Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Years of Fear
Truth and Justice for the enforced
disappearances in Syria
Transitional Justice in the Arab World Project
1970 “”
“”
“”
“”
198049
1
3
4
1
182
1162000
197919993
145139
20084
2008
20082007
2003
20091979
1970
1970
3.5
4.4
6.44.6 3.1
197051960
6
7
8
22919871 5
22
20056
5556
7
HannaPatatuSyria`sPeasantrytheDescendantsofItslesserRuralNotablesandtheirpoliticPrinceton
NJPrincetonUniversitypress1999
195819468
1949
196381958–1949
19611958 –
19631958
1963
19701949
1973
9 1973
103
10811110107
95
2007
200009
20021973
10
11101100
197311
1987
12
65
257
1531559.5%
13
12
MiddleEastWatchCommitteeedSyriaUnmaskedthesuppressionofhumanrightsbytheregime
NewHavenYaleuniversitypress1991
13
AlanGeorgeSyrianeitherbreadnorfreedomLondon ;NewYorkzedBooks2003p23
14VolkerPrethesThePoliticalEconomyofSyriaunderAsadLondonNewYorkIBTauris1995
pp141145
15
900
800
700
600
500
400
300
200
100
0
1965 1991 2005
“”
“”
”
196340016“
65398 1971
19923743321981
1.008.24317
16AlanGeorgeSyrianeitherbreadnorfreedomLondon ;NewYorkzedBooks2003pp71
Alan GeorgeSyrianeither bread nor freedompp1017
15.066199716.320200020 2004
13.782 1994
19606.30519709.046 1981
4.565
”
18“
8718
1980197919
19
20
1971
21
1963
19721971
1969 1973
22
–
1973
11381974
19801976 280 610 252
235.41976
2000
12
241971
197331
25
1950
“ ”
27
28
“”
“” “”
197229
1962
“”
30
2002197326
27PatrickSealeAsadofSyriaPP279
27928028
29HannaBatutuSyria`sPeasantrypp262265
30
“”
31“”
“”
19793616
1980
27
37
38
1964
“”1975
16 34
2000
35VolkerPerthesThePoliticalEconomyofSyriaunderAsadP147153
354442000
RegimethebyRightsHumanofSuppressionTheUnmaskedSyriaedCommitteeWatchEastMiddle
1991PressUniversityYaleHavenNew
Alasdair DrysdaleThe succession Question in SyriaMiddle East JournalVol39N2Spring 1985P
93111Tomas kozynovskyRifaat AlassadOrientVol41984P465470
shrcwww200216 36
org
279120002
6831985
Hanna Batatu Syria‘s Muslim Brothers MERIPReports Vol 12 November December 1982 No
110P1220
37PatrickSealAsadandtheStrugglefortheMiddleEastpp532533
200126wwwshrcorg
38
ItzchakWeismannSa`idHawwaandIslamicRevivalisminBa`thistSyriaStudiaIslamicaNo851997
pp;131154andItzchakWeismannSa`idHawwaTheMakingofaRadicalMuslimThinkerinModern
SyriaMiddleEasternStudiesVol29No4October1993pp601623
1973
30
1975
1976
1976
1979
39
1979 4
1979
1980749
40
41
39
MiddleEastwatchCommitteeedSyriaUnmaskedP163185
285
2001
198217198074940
491
533350635144 41
22
198061979
42
43
1978 30
99.61%
19788
” 1981
“
” ”
“ ”
1982
150005000
1800 44
534
25198042
450197043
HannaBatatuSyria‘sPeasantrytheDescendantsofItsLesserRuralNotablesandtheirpoliticsNew
JerseyPrincetonUniversityPress1999
53754044
Nikolaos Van Dam The Struggle For Power in Syria Sectarianism Regionalism and Tribalism in
politics19611978LondonGroomHelm1979ThomasFriedmanFromBeiruttoJerusalemNew
YorkFarrarStrausandGiroux1989p76105
“ ”
”
45“
461982
“”
”
”47“
48“
49
DavidRobertsTheBa‘thandtheCreationofModernSyriaLondon1987P128
ReymondHinnebuschAuthoritarianPowerandstateformationinBa‘thistSyriaArmyPartyand
PeasantSanFrancisco1990P291300
FredHLawsonSocialBasesfortheHamahRevoltMeripReportsNovemberDecember1982P
2428RobertFiskTheTimesLondon19February1982
12000
166167199311982
19871
Michel SeuratL’E’tat de barbarie ParisE’ditions du Seuil1989
45HannaBatatuSyria<sPeasantrypp274
46 Nikolaos Van Dam the Struggle for Power is Syria Sectarianism Regionalism and Tribalism in
politics19611978London ;1979FredHLawsonSocialBasesfortheHamaRevoltationMiddle
EastResearclandinformationProjectReportsNovemberDecember1982pp2428andRobertfisk
Times1921982
47
1042004
48
2005 –11125349
111
20072008
2008
1990
50
1984
1984
51
1987
198049
193850
1977 1975
1977
19901979
wwwaljazeeranet312200551
1920
1920
52
”
53“
1995
198049
54
2000
“”
1979
55
200057
1
55
167200556
57
2
3
4
5
58
”59
“
”
“
58
2006
200959
198260
198027
61
62
”
198049
“
63
”
65
198260
222006
187199919802761
43200662
19801998200963
64
65
2008
66
1973
251973
1
2
28
66
SyriaDisclose Fate of DetaineesHuman Rights Watch July 32009
httpwwwhrworgennews20090703syriadisclosefatedetainees
SyriaLift Blackout on Prisoners’ FateHuman Rights WatchDecember 102009
httpwwwhrworgennews20091210syrialiftblackoutprisonersfate
6
69
5
1952 626
72
252242
1
2
104
1
2
105
385
359
2
367
1
237
2
3
2
2 1 3
2
3
”14
1
2
3
6
7
”
“
–
14
”161969
“
”
“
1963
”
873369
459427
“586573
117
8
9
11
“
14
1969
74
1969525549
200893069
47“
195022761
”
“53
“”
”
67“
196382
”
“196338
69
70
73 72 71
74
75
68
69
4112111070
2252531967
71
319328451971
7361993582172
19966110973
805815
19754012111074
310
1975
76
77
6
293260
873369
2459427
586573
1982
83
“ ”
196576
”
”“
“
“”
3
”
“
39680
155157200710
15681
82
1162001
httpwwwaljazeeranetNRexeres2782922BCE354FEBB8299A20F7DD007Ahtm
196583
“19
“
“”
“”
1992
19921729
84
1963 18
”
85“
196623
“”
httpwwwshrcorgdataaspx004RESEARSHaspx84
85NikolaosVanDamTheStruggleForPowerinSyriapp8194
1967 17
196625
1967
“”
”
“
” “”
““
“
1967817 109
2
8619678141091966225
4
”
”
86
“”
1982
”19807132
19678171092
“
109
”
90“
91“”
1985330
”
wwwmoustafatlassorg87
18888
19672889
90
91
httpwwwshrcorgdata
aspx005BOOKSaspx
92
“
93“ ”
”
92
199393
httpwwwshrcorgdataaspx012BOOKSaspx
“
1967
196832847
““
““”
““
“
”
6
196517
httpwwwshrcorgdataaspx004RESEARSHaspx94
““
“
”
”“
95“
28319684795
96
278
286
285
307
Far from Justice Syria`s Supreme State Security Court Human Rights Watch HRWFebruary 2497
2009
httpwwwhrworgenreports20090223farjustice0
98
99
100
29
1969
1514
16
19695409
3016
10174196912514
525549
1969
1969125143016
19 98
252249
105200699
httpwwwhrworgar 100
news20090224
16
30
196952554910174
74
196911514101
”2
“
”367
“247
1 “391
“2
247 545
” 534 353 534
” 30 “
101“
9102
“
103“
16 “”
1970
22
1971 12
104“ ”
6065101
102
httpshrcorgdataaspx010BOOKSaspx
103
httpwwwshrcorgdataaspxd888aspx#D9
104PatrickSealeAsadofSyriaandtheStragglefortheMiddleEastpp278
105“”
1971
19712
400
”
106“
1973
” “”
” “
“
“”
148
107 1971
53
”19798
” ”
“” “” “
198049 –
1980749
105Ibidpp279
11106
200747
74107
“ ”
197953
”
“
49
” 5
30”“
198078”108“
“
109
198217108
20099109
httpwwwthisissyrianet20090909writers05html
2009110
30
”
“
198030
198077
”
” “
”“” “
“
”
“
”
“
”
“
”
“
”
”“
“
”
“
198049
49
”19807132
19688171092
“
109
”
111“
1979616
54 32
””
” ”
111
112“”
”
19801979
13
“
”
“”
139 147
“
”
httpwwwshrcorgdataaspx012BOOKSaspx112
113“
“”
11838131980627
114
1981
1982
25000 3500015000
1165000
httpbeirutindymediaorg – 113
200928ar200306301shtml
253262114
19801025019809116
1980 18198025
19801119801
1980
Middle East Watch, Syria Unmasked :The Suppression of Human Rights by the Asad Regime, Yale
Univ Press, 1991, for more about that see: Fisk, Robert, Pity the Nation, London, Touchstone, 1990
pp.87- 181,Time (Newspaper), Syria: Bloody Challenge to Assad, London, Monday, Mar. 08, 1982.
Time (Newspaper), Syria: Battle of Hama, London, Monday, Mar. 29, 1982. Read more: http://www.
time.com/
1983MDE 240483
1982
291976
“”
730
236
117
11820001500
19619865
”
236117
httpwww200811
200915elaphcomElaphWebPolitics20082303313htm
15 httpwwwfatehforumscomshowthreadphp?t109420 118
2009
119
196652140
92”
1961111598
1
“
88119
1980
17000
20091980
%4.3
“”
120
”
“
“”
2009 120
“”
“ ”
“
24
2
“
“””
“
121
” 1988525
122“
123
124
“”
”
”
123A PsychoMoral Support to the families of victims of enforced disappearance By Khurram Parvez
Association of Parents of Disappeared Persons KashmirIndia
httpwwwediecorgareasdescriptionconsequences#c186124
2009125
“
”
“
” ““
“
”
“
2009126
127
httpwwwictjnetarabicmemoralizationarhtm
”
“
”
“
“
“
“
“
“”
129
2009128
httpwwwediecorgareasdescriptionconsequences#c186129
130“
1980
”
16
14
“
”
131“
2009130
2009131
“
“132
“”
29“
133“
”
“
“
“
“”
134
”
135“
“ 1980
136“
2009135
2009136
“
”
150075
137“
1981
2009137
”
“
6 “24
“
“202
“
”204
“
2009138
”
“
”
“
2009139
2009140
”
“
”
“
” 1949812
“
“
“
141
“
“
142 30
“ ”
21112005142
“”
7”24
“
143 1980
144
143
2005
2000
Human Rights Watch 144
Syria UnmaskedThe Suppression of Human Rights by the Asad Regime
1990
MED 240483 1983MDE 240495 1995
MDE “ ” MDE 2400195 1999
240142001 2001
1453920041980
2004
4000 “ ”
“”
147146
” “”2003
14“
“7000“
145
ECN420056523 December 2004
198910146
1990
10
1991
%99.9819912
19921991
1992
72000
20072001
2003147
”
13347
“199218
20031999
148
” 2005
19901979 “
20062005
2006
1979
2003148
149
2008 31
2007
200615150
19891979
HRW
AMNESTY
” “ “””
151“
”
“”
1980
”
152“
“”
”
153“
“”1980
2006151
152Middle East Watch Syria Unmasked The Suppression of Human Rights by the Asad
Regimepp60
153Ibidpp60
1980
154
1991
2005
1995
200428
40
155
154Ibidpp61
2009155
”
” “
156“
AHRC9NGO30
““
”
“
358
”
“
”
“”
“
2003156
1981
27
2001980
160
131128157
httpwwwmokarabat158
200928commo211htm
5159
200928httpwwwhrworgarnews200104052001
.United Nations. Document No: E /CN .4/1469, Date: 4 March 1981 160
37
13
“”
” “”
1632161 “
1981 9
162
49
“”163
198026
1980132
““
“”
164
41469CNE161
162
20014
253261
198031163
1993164
500
165“ ”
166“ 150 ”
2005
167
“”168
26
1980
1979
Middle East WatchSyria UnmaskedThe Suppression of Human Rights by the Asad Regimepp16165
KoelblSusanneSYRIAA 101 Course in Mideast DictatorshipsDer SpiegelBrlin 02212005166
19791989
httpwwwspiegeldeinternationalspiegel0151834324200html
167
1964
14 57
1979
1963
Middle East Watch Syria UnmaskedThe Suppression of Human Rights by the Asad Regimepp130
198031168
1979
1982
169
19851984
291989
“”
17000
”1982
” “
” “
169 Middle East Watch Syria Unmasked The Suppression of Human Rights by the Asad
Regimepp130
Ibidpp6162170
141983ECN4 “
1980
” 1984
“” “
211984ECN4
198523
“”
151985ECN4
198624
“ ”
”
19858
“
” “”
E “
181986CN4
“”1987429
E “
171988CN4
200321
19803220021982
“”1994
2002
32”
”
” “
27”“
1413
702003ECN4“
21
”36 2004
“
201994198024
2003
3611
“”
13
636
15
2005
562006ECN415
200725
200513
16“”
19801712006
20051994
40 24
“”
“ ”
200623171
”
“
“”
”
” “
A61289“
1996
“”
200829 “”
AHRC9
NGO30
“”
“ ”
“”
“”
“”
172 –
173
Touvier
172GeorgeEmileIraniApologiesandReconciliationMiddleEastRitualsTakingWrongsSeriously
ApologiesandReconciliationEditedbyElazarBarkanandAlexanderKarnStanfordUniversitypress
20052006
2005173
737
ANC
174
175
1990176
1999199719941994
20042001
174
httpwwwarabtjorgnewsphp?idC15
175Louis Bickford The Encyclopedia of Genocide and Crimes Against Humanity Macmillan Reference
USA2004vol3pp10451047
176Kritz Neil ed 1995 Transitional Justice How Emerging Democracies Reckon with Former
RegimesVolsI–IIIWashingtonDCUSInstitute of Peace Press
177
178
179
180
181
177BoraineAlexJanet Levyand Ronel Scheffereds1997Dealing with the PastCape TownSouth
AfricaInstitute for Democracy in South Africa and CrockerDA1999“Reckoning with Past
WrongsA Normative Framework” Ethics &International Affairs 134361
178HaynerPriscilla2002Unspeakable Truths Facing the Challenge of Truth CommissionsNew
York Routledge and Zalaquett Jose 1993 Introduction to the English Edition In Chilean
National Commission on Truth and ReconciliationReport of the Chilean National Commission on
Truth and Reconciliation trans Phillip E Berryman South Bend Ind University of Notre Dame
Press
179
BassiouniMCherifed2000PostConflictJusticeNew YorkTransnational Publishers
180
232004
200420032004181
1
182
183
30182
2005
22004183
184
261974
185
4 184
Hayner Priscilla 2002 Unspeakable Truths Facing the Challenge of Truth
CommissionsNew YorkRoutledge
7 185
Taking Conflict Intrstate and Commissions Truth Apology RotbergI Robert
and Barkan Elazar by EditedReconciliation and Apologies Seriously Wrongs
3348P2006PressUniversityStanfordKarnAlexander
2
3
186
187
wwwictjorg 1 86
187
2004
188
“”
189 4
wwwictjorg188
200420032004189
1
2
3
190
“ ”
191
wwwictjorg190
wwwictjorg191
192
193
200420032004192
200420032004193
194 5
–
195
6
wwwictjorg194
195VamikDVolkan What Some Monuments tell us about Mourning and Forgiveness Taking
WrongsSeriouslyApologiesandReconciliationEditedbyElazarBarkanandAlexanderKarnStanford
UniversityPress2006P115130
– –
196
197
“” 198
·
·
·
·
·
·
·
·
1
2
3
5
·
49
·
·
·
·
·
·
·
·
·
·
30
19970
200
“”
“”
·
·
·
·
·
·
·
httpwwwediecorg EDIEC199
200
2008 20025
”
13347 “
201199218
”
“
10
2006
”
17761
200620
202
”
2 “
httpwww1umneduhumanrtsarabb053html201
2007 202
200720072007
·
1948103 217
1949 12 ·
·
1966 16 21 2200
196949197623
”
““
“
·
6631955
19771362207619573124
·
1985293440
·
19901411145
·
4639
198726198410
127
199628 ·
203
53150RESA10March1999203
1
2
3
4
1962122251
–1
–2
–3
–4
–5
–6
293 260
873369
2459427
586573
–7
–8
–9
–10
2
–11
–12
1958927162
13
162
162
162
–14
1967817109
19662252
1967814109
–1
196765
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
1968817
196832847
1
2
3
4
5
6
196517
6
7
8
9
10
11
“”3016
10174196912514
1969525549
1969125143016
16
30
196952554910174
74
196911514101
198049
49 198077
–1
–2
–3
4
5
–6