Professional Documents
Culture Documents
MEDIA EFFECTS
THE PHILIPPINES
SURVEYS EXPERIMENTS
SO C IAL ROLE RHETORI C AL
ANALYSIS ANALYSIS
DEPTH PARTI C IPANT
INTERVIEWS OBSERVATION
MEDIA STUDIES
CONTROVERSIES
PROBLEMS WITH A C TIVE VERSUS
METHODOLOGY AND PASSIVE AUDIEN C E
MEDIA THEORY
Although the use of advanced A passive audience, in the most
methodologies can resolve many of extreme statement of this position,
the questions raised about various passively accepts the messages
theories, the fact remains that the that media send it. An active
use of these theories in public audience, on the other hand, is
debate generally follows a broader fully aware of media messages and
understanding. makes informed decisions about
how to process and interact with
media.
ARGUMENTS AGAINST
ARGUMENTS AGAINST USES AND
AGENDA-SETTING THEORY GRATIFI C ATIONS
THEORY
An agenda-setting study could The general presuppositions of the
connect the prevalence of a topic uses and gratifications theory have
in the media with later changes in drawn criticism. By assuming that
public policy and may conclude media fulfill a functional purpose
that the media set this agenda. in an individual’s life, the uses and
However, policy makers and gratifications theory implicitly
lobbyists often conduct public justifies and reaffirms the place of
relations efforts to encourage the media in the public sphere
creation of certain policies.
ARGUMENTS AGAINST
C ULTIVATION AND
ANALYSIS THEORY
ARGUMENTS AGAINST SPIRAL Critics have faulted cultivation
OF SILENCE THEORY analysis theory for relying too
heavily on a broad definition of
Although many regard the spiral of
violence.
silence theory as useful when
applying its broadest principles, it
is weak when dealing with MEDIA BIAS
specifics. For example, the A good example of the ways that
phenomenon of the spiral of media can bolster political opinion
silence is most visible in individuals is through coverage, which leads to
who are fearful of social isolation. the debate over media bias
POLITI C S AND MEDIA MEDIA DE C EN C Y
STUDIES
Media theories and studies afford a Decency standards in media have
variety of perspectives. When long been an issue, and they
proponents of a particular view continue to change in ways that
employ those theories and studies, are not necessarily predictable. As
however, they are often media studies have progressed,
oversimplified and can result in they have increasingly appeared in
contradictory claims. the debates over decency
standards. Although media studies
cannot prove a word or image is
indecent, they can help discern the
impact of that word or image and,
thus, greatly influence the debate.