Professional Documents
Culture Documents
PURPOSE: To evaluate the efficacy of photoactivated leading to corneal perforation or endophthalmitis is not
chromophore for infectious keratitis (PACK-CXL) in uncommon. A new paradigm-changing treatment able to
the treatment of patients with moderate to severe infec- enhance microbial eradication and improve treatment out-
tious keratitis as adjunct therapy to the topical medication comes with fewer side effects needs to be established.
treatment. Corneal collagen cross-linking is a procedure in which
DESIGN: Randomized clinical trial. the photosensitizer riboflavin and ultraviolet A (UVA)
METHODS: Thirty eyes from 30 patients with moderate irradiation are used. This procedure preliminarily aims to
to severe infectious keratitis were randomized to receive strengthen the corneal stroma, thereby improving the
either standard treatment plus PACK-CXL (n [ 15) or corneal biomechanics in ectatic corneal disorders.1 Soon
standard treatment alone (control group, n [ 15). The after the acceptance of this concept, corneal cross-linking
primary outcome was the sizes of stromal infiltrates was proposed to be effective for treating infectious keratitis
measured on slit-lamp photographs 30 days after treat- based on the disinfectant properties of photoactivated
ment. The secondary outcomes were the sizes of epithelial chromophore. The possible mechanisms include inhibition
defects, the complication rates, and best pinhole- of microbial replication, intercalation of the chromophore
corrected visual acuity (BPVA). with microbial nucleic acid,2 direct damage to the path-
RESULTS: The median (interquartile range [IQR]) sizes ogen cell walls by reactive oxygen free radicals,3,4
of stromal infiltrates at day 30 were 5.0 mm2 increased resistance of the cross-linked cornea to enzymatic
(0–23.0 mm2) in the PACK-CXL group and 10.6 mm2 damage, and changing of the ocular surface environment.5
(1.1–16.3 mm2) in the control group (median difference However, the clinical evidence in terms of collagen cross-
0, 95% CI L7.0 to 0, P [ .66). The median (IQR) sizes linking efficacy for keratitis is still inconclusive.6–9
of epithelial defects were 0.7 mm2 (0–6.3 mm2) and In this study, we evaluated the efficacy of photoactivated
4.6 mm2 (0–10.2 mm2) in the PACK-CXL group and chromophore for infectious keratitis (PACK-CXL) as an
control group, respectively (median difference L3.0, adjunct to medical treatment for patients with moderate
95% CI L0.8 to 0, P [ .41). The complication rates to severe infectious keratitis.
and BPVA after treatment were comparable between
groups.
CONCLUSIONS: Standard treatment combined with
PACK-CXL did not provide any advantageous effect METHODS
over standard treatment alone in moderate to severe in-
fectious keratitis over a 30-day period. (Am J THE INSTITUTIONAL REVIEW BOARD, FACULTY OF MEDI-
Ophthalmol 2016;165:94–99. Ó 2016 Elsevier Inc. All cine, Chulalongkorn University approved and monitored
rights reserved.) this randomized controlled trial, which adhered to the te-
nets of the Declaration of Helsinki. The trial was registered
with clinicaltrials.gov (NCT01831206). The sample size
I
NFECTIOUS KERATITIS IS A LEADING CAUSE OF RAPID for the study was calculated using a superiority design for-
and devastating visual loss worldwide, especially in mula with power of 0.8 and a 2-tailed significance level
developing countries. Despite topical broad-spectrum of .05 to detect 7 mm2 difference in areas of stromal infiltra-
medical therapies being used initially, infectious keratitis tion with standard deviation of 6. This provided a sample
size of 15 patients per group. Written informed consent
was obtained from all participants.
Supplemental Material available at AJO.com. The participants were recruited from the Department of
Accepted for publication Feb 24, 2016.
From the Department of Ophthalmology, Faculty of Medicine, Ophthalmology, King Chulalongkorn Memorial Hospital,
Chulalongkorn University, and King Chulalongkorn Memorial Hospital, Bangkok, Thailand from March 2013 to December 2014.
Bangkok, Thailand. All patients presenting with infectious keratitis underwent
Inquiries to Vannarut Satitpitakul, Department of Ophthalmology,
Faculty of Medicine, Chulalongkorn University, 1873 Rama 4 Road ophthalmic examination including best pinhole-corrected
Pathuwan, Bangkok, Thailand 10330; e-mail: vannaruts@gmail.com visual acuity (BPVA), slit-lamp biomicroscopy, anterior
segment photography, and posterior segment ultrasonogra- medical therapy for bacterial keratitis included hourly instil-
phy. The severity of keratitis was graded by slit-lamp bio- lation of fortified cefazolin (50 mg/mL; BIOLAB, Samutpra-
microscopy using a modification of Jones’s grading.10 karn, Thailand) and fortified amikacin (20 mg/mL; Atlantic
Ulcers that were 2-6 mm in size and infiltration that Lab, Bangkok, Thailand); the primary medical therapy for
involved the mid stroma but not beyond the posterior fungal keratitis included hourly topical application of
one third of the corneal stroma were graded as moderate in- amphotericin B (1.0 mg/mL; Bharat Serums and Vaccines,
fectious keratitis. Ulcers either involving the posterior one Maharashtra, India) and topical natamycin (50 mg/mL;
third of the cornea or that were more than 6 mm in size Alcon, Bangkok, Thailand). In case of positive clinical
were graded as severe infectious keratitis. response, the medications were tapered based on the judg-
Consecutive cases of patients aged older than 6 years ment of 1 clinician (N.K.). However, if the ulcers
with moderate to severe infectious keratitis were enrolled progressed, the regimens were changed according to the re-
in the study. Pregnant patients or patients with a history sults of the microbiological evaluation. All participants were
or evidence of herpetic keratitis, parasitic keratitis, corneal treated as inpatients until the medications were tapered to
perforation, autoimmune diseases, endophthalmitis, or applications of fewer than 4 times a day. No topical or sys-
corneal thickness less than 400 mm by ultrasound pachy- temic corticosteroids were used during the study period.
metry were excluded. For the participants randomized to PACK-CXL, corneal
After enrollment, participants were randomized to collagen cross-linking with UVA and riboflavin was
receive standard treatment with or without PACK-CXL us- performed under topical anesthesia on the first day of pre-
ing simple randomization. Sealed envelopes, used to sentation. The corneal limbus was shielded by a Merocel
conceal the randomization, were opened after enrollment ring (Medtronic, Inc, Dublin, Ireland). Riboflavin (Medio-
of each participant. A microbiological evaluation included CROSS [Peschke Meditrade GmbH, Germany] 0.1% ribo-
Gram stain, KOH preparation, and cultures; the samples flavin/20% dextran solution) was administered to the
were obtained by corneal scraping in all participants. cornea every 2 minutes for an initial period of 30 minutes
Participants randomized to standard treatment received and then every 5 minutes for a further 30 minutes during
standard medical therapy according to the patient’s history, UVA illumination. The epithelium was not removed as
clinical findings, and initial laboratory results. The primary there were epithelial defects overlying the ulcers. The
P Valuea
.62
.87
TABLE 2. Areas of Stromal Infiltration in Participants With Moderate to Severe Infectious Keratitis at Day 7 and Day 30 After Treating With Medical Therapy Plus Photoactivated
mW/cm2) for 30 minutes. After the PACK-CXL treat-
ment, the participants received standard medical treatment
1.1 (16.9 to 0)
Median Difference
as described previously.
Fungal Keratitis Cases (Median, IQR; mm2)
6.0 (12.4
The results of measurement of the BPVA, slit-lamp ex-
(95% CI)
to 10.4)
amination, and anterior segment photography with and
without fluorescein staining were recorded at the initial
presentation and on day 7 and day 30. The logarithm of
the minimal angle of resolution visual acuity values equal
Control Group
40.5 (12.5
to 59.7)
to 23.9)
(n ¼ 10)
12.6 (4.4
to or below the counting fingers level were recorded as fol-
lows: counting fingers, 1.7; hand movements, 1.8; light
perception, 1.9; and no light perception, 2.0. All anterior
9.1 (0 to 27.4)
.75
Median Difference
Bacterial Keratitis Cases (Median, IQR; mm2)
PACK-CXL group ¼ medical therapy plus photoactivated chromophore; Control group ¼ medical therapy alone.
used for the complication rates and BPVA (IBM SPSS sta-
tistics, Version 22.0; IBM Corp, Armonk, New York,
USA). An alpha value of 0.05 was considered significant.
21.7 (8.1 to 25.4)
8.6 (0 to 14.9)
Control Group
(n ¼ 5)
RESULTS
Group (n ¼ 7)
18.1 (13.6
PACK-CXL
to 44.6)
to 19.1)
0.8 (0.3
.66
to 6.36)
P Valuea
.50
.83
41.6 mm2) and 0.7 mm2 (IQR, 0–6.3 mm2), respectively;
TABLE 3. Areas of Epithelial Defect in Participants With Moderate to Severe Infectious Keratitis at Day 7 and Day 30 After Treating With Medical Therapy Plus Photoactivated the median sizes of the epithelial defects in the control
1.48 (33.7 to 0)
group were 16.9 mm2 (IQR, 6.3–39.5 mm2) and 4.6 mm2
Median Difference
Fungal Keratitis Cases (Median, IQR; mm2)
(IQR, 0–10.2 mm2), respectively. However, there were
5.3 (12.2
(95% CI)
to 0.62)
no significant (P ¼ .68 and P ¼ .41) differences between
the 2 groups. Subgroup analysis regarding etiology also
showed no significant differences (Table 3).
Therapeutic keratoplasty was performed in 2 cases in the
Control Group
34.4 (6.6
3.8 (0.7
to 47.1)
to 22.8)
(n ¼ 10)
.75
.52
Median Difference
to 16.87)
12.4 (7.23
(n ¼ 5)
DISCUSSION
Group (n ¼ 7)
PACK-CXL
to 44.23)
31.3 (14.1
.68
.41
23.0 (13.5
to 41.6)
FUNDING/SUPPORT: NO FUNDING OR GRANT SUPPORT. FINANCIAL DISCLOSURES: THE FOLLOWING AUTHORS HAVE NO
financial disclosures: Ngamjit Kasetsuwan, Usanee Reinprayoon, and Vannarut Satitpitakul. All authors attest that they meet the current ICMJE criteria
for authorship.