You are on page 1of 6

DOI: 10.1111/1471-0528.

12943 Review article


www.bjog.org

Quality maternal and newborn care to ensure


a healthy start for every newborn in the World
Health Organization Western Pacific Region
H Obara, H Sobel
World Health Organization, Western Pacific Regional Office, Manila, Philippines
Correspondence: H Sobel, World Health Organization, Western Pacific Regional Office, PO Box 2932 (United Nations Avenue), 1000 Manila,
Philippines. Email sobelh@who.int

Accepted 6 June 2014.

In the World Health Organization Western Pacific Region, the Early Essential Newborn Care (EENC). The plan emphasises
high rates of births attended by skilled health personnel (SHP) the creation of an enabling environment for the
do not equal access to quality maternal or newborn care. ‘A practice of EENC; thereby, preventing 50 000 newborn deaths
healthy start for every newborn’ for 23 million annual births in annually.
the region means that SHP and newborn care providers give
quality intrapartum, postpartum and newborn care. WHO Keywords Asia, maternal, neonate, newborn, Pacific, preterm,
and the UNICEF Regional Action Plan for Healthy Newborn quality of care, World Health Organization.
Infants provide a platform for countries to scale-up

Please cite this paper as: Obara H, Sobel H. Quality maternal and newborn care to ensure a healthy start for every newborn in the World Health
Organization Western Pacific Region. BJOG 2014; 121 (Suppl. 4): 154–159.

Philippines 14, Vietnam 12 and China 9. Newborn deaths


Introduction
accounted for 55% of all children who died before the age
The World Health Organization (WHO) Western Pacific of five years. There are no estimates comparing NMR
Region (hereafter, the Region) has 37 countries and areas attended or not attended by SHP but clearly newborn
with approximately 1.8 billion people. In 2013, 23 million deaths occurred in both groups.
(17%) of the world’s 139 million live births took place in the
Region1 (Figure 1). Of these, 21 million (91.8%) had access
Critical moments for improving
to skilled health personnel (SHP) during birth while 2 mil-
quality of care
lion (8.2%) did not.2 SHP include ‘doctors, nurses or mid-
wives trained in providing lifesaving obstetric care, including Two-thirds of all newborn deaths occur in the first
giving the necessary supervision, care and advice to women three days of life,5 primarily due to complications of pre-
during pregnancy, childbirth and the postpartum period; to maturity and low birthweight, birth asphyxia and newborn
conduct deliveries on their own; and to care for newborns’.3 infections. International evidence suggests that there are
Obviously, improving the health of women and newborns several opportune moments during which prevention of
equitably necessitates improving access to SHP. The Lao newborn deaths is possible through provision of high-
People’s Democratic Republic (PDR), Papua New Guinea, quality routine care during labour, delivery and the imme-
Philippines, Solomon Islands, Cambodia, Vanuatu, Marshal diate postpartum period.6 Additional deaths can be pre-
Islands and Samoa have <90% of births attended by SHP.2 vented through simple actions for prevention and care of
A newborn baby dies every 2 minutes in the Western preterm, low-birthweight babies and sick newborns. Hence,
Pacific Region. In 2012, approximately 231 000 newborns the focus of attention needs to include not just the time
died within the first 28 completed days after birth, corre- after birth, but also the time during labour and delivery.
sponding to a neonatal mortality rate (NMR) of nine Hence, even where a high proportion of births are
deaths per 1000 live births.4 NMR varied between coun- attended by SHP there is a need to ensure that quality
tries: Lao PDR 27, Papua New Guinea 24, Cambodia 18, essential care is provided during all these critical moments.

154 ª 2014 Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists


Regional approach, a healthy start for every newborn

Births Newborns

Causes of newborn deaths

Access to SHP
2 million births - Preterm birth complicaƟons
8.2% a - Birth asphyxia
not aƩended by
- Neonatal infecƟons
SHP - Congenital abnormaliƟes
- Others
SHP: Skilled Health
Personnel
23 million live
231,000 newborn
births per year
deaths per year
(est. 2012) b (est. 2012) c

One newborn dies


Quality of Care

21 million births every two minutes


aƩended by SHP 91.8% a
Of those, 50,000
5.5 million births by C-secƟon
(24% of total births) a
newborn lives per year
will be saved if EENC
Sources: fully implemented.d
aGlobal Health Observatory, WHO, 2013
bWorld Population Prospects: The 2012 Revision, UN DESA, 2012
cTrend of Child Mortality 2013 Report, UNICEF, 2013
dCalculated using LiST, WHO, 2014

Figure 1. Births and newborns in the Western Pacific Region.

for decision-making; 3) the sequential order of early new-


The quality of care challenge
born care procedures not followed (e.g. delayed drying, too
In this article, we use the term ‘newborn care providers early cord-cutting, prioritising weighing baby rather than
(NCP)’ to include SHP, nurses, midwives, obstetricians, skin-to skin contact/initiation of breast feeding); 4) unnec-
paediatricians and inter-professional teams. However, NCP essary care provided, e.g. induction of labour and caesarean
may not be updated in early newborn care. Lay workers or section without maternal or fetal indication, routine episi-
family members often handle the newborn, but are not otomies, unnecessary suction of baby, forced breast feed-
included as NCP. ings when a baby is not ready, i.e. before feeding cues
As more than 90% of women and newborns have SHP occur; 5) skin-to-skin contact was not provided for babies
attending their births in the Region, the question increas- born by caesarean section. These substandard practices can
ingly becomes is the quality of care good? Do the annual result in death and illness of both mothers and babies. A
21 million SHP-attended live births have universal access review of newborn care clinical protocols in six countries
to quality of maternal and newborn care during the intra- in the Region demonstrated that only two were found to
partum and postpartum period by SHP and NCP? Do reflect WHO recommendations; however, both of these
5.5 million (24% of total) births by caesarean section needed updating.
annually have appropriate maternal or fetal indications?
Not all SHP and NCP provide Early Essential Newborn
Description of programme
Care (EENC). EENC Core interventions are outlined in
Figure 2. Full interventions can be found in the regional In consultation with member states and key development
plan.7 The United Nations Children’s Fund (UNICEF) partners, WHO and UNICEF jointly developed the Action
review of the Region highlighted that the quality of Plan for Healthy Newborn Infants in the Western Pacific
newborn care is generally substandard.8 Observational Region (2014–20) (Figure 3).7
studies9–11 identified the following common substandard This plan focuses on creating an enabling environment
practices: 1) newborns separated from mother (either left to support SHP and NCP to provide EENC. Improving
alone or passed to the family after the delivery); 2) fetal access to SHP during birth and the QoC during and imme-
heart rate not checked, partographs not completed or used diately after birth, could save an estimated 50 000 lives in

ª 2014 Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists 155


Obara, Sobel

Figure 2. Core early essential newborn care interventions.

Figure 3. Action plan for healthy newborn infants in the Western Pacific Region (2014–20).

the Region annually.12 Central to EENC is ‘The First


Country case studies
Embrace’—a protected and prolonged skin-to-skin cuddle
between mother and baby, which allows proper warming, Country case study 1—The Philippines
feeding and cord care. EENC also includes care of the A package of sequential and appropriately timed immediate
high-risk newborn, focusing on prevention and care of newborn care steps called ‘The First Embrace’ was devel-
babies born preterm, low birthweight babies and sick new- oped in 2009. This was used for both service provision
borns. (encouraging NCP to provide essential newborn care) and
Development of the regional plan drew on country expe- demand side (campaigning to increase client knowledge
riences, particularly those which led to changes in NCP and desirability of ‘The First Embrace’). The Department
routine practices at scale. of Health issued an administrative order to ensure that

156 ª 2014 Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists


Regional approach, a healthy start for every newborn

essential newborn care would be provided at all births. The 2014 targeted eight countries: Cambodia, China, Lao
administrative order provides steps for implementation and PDR, Mongolia, Papua New Guinea, Philippines, Solomon
defines roles and responsibilities for all levels of the health Islands and Vietnam. It revealed strengthened coun-
administration and health facilities. It defines and discour- try-level planning and implementation. EENC technical
ages unnecessary and substandard procedures. It also sets coordination groups were formed (six yes, one planned,
the path for health facility accreditation and ensures reim- one existing working group covers this), a full-time new-
bursement for national health insurance based upon imple- born health focal person was identified in the Ministries
mentation of the policy and protocol. In addition, the of Health (three yes, three planned, two no), the newborn
health professional curriculum and competencies were all health situation analysis was conducted (six yes, two no),
revised to reflect the latest standards. EENC national action plan was developed (three yes, two
Compared to only a low percentage of babies receiving ongoing or planned, three no), and clinical protocols were
skin-to-skin contact in 2008,9 in 2011, a nationwide popu- updated (two yes, four ongoing or planned, two no).
lation survey revealed that 65.6% of newborns in health Although still in the early implementation phase, progress
facilities were reportedly placed in skin-to-skin contact with was confirmed. Moreover, sharing the progress and the
their mothers.13 The factors associated with the increase experiences among these countries facilitates the imple-
may be: 1) all levels of health facilities, health administra- mentation in each country because country programmes
tions and wider stakeholders (e.g. professional may not want to lag behind. Monitoring will continue to
organisations) were involved and their roles in improving document how the national planning translates into
newborn care were defined; 2) a health-system-strengthen- improved quality of intrapartum and newborn care.
ing approach was taken to ensure essential drugs, commod-
ities, skilled health service providers, systems of referral,
Strengths
financing, supportive supervision, monitoring and evalua-
tion of progress as far as possible. A functional health The strengths of this regional programme include the
system with continuous health system support is critical to emphasis on when, what, who and how. The programme
sustain quality implementation of EENC by NCP. strategically targets the period from labour onset until
3 days after delivery (i.e. When); EENC interventions are
Country case study 2—Cambodia defined for all and for high-risk mothers and newborns
Changing entrenched newborn care practices requires using effective interventions based on scientific evidence7
changing the way training is done. Assessments revealed (i.e. What should be done). The programme emphasises
outdated newborn care practices remained although cost-effective interventions by discouraging common
training had been extensive.11 A 2-day coaching pro- unnecessary and substandard practices (e.g. unnecessary
gramme was conducted at local health facilities on induction of labour and caesarean sections) (i.e. What
immediate newborn care, based on adult learning princi- should not be done). The programme encourages identifi-
ples. Since 2011, it has been scaled up to reach more cation of programme coordinators and wider stakeholders
than half of all nationwide NCP beyond SHP. In the ses- in each country to effectively plan and implement EENC
sions, participants were first observed as they demon- (i.e. Who) and provides planning tools, a clinical pocket
strated what they normally did, then evidence around guide and social marketing tools, which countries can easily
the practice was explored. Participants repeatedly per- adapt (i.e. How). The regional programme has been
formed sequential immediate newborn care steps until planned in consultation with member states, jointly by
they were able to master these and could demonstrate WHO and UNICEF, for better coordination of implemen-
proficiency. Both the immediate evaluation and the tation and monitoring at both regional and country levels.
3-month supervisory visit afterwards showed remarkable The programme highlighted the need for the health system
improvement in knowledge and practice.11 to support improved access to SHP during birth and
improved access to quality newborn care by NCP, essential
drugs and commodities, effective supervision, referral, and
Current state of implementation
monitoring, infection control, and incorporation into
Newborn care programmes exist in most countries in the pre-service and in-service training curricula to ensure sus-
Region. After the member state consultation on the regio- tainability.
nal plan (March 2013), the increased momentum resulted
in strengthening national and regional implementation. In
Weaknesses
the 64th Regional Committee Meeting for the Western
Pacific in 2013, member states supported the regional Measuring some target indicators presents a challenge.
plan. The WHO/UNICEF joint monitoring as of January Baseline data for the subnational NMR and the proportion

ª 2014 Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists 157


Obara, Sobel

of births attended by SHP are not automatically available newborns. As tracking of resources is recommended by
in resource-limited countries. Therefore, the programme the Commission of Information and Accountability for
focuses on improving data availability for these indicators Women’s and Children’s Health, the Independent Expert
disaggregated by subnational level. The proposed target Review Group should oversee and verify whether govern-
indicators with disaggregated data will help in monitoring ments and partners commit as promised.
equity in countries. Monitoring EENC implementation in
health facilities requires practice and facility observation,
Conclusions
exit interviews and chart/record reviews to check the qual-
ity of intrapartum and newborn care. The regional pro- The Western Pacific Region boasts great improvements in
gramme includes tools and support to conduct this MDGs 4 and 5, but maternal and newborn health remain
monitoring. However, country-level evaluations will be ‘unfinished agendas’. Two possible trajectories depend on
resource intensive with obvious feasibility implications. national and global commitment. Diminished commitment
Simplified and standardised tools and methods for measur- will halt future improvements of women’s and newborns’
ing QoC and QoC indicators for intrapartum, postpartum health. Alternatively, ‘a healthy start for every newborn’
and newborn care need to be further explored at global, means that two million currently unattended births have
regional and country levels. improved access to SHP and all 23 million annual births
have quality intrapartum, postpartum and newborn care by
SHP and NCP.
Opportunities
Global initiatives and the new emphasis on newborns pro- Disclosure of interests
vide opportunities to catalyse country-level political com- The authors have no conflicts of interest to disclose.
mitment and momentum toward eliminating preventable
newborn deaths. Global initiatives include the United Contribution to authorship
Nations Global Strategy for Women’s and Children’s Both authors contributed equally to the design, drafting
Health, the ‘A Promise Renewed’ Initiative and the World and critical appraisal of this article.
Health Assembly Resolutions. In particular, the recent
Every Newborn Initiative has mobilised stakeholders and Details of ethics approval
partners to collaboratively develop the global Every New- Ethical approval was not required.
born Action Plan to End Preventable Deaths—launched in
June 2014.14 As the first WHO region to have developed a Funding
regional plan for newborn health in line with the global No funding was received for developing the manuscript.
plan, the early experiences aligned with and benefited from The regional newborn health programme has been funded
these global initiatives. It likewise contributed and shared by WHO, UNICEF, and grants from the Governments of
lessons learnt from the process of development and the re- Australia and Japan.
alisation of global initiatives.
Acknowledgements
The follow persons contributed information used in this
Threats
report: Dr Nabila Zaka (Maternal and Child Health Special-
In the Region, several countries are on-track toward ist, Young Survival & Development Section, UNICEF East
achieving Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) 4 and Asia Pacific Regional Office), Ministry of Health, Cambodia,
5.15 Consequently, policymakers and development partners Department of Health, the Philippines, Country office staff
may consider MDGs 4 and 5 ‘achieved’ and may nega- in UNICEF and WHO in the Region, Dr Mianne Silvestre
tively influence political commitment and funding for (Consultant Essential Intrapartum and Newborn Care), Dr
women and newborns domestically and internationally. John Murray (Consultant Newborn Health Programme
However, maternal and newborn mortality rates in low- Management), Professor Trevor Duke (Director of the Cen-
and middle-income countries are comparable to those of tre for International Child Health, University of Mel-
high-income countries (e.g. Japan) decades or even a cen- bourne), and Department of Maternal, Newborn, Child and
tury ago. Furthermore, there is a need to improve the Adolescent Health, WHO.
QoC for all 23 million births that occur every year in the
Region, even in high-income countries. Maternal and References
newborn health remain ‘unfinished agendas’. Stronger
1 Open database: world population prospects: the 2012 revision.
links are needed between the movement for universal
United Nations, Department of Economic and Social Affairs.
health coverage and improving the QoC for women and

158 ª 2014 Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists


Regional approach, a healthy start for every newborn

Population Division, Population Estimates and Projections Section. 9 Sobel HL, Silvestre MA, Mantaring JB, Oliveros YE, Nyuntu S.
[http://esa.un.org/wpp/unpp/panel_indicators.htm]. Accessed 29 Immediate newborn care practices delay thermo-
November 2013. regulation and breastfeeding initiation. Acta Paediatr
2 World Health Organization. World Health Statistics 2013. 2011;100:1127–33.
The Proportion of Births Attended by Skilled Health Personnel. 10 Sobel HL, Oliveros YE, Nyunt-U S. Secondary analysis of a national
(Data Year 2005–2012). Geneva: World Health Organization, health survey on factors influencing women in the Philippines to
2013. deliver at home and unattended by a healthcare professional. Int J
3 World Health Organization. Definition of the proportion of births Gynaecol Obstet 2010;111:157–60.
attended by skilled health personnel. WHO Global Health 11 Cambodia Ministry of Health, World Health Organization, and
Observatory. Indicator and Measurement Registry version 1.7.0. RACHA (Reproductive and Child Health Alliance). Report of Findings;
[http://apps.who.int/gho/indicatorregistry/App_Main/view_indicator. Coaching Sessions to Strengthen Immediate Newborn Care in 3
aspx?iid=25]. Accessed 29 November 2013. Operation Districts in Kampong Cham Province. Phnom Penh:
4 United Nations Children’s Fund. Trend of Child Mortality 2013 Ministry of Health Cambodia, 2012.
Report. New York, NY: United Nations Children’s Fund, 2013. 12 World Health Organization. The Estimate was Obtained Using LiST
5 World Health Organization. Special Tabulation of Demographic and (The Lives Saved Tool A Computer Program for Making Child
Health Survey in 43 countries (Data Year 2005–2011). Geneva: Survival Projections, Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public
World Health Organization, 2012. Health). Geneva: World Health Organization, 2014.
6 Darmstadt GL, Bhutta ZA, Cousens S, Adam T, Walker N, de Bernis 13 National Statistics Office, Republic of the Philippines. Family Health
L, Lancet Neonatal Survival Steering Team. Evidence-based, Survey 2011. Manila: National Statistics Office, Republic of the
cost-effective interventions: how many newborn babies can we Philippines, 2012.
save? Lancet 2005;365:977–88. 14 World Health Organization. Every newborn an action plan
7 World Health Organization. Action Plan for Healthy Newborn to end preventable deaths. [http://www.everynewborn.org/
Infants in the Western Pacific Region (2014–2020). Manila: World every-newborn-action-plan/] Accessed 1 August 2014.
Health Organization Regional Office for the West Pacific, 2014. 15 World Health Organization. Progress Report—MDGs 4 & 5
8 United Nations Children’s Fund. Comprehensive Newborn Care Maternal and Child Health. 64th Regional
Assessment of Newborn Care in Selected Countries. Bangkok: United Committee Meeting for the Western Pacific. Manila: World
Nations Children’s Fund East Asia and Pacific Regional Office, 2013. Health Organization Regional Office for the West Pacific,
[www.unicef.org/eapro/comprehensive_needs_assessment_of_newborn_ 2013. 6–7pp. [www.wpro.who.int/about/regional_committee/64/
care.pdf]. Accessed 29 November 2013. reports/en/]. Accessed 29 November 2013.

ª 2014 Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists 159

You might also like