Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract
The leaching kinetics of silver and lead simultaneously from zinc residue by chloride was investigated. The effects of stirring speed, tem-
perature, sodium chloride concentration, particle size and liquid/solid ratio on Ag and Pb dissolution in sodium chloride were studied. It was
determined that the dissolution rates increased with increasing sodium chloride concentration, temperature and decreasing particle size. The
dissolution kinetics followed a shrinking core model, with inter-diffusion through gangue layer as the rate determining step. This finding is in
accordance with the apparent activation energy (Ea) of 26.8 kJ⋅mol−1 (Ag) and 26.5 kJ⋅mol−1 (Pb), and a linear relationship between the rate
constant and the reciprocal of squared particle size. The orders of reaction with respect to sodium chloride concentration, temperature and
particle size were also achieved. The rate of reaction based on diffusion-controlled process can be expressed by semi-empirical equations.
Keywords: hydrometallurgical zinc residue; chloride leaching; inner diffusion-controlled; semi-empirical equations
2 Experimental
2.1 Materials
The representative samples of residues were obtained
from a plant in Shandong province. Prior to use in this study,
the samples were washed, dried and sieved to obtain a re-
quired fraction. These samples were subjected to detailed
analyses before experiments. The chemical composition by
X-ray fluorescence (XRF) and atomic absorption spectros-
copy (AAS) are given in Table 1 and chemical phase com-
positions of lead and silver are shown in Tables 2 and 3. The
pattern of X-ray diffraction analysis (XRD) is given in Fig. 1 XRD pattern of residue after zinc extraction
Fig. 1. The XRF and AAS analyses show that the samples
contain 12.26% Pb, 651 g⋅t−1 Ag, 2.78% Fe, 15.30% Si and the water-soluble substance and enrich lead and silver, and
4.99% S. XRD analysis shows Anglesit (PbSO4), Anhydrite the slurry was filtered. The cake was laid in a drying cabinet
(CaSO4) and Quartz (SiO2) as major components; there is no for 10 min, then the materials were dry-screened to obtain
obvious diffraction peak of silver because of its trace four different sizes to examine the possible effect of particle
amounts in the residues. size. The leaching experiments were performed in a 500 ml
2.2 Experimental procedure vessel with two opening set up in a thermostatically con-
The secondary hydrometallurgical zinc residuals after trolled oil bath and the temperature controlling accuracy was
zinc extraction were washed four times by water to scour off ±0.5 K. To minimize aqueous loss when the system was
heated, a reflux condenser was mounted on the top of one
Table 2 Mineral phase constitutes of silver opening. The mechanical stirrer used had a controller unit
and its agitator shaft was made of glass to avoid corrosion
Components Repartition of silver / (g⋅t−1) Percentage/% and cementation by iron. 500 ml of clear brine solution with
Silver in lead silicate 336 51.62 known concentration was added to the reaction vessel.
Native silver 177 27.14 When the temperature of the solution system reached the
Silver sulfide 48 7.37 predetermined value, 10.00 g sample was introduced into
the flask, the acidity was adjusted to the desired value by
Silver in silicate 33 5.02
using a small amount of HCl, and H2O2 was used as additive.
Rests 57 8.85 After maintaining for a preset reaction period, the leach
TAg 651 100.00 slurry was filtered immediately and washed for three times
and the filtrate was diluted with distilled water. The cake
Table 3 Mineral phase constitutes of plumbum was dried and analyzed for Pb and Ag.
listed as follows [14]: It can be seen from Fig. 2 that the extraction rate of Ag
2+
PbSO 4 ⇔ Pb + SO 4 2−
(1) or Pb increases steadily with stirring speed increasing from
2+ 2−i
100(12.5 m⋅s−1) to 400 r⋅min−1 (50 m⋅s−1) and afterwards it
Pb + iCl− = PbCli (i =1, 2, 3, 4, 5) (2) remains constant. This suggests that the influence of exter-
Ag − e = Ag + (3) nal diffusion control to the leaching process is eliminated
when the stirring speed is above 400 r⋅min−1 (50 m⋅s−1) [16].
Ag + + jCl− = AgCl j1− j ( j =1, 2, 3, 4) (4)
Thus, 400 r⋅min−1 (50 m⋅s−1) is chosen as an invariable
The particle of slags after dissolution was detected, and quantity for the subsequent experiments.
the average diameter of leached slags was 13.79 μm com-
pared with 14.9 μm of those before leaching; the particle 3.3 Effect of sodium chloride concentration
diameter hardly changed. The leaching rates of Pb and Ag The sodium chloride concentration was varied in a range
were 94.75% and 82%, respectively, when 10.00 g samples from 200 g⋅L−1 to 350 g⋅L−1 while keeping reaction tem-
were leached by 350 g⋅L−1 solution chloride for 2 h at a liq- perature, duration time, liquid/solid ratio and stirring speed
uid/solid ratio of 15, temperature of 368.15 K, stirring rate at 368 K, 2 h, 15, and 400 r⋅min−1 (50 m⋅s−1), respectively.
of 400 r⋅min−1, HCl of 12 ml, and H2O2 of 15 ml. The con- Figs. 3 (a) and (b) illustrate the influence of sodium chloride
centration of solution chloride decreased less than 10%, the concentration on leaching rate. It is indicated that increasing
amount largely exceeded the theoretical amount, so the sodium chloride concentration could promote extraction rate.
concentration was considered as constant during the whole Excess sodium chloride is necessary to maintain higher ex-
process, which was consistent with the hypothesis of the traction rate and ensure sufficient reactions, yet the extra so-
pseudo-stationary state. Therefore, the leaching process can dium chloride is not economical in industrial production
be analyzed with the shrinking core model [15]. According practice. Therefore, to investigate the effects of other pa-
to this model, the rate of reaction between solid particle and rameters, 350 g⋅L−1 was chosen.
solution may be controlled by one of the following steps When the diffusion through the gangue layer is rate con-
[13]: diffusion controlled, chemical reaction controlled and trolling, the kinetics may be correlated graphically using the
combination controlled of diffusion and chemical reaction. equation (Eq. 5) [17−18]:
The rate-controlling step of the leaching process depends on
experimental kinetics data.
Fig. 2 Effect of stirring rate on leaching efficiency (HCl, 12 ml; Fig. 3 Effect of chloride concentration on leaching efficiency
H2O2, 15 ml) (HCl, 12 ml; H2O2, 15 ml)
ZHANG Yali, et al., Kinetics of simultaneous leaching of Ag and Pb from hydrometallurgical zinc residues by chloride 405
k p t =1− 2/3 x − (1− x)1/3 (5) plots of lnkp versus lnco are shown in Figs. 4 (c) and (d). The
reaction orders are calculated to be 0.2114 for Pb and 0.0759
When the reaction rate is controlled by chemical reaction,
for Ag, which indicates that the dependency of Ag leaching
the following expression of shrinking core model can be
used to describe the kinetics: Table 4 Apparent rate constant and correlation coefficient
kc t =1− (1− x)1/3 (6) values (R2)
where kp = chemical rate constant (h−1); kc = reaction rate Reaction Chemical Diffusion through
constant (h−1); t = time(h); x = fraction reaction of Ag or Pb; condition reaction (Ag) the gangue layer (Ag)
On the basis of the experimental data in Figs. 3 (a) and K’a / min−1 R2 Ka / min−1 R2
(b), the rate constants and their correlation coefficients are 200 g·L−1 0.0824 0.9125 0.0092 0.9991
given in Tables 4 and 5 for the diffusion through the product 250 g·L−1 0.0882 0.9063 0.0175 0.9861
layer and the chemical reaction controlled model. Also, Figs. 300 g·L−1 0.0927 0.8832 0.0262 0.9957
4 (a) and (b) show the data plots according to diffusion con- 350 g·L−1 0.0966 0.8658 0.0356 0.9721
trol process.
The results in Tables 4 and 5 reveal that the values of the Table 5 Apparent rate constant and correlation coefficient
correlation coefficients for the diffusion through the product values
layer are closer to 1 than those of the chemical reaction con- Reaction Chemical Diffusion through
trolled model. Therefore, Eq. (5) was found to fit the data condition reaction (Pb) the gangue layer(Pb)
best. Figs. 4 (a) and (b) show that, during the whole reaction K’a/min−1 R2 Ka/min−1 R2
time, the data are linear, and zero point intercepts are ob-
200 g·L−1 0.1022 0.9158 0.0281 0.9806
tained. The linear relationship between 1− 2/3 x − (1− x)1/3
250 g·L−1 0.1153 0.8956 0.0468 0.9763
and leaching time is significant and indicates that the rates −1
300 g·L 0.1366 0.9186 0.0634 0.9934
of leaching reactions are controlled by diffusion through the
gangue layer [19]. The slope of these straight lines is kp. The 350 g·L−1 0.1524 0.9247 0.0760 0.9945
Fig. 4 Plots of leaching kinetics at different chloride concentration(a) and (b) and plots of lnKp against lnC0 (c) and (d)
406 RARE METALS, Vol. 31, No. 4, Aug. 2012
on sodium chloride concentration is less than that of Pb. Table 7 Apparent rate constant and correlation coefficient
However, all the dependency is slight, as can be seen in Fig. values
4, which indicates that a solid gangue layer forms and pre- Chemical Diffusion through
vents the mobilization of Ag and Pb from residuals. Reaction Reaction (Pb) the gangue layer (Pb)
condition
K’a/min−1 R2 Ka/min−1 R2
3.4 Effect of reaction temperature
The influence of reaction temperature on the Pb and Ag 318 K 0.0944 0.9936 0.0329 0.9815
leaching rates under the following conditions: time 2 h, liq- 338 K 0.1274 0.9789 0.0387 0.9926
uid/solid ratio 15, sodium chloride concentration 350 g⋅L−1, 353 K 0.1587 0.9748 0.0499 0.9948
stirring speed 400 r⋅min−1 (50 m⋅s−1), is investigated. The
results are presented in Figs.5 (a) and (b). The rate constants 368 K 0.1865 0.9666 0.0576 0.9947
and their correlation coefficients are given in Tables 6 and 7.
The plots of the right-hand side of Eq. (5) against time are It can be seen in Figs. 5 (a) and (b) that the temperature
obtained by substituting the experimental data into Eq. (5) has a noticeable influence on the extraction of Ag and Pb.
and given in Figs. 6 (a) and (b). About 47.15% for silver and 69.12% for lead in the fine
fraction of the residuals are extracted after 3.5 h at a reaction
temperature of 318 K; at 368 K, the leaching rate are
82.05% for silver and 97.29% for lead. The metal extraction
increased with increasing the temperature, which is mainly
because high temperature can increase the numbers of acti-
vated molecule and diffusion coefficient, the metal dissolu-
tion can be improved.
The experimental data in Figs. 6 (a) and (b) are approxi-
mately linear and almost goes through the origin, which also
suggests that an inner diffusion-controlled model is suitable
for this reaction process, as can be also seen from the value
of correlation coefficient values in Tables 6 and 7. The acti-
vation energy [19] of an inner diffusion-controlled process is
characterized to be 8-30 kJ·mol−1, while for a chemically
controlled process, it is usually greater than 40 kJ·mol-1. The
apparent activation energy was determined based on Ar-
rhenius equation [20]:
⎛ −E ⎞
K a = K 0 exp⎜ a ⎟ (7)
⎝ RT ⎠
where: K0 is frequency factor (min−1), Ea is apparent activa-
tion energy (kJ⋅mol−1), R is ideal gas constant (8.314
J·mol−1·K−1), T is leaching temperature (K).
To calculate the apparent activation energy, the values of
lnkp against 1000/T are plotted in Figs. 6 (c) and (d). The ac-
Fig. 5 Effect of leaching temperature on leaching efficiency tivation energy of the overall reaction is calculated to be
(HCl, 12 ml, H2O2, 15 ml)
about 26.8 kJ·mol−1 for Ag and 26.5 kJ·mol−1 for Pb. The
Table 6 Apparent rate constant and correlation coefficient frequency factor (K0) is calculated to be about 0.0399 for Ag
values
and 0.0412 for Pb. The energy values fall in the range of
Chemical Diffusion through typical inner diffusion controlled process, which supports
Reaction
reaction (Ag) the gangue layer (Ag) the conclusion that the leaching process is controlled by the
condition
K’a/min−1 R2 Ka/min−1 R2 mass transfer through the gangue product layer [21].
318 K 0.0498 0.9292 0.0227 0.999
338 K 0.0708 0.9007 0.0254 0.9966 3.5 Effect of particle size
353 K 0.0909 0.883 0.0286 0.9967 The influence of particle size on the extraction of Pb and
368 K 0.1118 0.8769 0.0329 0.9941 Ag was examined with four different size fractions (0.075~
ZHANG Yali, et al., Kinetics of simultaneous leaching of Ag and Pb from hydrometallurgical zinc residues by chloride 407
Fig. 6 Plots of leaching kinetics at different temperatures (a) and (b) and plots of lnKa against 1/T (c) and (d)
0.090 mm, 0.090~0.106 mm, 0.106~0.125 mm, 0.125~0.150 where: Ci is bulk fluid concentration (mol/L), α, β, Kd is re-
mm) at 368 K under a stirring speed of 400 r⋅min−1 (50 m⋅s−1) action order of variable C1, C2 and d0, respectively.
and sodium chloride concentration of 350 g⋅L−1. The kinetic Thus, the leaching of Pb and Ag can be presented by Eqs.
data are fitted well with Eq.(1) and the results are given in (9) and (10):
Figs. 7 (a) and (b). 2 2
−26800 ⎞
It can be seen from Figs. 7 (a) and (b) at the same leach- 1− x − (1− x) 3 = 0.0399C 0.2114 d 0−0.5678 exp⎛⎜ ⎟t (9)
3 ⎝ RT ⎠
ing time that the smaller is the particle size , the faster is the 2
2 −26500 ⎞
metal dissolution. The reason is likely that, when the total 1− x − (1− x) 3 = 0.0412C 0.0759 d 0−0.5108 exp⎛⎜ ⎟t (10)
weight is kept constant, decreasing the particle size can in- 3 ⎝ RT ⎠
crease numbers and the contact area of particles with the
fluid. The results for the effects of particle size on dissolu- 3.6 Effect of solid concentration(liquid/solid ratio)
tion were applied to this kinetic model, the apparent rate To make the leaching process analyzed with the shrink-
constant was determined. According to lnKd–lndo curve ing core model, the liquid/solid ratio of 15 was selected.
shown in Figs. 7 (c) and (d), the orders of reaction with re- However, this low solid concentration can result in more
spect to particle size (d0) were found to be inversely propor- consumption and large liquid circulation. In this work, sev-
tional to a 0.5678 power for Pb and a 0.5108 power for Ag. eral experiments were performed at other optimal leaching
Calculations show that activation energy and the orders conditions (stirring speed of 400 r⋅min−1 (50 m⋅s−1), particle
of reaction values with respect to sodium chloride concen- size of 0.075~0.090 mm and sodium chloride concentration
tration and particle size confirm to the shrinking core model of 350 g⋅L−1, time of 2 h, temperature of 368 K), and the ap-
for a diffusion controlled process. K can be expressed as the propriate liquid/solid ratio was determined. The results are
following equation [22−23]: presented in Fig. 8.
⎛ −E ⎞ As seen from Fig. 8, below liquid/solid ratio of 5, the
K = K 0 C1α ⋅C2β ⋅⋅⋅d 0Kd ⋅exp⎜ a ⎟ (8)
⎝ RT ⎠ leaching efficiency of Ag increased significantly with the
408 RARE METALS, Vol. 31, No. 4, Aug. 2012
Fig. 7 Plots of leaching kinetics at different particle sizes (a) and (b) and plots of lnKd against lnd0 (c) and (d)