary employees to assist in running its stores.
Amazon Inc. has announced that the company would invest an additional US$ 3
billion in India operations, thereby taking its committed investment in the
country to over US$ 5 billion.
Aditya Birla Fashion and Retail Limited (ABFRL) has announced that it will
acquire exclusive online and offline rights of Forever 21, an American fast
fashion brand, in the Indian market.
Massimo Dutti, a premium fashion brand from Spain offering sophisticated
women wear, menswear, footwear and accessories, has entered India by opening
its first store at the Select Citywalk mall in New Delhi.
Lenskart, India's largest online eyewear retailer, has raised Rs 400 crore (US$
59.3 million) in series D round of funding led by World Bank's investment arm
International Finance Corporation (IFC), which will be used to enhance its
technology, supply chain, lens manufacturing, and expand the reach of its high-
quality eyewear products across Tier-3 and Tier-4 cities of India.
ADITYA BIRLA RETAIL LTD 8
Neil Barrett, one of the leading Italian fashion brands, has forayed into the Indian
market by establishing its retail presence through an exclusive partnership with
Fervour, a multi-brand boutique that stocks international designer brands.
New York-based designer brand Kate Spade will be launched in India later this
year and will set up a network of stand-alone stores across major cities, thus
becoming one more global brand entering the Indian retail space after the
Government of India relaxed single brand retail norms recently.
KartRocket, a Delhi based e-commerce enabler has completed its US$ 8 million
funding round by raising US$ 2 million from a Japanese investor, which will be
used to enhance Kraftly, a mobile-first online-to-offline marketplace targeting
small sellers, individuals and home-based entrepreneurs in India in product
categories such as apparel and accessories.
PurpleTalkInc, a US based mobile solutions company, has invested US$ 1 million
in Nukkad Shops, a Hyderabad based uber-local commerce platform that helps
neighborhood retail stores take their businesses online through a mobile app.
Mumbai-based baby care and kids products retailer, Hopscotch.in, has raised US$
13 million in a Series C round of funding from Facebook co-founder Mr. Eduardo
Saverin, which will help the firm in growth and expansion of its technology
platform.
Gurgaon-based e-commerce firm Shopclues has raised US$ 150 million from
Singapore government's GIC and its existing investors Tiger Global and Nexus
Venture Partners, at a valuation of US$ 1.1 billion, thereby becoming the latest
among several e-commerce companies from India reaching a billion dollar
valuation.
Amazon India expanded its logistics footprint three times to more than 2,100
cities and towns in 2015, as Amazon.com invested more than US$ 700 million in
its India operations since July 2014.
Adidas AG, renowned for its Adidas and Reebok sports brands, has become the
first foreign sports company to get government approval to open 100 per cent
foreign-owned stores in India.
Walmart India plans to add 50 more cash-and-carry stores in India over the next
four to five years.
ADITYA BIRLA RETAIL LTD 9
Aeropostale, an American teen fashion retailer, has chosen to enter India over
China, and expects India to be among its top three markets over the next four
years with revenue target of Rs 500 crore (US$ 74.12 million).
Opinio, a hyperlocal delivery start-up, has raised US$ 7 million in a Series-A
funding from Gurgaon-based e-commerce fulfilment service firm Delhivery along
with investment from Sands Capital and Accel Partners.
Textile major Arvind Limited has announced a partnership with Sephora, owned
by LVMH Moet Hennessy Louis Vuitton, a French luxury conglomerate, in order
to enter into the beauty and cosmetics segment.
Mobile wallet company MobiKwik has partnered with Jabong.com to provide
mobile payment services to Jabong’s customers.
DataWind partnered with HomeShop18 to expand its retail footprint in the
country. Under the partnership, HomeShop18 and DataWind would jointly
launch special sales programmes across broadcast, mobile and internet media to
provide greater access to the latter’s tablet range.
FashionAndYou has opened three distribution hubs in Surat, Mumbai and
Bengaluru to accelerate deliveries.
Abu Dhabi-based Lulu Group plans to invest Rs 2,500 crore (US$ 370.6 million)
in a fruit and vegetable processing unit, an integrated meat processing unit, and a
modern shopping mall in Hyderabad, Telangana.
Aditya Birla Retail, a part of the US$ 40 billion Aditya Birla Group and the fourth-
largest supermarket retailer in the country, acquired Total hypermarkets owned
by Jubilant Retail.
With an aim to strengthen its advertising segment, Flipkart acquired mobile ad
network AdiQuity, which has a history of mobile innovations and valuable
experience in the ad space.
US-based Pizza chain Sbarro plans an almost threefold increase in its store count
from the current 17 to 50 over the next two years through multiple business
models.
ADITYA BIRLA RETAIL LTD 10
Government Initiatives
The Government of India has taken various initiatives to improve the retail industry in
India.
Government of India has allowed 100 per cent Foreign Direct Investment (FDI)
in online retail of goods and services through the automatic route, thereby
providing clarity on the existing businesses of e-commerce companies operating
in India.
The Government of Andhra Pradesh signed pacts worth Rs 1,500 crore (US$
222.36 million) in a wide range of sectors including retail and steel and gas with
Walmart India, Future Group, Arvind Lifestyle Brands Ltd and Spencer’s Retail,
during the Partnership Summit in Visakhapatnam, while also unveiling a retail
policy aimed to attract retail businesses to invest in the state.
The Ministry of Urban Development has come out with a Smart National
Common Mobility Card (NCMC) model to enable seamless travel by metros and
other transport systems across the country, as well as retail purchases.
IKEA, the world’s largest furniture retailer, bought its first piece of land in India
in Hyderabad, the joint capital of Telangana and Andhra Pradesh, for building a
retail store. IKEA’s retail outlets have a standard design and each location entails
an investment of around Rs 500–600 crore (US$ 74–89 million).
The Government of India has accepted the changes proposed by RajyaSabha
select committee to the bill introducing Goods and Services Tax (GST).
Implementation of GST is expected to enable easier movement of goods across
the country, thereby improving retail operations for pan-India retailers.
The Government has approved a proposal to scrap the distinctions among
different types of overseas investments by shifting to a single composite limit,
which means portfolio investment up to 49 per cent will not require government
approval nor will it have to comply with sectorial conditions as long as it does
not result in a transfer of ownership and/or control of Indian entities to
foreigners. As a result, foreign investments are expected to be increase,
especially in the attractive retail sector.
ADITYA BIRLA RETAIL LTD 11
Company Profile
Aditya Birla Retail Limited (ABRL) is the retail arm of Aditya Birla Group, a $41 billion
corporation. The company ventured into food and grocery retail sectors in 2007 with
the acquisition of Trinethra Super Retail and subsequently expanded its presence across
the country under the brand ‘more’ with two formats ― Supermarkets and
Hypermarkets.
In keeping with its motto Quality 1st, ABRL takes pride in being the first ever Indian
food and grocery retailer to receive the Food Safety Management System (FSMS)
certification. The company bagged the award for ensuring that manufacturing, storage,
distribution and sales of food adhere to the highest quality standards. The Aditya Birla
Science and Technology Centre in Taloja drives the quest for world-class quality
through extensive research and development across food and non-food categories.
Through Clubmore and its comprehensive range of brands, including power brands —
VOW, Feasters and Kitchen’s Promise — that offer unbeatable value for homemakers,
the company aims to create customers who keep on returning for more. In all, the
company's family of Clubmore members has grown to 17 million, all of whom enjoy a
host of customized offers and great savings.
ABRL follows the best industry practices in order to unlock the full potential of its staff
through its world-class learning institutes — the Aditya Birla Centre for Retail
Excellence and Gyanodaya. Coupled with learning initiatives such as
SPARK, Aarohan and Aarambh, these initiatives are critical in helping their people
imbibe the key characteristics of the Quality 1st philosophy.
Supermarkets
more ― conveniently located in neighborhoods, more supermarkets cater to the daily,
weekly and monthly shopping needs of consumers. The product offerings include a
wide range of fresh fruits and vegetables, groceries, personal care, home care, general
merchandise and a basic range of apparels. Currently, there are 490 supermarkets
across the country.
Hypermarkets
more. MEGASTORE is a one-stop shopping destination for the entire family. Besides a
wide range of products comprising fruits and vegetables, groceries, FMCG products,
more. MEGASTORE also has a strong emphasis on general merchandise, apparel,
consumer durables and IT goods. Currently, there are 19 hypermarkets across the
country.
ADITYA BIRLA RETAIL LTD 13
Own Brands
More strives to delight customers through a wide range of brands that deliver high
quality at attractive prices across ready-to-eat food, beverages, tea, staples, cereals,
instant mixes, papad, pickles, apparel, footwear, household cleaning essentials, personal
care and devotional products. The power brands — VOW, Kitchen’s Promise and
Feasters — deliver world-class quality to discerning consumers. All these brands are
developed in-house.
In addition, Own Brands across categories include Selecta, Prarthana, More Choice,
More Value, Paradise, Bluearth, TRU, Bjoyzz, Karinee, Kruff Jeans Company, Berwins,
Incheels, Chatter Kids and Yo. ABRL aspires for its range of brands to be a customer’s
most preferred brand across product categories.
ABRL’s research and development center in Taloja, spread across 3,380 square feet,
formulates, tests and develops food as well as non-food products. Each of our brands
undergoes stringent testing for shelf life and consumer acceptance before they are made
available commercially.
Clubmore
With the strength of around 17 million members, Clubmore has gone mobile. It
leverages the power of marketing analytics to deliver meaningful and tailor-made offers
to individual customers based on their shopping history. Thus, creating loyal customers
every time.
Customer-friendly, free-to-use and completely intuitive, Clubmore is easy to
understand. It strives to be a notch above the industry standard. This is achieved with
its mobile identifier system.
ADITYA BIRLA RETAIL LTD 14
News of bad customer service reaches more than twice as many ears as praise for a
good service experience. Detractors has been a major concern in retail organizations,
the challenges faced by organizations to keep their customers satisfied and retain them
in the organization are increasing, with changing times the customers mindset also
changes, traditional methods may not be effective anymore, we have to understand the
top L1, L2, L3 drivers for customer satisfaction and increase the Net Promoters Score,
the manager has to identify these critical parameters and take necessary action towards
reducing the detractors ratio and increasing the promoters ratio.
Objective:
METHODOLOGY
Data collection:
Primary Data Was Collected through Interacting with CSA’s And Store Managers and
Secondary Data Was Collected from weekly Mission Happiness report, customer
feedback report, NPS daily mail from HQ, verbatim and NPS dashboard.
RESEARCH DESIGN
Sample Population
The population consists of employees, i.e. CSA, supervisor and store managers, from
MORE super market in the below mentioned locations of TELANGANA.
Store Locations:
MORE Upparapally
MORE Shanti Nagar (Masab Tank)
PO Purchase Order
DC Distribution Centre
CM Category Manager
5 Days Plan:
Shelf Management:
• Stock Shelves, racks and display
• Maintain SKU rotation as per FEFO
• Follow near expiry process
• Maintain shelves as per the planogram
• Maintain Shelf Edge Labels and promo talkers as per planogram and active
promos
Store Operations:
• Effectively use Store equipment's
• Receive, check, and mark stock against an invoice
• Performs basic housekeeping duties
• Follows the store regulations and SOP’s
F&V Management:
• Stack and display F&V SKUs
• Do dump removal
• Execute display as instructed by the Duty Manager
Prevention of Shrinkage:
• Participate in Stock Takes
• Escalate any issue identified as a source of shrinkage
Customer Interaction:
• Interact with customers proactively and resolves customer issues
• Ensure timely escalations of issues where seniors input is required
• Inform the customer about the Clubmore program and increase enrolments
Cashiering:
• Customer greetings & Customer interaction
• Operate POS machine
• Learn how to check and redeem Clubmore Points
• Conduct tender reconciliation
ADITYA BIRLA RETAIL LTD 17
Day 1
Date: 3/5/2017
Shelf Management:
Planogram in a retail store is a diagram that shows how specific SKU’s have to be placed
in the shelf.
A Plano gram is a sheet which contains the plan of how particular SKU’s have to place in
the shelf of the store.
More supermarkets follow FEFO, which abbreviates to First Expiry First Out.
ADITYA BIRLA RETAIL LTD 18
Products that are close to get expired are placed in front of the shelves, and
products that have longer expiry date are placed at the back.
Any product that is expired is a loss to the store.
If there are any expired products, they are disposed in two ways
1. RTV (Return to vendor) & 2. NRTV(not return to vendor)
Any and all disposed goods are entered into the system
According to mark down policy, products that are about to be expired are placed at the
back and availed a discount rate of 20% to boost their sales before expiry.
To make it to the 20% discount shelf, products need to be at their near expiry date, the
product shelf life in months is multiplied with 5 and the resulted number is considered
as the number of days prior to which the product has to be placed in 20% discount shelf.
Non Food items, such as skin care, hair care products are put on the 20% discount shelf
2 months before expiry.
This policy is not applied to baby food; they are put in the 20% shelf 60 days
before expiry.
No items, food and non-food will be put on shelves that have one month of shelf
life left.
Shelf edge labels are posted just below the product on the shelf, to signify what the
product is and what price it is being sold for.
DESCRIPTION
Quantity
MRP
PRICE
BARCODE
SKU Rotation
SKU abbreviates to stock keeping unit, it describes the attributes of the product, such as
shape, size color, it is also known as unique identifier, and it is not regulated or
standardized.
Promo Talkers
Promo Talkers are promotional offers that are displayed on the shop floor, these offers
are provided by the respective product brands and the store promotes them of the floor.
ADITYA BIRLA RETAIL LTD 20
Day 2
Date: 4/5/2017
Early in the morning the truck arrives with a stock of vegetables and fruits, the security
check the documents and approves for dropping.
Fruits and Vegetables are either brought in cardboard boxes or plastic ones; they are
carries down the truck and into the store.
The fruits and Vegetables are unboxed and placed on their respective shelves, thereon
to be displayed and sold.
Vegetables are stacked together, in mild cold condition to maintain freshness of the
product.
Fruits are placed under luminescent light, hence creating a desirable image to boost
sales.
The store manager instructs how the Fruits and Vegetables are to be displayed
ADITYA BIRLA RETAIL LTD 21
Carrots are faced horizontally, with stems Coconuts are placed horizontally, and
sprinkled
Watermelon are placed upright Beetroots are placed with the tips
facing . Downward
Leafy Vegetables
A wet green cloth is laid on the tub, upon that the leafy vegetables are places, and
additional wet green cloth is placed over the leafy vegetables.
Dump Removal
Dump removal is the process of removing the rotten or damaged vegetables and fruits
and dumping them outside so that they can be replaced with fresh stock.
ADITYA BIRLA RETAIL LTD 22
The store manager instructs how the Fruits and Vegetables are to be displayed.
F & V Indent
F & V indent is an online tool used to order stock of Fruits and vegetables.
Among the three suppliers, the store prefers cc- collection center, because the F&V from
CC are of best quality.
Stock Clear
ADITYA BIRLA RETAIL LTD 23
Stock clear is the process of transferring stock towards gondolas in the store.
Upon receiving the goods, they are brought in cartons or tubs, There exists a reference
paper called TO (transfer order), the CSA needs to cross check the barcode in the TO to
the barcode on the tub or carton and transfer the products to the shop floor.
The CSA needs to count the exact amount of received stock, if there are any damaged
goods; the CSA needs to report to the manager.
Stock Out
Stock clear is the report of how much F&V is sold to estimate Indent.
Day 3
Date: 5/5/2017
Cashiering:
Operating POS
If customer has clubmore card, scan and check number of points, if qualified, avail
gift to the customer, and document the information.
There exist a few products that do not have MRP, we need to use “look up” option to
find out MRP, example Palak, Raw mango etc.
ADITYA BIRLA RETAIL LTD 24
If he customer wished to pay via Sodexo passes, choose coupons option in SOP
machine and generate bill.
If customer wishes to pay via card use the swipe machine and make the payment.
Tender Reconciliation
Day 4
Date: 6/5/2017
Store Operations:
1. Shop floor
Dry Mopping
Wet mopping
Floor Scrubbing
Cleaning Cob Webs
Cleaning Fire extinguishers
2. Back Office
Dry Mopping
Wet Mopping
Furniture
Dustbins emptied
Toilets Washing
ADITYA BIRLA RETAIL LTD 26
3. Electrical Fixtures
5. Cash Tills
Cleaning Glass
Cleaning Freezer
ADITYA BIRLA RETAIL LTD 27
Day 5
Date: 7/5/2016
Prevention of Shrinkage:
Shrinkage
Shrinkage is the difference between the stock on system and stock in store
Theft by customers
Theft by staff
Process Lapse, DC to store
Counting Mistake
Customer Interaction
Customer Assistance
Customer issue Escalation
Customer Interaction
Customer Feedback
ADITYA BIRLA RETAIL LTD 32
Under the Mission Happiness program ABRL has initiated to calculate their customer
satisfaction level and the impact of it on their sales.
What is NPS?
NPS is a metric designed to assist companies with strategies and tactics that drive revenue.
Mapping the cross-functional customer journey to highlight functional team customer
touch-points, team-interlock and to redevelop processes and metrics to drive positive NPS
influencing behavior is fundamental to developing strategies and tactics to improve NPS.
NPS is a metric & tool to drive revenue. NPS drives customer satisfaction, which motivates
customers to advocate on our behalf, stimulates buy-again behavior, enables reference
ability, minimizes customer churn, drives renewals and enables viral external product
promotion.
• Calculate the percentage of promoters and detractors out of the total number of -
responses
AVERAGE
VERY BAD
6. Freshness
ADITYA BIRLA RETAIL LTD 35
The information has been collected by interviewing CSA’s, Assistant store manager,
supervisor, Verbatim, daily and weekly data of NPS.
Objective:
Findings:
1. The Feedback response rate of this store was 79% which was very low according the
required standards which is 95%.
2. No proper MRP Cleanup at the store which resulted in many billing issues in the store. For
an instance in a span of 4 hours in the store there were 30 issues raised due to the MRP
cleanup.
3. No Daily Shelf Edge label changing in the store.
4. Negligence attitude of the CSA’s towards customers.
5. There are internal conflicts in the store between the CSA’s and Managers resulting, many
HR issues which has to be addressed by the HR Manager.
6. Weekly briefings or hurdle discussions were not happening the store regarding the NPS.
Response Rate:
The CSA’s in Langar Houz store are reluctant to take the feedback which is a standard
operations procedure to be followed in during the billing. To increase the feedback response
rate CSA’s were ordered to maintain 95% and above feedback response rate during their shift
and they were continuously monitored and there feedback response rate were given to them
during their SCV (Standard Cash verification) and at the logout from POS so that they could
remember to collect the feedback from the customers during the billing.
After implementing the above we were able to achieve a growth in the feedback response rate
from 79% to 95% or above.
MRP Cleanup:
MRP cleanup was not done properly by the store manager and the assistant store manager
being a new joiner was unable to do the cleanup process which related to many issues at the
ADITYA BIRLA RETAIL LTD 42
billing counter leading to customer dissatisfaction and increasing the detractor’s ratio for the
store. To overcome the situation the store manager was instructed to do the MRP cleanup
according to the SOP and training was given to the assistance store manager and L1 so that
anyone could be available in the store to regulate and do the MRP Cleanup on regular basis.
CSA’s in the Langar Houz store were not at all have any sort of motivation towards helping the
customers in finding the SKU’s or providing them with any information regarding the SKU or
store policies and procedures.
To overcome this the CSA’s were informed about the weekly verbatim and hurdle discussion
was conducted on daily basis about the issues happened the previous day and an RCA was done
and CA and PA was given so that same issues related to customer dissatisfaction was not raised
in the near future.
Daily SEL’s were not changed in the store according to the SNOP procedures, which was
creating customer dissatisfaction at the POS because of which few of the customers left the
SKU’s at the POS and walked out of the store with the dissatisfaction. After doing the root
cause analysis we could find out the SEL’s were not printed and given to the CSA’s on the
prescribed time and the morning shift CSA’s were reluctant to do their work. Corrective action
was taken against the defaulters and preventive action was taken to enroll the responsibility to
a single morning shift CSA’s before leaving for the day.
The CSA’s in the store were showing negligence towards customer interaction, instead of
helping the customer finding the required SKU they were just pointing the directions towards
the concerned category gondola’s. To prevent from further negligence towards the customer
regular briefing were conducted in certain intervals.
Learning’s:
CSA’s are not having product knowledge about the assortment range in different bays
apart from their own bay.
Customer looks the ready to help behavior from the staff.
The customer and employee engagement is not there in the stores.
Improving front line customer service communication.
Inter-talking: Identifying the regular customers and trying to build rapport with them
will increase the satisfaction level of the customer.
CSA’s are not aware about the relevance off their work with NPS, giving the right
feedback to the right person is necessary.
Negligence of the CSA’s to take feedback from the customers.
ADITYA BIRLA RETAIL LTD 43
After resolving the concerned issues related to store the results were promising, below
is tabular and bar chart representation of the NPS, promoter’s percentage and
detractor’s percentage.
The difference between the detractors percentage, promoters percentage and total NPS score of
Lungar Houz store in May 2017 and June 2017 is depicted in the below tabular form( Table 1).
LANGER HOUSE
STORE NAMES
STORE
LM 17%
Detractors% CM 16%
ACH% 94%
LM 29%
Promoters% CM 32%
ACH% 110%
LM 12%
CM 16%
NPS% ACH% 133%
The information has been collected by interviewing CSA’s, Assistant store manager,
supervisor, Verbatim, daily and weekly data of NPS.
Objective:
Findings:
The feedback response rate of the store was at 82% which is 13% below the required response
rate as per the standard policies and procedure, it was due to new hired trainee operating on
the POS in the morning shift they were slow in the operating the POS and needed to follow
the Pick Scan Bag(PSB) procedure. They were given a training session on the operating POS
and asking the customer for feedback was reinstated in there mind.
The CSA’s in the store were not aware of the NPS process and the importance of NPS with their
work, there was a session conducted with the help of store manager to all the CSA’s stating the
need to take the feedback and the importance of the happy and satisfied customer towards the
sales of the store reaching the target.
ADITYA BIRLA RETAIL LTD 45
Problem at Bizerba:
During the peak hours due to low staff in the evenings from 5pm to 8pm the customers were
facing lot of problems in weighing of staples or F&V, in few scenarios the cashier had to go to
the bizerba and do the weighing for the customer because of which lot of customers were
dissatisfied. To overcome this situation the CSA’s were instructed not to leave the bizerba
during the peak business hours both in the morning and evening.
After resolving the concerned issues related to store the results were promising, below is
tabular and bar chart representation of the NPS, promoter’s percentage and detractor’s
percentage (Graph 2).
35%
30%
25%
20%
Detractors %
15%
NPS Score
10% Promoters%
5%
0%
The difference between the detractors percentage, promoters percentage and total NPS score of
New Motti Nagar store in May 2017 and June 2017 is depicted in the below tabular form
( Table 2).
NEW MOTINAGAR
STORE NAMES
STORE
LM 12%
Detractors% CM 13%
ACH% 108%
LM 26%
Promoters% CM 25%
ACH% 96%
LM 14%
CM 13%
NPS% ACH% 93%
The information has been collected by interviewing CSA’s, Assistant store manager,
supervisor, Verbatim, daily and weekly data of NPS.
Objective:
Findings:
Understaffed:
The store is having only 7 CSA’s including morning, mid and evening shift due to which
they were not able to serve the customers, in the evening there were only 3 CSA’s
available so all had to occupy the POS, the customers were facing the problem in
finding the assortment’s, weighing and other assistance from the CSA’s. Due to
understaff the CSA’s were not able to imply 2+1 policy few a times and the problem of
shrinkage was also increasing.
ADITYA BIRLA RETAIL LTD 47
Billing, Price and Freshness/Quality were the top drivers at the store as the store was
facing a heavy competitors the price point and freshness of the F&V was not satisfying
the customers.
Hurdle discussions were not being conducted by the store manager as per the standard
store operations; the CSA’s were unaware of the reasons of dissatisfaction of the
customers. The store manager was given instructions to take the hurdle discussion on a
regular basis so that the CSA’s would be aware about the issues occurring at the store.
Follow up of Verbatim:
Daily verbatim which were received by the store manager was not being followed up by
the store manager, as a result the depth of the customer dissatisfaction was not
understood. The store manager was instructed to handle the verbatim on a regular
basis so that preventive and corrective actions can be taken to solve the problem.
After resolving the concerned issues related to store the results were promising, below is
tabular and bar chart representation of the NPS, promoter’s percentage and detractor’s
percentage (Graph 3).
40%
35%
30%
25%
20% Detractors %
15% NPS Score
10% promoters%
5%
0%
ADITYA BIRLA RETAIL LTD 48
The difference between the detractors percentage, promoters percentage and total NPS score of
Beeramguda store in May 2017 and June 2017 is depicted in the below tabular form ( Table 3).
The information has been collected by interviewing CSA’s, Assistant store manager,
supervisor, Verbatim, daily and weekly data of NPS.
Objective:
Findings :
The top drivers for low NPS score in the Anandbagh store are customer service and
assortment range, according to the customer in the catchment area the store was not having
the required assortment range and was not sufficient to satisfy the needs and want of the
customer another factor was the customer service which was not satisfactory, after doing the
root cause analysis the corrective actions taken was to take the regular briefings to the CSA’s
and inform them regarding the complaints raised through the verbatim
Hurdle discussions were not being conducted by the store manager as per the standard
store operations; the CSA’s were unaware of the reasons of dissatisfaction of the
customers. The store manager was given instructions to take the hurdle discussion on a
regular basis so that the CSA’s would be aware about the issues occurring at the store.
ADITYA BIRLA RETAIL LTD 50
The CSA’s were not doing the proper let down and facings and the Bay Ka Malik was not
taking the responsibility to maintain the bay according to the merchandise standards. To
eliminate this behavior of the CSA’s the store manager and the supervisor were instructed to
take strict against the Bay Ka Malik whose bay was not according to the merchandises
standards.
After resolving the concerned issues related to store the results were promising, below is
tabular and bar chart representation of the NPS, promoter’s percentage and detractor’s
percentage (Graph 4).
50%
45%
40%
35%
30%
Detractors %
25%
NPS Score
20%
promoters%
15%
10%
5%
0%
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15
The difference between the detractors percentage, promoters percentage and total NPS score of
Anandbagh store in May 2017 and June 2017 is depicted in the below tabular form ( Table 4).
The information has been collected by interviewing CSA’s, Assistant store manager,
supervisor, Verbatim, daily and weekly data of NPS.
Objective:
Findings:
Store Size:
This store is one of the best store in the Telangana region making a good in both sales and
employee customer engagement, the only problem was with the size of the store as an profit
making store it was receiving more stock from dry DC and the place to maintain the stock in
back office was not sufficient so they were stacking the stock in the floor area which was
making the store congested for moving to the customer.
Customer Service:
Customer Service was good at this store and the employee customer engagement was very
good, the satisfaction level of the customer was good, but still during the peak hours the CSA’s
in the process of fast billing were neglecting the feedback procedure.
ADITYA BIRLA RETAIL LTD 52
After resolving the concerned issues related to store the results were promising, below is
tabular and bar chart representation of the NPS, promoter’s percentage and detractor’s
percentage (Graph 5).
45%
40%
35%
30%
25% Detractors %
15% promoters%
10%
5%
0%
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
The difference between the detractors percentage, promoters percentage and total NPS score of
Gandhinagar store in May 2017 and June 2017 is depicted in the below tabular form ( Table 5).
According to the time frame and the target to convert the 30% of detractors into
promoters or passive to convert 30% of passives into promoters by taking the
preventive actions and corrective actions target was achieved in 3 stores and due to
time constraints the other 2 were able to reach only upto 95% and above (Table 6).
Apart from the five stores allotted to me I also visited Jublie hills store,
Upparapally store and Shaikpet store where I could understand the difference in
functioning and behavioral pattern of the employees towards the customer and
their job.
Jublie hills and Gandhinagar store was I found the store managers playing an
vital role in motivating the CSA’s to increasing their potential in both sales and
customer service.
My overall experience is if Hurdle Discussion, 2+1 rule and briefing the CSA’s properly
and other tools which are there in the SNOP then the NPS can be increased, as we
can’t change the customers behaviour we can try to implement these things properly
to make sure customer satisfaction is attained.
There is a must need of a single individual monitoring the NPS regularly in the ABRL
so that all the operations to increase the NPS is maintained smoothly.
ADITYA BIRLA RETAIL LTD 54
FINDINGS
CSA’s are not having product knowledge about the assortment range in different bays
apart from their own bay.
Customer looks the ready to help behavior from the staff.
The customer and employee engagement is not there in the stores.
Improving front line customer service communication.
Inter-talking: Identifying the regular customers and trying to build rapport with them
will increase the satisfaction level of the customer.
CSA’s are not aware about the relevance off their work with NPS, giving the right
feedback to the right person is necessary.
Negligence of the CSA’s to take feedback from the customers.
ADITYA BIRLA RETAIL LTD 55
Suggestions:
Make it relevant- CSA’s are to be made aware about the relevance of their work
towards the improvement of the store and MORE as they are the first point of contact
for customers.
“Amplify what CSA’s are doing right and minify what you CSA’s doing wrong”
Give them tools: “One person responsible for whole category”, for instance an CSA is
given the responsibility of complete customer service for the day and we need to make
sure they are doing it properly
Gamify: There should be an competition between the stores to make it an healthy
competition between the stores and improving the competitiveness in the stores
Customers are not aware of the NPS and its importance, we have to make them aware
of the importance of their feedback.
Add-on:
Separate billing counters for customers paying with Sodexho coupons and having less
than five SKUS’s during peak hours.
Display of fun facts near POS for diversion of the customer at the billing during peak
hours.
Pictorial representation of the category or “May I Help You” on the CSA’s apron.
Creating premium customer – by giving them premium services through out there
experience in the stores.
Listening to the feedback of customers, having meaningful discussions and making
systematic improvements
Discover which experiences do not matter to customers, in order to focus on areas
they value.
Sending a text message to the customer appreciating their purchase from MORE store.
During an RED alert in the verbatim using the LAST (Listen, Apologize, Solve, Thank)
approach to resolve the issue.
When customer refuse to give feedback there must be an additional option at the POS
stating customer refused to do the billing smoothly.
Giving the CSA’s an update regarding the current NPS status of the store of that store
during the Surprise Cash Visit (SCV), so that they can strive to improve the score.
Bay Ka Malik (BKM) to be rotated once in a month, so that the CSA’s have a complete
knowledge about all the SKU’s available in the store.
ADITYA BIRLA RETAIL LTD 56
Conclusion
The five store findings indicate a severe state of detractor’s ratio with Beeramguda store and
Langar Houz store where the level of detractor’s ratio is high compared with the other 3
stores. The detractor’s ratio can be controlled right away with the suggested solutions, the 5
stores have been struggling with expiry due to various reasons, mentioned in the findings,
information has been collected from last 6 months and has been analyzed according to the
pattern of detractors ratio, promoters ration and NPS score, the most important reasons of
expiry is lack of awareness about the NPS program and its impact on the sales, relativity of
their work with the NPS, Customer service, Quality/Freshness, assortment range, addressing
these issues and applying the solutions will bring positive change in the state of employees of
ABRL, it is imperative that the interests of the employee need to be considered ,so as to
achieve the best interests of the organization.
Mission Happiness was a very good initiative started by ABRL and there were very good
initiatives taken to ensure the NPS is maintained properly so that customer satisfaction rate is
high.
But those initiatives are dying their natural death eventually, for instance the signage for
customer feedback, which have to be reduced so that a proper system is regulated to ensure
the customer satisfaction is maintained.
ADITYA BIRLA RETAIL LTD 57
BIBLIOGRAPHY
1. http://www.adityabirla.com/businesses/Profile/aditya-birla-retail-limited
2. http://www.morestore.com/know-abrl/aditya-birla-retail-ltd
Submitted by
R Sunil Kumar