Professional Documents
Culture Documents
INTRODUCTION
in this chapter, the researcher presents the background of the problem, the identification of the problem,
the limitation of the problem, the formulation of the problem, the objective of the research, the uses of the
Language is absolutely significant in people’s life. Without it, people cannot interact with others.
However, people cannot understand what the other people say if they do not know the language that they
use. People neither can express their ideas nor opinion if they do not know the language. In other words, it
is difficult to do all our activities without language. People need language not only for communication but
Brown states that language is a system of arbitrary vocal of symbol with permits all people in given
H. Douglas Brown, Principle of Language Learning and Tebching New Jersey, Prentice Hall. mc, 1994, p.4
2,
for human being. Language is a system of communication consisting of sounds, words, and grammar, or
the system of communication used by the people of a particular country or profession. Therefore, there is
a relation between a language and the people who speak. Considering the facts above, the researcher
Lim states that language is a social phenomenon.2 It is a means of communication between individuals. It
also brings them into relationship with their environment. Language is therefore socially learned
behavior, a skill that is acquired as we grow up in society. There are many various languages in the world,
because language is a tool of conmrnnicaljon Language exists in two forms, the written and the spoken or
the oral form. Not all languages in the world have the written form of letters, but most languages have the
spoken form of sounds of phonemes. The need of mastering a language especially English is necessary.
English not only becomes more important in the world for communication, but also as an international
As a matter of fact, learning English as a foreign language is not the same as learning
English as the second language. The students who learn it as the second language
have greater opportunity than the students who learn English as a foreign language.
Students who learn English as a second language can use English in their daily
2 Lim Kiat Boey, An Introduction to Linguistics for The Language Teacher, Singapore, 1975,
p.3
3
communication simultaneously. On the other hand, students who learn English as a foreign language have
title exposure or opportunity to use English in their daily life situation. There are four language skills that
must be mastered by the students, namely reading, speaking, listening, and writing. To suppoit the four
language skills, mastering grammar cannot be avoided, so they are demanded to master English grammar
first, but many students find difficulties in making a good entcnce in English. Furthermore, by learning
Learning grammar is very important for the students in acquiring the language competence. In other
words, the understanding of grammar will enable the students to improve the four language skills better.
Listening and reading both rely on input from an outside source and require knowledge of the language,
background knowledge, and comprehension skills. The productive skills of speaking and writing are more
complex as they necessitate taking knowledge of a language a step further to actually produce new
language.3 In addition, the limited time to practice writing and lack of good knowledge of grammar and
organization may cause great difficulties to someone especially the problem to compose good and correct
sentence in English. Therefore, Dullay et.al state that people cannot learn language without first
Anonymous, Posted on December 15’, 2008, Language Skills in the Classroom. [Online]. Provides: ht
4Dulay, et al, Language Two, New York, Oxford University Press, 1982, p.138
4
Dullay et.aI also state that by knowing students’ errors, the teacher will get useful infonnation
and can be used to sequence items for teaching or devise remedial lesson.5 It can be said that
correcting the students’ errurs can function as teaching technique feedback. Further, Dullay et.ai
It provides data from which inferences about the nature of the language learning process can be
made, and
It indicates to teachers curriculum developers which part of the target language students have
most difficulty producing correctly and which error types detract most from a learner’s ability to
communicate effectively.6
In this research, the researcher focused on analyzing the students’ grammatical errors especially
in using singular and plural nouns in their descriptive writing. Then, by writing a paragraph,
students learn to communicate a single idea clearly and effectively in written form.
The research was conducted at SMP Tn Sukses Natar Lampung Selatan. Based on the
preliminary research, the data were obtained by interviewing the English teacher of the seventh
class at SMP Tri Sukses Natar Lampung Selatan, Mrs. Miswati, S.Pd. She said that the students
noticed that they often do mistake when they apply singular and plural nouns. They were still
1.
distinguish between singular form which is changed to plural form. The researcher has given test to the
students in preliminary research, and the result of the test still far from the standard scores. They made
many errors in their descriptive writing. Here is the researcher represents some of the errors made by
the students:
1. Ihaveabestfrieflds.
4. HeiswearingaglasseS.
5. Sheisanicegi!i.
6. This is my bedrooms.
The errors of singular and plural nouns above are taken from the students’ writing when the researcher
1. Ihaveabestfriend.
4. He is wearing glasses.
6. This is my bedroom.
When the students want to write some words, thoughts, and their ideas in Indonesian language, then the
grammatical changes will not be happen like in English language. That is why the students often do
mistake and find difficulty when they apply their writing in English. The researcher is so interested
their descriptive writing in using singular and plural nouns. Therefore, the researcher proposes a
research entitled: “An Analysis of Students’ Error in Using Singular and Plural Nouns in their
Descriptive Writing Based on Surface Strategy Taxonomy at the Seventh Class of Second
Based on the background of the problem above, the researcher identified the problem as follows:
3. The students still make a lot of errors in using grammar, especially in using singular and plural
nouns.
Based on the identification of problem above, the researcher focused on the main obIem that is
an analysis of the students’ error in using singular and plural nouns in t±ir descriptive writing
based on Surface Strategy Taxonomy at the seventh class of ecimd semester at SMP Tn Sukses
1. What types of errors do students make in using singular and plural nouns in their descriptive
2. What are proportions (frequency and percentage) of the four error types of Surface Strategy
Taxonomy that will be found of singular and plural nouns in their descriptive writing?
1. To find out types of errors the students make in using singular and plural nouns based on
2. To find out proportions (frequency and percentage) of the four error types of Surface Strategy
Taxonomy that will be found of singular and plural nouns in their descriptive writing.
1. The result of the study can be used to inform the English teacher about error analysis based on
The result of the study can be used to give motivation for the English teacher to improve their
The result of the study can be used to improve the students’ mastery in English, especially in
writing skill.
The result of the study can be used as complementary consideration for the other research that
The research subject was the students at the seventh class of the second semester at SMP Tn
The research object was an analysis the students’ errors in using singular and plural nouns in
their descriptive writing based on Surface Strategy Taxonomy. The Place of The Research
The research was conducted at SMP Tn Sukses Natar Lampung Selatan. The Research Time
The research was conducted at the seventh class of the second semester at SMP Tn Sukses Natar
CHAPTER ii
In this chapter, the researcher presents the theories of languages, the concePts of error analysis, the
concept of singular and plural nouns, and the concept of descriptive writing that mainly related to
this thesis.
Since English has been so widely used in the world, it serves different functionS in different countries.
Some countries use English as the first language, while some others use it as the second language and as
a foreign language. First language means that the language has been acquired since one was born, and
uses it when she or he starts learning to speak, and continues using it in his/her daily life as he/she growS
up. Different from first language, second language is not the first acquired by people. It is usually
acquired by people after they have mastered their first language, or they move from the communitY
where a first language is used to another in which people use a second language.
10
rwn states that second language learning context are those in which the classroom rzt language is readily
available out there. Teaching English in the United States or ‘.ra1ia clearly falls into to ESL category.
Foreign language contexts are those in &itiich students do not have ready contexts for communication
beyond their :ssroom.1 Teaching English as a foreign language should be put as the main priority
-.use, it will introduce not only something new about the language to students but so about its culture.
Teaching by using media and other equipments is hoped can 5upport the students achieve the goal. In
addition, the teaching methods should be a1 interesting and appropriate for students.
According to Dullay et.al that errors are flawed side of learner speech and writing.2 They are those
parts of conversation or composition that deviate from some selected norm of mature language
performance. Meanwhile, Brown states that error is noticeable deviation from the adult grammar or a
native speaker reflecting the inter language competence of the learner, while mistake refers to a
performance error that is either a random guess or slip, in that it is a failure to utilize a known system
correctly.3 It is a means slip of the tongue, random ungrammaticalities and other performance
lapses in native speaker production also occur in second language speech. However, the problem of
‘Douglas Brown, Language Assessment Principles and Classroom Practice, 2004, London,
Longman, p.1 16
2Dullay.et.a], Language Two, New York, Oxford University Press, 1982, p.138
Douglas Brown, Princ4Ie of Language Learning and Teaching New Jersey, Englewood Cliffs, Prentice
11
learner’s error is one of some difficulty and involves a much more sophisticated study and analysis of
Further, according to Dullay et.al the distinction between performance error (mistake) and competence
error (error) is extremely important, but it is often difficult to determine the nature of a deviation wthout
carefully analysis. Therefore, they define error as any deviation from a selected norm of language
In this research, practicallV the researcher holds on the idea proposed by Dullay et.al as the basis of
determining the deviations produced by the subject. In conclusion, error in this research is any deviation
Human learning is fundamentally a process that involves the making of mistakes. Brown states that
the fact that learners do make errors can be observed, analyzed, and classified to reveal
something of the system operating within the learner, led to a surge of study of learners’ errors, called
et.al state that the error analysis can be characterized as an attempt to account for iearner errors.6
2 To investigate whether it is necessary or not for teacher to have remedial teaching. In this case, the
& Errors tell the teacher how far their students have progressed to reach the goals.
b. Errors provide evidences of how language is learnt and viiat strategies the learners are employing.
c. Errorscanbeusedbythetstoi
Ziking about error analysis, Dulay et.al classifies four taxonomies of error analysis
—-
3. Comparative taxonomy
this research, to analyze the students’ error, the researcher focused on Surface aIegy Taxonomy as the
13
this taxonomy focuses on aspects on the errors themselves, it emphasizes on analyzing the ways
We have already seen that straitegies of learning basically hinge on genera] principles of
learning. Brown states that strategies for production discussed here under the rubric of “source of
—
1. hiterlingual Transfer
It is phenomenon in which the students’ native language influences the target language, so that the
to negative interlingual transfer. While it is not always clear that an error is the result of transfer from the
native language, many such errors are detectable in learner speech. Fluent knowledge of a learner’s
native language of course aids the teacher in detecting and analyzing such errors; however, even
familiarity with the language can be of help in pinpointing this common source.
2. Jntralingual Transfer
It is phenomenon in which the students make errors in target language caused by the grammatical rules
of the target language itself as the result of an adequate knowledge of the learners in the target language.
b.
3. Context of Learning
14
Context refers to classroom with its teacher and its mateaJs in the case of school Ieanjg In a
classroom Context the teacher or the textbook may lead the learner to make faulty hypotheses
about the language Here the sjdents often make ernors because of misleading explanation from
the teacher faulty presention of S1Ce or word in a textbook, or even because of a pattern that was
4. Comnjjcj0 Strategies
Brown stes that a COmcatiOn Strategy is the conscious emp1oyrn of verbai or nonverb& mechanisms
for ConlJnunicating an idea when precise linguistic forms axe for some reason not readily available to
the learner at a point in Comrm11jcatjon It is clear that the categories of strategies overlaps both inter-
5. Avojdan
Avoidance is a corn011 Cofli nication strategy that can be broken down into severaj subcategones and
thus distingus from other types of strategies The most COmnOfl type of avoidance strategy is syntac or
bid, p.178
15
taxonomy highlights the ways surface structures will be altered: learners may omit
necessary items or add unnecessary ones, they may misform items or misorder
items.’1 There are four types of errors based on the surface strategy taxonomy, they
are:
1. Omission
These errors are characterized by the absence of an item that must appear in a well-
Example:
2. Addition
These errors are characterized by the presence of an item which must not appear in a
a. Double Markings
For instance:
I
16
b. Regularizations
Regularizations errors that fall under the addition category are those in which
exceptional items of the given class that do not take a marker. For instance:
c. Simple Addition
If an addition error is neither a double marking nor regularization, it is called a simple addition.
No particular features characterize simple addition other those that characterize all addition
errors, the use of an item which should not appear in a well-formed utterance. For instance:
3. Misformation
These errors are characterized by the incorrect form of morpheme of structure. There are three
a. Regularization Errors
That fall under the regularization errors of misformation category are those in which a regular marker is
b. Archi Forms
—
The form selected by the student is called an “archi form”. For instance:
—
• fldogismine
For this learner “that” is archi demonstrative adjective representing the entire members of demonstrative
—
adjective.
c. Alternating Forms
As the learners’ vocabulary and grammar grow, they have known the various members of a class.
Nevertheless, they still fail to select and use the members appropriately. For instance:
4. jsordering
These errors are characterized by the incorrect placement of a morpheme or group of morphemes in an
Noun is a word that is used to show for name of people places, animalS, days, ideas, things, or etc.
ExanWleS Fatim (name of person); Jakarta (place); and SaturdaY (dy).’2 Frank states that the noun is one
of the most important parts of speech. Its arrangement with the verb helps to form the sentence core
which is essential to every complete sentence. Some flOUflS may belong to more than one of the pes given
below13
i. Proper Noun
A proper noun begins with a capital letter in writing. it Includes (a) personal names, (b) names of
geoaphi0 units such as countries, cities, rivers, etc, (c) names of nationalities and religions, (d) names of
holiday, (e) names of time units, (f) words used for personification a thing or abstraction tread as a
—
person. As opposed to proper nOUnS, all other nouns are classified as common nouns.
Widyatama,27 p.4
A concrete noun is a word for a physical object that can be perceived by the senses —
we can see, touch, smell the object (flower, girl). An abstract noun is a word for a
concept it is an idea that exists in our minds only (beauty, justice, mankind).
—
A countable noun can usually be made plural by the addition of —s. A noncountable
noun is not used in the plural. Mass nouns form one type of noncountable noun. They
are words for concrete objects stated in an undivided quantity. Abstract nouns
Some noncountable nouns may also be used in a countable sense and will therefore
have a plural. In the sentence We had chicken for dinner, chicken is a mass noun; in
There were many chickens in the yard, chickens is a countable noun. In addition, a
noncountable noun may be used in the plural with the special meaning of kinds of —
4. Collective Nouns
single unit. Example of collective nouns are audience, committee, class, crew, crowa
enemy, faculty, family, flock; folk; government, group, hera jwy, majority, minority,
I
20
Collective nouns are countable nouns; they may be used in the plural All the committees have now
—
Nouns in many European languages may be inflected, that is, changed in form, for certain grammatical
properties. Usually these changes are made through special endings. Inflectional forms of nouns may
indicate:
I. gender. Special endings mark nouns as masculine, feminine or neuter, not necessarily to actual sex.
2. case. Special endings mark nouns according to their function in the sentence- subject, object of the
verb, etc.
As a matter of fact, the only grammatical properties for which the English noun is inflected are: (1)
number —the noun has a special ending that signals not only actual possession, but a number of other
relationship for which of phrases may also be used. In this research, the researcher focused on analyzing
A noun is the name of a person, place or thing. A singular noun refers to one only. A plural noun
refers to two or more. Schmitt explains that defmition of singular noun is when a noun means one
only, it is said to be singular (example: boy, girl, book, church, box), when a noun means more
. 4 - — -— •-
boys, girls, books, churches).’4 There are many rules in using singular and plural nouns, as follows:
1. Es/s plural nouns.
a) The plural of nouns is usually formed by adding s to a singular noun.
Example:
Singular Plural
Lamp lamps
Cat cats
Fork forks
Flower flowers
Pen pens
b) Nouns ending in s, z, x, sh, and
Example:
Singular ___
Moss
Dish
Buzz
Box
Church
‘ Beverly Schmitt, 1997-2002, Singular and Plural Nouns lOnline]. Provides:
xpJ/www.teachingeng1ish.org.collum [November 3, 2011]
, d) Nouns ending in “y” preceded by a vowel from their plural by adding “s’.
Singular Plural
Boy boys
Day days
e) Most nouns ending in “o” preceded by a consonant is formed into a plural by
adding “es”. Example:
Singular Plural
Hero heroes
Buffalo buffaloes
Potato potatoes
Tomato tomatoes
The following are among those that add s only:
Canto solo piano lasso
Halo memento albino sirocco
_- -
23
I) Most nouns ending in “o” preceded by a vowel is formed into a plural by adding
“s’. Example:
Singular Plural
Folio folios
Cameo cameos
Studio studios
Poafolio portfolios
g) Some nouns ending in “f’ or “fe” are made plural by changing “F’ or “fe” to
“yes”. Example:
Singular Plural
Beef beeves
Wife wives
4 Life lives
I Safe safes
Roof roofs
Grief griefs
24
Specialn ote:
Man men
Woman women
Foot feet
Mouse mice
Tooth teeth
Child children
Goose geese
Some nOUnS are always singular. Some of these nouns may be used in the plural when different kinds
are meant as: sugars, coffees, Cottons, gold, silver, wheat, corn, molasses, copper, sugar, eotto news,
Plural
alumnae formulae nebulae vertebrae automata curricula
data errata gymnasia
phenomena
strata alumni
Singular
focus radius stimulus
terminus
amanuensis
analysis
axis basis ellipsis hypothesis parenthesis thesis
Plural
foci radii stimuli termini amanuenses
analyses
axes bases ellipses hypotheses
parentheses
theses
26
a) Possessive nouns
a.
My brother
The girl
My student
My wife
The lecture
James
My brothers
The girls
My students
My wives
The lectures
b) Usingtobe
Is
Possessive noun My brother’s The girl’s My student’s my wife’s the lectures James’
Plural noun
27
H. The Concept of Writing
Byrne states that writing involves the encoding of a message of some kind: that is, we translate our
thoughts into language.’5 Writing is more that the production of graphic symbol, just a speech is more
than production of sound. It means that writing is a process of sending a message by using !etters, express
idea, feeling, and thought, which are arranged in the word, sentence, and paragraph correctly.
Writing is a part of subject which is difficult in learning English, because in writing people need special
aspect of language, for instance: diction, structure, mechanic, and rhetorical. In other hand, Leo states
that writing as a process of expressing ideas or thoughts in words should be done at our leisure. Writing
can be very enjoyable as long as we have the ideas and the means to achieve it.16
There are several ways of organizing sentences which can be applied in writing activity depending on the
researcher purpose. According to Wishon and Burks, writing is classified into four types as follows:’7
1. Narration is the form of writing used to relate the story of facts or events.
Narration places occurrences in time and tells what happened according to natural time sequences.
16 Sutanto Leo, English for Academic Purpose, Essay Writing, Yogyakarta, ANDI, 2007, p.1
‘‘ George E. Wishon and Julia M. Burks, Let’s Write English Revised Edition, New York, Litton Educational
2. DescriPtion reproduces the way things look, smell, taste, feel, or sound; it may also evoke moods, such
as happiness, loneliness, or fear. It is used to create a visual image of people, places, even of units of
time days, time of days, or seasons. It may be used also to describe more than the outward appearaIW
—
instructional material.
hi this research, the researcher chose descriptive writing to collect the data because, the students at the
seventh class of the second semester were studying about descriptive text in this semester.
Descriptive writing is about using the power of words to arouse and capture the reader’s attentiOfl and
create a lasting impact. According to Osbinia and Hogue, descriptive writing appeals to the senses, so it
tells how something looks, feels, smells, tastes and/or sounds.’6 A good description is like a “word
picture”; the reader can image the object, place, or person in his or her mind. In a descrtptiofl,
writers
‘6Ajice Oshima and Ann Hogue, Introduction Academic Writing Second F4itiofl 1997, p.50
29
often use spatial order to organize their ideas. It means that the students are able to describe their way of
Descriptive writing is a type of writing in which to write the ideas are arranging on the basic of space
or location, such as in the description of a person, description of a landscape, description of the structure
the building, description of the structure of something, etc. Description helps the reader, though his/her
In this research, the researcher focused on describing person, place and things. The researcher chose
some tittles that were given for the students (See Appendix 2).