Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Sheldon Magder
McGill University Health Centre, Montreal, Quebec, Purpose of review
Canada
Interactions between the heart and lungs are magnified in patients undergoing
Correspondence to Sheldon Magder, Royal Victoria mechanical ventilation and the consequences of these interactions always need to be
Hospital, 687 Pine Av W, Canada H3A 1A1
E-mail: sheldon.magder@muhc.mcgill.ca considered when managing ventilated patients. In patients with normal lungs and normal
cardiovascular function monitoring needs are minimal, but when oxygenation and
Current Opinion in Critical Care 2011,
17:36–42
cardiac function are compromised careful assessment of the consequences of changes
in ventilator settings needs to be considered to ensure that adequate oxygen delivery is
maintained.
Recent findings
Primary determinants of heart–lung interactions are first reviewed and then approaches
to the use of simple hemodynamic measurements such as respiratory variations in
central venous and pulmonary artery occlusion, or arterial pressure are described for
assessing oxygen delivery, volume responsiveness as well as indicators of ventilatory
mechanics.
Summary
Use of simple measurements available during routine monitoring can be very helpful to
the informed clinician for optimizing hemodynamic performance as well as patient
ventilator interactions.
Keywords
arterial pressure, central venous pressure, heart–lung interaction, pleural pressure,
preload
Copyright © Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Hemodynamic monitoring in the mechanically ventilated patient Magder 37
Figure 1 Graphical solution of the interaction of venous return of the transducer relative to the region being measured.
curve (upper left) and cardiac function curve (upper right) define
The pressure that accounts for stretching of vascular
the ‘working’ cardiac output, venous return and right atrial
pressure (Pra) values structures is called transmural pressure and is equal to
the pressure inside a vessel minus the pressure outside
the vessel of interest. When vascular structures are not in
Venous return Cardiac function the chest, the pressure outside the vessel is atmospheric
pressure which was used to zero the transducer. However,
this is not true for vascular structures in the chest for they
are surrounded by pleural pressure and pleural pressure
changes relative to atmospheric pressure during the
Pra
ventilation cycle. During spontaneous inspiratory efforts
Pra
pleural pressure becomes negative relative to atmos-
pheric pressure, which means that the pressure in the
Working values heart decreases relative to atmosphere too. This is the
equivalent of lowering the heart relative to the rest of the
body and increases the pressure gradient for the return of
blood to the heart. On the contrary, on the left side of the
heart, the lower surrounding pressure relative to atmos-
Q ¼ flow. phere must be overcome by the ejecting heart, which
means the afterload on the left ventricle is increased
during ejection. The opposite occurs with positive pres-
to height relationship in a bathtub) and the resistance sure breathing. A positive pressure breath raises the
draining this region (equivalent to the hydraulic resist- pressure in the heart relative to the rest of the body
ance in the drain of the bathtub). A key point is that not and thereby decreases the return of blood to the right
all volume in the vasculature stretches the vascular walls; heart. It also lowers the afterload on the left ventricle
the bathtub equivalent in the body has the opening on during the ejection phase. The normal gradient for
the side of the tub instead of at the bottom. The volume venous return from the venous reservoir to the heart is
that stretches the walls of the vessels, which is the only in the range of 4–8 mmHg, which means that even
equivalent to the volume of water above the opening small increases in pleural pressure can significantly alter
in a bathtub, is called stressed volume, and the volume the gradient for venous return and this process generally
below the opening unstressed volume. Only stressed dominates the effect of inspiration on the heart. Two
volume contributes to the return of blood to the heart processes can compensate for the decreased gradient for
and normally about 30% of vascular volume is stressed venous return when pleural pressure is positive. One is an
[5]. The relationship of total volume (stressed and increase in blood volume. Clinically this occurs by the
unstressed) to pressure is called capacitance [5,6]. Impor- physician giving a bolus of intravenous of fluid, but also
tantly, unstressed volume can be converted into stressed occurs over time by salt retaining mechanisms in the
volume by contraction of smooth muscle in vascular walls; kidney. The second is contraction of venous capacitance
this is called a decrease in capacitance. Cardiac function vessels and the conversion of unstressed volume into
and venous return can be plotted together because they stressed volume [8–11]. This process can increase stressed
both have flow on the Y-axis and Pra on the X-axis (Fig. 1) volume by 10–15 ml/kg and happen almost immediately;
and this provides a graphical solution for their interaction. it is the body’s way of producing an auto-transfusion.
When these two functions intersect gives the working Importantly, removal of venous tone can remove this
cardiac output, working Pra and working venous return effective volume almost immediately.
[3].
The second major factor affecting cardiac output is
One more concept needs to be understood before related to lung inflation. For lung inflation to occur
explaining the effect of ventilation on cardiac output. alveolar pressure must increase relative to pleural pres-
Vascular pressures obtained with the usual fluid-filled sure. Whereas the heart is surrounded by pleural pres-
catheters are made relative to an external reference [7]. sure, pulmonary vessels situated between alveolae are
First the transducer is opened to air so that changes in surrounded by alveolar pressure and these vessels are
pressure are made relative to the surrounding atmos- compressed by lung inflation. This effect is trivial when
pheric pressure, which is called zero for the purpose of pulmonary venous pressure is greater than alveolar pres-
the measurement. Second the transducer must be leveled sure because the blood in vessels is not easily compres-
at an agreed-upon physical position because the mass of sible. However, when alveolar pressure is greater than the
fluid in the fluid-filled measuring device adds a pressure downstream pulmonary venous pressure, the soft-walled
to the transducer, which is dependent upon the position veins collapse with lung inflation creating West zone II
Copyright © Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
38 Respiratory system
[12]. When this occurs alveolar pressure becomes the ready accessibility of blood pressure measurements, it is
downstream pressure for pulmonary flow and the load on important to appreciate the limitations of the measure-
the right ventricle goes up with lung inflation. If the lung ment. Lack of a fall in blood pressure with an increase in
is in West zone II the load on the heart increases 1 : 1 with positive pressure does not mean that cardiac output did
the increase in alveolar pressure. Because vessel collapse not fall for neuro-humeral reflexes can quickly increase
occurs downstream from the venous compliant region of systemic vascular resistance and maintain or even
the lung, West zone II conditions will also result in back- increase blood pressure when cardiac output falls. A fall
up of blood in the pulmonary vessels and can contribute in blood pressure is thus fairly specific, but not sensitive
to increased lung water. for detecting a fall in cardiac output.
Copyright © Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Hemodynamic monitoring in the mechanically ventilated patient Magder 39
the transmural pressure of the heart is less than the output provides important information for the manage-
apparent value on the monitor. As a general rule, when ment for, as already discussed, it ultimately is not arterial
the lungs are normal, a little less than half of the airway saturation that is important but rather delivery of oxygen
pressure is applied to the pleural space. When lungs are to tissues. When there is a large pulmonary shunt, a low
diseased the fraction is smaller. As an example in some- cardiac output also can impact on arterial O2. This occurs
one on 20 cmH2O of PEEP and who has moderately because mixed venous O2 saturation falls with a decrease
diseased lungs, the pleural pressure likely is increased in cardiac output so that shunted venous blood to the
by around 8 cmH2O or close to 7 mmHg relative to arterial side has a greater impact on arterial O2 content.
atmospheric pressure. This would mean that a CVP of Measurement of central or mixed venous O2 content is
15 mmHg relative to atmospheric pressure only gives an useful in these cases and when very low, can indicate
actually 8 mmHg distension force on the ventricular wall. that increasing cardiac output will increase arterial
However, the capillaries in the periphery at the same oxygenation.
level of the heart are exposed to the 15 mmHg pressure
and another 4–8 mmHg to account for the resistance drop
from the periphery to the heart, which brings the value in Diagnostic uses of ventilatory variation in
these vessels to 19–23 mmHg; this is in the range in vascular pressure waves
which net increased fluid filtration into the interstitial Respiratory variations in central venous pressure
space is expected. In capillaries on the dorsal surface of When pleural pressure falls with a spontaneous inspi-
the patients, another 7 cm on average must be added [16] ration the pressure in the heart also falls relative to
to account for the hydrostatic pressure added relative to atmospheric pressure if there is no change in cardiac
the heart and this brings the pressure to around 26– volume and in the graphic representation, the cardiac
30 mmHg in these vessels. Thus even though a high function curve moves to the left of the venous return
cardiac filling pressure might increase cardiac output in a curve (Fig. 2). This includes spontaneous efforts that
patient with high PEEP, the price to be paid is increased trigger mechanical breaths in all demand modes. When
transudation of plasma fluid into the interstitial space. the heart is functioning on the ascending portion of the
cardiac function curve, CVP falls relative to atmosphere
When PEEP values are high and PaO2/FiO2 low and and output from the right heart increases (Fig. 2a). How-
arterial O2 saturation is low, measurement of cardiac ever, when the heart is functioning on the flat part of the
Figure 2 Interaction of venous return and cardiac function curves with respiratory variations
(a) Shows that a spontaneous, negative (ve) pressure breath moves the cardiac function curve to the left of the cardiac function curve (symbols are
the same as in Fig. 1). When the venous return curve intersects the ascending part of the cardiac function curve a breath decreases Pra and increases
right-sided output (left upper) but when the venous return curve intersects the flat part of the cardiac function curve, there is no change in Q. (b) Shows
the changes with positive pressure breaths. In this case inspiration moves the cardiac function curve to the right. When the venous return curve
intersects the flat part of the cardiac function curve, positive pressure is expected to decrease Q (left lower) but when it intersects the flat part of the
curve there is potentially no change in Q or Pra until the cardiac function curve is shifted sufficiently to the right (lower right). These predictions are
weaker than those for predicting fluid responsiveness in (a) because of reflex adjustments to cardiac and return functions.
Copyright © Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
40 Respiratory system
(a) Shows respiratory variations in pulmonary artery occlusion pressure (Ppao) with spontaneous inspiratory efforts. The line marks the appropriate
place to make the measurement. (b) Shows examples of Ppao and CVP with positive pressure breaths and no spontaneous effort. (c) shows an
example of a spontaneous effort with a marked active expiration which increases the pressures throughout expiration. The lines at the bottom indicate
inspiration. The line on the CVP tracing suggests an appropriate place for the measurement; although it is early in expiration, it occurs before the major
push. The fall in CVP with the onset of inspiraton does not necessarily indicate fluid responsiveness in this case because it is due to release of a positive
pressure. (d) Shows an example of active expiration when the effort decreases throughout the expiratory phase. The value at end-expiration in the
middle breath is lower than the other two because the breath is longer and there is more time for expiration. In this example, even after the active
expiration there still seems to be a fall in CVP suggesting fluid responsiveness.
cardiac function curve, there is no change in CVP or right PEEP although the predictive value is not as strong as is
heart output (Fig. 2b). Thus the ventilatory pattern of the case for the assessment of volume responsiveness
CVP gives an indication as to whether the heart is [18]. Patients who have an inspiratory fall in CVP would
functioning on the ascending or flat part of the cardiac be expected to always have a fall in cardiac output with
function curve [17]. An inspiratory fall in CVP indicates PEEP (Fig. 2c), but this is not the case because reflex
that the heart is on the ascending portion of the cardiac adjustments in venous capacitance as well as ventricular
function curve and may or may not respond to volume function can maintain cardiac output [19,20]. Patients
depending how close CVP is to the plateau, whereas lack who have no inspiratory fall in CVP with PEEP should
of an inspiratory fall indicates that the heart is functioning not have a fall in cardiac output unless the increase in
on the flat part of the cardiac function curve and will not PEEP is sufficient to move the cardiac function curve far
respond to a volume infusion (Fig. 3). This test is most enough to the right so that the venous return curve again
useful in the negative; that is lack of an inspiratory fall in intersects the ascending part of the cardiac function curve
CVP indicates that the cardiac output will not respond to in which case cardiac output will fall (Fig. 2d).
volume. There are a few caveats for the use of this test.
There must be an adequate inspiratory effort. An increase Respiratory variations in arterial pressure and stroke
in the ‘y’ descent does not constitute an inspiratory fall in volume
CVP; there needs to be a fall in the whole wave form Currently very popular techniques for assessing volume
which is best assessed at the base of the ‘a’ wave. One responsiveness are the assessment of respiratory vari-
must be careful to not confuse the fall in CVP from the ations in arterial pressure including systolic or pulse
release of an active expiration for an inspiratory fall in pressure or stroke volume [21,22]. During the inspiratory
CVP (Fig. 3). It also must be appreciated that the phase of an unassisted mechanical breath, the rise in
inspiratory rise in CVP with a mechanical breath gives pleural pressure decreases the gradient for venous return,
no indication of volume responsiveness. Finally, as with decreases right heart filling and decreases right heart
any test of volume responsiveness, it must be remem- output. At the same time, there is increased output from
bered that evidence of volume responsiveness does not the left heart because of increased filling of the left heart
mean that the patient needs volume; that is a clinical as a consequence of emptying of pulmonary veins by the
decision. inflating lungs and a decrease in left-sided afterload due
to the rise in cardiac pressure relative to atmosphere. The
Ventilatory patterns in CVP can also give an indication of consequence is a transient inspiratory rise in arterial
the potential for cardiac output to fall with increases in pressure. The decrease in right-sided output is passed
Copyright © Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Hemodynamic monitoring in the mechanically ventilated patient Magder 41
to the left heart over a few beats so that output from the increase in pleural pressure for the same reason. Changes
left heart decreases during the expiratory phase. When in pulmonary artery pressure can also be used but are a
the heart is functioning on the flat part of the cardiac little more awkward because of the larger excursions of
function curve there is less of a fall in right heart output the pressure during the cardiac cycle. Changes in CVP are
during inspiration and more volume in the pulmonary less useful because the source of volume for the right
veins to sustain left heart filling in the expiratory phase. heart is outside the chest and does not vary with the
Thus patients who have large decreases in arterial pres- change in pleural pressure. In contrast, the source of
sure or stroke volume during expiration are expected to volume for the left heart varies in the same way as the
have an increase in cardiac output with a volume bolus, left atrial pressure with changes in pleural pressure. Large
whereas those without should not. Although this pattern negative swings in either CVP or pulmonary artery occlu-
should predict volume responsiveness when used in the sion pressure with triggering of the ventilator indicate
operating room in patients with no spontaneous inspira- inadequate settings of the trigger threshold, increased air
tory or expiratory ventilatory efforts, regular rhythm and way resistance or decreased lung compliance, or
standard ventilator settings as originally described by increased inspiratory drive and ventilator settings need
Perel [23], it is not effective in patients who have any to be adjusted or potentially increased sedation (Fig. 4).
spontaneous ventilatory efforts, including inspiratory or
expiratory efforts because the patterns of right and left- A large increase in CVP with a mechanical breath
sided filling differ [22]. Ventilatory variations in arterial indicates that there was a large rise in pleural pressure
pressure or stroke volume have also been shown not to be and this is suggestive of a decrease in thoracic wall
predictive in patients with smaller tidal volumes, compliance. This can occur with edema in the chest wall,
increased West zone II conditions and in patients with the presence of large effusions or even with increased
pulmonary hypertension [24,25,26]. abdominal pressure.
Figure 4 Example of pulmonary artery occlusion pressure (Ppao), a reflection of left atria pressure, and CVP in a patient on a pressure
support of 6 cmH2O
There is a marked inspiratory fall in Ppao of 28 mmHg which would indicate an even greater fall in pleural pressure which in cmH2O would be greater
than 38. The fall in pressure is also evident in the CVP but that is not always the case. The patient was post cardiac surgery and had a history of chronic
obstructive lung disease. Rhonchi were evident clinically. He was treated with bronchodilators before extubation; this resolved the large inspiratory
swings and he was successfully extubated.
Copyright © Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
42 Respiratory system
9 Rothe CF. Reflex control of veins and vascular capacitance. Physiol Rev
expiration is likely more valid. This process can some- 1983; 63:1281–1295.
times be eliminated by having the patient try to talk, 10 Deschamps A, Magder S. Effects of heat stress on vascular capacitance. Am J
even when intubated for this decreases contractions of Physiol 1994; 266:H2122–H2129.
expiratory muscles. 11 Deschamps A, Magder S. Baroreflex control of regional capacitance and
blood flow distribution with or without alpha adrenergic blockade. J Appl
Physiol 1992; 263:H1755–H1763.
12 Permutt S, Bromberger-Barnea B, Bane HN. Alveolar pressure, pulmonary
Conclusion venous pressure, and the vascular waterfall. Med Thoracalis 1962; 19:239–
260.
In the straightforward mechanically ventilated patient
13 Magder S. How to use central venous pressure measurements. Curr Opin Crit
simple observation of the patient with intermittent blood Care 2005; 11:264–270.
pressure and pulse oximetry is likely sufficient. When 14 Magder S. Central venous pressure: a useful but not so simple measurement.
ventilatory management becomes more difficult, careful Crit Care Med 2006; 34:2224–2227.
hemodynamic monitoring with an assessment of cardiac 15 Marik PE, Baram M, Vahid B. Does central venous pressure predict fluid
responsiveness? A systematic review of the literature and the tale of seven
output becomes more important to ensure that venti- mares. Chest 2008; 134:172–178.
latory settings do not decrease oxygen delivery while 16 Magder S, Bafaqeeh F. The clinical role of central venous pressure measure-
trying to increase arterial saturation. Finally, a lot of ments. J Intensive Care Med 2007; 22:44–51.
information can be obtained from CVP and arterial pres- 17 Magder SA, Georgiadis G, Cheong T. Respiratory variations in right atrial
pressure predict response to fluid challenge. J Crit Care 1992; 7:76–
sure waveforms that can help guide management. These 85.
signals are continuously available on the monitor and 18 Magder S, Lagonidis D, Erice F. The use of respiratory variations in right atrial
readily available to the informed clinician. pressure to predict the cardiac output response to PEEP. J Crit Care 2002;
16:108–114.
19 Nanas S, Magder S. Adaptations of the peripheral circulation to PEEP. Am
Rev Respir Dis 1992; 146:688–693.
References and recommended reading 20 Fessler HE, Brower RG, Wise RA, Permutt S. Effects of positive end-
Papers of particular interest, published within the annual period of review, have expiratory pressure on the gradient for venous return. Am Rev Respir Dis
been highlighted as: 1991; 143:19–24.
of special interest
21 Perel A, Pizov R, Cotev S. Systolic blood pressure variation is a sensitive
of outstanding interest
indicator of hypovolemia in ventilated dogs subjected to graded hemorrhage.
Additional references related to this topic can also be found in the Current Anes 1987; 67:498–502.
World Literature section in this issue (p. 81).
22 Magder S. Clinical usefulness of respiratory variations in arterial pressure. Am
1 Magder S. The left heart can only be as good as the right heart: determinants J Resp Crit Care Med 2004; 169:151–155.
of function and dysfunction of the right ventricle. Crit Care Resusc 2007; 23 Perel A. Assessing fluid responsiveness by the systolic pressure variation in
9:344–351. mechanically ventilated patients. Anes 1998; 89:1310–1312.
2 Magder S, Scharf SM. Venous return. In: Scharf SM, Pinsky MR, Magder SA, 24 Daudel F, Tueller D, Krahenbuhl S, et al. Pulse pressure variation and volume
editors. Respiratory-circulatory interactions in health and disease, 2nd ed. responsiveness during acutely increased pulmonary artery pressure: an
New York: Marcel Dekker, Inc; 2001. pp. 93–112. experimental study. Crit Care 2010; 14:R122.
3 Guyton AC. Determination of cardiac output by equating venous return curves A recent experimental study in animals showing the limitations of pulse pressure
with cardiac response curves. Physiol Rev 1955; 35:123–129. variations to predict fluid responsiveness when there is pulmonary hypertension
associated with sepsis.
4 Magder S. Mechanical interactions between the respiratory and circulatory
systems. In Sleep apnea: implications in cardiovascular and cerebrovascular 25 Wyler vB, Takala J, Roeck M, et al. Pulse-pressure variation and hemodynamic
disease. 2nd ed. New York: Informa Healthcare USA, Inc; 2010. pp. 40–60. response in patients with elevated pulmonary artery pressure: a clinical study.
A review of the basic physiology of heart–lung interactions. Crit Care 2010; 14:R111.
A recent study showing that pulse pressure variations fail to predict fluid respon-
5 Magder S, De Varennes B. Clinical death and the measurement of stressed siveness in patients with pulmonary hypertension.
vascular volume. Crit Care Med 1998; 26:1061–1064.
26 Magder S. Further cautions for the use of ventilatory-induced changes in
6 Rothe C. Venous system: physiology of the capacitance vessels. In: Shep- arterial pressures to predict volume responsiveness. Crit Care 2010; 14:197.
herd JT, Abboud FM, editors. Handbook of physiology. American Physiolo-
gical Society: Bethesda; 1983. pp. 397–452. 27 Bellemare P, Goldberg P, Magder S. Variations in pulmonary artery occlusion
pressure to estimate changes in pleural pressure. Int Care Med 2007;
7 Magder S. Central venous pressure monitoring. Curr Opin Crit Care 2006; 33:2004–2008.
12:219–227. This study demonstrates that respiratory changes in pulmonary artery occlusion
8 Drees J, Rothe C. Reflex venoconstriction and capacity vessel pressure- pressures give a good estimate of changes in pleural pressure when compared to
volume relationships in dogs. Circ Res 1974; 34:360–373. measurements by an esophageal balloon.
Copyright © Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.