Professional Documents
Culture Documents
13]
Original Article
Abstract
Objective: The objective of the study is to analyze the health‑care costs of the hemodialysis (HD) patients
in a charitable hospital. Subjects and Methods: A prospective observational study was carried out in an
outpatient HD unit of nephrology department in a charitable hospital for a period of 8 months from August 2016
to March 2017. The collected direct medical and nonmedical cost data were analyzed for the median interquartile
(Q3–Q1) cost incurred in treating the HD patients. Results: A total of 39 outpatients were included in the
study. Of 39 patients, majority of the HD patients were males (66.2%) followed by females (33.8%). Most of the
patients underwent HD for twice a week (89.7%) followed by thrice a week (10.3%). The median direct medical
costs (85,999.2 Indian rupee [INR]) were found to be higher than direct nonmedical costs (14,437.1 INR).
Conclusions: The study revealed that the total median direct cost was found to be uppermost for the age group
of 41–60 years (1,12,438.8 INR) when compared to all other age groups, and it was also observed that the total
median direct cost for males (1,07,522.4 INR) was higher than females (1,03,170.7 INR). The factors such as
type of comorbidities, age, and number of HD per week may affect the cost of illness.
DOI: How to cite this article: Fathima S, Mateti UV, Philip ML, Kamath J.
10.4103/jina.jina_4_18 Pharmacoeconomic evaluation of hemodialysis patients: A study of cost of
illness. J Integr Nephrol Androl 2018;5:54-9.
54 © 2018 Spring Media Publishing Co. Ltd. | Published by Wolters Kluwer - Medknow
[Downloaded free from http://www.journal-ina.com on Thursday, November 29, 2018, IP: 158.140.165.13]
Data collection form was designed as per the study requirements. In the present study, the maximum number of medications prescribed
The details such as age, gender, diagnosis, number of HD to HD patients ranged from 6 to 9 medications (79.5%),
per week, number of visits to HD, comorbid conditions, and and the median number of medications prescribed per HD
number of medicines per prescription were obtained from the patients was found to be 9 (11–7) as summarized in Table 1.
patient medical records. The pharmacoeconomic‑related direct Higher incidence of various comorbidities among HD patients
medical costs (medicines, HD, laboratory investigations, was hypertension (46.2%) and hypertension with diabetes
consultations, hospitalization, and miscellaneous costs) and mellitus (25.6%) as is depicted in Table 1.
nonmedical costs (transportation to visit HD unit and food
expenses during HD) were collected from the patient records, The median direct medical costs (85,999.2 INR) were found
medical bills, hospital accounts section, and interviewing the to be higher than that of direct nonmedical costs (14,437.1
patients or patient parties. From the data obtained, the total INR) as summarized in Table 2. The median cost per
cost of HD for 6 months was calculated. patient for each session of HD was 980 INR (1100–900
INR). Among the various direct medical cost components, the
The collected data were analyzed for the median median cost was found to be highest for HD sessions (44,000
interquartile (Q3–Q1) cost incurred in treating the HD INR) followed by medication charges (30,507 INR). In
patients and were calculated based on the total amount spent this study, the median cost for the transportation of patients
by the patients to that of a total number of patients. Details to visit the HD unit was 9600 INR, and food cost during
of direct medical and nonmedical costs were analyzed. The HD was 3720 INR.
direct costs are the sum of the direct medical and nonmedical
costs. The data of all the costs in Indian rupee (INR) Costs were also categorized based on the age groups, where
were converted into the United States dollar (USD), i.e., it was observed that the total median direct cost was found
1 INR = 64.62 USD. to be highest for the age group of 41–60 years (1,12,438.8
Table 1: Baseline characteristics of hemodialysis patients twice‑weekly HD sessions which lead to increase in expenses
Characteristics Number of on transportation, food, HD sessions, and medications as
patients (%) described in Table 5. In this study, most of the HD patients
Age (years) were under various schemes and few without schemes, of which
18‑40 10 (25.6) the median (Q3–Q1) direct medical cost was found to be
41‑60 18 (46.2)
highest in patients with MED scheme (95,674.3 INR). In
61‑80 11 (28.2)
case of the median, the direct nonmedical cost was highest
Body mass index (kg/m2)
<18.5 7 (18)
in patients with group scheme (31,892.9 INR). The overall
18.5‑24.9 25 (64) median direct cost was found to be highest in patients who
25‑29.9 5 (13) were not on schemes (1,12,438.8 INR) as described in
≥30 2 (5) Table 6. The direct medical cost was high in the case of MED
Educational status scheme because patients availed reimbursements; hence,
Illiterate 9 (23.1) they preferred high‑end treatments as there are no monitory
Primary school certificate 5 (12.8) implications for them. Therefore, their medical costs would be
Medium school certificate 8 (20.5)
higher when compared to those patients who received no such
High school certificate 12 (30.8)
reimbursements. The total median cost was high in patients
Intermediate/posthigh‑school diploma 3 (7.7)
Graduate/postgraduate 2 (5.1)
without scheme as they were not getting any concessions and
Occupational status they had to spend more on transportation to the hospital.
Working 18 (46.2)
Not working 21 (53.8) DISCUSSION
Social habits
Alcoholic 4 (10.3) ESRD is a condition where there is irreversible loss of normal
Smoker 6 (15.4)
kidney function, and it has a greater impact on health economics.
Duration of dialysis (years), median (Q3‑Q1) 2 (5‑1)
The role of HD is to treat ESRD, which remains one of the
Number of medications prescribed
2‑5 3 (7.7)
most intensive and expensive therapeutic interventions. Thus,
6‑9 31 (79.5) this study was conducted to assess the expenditure of HD
>10 5 (12.8) patients to get the detailed information on their direct medical
Comorbid conditions and nonmedical costs in a charitable hospital.
No comorbidities 3 (7.7)
Hypertension 18 (46.2) A total of 39 HD patients were selected for the study, of
Pulmonary diseases 1 (2.6) which majority of them belonged to the age group of
Hypothyroidism 1 (2.6) 41–60 years (46.2%). The mean age of HD patients was found
Cardiovascular with hypertension 2 (5.1)
to be 51 ± 12.7 years which is comparable with the study results
Hypertension with diabetes mellitus 10 (25.6)
obtained by Suja et al., where it was reported that majority of
Hypertension with pulmonary diseases 1 (2.6)
Cardiovascular with hypertension and diabetes 1 (2.6)
the patients belonged to the age group of 51–60 years, and the
mellitus mean age of the patients was 49.72 ± 13.2 years.[11]
Hypertension with diabetes mellitus and 1 (2.6)
pulmonary diseases Of 39 patients, the majority were males (66.2%) followed by
Cardiovascular with hypertension, diabetes 1 (2.6 ) females (33.8%). Similar results were found in the studies of
mellitus and pulmonary diseases
Al Saran et al., Mateti et al., Al‑Shdaifat et al., where it was
reported that majority were males (60%, 80.7% and 53.6%)
INR) when compared to all other age groups. It was because followed by females (40%, 19.3% and 46.4% ).[14-16]
these patients were traveling from distant places, so they had
to spend more on traveling and food during HD sessions In this study, it was observed that hypertension (46.2%) and
as presented in Table 3. It was also observed that the total hypertension with diabetes (25.6%) were the major comorbid
median direct cost for males (1,07,522.4 INR) was higher conditions. Similar results were also found in the studies
than females (1,03,170.7 INR) as presented in Table 4. conducted by Suja et al., Mushtaq et al., and Shyamala et
al., where diabetes and hypertension were the leading causes
Among the HD patients, 89.7% underwent twice a week and in HD patients compared to other disease states.[12,17,18]
10.3% thrice a week. It was also found that the total median
direct costs were highest in patients on thrice‑weekly HD In this study, most of the patients were found to have HD
sessions (1,27,682.4 INR) when compared to patients on sessions for less than a year (31%). The median duration of
HD sessions was 2 (5–1) years. Similar results were obtained Patients undergo HD either twice or thrice weekly depending
in a study conducted by Suja et al., where it was reported that on the severity of their disease state and affordability. Of the
the mean duration of HD was 2.8 years.[11] In the present total number of 39 HD patients, majority of the patients
study, the median number of medications prescribed in our underwent HD for twice a week (89.7%) followed by thrice
study was 9 (11–7), and in the study conducted by Mateti a week (10.3%). Similar results were observed in the study
et al., the mean number of medications prescribed was by Abreu et al., where they selected patients undergoing
13.10 ± 4.86.[12,15] maintenance HD (2–3 HD sessions per week).[19]
In this study, the median direct medical costs (85,999.2 In the present study, it was observed that the total median direct
INR) were found to be higher than direct nonmedical cost for males (1,07,522.4 INR) was highest followed by
costs (14,437.1 INR). Similar study results were reported females (1,03,170.7 INR). In case of median direct medical
by Mateti et al., who reported that the median direct medical cost, it was found that cost for female patients (85,999.2
costs of HD patients were higher (573.11 INR) than direct INR) was higher than male patients (85,415.9 INR). Similar
nonmedical costs (67.50 INR).[15] results were reported in the study conducted by Roggeri
et al., where it was found that the total costs for male patients
Among the various direct medical cost components, the (53,945€/year/patient ± 14,884€) were highest followed
median cost was found to be highest for HD sessions (44,000 by female patients (53,467€/year/patient ± 14,356€).[23]
INR) followed by medication charges (30,507 INR). Similar
results were reported by Lorenzo et al., which stated that
major expenditure was from HD sessions (51%) followed
CONCLUSIONS
by medications (27%).[20] In this study, the median cost
This study gives an insight on the direct costs and the impact
of hematopoietic agents (55.1%) was highest followed by
phosphate binders (22.9%), which was similar to the results of economic burden on the HD patients. The most commonly
obtained from the study carried out by Lorenzo et al., where prescribed medication was found to be hematopoietic agents,
it was reported that 68% of total pharmaceutical cost was which consumes the highest cost. The total direct median cost
contributed by hematopoietic agents.[20] of HD treatment was 1,06,971.2 INR. The total median
direct cost was more for the patients undergoing three dialysis
Proportional allocation of costs in our study was as follows: sessions per week (1,27,682.4 INR). Type of comorbidities,
HD sessions (50%), medications (35%), diagnosis (6%), unemployment, age, number of HD per week, and number of
hospitalization (5%), laboratory investigations (3%), and medicines prescribed may affect the cost of illness. The costs
miscellaneous (1%). This was similar to the results obtained incurred for the HD patients were higher and can be minimized
by Lorenzo et al., where it was reported that proportional by providing concerns from the charitable hospitals, allowances
allocation of costs in their study was HD sessions (51%), from governments, and supporting with more insurance schemes.
pharmacy (27%), hospitalization (17%), transportation (3%),
and ambulatory care (2%).[20] The median cost for each Acknowledgment
session of HD was 980 INR (1100–900 INR) which was We would like to thank the Nitte (Deemed to be University)
similar to the results obtained by Khanna et al., where it was for providing participants recruited in this study. The authors
reported that the cost per each session of HD in South India wish to acknowledge the directors and staff of the respective
was 1100 INR.[21] dialysis units for their contribution toward the successful
completion of the project.
In our study, it was observed that the total median direct cost
was highest for the age group of 41–60 years (1,12,438.8 Financial support and sponsorship
INR) when compared to all other age groups. In contrast, Nil.
the study conducted by Kao et al. concluded that the total
cost per life year of patients was found to be highest for the Conflicts of interest
age group of ≥65 years (23,664 USD).[22] There are no conflicts of interest.