Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract
1
stress treatment inhibited growth (fresh weight), nitrogen fixation
(nitrogenase activty) and protein content of Azolla plants. The inhibitory
levels of salinity were about 0.6-0.8 % NaCl. Growth and nitrogen
fixation of Azotla plants were signifcantly inhibited at higher levels (2.4
moini3 and 5.1 molm3) of combined nitrogen (ammonium sulphate and
urea). The ccophysiological significance of Azolla existed in freshwater
habitats of Beni-Sucf Govcrnoratc is discussed.
Introduction
Azolla plants have been introduced into Egypt since 20 years ago
as green manures. The high cost of mineral nitrogen has encouraged the
use of Azo/la-nitrogcn to substitute mineral nitrogen in rice fields (EL-
BASSEL et al. 1994, YANNI et al. 1994). It is bcleived that at least five
species of Azolla have ivaded the freshwater bodies of the northern
govcrnorates of the Nile Delta few years ago (EL-HADIDI & FAY~’ED
1995), the fern continued fast wide spread up to the extent that it is now
observed floating on most stagnant water of drainage canals of the Nile
Delta (ABD-ALLA ct a!. 1994, YANNI et al. 1994, ELHADIDI &
FAYED 1995). The growth of Azolla in drainage canals forms thick mat
so that about 2 to 5 kg of fresh Azolla can be collected up from a square
meter of water surface (YANNI ct al. 1994). However, this heavy
vegetation of Azolla has created a serious problem due to water loss by
cvapotranspiration and mechanical obstruction of irrigation and drainage
canals. An extensive survey of the occurrence of Azolla fern at freshwater
habitats of BcniSuef district was started at 1994, the fern was observed
floating in several canals and drains in the district. Farmers collect Azolla
to feed their birds, and sometimes usc it as weed, especially when Azolla
2
forming thick mats which disrupt the irrigation streams and clog pumps
when propagation of Azolla is in its maximal value in warm season.
3
1980, PLAZINSKI 1990). The micronutricnts such as iron, cobalt and
molybdenum, which have been shown to be essential for the nitrogen-
fixing process, must also be present in adequate supply in waters where
the fern grows (MOORE 1969, PLAZINSKI 1990).
4
Materials and Methods
5
Freshwater environment: The concentration of dissolved 02 was
measured monthly the surface water at a depth reach to 10 cm in an
irrigation drain. Measurements were taken under or near the Azolla plants
by using aquamcter (Oxygen meter) N 5011 T, Electronic Works TEL-
EKO, Poland. The pH of freshwater was measured monthly by using
combined pH electrode, Electronic Works TEL-EKO, Poland. The water
temperature was measured monthly for one year by using the same
aquameter. The air temperature (day and night) was daily recorded in a
Mctrological station at Bcni-Sucf district.
6
mol m-3, CaC12.2H2O 1.0, MgSO4.7H2O 1.65, K2504 0.5, NaH2PO4.2H2O
0.65, and in m mol m-3, FcSO4.7H20 27, MnCl2.4H2O 1.1, CuSO4.5H2O
0.08, ZnSO4.7H20 0.19, NaMoO4.2H2O 0.05, H3BO3 5.8, pH was adjusted
to 7.0. The nutrient medium supplemented with four levels (0.2 %, 0.4 %,
0.6 and 0.8 %) of NaC1 equivalent to about 35, 70, 100 and 120 mol m~
NaCI. The salt-treated plants were compared with the control plants (no
salt added to the medium). The Azolla plants were cultured in small (7 cm
diameter) plastic pots, which were left at room temperature (26-28 °C) for
up to 7 days. Ten replicat were prepared for each treatment and kept in
randomized blocks. Five to ten plants (equal to 7 grams) of fresh Azolla
plants were cultured in each pot. Growth of Azolla was measured by
weighing a blot-dried fresh plants harvested after 1 to 7 days of treatment.
7
bottle and injected into ATI Unicome 610 Series Gas Chromatograph with
a flame ionization detector and a 5 ft. x 1/8 inch glass column of
8
activated alumina (80-100 mesh) at a temperature of 150 °C. The
carrier gas was nitrogen at a flow rate of 10 psi. The protein content was
determined for Azolla plants cultured for seven days under the same
conditions of salt stress. An oven-dried (85 °C) plant material was used
for protein analysis. Growth (fresh weight) and nitrogenasc activity
(acetylene reduction) of Azolla-Anabaena symbiosis were determined for
plants cultivated under treatment with combined nitrogen (ammonium
sulphate and urea) in nitrogen-free nutrient medium. Azolla plants were
culivated in plastic pots under the same conditions used for salt stress
treatment experiment. Three levels (100, 200 and 300 ppm) equal to 0.8,
1.6, 2.4 mol m3 (ammonium sulphate) and 1.7, 3.4, 5.1 mol m~ (urea)
were tested. The plants were left under treatment for 7 days.
9
Azolla fern, the cavities which containing the endophytc cyanobacterium
symbiont (Anabaena azollae) were observed. The cyanobactcrium
endophyte grows as a filament or trichome (thread) of cells (Fig. I b). The
trichome is unbranched and uniscriate. Two types of cells were
recognized in the cyanobacterium trichome, the vegetative cells and the
hcterocysts (Fig. ib).
10
multiseptate glochidia (SEVENSON 1944). The frond morphology and
other vegetative characteristics of the Azolla ecotype in this study are
very similar to that of A. mexicana and A. microphylla, the two species
also have multiseptate glochidia with a terminal anchor-shaped structure
(TAN et al. 1986). Furthermore, the Azolla ecotype is found to propagate
actively at temperature ranged between 30-37 °C, a character which
distinctive to the species to A. microphylla (TUNG &-WATANABE
1983). The similarity between the Azolla ecotype and each of A.
microphylla and A. mex/cana in some vegetative, reproductive and
physiological characteristics suggests that the species may be a sterile
hybrid of these two species. Hybrids of Azolla have been reported to be a
sterile forming only microsporocarps and may show new vegetative
characteristics not present in the parents (VAN CAT et al. 1989).
11
major factors affecting growth and hiomass yield of Azolla plants. It has
been reported (LUMPKIN & PLUCKNETT 1982) that high temperature
is considered a problem for the use of Azolla in the tropics, however, a
temperature-tolerant strains of Azolla were found among A. in/erophylla
and A. pinnata; these plants have showed good growth for 6 weeks at
37/29 ° C (TUNG & WATANABE 1983). The ecotype examined in this
study is, therefore a temperature tolerant, being produced high biomass in
warm seasons. The biomass production in Azolla is directly related to the
rate of growth and nitrogen fixation of Azolla-Anahaena symbiosis
(ThING & WATANABE 1 983). The biomass is usually influenced by a
range of environmental factors, the temperature arid low phosphorus
concentration are probably the most important. Since Azolla plants are
living in association with an endophyte cyanobacteriuni, the tolerance to
high temperature by Azolla-Anahaena symbiosis is determined both in
the host fern and the symbiontAnabaena (WATANABE et al. 1989).
12
Biomass production was determined for Azolla plants grown in an
irrigation drain, the contents of chlorides, carbonates, bicarbonates,
suiphates and total soluble salts, and the pH, were determined monthly in
drain water (data not shown). The higher biomass yield of Azolla in warm
seasons coincided with higher contents of total soluble salts (0.06-0.08
%), CF (0.007-0.11 %), HC03 (0.018-0.034 %), S04 (0.020-0.027), and
with high pH (7.37-8.01). The Azolla species under investigation was
tolerant to different salts or ions (e.g. S04~, HC03 and CL) in drain water,
since the higher biomass yield coincided with the highest levels of these
salts. I-ugh biomass yield and high concentration of anions and salts were
in warm seasons, the increase in salt and anion concentration may be
attributed to high evaporation rate in warm seasons. Higher
concentrations of the cations Na+ and K+, and also of phosphorus were
found in drain water (data not shown), the values ranged between 27-52
ppm, 7-8 ppm and 6-7 ppm, respectively.
13
concentration of any element in water is not an indication to the
concentration of the same element in plant tissues of Azolla. ROTHER &
WHITTON (1988) found that no significant relationship was found
between the concentration of the element in Azolla plants and that in the
water. The higher biornass yield of Azolla plants in this study may be
explained partly on the basis of higher mineral content in plant tissues.
The production of low biomass by some Azolla spesies (e.g. A. pinnata)
was attributed to phosphorus deficiency (AL! & WATANAI3E 1986).
Those authors suggested that the critical level of P in water which might
affect growth of Azolla is about 0.1 ppm. Therefore, the P level (about 6
and 7 ppm), in freshwater of the drain appear to be not a limiting factor to
the growth of Azolla. On the other hand, Azolla plants may use the
accumulated minerals as growth regulators, since it has been reported (AL! &
WATANABE 1986) that aquatic plants grown in flooded soils may use the
elements Zn, K, P, and Ca, as growth regulating elements. These findings may
explain the reasons for Azolla plants to absorb high amounts of these
minerals. The high mineral content of Azolla plants may have a significant
importance because the fern is usually used as a green manure in many
countries of the world. These minerals and also N (accumulated after
symbiotic N2 fixation) became available to plants, e.g., rice in flooded
soils, only after Azolla mineralization. The rate of decomposition and
mineralization of Azolla may affects its efficiency as a bio-fertilizer.
14
Azolla in waste water was determined and compared to another set of
Azol/a grown in N-free nutrient culture (data not shown). About 5 grams
fresh Azolla were cultivated in each treatment, fresh weight of Azolla was
increased to 5.16 g after 7 days in nutrient media and decreased to 3.66 g
in waste water. Current research in pollution control has been directed
toward removing nutrients (e.g. N and P) and minerals (e.g. Zn, Ni, Cu,
etc.) discharged into streams from sewage treatment plants (SHIOMI &
KITOH 1987). Various aquatic plants have been used to remove nutrients
and minerals from contaminated freshwater and also waste water, among
these plants E/ehhorn/a (CORNWELL et al. 1977), Lemna (HARVEY &
FOX 1973, ABDEL-HAMMEED 1993), ipornea (HASHIMOTO 1983),
and Azolla (KITOH et al. 1993), which was recently used to treat waste
water. Azolla plants may need the absorbed minerals (e.g., iron) for
growth and other activities, it has been found (RAINS & TALLEY 1979)
that the critical iron concentration in ~vatcr for Azolla growth is about
20mg L~ The levels of iron determined in freshwater in this study was
about 40 mg U’ and waste water 90 mg L-’. Although Azolla plants were
tolerant to waste water treatment for one week, growth was reduced by~
about 30 %. Waste or polluted water treatment was found to reduce
growth and nitrogen fixation of A. fil/eulo/a’es (KITOH et a!. 1993).
Those authors attributed the reduction in growth and nitrogen fixation to
phosphorus deficiency. In this study, the concentration of phosphorus in
waste water was about 0.650 %, therefore, it is not limiting. The
reduction in growth may be attributed to the accumulation of toxic
minerals in tissues of Azolba. The results underline that Azolla plants
may be used to purify polluted water (fresh or waste) for recycling.
15
(measured as fresh weight) of Azolla was significantly inhibited by about
20-40 %, 35-55 %, and 50-63 % after one, two and three days of salt
treatment, respectively (Table 4). The higher levels of salt (0.6 % and 0.8
%) were more inhibitory to growth than moderate levels (0.2 % and 0.4
%). The nitrogen-fixing activity (acetylene reduction) was also
determined for Azolla-Anabaena symbiosis under the sanic conditions of
salinity. Nitrogcnase activity was increased after exposure to salt
treatment for 1 8 h (data not shown), however, long-term treatment by salt
(7 days) significantly inhibited nitrogenase activity by about 90 % at 0.6
% NaCl (Table 5). The activity was completely inhibited after 7 days of
salt (0.8 % NaCl) treatment. in this study, young plants exhibited higher
nitrogenase activity compared to mature (sporulated) plants (Table 5).
The effect of salt stress on growth and nitrogen fixation of Azolla may be
reflected on their protein content; the salt stress treatments (0.2, 0.4 and
0.6 % NaCl) significantly inhibited the protein content in Azolla plants by
about 15 %, 27 % and 50 %, respectively (Table 5).
16
stress, a significant reduction in activity was indicated after 7 days of salt
treatment. Salt stress treatment (0.10 96 NaC1 and 0.1 5 96 Na2 SO4) has
also been reported (HERZ-ALLA 1991) to reduce nitrogcnase activity of
A. pinnata. The N content of A. Jiliculo ides was reduced when salt
concentration was increased from 0.3 96 to 0.9 96 (GE SF11-AN et al.
1980). The sensitivity of growth and nitrogen fixation of AzollaAnabaena
symbiosis to salt stress may be attributed to Na~ toxicity, it has been
found (RAHOMA 1985) that the total N content of Azolla was increased
with increasing the dilution of drainage water to reduce Na~
concentration. The salt-tolerance of Azolla plants was studied further by
testing the ability of the fern to absorb nutrients or salts from saline water
and salty soil (data not shown). When Azolla plants were grown in
nutrient solution containing about 0.6 96 NaC1, the plants were able to
remove about 24 96 of salts after five days of growth. Azolla plants were
also cultivated in salty soils with salinity up to 1.8 96 and 3.3 96, the fern
succeeded to withstand in the first soil (1.8 % salinity) for one week and
recovered about 27 96 of salts from the soil, but the plants that were
cultivated in the highly saline soil (3.3 96 salt) died after 2 days. The
Azolla ecotype showed better salt tolerance and ability to withstand in
saline environments than other Azolla species. It has been reported
(HALLER et al. 1974) that Azolla plants were died when cultured in soil
containing about 1 .3 96 salts (about 33 96 of sea water). Other species of
Azolla reduced water salt content by about 0.0 12-0.049 96 and soil salt
content by about 0.014-0.485 96 (see LUMPKIN and PLUCKNUTT
1980). The ecotype of Azolla under investigation may be used to purify
salt-contaminated water and soil, and it is suggested that the fern can be
cultivated in habitats with moderate salinity such a.s some irrigation
drains and flooded rice fields.
17
The growth and nitrogenase activity of Azolla-Anabaena symbiosis
were determined for plants grown in N-free nutrient solution in the
presence of ammonium sulphate and urea (Table 6). Generally, growth of
Azolla plants was reduced as the concentration of combined nitrogen
increased. The application of ammonium sulphate and urea at 100 ppm
reduced slightly growth of Azolla plants, however, higher levels (200 and
300 ppm) of ammonium sulphate and urea signifieatly inhibited growth
of Azolla by about 26 % and 32 %, and 32 % and 42 %, respectively
(Table 6). Nitrogenase activity (acetylene reduction) was significantly
reduced as the concentration of combined nitrogen increased (Table 6),
the activity was reduced by about 52 % and 82 % at 100 and 200 ppm
ammonium sulphate, and by 68 % and 86 % at 100 and 200 ppm urea,
respectively. The Azolla fern failed completely to fix nitrogen
(nitrogenase activity) at higher levels (300 ppm) of combined nitrogen
(ammonium sulphate and urea. Table 6). It has been found that the
nitrogen-fixing Azolla-Anahaena symbiosis is much more tolerant to
combined nitrogen in the medium than that of free-living eyanobaeterium
Anahaena species (ITO & WATANABE 1983). The nitrogen-fixing
symbiotic cyanobacterium is enclosed in a leaf cavity, therefore, it is not
in direct contact with an exogenous growth medium (KITOH & SHIOMI
1995). The presence of ammonium in the medium, however, is
unfavourable for growth and nitrogen fixation of Azolla-Anabaena
symbiosis, except when the concentrations are very low, about 10 mol m3
(MEEKS et al. 1987, KITOH & SHIOMI 1991, SHIOMI & KITOH
1993). Azolla plants were completely lost their nitrogen-fixing ability and
practically ceased to grow in a medium containing 20 mol m~ ammonia
(KITOFI & SHIOMI 1991). In this investigation, the Azolla-Anabaena
symbiosis is tolerant to treatment with ammonium sulphate and urea,
presumably because the concentrations used were slightly lower (about
18
2.4 and 5.1 mol m3, respectively). In addition, Azolla species may be
varied for their tolerance to combined nitrogen, tolerant strains of A.
caroiin~ana, A. mexicana, A. microphylla and A. p~nnafa were selected
(KITOH & SHIOMI 1991, 1995). The eeotype of Azolla studied can be
considered as a tolerant species to combined nitrogen, the levels used (2.4
mol m3 ammonia and 5.1 mol m3 urea) might equal to the levels of
nitrogen fertilizers sometimes added to rice fields.
Acknowledgements
References
19
Soil Sci. Plant nut. 32: 239 - 253.
20
Ph.D. Thesis, Zagazig University (Benha Branch), Egypt.
21
193: 265 -275.
22
Rahoma, A. T. M. (1985): Relation of Azol/a with some ecological
factors. M. Sc. Thesis, Alexandria University, Egypt.
Tryon, & Tryon, A. F. (1982): Ferns and allied plants, with special
reference to tropical America. Springer-Verlag, New York.
23
Anahaena azollae symbiosis: growth and nitrogen fixation. New
Phytol. 87: 743 -749.
24
Table I : Monthly variation in bioniass (Fresh or dry weight m 2 ~ of Azolla
plants naturally grow in an irrigation drain in relation to variation in
temperature and dissolved oxygen.
25
LSD at 1 ¾ 4.93 (biomass)
26
Table 2: Element analysis (%) of Azolla and freshwater (irrigation
drain ), where plants were grown.
Cu
Fe 0.003 0.004
Ni 0.004 1.156
Pb 0.138 0.022
Zn - 0.029
0.003 0.112
27
Table 3 : Uptake of minerals from waste water by Azol/a after one
week of treatment.
Cu 0.002 0.002
Fe 0.009 0.007
Mn 0.002 0.002
Ni - -
Zn 0.029 0.009
P 0.65 0.550
28
Table 4: Effect of salt stress on growth (Fresh weight) of Azolla
grown in nitrogen free nutrient solution.
-
Control (No salts) 7.3 ±o.ih 7.3 ±0.1 8.3 ±0.2 5.9±0.1
0.2 % (35 mol m~) 7.1 ± 0.1 6.7 ± 0.1 6.5 ± 0.03 4.0 ± 0.02
0.4% (70 mol mj 5.8 ± 0.1 4.6 ± 0.1 3.6 ± 0.2 2.7 ± 0.1
0.6% (100 mol n13) 4.7 ± 0.1 3.3 ± 0.4 2.9 ± 0.07 1.6 ± 0.1
0.8 % (120 mol m3) 4.6 ± 0.3 3.1 ± 0.04 2.8 ± 0.1 1.3 ± 0.3
LSD at 5% 0.50 0.96 0.59 0.74
LSD at 1% 0.71 1.37 0.85 1.05
29
Table 5: Effect of salt stress on nitrogenase activity (acetylene
reduction) and protein content of Azolla anahaena symbiosis grown in
nitrogen-free nutrient solution for 5 days.
Acetylene reduction
30
Table 6 : Effect of combined nitrogen (ammonium sulphate and
urea) on growth (gm fresh weight) and nitrogenase activity (acetylene
reduction, n moles C2 H4 / g fresh weight / hr) of Azolla after one week of
treatment in nitrogen - free culture medium.
Nitrogenase activity
Ammonium sulphateC 463 ± 3.59 220 ± 083 ± none 26.65 40.40
10.2 7.8
Urea 463 ±3.59 150 ± 066 ± none 9.79 4.84
6.27 2.04
[3] Molar concentrations of ammonium are: 0.8. 1.6 and 2.4 molm 3, and
of urea: 1.7, 3.4 and 1 molni -3, which correspond to 100, 200, and
300 ppm, respectively.
31
Figure Legends
32