Faces (October 1984). By Frank Lovece. Reviews of former Pink Floyd bandmates Roger Waters' "The Pros and Cons of Hitch Hiking" and David Gilmour's "About Face"
Original Title
Record Reviews - Rogers Waters and David Gilmour albums
Faces (October 1984). By Frank Lovece. Reviews of former Pink Floyd bandmates Roger Waters' "The Pros and Cons of Hitch Hiking" and David Gilmour's "About Face"
Faces (October 1984). By Frank Lovece. Reviews of former Pink Floyd bandmates Roger Waters' "The Pros and Cons of Hitch Hiking" and David Gilmour's "About Face"
scorching riffs. “Lonely
as it tempers the raucous
energy of the latter with
soulful blues. Pat
McManus’ fiddle blends a
mournful, uncertainty into
the tune, as unexpected
and effective as finding a
Mike Bloomfield track on
Judas Priest.
“In The Heat Of The
Night” returns to the hard
stuff, with lyrics like
“Living it up/Tearing it
down/we're going crazy
cause we're out of
bounds” shot like bullets
out of an electric storm.
Tommy McManus makes
his cymbals scream and
his listeners wonder how
many Paistes he's made
Into donuts.
More than metalheads
will appreciate this power-
packed LP. intertwined
with fire and frenzy are
words and riffs you can
actually hear. Mama's
Boys are sons of tradi-
tional Irish folk musicians,
and their earliest gigs
catered to Cajun tunes
and jigs. Even with a turn-
about to hard rock,
Mama's Boys don’t
sacrifice the quality of
their melody to thunder
and chaos, as do some of
their metal competitors.
Instead they show the
depth and diversity of
metal at its best. This LP
convinced this critic to
keep an open mind to
hard rock, and to keep
Mama’s Boys spinning
steadily on the turntable.
—Brooke Sheffield Comer
ROGER WATERS
‘The Pros and Cons of
Hitch Hiking
(Columbia/CBS)
DAVID GILMOUR
‘About Face
(Columbia/CBS)
These two pieces of the
Pink Floyd jigsaw puzzle
58 FACES
—Iyricistivocalistichief-
conceptualist Waters and
lead guitarist Gilmour—
récently released their
first solo works in years
at roughly the same time.
The albums have less in
common with each other
than they do with Pink
Floyd, creating an in-
teresting disparity when
considered in the agoniz-
ingly rich context of Pink
Floyd's albums.
Gilmour's effort is the
more tuneful and light:
weight of the two. His
voice is certainly silkier
than Waters’, but less ex-
pressive. Coupled with his
and (on two songs) Pete
Townshend's uninspired
lyrics, the album is sur-
prisingly flat. Gilmour's in-
strumental arrangements
redeem About Face to a
great extent—notwith-
standing some blatant
Jackson Browne swipes—
and the album is a pretty
and pleasant throwaway.
Its saving grace is in
reminding us who makes
Waters’ dark Floyd visions
palatable enough not to
‘tum away from.
Waters, on his own,
proves less frightening
than one would imagine.
His scope is as big as
‘ever—Hitch Hiking is an
allegory of life-travel—but
he holds out hope at the
end, rather than that sick-
ness-unto-death, despair
Hitch Hiking is, in fact,
indred spirit with Bruce
Springsteen and beat-
novelist Jack Kerouac.
“The road is life,” wrote
ramblin’ Jack, and Spring-
steen rhapsodizes on fac-
ing up to the darkness
(taking risks) and driving
‘out of town (leaving the
secure, spiritually unful-
filling life to reach for
your dreams). There are
no conventional songs on
Waters’ album. Rather,
each side is a suite with
few aural or metaphorical
holes. Side one revolves
around courtship and
mating/marriage; side two
trips through the phases
of family, separation’
divorce, fucking around
and finally settling for
someone or something
just good enough to cut
through the loneliness
and form a wall against
despair. Compare this
outlook to Springsteen's
Nebraska, for instance,
or The River, where
deferred and forgotten
dreams are the price one
pays to survive.
Of the two albums,
Waters’ sounds more like
Pink Floyd, with even
quest guitarist Eric Clap-
ton substituting standard
Floyd sustained-notes for
his own chugging-blues
style. To ears accustomed
to Waters integrated with
the rest of the band, Hitch
Hiking sounds incom-
plete, though. Gilmour's
tunefulness would have
gone a long way toward
making this meditation
more hummable. Regard
less, if you're used to a.
diet of live-fast-die-young,
Hitch Hiking brings up
some of the unpleasant
possibilities you might
have to face if by some
chance you survive.
—Frank Lovece