Professional Documents
Culture Documents
lt h M
n H ea y
owd
e nl
t® D
al u se o
h
yrig r person
Cop
Fo
Clozapine, despite its side effect burden, may be the most effective
and have the lowest mortality risk among all available antipsychotics
For mass reproduction, content licensing and permissions contact Dowden Health Media.
Life-threatening or
life-saving treatment?
R
Leslie Citrome, MD, MPH esearchers in Finland surprised psychiatrists this year by
Professor of psychiatry announcing that clozapine “seems to be associated with a sub-
New York University School of Medicine
New York, NY stantially lower mortality than any other antipsychotic.”1 This
finding also surprised the researchers, who expected their 11-year
Director, Clinical Research and Evaluation Facility
Nathan S. Kline Institute for Psychiatric Research study to link long-term use of second-generation (“atypical”) anti-
Orangeburg, NY psychotics with increased mortality in patients with schizophrenia.
Instead they found longer lives in patients who used antipsychotics
(and particularly clozapine), compared with no antipsychotic use.
This study’s findings do not change clozapine’s association with
potentially fatal agranulocytosis as well as weight gain, metabolic
abnormalities, and other adverse effects. Clozapine also is difficult
to administer (Box 1, page 58),2 and patients must be enrolled in FDA-
mandated registries (see Related Resources, page 63). These obstacles
might discourage you from offering clozapine to patients who could
benefit from it (Box 2, page 59).3-5
Why bother considering clozapine? Because recent data on de-
creased mortality, decreased suicidality, and control of aggressive
behavior make clozapine a compelling choice for many patients.
Careful attention to clozapine’s adverse effect profile is necessary,
but you can manage these risks with appropriate monitoring.
Current Psychiatry
Vol. 8, No. 12 57
reassuring) finding was that long-term • The Modified Overt Aggression Scale
antipsychotic treatment of patients with (MOAS) physical aggression score mea-
schizophrenia is associated with lower sured the number and severity of assaults.
mortality when compared with no anti- • The Positive and Negative Syndrome
psychotic treatment. Scale (PANSS) was used to assess psychiat-
ric symptoms.
Recommendation. Consider clozapine Clozapine was shown to be more effec-
earlier than as a “last resort” in the disease tive than olanzapine and olanzapine was
course of patients with schizophrenia. At more effective than haloperidol in reduc-
the very least, routinely present clozapine ing the number and severity of physical
to patients and their families as a possible assaults and in reducing overall aggres-
treatment option. sion. Clozapine’s antiaggressive property
was specific and not related to the PANSS
outcomes or sedation.
Antiaggressive properties
Case series and retrospective studies have Recommendation. Offer clozapine as an
provided insights into clozapine’s anti- option for patients with schizophrenia or
aggressive properties, but the strongest evi- schizoaffective disorder and persistent ag-
dence comes from a 12-week, double-blind, gressive behavior. Another antipsychotic
randomized trial that specifically enrolled might not be “good enough.”
patients with violent behavior.6 Clozapine,
olanzapine, and haloperidol were directly
compared in the treatment of assaults and Reduced risk of suicidality
other aggressive behaviors by physically The International Suicide Prevention Trial
assaultive inpatients with schizophrenia (InterSePT) was a multicenter, randomized,
Current Psychiatry
and schizoaffective disorder: 2-year clinical study that compared the risk Vol. 8, No. 12 59
antipsychotic might
for suicidal behavior in patients treated with Recommendation. Clozapine is a first-
not be ‘good enough’ clozapine vs olanzapine.7 Enrolled were 980 line treatment for patients with schizo-
patients with schizophrenia or schizoaffec- phrenia or schizoaffective disorder who
tive disorder who were considered at high exhibit suicidal behavior. This is reflected
risk for suicide because of past suicide at- in the drug’s product labeling.
tempts or current suicidal ideation. Ap-
proximately one-quarter had not responded
adequately to previous treatment. Superior symptom management
All patients were seen weekly for 6 CATIE findings. Phase 2 of the Clinical
months, then biweekly for 18 months. The Antipsychotic Trials of Intervention Effec-
weekly or biweekly contact required to tiveness (CATIE) showed clozapine to be
monitor for clozapine-associated agranu- more effective than other atypical antipsy-
locytosis was matched with a similar visit chotics, as measured by time to all-cause
schedule for olanzapine-treated patients, discontinuation.8 Patients in this phase of
during which clinicians obtained vital CATIE had discontinued another atypical
signs. Primary endpoints included suicide antipsychotic in phase 1, principally be-
attempts (including death), hospitalization cause of lack of adequate efficacy. In phase
to prevent suicide, and a rating of “much 2, they were re-randomized to receive
worsening of suicidality” from baseline. open-label clozapine or double-blinded
Blinded raters, including an independent risperidone, olanzapine, or quetiapine.
suicide monitoring board, determined Only 90 patients were included in
when patients achieved endpoint criteria. the time-to-discontinuation analysis, yet
Patients receiving clozapine showed the greater amount of time that patients
significantly less suicidal behavior than remained on clozapine (median 10.5
those treated with olanzapine (a 24% rela- months) compared with quetiapine (medi-
tive advantage in the hazard ratio for sui- an 3.3 months) or risperidone (median 2.8
cide attempts or hospitalizations to prevent months) was statistically significant. Time
suicide). Fewer patients in the clozapine to discontinuation because of inadequate
Current Psychiatry
60 December 2009 group: therapeutic effect also was significantly
Ñ Twice-daily updates
Ñ News and alerts from NIH, FDA, CDC, and other government
agencies
Ñ 2-year searchable archives of psychiatry news.
Bottom Line
Despite clozapine’s perceived dangerousness, recent data on decreased mortality,
decreased suicidality, and control of aggressive behavior make this antipsychotic
a compelling choice for many patients with schizophrenia. Careful attention to
clozapine’s adverse effects is necessary, but risks such as agranulocytosis, metabolic
62
Current Psychiatry
December 2009
abnormalities, and myocarditis can be managed with appropriate monitoring.
Current Psychiatry
Vol. 8, No. 12 63 CURRENTPSYCHIATRY.com