Professional Documents
Culture Documents
E m p o w e r i n g t h e Wo r l d
o f Higher Education IN THIS ISSUE
6 | WHEN FACULTY DESIGN
CLASSROOMS OF THE
FUTURE
At Indiana University, faculty input is a key part
of the classroom design process.
31 | CAMPUS TECHNOLOGY
IMPACT AWARDS
The 2018 Impact Award honorees are using
tech to improve teaching and learning, streamline
operations, build community and more.
2018
CT readers vote on the best technologies in use
at their institutions.
DEPARTMENTS
T
THE EDUCAUSE ANNUAL CONFERENCE (Oct. 30-Nov. IT Restructuring and Consolidation: Lessons Learned in the issues and their potential impact. Attendee participation
2) offers something for everyone: There are tracks focused Cost-Reduction Initiatives is encouraged, so bring your questions and ideas.
on IT infrastructure, teaching and learning, IT leadership and Resource constraints are driving many IT organizations to take
more. But if you are more of a generalist, there are some a close look at efficiency and effectiveness. Hear from two Blockchains and Credentialing: Educational Use Cases
tough choices to make in terms of which sessions to attend. institutions that have completed major IT consolidation efforts and Technologies of Trust
Here are our top picks for a conference schedule that hits key and what they learned from the experience. Arizona State University’s Lev Gonick and Georgetown
topics and trends in higher ed IT. University’s Phil Long explore the potential of blockchain
Encouraging Faculty Adoption of Learning Analytics: technology to give learners ownership of their educational
Demystifying AI and Predictive Analytics in Higher Ed Whose Job Is It, Anyway? achievements.
Experts from academia and industry offer their insights into A team from Indiana University Bloomington shares how faculty
artificial intelligence and predictive analytics, including benefits involvement was key to the implementation of an institution- The Pragmatist and the Futurist
vs. hype, ethical issues and what to expect down the road. wide LMS dashboard. Consultants Bryan Alexander and Michael Johnson give their
take on emerging challenges to college and university
Applying Mixed Reality to the Classroom of the Future The Bias Truth of AI Models sustainability, the academic business model and technology’s
Learn how Case Western Reserve University is implementing Teddy Benson, director of data integration for Walt Disney role in the future of higher education.
immersive educational resources in several different contexts. World, Parks and Resorts, dives into the problem of bias making
its way into artificial intelligence systems — and how we can What Do We Owe Students When We Collect Their Data?
The Future of Higher Education: Our Response to detect and remove it. Explore the opportunities, responsibilities and ethical issues
Disruption involved in the use of student data, as well as ways to encourage
James Phelps of the University of Washington explores the The Educause 2019 Top 10 IT Issues students to have agency over their own data.
trends and challenges impacting higher education and how Get a preview of the biggest topics in higher education IT
Continue the conversation.
institutions can remain relevant in the face of change. for the coming year, with panel members on hand to discuss E-mail me at rkelly@1105media.com.
MOBILE ACCESSIBILITY. The services; career counseling; orientation; exit the Moodle Certified Partner Program. form provides tools designed for
University of California, San Diego post-enrollment services; library; students Blackboard remains committed to provid- widespread use of OER, including
has become the first Aira-enabled univer- with disabilities services; technology sup- ing clients with the most mature and stable a library of peer-reviewed content,
sity in the United States. Through Aira’s port; and graduate student services. Read Moodle-based Software as a Service customization tools, assessments,
smartphone app, low-vision users can the full story online. (SaaS) product in the market and will analytics for tracking student engage-
vectorfusionart / Shutterstock
tap a button to be put in touch with an ment and progress, LMS integration
Aira agent who serves as a visual inter- and models for financial sustainability,
preter, helping navigate around campus according to a news announcement.
or read a blackboard. The university is Read the full story online.4
offering free smartphone access to the
accessibility technology for vision-impaired
members of its entire campus community,
including students, staff and faculty.
Read the full story online.
the Florida College System, the OLC Blackboard Open LMS. The company private liberal arts college in Massa-
Quality Scorecard for Online Student Sup- said it’s also “accelerating investment and chusetts, is rolling out open education
port is designed to help identify gaps in development of the product.” According to resources across the campus thanks to
services in 11 key areas: admissions; finan- a company statement, “The rebrand fol- a partnership with learning platform pan
cial aid; pre-enrollment advising; veterans lows Blackboard’s strategic decision to Open. PanOpen’s open education plat-
*KIJGT|'FWECVKQP
MASTER’S IN
HIGHER EDUCATION ADMINISTRATION
Michael Traitov / Shutterstock
#RRN[PQYHQTHCNNURTKPIQTUWOOGT
scs.georgetown.edu/higher
4 CAMPUS TECHNOLOGY | October/November 2018
Campus +Industry
P R O D U CT F O C U S
the cloud to redesign and automate universities empower more agile business textbooks being produced by the Rice
core processes across faculty and teaching and learning, extend access University-based publisher of open educational
student operations. and improve student outcomes. resources. Read the full story online.
Sponsored by DocuSign Sponsored by Cisco Systems
es. Without leaving the tiny house, students can flow from importantly, the fellows’ designs and thinking about space styles, so it’s natural to work together across fields to
group study to formal instruction to consultation with a reaffirmed work that the Learning Spaces team is already develop shared solutions to problems with those spaces.”
professor to post-class decompressing, all in one space. engaged in. Many concepts from the fellows’ designs have By bringing together instructors with different disciplines,
The faculty also proposed a natural aesthetic by designing parallels in current IU projects, so our space designers saw we can design classrooms that support a wider variety of
ample windows to allow for sunlight and views of the out- the fellows’ work as validation that they were on target with instructional needs.
side. “We pushed ourselves to design without considering addressing current and future faculty needs. There are several ways we plan to build on the Mosaic
cost or feasibility,” Associate Professor of English and One takeaway from the symposium was recognizing the Design Symposium’s successful outcomes. In early October
Senior Mosaic Fellow Andy Buchenot explained, “but by value of engaging faculty in conversations about space that 2018, the Mosaic fellows who participated in this year’s
the end [of the symposium] we found that the principles can occur before we even conceive of spaces. Such broad- symposium will be invited to present their ideas to key stake-
er, more conceptual conversations holders in classroom design, including space planners,
“Instructional space is often shared by many about space allow for greater cre- architects, interior designers and learning space design
instructors who teach many different disciplines ativity in considering what our learn- engineers. The Learning Spaces team continues to share
ing spaces can and should be. For the Symposium Summary document with different stake-
in many different styles, so it’s natural to work example, the tiny house design holders for the purposes of incrementally including design
together across fields to develop shared solutions allowed the design team to think ideas into a variety of new spaces. The Mosaic Initiative
to problems with those spaces.” more about possible connections plans to hold a similar event with undergraduate students
— Adam Maksl, Indiana University between formal and informal learn- this academic year, bringing student ideas to both classroom
ing spaces. The conversations from space and informal learning spaces. And finally, the Mosaic
animating our infeasible design could be applied to existing the event and the Symposium Summary document have Initiative will hold the Design Symposium event again next
learning spaces as well.” already served as a source of inspiration for current and year, inviting all IU faculty to participate with the aim to
The classroom designs that the Mosaic fellows generated new projects. broaden our conversation and come up with new future
during the symposium served as valuable inspiration and Another takeaway was the need to involve different disci- classroom designs to implement across the university.
feedback for the Learning Spaces team. The fellows shared plines in the design of classroom spaces. As Mosaic Fel-
new ideas and approaches to design concepts and did so low Adam Maksl, associate professor of journalism, put it: Tracey Birdwell is program director for the Mosaic Initia-
from a faculty perspective — bringing ideas to the fore that “Instructional space is often shared by many instructors tive at Indiana University. Julie Johnston is the director of
only those who teach in the space can produce. Just as who teach many different disciplines in many different Learning Spaces for Indiana University.
The nature of our jobs is relatively cyclical — for me, those cycles occur in roughly
14- to 18-month intervals. That gives you some idea of what is going to happen each
year — allowing you to plan and budget accordingly. At peak times — the budgeting
period for next fiscal year, the end of the current fiscal year, the start of the semester,
installations over summer and holiday breaks — a hired consultant can truly shine. Here
are three ways a consultant can be a big help as you deploy new technology, manage
the technology, keep projects flowing and keep users happy.
2) Helping with System Checks and QA implement your established standards across every project.
For some people on campus, summer is a quiet time. But in Splitting the wall elevation drawings, equipment lists,
AV services, summer means the added workload of installing electrical considerations, project management, system
new tech while the college is still actively filling the dorm commissioning, etc. can frankly help improve your work life
rooms and classrooms with students and off-campus groups and ensure a successful project.
as alternative sources of revenue. The phone does not stop In order to work with a consultant this way, there are two
ringing, and the projects need to be completed. As you things that you need to do. The first is to document the
commission your systems, hiring a consultant to perform the work that you are doing, either through some sort of project
final checks in the install can help immensely. If you have management/ticketing software or by keeping track of your
enough time to plan, you can create a standard system time manually. When it comes time to make the justification
verification checklist with your consultant, and possibly even for a consultant, you will need the data to show that the
have a well-trained AV tech student go through the checklist. extra help is warranted. The second is to find a consultant
A consultant can also assist with quality assurance checks nearby who you can establish a relationship with. Ask your
on installations as they occur. Often on campus we have two fellow tech managers if they have any recommendations, or
to three installations occurring at a time — and if you are on see if you can work a little closer to the architect’s consul-
the same page with your consultant, he or she can become tant during the next big renovation.
an extension of your install expectations and enable you to As you are able to integrate a consultant into your work-
stay on track with multiple large installations at once. flow, you will find that you are more easily able to respond to
last-minute requests and your installations will go more
received — and will probably catch 99 percent of the poten- 3) Sharing the Workload smoothly. Being able to identify periods of high workload
tial issues. Many technology managers find there are rela- Lastly, on the truly large projects, simply being able to ahead of time and responding accordingly, potentially months
GAMECHANGER R E T H I N K I N G H O W T E C H N O L O G Y I S U S E D I N E D U C AT I O N
vectorfusionart/Shutterstock
Sixty-four percent of cloud migration projects took longer to
complete than planned, and 55 percent went over budget.
A lack of expertise and competing IT priorities were among
the biggest reasons for these problems.
GAMECHANGER R E T H I N K I N G H O W T E C H N O L O G Y I S U S E D I N E D U C AT I O N
The survey polled more than 200 IT professionals from a and technology standardization and consolidation in advance can be significant, Reinitz said.
variety of industries, 10 percent of whom work in education. of a cloud migration can reduce complexities and improve IT “The capacity, resilience, speed and scalability associated
The survey results suggest that moving to the cloud takes operations. Make sure you know which existing systems must with cloud technologies offer a level of service that most
a great deal of time — and focus. Campus technology leaders be able to communicate with new cloud applications and how institutions are not able to provide on their own,” she observed.
need to be very deliberate in making the move and develop a you will achieve this integration. Map all related workflows as “And by moving systems out of an on-premises environment,
cloud migration plan that outlines all of the steps that have to well, and try to streamline these wherever possible. IT leaders have an opportunity to change their focus away from
occur and who will be responsible for each of these actions. Through careful planning, you can realize the benefits of simply providing technical support and toward a richer role
From a technical aspect, one of priorities for that plan moving to the cloud with minimal difficulty. These benefits through the support and enablement of institutional goals.”
should be managing and integrating data.
“The IT environment for most institutions includes a mix of
cloud and on-premises services, all generating and using data
IN DEVELOPING YOUR CLOUD
that are critical to daily operations and long-term decision-
making capabilities,” said Betsy Tippens Reinitz, director
MIGRATION STRATEGY, IT’S
of the Enterprise IT Program for Educause. “Managing this
IMPORTANT TO UNDERSTAND
hybrid environment and making sure that data are managed HOW THE NEW CLOUD
and integrated properly and securely has become a big ENVIRONMENT WILL FIT IN
challenge for IT leaders.” WITH YOUR EXISTING DATA,
In developing your cloud migration strategy, it’s important TECHNOLOGIES AND
vectorfusionart/Shutterstock
to understand how the new cloud environment will fit in with
WORKFLOWS.
your existing data, technologies and workflows. Start by doing a
comprehensive audit of your current IT infrastructure, and carefully
map each element to the new cloud environment. Application
GAMECHANGER R E T H I N K I N G H O W T E C H N O L O G Y I S U S E D I N E D U C AT I O N
MOVING TO THE CLOUD can be challenging, but 1) IDENTIFY A STRONG BUSINESS CASE. 3) CHOOSE THE RIGHT SOLUTION.
it doesn’t have to be that way. A well thought-out cloud Before moving to the cloud, consider: What are the goals of When evaluating possible solutions, consider not just the tech-
migration strategy can make this process go much more your college or university — and how can cloud technology nology but also the provider. This should be a company that
smoothly. Here are seven steps that will improve your support these? For instance, are you looking to improve the will serve as a trusted partner in your move to the cloud, not
chances of success. experience of students or staff? Support student success? just a technology vendor. Your cloud solution provider should
Improve operational efficiency? be a responsible steward of your institution’s data and should
“IT leaders must promote a cloud strategy that focuses support you through every step of the migration process.
on delivering the most business value to the institution,” said
Betsy Tippens Reinitz, director of the Enterprise IT Program 4) PREPARE.
for Educause. “An understanding of institutional goals is vi- Just as moving from one residence to another is simpler
tal to decision-making.” when you get rid of the things you don’t need, migrating to
the cloud becomes much easier if you prepare for the move
2) ASSESS YOUR NEEDS. by cleaning up your data. Use this as an opportunity to cor-
Once your goals in moving to the cloud are clear, you need rect or remove corrupt or inaccurate information before
to understand your business process requirements so that moving data over to the new system. Evaluate any custom-
you can choose the right solution for your needs. Make sure izations that have been made to on-premises applications,
winul/Shutterstock
you consult with all stakeholder groups who will be affected to determine which will be important going forward — and
by the change to learn what they are looking for in a solution. which will not. And make sure you’re running the latest ver-
GAMECHANGER R E T H I N K I N G H O W T E C H N O L O G Y I S U S E D I N E D U C AT I O N
rawpixel/Shutterstock
based environment. Wherever these don’t align, work with the
affected stakeholders to create new protocols. Also, establish
clear policies and procedures governing data security, permis-
sions and the setup of user profiles within the new system.
GAMECHANGER R E T H I N K I N G H O W T E C H N O L O G Y I S U S E D I N E D U C AT I O N
MOVING TO THE CLOUD is not much different than any other technology migration, according
to Geof Corb, vice president of customer success for Oracle Higher Education. As with other IT imple-
rangizzz/Shutterstock
mentations, focusing on communication and change management is essential for success.
In fact, it would not be a stretch to say that the biggest hurdle in moving to the cloud isn’t
technological, he asserted — it’s cultural.
“Moving to the cloud involves shifting the mindset of an institution,” said Corb, who was
deputy CIO at Johns Hopkins University before joining Oracle. In many ways, he said, success
is defined by how well an institution — and its IT staff in particular — adopts this change in
mindset.
GAMECHANGER R E T H I N K I N G H O W T E C H N O L O G Y I S U S E D I N E D U C AT I O N
One of the key advantages of moving to a cloud-based exchange information in real time.
environment is the agility this brings to the delivery of ap- The role of IT managers must evolve as well. “Modern For more information, please visit:
plications. Because software updates happen automati- IT managers are doing a tremendous amount of contract Oracle.com/higher-education
cally in the cloud, institutions no longer have to spend a lot management, because they are dealing with many cloud
of time and resources in deploying them. But this advan- vendors,” Corb explained. “They are doing a great deal of
tage is lost if IT staff are still locked into the old mindset of integration and vendor management. They become much
developing highly customized applications by creating a more of a technology-savvy business person, rather than
number of extensions and unique configurations. the other way around.”
If you’ve made several modifications to your software
over the years, take some time to evaluate which of these NO NEED TO GO IT ALONE
is worth preserving in your new cloud environment, Corb Working with a proven cloud provider who is responsive
recommended — and which you can live without. “In my ex- to your institution’s needs and who serves as a full part-
perience, a number of these customizations were personal ner in your cloud migration project can help you manage
preferences,” he said. “If challenged, they couldn’t stand this change effectively.
up.” “You want there to be a relationship that goes
beyond the transaction itself,” Corb said. “At the end
STAFF EXPERTISE MUST EVOLVE of the day, the cloud is simply an implementation detail.
The skill sets involved in shifting from an environment of cus- If I’m a registrar or a dean, it shouldn’t matter where
tomization to one of configuration must change as well, Corb the code is executing. It’s more about: Did we listen to
rangizzz/Shutterstock
observed. Instead of a cadre of software engineers who cus- everyone’s voices, and did we effectively lead them
tomize application source code,, institutions will need busi- through this change? Did we capture their requirements
ness process analysts and systems integrators: people who appropriately and determine the right solution to help
understand how to make various systems communicate and them? Those are the things that matter the most.”
anytime.” As a result, “naïve, gullible, desperate students just get sucked in,” said
Sutherland-Smith. (One site, UnemployedProfessors.com, suggests to potential NEED A SUBSCRIPTION?
customers that it provides the only reasonable alternative to intractable professors
who won’t give extensions due to active military missions, accidents that put students
in the hospital or English learners struggling to keep up in class.)
Thomas Mays, an associate professor at the Middletown Campus of Miami
University in Ohio, would likely agree with Sutherland-Smith’s assessment. In
“Promoting Academic Integrity in Online Courses,” a recent Online Learning
Consortium session, he told attendees, “[Contract cheating is] very difficult to catch.
It takes faculty members who have academic dishonesty on mind and are actually
looking for these things rather consistently. It’s easy to gloss over it and totally miss it.”
More broadly, Miami U has seen the cases of academic dishonesty increasing year
over year. While there were 460 cases identified during 2015-2016, that grew to
more than 500 cases in 2016-2017, Mays reported. And, the institution is “on track
to go beyond that this year,” he said.
What May can’t say for certain is whether the growth is because “students have less
integrity or that we’re just better at reporting it.” The go-to resource for campus professionals —
providing in-depth coverage on the technologies
and implementations influencing colleges and
The Nature of the Beast
universities across the nation.
Contract cheating takes place when a student has somebody else do all or part of the
work and then hands it in as his or her own. It could be a specific paper or some other
assessment task, or it could involve getting somebody else to take an entire course on
SIGN UP TODAY
behalf of the student (more easily accomplished in an online class). The cheating could
be for pay or it could be performed by a supportive friend or family member. Standard
IT’S FREE!
plagiarism checkers don’t catch these incidents because, frequently, the providers
promise “all original work” with “0 percent plagiarism.” (For proof, suggested Mays,
campustechnology.com/subscribe
20 CAMPUS TECHNOLOGY | October/November 2018
ANTI-P LAG IAR I S M TO O LS
just do a search for “research paper” on Twitter and follow — a pre-work module that might include course basics, but
the responses students get when they tweet complaints also includes an academic integrity sub-module laying out the
about their latest assignments.) guidelines, created by the teaching community, that can be
A
By posing as help services, many of the companies operating imported into the course with a couple of mouse clicks. And
uthorship Investigation is a new service announced (but not
in this space tap into the desperation students feel when early in the semester each year, Deakin’s student association yet released) by Turnitin specifically to combat contract
they’re overwhelmed. As Mays observed, schools have to get hosts a “contract cheating awareness week” on each of the cheating by comparing aspects of the file’s authorship, such
at “the heart of why students cheat. In many cases it’s because university’s three campuses to educate students about as readability, punctuation, vocabulary, file naming and changes in
they’re stressed out. It’s not because they don’t necessarily academic integrity, citing resources and references and how layout. According to the company’s public statements, the application
will use “a combination of machine learning algorithms and forensic
know what plagiarism is.” to spot unethical providers.
linguistic best practices to detect major differences in students’
And sometimes, the cheating happens accidentally. “The Awareness efforts also need to cover the “serious long-term
writing style between papers.” Wendy Sutherland-Smith, director of
thing is, you can tell students not to do something, but if they ramifications of this,” said Sutherland-Smith. Students may teaching and learning in Deakin University’s School of Psychology,
don’t understand what it is they’re not meant to do, then it not get caught right away; they may even believe they’ve has tested the technology and found it to be “impressive” in terms
makes no difference,” said Sutherland-Smith. “There’s been gotten away with cheating once their degree is in hand. “But of the “breadth of the forensic linguistics and what the software is
quite a bit of research about [telling students] in the unit guide what happens if all of a sudden you’re found out five years doing in terms of looking for writing style.”
Specifically, Deakin has run a trial of the software against historical
or in the syllabus, ‘Don’t engage in plagiarism [and] reference down the track and your degree is revoked and you can no
cases — situations where instances of contract cheating were
your stuff properly.’ But if students don’t know what that looks longer work in that profession? Students need to understand
proven. The technology could be invaluable in large-enrollment
like or they think they’re already doing that, you get into a that the quick fix of getting something contract cheated could
courses where faculty don’t have the time to get familiar with every
situation where students are very fearful. So you’ll get a citation cost them dearly in the end.” student’s writing style. “We don’t have the time and we don’t have
at the end of every sentence because they don’t want to be the resources to be able to do that kind of metadata comparison.
caught for plagiarism, which, of course, is not what you want The Good and Bad of Tech Solutions We just don’t have the staff to do it,” Sutherland-Smith explained.
either.” Her remedy: to show students examples and have Both institutions also turn to technology to help out. For “That’s where something like this tool is really useful. It can check
a number of files. It can do it quickly.”
them practice. example, Miami currently uses Proctorio, one of myriad
Her concern, however, is that the results will be misunderstood in
But that’s not all. Like many institutions, both Deakin and online proctoring services. According to a faculty
the same way they are for those who use the text-matching
Miami have specific ongoing educational strategies to help explanation, the software is useful for locking down the program. “The tool will not detect contract cheating,” she said. “The
students understand the rules of academic integrity. At Miami, browser for face-to-face class exams and recording tool will only supply data that warrants further investigation by
instructors are encouraged to use a “module zero” approach student activities and geographic location for online people like me.”
assessments. The program flags potential cheating and Technology isn’t a failsafe, use content positively identified by the software as a duplicate
generates a report for the instructor.
especially when a faculty or pulled from somewhere else that might be exactly what the
In addition, Turnitin is in use at Miami as well as Deakin. instructor said to use. All those nuances feed into a score that
This widely used plagiarism detection tool checks student staff member isn’t fully trained could generate suspicions.
papers against a multitude of sources (including other on the use of it. “The tool was never, ever about plagiarism detection,” she
papers already submitted) to identify those containing asserted. “The tool’s only ever about providing evidence from
unoriginal work. At Deakin, according to Sutherland-Smith, text matching. From there it has to be a human decision.”
students upload their papers to the service, which generates
a “similarity report.” This report, which instructors may A Better Alternative: Authentic Assessment
request be handed in with the student assignment, includes Another aspect of the solution, noted both educators, is to
a similarity score that summarizes the amount of matching come up with assessment designs that are tougher to hire
or similar text found in the paper. contract cheating companies to produce. One way to do that
But technology isn’t a failsafe, Sutherland-Smith added, is to make the assignment “authentic and local,” said
especially when a faculty or staff member isn’t fully trained on Sutherland-Smith. It might require the student to use locally
the use of it. She first learned of Turnitin in 2001, during a gathered data or information that’s hard for contracting
university pilot to test the service. “Part of what we found in cheating companies to get their hands on in time to complete
that pilot trial was that staff would misinterpret the information a given assignment, she offered.
they were getting. We found that staff would just look at the Mays, who teaches Excel courses, has modified his
total percentage and go, ‘All right. It’s a 75 percent text match; assignments to force the inclusion of something original. He’ll
[that means the paper is] 75 percent plagiarized.’” In reality, have the students create and customize a chart based on the
there can be many factors behind that number. data in a table and then have them write an essay that analyzes
As a guide on the Turnitin website itself laid out, “If the the results. “I have caught several students who have totally
student has used quotes and has referenced correctly, there copied everything,” he said. “Since I grade everything in one
will be instances where we will find a match.” Or the user may sitting, I can remember when one chart looks similar, which
not exclude “small sources” or “quotes and bibliography makes life easier on the detection end.” Or he might ask
items.” Sometimes, added Sutherland-Smith, a student will students to create a macro and do a save-as to record the full
path of where that file was created. purchased from contract cheating websites. As the researchers
Ultimately, the best solution may
Mays advised more frequent “lower-stakes assessments” to noted, “Sensitivity analyses showed markers detected
replace courses that rely on a midterm, a final and a lone paper contract cheating 62 percent of the time. Specificity analyses require human intervention: a
for grading. For example, the instructor might require multiple showed markers correctly identified real student work 96 faculty member taking the time
drafts. That prevents what he called “one-time transactions” percent of the time.”
with a contract cheating company. “If you’re doing it in steps, A follow-up study on a much wider group, awaiting publication,
to talk with the student whose
where you have multiple drafts to do, either the student is found similar results. “You can train markers to look for contract future could be at stake.
going to submit sub-par work for the drafts and then go buy cheating and quite successfully detect it,” she said.
the real essay — and you can obviously notice the difference And that gets at the central message when it comes to
in the quality — or they’re going to have to go back to the cornering contract cheating. While the various mechanisms
contract cheater for each draft.” for cutting down on contract cheating certainly hobble the
He also encouraged the use of tests that don’t reuse racket, ultimately, the best solution may require human
questions, either by scrambling their order or having multiple intervention: a faculty member taking the time to talk with the
editions, and using time limits on test-taking. Then there’s the student whose future could be at stake.
addition of “oral components,” which, if it’s an online course, It doesn’t have to take long, she insisted. Even a three-
may require video monitoring to make sure the student and minute conversation will divulge tons. She uses questions
not a proxy is making the recording. such as, “I’m really interested — that particular piece of
literature seems to be a little out of left field. How did you
Talking With Students come across that?” or “What drew you to that piece of
While contract cheaters tell prospects their approach is literature?” or “Why did you think that fitted in with everything
undetectable, Sutherland-Smith takes issue with that claim. else that we’ve covered in class?” “They’re not difficult
A research team at her institution ran a pilot study in which questions,” she pointed out, “but if you haven’t done the work,
“markers” were paid to read through a mix of “student work” you’re not going to know the answer.”
to find out how accurate they were in detecting contract
cheating. Seven people marked the same bundle of 20 Dian Schaffhauser is a senior contributing editor for
second-year psychology assignments, including six that were Campus Technology.
Sabelskaya / Shutterstock
it’s not necessarily the right approach for every project. Here are some best practices for agile success.
THE BUSINESS INTELLIGENCE TEAM at
George Washington University in Washington, DC, has changed
the way it works with partners across GWU’s business and academic
units. Rather than settling on all of a dashboard project’s parameters
up front, they now work in two-week “sprints” and have a quarterly
product release cycle. “During that transition from one release to the
next, we meet with our business intelligence guidance team made up
of community members across campus,” said Mike Wolf, director of
business intelligence. “They tell us what the priorities are for the next
release and we follow that process all the way through.”
More prevalent in the private sector than in government or higher
education, “agile” project management breaks software projects up
into short sprints of a few weeks. The traditional software develop-
ment approach, in which requirements and budgets are firmly estab-
lished upfront and each phase of a project is completed before mov-
ing to the next, is referred to as “waterfall.” The goal of agile is to end
up with fewer failed software development projects in which the
internal customers are dissatisfied with the results.4
key is applying the methodology to the right kind of projects, not just across the
board. You have to have the right timing and the right work. For instance, if it is enroll- 2019 IMPACT AWARDS CALL FOR
NOMINATIONS IS NOW OPEN.
ment season, you don’t want to do agile work on the enrollment system. You look for
SUBMIT YOURS TODAY!
opportunities and when you find the right projects you pounce on them.”4
CampusTechnology.com/Impact
25 CAMPUS TECHNOLOGY | October/November 2018
IT TRENDS
Greeves added that she has been impressed by how the the identification of roles. We have to know who we are
agile movement has spread from the BI team to other going to sit down with most frequently and who has the
areas of IT. The EIS team, the web services team, the authority to make decisions about building the backlog of
Sharepoint services team and the library are all adopting what is important.”
the methodology. Roljevic said that when agile was first introduced in busi-
T
“I am eager for us to build that mindset going forward — ness intelligence, the business people quickly realized the
fully focusing on training and how we can have everybody benefit of having direct input on how a dashboard might he Web and Technology Services team in the Division of
in IT understand the terminology,” Greeves said. (For look. “At the beginning some people were skeptical, but Student Affairs at California State University, Northridge
instance, an agile framework for iterative change is called they soon realized that every two weeks they would have has turned to agile in working with a few of its internal
customers, according to Paul Schantz, the team’s director.
a “scrum,” and the person leading the collaborative effort an opportunity to shape that product. They also realized
“We had a couple of customers we were building applications
is called the “scrum master.”) that this allows them to get their top priorities met and they
for using waterfall and it didn’t really work out. We were setting
Last fall, GWU created an agile steering committee that can always re-prioritize. They can get the most important milestones that were not realistic,” he said. “We adopted agile for
included members from IT as well as individuals from things done.” a couple of these projects serving students with disabilities, and
other groups on campus who could help IT think about the engagement with the customer is what ended up selling it.
the best implementation practices. “We invited core mem- Experimenting With Agile at Harvard The people who were direct stakeholders were engaged every step
of the way. They became the biggest cheerleaders for this process.
bers of the university community from both the academic A few years ago, Harvard University Information Technol-
It is a fundamental realignment of the IT-customer relationship.
and business sides, and representatives from the librar- ogy (HUIT) began experimenting with agile for a small
The customer is driving this.”
ies,” Wolf said. number of key strategic programs that needed to deliver Schantz shared his team’s success with a university vice
He admits that they occasionally struggle with getting business value quickly through iteration. In e-mailed president, who was impressed enough to host multi-day training
effective participation from customers who have a lot of responses to questions from Campus Technology, several sessions for the whole campus. “That was to seed the idea across
other irons in the fire. The people they deal with fall into two HUIT members made observations about their experience campus. We were under no illusions people would start adopting
it en masse,” he said. But one department liked it so much that
categories, Wolf noted: “The first is people we have dealt to date. “Agile better meets our need to show our work to
when they redesigned office space they created a ‘scrum room.’”
with before in this process and they pick it up quickly. The our business partners and provides opportunities to make
He cautioned, however, against IT leadership getting caught up
second involves customers we have not intersected with changes along the way — something that the waterfall in taking shortcuts or using buzzwords. “They will say agile, but
yet, so we have to help them prepare to work in an agile method didn’t always allow for,” said Tamara Larsen, infra- for them it just means you are working faster vs. actually using it
fashion. We do some training to introduce concepts and structure technology services director, DevOps. “Once as a methodology for getting things done.”
agile was established in those strategic programs, other mental changes on a continuous basis, synchronized to
teams began to see the value and then began to adopt each milestone of the academic year. “The process — and
agile as well.” the trust it allowed us to build over time with stakeholders
The my.harvard student information system was one of — also enabled us to emphasize the highest-value features
the first programs to adopt agile methodologies, because and to avoid some of the feature bloat common to ERP
it enabled HUIT to balance the competing demands of system implementations,” Shaffner said.
diverse constituencies in a time of rapid change to aca- Agile does require some training. Harvard IT leadership
created an in-house training program, the IT Academy, a
SMART RECRUITING
Oracle’s Student Recruiting module uses the information captured
during prospecting, as well as data gathered from mining a student’s
Monkey Business Images/Shutterstock.com
Advanced analytics can help colleges and universities Cloud includes a Student Financial Planning component that
identify the student engagement and success factors that helps students stay on track with their finances.
are unique to their institution. For instance, Valdosta State At the institutional level, when Student Cloud is integrated
University in Georgia worked with Oracle to uncover key trends with Oracle’s HCM and ERP solutions, campus administrators
and determine which metrics play a significant role in retention have access to all of the information they need to make better
and completion. decisions and manage the cost of an education, Rajecki
By combining and analyzing data from multiple sources, pointed out.
including student surveys and ID card usage, Valdosta State “Having a fully integrated solution in a single cloud
determined that students who eat breakfast on campus have environment helps campus leaders make timely decisions
a 10 percent higher retention rate, which led administrators based on real-time data, giving them much more control over
to promote on-campus eateries. With the help of this simple institutional finances,” he said. Through data visualization
change, the university increased student retention by more dashboards, administrators can see how factors such as
than 2 percent in one year. student and course enrollment, faculty workloads and the
In addition, Valdosta State discovered that freshmen who resource requirements of classrooms affect their budgets.
work on campus have a much higher retention rate than the With adaptive, cloud-based intelligence at their fingertips,
general freshman population (85 percent vs. 55 percent). higher education leaders can glean powerful insights, Rajecki
DEEPER ENGAGEMENT Equipped with this information, the university made a $200,000 concluded — enabling them to support student success more
For students to succeed, they not only need the right supports, investment in student jobs on campus, which is expected to effectively.
but also must be fully engaged in their education. save $2 million in student retention costs over four years. says Miller. “Colleges and universities need a flexible system
“Engagement is about more than just attending classes to support and manage those use cases appropriately.”
and turning in assignments,” Rajecki said. “We have seen POWERFUL INSIGHT
that institutions offering additional services to keep students Finances are another common reason why students drop
engaged have higher retention and graduation rates. The more out of college: Many students simply can’t afford the courses For more information, please
ase visit:
affinity that students have for the institution, and the greater they need to complete their degree program. Having access tion
Oracle.com/higher-education
their feeling of belonging, the higher their rate of success.” to sound financial information is critical — and Oracle Student
Ermolaev Alexander/Shutterstock.com
2018
We are pleased to present the repicients of this year’s Impact
Awards — 14 institutions using technology to improve teaching
and learning, streamline campus operations, build community
and more. By Rhea Kelly, David Raths and Dian Schaffhauser
T
ECHNOLOGY PROJECTS IN higher education can be truly
inspiring — not just because of their breadth or depth, but also
because of the impact they have on students, faculty and staff. The
Campus Technology Impact Awards, now in their second year, are
our way of recognizing that impact — honoring important work that is really
making a difference on campus and beyond.
For 2018, we are pleased to present 14 awardees in five categories:
Teaching and Learning, IT Infrastructure and Systems; Student Systems and
Services; Administration; and Education Futurists. Final winner selection
was guided by our Impact Awards Judging Committee members (see “Our
Judges,” page 46), who graciously volunteered their time and expertise to
review each nomination. Virtual reality in class at North
In the following pages, we will profile four of the winning projects — with more Carolina State University
(see page 32)
to come in the next few issues of Campus Technology. For the complete list of
winners, see page 44. Congratulations to all our Impact Award honorees! 4
but the group was ready to move beyond text- and cartoon-
based training for some of its scenarios.
After a lot of brainstorming for this “side project,” as
Misaras called it, GTI settled on the idea of creating 360-
degree videos. She wrote the script, and DELTA Creative
Director Michael Cuales concocted a custom rig with three
cameras to do the filming. All aspects of production were
handled in-house. Among the technologies involved: Kolor’s
Autopano Video software for processing the raw 360 video
array; Adobe Creative Suite for editing, masking and ren-
dering final video content; WondaVR for the development of
interactive 360 video experiences; and Moodle for delivery
of the course module. The work was started in fall 2016 and In NC State’s “First Impressions” VR experience, students attend a simulated
finished for piloting by students in spring 2017. business meeting from the point of view of one of the meeting participants.
For this first campus VR project, the university acquired
about a dozen Samsung GearVR headsets and requisite
sual and audible presence that differs from traditional me- get it. I understand his reasoning now.’”
phones, which meant the testing could only be done with
dia forms. That’s why Misaras considers the use of VR The use of VR for this kind of scenario-based experi-
smaller groups. That setup also turned out to be a limiting
so important to the effort. “There’s an element of novelty, ence could have application outside of school too, Misaras
factor, since faculty and assistants had to grapple with tech-
of course. It’s a new technology so it’s really cool [and] observed, where people need to have real conversations
nical issues that popped up with that combination of devices.
that gets them in the door,” she admitted. “But I think the with each other: “OK, I might not agree with you politically,
Since then, the school has purchased a classroom-sized
virtual reality helps with building empathy because you’re but instead of calling you a stupid idiot, let’s figure out, what
inventory of phoneless Oculus Go headsets, which is expect-
experiencing the meeting through someone else’s eyes were your experiences? What brought you to your beliefs
ed to minimize the amount of technical dinking required and
and you’re hearing their thoughts. You become that per- and how you see the world? What are your values? It’s not
will allow GTI to scale usage. That’s timely because although
son, even if you don’t agree with what they’re thinking or just for engineering or business. It’s for any kind of relation-
the original use of the system was among engineering stu-
saying, even if that’s not what you personally hold as your ship building.”
dents, GTI is seeing interest percolate in other disciplines too
point of view. We found that students will tend to argue
— starting with the school of business, which wants to use the
that point of view more. What we’ve heard is, ‘I don’t nec- Dian Schaffhauser is a senior contributing editor for
training as part of the orientation for new MBA students.
essarily agree with this guy and what he’s thinking, but I Campus Technology.
The resulting experience gives students a sense of vi-
The university chose Apple’s iBeacon software app to display as a student is searching for a book.
over other vendor offerings because the protocol The initial student response to the rollout has
was easiest to implement, noted Dent. “We went been very positive, Dent said. “Students appreci-
with this product because of its dashboard — the ate that this task is now supported by technology.”
idea that it is very simple to reprogram a beacon that She expects an initial spike in use because of the
needs to be moved and any one of us can do it. We novelty aspect. “When it levels off, we hope to see
don’t have to be a developer to figure out how to do an increase in circulation.” To sustain usage, the li-
it. The other products weren’t at the same level as brary plans to work with faculty members. “If they
far as user experience from the administrative end.” suggest that students use the app in a syllabus, for
Web & Emerging Technologies team member
Programming was done using the Ionic Frame- instance, the connection to coursework is more ap-
Ann Jusino
work, a free, open source, multi-platform software parent than if the library just advertises a new app.”
development kit for mobile applications. The BKFINDr app is not a stand-alone project. It
One challenge the design team ran into involved was designed to be implemented as a package with
tweaking the sensitivity and placement of the bea- two other mobile apps developed to help students
cons. The placement on library bookshelves had to in the library. One, called InQuery, helps students
be carefully designed so that users would not get use library resources to write research papers; the
conflicting location notifications. To address this other is a mobile book checkout app. “With these
problem, St. John’s created an algorithm to control three apps, students can complete the process of
the variability of beacon signal strength. The algo- finding a resource, getting the resource and leav-
rithm allows for the weighted total of signals emitted ing the library,” Dent explained. “It simulates in the
within a certain timespan to be used as an indicator digital space those three actions that most of our
of the beacon likely to be closest to the user. This users take at some point.”
means that the user is far more likely to receive the The three apps are part of a larger strategy to move
most accurate location notification. “We don’t want toward an environment that is mostly mobile. “As we
students walking into a space and getting pinged uncover additional services that can be mobilized,”
from two different beacons,” Dent said. Dent said, “that is what we are aiming to do.”
The project team also had to work with develop-
ers of the library catalog, which was built using open David Raths is a freelance writer based in Mobile developer Kiichi Takeuchi
source tools, to pull the correct metadata into the Philadelphia.
2015 when a team of faculty members and instructional both complement and supplement the text, the authors cre-
designers at Columbus State Community College ated videos, interviews, animations, photo galleries, virtual
(OH) began looking for a low-cost textbook option for the spaces, interactive objects and quizzes, and links to other
school’s online first-year English composition course, resources and readings on the web.
they opted to create their own. One goal was to help students see the real-world appli-
Three years later, CSCC’s “iComp: A Guide to First- cations of the writing skills they are learning. For example,
Year Writing” Multi-Touch iBook has completed a two- the project team linked to sites such as NPR’s StoryCorps
semester, seven-class pilot phase and is now being rolled and created activities around them so students can see
out to four courses. According to the project team, the book how people develop and use narratives for varied academ-
eliminates the need for traditional textbooks and re-frames ic, professional and personal purposes.
the ways students engage with course material. While it is Before setting out to create an interactive textbook, the
important that students are saving money, the hope is that CSCC team looked at existing attempts at composition e-
the innovative curriculum design will increase student suc- books and were not impressed. “They were static,” LaMar
cess and retention. said. “They were like glorified PowerPoint presentations.”
“We wanted to have the textbook be something stu- But he added that creating an e-textbook for composition
dents are constantly interacting with as a means of doing does present thorny challenges. In STEM fields, there is
the work, not a supplementary thing,” explained Nicholas objective content to be learned. This project involved con-
Lakostik, an associate professor of rhetoric and composi- cepts that were more subjective and contextual.
tion and one of the four authors of the book. The first pilot group was made up of high school
Composition class is about reading and writing, but students getting dual credit in community college. “We
the iBook allows students with different learning styles to have a facilitated model with students doing work in an
engage with the material, noted Jason LaMar, supervisor online shell,” Lakostik explained. “An instructor at our cam-
of instructional technology innovations in the Digital Edu- pus is the instructor of record, and an instructor in their CSCC’s iComp e-book
cation and Instructional Services division. “There are a lot high schools serves as a facilitator and gives students
Own Apple Device” (BYOAD) sections in order to access
of video clips and audio segments, as well as interactive feedback.”
the e-book.
pieces that are tactile,” he added. “Tapping into all those CSCC next integrated iComp into its distance learn-
For the upcoming semester, CSCC is changing the way
learning styles was a huge benefit of the platform.” ing courses and created a full 16-week course and as-
it advertises the course sections using the iComp book.
The iComp e-book is organized so that each chapter signments in the Blackboard learning management sys-
“We had students who had no idea they had signed up
leads students through a specific type of essay writing. To tem. Students register for specially designated “Bring Your
for an Apple class,” LeMar said. For the fall, the BYOAD
39 CAMPUS TECHNOLOGY | October/November 2018
2018
classes will be the first four sections listed with a big font and we wanted to see it through and
that says an Apple device is required. Another goal is to have enough time to do it the way we
develop a blended modality version of the course (an on- wanted to do it.”
line course with required real-time, face-to-face sessions). From the instructional design side,
iComp was created in Apple’s iBooks Author, with tools iComp was an interesting project be-
such as Adobe’s Premiere and After Effects used to en- cause it was the only e-book the team
hance and edit video clips and Apple’s Keynote used to had worked on that involved four au-
create interactive widgets. thors, each with their own chapter
The project team acknowledged that there are pros and own unique voice, LeMar said.
and cons to developing in an Apple-only environment. “The But both the authors and design-
overarching con is that you can only engage on a Mac or ers described being surprised by the
iOS device in the fully interactive way,” LeMar said. And the amount of work it took to see some
advantages? “Basically everything else,” he said. “There of the digital learning objects from
is not a better e-book development platform out there. concept to completion. The process
Nothing else allows you to incorporate audio and video so included composing multiple drafts of
seamlessly,” he added. “It has great built-in features such scripts and storyboards, searching for
as a popup glossary.” licensed images, recording audio and
The college is still working through whether to remain video, and editing and combining raw
The iComp e-book features interactive widgets, videos
Apple-centered or become more device-agnostic. footage.
and other multimedia elements.
The project required the e-book authors and instruc- Now CSCC, which had never
tional technology staff to work through several issues on before published a book, is working
ing also may be difficult. “We try to have them be reflective
the fly. There were questions about permissions, intellec- through other logistical issues. The team’s intent is to have
about their work. When they submit commentary about the
tual property and royalties. “The biggest one for us was the iComp book available in the Apple iBooks store this
challenges they faced, what they learned and their writing
realizing that writing a textbook is different than writing an autumn. It is not clear what the price point is going to be
process, we can glean a bit from that,” Lakostik said. “We
assignment or course notes,” Lakostik said. “Working with or whether it is going to remain free for students. “We are
did surveys of students at the midterm and end of semester
the instructional designers, we had to become the subject- working through the nuances of requiring it for a course,
and asked if this was helping their writing. The results were
matter experts and get their help in how best to explain the and what it means for financial aid and for the bookstore,”
positive, but it was a small sample size.”
concepts. We had to negotiate roles and advocate for the LeMar said. “There are a lot of moving parts.”
importance of the project. It got changed several times, Assessing the impact of the iComp book on student writ-
David Raths is a freelance writer based in Philadelphia.
40 CAMPUS TECHNOLOGY | October/November 2018
2018
the captioning in a self-service mode. However, bersome. “We were having a hard time getting
that level of faculty involvement came with anoth- people to implement something that is federal
er requirement: making the solution easier to use. law,” Cameron added.
“My mantra was always if it is going to be more The legacy solution also required a substan-
difficult than YouTube, we don’t want it,” said Jor- tial lead time for captioning while courses were
dan Cameron, assistant director for academic being created. “As faculty were developing a new
web accessibility. “We kept working on usability online course for the next year, we would advise
with the vendor, and they were very responsive.” them to do it six months in advance because it
Kennesaw, which has more than 1,100 online was going to take us a long time to get the videos
courses in 70 fully online programs, had previ- captioned,” she said. “We hated to do that.”
ously been using a speech-to-text appliance for The university realized it needed a solution to
machine-generated captions that student assis- meet the following needs:
tants would clean up and return to faculty. The pro- • Reduce the number of steps faculty must
cess involved no fewer than 12 steps on the part of take to get videos captioned;
faculty, many of them quite time-consuming. “We • Allow faculty to request machine-generated
want to meet the needs of students and be in line captions that they can edit;
with federal guidelines,” Cameron said, “but we • Allow faculty to request professionally cap-
just could not handle the volume anymore with tioned files; and
our old systems.” • Remain within the prescribed budget.
There were other problems with the legacy Cameron worked with a project team that
solution. First off, it required a huge amount of included Veronica Trammell, executive director
server space to maintain. Kennesaw couldn’t do of learning technologies, training, & audiovisual
any cloud storage with it, and no other vendor outreach, as well as instructional designers who
could partner to work on the captioning. “Every gave input on what the faculty members need
bit had to be done here with our student assis- and want. They also studied what others in higher
tants, who are limited to working 20 hours per education, such as the University of Minnesota
week,” she said. Even with five student assis- system, had done to address the issue.
tants, it took a long time to return files to faculty “We realized we wanted to make sure our
Veronica Trammell
members, who found the whole process cum- system gave the faculty opportunities to work on
their own captions if they wanted to,” Cameron of Education and the National Association of the
said. “Also, we couldn’t afford to do every cap- Deaf. “We gave them a copy of the guidelines
tion for our faculty, so we needed a system that and said we need what you are doing to conform
would give us flexibility and more self-service to these standards,” Cameron recalled. “They
functionality.” edited their settings to align with that.”
Because Kennesaw uses Kaltura Media The new solution went live in 2017, and now
Space for campus video storage, it chose to work more than 30 campuses in the University Sys-
with a company called Ceilo24, whose solution tem of Georgia have the offering available to
was compatible with Media Space. “We went them. “When they saw how well it worked, the
with the company with the lowest price that was university system said we can give the rest of the
willing to build the features we wanted,” Cam- universities in the system the opportunity to buy
eron said, adding that Ceilo24’s solution required this as well,” Cameron said.
some changes before it would meet Kennesaw’s Cameron noted that faculty members have in-
needs. “We were honest with them and said it creased their requests for professional caption-
was not going to work for us [as is]. There were ing as well as do-it-yourself captioning since the
several problems with it. It was difficult to use.” new system was deployed. “Our Kaltura usage
But she gives the company credit for being will- has gone up so much that we are paying a lot
ing to make necessary changes. “I think they ap- more,” she said, “but it is worth it to know our
preciated that it was making their product better.” videos are being captioned and more than that,
One of the benefits of the solution they co- the faculty is actively thinking about ways to meet
developed is that faculty do not have to down- the needs of diverse learners. That is the big-
load and upload files. They can create, edit and gest benefit from this — that they are engaged
share videos directly in the captioning environ- in these conversations and making sure their in-
ment. They also can create and edit caption files struction is encompassing all students. Those
as well. conversations were not happening on the same
Kennesaw also requested that Ceilo24 scale before this project.”
change its captioning to adhere to the DCMP
(Described and Captioned Media Program) David Raths is a freelance writer based in
Jordan Cameron
specification, a project of the U.S. Department Philadelphia.
OUR WINNERS
Advanced Cyberinfrastructure
Tech lineup: Ceph, Dell, MathWorks, OpenStack,
Red Hat
Look for in-depth profiles of each Impact Award honoree in our next few issues. Universidad del Sagrado Corazón
Project: Hurricane Maria Disaster Recovery
TEACHING & LEARNING Columbus State Community College
Project lead: Gilberto J. Marxuach Torrós, president
Project: “iComp: A Guide to First-Year
The University of Texas Tech lineup: Amazon Web Services, The College
Writing” Multi-Touch iBook
at El Paso Board, Dynamic Campus, Microsoft, Moodle
Project: Tech-E Outreach Program Project leads: Deb Bertsch, professor, Don Bruce,
associate professor, Rebecca Fleming, associate professor,
Project lead: Michael T. Pitcher,
Nick Lakostik, associate professor, Jason LaMar, supervisor,
director, academic technologies
Instructional Technology Innovations (Digital Education and
Tech lineup: 3DPrinterOS, Apple,
Michael T. Pitcher Instructional Services)
Ozobot, Raspberry Pi, Ultimaker
Tech lineup: Adobe, Apple
North Carolina State University
Project: GlobalVR: Teaching Cultural Competencies
Through Virtual Reality
IT INFRASTRUCTURE
Project lead: Ilin Misaras, assistant director, Global AND SYSTEMS After Hurricane Maria, Universidad del Sagrado Corazón turned every
Training Initiative Kennesaw State University available space into classrooms, including porches, terraces, porticos,
open spaces and hallways.
Project: Working with Vendors to
Tech lineup: Adobe, GoPro, Kolor, Moodle, Oculus,
Create a Custom Captioning Solution
Samsung, WondaVR
Project lead: Jordan Cameron,
STUDENT SYSTEMS &
Hillsborough Community College assistant director of academic web accessibility SERVICES
Project: Redesigning College Algebra: Delivery, St. John’s University
Tech lineup: Ceilo24, Kaltura
Support, Results Project: BKFNDr Mobile App
Project lead: Misty Vorder Bruegge, Indiana University
Project lead: St. John’s University Libraries Web &
math instructor Project: Jetstream: A Cloud System Enabling Learning in
Emerging Technologies Team
Higher Education Communities
Tech lineup: Apple, McGraw-Hill Education, Tech lineup: Apple, Ionic Framework, Radius Networks
Pearson, Promethean Project lead: David Y. Hancock, program director,
ADMINISTRATION EDUCATION FUTURISTS Drexel created an online resource that showcases leading technologies,
practices and research in virtual education.
Georgetown University
Project: Georgetown 360 Drexel University
Project lead: Linda Buckley, assistant vice president, Project: Virtually Inspired
administrative applications Project Leads: Susan C. Aldridge, president, Drexel
Tech lineup: Affinaquest, Appirio, Conga, University Online, and Marci Powell, project director and
DocuSign, Emma, ForceAmp, MuleSoft, Salesforce.org, researcher, Virtually Inspired, CEO/president, Marci Powell
Wealth Engine & Associates, and chair emerita and past president, United
States Distance Learning Association
Tech lineup: Adobe, GoDaddy, MailChimp,
At Washington College, students become curators, creating AR-enhanced Seer Interactive, WordPress
museum exhibits and more.
OUR JUDGES
Entries were reviewed by our Impact Awards Judging Committee, a group of higher ed tech leaders, many of whom are
former recipients of the Campus Technology Innovators Award. Judges did not review entries from their own institutions.
Final winners were chosen by our team of editors.
Most Valuable in
the Institution This Year WHO VOTED FAVORITE TECHNOLOGIES
Our 2018 Readers’ Choice Awards polled 307 respondents CURRENTLY USED
across a variety of higher education roles and institutions.
Platinum: Guidebook Our survey asked, “What are your three favorite technologies
The breakdown of job categories:
What readers said: “Guidebook allows us to that you currently use in your capacity as an education
host conferences, training sessions and move-in day 49.5% Administrators professional?” Here’s how our readers’ responses ranked:
54.7% Public
3
4
it is a great tool for online applications for the
30.0% Private nonprofit
Study Abroad office.”
“We’ve had the Terra Dotta software for a while, but
9.5% Private for-profit
5.9% Other post-secondary
5
added new features including AlertTraveler. It is such a
critical part of our operations in keeping track of all of our
Respondents didn’t necessarily vote in every category.
travelers and supporting them quickly and effectively.” 4 (tie) Adobe Creative Cloud
Throughout higher education, data By nature, an initiative of this type is Srinivas: Student advising has always student advising we are asking them to do.
analytics is playing an increasingly built on the latest technology. But for been considered the linchpin of retention,
important and game-changing role in Syracuse, technology is always looked a critical area for higher education CT: So is there more of a focus now
student advising. Campus leaders are upon as a path to a solution, not a driver institutions. And our retention gurus have on data analytics in higher education,
looking for successful models as they of change in itself. held for years that it’s important that a since it’s finding a niche in student
work to make the most of data analytics Here, Campus Technology asked student’s adviser is one of the key people advising?
in their student advising programs. Kalpana Srinivas, the university’s director they build a relationship with.
Syracuse University (NY) provides of retention for Academic Affairs, how Data analytics may seem to be a more Srinivas: The overall picture of data
such a model. In alignment with Syracuse streamlined the process of recent phenomenon, but it’s now over 10 analytics in higher education has taken
its 2015 academic strategic plan, advising across all schools and colleges, years since Educause began publishing shape mostly in the past five years, and
Syracuse conducted a university-wide and why understanding campus culture articles suggesting that if colleges and the scholarship on this topic has really
overhaul of its advising practices. was central to her team’s change universities can place more and better exploded recently. Linking data analytics
Its “Orange SUccess” initiative would management strategy as the initiative information into the hands of a greater with student advising and the science
implement a new, centralized student analyzed all the underlying business number of people, this enables better of that is a relatively new phenomenon:
advising system, provide intrusive processes across the entire university. decision-making. Even though higher education has been
advising, improve student persistence, These two factors together became the collecting data on students for decades,
and enable the sharing of data Campus Technology: Where are we crux of our understanding of how important especially via student information
seamlessly across all schools and now, in higher education’s adoption of it is to get critical information into the hands systems, most of that data has not been
colleges. data analytics in student advising? of advisers, so that they can do the holistic used to its full potential.4
Concurrently, there has been increasing pressure to making in many areas, especially advising. Pen-and-paper and Excel worksheets — where good
promote timely degree completion and increase student Always keep in mind, though: It’s not the technology — it’s data often goes to die — will ultimately reveal this fact to
success and graduation rates. We know that student success the people. institutions. They will find out that they are in need of real
can be improved when students, faculty and staff are on the change. We can’t just hold on to what has worked in the past.
same page. How can we achieve that? It’s possible when we CT: How do the vendors participate in this area of data And it’s only through the enterprise systems, where
leverage data-informed decision-making in student advising. analytics and student advising? everybody is on the same page, and where the enterprise
system serves as a hub of information that can move things
CT: Is data analytics becoming established as a Srinivas: The vendors we’ve worked with, and many of real time, that students will get the support they really need
technology that higher education can use to solve our those we’ve talked with, have explained to us that their today — before they feel overwhelmed.
problems? development is grounded in retention research. They are
well-informed about it and have some very good guidance Grush: In general, how is higher education doing
Srinivas: Well, that’s not the whole picture, of course. In to give us, too. So that has been very promising for with managing these changes? How did your team at
higher education, we do feel the need to work smarter Syracuse as we work with our vendor, Hobsons, and its Syracuse manage change?
and to break down the silos across our institutions. The Starfish product. (Starfish enterprise Connect and Early Alert
impact of data analytics in solving some of these problems tools are hosted for the university as SaaS.) Srinivas: Even though the record on delivering results is still
can be huge, and its application in student advising is not very good according to our change management gurus,
impressive. But, we have to remember that the technology CT: Typically, are higher education institutions “ready” there is still reason to press for change. What institutions
is not what’s driving the improved utilization of data for for change in these areas? need to do is embrace change management principles, as
hypothesis-driven data mining. Such initiatives are actually we did at Syracuse. Among other change management
guided by communities of practice — communities within Srinivas: Technology has revolutionized higher education. strategies, our team used John Kotter’s 8-Step Process
higher education, such as NACADA [National Academic We’ve all seen this happen over the past several years. for Leading Change (1996) to increase acceptance and
Advising Association], which in 2016 published a guide to So now, many institutions are stepping up and leveraging adoption on campus.
implementing data-informed advising. advising systems to support students with early alerts and And as we made the transition from pilot to a full campus
So, given research-based approaches to the science online scheduling, by integrating their SIS data. rollout, we continued to focus on the “why of the what” in
of data analytics, technologies have evolved to help The fact, though, is that institutions must be ready for order to win both hearts and minds as we worked for a shift
as higher education conducts data-informed decision- change now. Working in silos is just not effective anymore. in culture on campus. We implemented our Orange SUccess
initiative in a way that would inspire, create, and maintain trust. Upon his inauguration back in 2014, Chancellor the learning, counseling, engagement and development of
And that’s a strategy for the long term. Syverud had put in place a “Fast Forward” exercise to the whole student. We’ll continue our strong collaboration
examine the status quo. It revealed a need for more of Academic Affairs with ITS, as we maintain our ongoing
CT: So addressing campus culture was central to your systematic data about academic progress. We involved work with all our collaborators across campus.
initiative. faculty, students and staff, from all schools and colleges,
to consider the importance of creating an enterprise-wide CT: What has been most impactful, when you look
Srinivas: Yes, and culture is not one aspect of the game system for the future. back at the cultural changes you’ve seen?
… it is the game. So, we need to understand what our So I could say, we involved everyone as our partner.
university stands for: What are our values? We created shared goals to improve student success on Srinivas: Our work has created both a cultural change and
At Syracuse, students are our highest value. We are trying campus, and we built a guiding coalition. We emphasized cultural accountability. As we all know, accountability is a
to serve our students. Our chancellor and president, Kent enterprise benefits over departmental tradeoffs. measure of, or even the equivalent to, program effectiveness.
Syverud, has a very good mantra that we like to display And as for our implementation team, Academic Affairs So an increase in accountability is what I’d want to point to.
as a sign on our desks, saying: “And this would be good worked hand-in-hand with Information Technology Services — But we have time ahead to measure our effectiveness. We
for students because?” So, we ask ourselves how any the backbone of any technology implementation — as equal don’t want to jump the gun in terms of what we claim to be
implementation that we do brings value to our students. partners, to kick off Orange SUccess by January 2016, have it success. In reality, we are still early in our implementation
up and running for all undergraduates by Fall 2016, and then cycle, because we have only had the system running for five
CT: How did you learn from the cultural history of your available for all graduate and law students by Spring 2017. semesters, including the pilot.
campus as you approached your Orange SUccess We are working with our institutional research group to ask
initiative? Where did you look, and who did you ask? CT: Going forward, what is your most challenging goal the right questions that may give us reasonable measures of
And how did you form your team? and your approach to achieving it? success and of Orange SUccess’s impact on students.
The technology we implemented is both high-tech and
Srinivas: We had numerous conversations across campus Srinivas: That’s a really big, far-reaching question. We high-touch. But we still have to reflect, again and again,
to learn from the history of earlier implementations — what are trying to build synergy and enhance collaboration that technology is only a tool that makes tasks easier for
had worked, yes, but especially what had not worked. Why between Academic Affairs and Enrollment and Student students. It’s the people who actually support the students.
had some implementations settled for a diluted version of Experience (which was called Student Affairs in the past). That has to be in the DNA of the system. We’ll find out. We
performance? Which systems had low adoption rates? We want to advance a robust and seamless approach to still have so much to do, ahead of us.
Contributing Writers Mary Grush, David Raths, Associate Publisher David Tucker CORPORATE HEADQUARTERS
1105 Media
Dian Schaffhauser Senior Sales Account Executive Jean Dellarobba
6300 Canoga Ave., Suite 1150
Creative Director Jeff Langkau Senior Manager, Marketing & Client Services Woodland Hills, CA 91367
Weekdays 8:30 a.m.–5:30 p.m. PST
Art Director Chris Main Olivia Urizar Phone: (818) 814-5200
Fax: (818) 936-0496
Print Production Coordinator Lee Alexander 1105media.com
MEDIA KITS
Marketing Direct your media kit requests to Jean Dellarobba,
Marketing Manager Alene Metcalf (949) 265-1568, jdellarobba@1105media.com
President and Chief Content Officer General Manager, FedSoup & Washington Technology Annette Levee Chief Executive Officer REPRINTS
Anne A. Armstrong Director, Audience Development Tracy Kerley Rajeev Kapur For single article reprints (in minimum quantities of
Director, Audience Development, FedSoup & Washington Technology 250-500), e-prints, plaques and posters contact:
Chief Revenue Officer Chief Financial Officer PARS International
Ellen McGuyer
Stacy Money Craig Rucker Phone: (212) 221-9595
Director, Custom Editorial Lisa Daniel
Chief Technology Officer E-mail: 1105reprints@parsintl.com
Advertising and Sales Senior Custom Editorial Manager John Pulley
Erik A. Lindgren Web: 1105Reprints.com
Associate Publisher, Education David Tucker Senior Events Manager Christina Hong
Senior Sales Account Executive, Education Jean Dellarobba Event Managers Kristen Nemeroff, Casey Stankus Executive Vice President LIST RENTALS
Media Consultants Bill Cooper, Joy Destories, Michael J. Valenti This publication’s subscriber list, as well as other lists
OTHER PSMG BRANDS from 1105 Media, Inc., is available for rental. For more
Mary Martin, Kharry Wolinsky Chairman of the Board
FCW information, please contact our list manager, Merit Direct.
Art Staff Editor-in-Chief Troy K. Schneider Jeffrey S. Klein Phone: (914) 368-1000
Creative Director Jeff Langkau Executive Editor Adam Mazmanian E-mail: 1105media@meritdirect.com
Art Director Chris Main Staff Senior Writers Derek B. Johnson, Mark Rockwell Web: meritdirect.com/1105
Senior Web Designer Martin Peace Staff Writers Chase Gunter, Lauren C. Williams SUBSCRIPTIONS
Print Production Staff GCN For questions on subscriptions or circulation,
Print Production Manager Peter B. Weller Editor-in-Chief Troy K. Schneider contact 866-410-1321
Print Production Coordinator Lee Alexander Executive Editor Susan Miller REACHING THE STAFF
Lead Services Reporter/Producers Sara Friedman, Matthew Leonard Staff may be reached via e-mail, telephone, fax or mail.
A list of editors and contact information is also available on-
Director, Digital Programs & Demand Generation THE Journal
line at campustechnology.com, or editors can be reached at
Christopher Morales Editor-in-Chief David Nagel editors@campustechnology.com.
Senior Manager, Marketing & Client Services Olivia Urizar Reporter/Producer Sara Friedman
Manager, Digital Programs & Demand Generation Andrew Spangler E-mail: To e-mail any member of the staff, please use the
Washington Technology following form: FirstinitialLastname@1105media.com.
Manager, Audience Development Jason Pickup
Editor-in-Chief Nick Wakeman
Marketing Administrative Coordinator Raynette Carlin
Senior Staff Writer Ross Wilkers
Federal Soup
Managing Editor Sherkiya Wedgeworth
Syda Productions/Shutterstock
Denver Atlanta
Keith Bailey
Director, Office of Online Learning, University of Georgia Nov. 11–16 Jan. 31–Feb. 1
TDWI Orlando Conference LearnLaunch Institute
Edward Chapel
Senior Vice President, NJEDge; former VP for IT, Orlando, FL Across Boundaries
Montclair State University (NJ) Conference
Nov. 13
Maya Georgieva 2018 Blockchain in Boston
Co-Founder and Chief Innovation Officer, Digital Bodies
Education East Feb. 10–13
Thomas Hoover
Washington, DC Instructional Technology
CIO and Dean of the Libary,
University of Louisiana Monroe Nov. 14–16 Council
Kim Cliett Long Online Learning Consortium eLearning 2019
Director, The Center for Excellence in Distance Learning, OLC Accelerate 2018 Las Vegas ADVERTISER INDEX
Wiley College (TX)
Orlando, FL Feb. 19–21 Campus Technology Impact Awards...............................................................................................................25
Alexandra M. Pickett campustechnology.com/impact
Jan. 9–1 Educause
Associate Director, SUNY Learning Network, Campus Technology Subscriptions..................................................................................................................20
State University of New York NJEdge ELI Annual Meeting campustechnology.com/subscribe
Campus Technology (ISSN 1553-7544) is pub- Group publication, you’ll periodically receive uses, submit your request at 1105reprints.com.
lished eight times a year by 1105 Media, Inc., information about related products and servic- The information in this magazine has not under-
9201 Oakdale Avenue, Ste. 101, Chatsworth, CA es. To view our privacy policy for more informa- gone any formal testing by 1105 Media, Inc.,
91311. Complimentary subscriptions are sent tion, visit: 1105media.com/privacy.html and is distributed without any warranty
to qualifying subscribers. Subscription inquiries, expressed or implied. Implementation or use of
print back issue requests, and address changes: © Copyright 2018 by 1105 Media, Inc. All rights any information contained herein is the reader's
Mail to: Campus Technology, P.O. Box 2166, reserved. Electronic sharing of individual pages sole responsibility. While the information has
Skokie, IL 60076-7866; e-mail CAMmag@ or single issues of an edition by subscribers is been reviewed for accuracy, there is no guaran-
1105service.com or call 866-293-3194 for US permitted on a limited basis. Institutions that tee that the same or similar results may be
& Canada, 847-763-9560 for International; fax wish provide institution-wide access to aca- achieved in all environments. Technical inaccu-
847-763-9564. demic users for research purposes only must racies may result from printing errors and/or
As a subscriber of an 1105 Media, Inc. Education e-mail rkelly@1105media.com. For all other new developments in the industry.
56 CAMPUS TECHNOLOGY | October/November 2018